PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard...

30
PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 Pells Sullivan Meynink

Transcript of PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard...

Page 1: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

PIPELINE BRIDGE

CROSSING FOR MINING

TRUCKS

Bernard Shen

2015 Small Bridges Conference

Melbourne

26 November 2015 1Pells Sullivan Meynink

Page 2: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Overview

• Project introduction

• Design criteria

• The design

• Loads

• Analysis

• Construction

26 November 2015 2

Page 3: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Project Introduction

26 November 2015 3

ABOVE GRADE PIPELINES

CROSSING LOCATIONS

BURIED PIPELINES

Page 4: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Options

• Option 1 Relocate pipelines (buried)

– Uneconomical $$$

• Option 2 Above grade crossing (bridge)

– Selected option

26 November 2015 4

Page 5: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

The Challenge

• Asset owner requirements

• To provide 2 m x 5 m access envelope

around the pipes for minor works

• Crossing able to be dismantled within 24

hours for emergency access

26 November 2015 5

Page 6: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Plant

26 November 2015 6

• CAT 785

250t fully loaded

mining truck

(Frequent)

• CAT 5230

300t mining

excavator

(Occasional)

Page 7: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Ideas

• Off the shelf or prefabricated culverts

• Beams over 1m3 mass concrete blocks

• Formed walls and slab (selected option)

26 November 2015 7

Page 8: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Concept

26 November 2015 8

Page 9: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Design

26 November 2015 9

WATER MAINS

FILL

RESIDUAL SOIL

BEDROCK

MINING TRUCK

CAT 785C (250 TONNE)

Page 10: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Load Distribution

26 November 2015 10

Page 11: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Load Consideration

26 November 2015 11

LINE LOAD

UDL

Page 12: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Load On Structure

• Vertical load – Simplistic methods

probably sufficient

• Lateral load (earth pressure) – 6 methods

were considered

26 November 2015 12

Page 13: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Lateral Earth Pressure

• 6 methods considered

Method 1 – Line load

Method 2 – Rankine active earth pressure theory

Method 3 – Surcharge

Method 4 – Semi-infinite load with elastic theory

Method 5 – Loaded strip with elastic theory

Method 6 – Finite element method

26 November 2015 13

Page 14: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Lateral Earth Pressure

26 November 2015 14

Method 1

Method 4

Method 5

Page 15: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Lateral Earth Pressure

26 November 2015 15

• What to design for?

Page 16: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Adopted In Design

• Method 3 for structural design

• Method 6 to check stability

26 November 2015 16

Page 17: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Passive Earth Pressure

26 November 2015 17

Page 18: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Analysis (Stability)

• Hand calculation (overturning) – FOS>2

• 2D Finite element – Loaded to “failure”

26 November 2015 18

Page 19: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Analysis (Deformation)

26 November 2015 19

6 mm

17 mm

“POOR” BACKFILL CASE

UNDER SERVICE LOAD

Page 20: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Structural Design

26 November 2015 20

Page 21: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 21

Page 22: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 22

Page 23: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 23

Page 24: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 24

Page 25: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 25

Page 26: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 26

Page 27: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Construction

26 November 2015 27

Page 28: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

In Operation

26 November 2015 28

Page 29: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

• Donaldson Coal

• Hunter Water Corporation

Acknowledgements

26 November 2015 29

Page 30: PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS · PIPELINE BRIDGE CROSSING FOR MINING TRUCKS Bernard Shen 2015 Small Bridges Conference Melbourne 26 November 2015 1 ... CAT 785C …

Pells Sullivan Meynink

Thank You

26 November 2015 30

Thank You