Gotham Enhanced Value Indices -...
Transcript of Gotham Enhanced Value Indices -...
Gotham Enhanced Value IndicesEnhanced value investing in an accessible Index format
The Royal Bank of Scotland plc is an authorised agent of The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V. in certain jurisdictions.
2 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Introduction to the Gotham Enhanced Value Series
The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V. (“RBS”) has partnered with Joel Greenblatt, managing
partner of Gotham Capital International LLC to develop innovative and transparent indices
designed to provide investors with access to fundamental value investing principles utilising
Gotham Capital International’s proprietary approach to working with fundamental formulas.
Simulated past performance shows that the Gotham US Enhanced Value Index would have
outperformed benchmark indices without the performance fees normally charged by hedge
funds.
The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices are designed to select shares that exhibit a high earnings
yield and return on capital employed. Importantly, this investment approach is delivered as a
transparent, rules-based investment process. The Indices benefit from Gotham Capital Inter-
national’s experience working with and reviewing the company data used to calculate these ratios,
with the objective of ensuring that the data is comparable when analysing fundamental factors.
The Gotham US Enhanced Value Index offers exposure to highly liquid stocks in a variety of
business and industry sectors in the United States.
The Gotham Global Enhanced Index aims to give exposure to liquid worldwide shares.
The Gotham International Enhanced Index aims to give exposure to liquid worldwide
shares excluding the US.
The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices aim to provide investors with access businesses with above average returns on capital at below average prices using Joel Greenblatt’s fundamental value investing principles, through US, International and Global Indices, without the performance fees normally associated with hedge funds.
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
800
600
400
200
0
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Dec 99 Dec 01 Dec 03 Dec 05 Dec 07 Dec 09
World Government Bond Index S&P 500® Total Return Index
Gotham US Enhanced Value Index Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
Cumulative historical monthly returns
Years Gotham US
Enhanced
Value Index
S&P 500®
Total Return
Index
10-Year 521.5% -9.1%
5-Year -71.9% 12.3%
3-Year -31.9% -17.7%
1-Year 41.9% 50.5%
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31
December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
Simulated historical performance
The Gotham US Enhanced Value Index would
have outperformed the S&P 500® Index as
well as other well-known value investors.
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 3
“The Gotham Enhanced Value Index Series is a highly logical and consistent way to invest based on the value investment principles described in The Little Book That Beats the Market. We strongly believe that this approach has many advantages over traditional indices.”Joel Greenblatt, Managing Partner of Gotham Capital
International
Introduction to Joel Greenblatt & Gotham Capital
International
Joel Greenblatt is the author of the BusinessWeek bestseller You Can Be A Stock Market
Genius (Simon & Schuster, 1997) and The New York Times bestseller The Little Book that
Beats the Market (Wiley, 2005).
Joel Greenblatt is the Managing Partner of Gotham Capital, an investment partnership he
founded in April 1985 and several other Gotham Capital related investment partnerships.
Gotham Capital International was formed to use its intellectual property in overseas partnerships.
Joel Greenblatt is the former Chairman of the Board (1994-1995) and a former board member
(1994-2000) of Alliant Techsystems, a NYSE-listed aerospace and defence contractor. He
currently sits on the Investment Committee of both the University of Pennsylvania and the
UJA-Federation. Since 1996, Joel Greenblatt has been a professor on the adjunct faculty of
Columbia Business School where he teaches value and special situation investments.
Robert Goldstein joined Gotham Capital in 1989 and John Petry joined in 1997. Joel and
Robert have worked together for 20 years and all three partners have invested together
for over 12 years. Gotham Capital earned annual gross compounded returns of 50% (after
expenses, before incentive fee) from 1985 until it returned outside limited partner capital at the
end of 1994, generating cumulative gross returns of 5,197% vs. 154% for the S&P 500 during
this period. Subsequent to 1994, Gotham Capital has managed internal capital.
In addition to managing Gotham Capital, the principals have launched several ventures
together including the award winning Value Investors Club, Gotham Asset Management (a
value oriented fund of funds), Formulainvesting.com as well as charitable enterprises such as
the Success Charter Network, a network of charter schools in Harlem, New York.
