People vs Vera, 65 Phil 56

8/10/2019 People vs Vera, 65 Phil 56

1/26

!

!"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0

!"#$%&% ()"$*

12/'&2

34 5647

+,$, -., /012342 -.567869 :3; :

*?% #%)#/% )@ *?% #?A/A##A-% A!/B-C! DEF ?)-+G)-+ H !?B-+?BA

IB-GA-+ ()$#)$B*A)-;#",','*/"809

:0;

J)!% ), K%$B; JLFM6!.N OP6 (.L9O .N @Q9RO AERODES6 .N &DEQTD; DEF &B$AB-)

(" "-JA%-+;8"0#*/'/2& 2(,'*/ '/0,',$,"< '/ ,-'0 (*$8, */ 6$>$0, ?@9 ?@AB9 +*8 ,-"

'00$2/(" *+ ,-" C8', *+ $%,(#',/,# 2/< *+ #8*-'%','*/ ,* ,-" 7*$8, *+ D'80, E/0,2/("

*+ 12/'&2 0* ,-2, ,-'0 (*$8, F2G 8":'"C ,-" 2(,$2,'*/0 *+ ,-" 2+*8"02'< 7*$8, *+

D'80, E/0,2/(" '/ (8'F'/2& (20" 4*; HIJH@ "/,',&"< K=-" ."*#&" *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"

E0&2/ ,-"8"'/ +*8 #8*%2,'*/ $/ '/ ,-" (20" 20 #8':2," #8*0"($,*8;

6+,"8 2 #8*,82(,"< ,8'2& $/#282&&"&"< '/ ,-" 2//2&0 *+ .-'&'##'/" M$8'0#8$ 2/< T-2/>-2' 52/N'/> 7*8#*82,'*/; L#*/ 2##"2&9 ,-" (*$8,9 */ 128(

IJ9 ?@AX9 F*'0&2,$8"; S"8"'/ 8"0#*/ 0,2,"0 '/ -'0 #",','*/9 #.(%,

/+#/9 ,-2, -" '0 '//*("/, *+ ,-" (8'F" *+ C-'(- -" C20 (*/:'(,"9 0", ,-" #",','*/ +*8 -"28'/

*/ 6#8'& X9 ?@AB;

V/ 6#8'& I9 ?@AB9 ,-" D'0(2& *+ ,-" 7',G *+ 12/'&2 +'&"< 2/ *##*0','*/ ,* ,-"

>82/,'/> *+ #8*%2,'*/ ,* ,-" -"8"'/ 8"0#*/; =-" #8':2,


2/26

#

#8*0"($,'*/ 2&0* +'&"< 2/ *##*0','*/ */ 6#8'& X9 ?@AB9 2&&">'/>9 2F*/> *,-"8

,-'/>09 ,-2, 6(, 4*; HII?9 200$F'/> ,-2, ', -20 /*, %""/ 8"#"2&"< %G 0"(,'*/ I *+

68,'(&" _W *+ ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/9 '0 /":"8,-"&"00 :'*&2,':" *+ 0"(,'*/ ?9 0$%0"(,'*/

O?R9 68,'(&" EEE *+ ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/ >$282/,""'/> "]$2& #8*,"(,'*/ *+ ,-" &2C0 +*8

,-" 8"20*/ ,-2, ',0 2##&'(2%'&',G '0 /*, $/'+*8F ,-8*$>-*$, ,-" E0&2/ */ ,-" 2&&">"< $/(*/0,',$,'*/2&',G */6(, 4*; HII?9 20 2/ $/'0&2,':" #*C"8 ,* ,-" #8*:'/('2&

%*28 ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ 6(, 4*; HII?;

V/ U$/" IZ9 ?@AB9 -"8"'/ 8"0#*/2,"< 2

8"0*&$,'*/ C',- 2 +'//2 #8*%2,'*/ 2/< 2 /*,'(" *+ '/,"/,'*/ ,* +'&" 2

F*,'*/ +*8 8"(*/0' */ U$&G A?9 ?@AB9 %$, 02'< -"28'/> C20 #*0,#*/"/"< %G ,-'8,G[,-8""

O,-'8,G[+*$8R 2,,*8/"G0 -2< M$0, %""/ +'&"< C',- ,-" ,8'2& (*$8,; 6,,*8/"G 3$&2&'*

7-2:"0 C-*0" 0'>/2,$8" 2##"280 '/ ,-" 2+*8"02'< F*,'*/ 0$%0"]$"/,&G +'&"< 2

#",','*/ +*8 &"2:" ,* C',-':"/ %G (*$/0"& +*8 128'2/* 7$ L/M'"/> */ ,-" ":"/'/> *+ U$&G AQ9

?@AB9 2/< ,-2, -" 0'>/"< ,-" 02F" KC',-*$, F2,$8" $0, J9 ?@AB9 ,-" D'0(2& *+ ,-" 7',G *+ 12/'&2 +'&"< 2 F*,'*/ C',- ,-" ,8'2&

(*$8, +*8 ,-" '00$2/(" *+ 2/ *8$0, B9 ?@AB9 ,-" #8':2," #8*0"($,'*/ +'&"< ',0 *##*0','*/ ,* ,-" F*,'*/ +*

&"2:" ,* '/,"8:"/" 20 /:#$# $1,#/%2+*8"F"/,'*/" *+ ,-" 02F" 2/< ,-2,9 2, 2&& ":"/,09 02'< F*,'*/ 0-*$&< %" ; V/ 6$>$0, ?Q9 ?@AB9 -"8"'/

