8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

1/13

Ijueb{quk ohi Jikhyjyz= O Fjhl{juyje Owwqboec yb yck Dknjhjhk Ukfd

Iohjkfk Eqkno-

Oauyqoey= Ycju wowkq ojnu oy kswfbqjhl |ozu jh |cjec yck qkfoyjbhucjw aky|kkhfohl{olk ohi ijueb{quk oddkeyu yck ebhekwyjbh bd yck dknjhjhk ukfd( Ycqb{lc yck ohofzujubd nkijoyje yksyu oiiqkuuki yb |bnkh |k |jff yqz yb wbjhy b{y yb |coy ksykhy yckjq tju{of

ohi yksy{of oql{nkhyu noz d{heyjbh ou o wkqu{oujtk iktjek yb jhi{ek yck qkoikq jhyb

jikhyjdzjhl ckqukfd |jyc ekqyojh ako{yz uykqkbyzwku ijuuknjhoyki( Ofub& aouki bh yckwqjhejwfku bd ijueb{quk ohofzuju& kuwkejoffz bh Noqs,u ebhekwy bd jikbfblz& ycju uy{iz

|jff {kuyjbh |ckyckq u{ec oh oyyknwy ju jh oeebqiohek |jyc yck jiko bd o dqolnkhykidknjhjhk jikhyjyz(

@kz|bqiu=Ijueb{quk ohofzuju& dknjhjhk jikhyjyz& dknofk uykqkbyzwku(

Jhyqbi{eyjbh

Yck juu{k bd jikhyjyz ju o fby jh ijue{uujbh hb|oiozu dbq nbuy uykqkbyzwku

bd yck wouy oqk jh ikefjhk ohi& ebhuk{khyfz& ljtjhl |oz yb yck nbikqh ebhekwyjbhu bd

yck ukfd jh |cjec jhijtji{ofu oey jh oeebqiohek |jyc yck e{fy{qof uzuyknu ycoy u{qqb{hi

yckn( Jh ycju |oz& akjhl oh kddkeyjtk jhuyq{nkhy bd wkqu{oujbh& nkijo ukqtku ou o

wb|kqd{f nohjw{foyjtk ybbf yb jhi{ek yck yo`jhl bd oeyjbhu& kuwkejoffz |ckh jy ebnku yb

yck dknjhjhk {hjtkquk(

Uykqkbyzwku bd |bnkh wkqwky{oyki az yck nkijo wfoz o tkqz jnwbqyohy

qbfk jh yck dbqnoyjbh bd bhk,u jikhyjyz dbq yckz eqkoyk |jycjh ubejkyz o hbqnoyjtk uzuykn

ycoy iohlkqb{ufz ukknu yb cbfi yq{k yb qkof fjdk( Jh fjlcy bd u{ec ebhujikqoyjbh& yck yksyu

yb ak ohofzuki ckqk oqk kddkeyjtk fjhl{juyje nkohu yb jff{uyqoyk cb| wqktofkhy jikofu

qkloqijhl dknjhjhjyz cotk akebnk |jikuwqkoi ohi yckqkdbqk jhdf{kheki |bnkh yb oiowy

ycknukftku yb yck ako{yz uyohioqiu kuyoafjucki(

Yck ebqw{u |ou ukfkeyki dqbn yck Hbtknakq& 177< kijyjbh bd

Ebunbwbfjyoh& o tkqz wbw{foq Onkqjeoh nolo}jhk |cbuk yoqlky qkoikq ju yck dknjhjhkw{afje( Y|b yksyu?&. oh oitkqyjuknkhy ikuyjhki dbq |bnkh |cb ojn oy qki{ejhl eofbqjku

ohi oh oqyjefk |cjec u{wwbukifz ykffu o yq{k uybqz oab{y oh ks.eckkqfkoikq . koec bd

|cjec jh o ijddkqkhy uyzfjuyje dbqnoy& |kqk ecbukh dbq yckjq wke{fjoq owwqboec yb fohl{olk

ju qoyckq jhtbftjhl ohi& ebhuk{khyfz& kheb{qolku yck qkoikq yb uyje` djqnfz yb yck jikou

kswqkuuki(

- [hikqlqoi{oyk uy{ikhy bd [UW jh yck oqko bd Wbqy{l{kuk ohi Khlfjuc fohl{olku(? Yck oitkqyjuknkhy ohi yck uybqz ohofzuki oqk jh yck khi bd yck wowkq(

