The NInstitupractManaDelhi,impleMissioimplePeer dissemlearnproviissues The worganevent(MoEfrom Indorstate laterathe ev

Ms. Bset thShe cset-up

Pr

PRACT

National Instute (WBI) antitioner learnagement (SW, the event b

ementing PPon (JNNURMementation. T

Experience minating knoing event ade practitios on the grou

workshop conizations ant including rF), and the a total of e, Kanpur, L governmental institutionsvent.

Bhavna Bhatihe stage andcomplimentep platform

rof. Chetan VaNIUA

NA

ITIONERS

SOL

PEAR

titute of Urbnd Cities Alning event onWM). Held obrought togeP projects

M) but are fThis learning and Reflecowledge to and exchangoners with pund.

nvened overd private serepresentativDepartment 12 cities incLucknow, Mut representas including D

e

ia, Regionald guided thed PEARL by for peer

aidya,

ATIONAL W EXPERIEN

LID WASTE

RL Netwo

ban Affairs (liance organn Public Priv

on 3rd – 4th Jether SWM under the Jfacing challe event was ctive Learnin SWM sectoge was to

practical tips

r 80 represeector. Centraves from the of Economiccluding Agraumbai, Nandatives attendDFID, ADB, Ci

Prof. Chetparticipantthe PEARLvarious undertakenand encourcities to nuupon

experiences.

Coordinatoe deliberatioy mentioning learning

1

WORKSH

NCE EXCH

E MANAG

rk Learni

(NIUA) in conized a one

vate Partnersune 2011 aprofessionalJawaharlal enges in proheld to suppng (PEARL) or professiofacilitate d

s and guida

entatives froal governmee MoUD, Mic Affairs, Mia, Allahabadded Wagheded the evenities Alliance

tan Vaidya, ts to the woL programm

activities n by the iraged particurture and dtheir co.

or South Asiaons of the wo that it is ain India a

OP ON HANGE O

GEMENT

ng Event

ollaboration e and a halship (PPP) prt the India Hs in the counNehru Nati

oject preparport capacitynetwork und

onals. The pdiscussions onance for ad

om governmeent ministriesinistry of Eninistry of Find, Coimbato

ela, Thane ant. Also secte and World

Director, orkshop. He me and bri

being nitiative cipating develop ollective

a, WBI, orkshop. a unique and also

N PPPS I

t

with the Wlf day pracrojects in SoHabitat Centntry who areonal Urbanration, structy building thder the JNNpurpose of tn project isdressing som

ent, cities, ms participatinvironment anance. Repreore, Delhi, Fand Rajkot, a

tor experts ad Bank partic

NIUA welcooutlined theiefly highlig

Ms. BhavnW

N

World Bank titioner to lid Waste ter in New e currently n Renewal turing and hrough the NURM for the action ssues, and me of the

multilateral ing at the and Forest esentatives aridabad, as well as and multi-cipated at

omed the e vision of ghted the

na Bhatia, WBI

Ms

acknoeventand knowimpleknow

effecpartsfind sMoUDsimila Mr. Hsuppomentiimporsituatexcelmore follow Mr. AbriefementiPEARgrantprovitransf

netwoinformknow

s. Nisha SinghMoUD

owledged Mt on knowledexplained tledge shari

ementing SWledge gaps

tive manner. of the worlsolutions tailoD together aar areas and

Hubert Josseorted the nioned that Prtance in Frtions, SWMllent as well efficiency wed by finan

Ajay Suri, Sed on theioned that L network st facility. In cding the teform PEARL

ork by smation exchaledge produ

h,

Ministry of Udge and expthat the leaing among

WM PPP Proje and prioritiz

MsDecommemalink(UL

transpgenera

. She stressedd in terms ofored to diffeare taking upd wished the

erand, Operaneed of thePP projects rance. Since

M PPP pro in this countand discip

ncial benefits

Senior Prograe mandate

the organiince early 2collaborationechnical kno into an ef

strengtheningange and deucts.

