Geant4 v9.4 Kernel III Makoto Asai (SLAC) Geant4 Tutorial Course.
PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and...
Transcript of PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and...
![Page 1: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV
Marilena Bandieramonte
CERN
June 8, 2017
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 1 / 46
![Page 2: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Overview
1 PhotoElectric effect - IntroductionIntroduction
2 PhotoElectric effect - Literature reviewPhysics OverviewPhotoelectric cross section libraries
3 PhotoElectric effect in Geant4Standard electromagnetic packageLow energy package
4 Developing a new Photoelectric modelPossible actions and open pointsLivermore model analysisNew parameterisation with epics2014 dataBinding energies dataConclusions
5 Appendix
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 2 / 46
![Page 3: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Introduction
In the photo-electric absorption process a photon is absorbed by an atom and an electronis emitted with an energy:
Ephotoelectron = Eγ − Bshell (Zi ) (1)
The atom, left in an excited state with a vacancy in the ionized shell, decays to its groundstate through a cascade of radiative and non-radiative transitions with the emission ofcharacteristic x-rays and Auger and Coster-Kronig electrons.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 3 / 46
![Page 4: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Energy range
Photoelectric effect dominates at low energies.In the case of Carbon (C) it dominates for energies Eγ < 20KeV .
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 4 / 46
![Page 5: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Photoelectric process in a nutshell
5 main ingredients:
1 Macroscopic p.e. cross-section
2 Total p.e. atomic cross-section
3 Partial cross-section - sub-shell
4 Angular distribution
5 Atomic relaxation
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 5 / 46
![Page 6: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Total and partial cross sections
The total photoelectric cross section σpe exhibits a characteristicsawtooth behaviour corresponding to absorption edges.The K shell electrons are the the most tightly bound, and themost important contribution to the atomic photoelectric crosssection when there is enough energy to release them.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 6 / 46
![Page 7: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizationssolid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 8: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizationssolid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 9: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited states
multiple ionizationssolid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 10: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizations
solid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 11: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizationssolid state effects
near-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 12: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizationssolid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 13: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Physics overview - limitations
Current general purpose Monte Carlo codes for particle transportconsider single photon interactions with isolated atoms in theirground state.
So they neglect:
interactions with ions and excited statesmultiple ionizationssolid state effectsnear-edge absorption structures produced by molecular or crystallineordering.
Absorption spectroscopy techniques like:
NEXAFS (Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)EXAFS (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure)XANES (X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure)
cannot be simulated properly.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 7 / 46
![Page 14: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Total and partial cross sections
The elementary theory for p.e. has been reviewed by Pratt
The interaction between the active electron and the electromagneticfield is treated in first-order perturbation theory[Francesc Salvat , 2009]
It is usually assumed that the incident photon beam isunpolarized, and that the spin of the photoelectron is not observed.
With these assumptions, the partial DCS for photoionization of theactive shell is a function of only the direction k̂b of thephotoelectron.
dσph,a
dk̂b
= (2π)2e2~c1
Ekb
Eb + mec2
c2~2
∑′| (Mkα)ba |2 (2)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 8 / 46
![Page 15: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Total and partial cross sections [J H Hubbell , 2006]
Early theoretical calculations of photoionization cross sections werelimited to the K shell (Pratt (1960) , Pratt et al. - 1964) - showingasymptotic behaviourScofield’s (1973) non-relativistic calculations in a HS framework: allsub-shells, elements from Z = 1 to 101, energy range [1keV - 1.5MeV ].Provided renormalization factors to convert his cross section results tovalues expected from a relativistic Dirac-Hartree-Fock (DHF) computationChantler (1995 - 2000) in a self-consistent relativistic DHF framework.Z = 1 to 92, the lower-bound energy varies between 1eV and 10eV , andthe upper-bound energy varies between 0.4MeV and 1.0MeV .Salvat and Sabatucci (2015) formulation of p.e. within theone-active-electron approximation, with a DHFS self-consistent potential(Dirac-Hartree-Fock-Slater) - used in the latest 2015 version of Penelope.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 9 / 46
![Page 16: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Total and partial cross sections
These theoretical calculations provide the basis for the tabulated datalibraries [M. C. Han, 2016]
Various empirical formulations of photoionization cross sections are reportedin the literature
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 10 / 46
![Page 17: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Photoelectron angular distribution
Fischer’s non-relativistic theory addresses the calculation ofdifferential cross sections in the low energy region.
The first relativistic treatment of the photoelectric effect was givenby Sauter who calculated the K-shell cross section in the Bornapproximation; it concerns the lowest order in Zα/β
Gavrila and Nagel extended Sauter’s results to the next order inZα/β.
