PETITION FOR QUO WARRANTO - Pinoy...
Transcript of PETITION FOR QUO WARRANTO - Pinoy...
· . .• : ~~·I·: .... .:f;:; i,l· . ,..•~ ...-;~. ::~ :-~,:.;.'; .~:;-..:. ..::;.\ ~ ... ~~';.~,".~.~~ ... '~.:: \~X.~·~_"":!"~ ~.,.,}r' C·<';~~ ;:/.'- .;.:,...j,~. z·- .,. ~ :;.,~
fjI#<~_:",:::",f':' "
, "Republic of the PhilippinesHOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ELECTORALTItt~AIfREP.
, , <C' ["(..,- 'to" ".,' l~ Ii" 'fQuezon City !'iL :.~ , . ! 0W:i;'_ ;\-,.,.
'-,
DR. REYNALDO LESACA, JR.,CRIEtTINA PALABAY,RENATO M. REYES, JR.,ERLIN~ACADAPAN,ANTONIO ,FLORES,
'JOSELITO USTAREZPetit~oners,
- versus -HRET CASE NO. 07-()/lJFOR: Quo Warranto
"
MAJOR GEN. JOVITO S. PALPARAN, JR. (Ret.),Respondent.
x-------------~--------~----~--------------------------------x
"However, it is not enough for thecandidate to claim representation of themarginalized and 'underrepresented,becaus'e it is easy to claim and feign. Theparty-list _organization or party mustfactually and truly represent themarginalized and underrepresentedconstituencies mentioned in Section 5.Concurrently, the persons nominated bythe party·list candidate-organization mustbe "~ipino citizens belonging tomarginalized and underrepresented sectors,organization, or parties."l
PETITION FOR QUO WARRANTO
PETITIONERS, by themselves unto this Honorable Tribunal,.respectfully state:
lAng Bagong Bayani - OFW Labor Party vs. Ang Bagong Bayani - OFW Labor Party Go! Go!Philippines, et af., G. R. No. 147589, 26 June 2001.
2
THE PARTIES
1. The Petitioners are Filipino citizens, residents of the
Philippines, and are named below:
1.1 PETITIONER DR. REYNALDO LESACA, JR., is of
legal age, Filipino, a registered voter, and the
Chairperson of Bayan Muna, a political party
registered with the COMELEC under the party-list
system pursuant to the provisions of Republic Act No.
7941 (Party-List Act). He may be served with this
Honorable Tribunal’s processes and orders at 45 K-7
Street, West Kamias, Quezon City.
1.2 PETITIONER CRISTINA PALABAY is of legal age,
Filipino, a registered voter, and the Secretary General
of the Gabriela Women’s Party. She may be served
with this Honorable Tribunal’s processes and orders
at SW-309 House of Representatives, Batasan
Complex, Constitution Hills, Quezon City.
1.3 PETITIONER RENATO M. REYES, JR., is of legal age,
Filipino, a registered voter, and the Secretary General
of the Bagong Alyansang Makabayan (BAYAN). He
may be served with this Honorable Commission’s
processes and orders at Erythrina Bldg., No. 1
Matatag cor. Maaralin Streets, Central District
Quezon City.
1.4 PETITIONER ERLINDA CADAPAN is of legal age,
Filipino, a registered voter, and a founding member of
HUSTISYA, an organization of the families of victims
of extra-judicial killings and enforced disappearances
3
during the administration of President Gloria
Macapagal-Arroyo. She may be served with this
Honorable Tribunal’s processes and orders at
Erythrina Bldg., No. 1 Matatag cor. Maaralin Streets,
Central District Quezon City.
1.5 PETITIONER ANTONIO FLORES is of legal age,
Filipino, a registered voter, and a member of the
National Executive Committee of Kilusang
Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP) and ANAKPAWIS
Party. He may be served with this Honorable
Tribunal’s processes and orders at 161-B Chico St.,
Project 2, Quezon City.
1.6 PETITIONER JOSELITO USTAREZ is of legal age,
Filipino, a registered voter, and the President of
NAFLU-KMU and an officer of ANAKPAWIS Party. He
may be served with this Honorable Tribunal’s
processes and orders at 63 Narra Street, Barangay
Claro, Project 3, Quezon City.
2. Respondent JOVITO S. PALPARAN, JR., is the First
Nominee of Bantay Party-List who took an oath of office as the
representative of the said party-list in the House of Representative
after Bantay was proclaimed a winner during the 2007 party-list
elections, and entitled to one seat in Congress, pursuant to the recent
ruling of the Honorable Supreme Court in the case of Banat vs.
COMELEC [G.R. No. 179271, 21 April 2009]. He may be served with
this Honorable Tribunal’s processes and orders at the Office of the
Secretary General, House of Representatives, Batasan Hills, Quezon
City.