4 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Key features of the Gotham Enhanced Value Series indices and strategies
Simulated past performance shows that the Gotham US Enhanced Value Index • outperforms other well-known benchmarks and value investors
Unlike hedge funds, the Indices have a rigorous rules based methodology, offering • style purity and transparency
Each share is scored and ranked according to its pre-tax earnings yield and its return • on capital employed and a combined rank is assigned to each company
The Indices do not have the performance fees normally associated with hedge funds•
Company data is systematically extracted and evaluated by Gotham Capital International•
Overview
The Indices are long only equity indices developed by Gotham Capital International in
partnership with RBS, offering investors access to their expertise in fundamental value
investing and RBS’s custom index and global product capabilities.
The Indices seek to outperform the market over the long term by rigorously selecting shares
on a quarterly basis using a two-factor, fundamental model using return on capital employed
and pre-tax earnings yield. The model seeks to identify companies with above average
returns at below average prices.
The two-factor fundamental model is applicable to companies from a wide range of business
and industry sectors. However, certain industries such as financials, real estate, insurance
and utilities have characteristics that make the application of the two-factor fundamental
model less robust and are excluded from the selection universe.
The model is applied by Gotham Capital International, who analyze the company data and
remove any information they deem unreliable or inconsistent. The aim of this is to ensure that
all companies can be equally evaluated when applying the two-factor fundamental model.
Simulated past performance showed that the Gotham Enhanced Value US Index significantly
outperformed the S&P 500® Index and other market averages over time, with more attractive
risk reward characteristics.
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 5
3. Fama & French (1993) developed a fundamental
model with 3 factors (market, size, value). Carghart
(1997) added momentum as a fourth factor to the Fama
& French Model.
Fundamentals Analysis and Value Investing
The Indices are based on the principles of value investing, which uses fundamental analysis
to identify investment opportunities in companies with profit potential whose shares are
undervalued by the market, as indicated by fundamental analysis ratios.
Fundamental analysis: a telling indicator of future performance
In the context of investing in shares, selection based on fundamentals is one of the most
widely used methods for identifying potentially profitable investment opportunities. The role of
fundamental factors to assess the risk in a portfolio of shares and its performance has been
studied extensively in academic literature over the past four decades, reaching a significant
milestone with the development of the Fama & French fundamental model in 1993.3 By looking
at a company’s operational efficiency, cash flow, financial leverage, and growth prospects,
analysts seek to identify undervalued and overvalued companies and make investment
decisions based on this.
Fundamental analysis unpacked: Earnings Yield and Return on Capital Employed
After having rigorously analysed over 70 factors in the context of fundamental value investing,
Gotham Capital International favours a simple ranking technique which combines value
and quality (the “Formula”). The basic idea is to compare all shares in the universe by using
two key fundamental analysis ratios - earnings yield and return on capital employed - and
then to buy the shares with the best combined score. This is because the combined score
indicates that, according to its fundamentals, these are shares of profitable companies that
are currently undervalued by the market. A key factor in obtaining reliable results using the
Formula is to obtain comparable data, which is achieved by the Gotham Enhanced Value
Indices by utilising Gotham Capital International’s proprietary database.
The 2 key ratios explored in detail
The Formula favoured by Gotham
Capital International consists of
applying two ratios.
Earnings Yield (EY)
Earnings Yield is defined as EBIT1/
Enterprise Value rather than the
standard PE2 ratio. This is in order to
take into account the amount of debt
a company is using to generate its
earnings.
Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)
Return on capital employed is defined
as EBIT / (net working capital + net
fixed assets). EBIT is used to create a
level playing field across companies
that have different levels of debt and
are subject to different tax rates. Net
working capital and net fixed assets
are combined to give tangible capital
employed: an estimate of how much
capital a company is using to generate
its business.
1. Earning Before Interest and Tax.
2. Price Earnings.
First, it is desirable to be in
a business that earns more
relative to the price paid for
its shares rather than less.
Therefore, a higher earnings
yield is better than a lower one.
The Formula used in the Gotham Enhanced Value Indices combines two key ideas
Buying businesses with above average returns on capital at below average prices
when they are undervalued by the market is the overwhelming logic behind
the Gotham Enhanced Value Indices.
Over time, these undervalued shares should “tend towards the mean”
i.e. appreciate in price as their value is recognised by the market.
Second, buying a share of a
profitable business is better
than buying a share of a less
profitable business. Therefore,
businesses that earn a high
return on capital employed are
better than businesses that
earn a lower one.
High
Earnings
Yield
Gotham
“Value”
Companies
High Return
on Capital
Employed
6 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Access to fundamentals analysis
The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices are rules-based indices that incorporate a share
selection mechanism based on combining earnings yield and return on capital employed to
identify undervalued stocks with profit potential.