Urban Develperience shararning event

participantsects. The ultize capacity

s. Nisha Sivelopment, wmmendable entioned thaanagement aked and areLBs) have to

ortation, proated within d the need tf role that Perent local cp a capacityprogramme

ations Advisoe programmhave been o

e India hadojects wouldtry as projecpline to thes.

am Officer, of Cities

sation has 2010 througn with WBI, Cow-how to cffective hori

g the preveloping ne

2

opment (Moring. She bri would facis, drawing mate goal, sbuilding nee

ingh, Joint welcoming th

work beinat pollutionand environe areas of o undertake

ocessing andits jurisdictio

to study and PPPs could plcontexts. Shey building tr great succe

or, WB, me and of great

d similar d work cts bring e sector

Cities AllianAlliance

supported gh a three-yCities Allianccapacitate izontal learn

ocess of eed-based

Mr. HubertMr. Ajay S

oUD) supporefed about ilitate interafrom their

she said, woeds for cities

Secretary, he participanng undertak, climate cment are thconcern. Th collection,

d disposal ofon in a mor analyse suclay, and how

e also mentioaining progrss.

nce, and the

year ce is and ning

Josserand, WSuri, Cities All

rt to the prathe mandate

active discusown expe

ould be to id under JnNU

Ministry onts, acknowleken by PEchange, solhemes that e urban locsegregation

municipal sore scientific cess stories fw cities wouloned that MHramme for th

WB and liance

actitioner’s es of WBI, ssions and riences in entify key RM.

of Urban edged the EARL. She lid waste are inter-

cal bodies , storage,

olid waste and cost-

from other d need to HUPA and he ULBs in

ULBs wastetranspdiscusNGOstreet

The tModeoptiobeingtransastructissuesassiststruct

The fdissem

Group of D

while desige and its trportation of ssed. The se

O’s, informal t sweeping a

third session els under SWns for treatm

g consideredactions. The uring the PPs in procureance as weuring integra

following sesmination dur

iscussants at

ning an appransportation waste fromession also sectors incluactivities und

concentrateWM in missment and di

d by various risk allocatPP contract wement and ell. The citieated PPP pro

ssion was onring the sess

t the Worksho

framincePPPsrole issue

propriate syn. Issues suc source, washighlighted

uding rag per PPP contr

ed on Treatsion cities. Tisposal of so cities and thion framewowas also discontract do

es of Rajkoojects for tre

n PPPs for dion bought o

3

op

meworks ofntives availas being ado of public es in the des

c

T“RCthCimtr

PPiss

ystem of primch as vehicleste storage d experience

pickers, sweeracts.

ment and DThis session olid waste. Ihe key issueork models scussed. The ocumentationt and Mum

eatment and

developing rout clearly t

The first sefor SWM proverarching in SWM bstate govegovernmentsGujarat aexperiencesenabling fradiscussed th the state

able for PPPopted acrossand privateigning and i

contracts.

The second“Collection Role of PrivaChallenges”. he experienCoimbatore mplementingransportatioPP models. sues and cmary and see synchronizdepots and

es of cities epers, etc in

Disposal Techdiscussed thIt bought ou

es for structubeing consid session encons where U

mbai shared disposal.

egional landhe fact that

ession on PProjects, focus frameworkbeing suppernments. Ts of Ma

and Orissas in proviamework fohe legal ae governmePs, different s the SWM e sectors, anmplementati

d session and Trans

ate Sector, I This sessionces of the

and Dg SWM collen compone It elaborchallenges fecondary cozation in cotransfer statby involvin waste colle

hnology andhe various tut the revenuring financiadered by thouraged disLBs require their expe

dfill sites in a regional

PP options sed on the for PPPs orted by

The state harashtra,

a shared ding the

or PPPs. It nd policy

ent, fiscal models of chain, the nd critical ion of PPP

was on sportation: Issues and on shared cities of

Delhi in ection and nts under rated the faced by llection of

ollection & tions were g RWA’s, ection and

d Revenue echnology ue models ally viable he cities in scussion on advisory

eriences in

cities. The approach

Pan

for dunviaimpleand Cprojeand M

projeplayealso d The ssome to poPPP p– prosome been commissuesmonitmechsome tools like Rfor obligcritermet.

nelists of the Goo

disposal of Mble to cons

ementation oCoimbatore. ects were alsMumbai in d

ects, the risk aers. The creddiscussed in t

eventh sessio of the vital ost contractprojects fromojects that a time and p awarded

mence operats pertainingtoring and anisms. The of the pthat have b

Rajkot and Nensuring

ations ania defined f

Session on Inod Practices

MSW is a struct individf regional la The policy aso discussed designing reg

contrinvo The pracpart

allocation frdit assessmethis session.