4
NATURE OF THE PETITION
3. This is a verified Petition for quo warranto contesting the
assumption of retired Major General Jovito S. Palparan, Jr. as
representative of the party-list Bantay in the House of Representatives
on the ground of ineligibility. It is being filed in accordance with the
provisions of Rule 17 of the 2004 Rules of the House of
Representatives Electoral Tribunal.
CAUSES OF ACTION
I
RESPONDENT JOVITO S. PALPARAN, JR., A RETIRED MAJOR GENERAL, IS INELIGIBLE TO BECOME A PARTY LIST NOMINEE AND REPRESENTATIVE BECAUSE HE DOES NOT BELONG TO THE MARGINALIZED AND UNDERREPRESENTED SECTORS BANTAY PURPORTS TO REPRESENT. RESPONDENT ALSO COMMITTED GROSS HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AGAINST MARGINALIZED AND UNDERREPRESENTED SECTORS AND ORGANIZATIONS.
4. In several news reports, respondent Jovito Palparan has
been quoted as saying that his Bantay Party-List purportedly
represents victims of communist rebels, Civilian Armed Forces
Geographical Units (CAFGUs), former rebels and security guards.
5
5. From respondent Palparan’s own admission, Bantay,
which he seeks to represent in the House of Representatives, is a
party-list that will supposedly represent the following sectors, namely,
(1) victims of communist rebels, (2) Civilian Armed Forces
Geographical Units (CAFGUs), (3) former rebels and (4) security
guards.
6. Section 9 of R.A. 7941, or the Party-List Law provides that:
“Sec. 9. Qualification of Party-List Nominees. - No person shall be nominated as party-list representative unless he is a natural born citizen of the Philippines, a registered voter, a resident of the Philippines for a period of not less than one (1) year immediately preceding the day of the election, able to read and write, bona fide member of the party or organization which he seeks to represent for at least ninety (90) days preceding the day of the election, and is at least twenty-five (25) years of age on the day of the election.” [Emphasis supplied]
7. Relevantly, the Honorable Supreme Court, in the case of
Ang Bagong Bayani – OFW Labor Party vs. Ang Bagong Bayani – OFW
Labor Party Go! Go! Philippines, et al., has defined the qualification of a
party-list nominee as above-quoted, and which is reiterated hereunder,
thus:
““However, it is not enough for the candidate to claim representation of the marginalized and underrepresented, because it is easy to claim and feign. The party-list organization or party must factually and truly represent the marginalized and underrepresented constituencies mentioned in Section 5. Concurrently, the persons nominated by the party-list candidate-organization must be “Filipino citizens belonging to marginalized and underrepresented sectors, organization, or parties.” [Emphasis supplied]
6
8. In the same case, the Honorable Supreme Court came out
with the “Guidelines in Screening Party-List Participants”, number
seven of which states that:
“Seventh, not only the candidate party or organization must represent marginalized and underrepresented sectors; so also must its nominees. To repeat, under Section 2 of RA 7941, the nominees must be Filipino citizens “who belong to marginalized and underrepresented sectors, organizations and parties.” Surely, the interests of the youth cannot be fully represented by a retiree; neither can those of the urban poor or the working class, by an industrialist. To allow otherwise is to betray the State policy to give genuine representation to the marginalized and underrepresented.”
9. The Honorable Supreme Court, in the recent case of Banat
vs. COMELEC [G.R. No. 179271, 21 April 2009], has reiterated the
above-described qualification of a party-list representative, thus:
“Under Section 9 of R.A. No. 7941, it is not necessary that the party-list organization’s nominee “wallow in poverty, destitution and infirmity” as there is no financial status required in the law. It is enough that the nominee of the sectoral party/organization/coalition belongs to the marginalized and underrepresented sectors, that is, if the nominee represents the fisherfolk, he or she must be a fisherfolk, or if the nominee represents the senior citizens, he or she must be a senior citizen.”[Emphasis supplied]
10. Verily, the Honorable Supreme Court could not be clearer
as to the qualification of a party-list nominee, that is, he/she must
belong to the marginalized and underrepresented sector he/she
claims to represent.
7
11. In this wise, it must be emphasized that respondent
Jovito S. Palparan, Jr., does not belong to the alleged
marginalized and underrepresented sectors that he publicly
pronounced to represent.
12. Respondent Jovito Palparan, Jr. is not an alleged victim of
communist rebels, and neither is he a former rebel.
13. Furthermore, respondent is definitely not a security guard.
In fact, several news reports indicate that he is a co-owner of the 24-
Hour Security Agency, which figured in two mining disputes in the
provinces of Bulacan and Zambales last year. As an owner of a
security agency he certainly cannot claim to belong to
underrepresented sector of private security guards.
