part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino...

40
part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos Neutrino Physics Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos

Transcript of part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino...

Page 1: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos

part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos

1

Neutrino Physics

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos

Page 2: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 2

• im Standardmodell: ν sind masselos

• Massengrenzen aus Zerfallskinematik: – M(νe) < 2 eV/c2 (Tritium Endpunkt)

– M(νμ) < 0.19 MeV/c2

– M(ντ) < 18.2 MeV/c2

Eigenschaften der Neutrinos

• Massengrenzen aus Kosmologie (Strukturbildung): – ΣM(νe, νμ, ντ) < 0.2 eV/c2

• ν (ν) gehorchen nur der Schwachen Wechselwirkung (falls masselos); max. Paritätsverletzung: Helizität -1 (+1)

Page 3: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 3

• mögliche Konsequenzen von ν-Massen:

Eigenschaften der Neutrinos

– flavour-Eigenzustände νe νμ ντ können Mischung der Massen-Eigenzustände ν1 ν2 ν3 sein – –> Oszillationen zwischen flavour-Eigenzuständen

• ν könnten ihre eigenen Antiteilchen sein (Majorana Teilchen)

– ν könnten ein (kleines) magnetisches Moment haben –> wechselwirken auch elektromagnetisch?

Page 4: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 4

2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen:

3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen:

cij = cosθij

sij = sinθij

θatm ≅θ23

θsolar ≅θ12es gilt:

δ: CP verletzende Phase

n.b.: CP Verletzung wird immer mit s13 verknüpft!

z.B.: |νµ⟩ =−sinθ|ν1⟩+cosθ|ν2⟩

(L in km, E in GeV, m in eV)

Page 5: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 5

•Solare Neutrinos (Entstehen bei den Fusionsreaktionen in der Sonne), ca 2 x 1038 /s, Fluss auf der Erde ~ 7 x 1010 cm-2s-1 •Kosmische Hintergrundneutrinos Ausfrieren aus thermischen Gleichgewicht ~ 1s nach dem Urknall Temperatur ~ 1.9 K, <E> ~ 5 x 10-4 eV, ~ 330/cm3 •Kosmische Neutrinoquellen Supernova-Explosionen, Aktive Galaxien, GRBs... •Atmosphärische Neutrinos Entstehung in Luftschauern kosmischer Strahlung •Geo-Neutrinos Radioaktiver Zerfall in der Erde, Gesamt-Leistung ~ 20 TW, Fluss ~ 107 cm-2s-1 •Von Menschen erzeugte Neutrinos Reaktor-Neutrinos (MeV-Bereich), ca 1020 /s; Beschleuniger (MeV -> GeV),

Neutrino-Quellen:

Page 6: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 6

Sensitivität verschiedener Oszillationsexperimente

Page 7: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 7

Φν =2Lsun25MeV

14π (1AU)2

= 7 ⋅1010 sec−1 cm−2

Energieerzeugung  in  der  Sonne

Page 8: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 8

billion

Page 9: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 9

+12.8 MeV +0.86 MeV

+18.8 MeV

Das solare Standardmodell: Proton-Proton-Kette

Page 10: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 10

der CNO Kreislauf (Bethe-Weiszäcker)

• CNO dominiert in schweren Sternen • Sonne: ca. 1.7% des 4He durch CNO, sonst p-p.

Page 11: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 11

Solar Neutrino Spectrum (prediction)

Page 12: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 12

Solar Neutrino Spectrum (prediction)

Page 13: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 13

Die Sonne „gesehen“ mit Neutrinos (SuperK)

Page 14: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 14

langjährige Messungen: wir sehen signifikant zu wenige Neutrinos von der Sonne!

Experimente messen i.w. 8B Neutrinos

Quelle: Serenelli, Neutrino 2012, Kyoto

Page 15: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 15

(SNO)(1999-2006, near Ontario, Canada)

Page 16: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 16

SNO misst Elektron-Neutrino-Raten (cc) und Summe aller Neutrinos (nc):

gesamter Neutrinofluss (nc) stimmt gut mit Erwartung aus solarem Standardmodell (SSM) überein, aber nur 1/3 kommt als

Elektron-Neutrino an ––> Oszillationen! Nobel Prize 2015

Page 17: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos

• Kann man Neutrino Oszillationen mit man-made Neutrinos sehen?

• schwierig für kleine Δm2

• Um LMA zu testen, braucht man L~100km, 1kt

• niedrige Eν, hohe Φν

• Reaktor: n -> p e– νe• Nachweis: νe p –> n e+

• e+ : e+ e– –> 2γ; n Einfang17

Psurv = 1− sin2 2θ sin2 1.27Δm2c4

eV2GeVEν

Lkm

%

& '

(

) *

1kt

KamLAND

Terrestrische “Solare Neutrinos”:Neutrinos von Kernreaktoren

n→ p e– ν e

Page 18: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 18

Kamland ist umgeben von vielen Hochleistungsreaktoren (L ~180 km)

Page 19: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 19

Energiespektren

gemessenes Spektrum

; ~2% theor. b

ekan

nt; <

1%

berechnetes

Reaktorspektrum;

~5% ??