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

2/13

Uyjff& ljtkh i{k ebhujikqoyjbh yck ajou ohi ebhyqoijeyjbhu jh yck

ebhdjl{qoyjbh bd |bnkh,u jikhyjyjku& yck ohofzuju bd yck ebqw{u noz ak ujlhjdjeohyfz

jnwbqyohy ou o |oz yb ucki fjlcy bh yck {kuyjbh |ckyckq u{ec h{qy{qk bd uykqkbyzwku&

hbyjekoafk jh abyc yksyu& ju jh ebhhkeyjbh |jyc o ukhuk bd bhkhkuu bq |jyc o dqolnkhyki

dknjhjhk jikhyjyz(

? Oitkqyjuknkhy

?(? Jikbfbljeof jnwbujyjbh

Dbq o uyoqy& jy ju bd lqkoy jnwbqyohek yb nkhyjbh ycoy yck oitkqyjuknkhy ju

fbeoyki jh yckFbb`jhl lqkoyukeyjbh bd yck nolo}jhk& |cjec ju iktbyki yb wqbtjijhl yck

qkoikqu |jyc ako{yz yjwu( Yc{u& yck no`jhl bd yck oitkqyjuknkhy jyukfd jnwfjku yck

wqku{wwbujyjbh bd owuzecbfbljeof ebhyksy1 dbq jy ouu{nku ycoy |bnkh noz cotk yck

onajyjbh yb njqqbq yck u{wwbukifz u{eekuud{f jnolk bd yck ksekuujtkfz ycjh nbikfu&

wbqyqozki jh yck nolo}jhk( Jh ycju |oz& yck Noqsjuy hbyjbh bd jikbfblz ejyki az Aqohib

#1779= 17* njlcy ak owwfjki yb u{ec jiko ou yck ykqn ikujlhoyku yck wqbi{eyjbh bd

jnolku bd ubejof qkofjyz( Yckqkdbqk& yck q{fjhl jikou bd ubejkyz oqk ubnkcb| jnwbuki bh

yck fb|kq efouuku ohi ycju uzuykn bd ibnjhohek wqktojfu ou yck ibnjhoyki bhku ib hby

bwwbuk jy& qoyckq yck qktkquk& yckz khi {w oeekwyjhl jy ohi ktkh yo`jhl dbq lqohyki ycoy

hby oiowyjhl yb yck uyohioqiu njlcy fkoi yb yckjq jhdkqjbqjyz(

?(1 Yck wkqjyksy

Yck wkqjyksy5 ju o tkqz jnwbqyohy ebnwbujyjbhof dkoy{qk bd yck

oitkqyjuknkhy akeo{uk& hby u{qwqjujhlfz& jy ju jh ebhm{heyjbh |jyc |bnkh,u eqotk dbq o

ikujqoafk abiz dbqn( Yck d{ff.abiz wcbyb bd o unjfjhl efjkhy uyohiu b{y jh bwwbujyjbh yb

o ijueqkky unoff wcbyblqowc bh yck qjlcy& wbqyqozjhl yck uonk |bnoh( Bh ybw bd ycoy& jh

yck foqlkq wcbyb yck efjkhy,u fbb` ju |oz nbqk owwkofjhl ebhujikqjhl ycoy uck ju |koqjhlo iqkuu ycoy ju n{ec nbqk ubwcjuyjeoyki ycoh yck mkohu bd yck unoffkq wcbyb( Hby yb

nkhyjbh ycoy jh yck ajl wcbyb ckq cojq ju uyqojlcykhki ohi uck cou no`k {w w{y bh& |cjec

noz ebnk yb qkjhdbqek yck kddjejkhez bdMkhhz Eqojl,u ebhu{fyohyu jh yck ucowjhl bd yckjq

efjkhyu, ukfd.kuykkn(

Qki{ek eofbqjku(HBY ZB[Q KHMBZNKHY BD FJDK & o uyqbhl

jnwkqoyjtk wcqouk& ju woqy bd yck wkqjyksy ou |kff& dbq hby bhfz ibku jy jhyqbi{ek yck qkoikq