14. Significantly, the Honorable Tribunal may well take
judicial notice that members of the Civilian Armed Forces
Geographical Unit (CAFGU) cannot participate in the party-list
elections, it being a government-funded entity, pursuant to the
“Guidelines for Screening Participants” enunciated by the
Honorable Supreme Court in the Bagong Bayani case, to wit:
“Fifth, the party or organization must not be an adjunct of, or a project organized or an entity funded or assisted by, the government. By the very nature of the party-list system, the party or organization must be a group of citizens, organized by citizens and operated by citizens. It must be independent of the government. The participation of the government or its officials in the affairs of a party-list candidate is not only illegal and unfair to other parties, but also deleterious to the objective of the law: to enable citizens belonging to marginalized and
8
underrepresented sectors and organizations to be elected to the House of Representatives.”[Emphasis supplied]
15. Far from belonging to a marginalized and
underrepresented sector, respondent Jovito Palparan, Jr. is a “man of
power”, and in fact, he continues to wield power even after his
retirement from military service with the rank of Major General.
16. The truth is respondent Jovito Palparan, Jr. was never a
marginalized individual, but for practically more than half of his life,
he has wielded power by virtue of his being a high-ranking officer of
the Armed Forces of the Philippines, for which he has been accused,
and widely believe to have committed, a plethora of human rights
violations, including the extrajudicial killings of legal activists.
17. The Honorable Tribunal may consider the following
military career of respondent Jovito Palparan, Jr. 2, thus:
(1) Commanding General, 7th Infantry (Kaugnay) Division, Philippine Army (September 21, 2005-September 11, 2006)
(2) Commanding General, 8th Infantry Division, Catbalogan, Samar (2005)
(3) Chief of Staff, Philippine Army (4) Commander, Philippine Humanitarian Contingent in
Iraq (5) Brigade Commander, 204th Brigade, Mindoro and
Romblon (6) Commander, Task Force Banahaw, CALABARZON (7) Commanding Officer, Doctrine Center (8) Commander, AFP Rapid Deployment Force (9) Commander, 24th Infantry Battalion for 5 years
2 http://www.gmanews.tv/story/31867/Jovito-S-Palparan-Jr
9
(10) Lieutenant, served in Basilan and Sulu for eight years (11) Commissioned, called to active duty to the AFP in
1973
18. From the foregoing, there is no doubt that respondent
Jovito Palparan has always been a “man of power”, and not one who
belongs to a marginalized and underrepresented sector.
19. At this juncture, it must be stressed, as the Honorable
Supreme Court has in several occasions stressed, that the party-list
system is a social justice tool designed to enable the great masses of
the Filipino people to become lawmakers themselves through their
representatives, who comes from them, in order, among others, to give
life to the constitutional mandate of the right of the people and their
organizations to effective and reasonable participation at all levels of
social, political and economic decision-making.
20. Contrary to this, respondent Jovito Palparan is publicly
known to have nothing but sheer contempt for the organizations of
the marginalized and underrepresented, and for progressive
individuals, which he has publicly declared must be stopped in their
advocacies at any cost.
21. Significantly, the Honorable Supreme Court, in the case of
Secretary of National Defense vs. Raymond and Reynaldo Manalo [G.R.
No. 180906, 7 October 2008], affirmed the Court of Appeals ruling in
C.A. G.R. Amparo No. 00001 [26 December 2007] that respondent
Jovito Palparan was “directly involved” in the abduction of farmer-
10
brothers Raymond and Reynaldo Manalo in Bulacan on suspicion of
being communist rebels, thus:
“We affirm the factual findings of the appellate court, largely based on respondent Raymond Manalo’s affidavit and testimony, viz:
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Gen. Palparan’s participation in the abduction was also established. At the very least, he was aware of the petitioners’ captivity at the hands of men in uniform assigned to his command. In fact, he or any other officer tendered no controversion to the firm claim of Raymond that he (Gen. Palparan) met them in person in a safehouse in Bulacan and told them what he wanted them and their parents to do or not to be doing. Gen. Palparan’s direct and personal role in the abduction might not have been shown but his knowledge of the dire situation of the petitioners during their long captivity at the hands of military personnel under his command bespoke of his indubitable command policy that unavoidably encouraged and not merely tolerated the abduction of civilians without due process of law and without probable cause. [Emphasis supplied]
22. Indeed, allowing respondent Jovito Palparan’s nomination
as a representative of Bantay is tantamount to the “bastardization” of
the party-list system.
23. Again, how could a retired general of the Armed Forces of
the Philippines with a notorious human rights record against the
marginalized and underrepresented wherever he was assigned
represent the said marginalized and underrepresented when he
himself has repressed and suppressed them?