on was on poconcerns pe

t managemem two perspere operationprojects thatd but yetions. It focus

g to perfordispute resosession brief

project monbeen used byNanded Wa

that snd perforfor the proje

nternational

se

good alterndual disposaandfill projecand legal fra in details. Bgional facilitractual sidelvement of m

following dctices, the ticipants to

ameworks, rnt of SWM

ost contract rtaining ent of ectives nal for t have et to sed on mance olution fed on itoring y ULBs aghela service mance

ect are

4

Discussants econd day of t

native for smal facilities. cts through Pameworks reBesides discuties, the sess to designi

multiple ULBs

ay in the fipanelists a deeper

discussions in our nMaldives Private SIssues wasixth sesperspectlending iSWM secduring timplemen

roles and resprojects fro

managemen

during the the Workshop

maller ULBs This session

PPPs in differequired for iussing experion also focung such PP

s and the priv

ifth session oattracted thand more on scenarioneighboring s and Singap

Sector Perspas the pointssion. This stives of theinstitutions foctor. It also dthe construcntation phasponsibilities om the lende

t and monito

p

as it is econ also talkerent cities likmplementatiriences of Taused on the P projects vate sector.

on internatiohe attention thought pos that are

countries opore.

pectives and t for discusssession disc

e private seor PPP projediscussed thection, operaases of th of private a

er’s perspect

oring issues a

onomically ed on the e MMRDA ion of such amil Nadu legal and given the

onal good n of the pondering prevailing

of Europe,

Financing sion in the ussed the ector and ects in the e key risks ation and he SWM and public tives were

addressed

proce12th group The ebuildiexchaarran• S

remfoch

• Pinabc.de

The w

Prof. O.P.MaNIUA

eedings and Five Year Pp for capacit

event had soing needs. Tange, study ngements andome of the equired inclu

management,or regional harges / tipparticipants id

ncluding . Working . Preparati. Sharing e. Participat. Training.

workshop end

athur,

learning’s fPlan Committy building.

ought feedbaThe key areatours, learnind a helpline qualitative aude commun, treatment

initiatives, ping fees, etdentified are

groups and on of case stxperience; tion in worksh

ded with vot

The last sesknowledgeand implemidentify prcollaboratiexperiencethe HPEC thousand Cnext 20 yean effectivtrack this

from the wottee and the

ack from paas ranked ang notes, br on SWM. areas wherenity involvemtechnologiesdoor-to-doo

tc. eas where th

providing tetudies and e

hops and stu

te of thanks f

5

ssion on pane and capacmentation of riority areason across cit

e. Prof. Om Report has

Crores as theears for devve monitoring

capital. Herkshop be pe National

articipants abas priority inciefs and cas

e more knowment, behavs, environmeor collection

hey would be

echnical suppexchange of

udy tours; an

from Prof. V

el discussioncity gaps co PPP project and approties and alsoP. Mathur, N recommend

e minimum caelopment of g mechanisme also sugg

presented to Developmen

bout the knocluded Practse studies, pe

wledge and ior change, nt norms, In

n and finan

e keen to sup

port; documentati

nd

V. K. Dhar, NI

sought to idonstraining ts in SWM. It

oaches for ko to bring intNIUA, mentided a sum apital require SWM secto would be regested that the sub-gront Council (N

owledge andtitioner to Peer networks

thoughtful a conservancynstitutional mncial aspect

pport and pa

ions;

IUA.

dentify the he design t aimed to knowledge ernational ioned that of ` 50

ed for the r and that equired to t the key oup of the NDA) sub-

d capacity ractitioner s, twinning

actions are y workers

mechanisms s of user

articipate,

F

OWIIKV

S

CMDMMM

L

SC

CMDMMMT

S CMDMM SC

Friday, 3

OPENING Welcome Remntroduction tontroductory AKeynote AddrVote of Thank

SESSION 1

Chair : Ms. BModerator: MDiscussants: Mr. Manu SriMr. Sanjib MMr. Lekhan Th

LUNCH

SESSION IICHALLENG

Chair: Mr. NModerator: MDiscussants: Mr. Pradeep Mr. SavanakuMr. R.A. RajeTEA BREAK