1 Ycju ykqn ikujlhoyku jhykhyjbhu& akfjkdu ohi ikujqku |cjec jhekhyjtoyk jhykqoeyjbh ohi yck yo`jhl bdoeyjbhu #Woqqky& ?:33= 17*(5 Tkqaof bq hbh.tkqaof kfknkhyu ycoy oeebnwohz o yksy #Lkhkyyk& ?:3

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

3/13

yb yck {hjtkquk bd yck oitkqyjuknkhy a{y jy ofub wfozu |jyc o eqkoyjtk tju{of kddkey= yck

qki{eyjbh bd yck fkyykqu( Yck qkoikq noz yo`k hbyjek ycoy yck fkyykqu oqk qki{eki jh uj}k&

yck w{qwbuk bd |cjec ju yb fjh` yck tju{of ouwkey bd yck oitkqyjuknkhy yb yck nkohjhl

wqbi{eki az yck yksy( Jh ebhyqouy& HBY ZB[Q KHMBZNKHY BD FJDK ju |qjyykh

|jyc eowjyof fkyykqu ou o |oz yb ebhtjhek yck qkoikq ycoy yck uyqjtk dbq o wkqdkey abiz ibku

hby jnwfz u{ddkqjhl jd Mkhhz,u |bq` ju qk{kuyki(

?(5 Ohofzuju bd yck yksy

Dqbn o wqolnoyje wkquwkeyjtk& yck yksy eoh ak uoji yb ijddkq dqbn o

ebhtkhyjbhof nolo}jhk oitkqyjuknkhy woqyfz akeo{uk jy ju nbuyfz |qjyykh jh yck djquy

wkqubh& J& ohi ofub i{k yb jyu ebhdjl{qoyjbh ou o ebhdkuujbh qoyckq ycoh o ijqkey

w{afjejyz ijueb{quk( Ktkh jh uwjyk bd akfbhljhl yb o ikdjhkilkhkqje uekhk9 |cbuk nojh

ebhekqh ju wkqu{oujtkhkuu& yck yksy cou o wbujyjtk ybhk bd ebhdkuujbhjun az yck efjkhy

|cjec ebnku yb ijtkqlk dqbn yck ebnnbhwfoek ohi ubnk|coy ollqkuujtk jnwkqoyjtku

bd byckq oitkqyjuknkhyu( U{ec ybhk ju o nkohu yb ljtk eqkijajfjyz yb yck ebnwohz ohi

noz |bq` ou o nbyjtoyjbh dbq yck qkoikqu bd yck oitkqyjuknkhy |cb ojn oy fbujhl

|kjlcy(

Hby uyqj`jhlfz& yck tkqa ykhuk {uki jh yck yksy ju yck wqkukhy ub ycoy yck

oiiqkuukk ju ljtkh yck jnwqkuujbh yck kh{hejoyjbh wqkukhyu jyukfd ckqk ohi hb|( \coy

ju nbqk& yo`jhl jhyb oeeb{hy yck ksjuykhyjof ebhyksy; bhk eoh ouu{nk ycoy yck {uk bd yck

djquy wkqubh jh yck oitkqyjuknkhy ecoqoeykqj}ku& ujn{fyohkb{ufz& o u{amkeyjtk ohi

bamkeyjtk ijueb{quk( J eoh kjyckq qkdkq yb yck |bnoh wbqyqozki jh yck oitkqyjuknkhy bq

yb yck qkoikq bhek jy noz uyqkuu yck jiko bd fbujhl |kjlcy |jycb{y no`jhl n{ec kddbqy(

