Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay...

22
Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr´ e Cerezo, Olivier Devillers, Monique Teillaud To cite this version: Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr´ e Cerezo, Olivier Devillers, Monique Teillaud. Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points. [Research Report] RR-1415, INRIA. 1991. <inria-00075145> HAL Id: inria-00075145 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00075145 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Transcript of Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay...

Page 1: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay

triangulation of constrained sets of points

Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andre Cerezo, Olivier Devillers, Monique Teillaud

To cite this version:

Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andre Cerezo, Olivier Devillers, Monique Teillaud. Output sensitiveconstruction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points. [Research Report]RR-1415, INRIA. 1991. <inria-00075145>

HAL Id: inria-00075145

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00075145

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

������������� ���������������������������������������� ��!�#"%$ $&('*)+����)-,���.�*)+��/���'*)0�������1���2�����������3)+����546��7���8���9�:�����;����<

=>'�/?���.����!�@A#4CB �D ��4�)+�;�E4FG'*)H�����I����>�J�����E'*)#���.�*)+��/���'*)0��������4F$& '*)+����)K,L"M$ 4ONP ���� @RQ�'� �84FS�J���������T���������3)+���M���

U-V.WYX-Z\[2WYX0]^V._�`ba�]dcecea7X0XfW�gih jkXfl0m�nVponV.mfnV�qIa3r s _d]ut5]dV.mv[2VIt5]d_^_dV.mwcwhxya�Xf]dzK{fVp|;V.]^_d_^W�{fl-h

}P~u�(�Y~P�0���7� �.� �*�����*�*�*�*�����\�����������(�������e�����¡ Y¢�£�¤�£�¥F¦�§�¨^����¢�£�©ª�} �.���*��£�«�¬-�*���*�?�*­�®*®f�*����¯°�P±�������«3§i��¨u u�u�e��±�£*� � ��±+£�²7����¨������ ³�¨´¶µ7���¡·�£�¨u ����¹¸£ ¤�£0����¢�£*������¨u¢ ºY����¨u�* u£*���*�*�*��»��Y�¡¢�£ ¢�£�¤�£�¥F¦P§e¨^����¢�£�©¼�½�¾�¿¡À Á�Â\ÃPÄ0¾�ÅÆÀKÇ�ÈdÈ�É?À�Ê�Ë\Ë�Â\êÌ�È^Í5¿ÎÉ0ËeÅ\êÌIÇ�Ï+Ìо�È-Ñ�Ò�Ó�Ô�Õ\½�Ö�ÅÆÀ�¿�×(Ô�È�À�ÈdÅ\Ã�×^¾fØK×�Ì�¿ÎÂ\É?ÙKÃ^Ú�Û�Ü�Ý�ÞMßÎØ-à�á�â3ã?ä�Ú

Page 3: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

����������� �������������������� �"!���#%$&�'�()$)���*����+&�,�����-�.��� �����/�0�12�0$435$)+&��6.�0�7�����-89��':��6�����;&�����<����()6/=

'<�����*$)�>$�?,�2��� �-@A$�?,BC��$)�������7�*�ED"=F1G�*+�� ������$)����'H�����)35�I#J�.� �K�0�.�I�L$)�*�/���7'��*�I���E����� �MN$�?,OP��'<����� �Q&�R?�OTSVU4�����I��'*()$)�����0�.+W�X6����7���Y����+&��Z\[�B9'�$)(]B4^`_Xa7#J��� ���b_c�*�7������X�*d��2$�?e�0�.�2$)6�����6.��f]�g?7OihjDP�����k�0��+&�kl�$)6���1C�*�IZb[m_XOH'�$)(]Bna Qo���Cl�$)���p3 ����� �"!H������X�0$)�q��()�,���,Zb[�BLa Q�rJ���e���"3�$ ��1��'�()$)���*���.+s���%��tG��� ��1/�"12��$&�����73 �����7$�?���$ ���.�0�u'�;/�*�.(&���POv =F1/��+&� ���X�*$)���'w��;/��� ���.':��������$?�x y9z{Q

|~}� ������}��%� �,�����0�<35'��7������ �X� �/���c1/��6/t���'�( $)��������+&� ����$)6���'*�-3��'<356.'�1/�7'<�������:���.( 6.':������$ �P1G�-89�5=

'<��6����;�1/�\BK��$)�*�.�0��1������e'R� � �X���)35�-'�$)���q�{6��-'�� �,��$)����������$)���,35$)�����q���*�/���&��&������������� �.�*�I��OY�.':���.�"QI�/�]OTSsU2'R� ��'*()$)�����0�.+&�I��� ��+&�����&� �>��� +&�.��Z\[�B,'�$ (]B2^�_�ae$��6�_�� ���c'<���q���'�'*�1G6����� ��6�'��q���cfG����O4hiD\':�\35$)+&��'��5tG�������� �X�9Z\[�_XOJ'*$)(HBLa�QH8e�����%'�� �,1G� 6/t�3���!G'<�b+��� +&$)������,��"35� �X�q���*���7�����9Z\[�BLa Q��L�-1G� 6/t��F�� +&�c��'�()$ �X�*����+&�b�"� �{� ������1���6Y3 ���,1/�&Ok��$)6��0=�� �����)35� �,1/�1G�*+&��������$)��� v 1/�7x y�z{Q

Page 4: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

� ������������ ���������������������! #"$�!%'&�(*)��+"#,- .�/�+&0)213"4�+"657)2&98�5. 6�:�0;<&=�#��>�13(�1-"�1:?@�5A)��!,-(9�!BC;#�!(=�EDF �"65#�+BG�H"I&9�J�8*&=(� $KML&= #(��:8�)2"NK�1-BGO� #&9�!&0)213"6�:�P,-�H1-B7�Q&=(�%<RTSVU�W.X3Y�;VZ[5.�JX<\<; ]� �(_^�`Macbd"e&=fg1h5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$8H;g&����j8d)2kH�l1+D&=�#�:8*�48*&=(� 6K�&� �(��:8H;mD/1-(7noO61!)i"#&98H;p)�8�q�rdn�st�!"$5u&����Q(�����v.)�8*&w8*�Hx.�H(_�:�g13O#&0)2Bw�:�Eq�rdny�i1-,[n�st�J�iL,31-(*)i&=�#Bw8ED/1-(y&=�#��)2(�KM13"68*&=(� $KM&0)213"RPbd"z�.)i,-�#�H(�5A)iBG�Q"$80)i13"68H;{&����G8d)2kH�t1!Dg&=�#�t13 #&=O# �&�5.�QO6�H"65�813"|&=�#��)i"#O� #&�5<)�8*&=(*)i}# #&0)i1-"j�+"654Bw�:%~x-�!(=%�DF(�13B�qGr0nsg&�1lq'r0ny�_���A��G� s[fc�#�H(��G��5I�Q"�1-&=�J8y&����5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"pR�b0"�O$�!(�&0)�KM .�/�+(:;-)i"~�!L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)i1-"6�:��8*O$�-K��A;<&=�#�y�����/�+ #"$�!%�&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)213"�1!D��8*�H&��1+D�nu8d)i&=�J8�Bw�+%wKM13"68d)�8*&c1+Dg��"� #B�}6�H(c1!D�&��H&=(_�!���J5.(_�Gfc�.)/K9�~Bw�J%wx-�+(�%�DF(=1-B�q�rdn�s�&�1�qGr0n��Qs9R���� 68�)2&g)�8Efg1-(�&=�48*�H�Q�-)i"#,w�:�i,-1-(0)2&=�#B�8�f��#1A8*�tK�1-BGOI�i��v.)i&*)i�:8c5I�QO��H"65�13"l}613&��4&=�#��)2"�O# �&y8d)ikQ�nj�!"$5l&�����13 #&�O� #&E8d)ikQ���MR