SESSION II

Chair : Mr. MModerator: MDiscussants: Mr. R.A. RajeMr. Vijay Ana

SESSION IVChair: Ms. Bh

rd June, 2

SESSION: marks o the WorkshoAddress ress ks

: PPP OPT

Bhavna BhatiaMr. D.T.V. Ra ivastav, Princishra, Joint Shakkar, DoP

I: COLLECTGES

abaroon BhaMr. Anand M Khandelwal, umar, Assistaev, CommissK

II: TREATM

Manu SrivastaMr. D.T.V. Ra ev, Commissadkat, City E

V: PPPs fohavna Bhatia

India

2011

Mop M M M

TIONS FOR

a, Regional Caghu Rama S

cipal SecretaSecretary, HUT, Govt of In

TION & TR

attacharjee, IMadhavan, He

SE, Municipaant Executive ioner, Thane

MENT AND av, Principal aghu Rama S

ioner, Thane Engineer, Mun

r DEVELOa, Regional C

AGJune 3

a Habitat C

Mr. Chetan VaMs. Bhavna BMs. Nisha SingMr. Hubert JoMr. Ajay Suri,

R SWM PRO

Coordinator Swamy, iDeCK

ary, MaharashUDD, Orissa ndia (Gujarat

RANSPORT

India Countryead – Energy

al Corporatio Engineer, Co Municipal C

D DISPOSA Secretary, M

Swamy, iDeCK

Municipal Cnicipal Corpo

PING REGCoordinator S

6

GENDA 3 - 4, 2011Center, Ne

aidya, DirectoBhatia, Regiongh, Joint Secrsserand, Ope Senior Progr

OJECTS

South Asia, WK

htra t)

TATION: R

y Team Leadey & Urban In

on, Delhi oimbatore

Corporation.

AL: REVENU

Maharashtra K and Mr. M

Corporation oration, Rajk

GIONAL LASouth Asia, W

1 ew Delhi

or, NIUA nal Coordinatetary, Ministr

erations Advisram Officer, C

WBI

ROLE OF P

er, WSP nfrastructure,

UE AND TE

Mainak Hazra

kot

ANDFILLS WBI

A

or South Asiay of Urban Dor, WB

Cities Alliance

RIVATE SE

iMaCs

ECHNOLO

a, SENES

AMALTAS

10:30 – 1

, World BankDevelopment

e

11:15 – 12

12:45 –

ECTOR, ISS 1:45 –

3:15 –

OGY MODE 3:30 –

5:00 – 6

S HALL

1:15 AM

k Institute

2:45 AM

1:45 PM

SUES & 3:00 PM

3:30 PM

ELS 5:00 PM

6:00 PM

MDMMM

S

SCEMS

SCDMMMM

T

SCMKMM

CKPMMM

L

Moderator: MDiscussants:Ms. Uma, ChiMr. SavanakuMr. Piyush Jo

Saturday

SESSION VChair: Mr. ChEuropean CouMaldives Singapore

SESSION VChair: Mr. RaDiscussants Mr. Neeraj GMr. E.ShankaMr. Anouj MeMs. Sujatha S

TEA BREAK

SESSION VChair: Ms. BhModerator: MKey DiscussaMr. Vijay AnaMr. Nipun Vin

CONCLUDKey DiscussaProf. Om MaMs. Bhavna BMr. Raghu RaMr. Anand M

LUNCH

Ms. Suneetha: ief Planner, Mumar, Assista

oshi, Clarus L

y, 4th June

V: INTERNAhristopher Juuntries M M M

VI: PRIVATaghu Kesava :

Gupta, Seniorar Rao, Chiefehta, Asian DSrikumar, Dir

K

VII: POST Chavna BhatiaMr. D.T.V. Raants: adkat, City Enayak, Munic

ING SESSIants: athur, NIUA Bhatia, Regioama Swamy,

Madhavan, He

a D Kacker, W

MMRDA ant Executiveaw

e, 2011

ATIONAL uan Costian, PMr. Michael FMr. Neeraj GMr. Anand M

TE SECTORan, Senior Inf

r Investment Of General MaDevelopment rector, Power

CONTRACTa, Regional Caghu Rama S

Engineer, Mucipal Commis

ON: KNOW

onal Coordina CEO, iDeCKead – Energy

WSP

Engineer, C

GOOD PRPrincipal RegFox, Senior P

Gupta, Senioradhawan, He

R PERSPECTfrastructure S

Officer, IFC anager, IIFCL Bank rtech Enginee

T MANAGCoordinator SSwamy, iDeCK

nicipal Corpossioner, Nand

WLEDGE A

ator for SoutK y & Urban In

7

oimbatore

RACTICES Igional Team Public Privater Investment Oead – Energy

TIVES ANDSpecialist, W

L

ering

GEMENT & South Asia, WK

oration, Rajkded Waghel

AND CAPA

th Asia, WBI

frastructure,

IN PPPs foLeader, WSPe PartnershipOfficer, IFC y & Urban In

D FINANCorld Bank

MONITORWBI

kot a

ACITY NEE

I

iMaCs

MA

or SWM P ps Specialist, nfrastructure,

ING ISSUE

RING ISSU

DS

AGNOLIA

9:30 – 10

World Bank

iMaCs

ES 10:30 – 1

11:30 – 11

ES 11:45 –

1:00 –

1:45 PM ON

HALL

0:30 AM

k Institute

1:30 AM

:45 AM

1:00 PM

1:45 PM

NWARDS