Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov...
Transcript of Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov...
![Page 1: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology
V.A. Rubakov
Institute for Nuclear Research, Moscow
![Page 2: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
COSMOLOGY
Consistent picture of present and early Universe
But to large extent orthogonal to existing knowledgein particle physics
Major problems with the Standard Model:
Dark Matter and Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe
Dark matter:
“Seen” in galxies, galaxy clusters
Has strong effect on Cosmic Microwave Backgroundanisotropies
Bottom line
ρDM = (0.2−0.25) ·ρtotal
![Page 3: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Dark matter absolutely crucialfor structure formation
CMB anisotropies: baryon density perturbations at recombination,T = 3000 K
δB ≡(
δρB
ρB
)
rec'
(
δTT
)
CMB= (a few) ·10−5
Matter perturbations grow asδρρ (t) ∝ T−1
Perturbations in baryonic matter grow after recombination only.If not for dark matter,
(
δρρ
)
today= 1100× (a few) ·10−5 = (a few) ·10−2
No galaxies, no stars...
Perturbations in dark matter start to grow much earlier
![Page 4: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Growth of perturbations (linear regime)
tΛtrecteq t
Φ
δB
δDM
δγ
Radiation domination Matter domination Λ domination
![Page 5: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Baryon asymmetry of the Universe
There is matter and no antimatter in the present Universe.
Baryon-to-photon ratio, almost constant in time:
ηB ≡ nB
nγ= 6 ·10−10
What’s the problem?
Early Universe (T > 1012 K = 100 MeV):creation and annihilation of quark-antiquark pairs ⇒
nq,nq ≈ nγ
Hencenq −nq
nq +nq∼ 10−9
How was this excess generated in the course of the cosmologicalevolution?
Sakharov’67, Kuzmin’70
![Page 6: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
109 K 1 — 300 snucleosynthesis
3000 K CMB 300 thousand years
2.7 К Today 14 billion years
Inflation
Generaion ofdark matter
Generation ofmatter-antimatterasymmetry
![Page 7: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Best guess for dark matter: WIMP
New neutral stable (on cosmological scale) heavy particle
Does not exist in the Standard Model
Stability: new conserved quantum number⇐⇒ new symmetry
Pair produced in early Universe at T ' M, pair-annihilate atT < M, freeze out at T ∼ M/30
Calculable in terms of mass (log dependence) andannihilation cross section (1/σ dependence)
To have right present abundance:
Mass range: (10−1000) GeV
Strength of interactions ' weak force:
annihilation cross section = (1÷2) ·10−36 cm2
Just in LHC range
![Page 8: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Life may not be that simple
Clouds over CDM
Numerical simulations of structure formation with CDM show
Too many dwarf galaxies
A few hundred satellites of a galaxy like ours —
Much less observed so far
Kauffmann et.al.’93; Klypin et.al.’99;
Moore et.al.’99;...; Madau et.al.’08
Too low angular momenta of spiral galaxies
Too high density in galactic centers (“cusps”)
Not crisis yet
But what if one really needs to suppress small structures?
High initial velocities of DM particles =⇒ Warm dark matter
![Page 9: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Free streaming
At time t free streaming length
l f s(t) ∼ v(t) · t , v =pm
At radiation-matter equality (beginning of rapid growth ofperturbations),
l f s(teq) ∼pT
Teqteq
m
Perturbations at smaller scales are suppressed.
pT ' 3 (if relativistic thremal-like distribution at decoupling)
zeq ' 3000, Teq ' 1 eV, teq ' 60 kyr ' 20 kpc =⇒
Suppression of objects of mass
M . ρDM · 43πl3
0 ∼ 109M ·(
1 keV
m
)3
Cf. dwarf galaxies, Mdwar f ∼ 108 ÷109M.
![Page 10: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Power spectrum of perturbations
1 keV
5 keV
10 keV
15 keV20 keV30 keV
CDM
10 1005020 2003015 1507010-5
10-4
0.001
0.01
0.1
11071081091010
k, h Mpc
P k,HhM
pcL3
M, M
Assuming thermal primordial distributionnormalized to ΩDM ' 0.2.
![Page 11: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Warm dark matter: additional argument
Tremaine, Gunn
Hogan, Dalcanton;
Boyanovsky et.al., ...
Initial phase space density of dark matter particles: f (~p),independent of ~x.
Fermions:
f (~p) ≤ 1(2π)3 by Pauli principle
Not more than one particle in quantum unit of phase space
volume ∆~x∆~p = (2π h)3.