Further calculations by Gavrila are available for the L shell.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 11 / 46
![Page 18: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Double Differential Photoelectric cross section correct tofirst order αZ
dσκ
dω(θ,φ) =
4
m2α6Z 5 β3(1− β2)3
[1− (1− β2)12 ]5
{F(1− παZ
β+ παZG)
}(3)
where
F =sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)4− 1− (1− β2)
12
2(1− β2)
sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)3+
[1− (1− β2)12 ]2
4(1− β2)32
sin2 θ
(1− β cos θ)3(4)
and
G =[1− (1− β2)
12 ]
12
272β2(1− β cos θ)
52
[4β2
(1− β2)12
sin2 θ cos2 φ
1− β cos θ+
4β
(1− β2)cos θcos2φ− 4
1− (1− β)12
1− β2(5)
(1 + cos2 φ)− β2 1− (1− β2)12
1− β2
sin2 θ
1− β cos θ+ 4β2 1− (1− β2)
12
(1− β2)32
− 4β
[1− (1− β2)
12
]2(1− β2)
32
cos θ]
+1− (1− β2)
12
4β2(1− β cos θ)2[
β
1− β2− 2
1− β2cos θ cos2 φ+
1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
cos θ − β 1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
]
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 12 / 46
![Page 19: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Double Differential Photoelectric cross section correct tofirst order αZ
dσκ
dω(θ,φ) =
4
m2α6Z 5 β3(1− β2)3
[1− (1− β2)12 ]5
{F(1− παZ
β+ παZG)
}(3)
where
F =sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)4− 1− (1− β2)
12
2(1− β2)
sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)3+
[1− (1− β2)12 ]2
4(1− β2)32
sin2 θ
(1− β cos θ)3(4)
and
G =[1− (1− β2)
12 ]
12
272β2(1− β cos θ)
52
[4β2
(1− β2)12
sin2 θ cos2 φ
1− β cos θ+
4β
(1− β2)cos θcos2φ− 4
1− (1− β)12
1− β2(5)
(1 + cos2 φ)− β2 1− (1− β2)12
1− β2
sin2 θ
1− β cos θ+ 4β2 1− (1− β2)
12
(1− β2)32
− 4β
[1− (1− β2)
12
]2(1− β2)
32
cos θ]
+1− (1− β2)
12
4β2(1− β cos θ)2[
β
1− β2− 2
1− β2cos θ cos2 φ+
1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
cos θ − β 1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
]
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 12 / 46
![Page 20: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Double Differential Photoelectric cross section correct tofirst order αZ
dσκ
dω(θ,φ) =
4
m2α6Z 5 β3(1− β2)3
[1− (1− β2)12 ]5
{F(1− παZ
β+ παZG)
}(3)
where
F =sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)4− 1− (1− β2)
12
2(1− β2)
sin2 θ cos2 φ
(1− β cos θ)3+
[1− (1− β2)12 ]2
4(1− β2)32
sin2 θ
(1− β cos θ)3(4)
and
G =[1− (1− β2)
12 ]
12
272β2(1− β cos θ)
52
[4β2
(1− β2)12
sin2 θ cos2 φ
1− β cos θ+
4β
(1− β2)cos θcos2φ− 4
1− (1− β)12
1− β2(5)
(1 + cos2 φ)− β2 1− (1− β2)12
1− β2
sin2 θ
1− β cos θ+ 4β2 1− (1− β2)
12
(1− β2)32
− 4β
[1− (1− β2)
12
]2(1− β2)
32
cos θ]
+1− (1− β2)
12
4β2(1− β cos θ)2[
β
1− β2− 2
1− β2cos θ cos2 φ+
1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
cos θ − β 1− (1− β2)12
(1− β2)32
]
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 12 / 46
![Page 21: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Simplified differential cross section correct to first order αZ
This DCS describes the ionization of the ground state (1s1/2) ofhydrogenic ions, and is obtained in the plane-wave Born approximation:
dσ
d cos θ' sin2 θ
(1− β cos θ)4
{1 +
1
2γ(γ − 1)(γ − 2)(1− β cos θ)
}(6)
where β and γ are the photoelectron Lorentz factors.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 13 / 46
![Page 22: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 14 / 46
![Page 23: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section dataBiggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 24: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section dataBiggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 25: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section dataBiggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 26: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section dataBiggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 27: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section data
Biggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 28: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Photoelectric cross section libraries
EPDL - Evaluated Photon data Library. It combines two sets of datato compute the total cross-section.
Data calculated using Scofield’s sub-shell cross-sections from the edgeenergy up to 1 MeVHubbell’s total photoelectric cross- sections from 1keV to 100GeV.
PHOTX and XCOM. Both include
Scofield’s 1973 unrenormalized cross sections up to 1.5 MeV.At higher energies a semi-empirical formula connects Scofield’s values at1.5 MeV to the asymptotic high energy limit calculated by Pratt
Ebel. Parameterization based on fitting fifth order polynomials in thelogarithm of the photon energy to Scofield’s 1973 cross section dataBiggs and Lighthill. Analytical approximation using varioussemi-empirical and theoretical sources.
For more details look at:indico.cern.ch/event/629729/contributions/2569301/attachments/1449139/2233786/PhotoElectricEffect MB.pdf
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 29: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
PhotoElectric effect in Geant4
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 15 / 46
![Page 30: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Geant4 photoelectric package
The basic set of gamma models in EM physics packages [J Allison , 2016][V. Ivanchenko, 2011] includes:
Models developed for HEP applications: standard electromagneticpackage
G4PEEffectFluoModel : V. Grichine, M. Mairie and V. Ivanchenko
Models based on the Livermore evaluated data Library
G4LivermorePhotoElectricModel : A Ivanchenko and V. IvanchenkoG4LivermorePolarizedPhotoElectricModel : Sebastien Incerti, A.Forti,M.G.Pia, A. Mantero and V. Ivanchenko
C++ implementation of the Penelope 2001 models
G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel : L. Pandola
If photon energy is below the lowest available energy, the cross section iscomputed for this lowest energy, to ensure the gamma is absorbed byphotoabsorption at any energy.