A methodical selection approach based on earnings yield and return on capital employed
requires the discipline to be applied consistently and the patience to keep applying the
methodology even during periods of underperformance. Further, investors may not always
have access to high quality information on companies, which may be using different
accounting approaches and conventions. The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices address
these issues in the following ways:
Automated application of the two-factor formula on a quarterly basis, thereby making • easier to follow the methodology without emotional reactions
Company data is systematically extracted, collected and evaluated by Gotham Capital • International’s specialised team
Unique expertise in understanding the intricacies of the two-factor formula by having it • implemented by its author
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
60%
40%
20%
0%
-20%
-40%
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.Gotham US Enhanced Value Index
S&P 500® Total Return Index
Annualised performances
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
World Government Bond Index
S&P 500® Total Return Index
Gotham US Enhanced Value Index
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
Risk (as measured by volatility)
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
Retu
rn
Simulated annualised historical risk returns (monthly data)
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 7
Methodology and development in detail
The screening process of the Indices is independently carried out by Gotham Capital
International and involves the application of selection criteria and a ranking methodology
combining earnings yield and return on capital employed.
The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices aim to represent an investment in liquid shares, rebalanced
quarterly, that exhibit a high earnings yield and a high return on capital employed. The selection
criteria ensure that shares eligible for inclusion exhibit adequate liquidity and average daily value
traded requirements, as well as have sufficient data available for scrutiny to apply the ratios. All
business and industry sectors are eligible except for financials, real estate, insurance and utilities in
relation to US companies. For non-US companies, Gotham Capital International review on a country
by country basis whether the two-factor fundamentals ranking methodology is applicable.
Shares that meet the criteria are ranked according to their earnings yield and by their return
on capital employed, the two pillars of the Formula.
Firstly, shares are assigned a ranking according to their earnings yield. The share of the
company with the highest earnings yield will be given the top ranking of “1”. Shares of the
second most attractively valued company will be given a ranking of “2” and so on.
Secondly, shares are assigned a ranking according to return on capital employed. The share of the
company with the highest return on invested capital will be ranked “1”, the share of the company
with the second most attractively valued company will be given a rank of “2” and so on.
Finally, the two rankings for each share will be added together and a final, combined rank will be
assigned so that the share of the company with the lowest combined score will have a combined
score of “1”, the share of the company with the second-lowest combined score will have a rank of
“2” and so on. The combined rank reflects the principle that the two-factor Formula isn’t looking
for the company that ranks best on return on capital or the one with the highest earnings yield,
but rather for the company that has the best combination of those two factors.
Share selection process
Liquidity screen & removal
of excluded sectors
Eligible companies
Removal of companies by Gotham with
incomplete financial information or aged
data, material pending corporate events and
additional analyst accounting adjustments
Final Combined Ranking
Return on Capital Employed RankingEarnings Yield Ranking
8 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Sector composition
Gotham US Enhanced Value Index
The Gotham US Enhanced Value Index is a total return index designed to reflect the
performance of shares screened by applying the two-factor Formula of earnings yield and
return on capital employed to companies in the United States excluding financials, real estate,
insurance and utilities. Only ordinary shares are eligible for inclusion in the index. The top 25
shares according to the combined scores are selected for inclusion in the index.
The index includes a maximum of 25 shares and is rebalanced quarterly.
The Index is calculated in USD•
The Bloomberg Code is GEVIUSA Index•
Rebalancing of shares occurs quarterly in March, June, September and December of • each year
All shares shall initially and on each rebalancing date be equally weighted.
The largest member shares of the Index
Companies Bloomberg Ticker Sector Market Capitalisation
Accenture plc ACN UN Equity Software & Services USD 30,579 million
Raytheon Co RTN UN Equity Capital Goods USD 20,203 million
Viacom Inc B (New) VIA/B UN Equity Media USD 18,358 million
Reynolds American Inc RAI UN Equity Food Beverage & Tobacco USD 15,638 million
Lorillard Inc LO UN Equity Food Beverage & Tobacco USD 12,949 million
McGraw-Hill Cos Inc MHP UN Equity Media USD 10,571 million
Forest Laboratories FRX UN Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 9,798 million
Apollo Group Inc APOL UQ Equity Consumer Services USD 9,448 million
Fluor Corp FLR UN Equity Capital Goods USD 8,158 million
CF Industries Holdings CF UN Equity Materials USD 4,531 million
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Capital Goods 20.27%
Consumer Services 8.23%
Energy 4.35%
Food Beverage & Tobacco 11.80%
Health Care Equipment & Services 4.00%
Materials 4.03%
Media 7.48%
Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology 15.62%
Retailing 11.88%
Software & Services 11.46%
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 9
Comparison of the Gotham US Enhanced Value Index vs
Well Known Value Investors
The initial financial selection criteria
require that shares must have:
A market capitalisation of
USD 1,000,000,000 or be among
the top 1,000 shares with the
largest market capitalization in
the US market universe
For continued inclusion in the
Index (but not for initial inclusion),
the shares must be issued
by a company with a market
capitalisation that is greater than
USD 700,000,000 (or the equivalent
amount in another currency).