]�8�)/8�fg���T���."#13fc";�K�1-"$8*&�(= 6KM&0)i"#,h&=�#�j�y�M���+ #"6�+%�&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)i1-"�r�1-(w&����j>[1-(=1-"�1:?@�5<)��!L,3(_�!B~s�1+D�O61!)i"�&_8m)i"l�3Ld5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��8*O6�3KM��KH�!"�}6��(��:5I 6K��J5�&=17KM13"68*&�(= 6K�&*)i"#,7�'K�1-".x-�MvG�� I���$)i"rd�c��`!s�Ld5A)iBG�Q"$80)i13"6�J�p8*O6�-K��AR����� 68�&�����1- �&�O� #&�8*�Q"$8d)i&*)ix.�y�J�i,-13(*)i&���B�1+D�WA�M)�5.�M��DF13(�KM13"68*&=(� 6K�&�L)i"#,uKM13"#x-�Mvh�. I����8�)i"e�.)2,3�#�H(w5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$8HS�W-�M)�X-�+aEKQ�+"e}6�l $8*�J5�&�1uKM13"68*&=(� 6K�&G&=�#�C�y�M���! �"6�+%&=(*)��!"�,- I���+&*)i1-"�1!D�n�8d)i&=�J8t)i"o�+"e13 #&�O� #&�8*�Q"$8d)2&0)ixA��B��!"#"��Q(QR������l&0)iBG�4K�1-BGO.�2��v.)i&=%j1!DP&=�#�13(*)i,!)i"6�:�[�J�i,-13(*)i&���B��38�5I�:8�KM(0)2}6�:54}#%jWA��)�5I�M��)�8�qGrdn������<�i13,gn�sgD/1-('�+".%j�z� ��R�]¡x.�H(�%~(��HLK��Q"�&�(=�J8* .�2&'1+Dy¢z�+&�13 £8*�H�4B7�Q"#&0)i1-"��J5l)2"������Q13(��HB�Yl�J���i1-fy8�&=1z(��:5I 6K���&=�#��K�1-B7OI�i�Mv<)2&=%4&=1q'r0n{¤_¥0¦P�e�<�i13,gn�s7§�f�)2&=��¢z�!&=1- m£8*�Q�zBG1$5A)�¨�KQ�+&*)i13";�&��.)/8'�J�i,-13(*)i&���B©)�8t(9�!&=�#�H(GK�1-BGO.�T)�KH�!&=�J5�+"65l8*&0)��T�m"#13&y8��+&*)�8dDF%-)i"#,�)�D���)�8cªArdn ¤_¥0¦ s_R

«E&=�#�Q(��:�2,31-(0)2&=�#Bw8��!(=�[�."�1-fc"�&��$�!&��+(���8*�H"68d)i}I�i�[&�1E&����[1- #&=O# �&pD/1-(�8*1-B7��8*O��:K_)�¨�K�&0%<O6�J8p1!D)i"#O� #&98HR�bd"6KM(=�QBG�H".&_�:��(9�!"65.1-B�)ikH�J5~�J�i,-13(*)i&���Bw8H;.D/1-(g)2"$8*&_�+"6K��A;6�!(���8*�Q"$8d)2&0)ix.��&=1G&=�#��B��Jv.)iBw�:�8d)ikQ��1+Dc&=�#�~8* 6KHK��J8�8d)ix.��&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)213"68HR�S­¬cW.X3^�;V®��tW�¯:a�����1- �,-�u&=�#��)i(�&0)iBG��KM13BGOI�i��v.)i&�%zBw�J%}6��13 #&=O# #&[8*�Q"$8d)2&0)ix.�[)2"~8*13BG��KH�-8*�J8�r/)i"�O$�!(�&0)�KM .�/�+(:;3&����J8*���J�i,31-(*)i&=�#Bw8��!(=�y��)i"#�:�!(�)�Dp&=�#�E)i"#O� #&8d)i&��:8��+(��� #".)TD/13(�B��i%�5A)�8*&�(*)i}# �&��:5{s9;-)i&�Bw�+%�fc���T�#�$�!O#O��H"�&��$�!&��+"w)i"�&��H(�BG�J5A)��!&=�E&=(*)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)i1-")�8EB7 6K9��}I)i,-,3�Q(y&=�6�!"4&=�#��¨6"6�:��13"#�ARyW-1w&����J8*���:�i,-1-(0)2&=�#B�8E�+(��t"�1-&P8*�H"68d)i&*)ix<��&=1G&=�#�t13 #&=O# #&)i"l}$�-54KH�-8*�:8HR

]°5.�Q&=�Q(=B�)2".)�8*&*)�Kl�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B±fc�#1A8*�4K�1-BGO.�i�Mv.)i&0%h5I�HO6�Q"$5#8�13"²&=�#�~1- �&�O� #&wrd�!"$5h)i"hD��3KM&(��:�-K��#�:8E&=�#��1-O#&0)iBw�J��&0)2BG��}613 #"65jq�rdny�i1-,[n����_s=sg)/8��<"#13fc"�)i"j&�����8*O6�:K_)��J�[KH�-8*��1!D�O�1+)2".&98)i"4�+Ld5A)2B7�Q"68d)i13"6�J��8*O6�3KM��KM13"68*&=(_�J)i"#�:5�&=1���)i�P)i"l&=f�1'O$�!(_�:���2���OI���!"#�:8HR�S³®[1+)/X3X!a

���I)�8�O6�+O6�Q(y��v�&=�Q"$5#8�13"l&=�I)�8����-8*&�(��:8* I�i&y�+"65�O#(��:8*�Q"�&_8�&�fg17�J�i,-13(*)i&���Bw8�&�1�K�1-BGO� #&=��&=�#��y�M���+ #"6�+%~&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)213"41!D��w8*�H&P��1!DgnuO61!)i"�&_8[)i"u�+Ld5A)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:�g8*O$�-K��tfc�#�H"j&����tO�1+)2".&98��)i��)2"´�w8*�H&yµ¶1!D[·~OI���+"#�J8HR����#���:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B¸D/1-(y&=�#��KH�-8*�t1+D�&0fg1~r�"#13&y"#�:KM�:8�8��!(0)T�i%CO6�+(_�J���i�M��sO.�/�+"#�:8�(� #"$8�)i"l13O#&0)2Bw�:��&0)2BG��q�rdny�i1-,[nG�4�9s9R�b�D�·~�o��&=�#��&0)iBG��KM13BGOI�i�Mv<)i&�%t)�8cq�r��*·[�i1-,[n�s9Rbd"l}�1-&=�4KH�-8*�:8H;�&=�#��8*&�13(_�+,-��)/8cqGrdn�s9R

���I)�8����-8*&l�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B¹K�1-B7O6�!(=�J8�D��!x-13(_�!}.�i%�f�)i&�� WA��)/5.�M�dºV8�1-"��AS­WA��)/X3�!aPfc���Q"»&����|". #B7L}6�H(~1+D'OI���!"#�:8�)�8~8*Bw�:�T��f�)i&=��(��:8*O6�JK�&�&�1²&=�#�j"# #B'}#�H(~1+D'O61!)i"#&98HR¼���I)�8�)�8�)i"NO6�!(=&*)�KM .���!(&=(� #�~fc���Q"�5I�:�J��)i"#,zf�)i&���&�13BG1-,3(_�+O#�I)�K7)iBw�!,3�J8G�+"65��!L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"6�:�E8*�6�+O���(=�JK�1-"$8=&=(� $KM&0)i1-"O�(�1-}.�2�HBw8HR�S³®[1+)/X3X!a�«c #(P�J�i,31-(*)i&=�#Bw8y�!(���½A .)2&=�t�:�-8*%~&=1�KM1I5.���!"$54�!O#O6�:�!(y&=1w}6�t,-1A1I54KQ�+"65<)iL5��!&=�J8[D/1-(yO�(_�-K�&*)�KH�J��)2BGO.�i�QBG�H"I&9�+&*)i1-"$8HR

¾�8d)i"#,�¢z�!&=1- £8*�Q�{º³8�(��JK��Q"�&g(��:8* I�i&:;I&=�I)�8c�J�i,-13(*)i&���B¿KQ�+"l}6���MvI&��H"65I�:5�&=1w8*�H&_8�1+D�O61+)i"#&98[1!DÀ³ÁcÂ��2%-)2"�,�)i"4·7Ã�L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:����%.O��Q(�O.�/�+"#�:8HR

Äh��"�1-f»}�(*)i�MÅ$%413 #&0�T)i"��t&������J�i,-13(*)i&���BÆ)i"´�!L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"6�:��8*O$�-K���Çc&=�#�t&=(*)��!"�,- .�/�+&*)i1-"l)�8K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&=�J5�)2"$KM(=�QBG�H"#&9�J���i%-R�¬�1-"68d)�5I�H(y�'&��H&�(9�!���J5I(=1-"CÈ.ÉMÊM�G1+D�&�����&=(*)��!"�,- .�/�+&*)i1-"p;I&��#��}6�38d)�K