This is done for transport reasons in HEPAs a result, all media is non-transparent to low-energy gamma rays
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 16 / 46
![Page 31: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Geant4 photoelectric package
The basic set of gamma models in EM physics packages [J Allison , 2016][V. Ivanchenko, 2011] includes:
Models developed for HEP applications: standard electromagneticpackage
G4PEEffectFluoModel : V. Grichine, M. Mairie and V. Ivanchenko
Models based on the Livermore evaluated data Library
G4LivermorePhotoElectricModel : A Ivanchenko and V. IvanchenkoG4LivermorePolarizedPhotoElectricModel : Sebastien Incerti, A.Forti,M.G.Pia, A. Mantero and V. Ivanchenko
C++ implementation of the Penelope 2001 models
G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel : L. Pandola
If photon energy is below the lowest available energy, the cross section iscomputed for this lowest energy, to ensure the gamma is absorbed byphotoabsorption at any energy.
This is done for transport reasons in HEPAs a result, all media is non-transparent to low-energy gamma rays
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 16 / 46
![Page 32: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Geant4 photoelectric package
The basic set of gamma models in EM physics packages [J Allison , 2016][V. Ivanchenko, 2011] includes:
Models developed for HEP applications: standard electromagneticpackage
G4PEEffectFluoModel : V. Grichine, M. Mairie and V. Ivanchenko
Models based on the Livermore evaluated data Library
G4LivermorePhotoElectricModel : A Ivanchenko and V. IvanchenkoG4LivermorePolarizedPhotoElectricModel : Sebastien Incerti, A.Forti,M.G.Pia, A. Mantero and V. Ivanchenko
C++ implementation of the Penelope 2001 models
G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel : L. Pandola
If photon energy is below the lowest available energy, the cross section iscomputed for this lowest energy, to ensure the gamma is absorbed byphotoabsorption at any energy.
This is done for transport reasons in HEPAs a result, all media is non-transparent to low-energy gamma rays
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 16 / 46
![Page 33: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Standard electromagnetic package: G4PEEffectFluoModel
The atomic cross sections. Biggs et al. parameterization from SANDIAtables, with separate fit of coefficients, is used :
σ(Z ,Eγ) =a(Z ,Eγ)
Eγ+
b(Z ,Eγ)
E 2γ
+c(Z ,Eγ)
E 3γ
+d(Z ,Eγ)
E 4γ
(7)
The sub-shell it’s chosen in a deterministic way, not sampled:
the first inner shell having a binding energy Bshell < Eγ
Shell atomic energies are taken from G4AtomicShells data
The photoelectron angle is calculated according to the Sauter-Gavriladistribution for K shell, which is correct only to zero order in αZ
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 17 / 46
![Page 34: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Low Energy Package: G4LivermorePhotoElectricModel
The total photoelectric and single shell cross-sections aretabulated from threshold to 600keV. Above 600keV EPDL97 crosssections are parameterised as following:
σ(E ) =a1
E+
a2
E 2+
a3
E 3+
a4
E 4+
a5
E 5 (8)
The accuracy of such parameterisation is better than 1%.
The sub-shell is sampled according to the relative cross-sections ofall sub-shells.
Two angular generators:
G4SauterGavrilaAngularDistribution: same as in the standard model -default optionG4PhotoElectricAngularGeneratorPolarized : double differential crosssection generator derived from Gavrila’s calculations, which can alsohandle polarized photons.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 18 / 46
![Page 35: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Low Energy Package: G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel
The total photoelectric cross section at a given photon energy E iscalculated from the data EPDL89 [D.E.Cullen , 1989].
The sub-shell is selected according to the relative cross sections of sub-shells,determined at the energy E by interpolation of the data. Only K-L-M shellsare taken into account.The direction of the electron is sampled according to the Sauterdistribution. Introducing the variable ν = 1− cosθe , the angular distributioncan be expressed as:
p(ν) = (2− ν)[1
A + ν+
1
2βγ(γ − 1)(γ − 2)]
ν
(A + ν)3 (9)
where
γ = 1 +Ee
mec2, A =
1
β− 1 (10)
where Ee is the electron energy, me its rest mass and β its velocity in units ofthe speed of light c .
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 19 / 46
![Page 36: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Low Energy Package: G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel
The total photoelectric cross section at a given photon energy E iscalculated from the data EPDL89 [D.E.Cullen , 1989].The sub-shell is selected according to the relative cross sections of sub-shells,determined at the energy E by interpolation of the data. Only K-L-M shellsare taken into account.