A minimum aggregate daily
value traded of USD 250,000,000
registered over each of the previous
3 trailing months, or be among the
top 1,000 most liquid shares in the
US market universe as determined
by this same measure
Industry concentration limits
are applied for diversification
Selection criteria
Performance statistics (monthly data)
Gotham US
Enhanced Value
Index
Berkshire
Hathaway
Inc.
World
Government
Bond Index
S&P 500®
Total Return
Index
Annualised return 20.0% -0.9% 5.9% 6.6%
Annualised risk* 23.3% 16.4% 19.3% 7.6%
Return/risk 85.9% -5.8% 30.4% 87.4%
Average 1-month return 1.8% 0.0% 0.6% 0.6%
1-month wins 61.7% 58.3% 55.0% 59.2%
Worst 1-month period -18.4% -16.8% -14.1% -5.0%
Average 12-month return 20.4% -0.9% 7.3% 7.5%
12-month wins 78.9% 54.1% 68.8% 84.4%
Worst 12-month period -44.5% -43.3% -43.9% -6.9%
* Risk as measured by volatility.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
800
600
400
200
0
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Dec 99 Dec 01 Dec 03 Dec 05 Dec 07 Dec 09
First Eagle Global-A
Gotham US Enhanced Value Index
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
10 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
30%
0%
-30%
-60%
An
nu
al P
erf
orm
an
ce
An
nu
al P
erf
orm
an
ce
Feb 04
Mar 04
Jan 04
Dec 03
Sep 03
Dec 09
Apr 04
Nov 09
May 07
Oct 03
Jun 07
Jun 04
May 04
Sep 07
Oct 06
Jul 07
Dec 06
Apr 06
Apr 07
Aug 07
Correlation graphs
Correlation during Equity Bull Markets (20 Best 12-month Rolling Periods)
Correlation during Equity Bear Markets (20 Worst 12-month Rolling Periods)
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
Standard and Poor’s calculates the Gotham Enhanced Value Index Series to introduce an
independent third party check and publication of Index values.
The historical simulated data has been initially provided by Gotham Capital International,
who have performed backtesting using point in time data that was available historically using
Standard and Poor’s Compustat data as a basis. The simulated historical performance uses
companies that would have been selected by Gotham according to combined scores in
Earnings Yield and Return on Capital Employed with data that would have been available on
the actual historical rebalancing dates, rather than more recent data. This approach has been
adopted deliberately in order to avoid survivorship bias and as well as bias resulting from
growth of smaller companies.
The historical simulation has also been verified by RBS and an independent third party
appointed by RBS.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Gotham US Enhanced Value Index S&P 500® Total Return Index
Feb 09
Jan 09
Nov 08
Mar 09
Dec 08
Oct 08
Apr 09
May 09
Sep 01
Jun 09
Oct 01
Mar 03
Aug 01
Jul 02
Jan 03
Feb 03
Dec 02
Sep 08
Mar 01
Sep 02
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 11
Gotham Global and International Enhanced Index
The Gotham Global Enhanced Index and the Gotham International Enhanced Index offer
investors the opportunity gain exposure to worldwide stocks using the Gotham Capital
International two factor Formula.
The Gotham Global Enhanced Value Index and the Gotham International Enhanced Value
Index are total return indices designed to reflect the performance of shares selected by taking
the highest ranked companies from Gotham’s proprietary financial statement database in
Gotham Capital International’s coverage universe. The rankings are made by combing scores
in Earnings Yield and Return on Capital employed. Gotham Capital International’s coverage
universe generally excludes sectors whose financial statements are presented in a manner
such that they do not provide a reliable indication as to their return on invested capital or their
earnings yield, such as in financial related sectors.