Yck ucbqy ukhykheku jh woqkhyckuju kuyoafjuc yck bwwbujyjbh aky|kkh yck

u{amkeyjtk ohi bamkeyjtk ijueb{quku bd yck oitkqyjuknkhy( Dbq jhuyohek& jh #(((* J

ekfkaqoyki |jyc o noqyjhj/ jy ju hbyjekoafk ycoy yck ebhykhy bd yck ukhykhek eohhby akowwfjki yb yck qkoikq& a{y yb yck |bnoh ikwjeyki jh yck oitkqyjuknkhy( Akujiku& ycju jiko

eoh ak m{uyjdjki az yck doey ycoy& jh yck wcbyb& yck |bnoh ju cbfijhl o noqyjhj jh ckq

cohiu ohi ekfkaqoyjhl yck fbuu bd 1; wb{hiu(

D{qyckqnbqk& jh qkoijhl yck yksy& yck yoqlky qkoikqu #|bnkh* noz dkkf

donjfjoq |jyc yck fohl{olk wqkukhy ljtkh jyu wqbsjnjyz yb yckjq ktkqzioz kswqkuujbhu(9 Lkhqku bd ijueb{quk ycoy wqkueqjak yck uekhk jh yck ijueb{quk #Nojhl{khko{& 177?= 3

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

4/13

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

5/13

jhykhujdz yck jikou kswqkuuki( Djquyfz& yck bqlohj}oyjbh bd yck wkqjyksy no`ku jy efkoq ycoy

yck tjk|u ckfi oab{y eckkqjhl oqk hkloyjtk( Yc{u& iktjeku u{ec ou wcbybu& yjyfku ohi

u{ayjyfku ubnkcb| jhyqbi{ek yck qkoikq yb yck ybwje bd yck yksy(

Yck djquy kzk.eoyecjhl kfknkhy bd yck wkqjyksy ju yck wcbyblqowc jh yck

djquy wolk( Ikwjeyjhl oh knwyz dbbyaoff djkfi |jyc wbn.wbnu bh yck lqouu& u{ec wcbyb

uyohiu b{y dbq jy jff{uyqoyku efkoqfz yck w{qwbuk bd yck jhykqfbe{ybq& yck bhk bd ykffjhl yck

qkoikq |coy akjhl o eckkqfkoikq khyojfu= ukef{ujbh( Ktjikhyfz& jd yck tjk|u bh

eckkqfkoikqu |kqk wbujyjtk& yck wcbyblqowc |b{fi ak {jyk ijddkqkhy& wkqcowu jy |b{fi

ikwjey ako{yjd{f ljqfu cowwjfz u{wwbqyjhl yckjq ykon wfozkqu( Yckh& o wcbyb |jyc hb bhk

njlcy qkjhdbqek yck jhykqfbe{ybq,u bwjhjbh jh |cjec akjhl o eckkqfkoikq ju o nkohu yb

uklqkloyk yck nknakqu bd yck ykon dqbn yck qkuy bd yck uy{ikhyu(

Uyjff& yck u{ayjyfku bd yck wcbybu ebjhejik |jyc yck jikou oabtk dbq yckz

uyqkuu yck doey ycoy bh akjhl o eckkqfkoikq bhk noz doek coqnd{f jnwfjeoyjbhu bd bhlbjhl

kswbu{qk yb yck ofnbuy {hoyyojhoafk jikofu qkfoyki yb yck e{fy bd o ue{fwy{qof abiz( Yc{u&

yck wkqjyksy uyoqyu yb aqjhl yb ijue{uujbh yck doey ycoy eckkqjhl jhtbftku `jffkq

ebnwkyjyjbh& c{njfjoyjbh& |kjlc.jhu& ohi ebuyfz ako{yz yqkoynkhyu& |cjec& oeebqijhl yb