The direction of the electron is sampled according to the Sauterdistribution. Introducing the variable ν = 1− cosθe , the angular distributioncan be expressed as:
p(ν) = (2− ν)[1
A + ν+
1
2βγ(γ − 1)(γ − 2)]
ν
(A + ν)3 (9)
where
γ = 1 +Ee
mec2, A =
1
β− 1 (10)
where Ee is the electron energy, me its rest mass and β its velocity in units ofthe speed of light c .
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 19 / 46
![Page 37: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Low Energy Package: G4PenelopePhotoElectricModel
The total photoelectric cross section at a given photon energy E iscalculated from the data EPDL89 [D.E.Cullen , 1989].The sub-shell is selected according to the relative cross sections of sub-shells,determined at the energy E by interpolation of the data. Only K-L-M shellsare taken into account.The direction of the electron is sampled according to the Sauterdistribution. Introducing the variable ν = 1− cosθe , the angular distributioncan be expressed as:
p(ν) = (2− ν)[1
A + ν+
1
2βγ(γ − 1)(γ − 2)]
ν
(A + ν)3 (9)
where
γ = 1 +Ee
mec2, A =
1
β− 1 (10)
where Ee is the electron energy, me its rest mass and β its velocity in units ofthe speed of light c .
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 19 / 46
![Page 38: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Validation of Photoelectric effect models
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 19 / 46
![Page 39: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Validation of photoelectric model
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 20 / 46
![Page 40: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Validation of the Geant4 electromagnetic photoncross-sections for elements and compounds
[G.A.P. Cirrone, 2010]
Validation against NIST, SANDIA and EPDL97 data libraries15 elements, spanning the range of atomic number Z from 1 to 82, havebeen selected for validation and three compounds, namely Air, Water andNaIThe deviation of the Geant4 Standard model with respect to NIST andEPDL97 is within 10%.The two Geant4 LowEnergy models exhibit a very close agreement withthese libraries, as it is expected, because both NIST and EPDL97 use thesame data source below 1 MeV.The agreement of the Livermore and Penelope photoelectric models withthe SANDIA database is within 10% and in the energy range[1KeV − 1MeV ] is lower.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 21 / 46
![Page 41: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Validation of the Geant4 electromagnetic photoncross-sections for elements and compounds
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 22 / 46
![Page 42: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Validation of the Geant4 electromagnetic photoncross-sections for elements and compounds
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 23 / 46
![Page 43: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Validation of cross sections for Monte Carlo simulation ofthe photoelectric effect
[M. C. Han, 2016]
The validation process identifies Scofield’s 1973 non-relativisticcalculations, tabulated in EPDL97, as the one best reproducingexperimental measurements of total cross sections.
In a few test cases Ebel’s parameterisation [1KeV-300KeV], producesmore accurate results close to absorption edges.
G4Sandia parameterization differs from Biggs and Lighthill’s and isreported to significantly reduce the accuracy of total cross sectionsbelow 1KeV.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 24 / 46
![Page 44: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Validation of cross sections for Monte Carlo simulation ofthe photoelectric effect
[M. C. Han, 2016]
The validation process identifies Scofield’s 1973 non-relativisticcalculations, tabulated in EPDL97, as the one best reproducingexperimental measurements of total cross sections.
In a few test cases Ebel’s parameterisation [1KeV-300KeV], producesmore accurate results close to absorption edges.
G4Sandia parameterization differs from Biggs and Lighthill’s and isreported to significantly reduce the accuracy of total cross sectionsbelow 1KeV.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 24 / 46
![Page 45: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Validation of cross sections for Monte Carlo simulation ofthe photoelectric effect
[M. C. Han, 2016]
The validation process identifies Scofield’s 1973 non-relativisticcalculations, tabulated in EPDL97, as the one best reproducingexperimental measurements of total cross sections.
In a few test cases Ebel’s parameterisation [1KeV-300KeV], producesmore accurate results close to absorption edges.
G4Sandia parameterization differs from Biggs and Lighthill’s and isreported to significantly reduce the accuracy of total cross sectionsbelow 1KeV.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 24 / 46
![Page 46: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Validation of cross sections for Monte Carlo simulation ofthe photoelectric effect
[M. C. Han, 2016]
The validation process identifies Scofield’s 1973 non-relativisticcalculations, tabulated in EPDL97, as the one best reproducingexperimental measurements of total cross sections.
In a few test cases Ebel’s parameterisation [1KeV-300KeV], producesmore accurate results close to absorption edges.
G4Sandia parameterization differs from Biggs and Lighthill’s and isreported to significantly reduce the accuracy of total cross sectionsbelow 1KeV.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 24 / 46
![Page 47: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Modified Biggs-Lighthill parameterisation
The data sample was limited to test cases where the two cross sectioncalculations produce different values at the same energy of an experimentalmeasurement.
These test cases concern only noble gases, oxygen and hydrogen, andconcerns data below 1 keV, since the coefficients of the twoparameterisations differ only in the low energy range.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 25 / 46
![Page 48: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Ebel’s parameterisation
This parameterisation is applicable to energies between [1keV − 300keV ].
The efficiencies show similar compatibility with experiment for Ebel’s and EPDLcross sections, which is confirmed by the statistical comparison of the twocategories.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 26 / 46
![Page 49: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Ebel’s parameterisation - K shell cross sections
Ebel’s parameterisation appears more efficient than EPDL tabulations atreproducing experimental K-shell cross sections.