`

Page 5: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

O�(�1-}.�2�HB�)�8[&=1�¨$"65�&�����&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(_��&=�6�!&E8*�6�+(��ED��-K��J8�f�)i&=��)i&:R����.)/8�)/8��:½A .)2x3�J�i�Q".&�&=1'¨6"65A)2"�,D/1-(P�J�3KM�lD��-K���1!D�È.ÉMÊM�$;�8��+%CÈ.ÉMÊ+;{&=�#���QBGO�&�%C8*O��#�H(���&��$�!&PO6�38�8*�J8�&=�#(=1- #,3�uÈ<ÉMÊ'�!"$5|�+"#13&����Q(8d)i&����!r��� ��s_R4���#�~8*�:�!(9K_���J5´8*O#�#�H(��-;m)�Dc)i&���v.)�8*&_8H;�)�8�)i"�&�����O6�H"6K9)���1!DE8*O#�#�H(��:8t&=�6�!&'O$�-8�8*�:8&=�#(�13 #,3�uÈ<ÉMÊ+R��g�#�t�<�Q%�)�8E&=1l�!x!1+)/5l&=�J8*&0)i"#,l����)2"��J�+(�"# �B�}6�Q(y1+D�O61+)i"#&98�)i"41-(95I�Q(P&=1G¨6"65��AR���.)�8EKH�!"�}���5I13"#��}I%G $8d)2"�,�&=�#��D��-K�&g&��$�!&�&�����8d)i&=�J8[��)i�P)i"~·�O.�/�+"#�:8HR�b0"~O6�!(=&*)�KM .���!(:;<13}68*�H(�x.�&=�6�+&c&=�#��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"�1!D�&�����O��Q"$K_)��1!D�8*O#���Q(��:8�f�)i&��C��O.�/�+"#��� )�8c�GO6�Q"$K_)��1!D�K_)i(_K9�i�J8[)i"���RÄh�G8*�Q�H�z�~8d)i&=����)i"|�:�-K��4OI���!"��� &=�6�+&��$�-8��wBG�QB'}6�Q(P1!Dg&=�#��O6�Q"$K_)���1!D�K9)2(9K_�i�J8�O6�38�8d)i"#,&=�#(�13 #,3�|)i&�8* $KM�j&��$�!&P&=�#��K9)i(_K_�i�G5I1<�:8�"#1-&tKM13".&_�:)2"´�!"�%C8d)2&=�7)i"4)2&98�)2".&=�Q(0)213(:R7���#�G8d)i&����7)/8&=�#��8d)2&=� ����� �w8* $KM��&=�6�!&�&=�#��8*O#�#�H(���K_)i(_K� #Bw8�K�(*)i}I)i"#,�È.É�Ê����)/8��HBGO#&=%-R���#���<�Q%´&=1C¨6"65�½A .)/K��A�i%����)�8G5I�:8�KM(0)2}6�:5h)i"oWA�:KM&0)i1-"��|�!"$5h&=�#�~fc��1!�i�4�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B )/8,+)2x<�Q"�)i"|W-�JK�&*)i1-"C��RcW-�JK�&*)i13"��w5.�J�:��8�f�)2&=�l&=�#��O6�+(�&0)/K� I���!(PKH�-8*��1!D�1-".�2%w&�f�17OI���!"��J8HR

� ��������������� �E� � ���"!��0�#!]�8�BG�H"#&0)213"#�:5�)i"�&�����)i"#&=(�1<5. 6K�&*)i1-"p;-O��Q"$K_)���8m1!DK_)i(_K9�i�J8�OI���!%'�PKM�H"#&=(_�J�#(=1!�i��)i"713 #(g�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#BCR&=�I)�8c8*�JK�&*)i13"lO#(=1-x-)/5.�J8[&=�#��"#�:KM�:8�8��!(=%�Bw�+&��H(*)��J�m�!}613 #&�O6�Q"$K_)��/8�1+D�K_)i(_K9�2�:8c�!"$5l8*1!�ix<�J8��7½A ��Q(=%O�(�1-}.�2�HB¸fc�.)/K���f�)��T�}��t�'}6�-8d)�KE)2"�,-(��:5<)i�Q"�&g1!D�1- �(y�:�2,31-(*)i&=�#BCR$&%(' )+* W-,�Vpa-./,�]dm0,�_dV.cvW�Xfl * V�X1,I]^_dcva-. ,I]^m0,I_^V.cÄh��&9�!�.�[)i"#&=�Q(=�J8*&�)i"�&�����8*�H&�1!DK_)i(_K9�i�J8�5I(9�!fc"t)2"GOI���!"��2��R����.)/8�8*�H&�1+D�K9)2(9K_�i�J8m)�8[(��HO#(=�J8*�H"I&=�J5}�%���&=�#(��H��5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J�8*O$�-K���34��Ç�&=�#��8*O$�-K���1!DK_)i(_K9�2�:8HR65��H&�7 � �98 �;: �0<+7 : �>="8g��? ��@}6��&������:½A $�!&0)213"l1+D��GK9)2(9K_�i�P)i"���§I&��.)/8gK_)i(_K9�2��)�8�(��QO�(��:8*�Q"#&=�:57}#%G&=�#��O�1+)i"I&yrA<"BC=�BD?�s�)i"34��R

b0"N&=�I)�848*�:KM&0)i1-"p;yfc�j5I�H(*)ix.�4&=�#�jO�(�1-O��Q(=&*)i�J8w1!D 3E� DF(=1-B f��M���P�<"#1-f�"�(=�J8* I�i&98�1-"NO�1-L���!(0)2&=%-R�FE�JK��J8�8��+(�%´"#13&*)i1-"$8��!"65�8*&9�!"$5#�!(95uxA1IKH�!}� I���!(=%�r�O6�H"6K9)��0;�(_�35<)�KQ�:�E�Jv<)/8H;�O61+���!('OI���!"��A;K�1-"HG* �,<�+&��-R:RMRMsg�+(��t5.�M¨$"#�:5w)i"u¬�1:v��H&��H(�13(PUm�J5.1<�J8HºV8�}61<13��8HS­¬�1!v#��`3;³Um�:5{\ @ a$D/13(c�Mv#�!BGO.�2�-R

I ������8*�Q&�1!D[K_)i(_K9�2�:8�1!D�(_�-5A)2 $8 @ )�8��'O6�!(9�!}61+�21+)�5l1!D��J½- 6�!&0)i1-"�Ç"<m�[�J=�� � ?gR�] O61+)i"#&)2"9� )�8�1!D/&=�Q"�)/5.�Q"�&*)�¨6�:5�f�)2&=�l&=�#� @ (9�-5<)i $8cK_)i(_K9�2��KM�H"#&=�Q(=�J5��!&�&��.)�8�O61!)i"#&QR�b�D�OI���+"#�/�)/8�)/5.�Q"�&*)�¨6�:5�&�1'&=�#��OI���!"��K? ��@ &=�#�H"�&���� @ (_�35<)i 68cK9)2(9K_�i�P)�8[13}#&9�J)i"#�:5�}�%�(_�:)/8d)i"#,7&=�#�O61!)i"#&g13"�&=�#��O6�+(_�!}61+�i1!)�5�R����#��)i"#&=�Q(*)i13(�1!D�&�����O$�!(_�+}61!�i1!)�5�)/8�&����t8*�H&c1+DML�)iBw�!,+)i"6�!(=%ONK_)i(_K9�2�:8�r�f�)i&=�u"#�H,<�+&*)ix.�G8�½A $�!(=��(_�35<)i 68�s�rd8*�H�QPp)2,3 #(��C`!s9R�FE1-&0)/K���&=�6�+&�&=�#����1-(*)ikH1-"�&_�:�O#(�1RG0�JK�&*)i1-"~1!D��'O61!)i"#&�)2"Q3 � )/8�&����tK��Q".&=�Q(g1!D�&=�#��K_)i(_K9�i�A;#�!"$5�&��#�S?LdK�1<1-(95<)i"6�+&��E)�8�&����O61-fg�Q(g1!D�&=�#��13(*)i,!)i"lfg)2&=�l(=�J8*O��JK�&c&=1G&=�#��K_)i(_K9�i�AR