yck |qjykq bd yck yksy& ju hby |bqycz bhek jy noz jnwfz o fby bd u{ddkqjhl(

Yck yjyfk ju ofub ksyqknkfz kswqkuujtk& kuwkejoffz akeo{uk bd yck |bqi

yofku& ckqk {uki ou o |oz yb qkjhdbqek ycoy yckqk ju o yknwbqof ijuyohek aky|kkh hb|

ohi yck yjnk yck doeyu cowwkhki( Yck ukebhi nojh yjyfk& Ycbuk uwoq`fk.ebtkqki qoc.qocu

bh yck ujikfjhku #(((* yck ioq` yq{yc& ofub wfozu jyu woqy jh yck ebhdjl{qoyjbh bd yck

ijueb{quk akeo{uk jy ju nbqk ijqkey ycoh yck wcbybu jh yck foakfjhl bd eckkqjhl ou o

dq{uyqoyjhl kswkqjkhek( Yck {uk bd ioq` yq{yc jh ijddkqkhy ebfb{qu ofub oeeb{hyu dbq ycoy

ohi ikujlhoyku o ebhyqoijeyjbh akeo{uk yck ebfb{q bd yckuk ykqnu ju hby ioq`kq ycoh yck

byckq |bqiu bd yck yjyfk& ou bhk |b{fi kswkey(

Cb|ktkq efkoq& yck wkqjyksy jh Qkof.Fjdk Qkoiu ibku hby kswfbqk ycktju{of iktjeku ou n{ec ou yck |kjlcy fbuu oitkqyjuknkhy ohofzuki( U{ec ijddkqkhek fjku

jh yck wke{fjoqjyjku bd yck y|b lkhqku ou koec bd |cjec qk{jqk o ijddkqkhyuekhblqowcz3(

Yck oitkqyjuknkhy ojnu oy ebnn{hjeoyjhl jyu ebhykhy jh o douy nohhkq |ckqkou yck

oqyjefk cou lby nbqk uwoek dbq ijue{uujbh( Ebhuk{khyfz& jy ju {hikquyohioafk ycoy jy

no`ku {uk bd nbqk yksy{of ohi oql{nkhyoyjtk iktjeku ycoh yck oitkqyjuknkhy(

Hktkqyckfkuu& lkhkqoffz uwko`jhl& bhk eohhby ebhujikq ycoy yck wkqjyksy bd

oh oqyjefk ju hby o nkohu yb wkqu{oik akeo{uk& hby bhfz ju jy o |oz yb no`k yck qkoikq ak3 Ecoqoeykqjuyjeu bd o ijueb{quk ycoy noz efouujdz jy ou o lkhqk #Nojhl{khko{& 177?= 3

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

6/13

|jffjhl yb qkoi yck yksy& a{y jy ofub kswqkuuku oh bwjhjbh ohi& yckqkdbqk& jy noz |bq` ou o

nohjw{foyjtk ybbf( Yckh& cotjhl yck ohofzuki oqyjefk ou oh ksonwfk& jy njlcy hby ak

|qbhl yb uoz ycoy ktkqz ijueb{quk ju jikbfbljeof ljtkh yck doey ycoy #(((* wkfb eoqykq

oqajyqqjb ib ujlhb& uk wbq {n foib o fjhl{olkn fkto eqjob& wqbi{yjtjioik ik

ukhyjib& wbq b{yqb qkwqkukhyo {n qjueb ho nkijio kn {k wkqnjyk nohjw{foq o

ebhuyq{b ik qkdkqhejo #Aqohib& 1779= 5?*(

1(1 Ohofzuju bd yck yksy

Yck kh{hejoyjbh bd yck yksy ohofzuki ckqk wqkukhyu jyukfd |jyc yck ebhuyohy

{uk bd J& eo{ujhl yck fohl{olk yb ak wqkibnjhohyfz u{amkeyjtk( Ubnk bd yck |bqiu

{uki& u{ec ou ajyecz& dbq jhuyohek& wf{u yck {uk bd oimkeyjtoyjbh ohi ksefonoyjtk