The failures of EPDL-based cross sections at reproducing experimental datamostly concern test cases close to absorption edges
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 27 / 46
![Page 50: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
New G4/GV photoelectric models development
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 27 / 46
![Page 51: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Possible actions and open points
Revert to original Sandia coefficients: not an option. Sandiaparameterization is not statistically superior to EPDL. Furthermore subshellscross sections are missing and the selection is currently done in a deterministicway.
Use EPDL/livermore in standard physics: livermore model is more complex(but also more accurate) than the current standard. It can be improved:
Accuracy of cross-sections with new available data (livermore/epics2014)CPU perfomanceAngular generator sampling algorithm
Other possibilities under investigation:
Move to Ebel’s parametrization: K- shell cross sections based on Ebel’sparameterisation produce more accurate results than EPDL in some test casesclose to absorption edges for energy range [1KeV- 300 KeV]Salvat and Sabatucci new formulation (Penelope 2015 version):uses the sametheory as in Scofield (1973) of the EPDL tables, but more accurate numericalalgorithms.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 28 / 46
![Page 52: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Possible actions and open points
Revert to original Sandia coefficients: not an option. Sandiaparameterization is not statistically superior to EPDL. Furthermore subshellscross sections are missing and the selection is currently done in a deterministicway.
Use EPDL/livermore in standard physics: livermore model is more complex(but also more accurate) than the current standard. It can be improved:
Accuracy of cross-sections with new available data (livermore/epics2014)CPU perfomanceAngular generator sampling algorithm
Other possibilities under investigation:
Move to Ebel’s parametrization: K- shell cross sections based on Ebel’sparameterisation produce more accurate results than EPDL in some test casesclose to absorption edges for energy range [1KeV- 300 KeV]Salvat and Sabatucci new formulation (Penelope 2015 version):uses the sametheory as in Scofield (1973) of the EPDL tables, but more accurate numericalalgorithms.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 28 / 46
![Page 53: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Possible actions and open points
Revert to original Sandia coefficients: not an option. Sandiaparameterization is not statistically superior to EPDL. Furthermore subshellscross sections are missing and the selection is currently done in a deterministicway.
Use EPDL/livermore in standard physics: livermore model is more complex(but also more accurate) than the current standard. It can be improved:
Accuracy of cross-sections with new available data (livermore/epics2014)CPU perfomanceAngular generator sampling algorithm
Other possibilities under investigation:
Move to Ebel’s parametrization: K- shell cross sections based on Ebel’sparameterisation produce more accurate results than EPDL in some test casesclose to absorption edges for energy range [1KeV- 300 KeV]Salvat and Sabatucci new formulation (Penelope 2015 version):uses the sametheory as in Scofield (1973) of the EPDL tables, but more accurate numericalalgorithms.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 28 / 46
![Page 54: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Possible actions and open points
Revert to original Sandia coefficients: not an option. Sandiaparameterization is not statistically superior to EPDL. Furthermore subshellscross sections are missing and the selection is currently done in a deterministicway.
Use EPDL/livermore in standard physics: livermore model is more complex(but also more accurate) than the current standard. It can be improved:
Accuracy of cross-sections with new available data (livermore/epics2014)CPU perfomanceAngular generator sampling algorithm
Other possibilities under investigation:
Move to Ebel’s parametrization: K- shell cross sections based on Ebel’sparameterisation produce more accurate results than EPDL in some test casesclose to absorption edges for energy range [1KeV- 300 KeV]
Salvat and Sabatucci new formulation (Penelope 2015 version):uses the sametheory as in Scofield (1973) of the EPDL tables, but more accurate numericalalgorithms.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 28 / 46
![Page 55: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Possible actions and open points
Revert to original Sandia coefficients: not an option. Sandiaparameterization is not statistically superior to EPDL. Furthermore subshellscross sections are missing and the selection is currently done in a deterministicway.