Only ordinary (or their equivalent) shares are eligible for inclusion in the Index, however,
American Depository Receipts or Global Depository Receipts may be used in the Index in
place of the primary listing for liquidity or trading cost reasons.
Each Index has two versions, a version solely for delta one wrappers and a version with higher
liquidity requirements, which can be used for delta one wrappers and wrappers containing
options. Both indices started on 1 January 2010.
Both the Gotham Global Enhanced Value Index and the Gotham International Enhanced Value
Index include a cost of 0.4% which is added to the price of shares from certain countries which
have high trading costs. In addition, a further cost of 2% will be added to the price of shares
from Brazil. These costs will be reflected by a reduction in the value of the Index proportionate
to these costs initially and/or on a rebalancing date when allocation to these countries is
increased or when such shares are introduced in the Index for the first time.
12 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Sector composition
Gotham Global Enhanced Value Index
The Gotham Global Enhanced Value Index includes shares from a selected universe of
securities in the Americas, Europe and Asia. The Index comprises 45 stocks, with 15 shares
from each region. In order to increase allocation to the best global opportunities, the top 10
companies with the highest combined ranking in Earnings Yield and Return on Capital have a
weight of 3% and the remaining shares have a weight of 2%. There are country concentration
limits on shares in the Index which have been designed to ensure diversification.
The Index includes a maximum of 45 shares and is rebalanced quarterly.
The Index is calculated in USD and in EUR•
The Bloomberg Codes are GEVIGU Index (USD) and GEVIGE Index (EUR)•
Rebalancing of shares occurs quarterly each year in September, December, March and June•
A version with enhanced liquidity is also available•
If there are less than 35 shares in the Index, the companies shall be equally weighted.
The largest member shares of the Index
Companies Bloomberg Ticker Sector Market Capitalisation
Astrazeneca plc AZN US Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 68,093 million
Nintendo Co Ltd 7974 JP Equity Software & Services USD 33,941 million
Takeda Pharmaceutical Co Ltd. 4502 JP Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 32,876 million
Raytheon Co. RTN US Equity Capital Goods USD 20,192 million
Viacom Inc VIA/B US Equity Media USD 18,216 million
Astellas Pharma 4503 JP Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 17,901 million
Reynolds American Inc RAI US Equity Food Beverage & Tobacco USD 15,638 million
Lorillard Inc LO US Equity Food Beverage & Tobacco USD 12,978 million
Telecomunicacoes de Sao Paulo SA TLPP4 BS Equity Telecommunication Services USD 12,121 million
Grupo Televisa, S.A.B TV US Equity Media USD 11,693 million
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Capital Goods 9%
Commercial & Professional Services 2%
Consumer Durables & Apparel 4%
Consumer Services 13%
Energy 2%
Food & Staples Retailing 2%
Food Beverage & Tobacco 7%
Materials 3%
Media 9%
Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology 18%
Real Estate 4%
Retailing 5%
Software & Services 16%
Technology Hardware & Equipment 2%
Telecommunication Services 4%
The initial financial selection criteria
require that shares must have:
A market capitalisation of
USD 2,000,000,000 (for US
companies) or USD 1,000,000,000
(or non-US companies)
For continued inclusion, liquidity and
market cap must not fall by more
than 25% from initial requirements
and full requirements must be met
every two quarters.
A minimum 3 month average daily
value traded of equal to or greater
than USD 3,000,000
Region and country caps are
applied for diversification
Industry concentration limits
are applied for diversification
Selection criteria
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 13
Sector composition
Gotham International Enhanced Value Index
The Gotham International Enhanced Value Index includes shares from the Americas (excluding
the United States), Europe and Asia. The Index comprises 45 stocks, with 20 shares from
Europe and Asia each and 5 from non-US Americas. Similar to the Gotham Global Enhanced
Value Index, this Index also increases allocations to the best global opportunities and the top
10 companies with the highest combined ranking in Earnings Yield and Return on Capital have
a weight of 3% and the remaining shares have a weight of 2%. There are country concentration
limits on shares in the Index which have been designed to ensure diversification.
The Index includes a maximum of 45 shares and is rebalanced quarterly.
The Index is calculated in USD and in EUR•
The Bloomberg Codes are GEVINU Index (USD) and GEVINE Index (EUR)•
Rebalancing of shares occurs quarterly each year in September, December, March and June•
A version with enhanced liquidity is also available•
If there are less than 35 shares in the Index, the companies shall be equally weighted.