8"0#*/ *+ -'0 F*,'*/ +*8 "Y"($,'*/ *+ M$F"/, '/ #8"+"8"/(" ,* ,-" F*,'*/

+*8 &"2:" ,* '/,"8:"/" 20 /:#$# $1,#/%%$,9 $#*/ *%M"(,'*/ *+ (*$/0"& +*8 128'2/

7$ L/M'"/>9 -" F*:"< +*8 ,-" #*0,#*/"F"/, *+ ,-" -"28'/> *+ %*,- F*,'*/0; =-

8"0#*/$0, I?9 ?@AB9 %$, #8*(""2& #8*("00 ,* #$, 2/ "/< ,*

C-2, ,-"G 2&&">"< C20 2/ '/,"8F'/2%&" #8*("" %"+*8" ,-" ,8'2& (*$8, C20 2((*8


3/26

$

E; 5"(2$0" 02'< 8"0#*/ $/"/"82& 2##&'(2,'*/ %"(2$0" ', '0 F2 ,* #8'0*/ 2+,"8 -" -2< #8*F$&>2,"< -'0 8"0*&$,'*/ *+ U$/" IZ9 ?@AB9

`0 2##&'(2,'*/ +*8 #8*%2,'*/9 +*8 ,-" 8"20*/ ,-2,a

O?R S'0 M$8'0 128'2/* 7$ L/M'"/>`0 #",','*/

+*8 #8*%2,'*/ */ U$/" IZ9 ?@AB9 ', %"(2F" +'/2& 2/< "Y"($,*8G 2, ,-"

F*F"/, *+ ',0 8"/ *+ 02'" *8 *:"8 C-* 28" (*/:'(,"< *+ (8'F"9 '0

$/(*/0,',$,'*/2& %"(2$0" ', '0 :'*&2,':" *+ 0"(,'*/ ?9 0$%0"(,'*/ O?R9 68,'(&" EEE9 *

,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/ *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0 >$282/,""'/> "]$2& #8*,"(,'*/ *+ ,-" &2C0

%"(2$0" ', (*/+"80 $#*/ ,-" #8*:'/('2& %*28< *+ ',0 #8*:'/(" ,-" 2%0*&$,"

,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ 6(, 4*; HII?9 2/< */ ,-" *82& 28>$F"/, -"&< */ V(,*%"8J9 ?@AB9 +$8,-"8 "&2%*82,"< */ ,-" ,-"*8G ,-2, #8*%2,'*/ '0 2 +*8F *+ 8"#8'":"

2/< ,-"8"+*8" 6(,; 4*; HII? '0 2/ "/(8*2(-F"/, */ ,-" "Y(&$0':" #*C"8 *+ ,-"

7-'"+ 3Y"($,':" ,* >82/, #28 '/ %"-2&+ *+ ,-" ."*#&" *+ ,-"

.-'&'##'/" E0&2/ ,-" #*C"8 *+ ,-" 0,2," ,* 'F#$>/

,-" :2&'


4/26

%

(*/0,',$,"0 2/ $/C2882/,"< 2,'*/ *+ &">'0&2,':" #*C"89 C"8" #8"0"/," ,-2, 6(, 4*; HII? '0 $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& %"(2$0" ', $F"/, 2/< F"F*82/*'/>

#8*#*0','*/ 82'0"< %G ,-" #",','*/"80;

60 0#"('2& ,-"F0"&:"0 82'0"< ,-" ]$"0,'*/ 20 ,* ,-"

"Y"($,'*/ *+ M$F"/, %"+*8" ,-" ,8'2& (*$8,9 02'< ,8'2& (*$8, -20

2(]$'8"< "Y(&$0':" M$8'0 #8*%2,'*/ '0 $/2##"2&2%&";

OHR =-2, $#*/ ,-" -G#*,-"0'0 ,-2, ,-'0 (*$8, -20 (*/($88"/, M$8'00 ,* ,-'0 (*$8,9 0-*$&< /*, %" ,*&"82,"< %"(2$0" ',

'F#2'80 ,-" 2$,-*8',G 2/< '/ ,-" #8*%2,'*/ (20"0 '0 K2 (*$8, *+ &'F',"< M$8'08"2, #8*%2,'*/ '0 2##"2&2%&"c +*8 2&,-*$>- ,-" .8*%2,'*/

^2C #8*%2,'*/ *+ -"8"'/

8"0#*/ %"'/> 2##"2&2%&"9 ,-" 02F" -2< /*,

%"(*F" +'/2& 2/< "Y"($,*8G +*8 ,-" 8"20*/ ,-2, ,-" 02'< 8"0#*/ *8 #8*%2,'*/ '0 /*, +'/2& 2/ :0; =8'/'


6/26

'

#*#$&28&G N/*C/ 20 ,-" 7-'/"0" 5**NN""#'/> ^2C9 C20 ,-"8" (-2&&"/>"< %G ,-"

#",','*/"809 2/< ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2& '00$" C20 /*, F", 0]$28"&G %G ,-"

