Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied...

43
29 June 2011 LIBER 40th Annual Conference 1 Ellen Simons Learning and Innovation Centre ‘Paradise by the dashboard light’ working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Sciences

description

Liber Conference, Barcelona, June 2012. In view of all the reorganisations and budget cuts we see everywhere; I would like to share our experiences in working with a simple PDCA cycle. I work at the Learning and Innovation Centre (LIC) of the Avans University of Applied Science in the Netherlands. Avans has opened three Xplora’s (Learning Centres) in 2006 and 2007. The traditional library has changed into a learning-centre and now resides under the LIC. Since 2005 a new organizational structure and new working-arrangements with faculty staff have been set up. The LIC has 85 fte staff divided over 7 teams. In 2009 we started with an experiment introducing a new and more effective way of reporting to our executive board. We designed a simple ‘dashboard’ on which at a glance one can see how the Learning and Innovation centre is doing on a quarterly basis from the perspective of the Balanced Score Card (financial, customer, internal and Innovative). Commissioned by the executive board in 2009 we also developed an activity-based budget model applied to each team. Thus we set up a PDCA cycle. We adopt KPI’s, not only for the LIC as a whole but also for each team. The aim was not only to deliver information to the executive board but also for ourselves to have more objective information about our own organization. We introduced the KPI and dashboard for all our teams. Our executive board only get’s a copy of the main dashboard which is composed of the dashboard from the different teams. We also introduced simple time schemes for our staff. With the information from these time schemes we can check if the time we planned to spend on activities in practice really was spent and also the progress being made each quarter. The PDCA-cycle we set up is not complicated and is easy to use. We are very pleased with what we have done because we now have more objective management information. Important to mention is that we developed this tool only for improving processes and not as a control instrument directed at staff! The Executive Board is pleased with the new way we submit the different necessary documents and the way we do our updates every quarter. Because we now have much more meaningful information about our performance we also are very content with it and because everything now is transparent, we can easily demonstrate how we invest Avans’ money and this makes the discussion with our board much easier.

Transcript of Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied...

Page 1: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference 1

Ellen SimonsLearning and Innovation Centre

‘Paradise by the dashboard light’

working with a simple PDCA cycle at

Avans University of Applied Sciences

Page 2: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

2

Avans University of Applied Sciences

• 3 locations• 24.000 students• 103 bachelor’s programs• 5 master’s programs• 22 research groups• 2.000 staff• 1 Learning and

Innovation CentreBreda Den Bosch

Tilburg

Page 3: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

Avans University of Applied Sciences

3

Executive board

19 Schools- Engineering & ICT- Business- Law- Health- Education- Social studies- Art

Learning & Innovation

Centre

4 Support Units- ICT & Facility management- Finance & Student administration- Human Resources- PR & Communication

Staff

Page 4: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

Organizational chart Learning and Innovation Centre

4

Management

Consultancy (13 fte)

Research & Evaluation (5 fte)

Quality management & Organizational development (6 fte)

Virtual Learning Support (9 fte)

Information Provision & Collection Management (27 fte)

Services & Support (11,5 fte)

Information Services (8 fte)

90 fte’s 120 staff working in

Breda, Den Bosch and Tilburg 

Page 5: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

5

Aim PDCA-cycle

• Streamlining

• Discipline

• Transparancy

Diagram by Karn G. Bulsuk (http://blog.bulsuk.com)

Page 6: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

6

Quality system

• Basic quality system (2009- )– Implement PDCA-cycle parallel to P&C-cyclus Avans–Perspectives of the Balanced Score Card required