The largest member shares of the Index
Companies Bloomberg Ticker Sector Market Capitalisation
China Mobile CHL US Equity Telecommunication Services USD 183,513 million
America Movil, S.A.B, de C.V. AMXL MM Equity Telecommunication Services USD 76,065 million
Astrazeneca plc AZN US Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 68,093 million
Nintendo Co Ltd 7974 JP Equity Software & Services USD 33,941 million
Takeda Pharmaceutical Co Ltd. 4502 JP Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 32,876 million
Alstom SA ALO FP Equity Capital Goods USD 20,569 million
Astellas Pharma 4503 JP Equity Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology USD 17,901 million
Compass Group plc CPG LN Equity Consumer Services USD 13,363 million
Telecomunicacoes de Sao Paulo SA TLPP4 BS Equity Telecommunication Services USD 12,121 million
Grupo Televisa, S.A.B TV US Equity Media USD 11,693 million
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International, 29 December 2009.
Capital Goods 12%
Commercial & Professional Services 2%
Consumer Durables & Apparel 7%
Consumer Services 14%
Energy 2%
Food & Staples Retailing 2%
Food Beverage & Tobacco 6%
Media 2%
Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology 15%
Real Estate 3%
Retailing 2%
Software & Services 14%
Technology Hardware & Equipment 5%
Telecommunication Services 14%
The initial financial selection criteria
require that shares must have:
A market capitalisation of
USD 1,000,000,000
For continued inclusion, liquidity and
market cap must not fall by more
than 25% from initial requirements
and full requirements must be met
every two quarters.
A minimum 3 month average daily
value traded of equal to or greater
than USD 3,000,000
Region and country caps are
applied for diversification
Industry concentration limits
are applied for diversification
Selection criteria
14 Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
Gotham Alpha US Strategy
The Gotham Alpha US Strategy (the “Strategy”) aims to reflect the excess return performance
difference between Gotham US Enhanced Value Index and the US 500 Strategy, thereby attempting
to generate returns in any market environment. By targeting the relative performance between
these two, the Strategy endeavours to minimise exposure to the market and achieve neutrality.
The Strategy has an automatic feature that aims to protect against some of the inherent volatility
exhibited by the stock market. The Strategy will be exposed to the performance of the Gotham
US Enhanced Value Strategy against the US 500 Strategy during periods of low volatility but
will be reduced proportionally in periods of higher volatility. In periods of higher market volatility
this feature may cushion the effect of market falls and constrain the benefit of market rises.
The Strategy has a volatility target of 12%•
The Strategy is calculated in USD•
The Bloomberg code is RBSAGVU1 Index•
The Strategy has a management fee of 0.75% per annum and an access cost of 1.0% p.a.•
The excess return strategy has a cost which can vary between 0.25% and 2.25% p.a., • which represents the interest rate component to make it excess return and the cost of
investing in the Gotham US Enhanced Value Index
Gotham Alpha US Strategy performance
Note: Data observed from 31 December 1999 to 31 December 2009. Past performance and simulated past
performance are not indicative of future performance.
Treatment of dividends within the Strategy
The Strategy is based on the excess return performance difference between the Gotham
US Enhanced Value Index and US 500 Index, neither of which include dividends or interest
rates.
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Source: RBS and Gotham Capital International.
Dec 00 Dec 01 Dec 02 Dec 03 Dec 04 Dec 05 Dec 06 Dec 07 Dec 08 Dec 09
S&P 500® Index
Gotham Alpha US Strategy
Gotham Enhanced Value Indices 15
Risk Stabilisation
For investors looking for additional
performance stability, a volatility
stabilisation overlay can be added to
their product. The volatility stabilisation
overlay evaluates the risk in the index
or strategy every day and then gives
varying exposure to the index or
strategy dependent on the risk. When
the index or strategy has exhibits less
risk, then the product will have more
exposure to the index or strategy. When
the index or strategy exhibits more risk,
the product will give less exposure to
the index or strategy.
Accessing the Gotham Enhanced
Value Indices
Investors can choose to access the
performance of the Gotham Enhanced
Value Indices via delta-one products
(such as Open Ended Certificates)
OTC Options and/or Swaps. Investors
requiring capital protection can achieve
this via CPN or CPPI structures.
Treatment of dividends
The Gotham Enhanced Value Indices
are total return, which means that
the indices shall reinvest dividends
distributed by constituent companies
as and when they occur and these shall
be reflected in the level of the relevant
index in proportion to the prevailing
level of constituent company exposure.