II RETIRED MILITARY GENERALS LIKE RESPONDENT JOVITO PALPARAN, AND THEIR POLICE COUNTERPARTS, ARE NOT
11
ELIGIBLE TO BECOME PARTY-LIST NOMINEES AND REPRESENTATIVES BECAUSE THEY DO NOT BELONG TO, AND CANNOT REPRESENT THE MARGINALIZED AND UNDERREPRESENTED SECTORS OF PHILIPPINE SOCIETY.
24. It is respectfully submitted that retired military generals
like respondent Jovito Palparan, Jr., and their counterparts in the
police, cannot truly represent the marginalized and underrepresented
sectors of Philippine society.
25. There is no doubt that military generals, and their police
counterparts, are at the helm of power in Philippine society. They
wield enormous powers while they are in the service. A great many of
them are known to live in luxury and comfort in exclusive villages and
subdivisions.
26. In retirement, they continue to exercise power and
influence and wallow in privilege. They are even appointed to top
government positions. Consider the following generals in the Arroyo
government:
(1) Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita (2) Arturo Carillo, Military Affairs Adviser (3) Honesto Isleta, Presidential Assistant on Strategic
Information (4) Glenn Rabonza, Office of the Civil Defense Executive
Director and National Disaster Coordinating Council Administrator
(5) Angel Atutubo, Manila International Airport Authority Assistant General Manager
12
(6) Thelmo Cunanan, Chairman of the Social Security System
(7) Proceso Maligalig, Head of Bataan Shipyard (8) Hermogenes Ebdane Jr., Public Works Secretary (9) Leandro Mendoza, Transportation and
Communications Secretary (10) Roberto Lastimoso, Director of Metro Rail Transit
Corp. (11) Angelo Reyes, Energy Secretary (12) Narciso Abaya, Chair of Bases Conversion
Development Authority (13) Dionisio Santiago, PDEA Director (14) Roy Cimatu, Special Envoy to Middle East (15) Efren Abu, Ambassador to Brunei-Indonesia-
Malaysia-Philippines-East Asia growth Area (BIMP-EAGA)
(16) Generoso Senga, Ambassador to Iran (17) Orlando Macaspac, Presidential Adviser for Police
Affairs (18) Florencio Fianza, Former Chairman of the Philippine
Racing Commission (19) Vidal Querol, Ambassador to Indonesia (20) Ernesto de Leon, Ambassador to Australia.
27. Respondent Jovito Palparan himself was reported to have
been offered various positions in government immediately after his
retirement from military service, but the public uproar over his then
impending appointment in government office made the would-be
appointing power back out. However, as the furor died down, the
appointing power surreptitiously appointed respondent Jovito
Palparan as Director of Freeport Services Corp., a company of the
state-owned Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority.
28. We thus pose this question, “How can men and women of
power truly represent the powerless?” Indeed, how can one who
belongs to that privileged class of military officers that has long taken
political and economic power in Philippine society represent the
marginalized and underrepresented sector?
13
29. Allowing retired military generals, and their police
counterparts, therefore to become nominees and representative of
party-list organizations would desecrate the hallowed intent of the
party-list provision of the Constitution and violate the ruling of the
Supreme Court in the case of Bagong Bayani that the party list
system is reserved for the marginalized and underrepresented.
30. The Honorable Supreme Court, again the in the case of
Bagong Bayani, has clearly elucidated the import of the party-list
provision, that is Section 5 (2), Article VI of the Constitution, thus:
“The intent of the Constitution is clear: to give genuine power to the people, not only by giving more law to those who have less in life, but more so by enabling them to become veritable lawmakers themselves. Consistent with this intent, the policy of the implementing law, we repeat, is likewise clear: “to enable Filipino citizens belonging to marginalized and underrepresented sectors, organizations and parties, x x x, to become members of the House of Representatives.” Where the language of the law is clear, it must be applied according to its express terms.
31. This being the case, military generals, and their police
counterparts, certainly cannot represent the marginalized and
underrepresented because they do not belong to the these sectors of
Philippine society, but as pointed earlier, they wield enormous
political and economic powers in Philippine society while in military
service and even after their retirement.
32. Those who continue to belong to this privileged class
cannot make the hopes and dreams, the aspirations and longings of
the underprivileged their own. Unfortunately, respondent Jovito
Palparan belongs to this class. He is therefore not qualified to
become a nominee of Bantay Party-List.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE, premIses considered, Petitioners
respectfully pray that this Honorable Tribunal, after hearing,
disqualify respondent Jovita Palparan as a nomInee and
representative of Bantay Party~List.
Other forms of relief, just and equitable under the
circumstances are likewise prayed for.
Quezon City, 28 April 2009.