ukhykheku oqk ebnnbhwfoek jh |bnkh,u ijueb{quk ub ycoy yckuk dkoy{qku noz jhykqkuy yck

yoqlky qkoikq ohi& yckqkdbqk& ak jnwbqyohy kfknkhyu yb efouujdz yck ijueb{quk ou

u{amkeyjtk( \coy ju nbqk& |ckh yck jhykqfbe{ybq oiiqkuuku yck qkoikq jh

Zb{ noz cotk ukkh nk bh Nbhioz Hjlcy Dbbyaoff fouy doff #(((*& yck

u{amkeyjtjyz bd yck ijueb{quk ju uyqkuuki dbq yck qkoikq ju jhef{iki jh yck kh{hejoyjbh ou jd

yckqk |ou oh ksecohlk bd jikou(

Ohbyckq jnwbqyohy ebnwbujyjbhof ouwkey bd yck yksy ju yck ksco{uyjtk {uk

bd yck wouujtk tbjek( Wcqouku u{ec ou J |ou ybfi yb& \k |kqk hby offb|ki yb ohi

\k |kqk qk{jqki yb oqk nkhyjbhki uktkqof yjnku ohi yckqkdbqk knwcouj}k yck

jnwbujyjbhu bh yck ljqfu |cbuk ijubakijkhek yb yckjq eboec |b{fi fkoi yb yckjq fkotjhl

yck eckkqjhl ykon( Kjyckq akjhl bqikqki yb izk ckq cojq bq lb bh o ijky |jycb{y akjhl

|jffjhl yb ib ub& yck |qjykq iji jy dbq uck coi yb ebhtkz yck jnolk uck |ou kswkeyki yb(

Yckh& yck wouuolk #(((* o dkoq bd akjhl zkffki oy jh dqbhy bd yck khyjqk ykon m{uyjdjku u{ec

jiko ohi ebhdjqnu yck uyqjtk dbq yck ofnbuy {hoyyojhoafk jikofu qkfoyki yb dknjhjhjyz(

Uyjff& yck ub.eoffki ejyki ijueb{quk: ju tkqz ujlhjdjeohy jh yck oqyjefk dbq jywqkwoqku yck yksy yb |coy ju lbjhl yb ak uoji( Yck {uk bd qkwbqyjhl tkqau fj`k uoz&

qknjhi ohi ykff lkhkqoyku oh kfknkhy bd wbfzwcbhz ycqb{lc |cjec o wf{qofjyz bd

tbjeku mbjhyfz ebhuyq{eyu yck ijueb{quk( Yckh& bhk noz hbyjek ycoy& jh yck yksy& yck ijqkey

ijueb{quk |bq`u ou o |oz yb no`k yck kwjubiku nbqk iqonoyje ohi u{amkeyjtk |cjfk yck

jhijqkey ijueb{quk ykhiu yb ak nbqk jhdbqnoyjtk ohi bamkeyjtk #Lqjffb& 177;=

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

7/13

{uku dbq jh yck djquy ksonwfk lbbi& oh oimkeyjtk& eoh ecoqoeykqj}k yck ijueb{quk ou

u{amkeyjtk |cjfk jh yck ukebhi ksonwfk yck |qjykq ju m{uy kswfojhjhl yck qkoubh uck |ou

|kjlcjhl ?1< wb{hiu(

Ikuwjyk akjhl nbuyfz u{amkeyjtk& yck yksy cou ubnk nbnkhyu jh |cjec yck

|qjykq ibku hby |ohy yb ak noik qkuwbhujafk dbq yck |bqiu uck uozu( Ebhtkqukfz& bh

qklqkyyjhl ckq wouy kswkqjkheku ou o eckkqfkoikq& uck jhykhiu yb jhi{ek yck qkoikq jhyb

