PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The...

28

Transcript of PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The...

Page 1: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...
Page 2: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

PLAINS CO2 REDUCTION (PCOR) PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS

© 2018 University of North Dakota Energy & Environmental Research Center.

13th Annual SECARB Stakeholders’ Briefing Atlanta, Georgia March 7‒8, 2018

Charles Gorecki

Director of Subsurface R&D

Page 3: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

• The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success • Benefits • Outreach

Page 4: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

4

A GROWING PARTNERSHIP!

Page 5: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

5

AN ENGAGED PARTNERSHIP

Images Credit – EERC

Page 6: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

Completed and ongoing CO2 storage projects (outline shows PCOR Partnership region)

Encouraging the commercial

deployment of CCUS in the region.

AN EFFECTIVE PARTNERSHIP

AN ACTIVE REGION

Image Credit – EERC

Page 7: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

7

IDEAL OPPORTUNITIES

Image Credit – EERC

Image Credit – EERC

Image Credit – Basin Electric Power Cooperative

Image Credit – EERC

Image Credit – NACCO Industries

Page 8: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

8

CCUS WORKS!

Images Credit – EERC

Page 9: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

9

BELL CREEK

Images Credit – EERC

Page 10: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

10

SUCCESSFUL MONITORING

Image Credit – Annette Tait

Image Credit – EERC

Image Credit – EERC

Page 11: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

11

PULSED-NEUTRON LOGGING

Images Credit – EERC

04-03 Saturations

04-04 Saturations

05-01 Saturations

Water

Oil

Gas

05-01 04-04 04-03

Page 12: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

12

Simulated CO2 Saturation 4-D Seismic Difference Map

SEISMIC SURVEYS

Images Credit – EERC

Page 13: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

CONNECTING THE DOTS

Equivalent Thickness CO2 Column (Feet) = 𝛴(𝐼𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑣𝑎𝑙 𝑇ℎ𝑖𝑐𝑘𝑛𝑒𝑠𝑠 ∗ ∅∗𝑆↓𝐶𝑂2  )

y = -2.143ln(x) - 9.9285 R² = 0.9955

-16

-14

-12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0 0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00

Am

plitu

de C

hang

e

Seismic Amplitude Change vs. Equivalent Thickness of CO2 Column

Image credit – EERC

Page 14: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

At Bell Creek: •  Estimated 20‒40 MMbbl of oil.(1)

•  Nearly 5 million tonnes of CO2 has been stored incidental to EOR.

14

ECONOMIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS

(1)  Estimated proved plus potential tertiary reserves. Denbury, 2018, Presentation at the J.P. Morgan 2018 Global High Yield & Leveraged Finance Conference, February 26: http://s1.q4cdn.com/594864049/files/doc_presentations/2018/JP-Morgan-2017-Global-High-Yield-Leveraged-Finance-Conference-FINAL.pdf

Image Credit – EERC

0

20,000

40,000

60,000

80,000

100,000

120,000

140,000

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

Mon

thly

Oil

Prod

uctio

n,

bbl

Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4 Phase 5Source: Montana Board of Oil & Gas Conservation (November 2017)

Phase 1 CO2Injection Start

Water Flood

Page 15: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

15

LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS

A spreadsheet CO2 EOR life cycle analysis model is available on the PCOR Partnership public Web site!

Page 16: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

AQUISTORE

Images Credit – EERC

Page 17: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

OUTREACH IS KEY!

17 Images Credit – EERC

Premiers Mar. 27 on Prairie Public TV!!!

Page 18: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...
Page 19: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

Image Credit – EERC

Page 20: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

COMPLEMENTARY PROJECTS

Images Credit – EERC

Page 21: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

INNOVATIVE SEISMIC EFFORTS

Model Data Field Data

Scalable, Automated, Semipermanent Seismic Array (SASSA)

Joint Inversion of Time-Lapse Seismic Data

Images Credit – EERC

Page 22: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

NORTH DAKOTA CarbonSAFE

Image Credit – Allete Clean Energy

Page 23: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

• CCUS Requires Active Public Engagement!

THE PCOR PARTNERSHIP KEY MESSAGES:

23

• CCUS Provides Economic and Environmental Benefits! • We Can Successfully Monitor CO2 Storage!

• CCUS Works!

• The PCOR Partnership Region Is Ideal for CCUS Deployment! • Stakeholder Collaboration Is Essential for CCUS Deployment!

Image credit – EERC

Page 24: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

The image part with relationship ID rId3 was not found in the file.

24

Thank You!

Image Credit – EERC

Page 25: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory under Award Nos. DE-FC26-05NT42592, DE-

FE0029488, DE-FE0012665, DE-FE0024453, DE-FE0024233, and DE-FC26-08NT43291.

Disclaimer This presentation was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United

States Government. Neither the United States Government, nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its

endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or

reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof.

Page 26: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

26

CONTACT INFORMATION

Energy & Environmental Research Center University of North Dakota 15 North 23rd Street, Stop 9018 Grand Forks, ND 58202-9018 www.undeerc.org 701.777.5355 (phone) 701.777.5181 (fax) Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D [email protected]

Page 27: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...

THANK YOU!

Page 28: PLAINS CO - sseb.org · Charles Gorecki Director of Subsurface R&D . PRESENTATION OUTLINE • The PCOR Partnership • The Opportunities • CCUS Works • Monitoring Success ...