ONIO FLORESPetitioner
~tMftJ~~CRIstINA-PALAJIAY
Petitioner
~ERLINDA DAPAN
Petitioner
JOS~~ZPetitioner
14
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES)QUEZON CITY ) S.S.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, DR. REYNALDO LESACA, JR., oflegal age, a Filipino, with officeaddress at 45 K-7 Street, West Kamias, Quezon City, after been havingbeen duly sworn to in accordance with law hereby depose and state that:
1. I am a Petitioner in this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovita Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shall duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
DR. ~D~~~JR.Affiant/Petitioner .
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28 th day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed and understood the above, theaffiant/petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number W0371394 issued on May 31, 2007and which expires on May 31, 2012.
DNO·WPageNo.---!::;iv{BookNo.~;
Series of 2009.
15
#Doc.NO.~Page No. .Book No. ;Series of 2009.
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES)QUEZON CITY ) 8.S.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, CRISTINA PALABAY, of legal age, a Filipino, with office addressat 8W-309 House of Representatives, Batasan Complex, ConstitutionHills, Quezon City, after been having been duly sworn to in accordancewith law hereby depose and state that:
1. I am a Petitioner in this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovita Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shall duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
(lP~dLfL{//CRISTINA PAL-;;AY
Affiant / Pe titioner
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28 th day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed' and understood the above, theaffiant/ petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number 880035148 issued on December 01,2005 and which expires on December 01,:~o
riC" ' 'NOTi\RYtiPUBmt, . ,,~:: G, :;::: '"i 5S
";::, 1 '>n~ P,G," ~ .', ",,"';; GlT'f 1't f 1110;",,: "'. ',,:, ':~i"i'·~G),S-:;)I"ln1'
( f U~ .. c • :..' i <, " , • '. " ,
16
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES)QUEZON CITY ) 8.8.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, RENATO M. REYES, JR., of legal age, a Filipino, with officeaddress at Erythrina Bldg., No. 1 Matatag cor. Maaralin Streets, CentralDistrict Quezon City, after been having been duly sworn to in accordancewith law hereby depose and state that:
1. I am a Petitioner in this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovita Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shall duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
------.
)\
ENATO M. REYES, JR.Affiant/ Petitioner
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28th day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed and understood the above, theaffiant/petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number PP0053767 issued on September 01,2004 and which expires on September 01,2009.
Doc. No. 74-~Page No.~~Book No.m;Series of 2009.
r-~~"• : . . . l ; :,. 1..: l;~ tJI'~'-" NOTARY::PUBlIIC
': ,,': .. ," '., "~co ['IT': 12/1;'/ OJ(F'UR ~jw ~ ( ;c 'ill I;)' (' 1i·~'·-"rl~· 55 ~. 1131i
17
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES)QUEZON CITY ) S.S.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ERLINDA CADAPAN, of legal age, a Filipino, with office addressat Erythrina Bldg., No. 1 Matatag cor. Maaralin Streets, Central DistrictQuezon City, after been having been duly sworn to in accordance withlaw hereby depose and state that:
1. I am the Petitioner in this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovita Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shall duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
E~APANAffiant/ Petitioner
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28th day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed' and understood the above, theaffiant/ petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number UU0142540 issued on November 08,2006 and which expires on November 08, 2011.
!fl:JDoc. No.~;PageNo.~
Book No. l::..,l::£:;Series of 2009.
18
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES 1QUEZON CITY 1S.S.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ANTONIO FLORES, of legal age, a Filipino, with office address at161-B Chico St., Project 2, Quezon City, after been having been dulysworn to in accordance with law hereby depose and state that:
1. I am a Petitioner in this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovita Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shaH duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
ANTONIO FLORESAffiant/ Petitioner
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28tl1 day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed and understood the above, theaffiant/petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number 880044754 issued on November 24,2005 and which expires on November 24,2010.
kt/DOC.NO'~Page No. .Book No. ,Series of 2009.
•000;Tr~~~~U~i. ::'. '; ~"", ro'" k.'. :'3~ sar ' :: . ~ 1.~ -(I? P,c.
.;r:' ; '_," ,;~UTY~2f1·1f{n
l H R~ ;:.; '~: ,., :: , ",i; • ill'> -S5;; - 3:> 1')
19
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES)QUEZON CITY ) S.S.
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I, JOSELITO V. USTAREZ, of legal age, a Filipino, with officeaddress at 63 Narra Street, Barangay Claro, Project 3, Quezon City, afterbeen having been duly sworn to in accordance with law hereby deposeand state that:
1. I am a Petitioner m this instant case against retired MajorGeneral Jovito Palparan.
2. I have caused the preparation and filing of this instant Petition.
3. I have read the contents of this Petition and affirm that theallegations therein are true of my own knowledge and belief, on the basisof my reading and appreciation of documents other records pertinentthereto.