I ��f�1yK9)2(9K_�i�J8�rT<+UHBV=WU�BD?;UJs��+"657rA< � BV= � BD? � s��+(��[1-(=&���1-,31-"6�:�<)�D$&=�#��K�1-(=(��J8*O613"65A)2"�,yO�1+)2".&98�!(��yKM13">G0 #,A�!&=�Ef�)i&��G(��J8*O��JK�&�&=1�&=�#�EO$�!(9�!}�1!�i1!)�5713(��J½- I)ix-�J�i�H"I&0�i%�)�D#? U �X? � � �0< U < � ��0= U = � RI ]�8y�GO6�+(�&0)/K� I���+(�KH�-8*�-;$&=�#��8*�H&c1+DgK9)2(9K_�i�J8cO6�38�8d)2"�,w&���(�1- �,-��Y[Z \��¼)�8y�J��8*1G&=�#��8*�H&y1!DK_)i(_K9�2�:8�O��H(�O6�H"65<)�K� I���!(�&�1w&=�#� @ (_�-5A)i 68cK_)i(_K9�i�/Y�Z-;Ifc�.)/K���)/8�)i"X3]��&=�#�tO61+�/�+(cOI���+"#�t1!DY Z RP®[ #&Q;��-8^Y Z }6���i1-"#,A8E&=1�&����tO6�+(_�!}�1!�i1+)/5�;{&����tO61!���!(POI���!"���)�8�"#13&��I)i"�,w�M��8*��&��$�!"&����P&9�+"#,-�H"#&�OI���!"���&�1'&=�#��O6�+(_�!}61+�i1!)�5��!&�Y�Z-R+P�13(g�'K_)i(_K9�i�y)i"�&=�#���6�:�TD�8*O$�-K��trF��)iB�)2&=�:5}#%�&��.)/8�OI���!"��3s�fc�.)/K���5.1<�J8["�1-&�K�1-".&9�J)i"�&=�#��O6�+(_�!}61+�i1!)�5�;]Y Z )/8�)i"68d)�5I��&=�#��K_)i(_K9�i�AR+P{1-(�GK9)2(9K_�i�P)i"l&=�#��1-&=�#�H(y�6�:�TD�8*O6�3KM�-;_Y`Z�)�8�1- �&_8d)�5I�-R

Page 6: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

��������� �������

� ��������������������������

Z ������� ��������������

��

�������� � ��!���"���������#����$�� ����%���

& �������� &�#�%�'���

(*)������������+�,�-� ���&/. ���'��� . ( )

Pp)2,3 #(=��`3������t8*O$�-K��t1!D�K_)i(_K9�i�J8

I ]NO6�H"6K9)T�61!DK_)i(_K9�2�:8H;-&=�6�+&�)�8�&�����8*�H&�1!D{��)2"��J�+(gKM13B�}.)2"$�!&0)213"68m1+Dp&=f�1�K_)i(_K9�2�:8H;<&�(9�!"68dD/13(�Bw8)2" 3E�j)2".&=1P&��#����)2"��E&���(�13 #,-�G&�����&=fg1�O61+)2"�&_8HR�]NO6�Q"$K_)��{1+D�K9)i(_K_�i�:8�fg)2&=�'��)iB�)i&*)i"#,�O61+)i"#&98)/8�����)2"����I)i&�&0)i"#,�&=�#��O$�!(_�+}61!�i1!)�57)2"�&=�#�c&�fg1���)2B')2&0)2"�,�O61+)2"�&_8�rd8*�Q�2Pp)i,- �(��S�.s9R�]�O6�H"6K9)T�1!DEK_)i(_K9�2�:8�f�)2&=��KM13BGBG1-"´O61!)i"#&98E)�8t�~��)i"#��f��I)�KM�´5I1<�:8t"#13&��.)2&�&�����O6�+(_�+}�1+�21+)�5�;�&=�I)�8�T)i"#�[)�8�&�����)i"I&=�Q(98*�JK�&*)i1-"�1+Dp&=�#��&�fg1yOI���!"��J8�&9�!"�,-�H"I&�&=1�&=�#��O6�!(9�!}�1!�i1!)�5��!&�&����EK�1-BGBG13"O61!)i"#&98mr08*�H� Pp)2,3 #(��g�.s9R�]�KM1-"$KM�H".&�(0)/KmO��H"6K9)T�A)/8�����)i"#�[O6�+(_�:�T�i���I&�1y&=�#�6?l�Jv<)/8mrd8*�Q�"P)i,3 #(��`!s9R

I ������O61!)i"#&98��+&y)2".¨6"I)i&=%~1!Dg&=�#��O#(�1>G*�:KM&0)ix.��K9�21A8* #(���1+D13 � K�1-(�(=�J8*O�1-"654&=1~&=�#�G8*&=(_�J)i,-��&�T)i"#�:8�)i"��7;<"$�!BG���i%�&=�#��O61+)2"�&g�+&�)2".¨6".)2&=%t)i"�&=�#��5<)i(��:KM&0)213"�1!D�rA< B =�BD?�s�)/8�&�����8*&�(9�J)i,-��&�T)i"#��1!D��J½- 6�!&0)i1-" : �>< 7 : �>="8�� ? ��@ ;6�!"65�&����tO61!)i"#&��+&c)i"I¨6".)i&�%G1!D[�t��)i"#��)i"X3O��)�8&�����(_�35<)�KQ�:�m�Jv.)�8�1+D�&=�#��K�1-(=(��J8*O613"65A)2"�,GO6�H"6K9)T�dR���# $8m&����EO��Q"$K_)��/8�fc��1<8*��(_�35<)�KH�J���:v.)�8m)�8���,+)2x<�Q"t��)2"��E)2"Q��D/13(�B )2"3O�j&=�#��8*�Q&�1!Dp��)i"#�:8O6�!(9�J���i�M�&�1���,+)2x<�Q"~5A)2(=�JK�&*)i1-"jr�13(�&=�#1-,31-"$�J�&�1�&��#��(_�35<)�KQ�:���:v.)�8�s9Rb0"4O$�!(�&0)�KM .�/�+(:;#�GO6�Q"$K_)���1+DgK_)i(_K9�i�J8��6�+xA)i"#,7&���� 7�Ld�:v.)�8c�-8�)2&98c(_�-5A)/KH�J�m�:v.)�8�K�1-(=(��J8*O613"65�8)2"Q3O��&=1w����)i"#��O6�!(9�J���i�M�&�17&����/=�L��:v.)�8HR

$&% $ 021 * g�3 ,�]dm0,�_dV�c WYXfl54 a�mwa�Xfa76 8Mlf]dW:9�mwW 1 c������O#(�13O6�Q(�&0)i�J8�1+D 34� �!}613x!�t%A)i�M��5j�!"�1-&=�#�H(E)i"�&��H(�O#(=�Q&9�!&0)213"41!D�&����7fc�������<"#13fc"jKM13(�(��:8*O61-"�L5��!"6K���}6�H&�fg�Q�H"´�!(�(9�!"#,3�QB7�Q"#&98�1+DcOI���+"#�:8t�+"65|>�1-(�13"#1Q? @[5A)/�+,-(9�!Bw8HR�SVZ�W<X-�+ag���.)/8�f�)����g}6�w5I�HL&9�J)��i�J54}6�M�i1-f��!"654 68*�:5�)i"|&=�#��8* �}68*�:½A #�H"#&E8*�JK�&*)i13"RP]�8E"�1-&0)�KM�:5C)i"4&�����O#(��:KM�:5<)i"#,�8*�:KM&0)i1-";

Page 7: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

��

���+�"�%�����������

����� ����� ��!�����������

Pp)i,- �(��/�I�] O��H"6K9)T�1+D�K9)2(9K_�i�J8�fg)2&=����)iB�)2&0)i"#,7O�1+)2".&98