Use EPDL/livermore in standard physics: livermore model is more complex(but also more accurate) than the current standard. It can be improved:
Accuracy of cross-sections with new available data (livermore/epics2014)CPU perfomanceAngular generator sampling algorithm
Other possibilities under investigation:
Move to Ebel’s parametrization: K- shell cross sections based on Ebel’sparameterisation produce more accurate results than EPDL in some test casesclose to absorption edges for energy range [1KeV- 300 KeV]Salvat and Sabatucci new formulation (Penelope 2015 version):uses the sametheory as in Scofield (1973) of the EPDL tables, but more accurate numericalalgorithms.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 28 / 46
![Page 56: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard - execution time
Model level test, #particles = 107, #repetitions = 10
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 29 / 46
![Page 57: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard - execution time
Model level test, #particles = 107, #repetitions = 10
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 30 / 46
![Page 58: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard - execution time
Model level test, #particles = 107, #repetitions = 10
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 31 / 46
![Page 59: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard percent variation
Max percent variation: all energies vs E >= 1MeV
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 32 / 46
![Page 60: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard - Angular distribution ON
The standard angular distribution has a threshold at ∼ 26MeVGreater differences are observable at low energies and for heavierelements
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 33 / 46
![Page 61: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
New Penelope-like angular distribution
Achievements:
Increased threshold from 26MeV to 100MeVSpeedup between 4% and 10% in most cases
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 34 / 46
![Page 62: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Unit test and benchmark of improved PELivermore model
The improved Livermore model has been included in 10.3ref04 and tested:
Results for 10.3ref04 are stable compared to 10.3ref03
No visible degradation of any result
Validation results available athttps://geant4-tools.web.cern.ch/geant4-tools/emtesting/
Version 10.3ref04 with Livermore model for Rayleigh and Photo-effectused as default in Em physics list, to check CPU performance:
Improved quality of photon cross sections that may slightly affectshower shape
1% slowdown for Higgs sample
2% slowdown for e- showers
− > Optimization on photoelectric model might recover CPUperformance.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 35 / 46
![Page 63: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Livermore vs Standard - Angular distribution OFF
Switching off the angular distribution we clearly see a dependency on theenergy and on the Z of the material.This is dependent on a 600KeV threshold between tabulated andparameterised cross sections (EPDL97)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 36 / 46
![Page 64: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
New parameterisation - livermore/epics2014 data
New cross sections data recently introduced in Geant4: livermore/epics2014 (S. Incerti)New fit: adding one more parameter and performing two separate fits we can reduce thethreshold from 600KeV to 5KeV.
σ(E ) =a1
E+
a2
E 2+
a3
E 3+
a4
E 4+
a5
E 5+
a6
E 6 (11)
Eγ >= 5KeV : Two new fits in two different energy ranges
Eγ ∈ [5KeV − 50KeV ]Eγ > 50KeV
Eγ < 5KeV :
Keep the parameterisation (under evaluation): high-energy physics simulationsTabulated cross sections: low-energy physics simulations
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 37 / 46
![Page 65: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Two separate fits - new data
Achievements:
Threshold moved from 600KeV to 5KeV
Speedup has to be measuredMarilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 38 / 46
![Page 66: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Two separate fits - new data
In some cases we are able to cover all the spectrum withparameterization
Especially for inner shells
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 39 / 46
![Page 67: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
New parameterisation: example
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 40 / 46
![Page 68: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
Two separate fits - new data: special cases
Outer shells present a non-monotonic behaviour, significantly at verylow energies
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 41 / 46
![Page 69: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
Two separate fits - new data: special cases
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 42 / 46
![Page 70: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
Binding energies data analysis
At least four different sources of binding energies data in Geant4:
G4AtomicShells: used in the standard physics
G4AtomicShellsEADL: recently introduced by L. G. Sarmiento
livermore/phot/pe-: livermore parametrisation
fluor/binding.dat: used for de-excitation model - same as theparametrisation ones
EADL vs livermore/phot/pe-MeV
G4AtomicShells vs G4AtomicShells_EADLMeV
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 43 / 46
![Page 71: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
Binding energies data analysis
G4AtomicShellsEADL and livermore/phot/pe-For Z < 60 differences are within 35eV .From Z = 60 (mostly on k-shells) we have differences from around 50eV up to630eV for Z = 98
G4AtomicShells and G4AtomicShellsEADLTotal differentNumShell: 38Total n. energies that differ more than 10 eV: 19 (72 eV is one of the biggest)G4AtomicShellsEADL has always one more shell than G4AtomicShells - and it’sthe right number of shells (ionisation potential taken mostly from theoreticalcalculations)
Decoupling of models from binding energies would be desirable. But not easyto achieve:
Data should not disagreeAt least the deexcitation model has to have the same number of shellsThe source of data of EADL class need to be clarified - detailed study need tobe doneTo guarantee the consistency the decision (today) is to include binding energiesinside the model.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 44 / 46
![Page 72: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
Conclusions and plans
Review of G4 photoelectric models has been doneUpdated and improved Livermore model:
Photoelectron angular distribution sampling has been improved.Measurements report improvements between 4% and 10%.
The use of Alias sampling in GeantV for the rejection part will eventuallyproduce greater gains.
A new fit (in two steps) on updated cross-sections data has been performed
More accuracyMore efficiency: threshold from 600KeV to 5KeV
We may produce an alternative standard model:
More accurate parameterizationThat take into account shells samplingFast
Open issue: have consistency in the atomic binding energies data
PhotoelectricDeexcitation modelOther modelsWe are not ready to drop G4AtomicShells data
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 73: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Conclusions and plans
Review of G4 photoelectric models has been done
Updated and improved Livermore model:
Photoelectron angular distribution sampling has been improved.Measurements report improvements between 4% and 10%.
The use of Alias sampling in GeantV for the rejection part will eventuallyproduce greater gains.
A new fit (in two steps) on updated cross-sections data has been performed
More accuracyMore efficiency: threshold from 600KeV to 5KeV
We may produce an alternative standard model:
More accurate parameterizationThat take into account shells samplingFast
Open issue: have consistency in the atomic binding energies data
PhotoelectricDeexcitation modelOther modelsWe are not ready to drop G4AtomicShells data
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 74: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
Conclusions and plans
Review of G4 photoelectric models has been doneUpdated and improved Livermore model:
Photoelectron angular distribution sampling has been improved.Measurements report improvements between 4% and 10%.