NB: Thermal distribution: fmax = 12(2π)3
Expect maximum initial phase space density somewhat
below (2π)−3
![Page 12: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Non-dissipative motion of particles, gravitatonal interactionsonly: particles tend to penetrate into empty parts of phasespace =⇒ coarse grained distribution decreases in time;maximum phase space density also decreases in time.
But not by many orders of magnitude
initial phase space density
present phase space density=
ff0
= ∆
with
∆ ' 10÷1000
![Page 13: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Observable:
Q(~x) =ρDM(~x)
〈v2||〉3/2
ρDM(~x)⇐⇒ gravitational potential
〈v2||〉⇐⇒ velocities of stars along line of sight.
Assume dark matter particles have same velocities as stars(e.g., virialized)
Q 'm4 n(~x)
〈 13 p2〉3/2 ' 33/2m4 f0(~x,~p)
Estimator of primordial phase space density:
f ' ∆Q
33/2m4
![Page 14: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Largest observed: dwarf galaxies
Qmax =(
3 ·10−3 ÷2 ·10−2) M/pc3
km/s
With M ' 1 ·1063 keV, 1 pc= 1.5 ·1026 keV−1, km/s= 3 ·10−6
Qmax = 0.2 keV4
' 33/2∆−1 ·m4 fmax ' 33/2∆−1 ·m4 #(2π)3
If maximum observed Q indeed estimates the largest phase spacedensity of DM particles in the present Universe, then
m ∼ (1÷10) ·keV
![Page 15: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Gravitinos as WDM candidatesGorbunov, Khmelnitsky, VR’ 08
Mass m3/2 ' F/MPl√F = SUSY breaking scale.
=⇒ Gravitinos light for low SUSY breaking scale.E.g. gauge mediation
Light gravitino = LSP =⇒ Stable
Decay width of superpartners into gravitino + SM particles
ΓS 'M5
S
F2 =M5
S
6m23/2M2
Pl
MS = mass of superpartner S
Heavy superpartners =⇒ gravitinos overproduced in theUniverse
Need light superpartners
![Page 16: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Superpartner mass range
![Page 17: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
To summarize:
Gravitinos are still warm dark matter candidates
Possible only if superpartners are light,
M . 300 GeV
Will soon be ruled out (or confirmed) by LHC
![Page 18: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Competitor: strile neutrino
Gorbunov, Khmelnitsky, VR’ 08
Simplest production mechanism: via active-sterile mixing.
Dodelson, Widrow; Dolgov, Hansen; Asaka et.al.
Almost thermal primordial spectrum normalized to ΩDM ' 0.2
f (p) =gνs
(2π)3β
ep/Tν +1
Ων = ΩDM =⇒
β = 10−2(
1 keV
m
)
∝ sin2 2θ
![Page 19: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Phase space bound:
Also: Boyarsky et. al.
m4 fmax > # ·Qmax =⇒
m > 5.7 keV =⇒ sin2 2θ = (a few) ·10−9
Similar to, and independent from Ly-α bounds.
Ly-α: Abazajan; Seljak et.al.; Viel et.al.
m > 10÷28 keV
Tension with X-ray limits:
νs → νγ in cosmos
m < 4 keV
Boyarsky et. al.; Riemen-Sorensen et.al., Watson et.al.; Abazajan et.al.
X-ray astronomy: way to discover sterile neutrinos, if they are darkmatter particles
![Page 20: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Baryon asymmetry: Sakharov conditions
To generate baryon asymmetry, three necessary conditions shouldbe met at the same cosmological epoch:
B-violation
C- and CP-violation:microscopic physics discriminates betweenmatter and antimatter
Thermal inequilibrium
![Page 21: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Conservation laws in the Standard Model
Energy, momentum
Baryon number (Nq −Nq)
proton is stable, τp > 1033 years!
Lepton numbersLe = (Ne− +Nνe)− (Ne+ +Nνe)Lµ , Lτ
Muon decay
µ
νµ
e
νe µ /−→eγ , Br < 10−11
Matter-antimatter asymmetry cannot be explained within theStandard Model
![Page 22: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
BUT
Baryon number is violated in electroweak interactions.
Non-perturbative effect, requires large fluctuationsof W -and Z-boson fields
At zero temprature rate suppressed by tunneling exponent:
e− 16π2
g2W ∼ 10−165
High temperatures: large thermal fluctuations (“sphalerons”).
B-violation rapid as compared to cosmological expansion at hightemperatures, T & 100 GeV.