��

& �������� &�#�%�'���

& �������� &� ����� &

� �������� �'!������������

��� ���$�'! ���� & �����

Pp)2,3 #(=����Ç�] O6�H"6K_)��1!D�K9)2(_K9�i�J8cf�)i&��CKM13BGBG1-"~O61!)i"#&98

Page 8: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

&=�#�~8*�H&'1!DyK9)i(_K_�i�:8tfc�.)/K���5I1l"#13&7KM13"#&_�:)i"��~,+)2x<�Q"uO61+)i"#&�Bw�+O68�)i" 3 � )i"#&=1z�!"´�6�J��DP8*O$�-K��A;��)iB�)2&=�J54}#%~&=�#��O61+�/�+(�O.�/�+"#��1!D�&����7O61+)2"�&:R����. $8H;6)�D��#�e)�8���8*�Q&P1!D[8d)2&=�J8c)2"jOI���!"�� �7;�&����Q"&=�#�G8*�Q&�1!Dg�HBGO#&=%CK_)i(_K9�2�:8tr/)0R �-R�&=�#�G8*�H&�1+DyK9)i(_K_�i�:8�fc�I)�K��j5I1�"#1-&�8* �(�(�13 #"65´�!".%j8d)i&=�71+Dg�#�[s1+DyOI���!"���� )/8�)i" 3 � &=�#��)i"#&=�Q(98*�JK�&*)i1-"j1+Dy&����lK�1-(=(��:8=O613"65A)2"�,z�6�:�TDE8*O6�3KM�:8HRCb0&�)�8��lKM13"#x-�MvO61+�2%<�#�:5I(�13"�������;pfc��1<8*��D��-K��Q&98��+(���&_�+"#,-�H"#&E&�1w&=�#��O6�+(_�!}�1+�21+)/5�R��g�#�t)2".&=�Q(98*�JK�&*)i1-"41+Dg&��.)/8K�1-"�xA��v'8*�Q&�f�)i&����y�T)i"��A;3(��QO�(��:8=�H"#&0)i"#,P��O��Q"$K_)��#1!DK_)i(_K9�i�J8m)�8�Bw�35I�� #OG1!D�&����E�MvI&�(=�QBw�:�#�QBGO�&�%K9)2(9K_�i�J8�1+Dy&��.)�8�O6�Q"6K9)���rd8*�Q�9Pp)2,3 #(=�X�Is9Rhb0"�,-�H"#�H(_�:�y&=�#�H(��C�!(���kH�Q(=1´1-(7&0f�1|8* $K_����v�&=(��HBw�J�K9)2(9K_�i�J8HR������J8*��K9)2(9K_�i�J8c�+(���&������QBGO�&�%7K_)i(_K9�2�:8�1!D�&=�#��O��Q"$K_)���O6�38�8d)i"#,'&���(�1- �,-�C��O61!)i"#&�1+D�� � R®[�JKH�! $8*��&����Q(��E)�8[��v$�3KM&0�i%�13"#��K9)2(9K_�i��1!D���O6�H"6K9)T��O$�-8�8d)i"#,'&=�#(�13 #,3�~�t,+)ixA�H"�O�1!)i".&:;3&�����5I�Q&=�H(�LB�)i"6�+&*)i13"l1!D�&=�#����v�&=(��HBw�J��QB7O#&=%GK_)i(_K9�2�:8[1+D���,+)2x<�Q"GO��H"6K9)T�KH�!"�}���xA)i�Qf��J57�:½A .)2x<�:�2�H"A&0�2%<;<�38&=�#��5I�H&��H(�B�)i"6�+&*)i1-"41+D�&=�#��O61!)i"#&98[1+D�� � 13"l&=�#�:8*�tK9)2(9K_�i�J8HR

��� ��

( � ( � (�� � �

���������������� & �'� �#�����( �

���������������� & �'� �#�����( � ����� ( �

� � & ��� �������

�� �+����������������������

�� ��

���������������� & �'� �#�����( �

�� ������������ & �����#�����( �

�� ������������ & �����#�����( � �'��� ( �

Pp)i,- �(��S�$ÇgWA�H&c1+D��HBGO#&=%wK_)i(_K9�2�:8b0"�O6�+(�&0)/K� I���!(Q;!D/1-(g��KM13"6K��Q".&�(0)/K[O6�H"6K9)T�d;-&=�#��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"tf�)i&��w��x<�Q(�&0)�KQ�:�I�T)i"#�[)i" 3O�j,+)ixA�:8

&=�#���/�+(�,3�J8*&��QBGO�&�%wK9)2(9K_�i���$�!x-)2"�,G�',!)ix<�Q"~KM�H"#&=�Q(QR����I)�8cK9)2(_K9�i��O$�-8�8*�:8E&=�#(�13 #,3�4�G8d)i&=��1+D�� ��;"$�!BG���2%w&����t8d)i&=��1!D��#��fc�.)/K���)/8�&=�#��K_�i1<8*�:8*&c&=17&��#��K��Q"#&=�H(:R�b0"~1-&=�#�H(cfc13(_5#8�&�����O�(�10G0�JK�&0)213"1+D�� � �|13"l&=�#���#13(*)ikQ13"#&9�J��OI���+"#��)/8c&�����>�1-(�13"#1Q? @5A)��!,-(9�!B¿1!D�� � R$&%�� j zK{fV.m 3 * m�a��0_^V 1����������� ��!#".� �%$&!�')(�!#"�*,+-(/.0"1!2(3.0465�78'94:!"�<;='94?>A@B$C!�'D5�!#4?E#.F79*G+�E#.FHIE#7J!K(&;L"FM�!!KNO"1HC!#PQ'97!#P35�"1RSET.0H,E#7J!K(�*G+U@VE&'94W$G!Q+K*YXZ4?>�.04eqGrF�i1-,[n�s["1.FPQ!\X�(/.049]´q�rdn�s[(^5_'9E&!`'94?>�q'r0ny�i13,gn�s5�HI!,5�H,*2E&!K(&(/.049]a"1.0PQ!cb

dfe2g�g:h�i �g�#�t�:�i,-13(*)i&��#B¸¨$(_8*&yK�1-"$8*&�(= 6KM&986�j� � �+"65�&=�#�H"4K�1-BGO� #&=�J8[)i"X3O��&����P)i".&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"1+Dc&=�#�7��)i"#�G(��QO�(��J8*�H"#&0)i"#,[@ f�)i&��´&�����KM13"#x-��vS�k���m;�f��I)�KM�´KQ�+"u}6��5.1-"���f�)i&��.)i"u&�����,!)ix<�Q"

Y

Page 9: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

}613 #"65�8HR�S³Z�¢zX-Y+a{b�D�&����Q(��E)�8["�1�)2".&=�Q(_8*�:K�&*)i1-"�}6�H&=f��H�Q"�&=�#���T)i"#���+"65 � � ��;<&����Q"��:����&�����K_)i(_K9�2�:81+D�&=�#�tO6�H"6K9)���K�1-"�&_�:)2"~8*13BG��O61+)2"�&_8�1!D��#��R �

� � �M�D�P��� �"� �����D�P������D��������� �����~���_��� ! ��� ��Q�D�P� �"!���.)�8[8*�:KM&0)i1-"�5.�J�:�/8�f�)i&���&=�#�cBw�J)i"�O#(=1-}.�2�HB¡1!D�&��.)/8�O6�+O6�Q(PÇ�&=�#��K�1-"$8*&�(= 6K�&*)i1-"�1+Dp&=�#�y�������! #L"$�!%�&=(*)��!"�,- .�/�+&*)i13"41!D��w8*�Q&y�o1!D[n|O61!)i"#&98[}��M�i1-"�,!)i"#,7&�1��w8*�H&yµ 1!Dg·�OI���!"��J8HR�Äh�t8* �O#O61A8=�&=�6�+&�"#1�¨6x-��O61!)i"#&98��!(=��K�1<8*O��#�H(*)�KQ�:�0;�f��I)�K9�z)iBGOI��)i�J8�&=�6�!&y)i"u�:�-K��4OI���!"��7D/1- #(�O61+)i"#&98�KH�!"#L"�1-&P}��GK�1IK_)i(_K� I���!(QR'���I)�8���%.O�1-&=�#�J8d)�8�1+Dg"#1-"h5I�H,-�H"#�Q(9�!&=�7O61A8d)i&*)i1-"$8�KQ�+"|}6��(��HBG13xA�:5l 68d)i"#,8*&9�!"$5#�!(95�O��Q(=&� #(=}6�+&*)i1-"$8�&��:KM��"I)�½A ��J8HR�S³Z�¢z^ @ a���#�´�:�2,31-(*)i&=�#B 8*&_�+(�&98�D/(�1-B �u¨$(_8*&w&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(�1-"»�!"$5 �H"# �BG�Q(9�!&=�J8G�:�T��&=�#�´�y�M���! �"6�:%&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(_�~)i"o�z8* I)i&9�!}I�i��13(_5I�H(�&=1z}��~5.�M¨$"#�:5´���+&��H(:R`5��QBGBw�h`w)/8� 68*�:5²�38�5.�J8�K�(*)i}6�J5h)i"W-�JK�&*)i1-"��IRT`��38G�4�.)i"#&�&=1|5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#��&=�#�~�y�M���! �"6�+%j"#��)2,3�#}�1-('1!DP�+"��J�i(��:�-5I%²KM13"68*&=(� 6K�&��:5&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(�13"l&=�#(�13 #,3�41-"#��1!D�)i&_8[D��-K��Q&98HR� %(' ) V.WYm>,��f]dX 9 .�a�m WCXfV.]�9�� ��a�m5��HBGBw�´`-;fc�I)�KM�´8*1!�ix.�:8��9�+L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:�gO#(=1-}.�2�HBC;�KH�!"´}��G 68*�J5j&�1z8*1+�ix.�G�!L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)i1-"6�:�½- #�H(*)i�J8m)2"w��8*O6�JK9)��J��KQ�38*�AR+5��Q&1��}����yOI���!"���)i"�&=�#��Z� 6K9��)/5.�J�+"��!L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��8=O$�-K��A;A�!"$5��}6��&�����(_�-5A)/KH�J�OI���+"#��1!D���O��Q"6K9)���1!D�8*O#���Q(��:8Er�&�����(9�-5<)�KH�J��O.�/�+"#��)/8�&����t8*O��#�H(���1!D�&�����O6�Q"$K_)��f�)i&=�l)2".¨6".)2&=�t(_�35<)i 68�sP§#&����Q"4&=�#��)i"#&=�Q(98*�JK�&*)i1-"~1!D�&��#�'8*O#�#�H(��:8Ef�)i&=���¼)�8��GO6�H"6K9)T�m1!DgK9)i(_K_�i�:8fc��1<8*��(_�35<)�KQ�:���:v.)�8E)�8S����� rd8*�Q� Pp)2,3 #(��GY<s_R 5��H&�� � }��G�~8*�H&P1!D�8d)i&��:8P)i"jOI���!"����R7�����

� ����� � �'! �-� . ������

� ����� � �'!��������%���

Pp)2,3 #(���Y��b0".&=�Q(_8*�:KM&0)i1-"�1!D[��O6�H"6K9)T�1!D�8*O#���Q(=�J8�f�)i&=�j��OI���+"#�-R

Page 10: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

��v�&=(��HBw�J���HBGO#&=%~8*O��#�H(��J8�rF)�D�&=�#�H(��t��v.)�8*&P�!"�%6s�fc�I)�KM�C5I1w"�1-&PK�1-"�&_�:)2"C�!"�%�O61+)2"�&c1+Dg� � �+(��13}#xA)i13 68d�i%w5I�Q&=�H(�B�)i"#�J5�}.%G&��#����v�&=(��QBw�:��QBGO�&�%wK_)i(_K9�i�J8�1!D�&�����O6�H"6K9)T�1!D�K9)2(9K_�i�J8HR����$�!"#�I8�&�15��HBGBw�~`3;$&=�I)�8cKQ�+"l}6�t5.1-"��P)i"jq�r/�i1-,gns�&0)iBG�AR

b�D�J���6&��#��O.���!"#�:86��)2"�µ �!(=��KM13"68d)�5I�H(��:57"#13f�;-&=�#�H"�&=�#�E��v�&=(��HBw�J���HBGO#&0%G8*O��#�H(��:8�f��I)�KM�5.1w"#13&yK�1-"#&9�J)i"C�!".%�O61+)2"�&c1+D�� ��� � M �#�²KQ�+"4}6��5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:5�)2"~&�fg178*&��HO68HR�Pp)i(_8*&*�i%<;.D/13(�:�-K��PO.���!"#�6��;:&=�#���MvI&�(=�QBw�:�I8*O��#�H(��:8�f��I)�KM��5I1�"#13&�K�1-"�&_�:)2"��+"#%cO61!)i"#&{1+DI�#�C�+(���5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:5�R�����Q"p;-fc�c8*���2�:KM&�DF(=1-B &=�#�y�!&�BG1<8*&W�-·�KQ�!"$5<)�5#�+&��c8*O#���Q(=�J8�&=�#�EO61A8�8d)2}.�2�y8*1!�i #&0)i1-"68��-8mDF1+���213fy8HR

5��Q&��"UHB�� � BMR:RQR�B����wÃ� �3·�}6�l&=�#�zKQ�+"65<)�5#�+&��z8*O#�#�H(��:8HR Z��-K������O$�-8�8*�:8�&=�#(�13 #,3�o�O61+)2"�&�à � 1!D��ER�IJ���Mv#�!B�)i"��P)i"l&= #(�"~�J�3KM�~KH�!"65A)�5#�!&=�t8*O��#�H(����!"65�;$�+&E8=&=�HO� �;� � `�R:RMR�Ãp;Ifc�Bw�:)2"�&_�:)i"�&����tr0�+&gBG1<8*&�&0f�1Is�8*O��#�Q(=�J8�fc�I)�KM�w5I1'"#13&�KM13"#&9�J)i"��!"�%�Ã��HB����� �R����.)/8gKQ�+"��:�-8d)��i%}6��5.1-"��P)i"4q'r0·{s�&0)2BG�-R

b0"�&=�I)�8�f��:%-;:)i&�)�8mO�1A8�8d)2}.�i��&=1�¨$"65'&=�#�c"#��)2,3�.}61-(_8�1!D��y,+)2x<�Q"��y�M���+ #"6�+%t&=�H&�(_�+�#�:5I(�13"R+5��H&È<ÉMÊ�}6���ED��3KM�[1+D$&=�#�c�������! #"$�:%�&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)213";+&=�I)�8�D��-K���}6�M�i1-"�,<8�)2"�,3�Q"#�H(_�:�I&=1y&�fg1y�y�M���+ #"6�+%&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(_�wÈ<ÉMÊM�~�+"654È<ÉMÊ��AR����#��K9)i(_KM �Bw8�KM(0)2}.)2"�,�8*O#���Q(��:8E1+D�&=�#�:8*�t&0f�17&��H&�(9�!���J5.(_�w�!(=�t&����&=f�1'��v�&=(��HBw�J��QBGO�&�%w8*O��#�Q(=�J8�1+D�&=�#��O��H"6K9)���1+D�8*O��#�H(��J8�fg)2&=�4K�1-BGBG13"lO�1!)i".&_8gÈ.ÉMÊ+R������������� (/!#"p�*,+yn�5�*Y.F4?"F( 7JRO.04�] .F4�· 5�7J'Y4:!K(AEK'94�$&!-5�H,!,5�H,*TEI!K(&(/!&>a.04�q�rdn��213,�n�s3"1.FPQ!'94?>´q�rdn�sU(^5:'9EI!K;Q(�* " M�'9"Q" M�! "���*��6!#7J'9X�4:'YR "1!T"1H,'cM�!�>9H,' '9>��K'9E&!#4:"f"1*�'�]Y.! #!T4�6!#7J'9X�4:'9R"1H�.0'94�]Y7J! EK'94�$&!f>9!#"1!#H�P .04?!K>a.04Cq'r0·��i1-,gns "1.FPQ!Ob� % $ | �0V 1 WY]dX>WY_�9�a7mw]¶g � 1�����J8*�G(��QBw�+(��I8�%A)i�M��5u��8d)iBGOI�i���:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B &=1zK�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&P&=�#���y���/�+ #"$�!%~&=(*)��!"#,3 I���!&0)i1-"u1+D��8*�H&g1!DnlO61!)i"#&98��i%-)2"�,�)i"l·7OI���!"��J8HR����#�y�J�i,-13(*)i&���B¸8*&9�!(�&98mDF(=1-B¶1-"#�E)i"I)i&0)/�:�{&=�H&�(_�+�#�:5I(�13"~�!"$5&=�#�H"�K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&98�&�����f��#1!�i�c8*�Q&�1+D��y�M���! �"6�:%�&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(_��)i"6K�(��HBG�Q".&9�J���i%.R�b0"�1-(95I�H(�&=1'�-K9�.)2�Hx-�����)i"#�:�!(y8*O$�-K���KM13BGOI�i�Mv<)i&�%-;If���O#(=1IKM�:8�8E&=�#��&��H&�(9�!���J5I(9��)2"C�!"413(_5I�H(c&=�6�+&y�Q"$8* #(��:8E&=�6�+&c&=�#� �"I)i1-"41+Dg�J�i(��:�-5.%CKM13"68*&=(� 6K�&��:5l&��H&=(_�!���J5.(_�G(��HBw�J)i"68y8d)iBGOI�i%CKM13"#"��JK�&��:54�!&y�:�-K��48*&=�QO41+D�&=�#�)i"6K�(��HBG�Q"�&_�:�KM13"68*&=(� 6K�&*)i13"R