8"0#*/'/2& M$8'0 +$/(,'*/0 C',-*$, *8 '/ "Y("00 *+ ,-"'8

M$8'0- *%M"(,'*/ ,* ,-" M$8'02&&G :"0,"- ,-"8" '0 2 (*/+&'(, '/ ,-" (20"09 '0 ,-2, ,-" F"8', *+ #8*-'%','*/ C'&& /*,

&'" C-",-"8 ,-" '/+"8'*8 (*$8, -20 M$8'0 '/ #8*%2,'*/ #8*("" (20" *+ @R D/,(%L/',"< T,2,"0 Oe?@?Jf9 IHI L; T;9 IBc J? ^2C;

"9 ,-8*$>- 7-'"

U$0,'(" d-',"a

E/-, ,* ,8G *++"/0"0

2>2'/0, ,-" (8'F'/2& &2C0 2/< $#*/ (*/:'(,'*/ ,* 'F#*0" ,-"

#$/'0-F"/, #8*:'8*$/< +*8 ,-" (*/,"/,'*/ 20 ,* #*C"8 -"8"

F2"< $#*/ ,-" '0&2,':" 2/< '/(&$ ,-" 0,2,$,

"&"F"/,0 *+ (*/0'


7/26

(

*+ M$-, ,* 8"&'":" +8*F ,-" #$/'0-F"/,9

+'Y"< %G &2C 2/< 20("8,2'/"< 2((*8 *#'/'*/ '/ ,-" (20" *+ 7#,%$(', '"

>,#2'.2 92; F13B% '" 6#,2( O.2(/.$% '" 4/9#(% OI@ .-'&;9 IJXR9 0 '0 2 (*$8, *+ &'F',"'/> ,-2, ,-" 0,2,$," $/-, C20 $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& %"(2$0" ', 'F#2'8"< ,-"

*%&'>2,'*/ *+ (*/,82(,0; =-" (2#2(',G *+ ,-" (-'"+ &2C *++'("8 *+ ,-" 0,2," ,*

]$"0,'*/ ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ ,-" 0,2,$," C20 ,-*$>-9 20 2 >"/"82& 8$&"9 */&G

,-*0" C-* 28" #28,'"0 ,* 2 0$', F2G ]$"0,'*/ ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ 2 0,2,$,"

'/:*&:"< '/ 2 M$'/ ,-" 0,2,$,"; O?I 7;U;9 0"(; ?ZH9 #; BJJ;R 6/09 *8- 82'0"< +*8 +'80, ,'F" */ 2##"2&9 '+ ', 2##"280 ,-2,

2 2'/ 2/< #*'/, C',- "F#-20'0 ,* ,-" (20" *+ Q1 4'.B @.B; 92; 0,#.#3/3= 21D,/;

6/< */ ,-" -G#*,-"0'0 ,-2, ,-" S*/>N*/> i T-2/>-2' 52/N'/> 7*8#*82,'*/9

8"#8"0"/,"< %G ,-" #8':2," #8*0"($,'*/9 '0 /*, ,-" #8*#"8 #28,G ,* 82'0" ,-"

(*/0,',$,'*/2& ]$"0,'*/ -"8" j 2 #*'/, C" 8"2,"8 'F#*8, ,-2/ ,-" "

(2$0"< %G ,-" '&&">2& "Y#"/ (*8#*82,'*/9 2&&">'/> ,-2, ,-" 0,2,$," $/-, C20 $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& %"(2$0" ', 'F#2'8"< ,-"

*%&'>2,'*/ *+ (*/,82(,0; =-" (2#2(',G *+ ,-" (-'"+ &2C *++'("8 *+ ,-" 0,2," ,*

]$"0,'*/ ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ ,-" 0,2,$," C20 ',0"&+ ]$"0,'*/"

,-" :2&''0&2,$8"9 2/< ,-" #"*#&" F$0, %*C ; ; ; =-"

&">'0&2,$8" 2/< ,-" 8"0#*/ *+ 2/ 2(]$'"0("/(" %G 2 #28,G 2++"(,"< %G 2/

$/(*/0,',$,'*/2& 2(, *+ ,-" &">'0&2,$8"a K=-" #"*#&" -2:" 2


9/26

*

E/ T,2," :0; \*2/" Oe?@?Jf9 @Z h2/;9 HAXc ?XZ .2(;9 AZ9 HQR9 2/ *8'>'/2& 2(,'*/

OF2/-, %G ,-" 6,,*8/"G[P"/"82& *+ h2/020 ,* ,"0, ,-"

(*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ 2 0,2,$," *+ ,-" 0,2,"; E/ *+ ,-" ]$"0,'*/ C-",-"8 *8

/*, ,-" 0,2," F2G %8'/> ,-" 2(,'*/9 ,-" T$#8"F" 7*$8, *+ h2/020 02'28-, ,* #&"2 2 #"80*

C',- 2 :'*&2,'*/ *+ ,-" 0,2,$,"; E/ *,-"8 C*8

7*;9 ",(;9 '0 2$,-*8',G +*8 ,-" #8*#*0','*/ F"8"&G ,-2, "Y"($,':" *++'("809

";>;9 ,-" 0,2," 2$ ,-2, ,-" :2&'


10/26

!+

(*/0,',$,'*/2&9 '0 /* 8"20*/ +*8 (*/0' ',0 :2&' ', 20 :2&'< $/,'& ', '0 -"&'0&2,':" 8"0,8'(,'*/09 /*8 (2/ &'N" #*C"8 %" >':"/ %