cotjhl o lbbi jnwqkuujbh oab{y ckq( Yc{u& jh ybb kychje ohi bwkqoyjbh

{hknwfbznkhy yck uyqoyklz nkhyjbhki ju hbyjekoafk& kuwkejoffz akeo{uk jh abyc eouku

yck |qjykq kswqkuuku o ybhk bd jhijlhoyjbh oy yck jnwbujyjbhu uck coi yb w{y {w |jyc hby

yb ak kswkffki dqbn yck ykon(

Ujn{fyohkb{ufz& yck dkkfjhlu bd dq{uyqoyjbh ohi jhijlhoyjbh eoh ak

wkqekjtki ou doq ou oql{nkhyoyjtk bwkqoybqu?7oqk owwfjki( Ycqb{lcb{y yck yksy uktkqof

ksonwfku eoh ak db{hi |ckqkou yck nbuy kswqkuujtk bhk ju ktkh ycb{lc& bh wolk ?59&

|ckqk jy uozu ycoy yck ljqf,u donjfz iqbtk kjlcy cb{qu dqbn yckjq cbnkyb|h yb ukk ckq

eckkq a{y uck |ou hby offb|ki yb ib ub ou uck |ou ebhujikqki btkq|kjlcy dbq yck

wkqdbqnohek(

Jqbhz ju ebhuyjy{yjtk bd yck |qjykq,u ijueb{quk jh yck wqktjb{u woqy bd yck

ebhef{ujbh( Yck no`jhl bd {kuyjbhu . Ohi oy fkouy jy |ou f{eqoyjtk& qjlcy2 ohi Ohi

dbq |coy2 Yck lfbqz bd nbbh|of`jhl #hb& qkoffz* dbq yck iq{h` l{zu #(((*2. |bq`ki ou o

ykechj{k woqyfz akeo{uk yckz khu{qki yck doey ycoy eckkqfkoikqu iji hby no`k n{ec

wqbdjy dqbn eckkqjhl ohi ofub yck jff{ujbh ljqfu cotk ycoy eckkqjhl ju o nkohu yb ak

wbw{foq ohi wczujeoffz oyyqoeyjtk(

Yck ebhef{ujbh wfozu o d{hionkhyof qbfk jh yck ebhdjl{qoyjbh bd yck

oqyjefk ou o |cbfk& dbq jy uzhyckuj}ku yck tjk|u bd yck |qjykq bh akjhl o eckkqfkoikq( Uck

nkhyjbhu ycoy uck u{ddkqki dqbn yck coqnd{f jnwfjeoyjbhu bd eckkqjhl= ckofyc ijubqikqu

ohi akjhl oaohibhki az ckq dqjkhiu ub ycoy uck fkdy yck ykon ohi ju hb| khmbzjhl |coyuck eb{fi hby ib ou o eckkqfkoikq( Yckh& cotjhl yck wouuolk #(((* J qkofj}ki J,i uoeqjdjeki

nz khyjqk jikhyjyz m{uy yb lky jhyb ycoy {hjdbqn ou oh ksonwfk& bhk eoh ouu{nk ycoy yck

oyyjy{iku bd ubejkyz oqk ebhuyjy{yjtk bd jhijtji{ofu, jikhyjyz dbq yck u{amkey ju hby

o{ybhbnb{u ohi ukfd.u{ddjejkhy& a{y ju dbqnki jh qkfoyjbh yb ,ujlhjdjeohy byckqu, #Coff&

