Moderate consumption of Beer can Be Good for Your Heart

Many epidemiological studies report on the overall balance of risks and benefits of alcohol consumption. They show a U or J shaped relationship with a decreased risk of premature death (mortality) in moderate drinkers compared to heavy drinkers and non drinkers of all ages1. It is also clear that men and women differ – the beneficial effect being seen at lower consumption levels in women than in men2. A recent statistical analysis (metaanalysis) of 34 studies from all over the world found that consumption of alcohol (up to four drinks per day in men and two in women) leads to a reduction of premature mortality of up to 18% compared to abstainers and heavy drinkers3. The analysis illustrates the J shaped relationship between alcohol consumption and the risk of deaths from all causes for men and women. At moderate levels of consumption, in all places and in both men and women, the risk of early death is reduced relative to the risk in abstainers and heavy drinkers. The conclusion from this meta-analysis was that “people who already regularly consume low to moderate amounts of alcohol should be encouraged to continue”.

Coronary Heart Disease (heart attack)

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) that includes cardiovascular stroke and coronary heart disease (CHD) (heart attack) is the leading cause of death and disability among adults, representing 32% of all deaths or almost 73,000 Canadians killed in 20044 . Preventative measures include modification of lifestyle factors such as adopting a healthy diet and taking exercise. Moderate consumption of beers, wines and spirits can be part of a healthy lifestyle5. There is strong evidence that people who are moderate consumers of beer, wine or spirits have a substantially (30-40%) reduced risk of coronary heart disease when compared to teetotalers and heavy drinkers. Similar results have been shown by many studies throughout the world. The WHO Global Status Report on Alcohol (2004) describes this as the “most important health benefit of alcohol”7. This reduction in risk (associated with consumption of one to a little over two drinks a day) is on a par with preventive measures such as the use of aspirin, weight control and exercise 8.

Additionally, a comparison of moderate alcohol consumption and exercise showed that both were important in the reduction of risk9. The benefit applies to a broad range of individuals including those considered to be of higher risk of cardiovascular disease for example with high blood pressure10, diabetes11 or metabolic syndrome12 and those with a lower risk (have a healthy lifestyle)13. There are several well-established explanations for this observed reduction in risk of coronary heart disease. The mechanisms below have been shown to account for almost all of the association in men and approximately 75% in women14. Blood cholesterol levels The mechanism which has been shown to be responsible for the majority of the effect is that the amount of “good cholesterol” (HDL cholesterol) in the blood increases when alcohol is consumed. Higher levels of “good cholesterol” have been shown to be associated with lower risk of coronary heart disease. Research has shown that one glass of beer a day can significantly increase HDL levels15.

Clotting

Scientists have also shown that alcohol has a beneficial blood thinning effect and reduces the tendency of blood to form clots17, with moderate beer consumption being associated with favourable changes on the blood lipid profile18. Inflammation

Atherosclerosis, which leads to heart attacks, is an inflammatory disease and local inflammation in the vessel wall contributes to the increased risk of constriction and blockage. There is growing evidence that alcohol also has an anti-inflammatory effect and that this may contribute to the reduction in cardiovascular risk19, 20.

Insulin resistance

Insulin is the hormone which controls blood sugar. One of the first steps in developing diabetes mellitus is when the body becomes resistant to insulin. Moderate alcohol consumption may help in the prevention of insulin resistance and may reduce the risk of diabetes (see page 11). Insulin resistance is also linked to cardiovascular disease so this may be an additional mechanism by which alcohol consumption reduces risk of cardiovascular disease.21

Beer is just as good at protecting the heart as wine

There have been many studies that have attempted to compare the effect of beer, wine and spirits to see whether they have the same risk reduction properties against cardiovascular disease but when the evidence

is examined, it is clear that the major protective agent is alcohol itself22. The protective effects of moderate alcohol consumption are seen in many different countries with different cultures and drinking habits and this, combined with the established mechanisms described above, confirms that it is the alcohol that is having the major protective effect and no individual type of drink can claim the monopoly23 in relation to cardiovascular disease

Other vascular diseases

There is also evidence that regular, light to moderate drinking may reduce the risk of other vascular diseases. Ischemic stroke, the most common form of stroke, has been the subject of a statistical review showing consistently reduced risk24 and since then studies have shown the risk reduced by 50% at consumption levels of up to two drinks per day25. Moderate alcohol consumption has also been shown to be associated with a slight decrease in cardiovascular and total mortality in people who have already had a heart attack26 or who have had heart surgery27 and can reduce the risk of lower extremity arterial disease in older adults28.

Moderate beer consumption can have a role in reducing risk in other conditions