,-" &">'0&2,$8" ,* 2/G *,-"8 *++'("8 *8 2$,-*8',G; =-" (**8 ,* #*C"89 0'/(" /* #"80*/

#8*#"8&G %"&*/>'/> ,* */" *+ ,-"


12/26

!#

2##"8,2'/'/> ,* "',-"8 *+ ,-" *,-"80 "Y("#, '/ (20"0 "Y#8"00&G #8*:''0&2,$8" (2/ /"',-"8 "Y"8('0" 0$(- #*C"8 ',0"&+ /*8

2," ', "&0"C-"8"9 /*8 '/,"8+"8" C',- *8 (*/,8*& ,-" #8*#"8 "Y"8('0" ,-"8"*+9 ;

; ;K O?I 7;U;9 ##; ZAZ9 ZA@9 2/< (20"0 (',"*:"8/F"/, 2/< /*, '/ ,-" M$"< %$, C'0" 0 2

0"/,"/(" *8 %G #&2('/> ,-" -, *+ ,-" '0&2,'*/; E/ ?@?B9 2 %'&& C20 +2:*82%&G 8"#*8,"< %G

,-" U$2'/ +2:*82%&G 8"#*8,"< 2 #8*%2,'*/ %'&& ,* ,-" S*$0"9 %$, '

C20 /":"8 8"2(-"< +*8 ,-" #*&'(G *+ ,-" D">0 :0; L/',"< T,2,"0 21D,/9 ,-" 7'8($', 7*$8, *+ 6##"2&0 *+

,-" D*$8,- 7'8($', 02'$2>"9 #*'/,"< ,* 7*/>8"00 20 #*00"00'/> ,-" 8"]$'0'," #*C"8 ,

"/2(, #8*%2,'*/ &2C09 ,-2, 2 +"


13/26

!$

2/< ,-2, ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',G *+ ,-" 6(, -20 %""/ 200$F"< %G ,-" T$#8"F"

7*$8, *+ ,-" L/',"< T,2,"0 '/ ?@IZ 2/< (*/0'0,"/,&G 0$0,2'/"< %G ,-" '/+"8'*8

+"'0&2,$8" ,*'0&2,':" #*C"8 ,* 0", #$/'0-F"/, +*8 (8'F" '0 :"8G %8*2

,-" #"/2&,'"0 C-'(- ,-" &2C #8"0(8'%"0 '/ #28,'($&28 (20"0; E, '0 %"&'":"< ,-2,M$0,'(" (2/ %"0, %" 0"8:"< %G :"0,'/> ,-'0 #*C"8 '/ ,-" (*$8,09 ,-"G %"'/> '/ 2

#*0','*/ ,* %"0, 2 0"/,"/(" F"8"&G %"(2$0"9 ,2N'/> '/,* (*/0'- ,-" \"#28,F"/, *+ U$0,'("9 0$(- 0,2,"F"/, 20 ', F2G 82#- B9 *+ ,-" !":'0"'0&2,$8" ,* 0$0#"/< 0"/,"/(" %G ,-" "0,2%&'0-F"/, *+ 2

0G0,"F *+ #8*%2,'*/ -*C":"8 (-282(,"8'b"


15/26

!&

*8 #"2(" *++'("8 #*C"8 '/ ,-"

(-'"+ "Y"($,':" *+ ,-" 0,2,"; OW'&'0- (8*C/9 *8 %G ',0 8"#8"0"/,2,':"0 '/ ,-" (*&*/'"0; O@R

D/,(%d"&&09 X@ L; T;9 ?Z S*C;9 AQBc ?X ^2C; " ,-"#"8'*< *+ #8*%2,'*/9 8"F2'/0 '/ &">2& ($0,*


16/26

!'

8"#8'":"09 -2:'/> %""/ :"0,"< "Y(&$0':"&G $#*/ ,-" 7-'"+ 3Y"($,':" %G ,-" U*/"0

^2C9 F2G /*, %" (*/+"88"< %G ,-" &">'0&2,$8" $#*/ ,-" (*$8,0 %G F"2/0 *+

#8*%2,'*/ &2C 2$,-*8'b'/> ,-" '/- S28#"89 F;a

=-2, ,-" #*C"8 ,* 0$0#"/< ,-" 0"/,"/(" 82/, (*FF$,2,'*/0 *+ #$/'0-F"/,9

+*8 2 (*FF$,2,'*/0 '0 /*, %$, ,* (-2/>" ,-" #$/'0-F"/, 200"00"< ,* 2

&"00 #$/'0-F"/,;