���I)�8GKH�!"e}6�z�-8�KM�H(�&9�J)i"#�:5²}�%´Bw�!�-)2"�,´ 68*�~1!D�&����lBG�:KM�$�!".)/8*B±1!D�8*�#���T��)i"#,z)2"�&�(=1<5I $KM�:5}�%�®[(� �,-,3�J8�8*�H(P�!"65~¢z�!".)0SV®�¢´\<`MapD/1-(yO#(=1+xA)i"#,7&��6�+&�&��#��}61- #"$5#�+(�%CK�1-BGOI�i��v~1+Dg�!".%~K�1-"�x!��vO61+�2%<&�13O���)�8G8*�#�����/�+}I�i��)2"��+"#%h5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"pS³®�¢´\<`3;�U�(=1-O61<8d)i&0)213"��+a�Ru���.)/8�)/5.�J�z�6�38��J�i(��:�-5.%}6�H�Q"4��v�O.�21+)2&=�:5�}#%~W-�M)�5I���0S­WA��)�X-�+a��+"65�&=�#��(��:�-5.�Q(yKH�!"C�J��8*1w(���DF�H(c&=1G�.)/8�O$�!O6�H(:R

���#���+Ld5A)iBG�Q"$80)i13"6�J�p�����/�+ #"$�!%�&=(*)��!"�,- .�/�+&*)i13"w)�8�)i"#&=�H(�O#(=�Q&=�J5��38����-L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$�J�8d)iBGOI��)iLK9)/�:���213f��H(�KM1-"�x!��v��� I���#"o1!D�O61!)i"#&98[13"4�'O6�+(_�!}�1!�i1+)/5�R65��H&%$¸}6���t��)i"#��O6�+(_�J���i�M�m&�17&����t�:v.)�81+Dp&=�#�EO$�!(9�!}�1!�i1!)�5�;A�!"$5')iBw�!,+)2"����!"�13}68*�H(�x-�Q(�BG1+x-)2"�,'5I1+fc"G�J�i13"#,&$ D/(�1-B¡&=�#��)2"�&��H(_8*�JK�&0)213"O61+)2"�&P1!D%$ �+"65'"�R����.)/8�13}68*�Q(=x-�Q(P(��QO�1-(=&_8�¨6(98*&�&=�#�7D��-K��Q&<@ U 1!D("¼�.)i&�}#%)$ �!"$5�;��38��#�BG13x-�J8�5.1+fc"~�J�i1-"�,�$z;<����(��HO�13(�&98�&����PD��-K��Q&98�@ � B:RMRQR�B&@+*m)i"l&=�#��1-(_5.�Q(c&=�#�H%�}6�:KM13BG��x-)�8d)2}.�2�rd8*�Q�9Pp)2,3 #(��C�.s9R²���.)/8�13(_5I�H(7KQ�:�T�i�:5²&����48*���M����)2"�,´13(_5I�H(�)�8t,+)2x<�Q"�}#%´&=�#�~�+&�&=(*)i}# �&*)i1-"�1!D��O�(*)i1-(*)i&=%�&=1w�:�-K9��D��-K��Q&�1!D,"�Rg������O�(*)i1-(*)i&=%G1!Dg��D��3KM�H&�)�8c&����t�:�2&0)i&� $5I��1!D�&=�#��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"�1!D)i&_8�8* �O#O61-(=&*)i"#,l�I%<O6�Q(=OI���!"��7fg)2&=�-$±�+"654&�����8*�#���T��)i"#,�1-(95I�Q(�1!Dg&����7D��-K��Q&98�K�1-(�(=�J8*O�1-"$5#8�&=1&=�#��5.�JK�(��:�-8d)i"#,G13(_5.�Q(y1!D�&=�#�:8*�tO#(*)i13(*)2&0)i�J8HR[®g(= #,-,3�J8�8*�H(P�!"$5l¢z�!".)0SV®�¢´\<`Ma��H"68* #(=�J8�&=�6�+&y&��.)/813(_5I�H(�)�8��',-1<1I5~8*�#�M����)i"#,'1!D��Qx<�Q(=%GKM13"#x-��vGO61!�i%.&=1-O��-;-)0R �-R�&=�6�+&�D/1-(��:�T�. �; � ��0/ U @ � )�8c�'8d)2BGO.�i%K�1-"�"#�JK�&=�J5l�+L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:��&=1-O61!�i13,!)�KQ�:��}$�J����)2"��-L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"6�:�m8*O6�-K��AR

1y1+)2"�,�}$�-K9��&=1�&=�#��1-(*)i,!)i"6�:�#O#(=1-}I�i�HB 1!D�K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&0)i"#,P�!L�5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J�6�y�M���! �"6�+%�&�(0)/�+"#,3 #L���!&0)i1-";Ifc�y�!(����!}.�2��&=1wK�1-B7O# #&=��&=�#��O�(*)i1-(*)i&=%�1+D��:�-KM�G&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(=1-"´§$�+"65�;<)�D�&�����&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(_�

\

Page 11: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

��

� � � �� �

���

���

���

��

Pp)2,3 #(�����Ç[���#��8*�#���T��)i"#,71-(_5.�Q(

�+(��GKM13"68*&=(� 6K�&��:5l}#%�5I�:KM(��:�-8d)i"#,wO�(*)i1-(0)2&=%-;$&=�#��8*�H&y1!D�K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&=�J5l&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(_�G(=�QBw�:)2"$8�8d)iBGLO.�2%|KM1-"�"#�:KM&=�J5´�!&��:�-K��j8*&��HORwÄu���38�8* #BG��&=�6�+&���)i"#� $ )�8�)i"u,-�H"#�H(_�J��O�1<8d)i&0)213";�!"$5|&����Q(���+(���"�1C&0f�1l5A)/8*&0)2"$KM&P&=�Q&=(_�+�#�J5.(_�~fg)2&=�u&=�#�G8��!BG�GO#(*)i1-(0)2&=%jrd5I�Q,3�Q"��Q(9�-K9)2�:8�KQ�+"u}6��8*1+�2x<�J5l}�%O6�H(�&= #(�}.)2"�,�$C;#8*�Q��&�����"��MvI&y8*�:KM&0)213"�s9R

5��Q&�»}6��&�����8*�Q&�1+Dp�:�i(��J�35I%'KM13"68*&=(� 6K�&=�J5t&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(9��R�Äh�[Bw�:)2"�&_�:)2"�)i"G��O#(0)213(*)i&0%�½- #�H #�&=�#�~8*�H&'1!Dc&=�H&�(_�+�#�:5I(_�C"�1-&�)i"�G;�}# #&78*�$�!(*)i"#,4�~D��3KM��f�)i&=�²&=�#�G&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(9�C1!D GR�FE1-&0)/K��&=�6�+&:;�}.%C&�����(��:8* I�i&P1!DE®g(= #,-,3�J8�8*�H('�!"$5|¢z�+"I)dSV®�¢´\A`Ha[�~&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(�1-"´1!Dg&=�#��½- #�H #��8*�$�!(��:813"#�-;$&�f�171-(y&=�#(��H��D��3KM�:8Ef�)i&=��¿§$&��. $8[)2&P�+O#O6�:�!(98E13"#��&=fg1�13(y&���(��H�t&*)iBG�:8[)2"4&=�#��O#(*)i13(*)i&�%½- #�H #��r�f�)i&=�|&=�#��8��+BG��O#(*)i1-(0)2&=%6s9R�] &��H&=(_�!���J5.(�1-"4)�8EO�(��J8*�H"#&y13"I�i%~1-"$KM�t)�D��!"65l13"I�i%~)TDg13"#�1+Dm)i&98Ex-�H(�&*)�K��J8[�$�-8c"#�Hx-�Q(g}��H�Q"CKM13"68d)�5I�H(��:5l8*1�D��+(:R

]�8c�J���&������������! #"$�!%G&=�Q&=(_�+�#�J5.(_�7�-5RG=�3KM�H"#&g&�1�¡�+(���O�(��:8*�Q"#&�)i"�&�����O�(*)i1-(*)i&=%w½A #�H #�-;Ifc�KH�!"u�H"68* �(���&��$�!&�&=�#��"��Mv�&P&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(�13"|)i"|&=�#��8*���M����)2"�,�)�8�&=�#�t¨6(_8*&P���2�HBG�Q"�&P1!Dg&�����½- #�H #�r/)0R �-RT;I&=�#�t13"#��f�)2&=�l&=�#���I)i,-���J8*&�O#(0)213(*)i&�%$s_R