Additional information
Financial companies (including insurance and real estate)
Financial companies have several issues with their financial statement presentation that impact
the application of the two-factor Formula employed. Financial companies interest income and
interest expense impact EBIT. Additionally a company’s decision to invest assets in short/
long term instruments could impact the computation of Enterprise Value. Non-debt liabilities,
banks deposits and insurance unearned premiums as well as other non-debt liabilities can
significantly impact the calculation of Enterprise Value.
The balance sheet structure of financial companies and the treatment of interest on the
income statement makes the calculation of return on invested capital, EBIT, and Enterprise
Value subject to significant variability, distortion and interpretation.
Real estate companies often employ significant amounts of leverage, have attributes similar to
financial companies, and in the United States many have a different corporate structure than
a traditional operating company.
Utilities
In the United States, utilities are generally regulated with the consequence that return on capital
employed is a guaranteed, regulated return to the equity holder, with a capital structure that
is set around that regulated return. For this reason, utilities do not have market rates of return
and are therefore not comparable with other business/industry sectors for the purposes of
applying the two-factor Formula to companies in the United States. For non-US countries, the
applicability of the two-factor Formula will be reviewed on a country by country basis.
Gotham Capital International’s contribution to evaluating company information
Some companies report and/or account for similar items in different ways, making some data
provided even by major data providers difficult to work with. Gotham Capital International has
developed techniques for addressing these difficulties through years of experience working
with these data sources and its own internal data. In the context of applying fundamental
analysis ratios like the ones employed in the two-factor Formula used in the Gotham Enhanced
Value Indices, it is vital to obtain reliable information as such data determines what companies
will be invested in.
Gotham Capital International provides a significant informational advantage to the Gotham
Enhanced Value Indices by providing a sophisticated data analysis and research function.
Gotham Capital International employs a team of dedicated accounting analysts who analyse
and examine company filings and announcements to make adjustments to the data where
necessary. The team is long-standing, with an extensive six month training process before
they can make adjustments to company filings. Gotham Capital International has created a
proprietary database that tracks and stores the adjustments made to any relevant company
filing. This is to attempt to ensure that financial statements are uniformly represented according
to Gotham Capital International’s internal specifications before being entered into the two-
factor Formula to ensure data consistency and comparability.
Types of adjustments made
Adjust the earnings number if a company makes consistent and ongoing restructuring provisions•
Adjust for minority interests•
Adjust the number of shares to account for employee registered shares, employee• registered shares are freely tradable but typically not included in a companies free float
The screened and adjusted data in the Gotham Capital International proprietary database
is used to apply the two-factor Formula to the shares eligible for inclusion in the Gotham
Enhanced Value Indices, with the purpose of ensuring that the ratios produce reliable,
comparable and consistent results across the company universe.
To find out more about Gotham Enhanced Value Indices,
Log on to www.rbs.com/indices or call +44 20 7678 7667
This document has been prepared by The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V. or one of its affiliates (“RBS”) for information and discussion purposes only and is aimed at informing its
readers of the main characteristics of the securities described herein, although it is not intended to specify all possible risks or characteristics of the same. It shall not be construed
as, and does not form part of an offer, nor invitation to offer, nor a solicitation or recommendation to enter into any transaction, nor is it an official or unofficial confirmation of terms.