E/ T,2," %R ,%+; 5*,,*F/&G :0; \'0,8'(, 7*$8, Oe?@IXf9 BA 1*/,;9 XH?c IAB .2(;9

XIXR9 ,-" T$#8"F" 7*$8, *+ 1*/,2/2 -2< $/'/>

$#*/ ,-" #2882("9 #8*("" #*C"89 '/ 8"0#"(, ,* ,-*0" 0"8:'/> ,-"'8

#8*%2,'*/28G 0"/,"/("09 8"F2'/0 20 +$&& 2/< (*F#&"," 20 '+ ,-" .8*%2,'*/ ^2C

-2< /":"8 %""/ "/2(,"*:"8/F"/,

'/2,"< C',- ,-" >&*002,*809 C20 '/,8*


17/26

!(

%G ^*8< 7*N" '/ ,-" 3/>&'0- #$%&'( &2C '/ *:"8/F"/,; E, -20 0'/(" %"(*F" 2/ 2(("#,"< (*8*&&28G *+ ,-" #8'/('#&" *+

0"#282,'*/ *+ #*C"80; OX 3/(G(; *+ ,-" T*('2& T('"/("09 #; JJ;R =-" (&200'(

0,2,"F"/, *+ ,-" 8$&" '0 ,-2, *+ ^*(N"9 /2F"&Ga K=-" &">'0&2,':" /"',-"8 F$0, /*8

(2/ ,82/0+"8 ,-" #*C"8 *+ F2N'/> &2C0 ,* 2/G%*'0&2,$8",* F2N" &2C0 (2//*, %" 2,"< %G ,-2, "/('"0 $#*/ C-'(- ,-" #*C"8

0-2&& %" -, %$, 2 'FF"'0&2,':" %*'0&2,':"

#*C"80 ,* &*(2& 2$,-*8','"0; O!$%' :0; .8*:'/('2& 5*28< *+ 1'/*:"8/F"/,9

,-2, &*(2& 2++2'80 0-2&& %" F2/2>"< %G &*(2& 2$,-*8','"09 2/< >"/"82& 2++2'80 %G ,-"("/,82& 2$,-*8','"0c 2/< -"/(" C-'&" ,-" 8$&" '0 2&0* +$/'0&2,':" #*C"89 %$, 82,-"8

20 ,-" >82/, *+ ,-" 2$,-*8',G ,* #8"0(8'%"< &*(2& 8">$&2,'*/09 2((*8- :0; S"//'(N9 21D,/;R V/ ]$'," ,-" 02F"

#8'/('#&"9 7*/>8"00 '0 #*C"8"< ,* 2," &">'0&2,':" #*C"8 ,* 0$(- 2>"/('"0 '/

,-" ,"88',*8'"0 *+ ,-" L/',"< T,2,"0 20 ', F2G 0"&"(,; 6 ,"88',*8G 0,2/8"00 20 2 F$/'('#2&',G *8 (',G ,* ,-" 0,2," >*:"8/F"/,;

OL/',"< T,2,"0 :0; S"'/0b"/ e?@QBf9 IQJ L; T;9 ABQc IB T$#; 7,; !"#;9 BHIc X? ^;

" ."*#&"

:0; h"//"*/e?@?If9 IIA L; T;9 ??Zc XJ ^2C; "8"00':" (*$8,09 ,-" 0,'/> *+ ,-" 82#- I9 *+ 28,'(&" WE *+ ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/ *+

,-" .-'&'##'/"0 #8*:' (*/0,',$,'*/2&

#8*:'0'*/09 ,-" .8"0'


18/26

!)

E/ ,"0,'/> C-",-"8 2 0,2,$," (*/0,',$," 2/ $/'0&2,':" #*C"8

*8 /*,9 ', '0 $0$2& ,* '/]$'8" C-",-"8 ,-" 0,2,$," C20 (*F#&"," '/ 2&& ',0 ,"8F0

2/< #8*:'0'*/0 C-"/ ', &"+, ,-" -2/'0&2,$8" 0* ,-2, /*,-'/> C20 &"+,

,* ,-" M$F"/, *+ 2/G *,-"8 2##*'/,"" *8 2," *+ ,-" &">'0&2,$8"; OJ !; 7; ^;9

#; ?JX;R E/ ,-" L/',"< T,2,"0 :0; 6/> =2/> S* Oe?@IIf9 HA .-'&;9 ?R9 ,-'0 (*$8,

2*'/> 8$&" C-"/ ', -"&< 2/ 2(, *+ ,-" &">'0&2,$8" :*'< '/ 0* +28

20 ', $/ ,-" #8'(" *+ 8'(" 2/< ,* F2N" ,-" 02&" *+ ', '/ :'*&2,'*/ *+ ,-"

#8*(&2F2,'*/ 2 (8'F"; O*%%2/< (+; 7*F#2n'2 P"/"82& 2,"< %G "Y"($,':"

*++'("80 2/< 2 ,-"

>82/,"< '0&2,$8" ,* / (2,,&"9 0$(- #8*-'%','*/ ,* %" 82'0"

K'+ ,-" (*/

+*8"'>/ (2,,&" -20 ("20"< ,* %" 2 F"/2(" ,* ,-" 2>8'($&,$8" 2/< &':"0,*(N *+ ,-"

&2/8" :0; 7*&&"(,*8 *+ 7$0,*F0 e?@I@f9 XA .-'&;9 A@Hc 7"%$ 6$,*%$0 7*; :0;

\" U"0$0 e?@A?f9 XJ .-'&;9 HHJc L; T; :0; P*F"b e?@?Xf9 A? .-'&;9 I?Zc !$%' :0;

.8*:'/('2& 5*28< *+ 1'/


19/26

!*

2'0&2,$8" F2G 2," 2 #*C"8 /*, &">'0&2,':"

C-'(- ', F2G ',0"&+ 8'>-,+$&&G "Y"8('0";OW' '/,*

"++"(, *+ 2 &2C; =-2, '0 2 F"/,2& #8*("00 (*FF*/ ,* 2&& %82/(-"0 *+ ,-"