The use of Alias sampling in GeantV for the rejection part will eventuallyproduce greater gains.
A new fit (in two steps) on updated cross-sections data has been performed
More accuracyMore efficiency: threshold from 600KeV to 5KeV
We may produce an alternative standard model:
More accurate parameterizationThat take into account shells samplingFast
Open issue: have consistency in the atomic binding energies data
PhotoelectricDeexcitation modelOther modelsWe are not ready to drop G4AtomicShells data
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 75: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
Conclusions and plans
Review of G4 photoelectric models has been doneUpdated and improved Livermore model:
Photoelectron angular distribution sampling has been improved.Measurements report improvements between 4% and 10%.
The use of Alias sampling in GeantV for the rejection part will eventuallyproduce greater gains.
A new fit (in two steps) on updated cross-sections data has been performed
More accuracyMore efficiency: threshold from 600KeV to 5KeV
We may produce an alternative standard model:
More accurate parameterizationThat take into account shells samplingFast
Open issue: have consistency in the atomic binding energies data
PhotoelectricDeexcitation modelOther modelsWe are not ready to drop G4AtomicShells data
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 76: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
Thanks for your attention.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 77: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
Appendix
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 78: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
Experimental data: Total cross sections
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 79: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
Experimental data: Total cross sections
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 80: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
References
D.E.Cullen et al
Tables and graphs of photon-interaction cross sections from 10 eV to 100 GeV derived from theLLNL evaluated photon data library (EPDL)
Report UCRL-50400 (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
J Allison et al., by the Geant4 Collaboration
Recent Developments in Geant4
Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 835 186-225, 2016
V. Ivanchenko et al.
Recent Improvements in Geant4 Electromagnetic Physics Models and Interfaces
Progress in NUCLEAR SCIENCE and TECHNOLOGY, 2011 Vol. 2, pp.898-903,
J H Hubbell
Review and history of photon cross section calculations
Phys. Med. Biol. 51 (2006) R245-R262 .
Francesc Salvat and Jose M Fernandez-Varea
Overview of physical interaction models for photon and electron transport used in Monte Carlocodes
Metrologia 46 (2009) S112-S138 2010.
Vladimir Ivanchenko et al. (2010)
Recent Improvements in Geant4 Electromagnetic Physics Models and Interfaces
Joint International Conference on Supercomputing in Nuclear Applications and Monte Carlo 2010618(1-3), 315 - 322.
G.A.P. Cirrone and G. Cuttone and F. Di Rosa and L. Pandola and F. Romano and Q. Zhang(2010)
Validation of the Geant4 electromagnetic photon cross-sections for elements and compounds
Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers,Detectors and Associated Equipment 618(1-3), 315 - 322.
M. C. Han and H. S. Kim and M. G. Pia and T. Basaglia and M. Batic and G. Hoff and C. H. Kimand P. Saracco (2016)
Validation of Cross Sections for Monte Carlo Simulation of the Photoelectric Effect
IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 63(2), 1117-1146.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 81: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
The End
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 82: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
Backup slides
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 45 / 46
![Page 83: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
Standard electromagnetic package - Geant4-10.2 - Finalstate sampling
Differential Photoeffelectric cross section correct to first order αZ
dσ
d cos θ' sin2 θ
(1− β cos θ)4
{1 +
1
2γ(γ − 1)(γ − 2)(1− β cos θ)
}(12)
where β and γ are the photoelectron Lorentz factors. cosθ is sampled from the probability density function:
f (cos θ) =1− β2
2β
1
(1− β cos θ)2(13)
so
cos θ =(1− 2r) + β
(1− 2r)β + 1(14)
The rejection function is :
g(cos θ) =1− cos2θ
(1− β cos θ)2[1 + b(1− β cos θ)] (15)
with b = γ(γ − 1)(γ − 1)/2It can be shown that g(cosθ) is positive for each cosθ ∈ [−1,+1], and can be majored by :
gsup =
{γ2[1 + b(1− β)] if γ ∈]1, 2]
γ2[1 + b(1 + β)] if γ > 2(16)
The efficiency of this method is ∼ 50% if γ < 2,∼ 25% if ∈ [2, 3].
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 84: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
Standard electromagnetic package - Geant 10.2 -Macroscopic and atomic cross-sections
Once the photoelectric process is selected, the model must choosewhich atom is involved. In compound materials the i th element ischosen randomly according to the probability:
Prob(Zi ,Eγ) =niσi (Zi ,Eγ)∑
i [niσi (Eγ)](17)
where ni is the number of atom per volume of the i th elementcomposing the material.
For each process the total cross section at a given energy E isobtained with a log-log interpolation of cross section data σ1 and σ2
available in the data libraries from the closest energies.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 85: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
Macroscopic cross section and mean free path
For compound materials (and also for mixtures) the molecular crosssection σph(E ) is evaluated by means of the additivity approximation.