4. I have not instituted a similar action in another forum ortribunal; neither is there any pending case involving the same issues andthe same parties in any other forum or tribunal; I shall duly inform theHonorable Tribunal within five (5) days from knowledge of the filing orpendency of such case in such other forum or tribunal.
~JOSELITO V.~EZ
Affiant / Petitioner
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me on this 28th day ofApril 2009 at Quezon City, Philippines. I hereby certify that theaffiant/petitioner executed· and understood the above, theaffiant/petitioner personally appearing and known to me to be the sameperson who executed the foregoing Petition and exhibiting to me hisPhilippine Passport with Number RR0153110 issued on October 03,2005 and which expires on October 03, 2010.
t/JJrDoc. No . ..p;-.,-.;Page NO.~I~'Book No. .Series of 20 9.
20
21
ANNEX “A”
Last update: April 23 2009, 11:56 PM INQUIRER HEADLINES - NATION Palparan fitness for Congress questioned Tonette Orejas / Central Luzon Desk April 23, 2009 MANILA, Philippines—The most prominent “leftist” in the House of Representatives would rather not be a seatmate of the “butcher.” If he had his way, Bayan Muna party-list Rep. Satur Ocampo would not even let retired Army Maj. Gen. Jovito Palparan Jr. take his seat. Ocampo, a House minority leader, is readying legal actions to stop Palparan from assuming a seat in the House as representative of the party-list group Bantay. Militants have taken to calling Palparan a “berdugo (butcher)” for the strings of alleged extrajudicial killings and other forms of human rights violations in Luzon and the Visayas where he was assigned until he retired in September 2006. It’s possible that Ocampo and Palparan would be sitting next to each other because seats are alphabetically arranged in the House. Despite the outcry from the Left, Palparan said he still preferred serving in the House to accepting his appointment as director of Freeport Services Corp., a company of the state-owned Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority. “Of course, Congress,” Palparan said when asked what his choice was. “That has the people’s mandate. Bantay was voted to Congress.” Bantay has “every right” to sit in Congress because it “represents marginalized sectors engaged in security and peace and order concerns,” he said. “I have no fear of him. We (members of the so-called leftist bloc in Congress) sat side by side with the Marcoses. But I don’t want to imagine myself sitting beside him,” Ocampo said in a phone interview on Wednesday, a day after the Supreme Court increased the numbers of party-list representatives to 55. But having Ocampo as a seatmate and colleague in the House is “OK” with Palparan. “I’m not picky with people. If my enemies reform, I shall love them more,” he said. Ocampo said he and his colleagues in Bayan Muna, Anakpawis and Gabriela would question Palparan’s qualifications. Ocampo has been Bayan Muna representative in the House since 2001. He is serving his last three-year term. “What are they afraid of? These militants should be afraid of what they are doing. They’re engaged in violence,” Palparan said in a phone interview. Constituents Palparan said his sector includes “victims of communist rebels, Civilian Armed Forces Geographical Units (CAFGUs), former rebels, security guards and others of similar occupations.”
22
Asked about laws he would sponsor, the retired general said: “I would focus on the welfare and protection of those sectors, and improve their livelihood. The CAFGUs, for instance, live only on small allowance and they have no benefits but their work is risky.” Palparan said he also planned to continue organizing a “counterinsurgency civilian force” throughout the country. “There are such people. They are only working silently. If given the opportunities and capabilities this time, I would push for that. I have been organizing people to resist communist rebels,” he said. On his human rights record, he said: “Nobody has proven I committed anything bad. Their apprehension is really within their minds. I can’t provide an answer to those apprehensions.” “My entry in Congress will provide the answer [if their apprehensions have bases],” he added. Security firm, dog Asked if he would divest his interest in the company 24-Hour Security, which figured in two mining disputes in the provinces of Bulacan and Zambales last year, Palparan denied owning the firm. Palparan expressed the hope that he can take along his dog Cloud, a Maltese, when reporting for office in the House. “If it’s not prohibited, I would take her along. Cloud always tags along with me,” he said. Not marginalized In Baguio City, the Cordillera Peoples Alliance (CPA) said Palparan and his party-list group had no clear representation of marginalized sector. Beverly Longid, CPA chair, said Palparan’s motive in forming Bantay was “not meant to represent the poor and marginalized sectors of society but to commit more human rights abuses against activists and left-leaning party-list groups.” She said there should be a review of the antihuman rights programs of Bantay so Palparan’s representation could be opposed. The Supreme Court disqualified in 2001 major political parties from participating in the party-list system because they did not represent marginalized and underrepresented sectors. Man of power “Palparan is not marginalized. He’s a man of power. He still exercises political influence,” Ocampo said. Another reason Palparan should not be allowed to join Congress was the Supreme Court affirmation in 2008 of the Court of Appeals ruling that the retired general was “directly involved” in the abduction of farmer-brothers Raymond and Reynaldo Manalo in Bulacan on suspicion of being communist rebels, according to Ocampo. Palparan also drew fire from the Bagong Alyansang Makabayan (Bayan). Palace support “Palparan is gloating over the fact that he gets to sit in Congress and terrorize the public anew. He owes his latest position to the support given by Malacañang and the AFP (military) for his congressional bid in 2007. Can there be any question as to where his loyalties lie now?” Bayan secretary general Renato Reyes said. Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita expressed support for Palparan, saying he could help the House draft bills because of his long experience in counterinsurgency.