>*:"8/F"/,; O\*C&'/> :0; ^2/(20-'8" E/0; 7*;921D,/c O. ,%W'&&2>" *+ 4*8,-

1'&C2$N"" e?Z@Jf9 @A d'0;9 J?Jc @B 4;d;9 ?QAAc AA ^;!;6;9 @AZc 420- :0; D8'"0

e?@QJf9 ?I@ d'0;9 ?IQc ?QZ 4;d;9 I?Qc D'"&< :0; 7&28N e?Z@If9 ?HA L;T;9 JH@c ?I

T$#; 7,;9 H@Xc AJ ^2C; " ,-" 2##28"/, ,"/ +8*F 0*('2& 2/< "(*/*F'( +*8("0 2, C*8N '/

,-'0 F* &2/>$2>" j 0#"2N'/> *+'0&2,':" #*C"8 ,* 2"/, F2G

82/,"'0&2,':" 2(,9 '0 ':"/ ('8($F0,2/("09 ("8,2'/ "Y"($,':" *8 2*:"8/""/(G $#*/ C-'(- ,-" 6(, 0-2&& ,2N" "++"(, F2G %"

&"+, ,* 0$(- 2>"/('"0 20 ', F2G :0; 5$88 e?ZX@f9 ?A 72&;9 AHA9 IXZ;R =-"

&">'0&2,$8"9 ,-"/ F2G #8*:' ,* 0*F" *,-"8 #"80*/

*8 %*'0&2,$8" -20 /*, F2"/, $#*/ 0#"('+'"< +2(,0 *8 (*/'0&2,$8"; E, F2G ,2N" '/,* (*/0' *+ 2 ("8,2'/

0#"('+'"< (*/,'/>"/(G9 *8 $#*/ ,-" 20("8,2'/F"/, *+ ("8,2'/ +2(,0 *8 (*/ &2C0 '/ ,-'0 0,2,"

0-2&& %" "Y"8('0"< "Y("#, %G ,-" &">'0&2,$8"Kc 2/< 0"(,'*/ IJ9 28,'(&" E *+ ,-"

7*/0,',$,'*/ *+ E/-,0 '/ ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/

*+ ,-'0 (*FF*/C"2&,-9 ', '0 -, /":"8 ,* %" "Y"8('0"< %$, %G

,-" &">'0&2,$8"9 *8 %G 2$,-*8',G '0&2,$8" 0-2&& "Y#8"00&G #8*:'/2 7-28,2 *+ 3/>&2/

*+ d'&&'2F 2/< 128G; =-" %'&& *+ 8'>-,0 (*/,2'/0 2/ "/$F"82,'*/ *+ ,-"

*##8"00':" 2(,0 *+ U2F"0 EE9 ,"/


20/26

#+

+'80, *+ ,-"F '0 ,-" 200$F'/> 2/< "Y"8('0'/> 2 #*C"8 *+ C',-

2/< 0$0#"/-,0

(*/,2'/"< '/ ,-" 0,2,$," '09 ,-2, ,-" "Y"8('0" *+ 0$(- #*C"89 %G &">2&

2$,-*8',G C',-*$, (*/0"/, *+ #28&'2F"/,9 '0 '&&">2&; E/ ,-" ,"/,- 0"(,'*/

*+ ,-" 02F" 0,2,$," ', '0 +$8,-"8 '0&2,$8" (2/ */&G "Y"8('0" C-2, '0 2,"< ,* ,-"F 2((*8 &2C09K C-",-"8 "Y"8('0"< %G */"F2/ *8 %G 2 /$F%"8 *+ F"/; E, (2//*, %" 0$##*0"< ,-2, ,-" #"*#&"

C-"/ 2"/"82& #8'/('#&" +8*F ,-" 3/>&'0- %'&& *+ 8'>-,0 2/ ', '/ *$8 (*/0,',$,'*/9 '/,"/ 2 N/*C&"" *+ ', :'('*$0 '0&2,$8"

(*$&< /*, (*/+"8 ,-2, #*C"8; =-" (*$8, *%0"8:"< ,-2, ', (*$&< /* F*8" (*/+"8

0$(- 2 #*C"8 ,-2/ ,* 2$,-*8'b" ,-" %*28< *+ 0$#"8:'0*80 *+ 2 (*$/,G ,* 2%*&'0-

'/ 0$(- (*$/,G ,-" 82(" */ (*FF"8('2& #2#"89 *8 ,* 0$0#"/< ,-" 0,2,$,"

*+ &'F',2,'*/0; OT&'/>"8 :0; S"//"F2/ e?ZBXf9 AZ d'0;9 XQH;R 6 0'F'&28 0,2,$," '/

1'00*$8' C20 -"&< :*'< +*8 ,-" 02F" 8"20*/ '/ T,2," :0; D'"&< Oe?ZXA9 ?B 1*;9

XI@cX@ 6F; \"(;9 IBX;R E/ ,-2, (20" 2 >"/"82& 0,2,$," +*8F$&2,'/> 2 8*2< 0G0,"F

(*/,2'/"< 2 #8*:'0'*/ ,-2, K'+ ,-" (*$/,G (*$8, *+ 2/G (*$/,G 0-*$&< %" *+

*#'/'*/ ,-2, ,-" #8*:'0'*/0 *+ ,-" 2(, 0-*$&< /*, %" "/+*8("'/2&

]$"0,'*/9 ,* %" 2,"< ,-" '/(*/0'0,"/, #8*:'0'*/0

*+ #8":'*$0 &2C09 ,-" (*$/,G (*$8, '0 ; ; ; "F#*C"8"'0&2,':" #*C"89 C-'(- $/ F2,,"80 *+ #$8"&G &*(2& (*/("8/ '/ ,-"

-2/


21/26

#!