���# $8[13 #(y�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B¸fg)T���(� #"C�-8[D/1!���i1-fy8yÇ`-R�Zmv��:KM �&��t&=�#��O#(=�QO�(�1IKM�:8�8d)i"#,w8*&=�QO~1!D15p�HBGBw� ��R��Rgbd"I)i&*)��:�T)ikJ�+&0)213"�Ç

rd�.sC¬�1-BGO� #&=�j��&=(*)��!"�,!�i�jÈ U É U Ê U 1!D�&=�#�´K�1-".x-�Mv��. I���'r/D/1-(w�Mv#�!BGO.�2�j&=�#�4¨6(98*&GD��3KM�O#(�1I5. 6K��J5�}#%G&�����,+)TD/&�fc(_�+O#OI)i"#,��J�i,-13(*)i&���BCS³U�W.X3Y!a/s9R

r�}�s�¬�1-BGO� #&=�t� U � Ã�� ���F���F� 68d)i"#,5��QBGBw� ��Rr0KJs����+�A���-8 $¼�!"�%L9xA�H(�&0)/KH�J� N��T)i"#��)i"tÀ Á ¤ O6�-8�8d)i"#,E&���(�1- �,-���cO61+)2"�&$à � 1!D#&��#��)2".&=�Q(*)i13(1!D�&=�#��D��3KM�H&yÈ U É U Ê U � U ��)TD/&=�J5�1-"~&����2�-L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)i1-"6�:�O6�!(9�!}61+�21+)/54r�"�1-&0)�KM��&��$�!&Q;<}#%

X

Page 12: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

KM13"68*&=(� 6K�&*)i1-"~1!D $C;#ÈEUHÉ�UHÊ�UH�0UE)�8�&����P¨$(_8*&�D��-K���)2"~&����t8*�#�����T)i"#,'13(_5I�H(�)i"65. 6K��J5�}#%$~s_R

r056s7b0"$8*�Q(�&EÈ U É U Ê U � U )i"l&=�#��O#(*)i13(*)i&�%w½A ��Q ��AR��R����QO��J�+&

rd�.sXPp)i"65�&����P¨$(_8*&c&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(�13"4È<ÉMÊM��)i"l&=�#��O#(0)213(*)i&�%w½- #�Q ��A;r�}�s7b�DgÈ<ÉMÊM�C�+O#O6�:�!(_8c1-".�2%~13"6K��A;{f�)i&=�#13 #&c�i1<8�8c1!D�,-�Q"��Q(9�J��)i&�%�� � à � � � Rcbd"68*�H(�&P&��H&�(9�!L�#�:5I(�13"uÈ<ÉMÊM��)i" w;�KM13BGO# �&���à �

�  ;$à � �  �!"$5�à � �  ;$)i"68*�H(�&�È.ÉM�:à � �  ;�È.ÊM�:à � �  �+"65ÉMÊM�:Ã� �  )i"l&=�#�tO�(*)i1-(*)i&0%w½A ��Q ��ARr0KJs7b�D�È.É�ÊH���!O�O��:�!(98m&�fg)/K��A;Qf�)2&=�#13 #&��i1<8�8m1+D{,-�H"#�H(_�J��)i&�%�� � à � � � �!"$57Ê � à � �  R�bd"68*�Q(=&&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(=1-"4È<ÉMÊM��)i"�G;{K�1-BGO� #&=�Eà �

�  �!"$5�à � �  ;�)i"$8*�Q(�&EÈ.ÊM�:à � �  �+"65lÉ�ÊH�Qà � �  )i"&�����O#(0)213(*)i&�%w½- #�H #�-Rr056s7b�D�È<ÉMÊM�G�+O#O6�:�!(_8�&=�#(��H��&*)iBG�:8H;<f�)i&���1- #&��i1A898�1+D�,-�H"#�H(_�J��)i&�%'� � à � � � ;IÊ � à � �  �+"65É � à � �  R�b0"$8*�Q(�&P&=�Q&=(_�+�#�:5I(�13"uÈ<ÉMÊM��)i" w;�KM13BGO# �&���à � �  ;$)i"68*�Q(=&�ÉMÊM�:à � �  )i"|&=�#�O#(*)i1-(0)2&=%w½A ��Q ��AR¾E"#&0)T��&����t½A ��Q ��P)�8��QB7O#&=%-R

� %�� [2V.WY_d]^X 9��v]ug �>lfV797V.XfV.mwW-,�]dV�cbd"�&��.)/8'8*�JK�&*)i1-"p;�f�����v�OI���J)i"��#13f¡&�1|5.�J�:��f�)i&���5I�H,-�H"#�H(_�3K_)i�J8�&��$�!&'Bw�:%j1#KQK� #(75I ���&�1|�+" �"I�i 6K��.%zKM��1!)�KM��1!D $CR�$ )�8��~x.�H(�&0)�KQ�:����)2"��A;p)i" �3Ld5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��8*O6�3KM�-;�5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:5|}#%C&����¨$(_8*&'&��.)2(95eK�1<1-(_5A)i"6�!&=�J8�1!Dgà � ÇX7 � ;"8 � �+"65�� � R $ )/8� $8*�J5u&=1´8*13(�&78*1-B7�l�.%.O6�H(�OI���+"#�:8�3KQK�1-(_5A)i"#,G&=1w&=�#�M)i(�)i".&=�Q(_8*�:KM&0)i1-"lO61+)i"#&98[f�)i&�� $CR

b�D $±O6�-8�8*�:8�&���(�1- �,-��8*1-B7��x.�H(�&0)/K��J8H;��J5.,-�:8t13( �!L�D��3KM�:8t1+Dc&=�#�~�!(=(_�!"�,-�HBG�Q".&�1!D��#%.O��Q(=LO.�/�+"#�:8H;y&����Q"Nfc�j�+(��|)i"��²5.�Q,-�H"#�H(_�+&��´KQ�38*��Ç $ )2"$5I $KM�:8�1-".�2%���O$�!(�&0)��J��13(_5I�H(~13"�&=�#���%.O#�H(�O.�/�+"#�:8HR�®[ #&Q;$)i&�)�8�K9�2�:�!(Q;$DF13(�K�1-".&0)2". I)i&0%~(��:�-8*13"68H;{&=�6�+&c)2&y)�8�O61<8�8d)i}.�2��&=1~&=(_�!"$8d���!&=� $}�%��P8*Bw�J���6�#1-(0)2kH1-"�&_�:�#x.�:KM&=1-(��� rT7�BC8��B�� Jsm8* 6K9�7&=�6�+&�&=�#�c1-(_5.�Q(�)2"$5I $KM�:57}#% $����� )�8��y&�13&_�:�13(_5I�H(yK�1-BGO$�!&0)2}.�2��f�)2&=�l&=�#��1-(95I�H(�)2"$5I $KM�:5�}�% $lR

���#���J�i,31-(*)i&=�#B�)�KPfy�:%G&=1�¨$"65��� )�8E&=�#��D/1!���21+f�)i"�,CÇI b�D $¼O6�-8�8*�:8&=�#(=1- �,-��8*1-B7�[x.�H(�&���v���1+D$&=�#���+(�(_�+"#,-�HBG�H"I&1!D$�.%.O6�H(�O.�/�+"#�:8H;+f���&�(9�!"68d���+&��$�&=1&$ U )i"�&����S7~5<)i(��:KM&0)i1-"�}#%G�'8* ���K_)i�Q"�&*�i%'8*Bw�J����!B71- #"�&g8*1'&=�6�!&g"�1 �!L�D��3KM��1+D�&�����!(�(9�!"#,3�QB7�Q"#&�)�8cK�(�1<8�8*�:5�R���#�9�!L�D��3KM�:8�)2"$K_)�5I�H"#&'&=1���KH�!"#"�1-&w}6�zKM(�1A8�8*�J5�}#%�$ 5I �(*)i"#,´)i&_8GBG1+x-�AR��c1!fg�HxA�H(:;)TD�8* 6K9���4D��3KM����)�8�O6�+(_�J���i�M��&=1|&�����7�5<)i(��:KM&0)213";g�:���y&=�#�~x.�H(�&0)/KH�J���T)i"��J8�}��Q&0fg�Q�H" $�!"65-$ U f�)����g)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&���Ru���#�~8d)i&� $�!&0)i1-"eBw�:%h8*&0)T����}6�C5I�H,-�H"#�H(_�!&=�A;�)�D $ �6�38t}6�H�Q"&�(_�+"68d���!&=�:5²�:