Page 20: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 20

≈Proper time τ

L0=180 km

KamLANDReaktor Neutrinos oszillieren!

Page 21: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 21

Zusammenfassung aller Oszillations-Messungen (farbige Fächen) und Ausschlussmessungen (Linien): [Annahme: 2-ν-mixing]

Page 22: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 22

Kombination aller solaren Neutrino Daten mit KamLAND Reaktor Daten:

Δm2 = 8.0−0.4+0.6 ×10−5eV 2

θ = 33.9−2.2+2.4 deg

Page 23: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 23

θ13 ?

Page 24: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 24

• target: 5 t flüssig-Szintillator, dotiert mit Gadolinium • containment region: 17 t Szintillator (undotiert) • veto region: 80 t Szintillator (undotiert)

Chooz

sin2θ13 < 0.17 (θ13 < 24°) bei Δm132 = 2.5 10-3 eV2

Page 25: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 25

Double-Chooz (

Page 26: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 26

Double-Chooz

• 10 t Flüssigszintillator (Gadolinium-dotiert)

• 500 Photomultiplier

• Untersuchung von sin2θ13 im Bereich ~ 0.03 bis 0.20

• Sensitivität: 0.03 nach 3 Jahren Betrieb

Messung: - inverser β-Zerfall νe p → n e+ - e+ e- Vernichtung → 2γ - n-Einfang Gadolinium → γ (30 ms)

Page 27: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 27

Page 28: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 28

Double-Chooz

after ~3 years with both detectors: Δsin2θ13 ~ 0.03

Page 29: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 29

sin2(2θ13)=(0.09±0.03)

Double-Chooz (2013; far detector)

(χ2/n.d.f. = 51.4/40)

Rate+Shape results

Page 30: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 30

Daya Bay

Page 31: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 31

Daya Bay

mono-energetische ν

Daya Bay E-Verteilung

• Sensitivität: bis 0.01 in sin2θ13

Page 32: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 32

Folien von: Chao Zhang (Brookhaven), Neutrino 2014 Boston

Daya Bay Antineutrino Detector

Page 33: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 33

Page 34: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 34

Page 35: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 35

Far vs Near Comparison (2012)

sin2 2θ13 = 0.092 ± 0.016(stat) ± 0.005(syst)

arXiv:1203.1669 [hep-ex]

Page 36: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 36

Page 37: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 37

Page 38: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 38

• sin2(2θ13) = 0.093±0.008.[20] PDG combination of Daya Bay, RENO, and Chooz results.

• sin2(2θ12) = 0.846+0.021−0.021.[20] corresponds to θsol (solar), from KamLand, solar, reactor and accelator data.

• sin2(2θ23) > 0.92 at 90% confidence level, corresponding to θ23 ≡ θatm = 45±7.1° (atmospheric)[21]

• Δm221 ≡ Δm2sol = 7.53+0.18−0.18×10−5 eV2[20]

• |Δm231| ≈ |Δm232| ≡ Δm2atm = 2.44+0.06−0.06×10−3 eV2 (normal mass hierarchy)[20]

3-Neutrino global fit (PDG 2014):

Page 39: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 39

weitere offene Fragen:

- Majorana oder Dirac Neutrinos? - Massen-Hierarchie? - CP-Verletzung im Neutrino-Sektor

Zusammenfassung:

- Neutrino-Oszillationen erklären solares Neutrino-Defizit! – Neutrinos haben Masse! - Reaktorneutrinos bestätigen Oszillation der atmosph. und solaren Neutrinos - sin2 2θ13 = 0.093±0.008 > 0 (-> CP Verletzung messbar)

Page 40: part II: Solar- and Reactor-Neutrinos€¦ · 2-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: 3-Flavour Neutrino Oszillationen: € c ij = cosθ ij € s ij = sinθ ij € θ atm ≅θ 23 € es

Particle physics with cosmic and with terrestrial accelerators TUM SS17 S.Bethke, F. Simon V07: Solar and Reactor Neutrinos 40

Literatur:

• B. Kayser, „Neutrino Mass, Mixing, and Flavor Change“: arXiv:0804.1497 [hep-ph]

• Th. Schwetz et al., „Three-flavour neutrino oscillation update“; arXiv:0808.2016v2

• newest results from London Neutrino Conference 2016: http://neutrino2016.iopconfs.org/programme

• K. Nakaruma, S. Petcov „Neutrino Mass, Mixing, and Oscillations“: auf: pdg.lbl.gov

• G.L. Fogli et al., „Global analysis of neutrino masses, mixings and phases”; arXiv:1205.5254, Phys.Rev: D86, 013012.