• Institutional audit in 2013 –quality assurance systems of the support

departments critically examined

Page 7: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

7

Plan: Design or revise business process components to improve results

Page 8: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

8

Planning process Businessplan

Mission/goals Avans

Business-plan

LICPlans

Schools

Long-term policy

Avans

2011-2014

Hippo-

campus Avans

& ICT

Page 9: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

9

Business Plan 2011

Vision

Mission

Targets

Strategy

Business Plan 2011

Activity budget

Staff planning

2011-2014

+

Targets

Results

Page 10: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

10

From Business Plan to team activity Plans

Business-plan

2011

Team-activity plans

Formation

Training

Vision

Mission

Targets

Strategy

Page 11: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

11

Business Plan 2011

Vision

Mission

Targets

Strategy

Business Plan 2011

Staff planning

2011-2014

+

Targets

Results

Activity budget

Page 12: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

Old: regular budget 2010Example: team Information Services

12

Page 13: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

New: Activity budget 2010: team Information Services

13

Page 14: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

14

Do: Implement the plan and measure its performance

Page 15: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

15

Janssen, Paula

Timesheet June 2010Activities

Total hours

Page 16: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

New: Activity budget 2010: team Information Services

16

Page 17: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

17

Check: Assess the measurements and report the results to decision makers

Page 18: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

18

Accountability

Management LIC

Team-managers LIC

Staff LIC

Executive board Avans

Discussion

Page 19: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

19

Introducing the dashboard

• Overview of performance figures on a quarterly basis

• More effective way of reporting

• Accountability of– Meeting specified goals– Realization Business Plan

• Goals and results on the basis of agreed performance indicators

• General dashboard for executive board and internal dashboards per team

Page 20: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

20

Customerperspective

Innovative/learning

perspective

Financialperspective

Internal/Organizationperspective

Critical Success Factor

Critical Success Factor

Page 21: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

21

Dashboard: Customer perspective

• Goals and activities focussed on customers

• Xplora/Learning Centre:–Customer satisfaction Xplora–Total visitors

• Virtual Learning Environment ‘Blackboard’– Customer satisfaction–Total visitors Black Board 

Page 22: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

22

Dashboard: Customer perspective

Page 23: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

23

Dashboard: Financial Perspective

• Staff in fte’s –Permanent and temporary–Total available fte’s–Flexible part fte’s –Average staff costs 

• Regular operation cost–Staff costs–Total regular income–Total regular expenses–Achieved operating-balance –Projects

Page 24: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

24

Dashboard: Financial perspective

Page 25: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

25

Dashboard: Internal perspective

• Hours registered

• Percentage of hours spent

• Reduce absenteeism

• Employee satisfaction

Page 26: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

26

Dashboard: internal perspective: hours

Page 27: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

27

Dashboard: internal perspective: percentage

Page 28: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

28

Activities Learning and Innovation Centre

Innovation projects

Plus services

Training

General

Services

Business

Page 29: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

29

Dashboard: Innovative/learning perspective

• Goals and activities in Business plan focused on innovation

• Number of visited conferences

• Number of external presentations

Page 30: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

30

Dashboard: Innovative/learning perspective

Page 31: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

31

Act: Decide on changes needed to improve the process

Page 32: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

32

Plan: Design or revise business process components to improve results

Page 33: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

33

Near future 2011-2012

• Introduction of analysis and reflection according to the C of the PDCA-cycle

• Preparation institutional audit in 2013 –quality assurance systems of the support

departments critically examined

• Enhanced quality–Where do we want to excel? 

Page 34: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

3429 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

What users conclude

Page 35: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

35

drs. M.M.J. Kamsma MBA/MBI

Member executive board

Avans University of Applied Sciences

“ It's a iterative working routine

that is constantly improved, which

for me as a member of the board is

getting more convenient all the

time and allows me to understand

where the LIC stands and where

it is headed”.

Page 36: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

36

Henri Vossen

Concern Controller

Avans University of Applied Sciences

“It's trustworthy if an organization

as LIC governs her own processes

in enough detail to see things they

ought to see for their own sake,

and mature enough for me to give

understanding how things develop

in risk and control as

a whole”.

Page 37: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

37

Rien Brouwers

Director

Learning and Innovation Centre

“The situation changes

daily, so you've got

to keep

your finger

on the pulse”.