It consists in the sum of the atomic cross sections of all the elementsin the molecule:
σ(Eγ) =∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ) (18)
where ni is the number of atoms per volume of the i th element of thematerial.The mean free path, λ, for a photon to interact via the photoelectriceffect is given by:
λ(Eγ) =(∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ))−1
(19)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 86: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Macroscopic cross section and mean free path
For compound materials (and also for mixtures) the molecular crosssection σph(E ) is evaluated by means of the additivity approximation.It consists in the sum of the atomic cross sections of all the elementsin the molecule:
σ(Eγ) =∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ) (18)
where ni is the number of atoms per volume of the i th element of thematerial.
The mean free path, λ, for a photon to interact via the photoelectriceffect is given by:
λ(Eγ) =(∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ))−1
(19)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 87: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
Macroscopic cross section and mean free path
For compound materials (and also for mixtures) the molecular crosssection σph(E ) is evaluated by means of the additivity approximation.It consists in the sum of the atomic cross sections of all the elementsin the molecule:
σ(Eγ) =∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ) (18)
where ni is the number of atoms per volume of the i th element of thematerial.The mean free path, λ, for a photon to interact via the photoelectriceffect is given by:
λ(Eγ) =(∑
i
niσ(Zi ,Eγ))−1
(19)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 88: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
PhotoElectric SG angular distribution
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
-12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2
’photoelectric_G4_angular_Pb.ascii’ u 2:3’photoelectric_GV_angular_NIST_MAT_Pb.ascii’ u 2:3
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 89: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
Total Photoeffect cross section correct to first order αZ
σκ =3
2φ0α
4Z 5 β3(1− β2)[1− (1− β2)
12
]5
[M
(1− παZ
β
)+ παZN
](20)
where
M =4
3+
1− 3(1− β2)12 + 2(1− β2)
β2(1− β2)12
[1 +
1− β2
2βln
1− β1 + β
](21)
and
N =1
β3{− 4
15
1
(1− β2)12
}+34
15− 63
15
(1− β2
) 12 +
25
15
(1− β2
)+
8
15
(1− β2
) 32 + (1− β2)
12
[1− 3(1− β2)
12 + 2(1− β2)
] 1
2βln
1− β1 + β
(22)
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 90: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Standard electromagnetic package - Geant 10.2 - Totalcross-section
For each process the total cross section at a given energy E is obtained witha log-log interpolation.
log(σ(E )) = log(σ1)log(E2)− log(E )
log(E2)− log(E1)+ log(σ2)
log(E )− log(E1)
log(E2)− log(E1)(23)
where E1 and E2 are the closest lower and higher energy for which crosssection data σ1 and σ2 are available in the data libraries respectively.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 91: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
Notes
According to G4PEFluoModel for energies Eγ > 25.55MeV it isassumed that the emitted photoelectron has the same direction as theincident gamma. This means that for Eγ > 25.55MeV cosθ = 1always.
N.B.: Need to test/check and correct the number of bin and thenumber of tested energies. (with nBins=200 there aren’timprovements with respect to nBins=151 which is working betterthan nBin=99
Da 0.5MeV in su abbiamo problemi nel riprodurre la distribuzioneangolare. Update: Improved, but still need to test.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 92: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
Photoelectric effect in Geant4 - low energy package
Two implementations of the p.e. effect. The Livermore and Penelopecross-sections are tabulated according to EPDL97 and EPDL89[D.E.Cullen , 1989], respectively.
G4Livermore model provides two options of computing the angulardistribution of the emitted photoelectron
Based on Gavrila’s distribution of the polar angle for the K shell andthe L1 sub-shell - default as the standard modelBased on a double differential cross section derived from Gavrila’scalculations, which can also handle polarized photons.
G4Penelope model is reengineered from the 2001 Penelope code.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 93: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
Photoelectric effect in Geant4 - low energy package
Two implementations of the p.e. effect. The Livermore and Penelopecross-sections are tabulated according to EPDL97 and EPDL89[D.E.Cullen , 1989], respectively.
G4Livermore model provides two options of computing the angulardistribution of the emitted photoelectron
Based on Gavrila’s distribution of the polar angle for the K shell andthe L1 sub-shell - default as the standard modelBased on a double differential cross section derived from Gavrila’scalculations, which can also handle polarized photons.
G4Penelope model is reengineered from the 2001 Penelope code.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46
![Page 94: PhotoElectric effect models in Geant4 and GeantV€¦ · PhotoElectric e ect models in Geant4 and GeantV Marilena Bandieramonte CERN marilena.bandieramonte@cern.ch June 8, 2017 Marilena](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022071409/610326e0c70fde36c5560b57/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
Photoelectric effect in Geant4 - low energy package
Two implementations of the p.e. effect. The Livermore and Penelopecross-sections are tabulated according to EPDL97 and EPDL89[D.E.Cullen , 1989], respectively.
G4Livermore model provides two options of computing the angulardistribution of the emitted photoelectron
Based on Gavrila’s distribution of the polar angle for the K shell andthe L1 sub-shell - default as the standard modelBased on a double differential cross section derived from Gavrila’scalculations, which can also handle polarized photons.
G4Penelope model is reengineered from the 2001 Penelope code.
Marilena Bandieramonte (ep-sft) PhotoElectric effect review June 8, 2017 46 / 46