23
“He’ll be able to contribute a lot especially on possible laws on how to address our insurgency problem, including secessionist movement, and other activities that have something to do with breach of the law, security and peace and order,” Ermita said. Wrong signal The human rights group Karapatan, however, said Palparan could use the House as a venue for his anti-insurgency campaign. Palparan as a sectoral representative “sends a wrong signal to perpetrators that they can continue committing human rights violations with impunity,” said Karapatan secretary general Marie Hilao-Enriquez in the statement. With reports from TJ Burgonio and Nikko Dizon in Manila; Desiree Caluza, Inquirer Northern Luzon ©2009 www.inquirer.net all rights reserved
Send your feedback here < Back
24
ANNEX “B”
Villagers want TRO on mining firm lifted Wednesday, August 20, 2008 http://www.manilatimes.net/national/2008/aug/20/yehey/prov/20080820pro2.html
DOÑA REMEDIOS TRINIDAD, Bulacan: Residents of Barangay Camachin, Doña Remedios Trinidad, Bulacan are calling on Environment Secretary Lito Atienza to lift the suspension order issued by the regional office preventing the legit operation of Ore Asia Mining and Development Corporation (OAMD) causing some 7,000 families jobless.
Barangay Chairman Roberto Sembrano said Judge Rodolfo de Guzman of the Municipal Trial Court-Doña Remedios Trinidad had already issued a mandatory injunction and temporary restraining order for OAMD to reassume the mining operations from the Oro Development Corporation II allegedly financed by a certain Go Kong Ket alias “Willy Keng” and being guarded by a security agency owned by Retired General Jovito Palparan.
Immediately after the said court order, Palparan directed his guards from the 24-hour Security Agency to withdraw from area.
Despite the court order favoring OAMD, its mining operations remain paralyzed as a result of the suspension order of Region 3-Mines Geoscience Bureau Director Anselmo Abungan.
“Kung patuloy pa nilang sususpendehin ang operasyon ng minahan ay para na nilang pinatay sa gutom ang mga residente, labag ito sa 10 point-agenda ni Pangulong Gloria Arroyo sa pamamagitan ng kanyang job creation program dahil marami ang maaring makinabang sa pamumulot ng bato”. Sembrano said.
Recently, the affected families held a peaceful rally in front of the DENR building asking Atienza to lift the suspension order so that they can return to work. But their pleas went to naught.
Palparan admitted that he ordered his men to withdraw from the premises because he could no longer bear with the way Keng treated the situation.
In a press conference, Palparan said that he turned down Keng’s orders to burn the mining equipments saying “hindi na ito makatao at labag sa aking konsensya,”
At the same time, Palparan warned mining financiers and DENR officials to be extra careful on Keng to avoid being used for his personal interest. --Jefferson Antiporda
25
ANNEX “C”
Palparan says Army general cleared soldiers who stormed mining firm http://www.malaya.com.ph/may03/metro4.htm
RETIRED Army Maj. Gen. Jovito Palparan yesterday said the deployment of 14 Army soldiers involved in the "takeover" of the Consolidated Mines Inc. compound in Masinloc, Zambales last April 29 was approved by 7th Infantry Division chief Brig. Gen. Ralph Villanueva, commander of the Army in Central Luzon.
He said Villanueva cleared the deployment at the request of Faith Investment House (FIH) which bought the mining firm CMI. He said this was according to FHI and the PNP Criminal Investigation and Detection Group.
Palparan said his security agency, 24-Hour Security Provider, had been hired by FIH to consolidate its property and that he only issued orders to his security guards and not to the soldiers. He said the soldiers were backups who were supposed to serve as blocking force outside the CMI compound while the CIDG flushed out the armed men inside who were "identified with a businessman with dealings with CMI or Zambales governor Amor Deloso."
He said the soldiers only entered the compound because they were open targets where they were.
Palparan said Deloso’s group later arrived and took custody of at least 10 armed men the CIDG had arrested. He said the governor asked his security guards to leave the compound but he refused. Later, he said two teams from the police and the Army assaulted the compound with clearance from Villanueva.
