PERSPECTIVES ON ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN HAWAI'Imanoa.hawaii.edu/hpicesu/book/1988_chap/38.pdf ·...

2
PERSPECTIVES ON ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN HAWAI'I Our CIIUIIL'II~C tod(n. in lluwai'i is to !how that conservation conc~~rtls (1w w/e~.atll to the body polrlic. Lorin T. Gill Why arc we where we are in environmental education in ilawai'i? Or, hettcr yet, whv aren't we furlher? I think environmcntnl education needs to he undcrwx~d in several contexts to answer thst queiti~m. Since the mid-1S00s the princi dl segments o f ~ ~ u r popul:ltion have come to ilawai'i to hrtter themselves. &inland ~rncric:tnt ;liter thc Civil War were pretty ml~cli exercising the frontier eth~c of uilng what thev nccded and moving on when things became difficult. Arian and t u r ~ p e : ~ n immigrant\, most ofwhom came to work on plantations, camr for :I hettcr iitc ti1.m tllev had at home--at least those who-came to stav. Manv had the set of mind char- acteristic of immigrants. These settlers were not p<;l~ul:ttiirns wi~h conwrva- tion primarily in mind. Cattle ranches, largc p!ant:~t:on~, ;111d, in gr.ner:~l, economic ex~loitation of the land prevailed. li I r~~uld IN.^ niv 1:ner.r on the practices thai were most inappropiiate in our part hi*t&y, it iu.113 he those which applied continental techniques to little islandr. Tliesc inc,lude certain forms of forestry, ranching, and agriculture. Immigrants from Asia, America, and Europe did not come with an appre- ciation of what was here. There's a concept in anthropology called trans- ported landscapes: you make where you went look like where you came from. The English >pent a hundred years trying to make New Zealand look like Leland, for example.) We can see this today even in Sierra Club high school hikmg pro rams in Hawai'i. The kids who have been here longer look at Hawai'i differently from those who have just arrived. (How's that for a big stereotype?) Populations came and still come to exploit, use, and better themselves. During the period of early immigration the native Hawaiian population was swept up in change. They were diminishing in numbers, losing control, and trying to survive. In the societal dynamics of the times, conservation was certainlv not at the forefront of educational oriorities. Peoole were con- cerned &lth vact agricui~~rsl cnt~rpri~ei. the; were struggling economically, and they were iun.lviny. TIic\c II~IJII~~. were not interested in conservation of rare kosvstems. Th% concern his traditionah been the 1 wu~ of the secure, the ';arrived soc~oeconom~cally, and, perha s, the comfortable. Economic and conservation concerns did run uaral P el courses when water rcrollrces were threateneu; thcn thrre was a lot of activity on the part of agriculture (read big husinets). I'copie saw that the problem of u x e r \va ~ rclevant to them in the early 1003 when the aquifer began to draw s:d:

Transcript of PERSPECTIVES ON ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN HAWAI'Imanoa.hawaii.edu/hpicesu/book/1988_chap/38.pdf ·...

  • PERSPECTIVES ON ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN HAWAI'I

    Our C I I U I I L ' I I ~ C tod(n. in lluwai'i is to !how that conservation conc~~rtls (1w w/e~.atll to the body polrlic.

    Lorin T. Gill

    Why arc we where we are in environmental education in ilawai'i? Or, hettcr yet, whv aren't we furlher? I think environmcntnl education needs to he undcrwx~d in several contexts to answer thst queiti~m.

    Since the mid-1S00s the princi dl segments o f ~ ~ u r popul:ltion have come to ilawai'i to hrtter themselves. &inland ~rncric:tnt ;liter thc Civil War were pretty ml~cli exercising the frontier e th~c of uilng what thev nccded and moving on when things became difficult. Arian and t u r ~ p e : ~ n immigrant\, most ofwhom came to work on plantations, camr for :I hettcr iitc ti1.m tllev had at home--at least those who-came to stav. Manv had the set of mind char-

    ~ ~~~~~~

    acteristic of immigrants. These settlers were not p

  • in more areas than thev wished. Thev then ran out to out eucalwtus trees . . on bare laces, hoping-to reduce the problem.

    Pubfk educat~on m Hawai'i in the last hundred years has reflected the society it serves. It has been most concerned with fitting populations into the American western mode. In the late 1800s English was adopted in the Hawaiian common schools. Would you believe t h ~ s was by petition of Hdwaiianc? As early as the 1860s Hawaiian parents were beseeching the Minister ot Fducation to teach their children English. Hawaiian could be taught at home, but English was needed to cope with the bigger world. And it was during the Republic that English was made the language of education in all areas. From the early 1900s until World War 11, schools were focused on Americanizing immigrant populations and helping them "mainstream." Great success was achieved, for example, in McIGnley School in Honolulu under Miles Carey. A good number of nisei (children born in US. of Japa- nese immigrants) learned that, indeed, the Bill of Rights applies to everyone; the American Constitution guarantees rights for everyone despite what was avoarent in Hawaiian societv in the 1930s. Facilitating the success of new pebp~es coming to the 1slmds is still a great concern. 30 in this contcut, one should not he sur riced at the query "Environmental Education? What's ha t ? ' 0 refer r%e ierm '"environmenrnl education' to conservation edura- tion. ~t'einbraces conservation education, the reservation concerns of the 1970s. and the human risk concerns of the I%&,)

    The Hawaii Department of Education (DOE) is criticized todav because of three decadcs of frustration bv the secure, the "arrived." the comfortable. i f you will, and by th~-scientif~call~ astute. Tl~ose who know what IS happen- ine to the natural environment arid those who know how touse the ~ u b k fo'ium and political processes to address concerns are attempting tdhring nhout change. Yet the criticismsof the last three decades were made to a DOE. that did not redly understand environmental issues. We hrought out- door education experts in from the Mainland, and we talked to schonl superin- tcndents hnd c~rriculum pi'nple. Cverytliin was dgreeoble. but there wac nothing out there for DOE to use--no mode%. no;,verridlng reasons for concern. Environmental education was simolv not a maior>mohasis.

    l'he resolution of the environmental e d k t i o n prol;lem cdntinues to he ynliti;;tl. l'he Department of Education has staff in the area uhich addresses invironmental concerns. However. the State Environmental Education Spec1:dist positlm is still a tempor& position, and if budgets suffer, tcm- purary position\ are lost. The Depanment must have lcglsla!ive and,adminis- tratiw support, i t mu