PROBLEM:
Universe expands slowly. Expansion time at T ∼ 100 GeV
H−1 ∼ 10−10 s
Too large to have deviations from thermal equilibrium?
![Page 23: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
The only chance: 1st order phase transition,highly inequilibrium process
Electroweak symmetry is broken in vacuo,restored at high temperatures
Transition may in principle be 1st order
1st order phase transition occurs from supercooled state viaspontaneous creation of bubbles of new (broken) phase in old(unbroken) phase.
Bubbles then expand at v ∼ 0.1c
Bubbles born microscopic, r ∼ 10−16 cm, grow to macroscopic size,
r ∼ 0.1H−1 ∼ mm, before their walls collide
Boiling Universe, strongly out of thermal equilibrium
![Page 24: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
φ = 0
φ 6= 0
![Page 25: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Does this really happen?
Not in Standard Model
Standard Model fully calculable
No phase transition at all; smooth crossover
Also: way too small CP-violation
What can make EW mechanism work?
Extra fields/particles
Should interact strongly with Higgs(es)
Should be present in plasma at T ∼ 100 GeV=⇒ not much heavier than 300 GeV
Plus extra source of CP-violation.Better in Higgs sector =⇒ Several Higgs fields
![Page 26: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
More generally, electroweak baryogenesis at T ∼ 100 GeV requires
complex dynamics in electroweak symmetry breaking sector
at E ∼ (a few) ·100 GeV , LHC range
Is EW the only appealing scenario?
By no means!
— Leptogenesis
![Page 27: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Key: neutrino oscillations
The first phenomenonbeyond the Standard Model
ντ
νµ
νe
νµ , ντ
Super–K
Accelerator νµ : K2K
Homestake
Kamiokande, Super-K
SAGE
GALLEX/GNO
SNO
Reactor νe: KamLAND
Lepton numbers are not conservedIn principle, this is sufficient to generate baryon asymmetry.
![Page 28: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Scenario:
Generation of lepton asymmetry due to new interactions at
temperatures 108 – 1010 GeV⇓
reprocessing of lepton asymmetry into baryon asymmetry ininteractions of leptons and quarks at high temperatures
within the Standard Model.
Neutrino masses in right ballpark
Prospects
Neutrino masses ⇐⇒ role of neutrino in the Universe
CP-violation in neutrino sector ⇐⇒ asymmetry betweenmatter and antimatter
![Page 29: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
To conclude
Particle physics may well discover things crucial for our existence
Dark matterDynamics behind baryon asymmetry
Quite possibly not particular ones discussed here
May find something even more profound
Like extra dimensions/TeV-scale gravity
Quite possibly something else
And in any case the landscape of physics,cosmology included, will change in near future
![Page 30: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
![Page 31: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Warning: supersymmetric models are already constrainedexperimentally
mSUGRA
From Giudice, Rattazzi’ 06
![Page 32: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
mSUGRA at fairly low tanβ
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 10000
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 10000
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
mh = 114 GeV
m0
(GeV
)
m1/2 (GeV)
tan β = 10 , µ > 0
![Page 33: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Larger tanβ is better
100 1000 2000 30000
1000
1500
100 1000 2000 30000
1000
1500
mh = 114 GeV
m0
(GeV
)
m1/2 (GeV)
tan β = 50 , µ > 0
![Page 34: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Bullet cluster 1E0657-558
![Page 35: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
But cosmology may be telling us
something different — and unpleasant
Both particle physics and Universe appear heavily fine tuned
Friendly fine-tunings
Dark energy density ∼ (10−3 eV)4
Just right for galaxies to get formed
Primordial density perturbationsδρρ ∼ 10−5
Just right to form starsbut not supermassive galaxies w/o planets
Dark matter sufficient to produce structure
Also
Light quark masses and αEMJust right for mn > mp
but stable nuclei
Many more...
Is the electroweak scale a friendly fine-tuning?
![Page 36: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Anthropic principle/environmentalism
“Our location in the Universeis neccessarily priviledged tothe extent of being compatiblewith our existence as observers”
Brandon Carter’1974 Fig
Recent support from “string landscape”
We exist where couplings/masses are right
Problem: never know which parameters are environmental andwhich derive from underlying physics
Disappointing, but may be true
May gain support from LHC, if not enough new physics to solvethe gauge hierarchy problem
![Page 37: Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology · Particle Physics: Hints from Cosmology V.A.Rubakov InstituteforNuclearResearch,Moscow. COSMOLOGY Consistent picture of present and early](https://reader035.fdocuments.in/reader035/viewer/2022062604/5f907e4be901d02e52503363/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)