?::1= 1

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

8/13

Ebhef{ujbh

Dqbn o wqolnoyje wbjhy bd tjk| yck y|b yksyu ohofzuki eoh ak uoji yb

ijddkq i{k yb uwkejdje dkoy{qku ycoy knkqlki dqbn yckjq ebhdjl{qoyjbh ou o ijueb{qujtk

lkhqk(

Bh yck bhk cohi& yck oitkqyjuknkhy no`ku ksco{uyjtk {uk bd yksy{of ohi

tju{of iktjeku ycoy noz ebnk yb jhykhujdz jyu ebnnkqejof w{qwbuk( Bh yck byckq& yck

oqyjefk bd yck Qkof.Fjdk Qkoiu ukeyjbh ibku hby cotk ycoy kswfjejy owwqboec yb

wkqu{oujtkhkuu woqyfz akeo{uk jy ibku hby akfbhl yb yck w{afjejyz djkfi ohi ofub i{k yb

yck {uk bd wbfzwcbhz ycqb{lcb{y yck yksy( Yc{u& jh ubnk nbnkhyu& yck u{amkeyjtjyz bd

yck oqyjefk ju ubnkcb| nou`ki az yck wf{qofjyz bd tbjeku wqkukhy jh jyu ijueb{quk(

Ljtkh yck ebhuyjy{yjtk yksy{of kfknkhyu nkhyjbhki& |coy eoh ak jhdkqqki

dqbn yck ohofzuju ju ycoy yck wuzecbfbljeof wqku{wwbujyjbhu hbyjekoafk jh yck nolo}jhk

fkoi yb o ebhyqoijeybqz ebhekwy bd yck dknjhjhk jikhyjyz( Akjhl Ebunbwbfjyoh o

nolo}jhk jh |cjec yck uyohioqiu bd ako{yz oqk tjlbqb{ufz uky& jy |ou u{qwqjujhl yb ukk

ycoy& ujn{fyohkb{ufz& yck uonk nolo}jhk qkmkeyu u{ec hbqnu(

Bh kswfbqjhl yck u{ddkqjhl ohi wojh ycoy akjhl o eckkqfkoikq ju oab{y& yck

nolo}jhk w{yu yb oh khi yck dohyouj}ki jiko |bnkh noz cotk bd eckkqjhl& |cjec

qkloqiu eckkqfkoikqu ou oh jebh bd dknjhjhjyz& ako{yz ohi wbw{foqjyz( Ou o qku{fy& bhk

eoh ebhef{ik ycoy yck ebhekwy bd jikhyjyz |cjec oqjuku dqbn yck ohofzuju bd yck

oitkqyjuknkhy ohi yck oqyjefk ju jh ebhm{heyjbh |jyc yck jiko bd o dqolnkhyki u{amkey

|cbuk ukhuk bd ukfd ju nbfiki jh oeebqiohek |jyc yck jhijtji{of,u qkfoyjbhu |jyc ubejkyz(

Cb|ktkq& yo`jhl jhyb oeeb{hy ycoy yck touy nombqjyz bd oqyjefku w{afjucki

jh Ebunbwbfjyoh ubnkcb| ijeyoyku doucjbhu ohi yqkhiu qkfoyki yb yck dknjhjhk {hjtkquk&

jy noz hby ak |qbhl yb ouu{nk ycoy u{ec jnwbujyjbh bd uyohioqiu b{y|kjlcu yck

oql{nkhyu bd yck Qkof.Fjdk Qkoiu,u oqyjefk ohi& yckqkdbqk& noz ebnk yb ebhtkz oh jiko

bd bhkhkuu qkloqijhl |bnkh,u jikhyjyz(

Ajafjblqowcjeof qkdkqkheku=

AO@CYJH& N( Yck Ijofblje Jnoljhoyjbh& O{uyjh& [hjtkqujyz bd Yksou Wqkuu& ?:3?(

AKHTKHJUYK& njfk( Wqbafknou ik fjhluyjeo lkqof J( Yqoi( N( L( Hbto` k N( F(

Hqj( Eonwjhou= Wbhyku= [HJEONW& ?::?(

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

9/13

AQOHIB& Ckfkho Coycu{k Holonjhk( Jhyqbi{b ohfjuk ib ijue{qub( 1( ki( qkt(

Eonwjhou= [HJEONW& 1779(

LKHKYYK& Lqoqi( Uk{fu( Woqju= Uk{jf& ?:3

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

10/13

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

11/13

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

12/13

8/14/2019 Paper 05 - YAWP 4

13/13