Reports later quoted Villanueva as saying that the 7th ID was deceived into deploying soldiers to accompany the group of Palparan in taking over the mining firm. The AFP last Wednesday ordered the soldiers involved in the assault restricted and investigated but admitted it no longer has jurisdiction over the retired Palparan.
Palparan said there is nothing irregular with soldiers acting as backup. He said he is willing to give a statement to Army investigators. "I did not commit any wrongdoing. But I think Gen. Villanueva, Col. (Philip) Lapinid (the battalion commander) and the provincial director (of the PNP) and the governor must be investigated also."
He said he feels the initial entry of the soldiers in the compound was legitimate but he wants their actions inside the compound investigated since what they assaulted was private property. – Victor Reyes
26
ANNEX “D”
http://www.gmanews.tv/story/31867/Jovito-S-Palparan-Jr Jovito S. Palparan, Jr. 02/23/2007 | 06:28 PM PERSONAL INFORMATION
• Birthdate: September 11, 1950 • Birthplace: Cagayan de Oro City • Wife: Ma. Evangelina Gamad Flores Palparan, dentist • Children: Macy, JC, Martin, Bullet, Claude
ISSUES
• Alleged human rights violator. The International Peasant Solidarity Mission found that there are "clear indications of military involvement" in the cases of human rights violations in Central Luzon and Southern Tagalog. The group's report noted that the military seems to have become more brazen (in committing the human rights violations) under the command of MGen. Jovito Palparan, Jr.. Malacañang came to Palparan's defense, saying that the international group's report linking the military to political killings is preposterous. In a press conference, Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita praised Palparan as an effective component in the government's anti-insurgency campaign.
• Campaign against communist insurgency. In his brief stint as 8th Infantry Division commander, Gen. Palparan was credited for reducing the insurgency problem in Samar by 80 percent. Palparan however said he could have terminated insurgency in the province had he been given a two-month extension to implement his "clearing operation". In April 2006, Palparan gave a five-month deadline to wipe out the communist insurgency in Central Luzon - his area of responsibility as 7th Infantry Division commander.The deadline coincides with his 56th birthday and date of retirement from the AFP.
• In Malacañang's good graces. President Arroyo promoted Palparan twice: from colonel to brigadier general (2003); and from brigadier general to major general after serving as commander of the Philippine contingent in Iraq (2004). His promotion to major general came within months of his previous promotion. In her 2006 State of the Nation Address, President Arroyo acknowledged Palparan for his offensives against rebel terrorists. In the same breath she also said that she condemns political killings.
EDUCATION
• Masters in National Security Administration, National Defense College of the Philippines (1999)
• Masters in Management, Philippine Christian University • Joint Services and Staff Course, Canberra, Australia • Command and General Staff Course, Fort Bonifacio, Metro Manila (with honors)
27
• Infantry Officers Advanced Course, US Infantry School, Columbus, Georgia, USA
• Field Officers Tactics III, Land Warfare Center, Canungra, Australia (excellent rating)
• BS Business Administration, University of the East • Cathedral High School, Cagayan de Oro City
CAREER
• Commanding General, 7th Infantry (Kaugnay) Division, Philippine Army (September 21, 2005-September 11, 2006)
• Commanding General, 8th Infantry Division, Catbalogan, Samar (2005) • Chief of Staff, Philippine Army • commander, Philippine Humanitarian Contingent in Iraq • brigade commander,
204th Brigade, Mindoro and Romblon • commander, Task Force Banahaw, CALABARZON • Commanding Officer, Doctrine Center • commander, AFP Rapid Deployment Force • commander, 24th Infantry Battalion for 5 years • lieutenant, served in Basilan and Sulu for eight years • commissioned, called to active duty to the AFP in 1973
ACHIEVEMENTS (as claimed in his official biodata)
• As company grade officer, his unit defeated the most notorious group of Moro National Liberation Front in Paticul, Sulu; this led to the surrender of rebel Hakim Sale a.k.a. Snake and 60 fully-armed fighters
• As commander of the 24th Infantry Battalion, his unit was instrumental in o clearing eight provinces in Central Luzon and Cordillera of insurgents; o preventing the launching of coup d' etat between 1987 and 1989 o elimination/liquidation of the New People's Army / ABB in NCR, also
between 1987 and 1989 AWARDS
• Distinguished Service Stars o Palparan received a distinguished service star in March 2006 for his
service as commander of the 8th Infantry Division-- the award was given amid persistent allegations from militant groups that he is a human rights violator.
• Gold Cross Medal • Gawad sa Kaunlaran Medal • Bronze Cross Medals • Wounded Personnel Medals
o Palparan was wounded early on in his military career, during an encounter with the Moro National Liberation Front.
• Military Merit Medals • Campaign Medals
Sources: Official Biodata, Office of the President website, GMA News, Sunday Inquirer Magazine, Newsbreak, INQ7, Arkibongbayan.org