C" %"&'":" ,-2, '/ F2,,"80 *+ >"/"82& *+ >"/"82& &">'0&2,'*/ &'N" ,-2, C-'(- ,8"2,0

*+ (8'F'/2&0 '/ >"/"82&9 2/< 20 8">28'0&2,$8" ,* 0$0#"/< ,-" *#"82,'*/ *+ ,-"

.8*%2,'*/ 6(, '/ #28,'($&28 #8*:'/("09 ,-" 6(, ,* %" -"&< '/ 2%"G2/(" $/,'& ,-"

#8*:'/('2& %*288"2, '0&2,$8"

/*, */&G '/ ,-" "Y#8"00'*/ *+ C-2, F2G %" ,"8F"< &">'0&2,':" #*&'(G %$, '/ ,-"

"&2%*82,'*/ 2/< "Y"($,'*/ ,-"8"*+; Kd',-*$, ,-'0 #*C"89 &">'0&2,'*/ C*$&"8 :0; 1*82/ e?@AJf9 AX V++; P2b;9 ?A?B;R 5$,9 ', 0-*$&< %"

%*8/" '/ F'/< ,-2, 2 (*/0,',$,'*/ '0 %*,- 2 >82/, 2/< 2 &'F',2,'*/ *+ #*C"8 2/'0&2,':" #*C"8 0-2&& /*, %" 2,"-, 0-"&,"8"< %G ,-" 7*/0,',$,'*/ '0 2 8"0,82'/, */ 2&& ,-"

,8"" >82/< *:"8/F"/, 2/< */ ,-" 0$%*828'0&2,'*/ 2>2'/0, 0*F" 2/< +2:*8'/> *,-"80 '/

#8*-'%',"/'0 :0; D2&N; 7*; e?@??f9 ?HB

d'0;9 AIB9 AXAc ?AA 4; d;9 IQ@c A 4; 7; 7; 6;9 JH@c AB ^; !; 6; e4; T;f9 HZ@c T,2," :0;

7**&"G9 XJ 1'//;9 XHQc XAQ[XXIc XZ 4; d;9 ?XQc ^'/ ,-" "Y2F#&" >':"/ %G */" *+ ,-"

(*$/0"& +*8 ,-" #",','*/"80 '/ ,-" (*$80" *+ -'0 *82& 28>$F"/,9 */" #8*:'/(" F2

2##8*#8'2," ,-" /"("0028G +$/< ,* C',-'/ ,-" #$8:'"C *+ ,-" .8*%2,'*/

6(, C*$&< %" "/,',&"< ,* 2:2'& *+ ,-" %"/"+',0 *+ ,-" 6(,; 4"',-"8 C'&& ,-"8" %" 2/

8"0$&,'/> '/"]$2&',G '+ /* #8*:'/("9 ,-8*$>- ',0 #8*:'/('2& %*28


22/26

##

2##8*#8'2," 2/G 2F*$/, +*8 ,-" 02&28G *+ ,-" #8*%2,'*/ *++'("8 j C-'(- '0 ,-"

0',$2,'*/ /*C j 2/G9 7-G ^$/> :0; D8""F2/ e?ZBJf9 I@I L; T;9 IBXc IA ^2C; " ,-" "]$2& #8*,"(,'*/ *+ ,-" &2C ', '0 $/(*/0,',$,'*/2&; OJ !; 7; ^; #; ABIc

7':'& !'>-,0 720"09 ?Q@ L; T;9 Ac A T$#; 7,; !"#;9 ?Zc IB ^2C; "2,'*/0 '/

(8'F'/2& (20"0 *8'>'/2&&G >82/,"< %G P"/"82& V8 2,,*8/"G9 2+,"8 2 - /*, '/ ,-" +*8F -2< '/ ,-" #8*:'/("0 j C20 (*/0''0&2,$8" ',0"&+;

!"&'2/(" '0 2&0* #&2("< */ ,-" (20" *+ 1'00*$8' :0; ^"C'09 21D,/; =-2, (20" -20

8"+"8"/(" ,* 2 0',$2,'*/ C-"8" ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/ *+ 1'00*$8' #"8F',0 2##"2&0 ,*

,-" T$#8"F" 7*$8, *+ ,-" 0,2," +8*F +'/2& M$F"/,0 *+ 2/G ('8($', (*$8,9 "Y("#,

,-*0" '/ ("8,2'/ (*$/,'"0 +*8 C-'(- (*$/,'"0 ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/ "0,2%&'0-"0 2

0"#282," (*$8, *+ 2##"2&0 (2&&"< T,; ^*$'0 7*$8, *+ 6##"2&0; =-" #8*:'0'*/

(*F#&2'/"< *+9 ,-"/9 '0 +*$/< '/ ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/ ',0"&+ 2/< ', '0 ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/

