Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More...

44
Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt Paul Wade W1GHZ

Transcript of Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More...

Page 1: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Parabolic DishFocus, Zoom

and TiltPaul Wade

W1GHZ

Page 2: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

EME Prevention

• TREES – no window

Page 3: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Solution – new QTH

Page 4: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Clear View

Page 5: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Dish Pattern Simulation

• Ansoft HFSS• More detail than

measurement• No reflections• See affect of

focus, zoom, andtilt

15Dish,

Coffee-can feed

Page 6: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

BetterFeed

• More gain• Smaller

sidelobes• Same

beamwidth

15Dish,

Super-VE4MA feed

Page 7: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Dish Focus

Page 8: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

0.25Closer to Reflector

Page 9: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

0.5Closer to Reflector

Page 10: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

0.75Closer to Reflector

Page 11: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

1Closer to Reflector

Page 12: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

1.25Closer to Reflector

Page 13: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

1.5Closer to Reflector

Page 14: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

1.75Closer to Reflector

Page 15: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

2Closer to Reflector

Page 16: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

2.5Closer to Reflector

Page 17: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

3Closer to Reflector

Page 18: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Plot the gain vs focus shiftDish with Axial Feed Displacement

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3

Feed Aperture Position in Wavelengths from Dish Focal Point

Gai

n(d

Bi)

Super VE4MA

Coffee-can

Page 19: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Axial Defocusing Loss

Page 20: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Focus Summary

• As Feed moves toward reflector, patterngets wider, gain decreases (Conservationof Energy)

• Other direction similar• Focus is critical for deep dish

– ¼ error = ~1dB– For any diameter dish

Page 21: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

How to focus accurately

• Range > 50x Rayleigh Distance (Imbriale)– Not practical for EME dish

• Sun Noise• Celestial Sources (Larger dishes)

Page 22: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15
Page 23: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15
Page 24: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Practical Focus Error

• Normal antenna range ~= Rayleigh Distance• Focus at infinity = measured gain ~1 dB low• Focus on range = real gain ~ 1 dB low

– Feed will be too far from reflector

> Focus at 5x Rayleigh Distance = tiny error

Page 25: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Focus for BIG Dish

Page 26: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Offset Dish

18 inch DSS Dish,

W2IMU dual-mode feed

15.7 wavelengths

Page 27: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

BetterFeed

• More gain• Smaller

sidelobes• Same

beamwidth18 inch DSS Dish,Skobelev optimizeddual-mode feed

Page 28: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Feed 0.83closer to reflector

uptilt

Page 29: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Feed 1.66closer to reflector

uptilt

Page 30: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Feed 0.83away from reflector

downtilt

Page 31: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Offset Dish Focus Shift

• Axial feed shift tilts pattern– Closer tilts up– Away tilts down

• Maximum gain – only small decrease• Axial gain – decrease due to pattern tilt

Page 32: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Lateral Feed Shift

• Beam Scanning• Multiple feeds – several bands

• Lateral Feed shift causes beam shift inopposite direction

Page 33: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Lateral Feed Shift - Focus

• Shifted Focus follows Petzval Surface– Parabola with ½ radius of curvature– Tangent to focal plane at focus

• Shifted Focus farther away from reflector• Adjust for Maximum Gain

Page 34: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Shift - Maximum Gain Contour

Page 35: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Scanning Limit (1 dB Loss)

Page 36: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Feed-scanning Loss

Page 37: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Feed Pointing

StraightAheadBest

Page 38: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Zoom Control

• Move feed in or out to broaden pattern• Easier to find signals

• BUT• Maximum beamwidth increase ~3 times• Gain ~10 dB lower at 3X beamwidth• Gain never higher anywhere than focused• So zoom only finds strong signals• Small shift can fill in null around main beam

Page 39: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Alternative to Zoom

• Align bearing accurately– Beacon– Sun– Compass

• Know your pattern• Search by ½ beamwidth

– For 4 degree beam, move in 2 degree steps

Page 40: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Tilt

• A few degrees uptilt can enhanceterrestrial signals

• More for rain scatter• Offset zoom = tilt

– Bad idea – no intuitive reference for level

Page 41: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

RV tilt gauge good for dishes

Page 42: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

Summary• Accurate focus is important, especially for

deep dishes• Sun noise or celestial source needed for

accurate focus• Lateral shifted feed adjusted independently• Zoom has little benefit• Tilt is useful, best done mechanically• Location of dish is important• www.w1ghz.org

Page 43: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15

W1GHZ --> Vermont

Page 44: Parabolic Dish Focus, Zoom and Tilt - NTMS · Dish Pattern Simulation • Ansoft HFSS • More detail than measurement • No reflections • See affect of focus, zoom, and tilt 15