This document does not replace the essential advice given by your advisors before entering into any derivative activity and does not constitute an offering document or prospectus
and is not intended to provide the sole basis for any evaluation of transactions in securities or financial interests mentioned herein. Potential investors are, therefore, urged to seek
adequate information, before investing in the securities, on the nature of these products and the risks to which they will be exposed. An offer or invitation to offer, solicitation or
recommendation to enter into any transaction will solely be made on the basis of an offering document or where applicable a prospectus which can be obtained free of charge from
RBS offices at 250 Bishopsgate, London, EC2M 4AA, United Kingdom. The purchase of securities involves certain risks including market risk, credit risk and liquidity risk. Investors
should ensure that they understand the nature of all these risks before making a decision to invest in the securities. Investors should carefully consider whether the securities
are suitable for them in light of their experience, objectives, financial position and other relevant circumstances. If in any doubt, investors should obtain relevant and specific
professional advice before making any investment decision. In structuring, issuing and selling the securities, RBS is not acting in any form of fiduciary or advisory capacity. No
representation, warranty or assurance of any kind, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained herein. RBS accepts no obligation
to any recipient to update or correct any such information. No act or omission of RBS or any of its directors, officers, employees or agents in relation to the information contained
herein shall constitute, or be deemed to constitute, a representation, warranty or undertaking of or by RBS or any such person. Any indicative prices or analysis provided herein
have been prepared on assumptions and parameters that reflect our good faith judgement or selection and, therefore, no guarantee is given as to the accuracy, completeness
or reasonableness of any such quotations or analyses. Any person who subsequently acquires securities or other financial interests mentioned herein must only rely on the terms
of the definitive offering document or, where applicable, prospectus to be issued in connection herewith, on the basis of which alone subscriptions for securities or other financial
interests may be made. Without prejudice to the legal responsibility on information, RBS does not accept any kind of liability for any cost, loss or claim arising from or related to
the investment on the securities described herein. RBS and/or their affiliates, connected companies, employees or clients may have an interest in financial instruments of the type
described in this document and/or related financial instruments. Such interest may include dealing, trading, holding, acting as market-makers in such instruments and may include
providing banking, credit and other financial services to any company or issuer of securities or financial instruments referred to herein. RBS is not acting as a financial adviser or in
a fiduciary capacity in respect of any transaction or the securities or other obligations referred to herein. RBS makes no representation and gives no advice in respect of any tax,
legal or accounting matters in any applicable jurisdiction. This document is not intended for distribution to, or use by any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such
distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation. The information contained herein is proprietary to RBS and is provided upon request to selected recipients and may
not be given (in whole or in part) or otherwise distributed to any other third party without the written permission of RBS.
The contents of this document have not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in the countries in which this document is distributed. If you are in any doubt about any contents
of this document, you should obtain independent professional advice.
United States of America: This document is intended for distribution only to “major institutional investors” as defined in Rule 15a-6 under the U.S. Exchange Act of 1934 as amended
(the “Exchange Act”), and may not be furnished to any other person in the United States. Each U.S. major institutional investor that receives these materials by its acceptance hereof
represents and agrees that it shall not distribute or provide these materials to any other person. Any U.S. recipient of these materials that wishes further information regarding, or
to effect any transaction in, any of the securities discussed in this document, should contact and place orders solely through a registered representative of RBS Securities Inc.,
600 Washington Boulevard, Stamford, CT, USA. Telephone: +1 203 897 2700. RBS Securities Inc. is an affiliated broker-dealer registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission under the Exchange Act, and a member of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
Further, please be advised that the securities referred to herein have not been and will not be registered under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”)
and may not be offered or sold in the United States except to qualified institutional buyers (“QIBs”) in reliance on Rule 144A or another exemption from, or transactions not subject
to, the registration requirements of the Securities Act. The offer or sale of Securities or the transactions contemplated herein may be further restricted by U.S. federal and state
securities law. Potential investors are required to inform themselves of and to observe any legal restrictions on their involvement in the transactions. Please be advised that the
Securities may not be appropriate or suitable for all investors.
Gotham Capital International and its affiliates do not sponsor, endorse, sell, or promote any investment fund or other vehicle that is offered by third parties and that seeks to provide
an investment return based on the returns of the Gotham Enhanced Value Index, the Gotham Global Enhanced Value Strategy, the Gotham International Enhanced Value Strategy
and the Gotham Alpha US Strategy.
Standard & Poor’s does not sponsor, endorse, sell, or promote any investment fund or other vehicle that is offered by third parties and that seeks to provide an investment return
based on the returns of the Gotham UU Enhanced Value Index, the Gotham Global Enhanced Index, the Gotham International Enhanced Index or the Gotham Alpha US Strategy.
The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V. is authorised by De Nederlandsche Bank and subject to limited regulation by the Financial Services Authority. Details of our regulation by the
Financial Services Authority are available from us on request.
© The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V.. All rights, save as expressly granted, are reserved. Reproduction in any form of any part of the contents of this brochure without our prior written
consent is prohibited unless for personal use only.
The brochure contains numerous trade marks belonging to The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc and other companies in the RBS Group. These trade marks include, but are not
limited to, The Royal Bank of Scotland logo, The Royal Bank of Scotland and RBS. If you are in doubt as to whether an item is a trade mark of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc
or a member of the RBS Group, please contact us for clarification at the registered office address of The Royal Bank of Scotland plc, Registered in Scotland No 90312. Registered
Office: 36 St Andrew Square, Edinburgh EH2 2YB.
The Royal Bank of Scotland plc is an authorised agent of The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V. in certain jurisdictions.