,-2, F2N"0 ,-" 2##*8,'*/F"/, *+ ,"88',*8'2& M$8'0 $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& 2/< :*'< +*8 ,-" 8"20*/0

2&8"2


23/26

#$

E/ 0""N'/> ,-" &">'0&2,':" '/,"/,9 ,-" #8"0$F#,'*/ '0 2>2'/0, 2/G

F$,'&2,'*/ *+ 2 0,2,$,"9 2/< ,-" (*$8,0 C'&& 8"0*8, ,* "&'F'/2,'*/ */&G

C-"8" 2/ $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& #8*:'0'*/ '0 '/,"8M"(,"< '/,* 2 0,2,$,"

*,-"8C'0" :2&' &2/>$2>"a

; ; ; C-"8" #28, *+ ,-" 2 0,2,$," '0 :*'2/'( ^2C9

C-'&" 2/*,-"8 #28, '0 :2&''0&2,$8"; OT,2," :0;

6; 7; ^; !;9 7*;9 XJ D&2;9 J?B9 JHIc HB T*$;9 @J@c S28#"8 :0; P2&&*C2G9 XZ

D&2;9 IXXc X? T*$;9 IIJc IJ ^; !; 6;9 4; T;9 B@Hc 7*//*&&G :0; L/'*/ T"C"8

.'#" 7*;9 ?ZH L; T;9 XHQ9 XJXc ."*#&" :0; T,8200-"'F9 IHQ E&&;9 IB@9 AQQc ZZ

4; 3;9 ZI?c II ^; !; 6;9 4; T;9 ??AXc T,2," :0; 7*>/":'(-9 ?IH ^2;9 H?Hc XQ

T*$;9 HA@;R =-" &2/>$2>" $0"< '/ ,-" '/:2&'< #28, *+ 2 0,2,$," (2/ -2:"

/* &">2& +*8(" *8 "++'(2(G +*8 2/G #$8#*0" C-2,":"89 2/< C-2, 8"F2'/0

F$0, "Y#8"00 ,-" &">'0&2,':" C'&&9 '/'0&2,"; OT,2," :0; U$/N'/9 ZX 4"%;9 ?c ?II 4;d;9 HBAc IA ^; !; 6;9 4; T;9 ZA@c W' -'0 (*/R T-2&& 8"F2'/ *8 8"0'>8'":"< #28,'"0 +*8

2(,$2& "0 *8 &*00"0 (2$0"< %G -'0 *++"/0"c


24/26

#%

O>R T-2&& (*F#&G C',- 0$(- *82,"< '/ 2((*8 *+ ,-"(*$8, ,-2, ,-" #8*%2,'*/"8 -20 (*F#&'"< C',- ,-" (*//F"/, 2/< 2+,"8 2/ *##*8,$/',G ,*

%" -"28/2,"< %G

,-" T"(8",28G *+ U$0,'(" 0-2&& 2(, 20 #28*&" *++'("8 *+ #"80*/0 8"&"20"< */ #28*&"$/ 0"(,'*/ 28" (&"28&G /*, ,-*0" #8*%2,'*/ *++'("80 8"]$'8"< ,* %"

2##*'/,"< +*8 ,-" #8*:'/("0 $/ -'0 (*/ *+ ,-" #"8'*< 2/< ,"8F0 *+ #8*%2,'*/ O0"(; A9

&20, #28;R9 ', F"2/0 ,-" #8*%2,'*/ *++'("8 C-* '0 '/ (-28>" *+ 2 #28,'($&28

#8*%2,'*/"8 '/ 2 #28,'($&28 #8*:'/("; E, /":"8 (*$&< -2:" %""/ '/,"/,'*/ *+ ,-"

&">'0&2,$8"9 +*8 '/0,2/("9 ,* 8"]$'8" ,-" #8*%2,'*/"8 '/ 52,2/"09 ,* 8"#*8, ,* 2

#8*%2,'*/"8 *++'("8 '/ ,-" 7',G *+ 12/'&29 *8 ,* 8"]$'8" 2 #8*%2,'*/ *++'("8 '/

12/'&2 ,* :'0', ,-" #8*%2,'*/"8 '/ ,-" 02'< #8*:'/(" *+ 52,2/"09 ,* #&2(" -'F

$/ ,-"

(*//"-, ,-"8" '0 2 +28 (8G; =-" C'0


25/26

#&

'/,* ,-" &2C F2,,"80 2/< #8*:'0'*/0 C-'(- 28" /*, ,-"8"; 4*, +*8 2/G #$8#*0" j

/*, ":"/ ,* 02:" 2 0,2,$," +8*F ,-" 09 ,-" 02&28'"0 *+ ,-" 282(" '/ *8 2, ,-'0 (*/(&$0'*/9 C" -2:" "/2& #8'/('#&"0 '/:*&:"< C" -2:" '/(&'/"< ,*

2"/"82& C"&+28"; OTF',-9 5"&& i 7*; :0;

42,':'


26/26

#'

T9/.$%V/= 4;F;= O:D%,#/+= 7#/8 /.3 4'.$%D$#'.= FF;= $'.$1,;

E#++/W,%/+ /.3 TH/3 */.('2= FF;= $'.$1, #. ()% ,%21+(;

People vs Vera, 65 Phil 56

Documents

Transcript of People vs Vera, 65 Phil 56