Page 38: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

38

Linda Brouwers

Teammanager

Learning and Innovation Centre

“The PDCA

gives me clarity

and

overview”.

Page 39: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

39

Sandra Brocx

Teammanager

Learning and Innovation Centre

"Working with the PCDA-

cycle provides insight,

information and guidance

about my team.

It promotes making

strategic choices”.

Page 40: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

40

Niek Van Hoof-Verhagen

Information specialist

Learning and Innovation Centre

Fear: “I didn't know I spend that

incredible amount of hours on

information skills workshops”.

Relief : “I spend much more time than I

thought on advising schools”.

Insight: “I really need to delegate

some activities, organize them

differently or even stop

some activities”.

Page 41: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

41

Ellen Simons

Deputy Director

Learning and Innovation Centre

“Necessary adjustments

to processes can now be

based on objective

information”.

Page 42: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

42

Recommendations

• Keep it simple

• Don’t use it as a top-down control instrument for staff

• Produce a factsheet with facts & figures!

We actively work on an

inspiring learning and working

environment in which

lecturers, students and other

professionals meet in

innovative learning processes.

As a unique combination of

teams of content experts and

high quality facilities:

1. We advise Avans University

on relevant developments.

2. We encourage and support

innovation in learning and

teaching.

3. We promote excellence in

learning and teaching.

4. We provide a powerful

learning and working

environment.

The Learning and I nnovation

Centre provides an integrated

learning environment: the

physical environment Xplora

combined with the virtual

environment of Blackboard

Learning and I nnovation Centre Factsheet 2010

I nnovate Supported innovation projects in 14

faculties

Supported 9 university-wide strategic

projects

Provided application support to 4

Associated Degree programs

Developed Master plan Virtualization

for 6 engineering faculties

Provided support to 6 faculties for

assessment improvement

I ntroduced principles of Cognitive Load

Theory in propaedeutic program of

school of management

Conducted 4K video project

Hosted 97 videoconference sessions

Recognized by the Dutch Knowledge

Centre for Prior Learning Assessment

and Recognition

Excell Hosted annual educational conference

and three theme sessions for university

faculty and staff

Hosted 35 study days for schools

Provided educational training for 267

lecturers

Provided 50 individual lecturer

consultations

Provided 484 information literacy

workshops

Hosted visits from domestic and

foreign guests

Presented at 52 national and

international conferences

Learn Hosted 1.4 million visitors in Xplora

Added 6,700 books, 660 subscriptions

and 40 databases to collection of

educational resources

158,000 resources borrowed

Provided 189 guided tours in Xplora

Provided 448 introductions to Xplora

Facilitated 3.3 million visitors, 10,000

courses, 9,650 digital portfolios and 1.4

million documents in Blackboard

Facilitated Online Languages Training

and MS- Offi ce training for faculties

Published dissertation by students from

13 schools in the national repository

Checked 18,000 papers for plagiarism

Advise Hosted 27 decision room sessions

Conducted 33 advisory processes on

quality assurance

Provided extensive support on the

accreditation process for 13 majors

Provided support for the development

and implementation of two new bachelor

programs

Conducted 13 preliminary accreditation

audits

Started preparation for the institutional

audit

Conducted 40 research projects

including the student satisfaction survey

Developed retention scan on school and

university level

Provided coordination on accreditation

processes and developed educational

guidelines

Attended 118 domestic and international

conferences

http: / / l i c .avans.n l

Mission and Goals

PO Box 90 .116, NL - 480 0 RA Breda,

You learn, we support

Page 43: Paradise by the dashboard light': working with a simple PDCA cycle at Avans University of Applied Science

Learning and Innovation Centre

29 June 2011LIBER 40th Annual Conference

Further Information:

Ellen SimonsE-mail: [email protected]

Slidesharehttp://www.slideshare.net/pmgsimon/

Facts and Figures Learning and Innovation Centre 2010

http://lic.avans.nl/index.php/en/over-het-lic/facts-and-figures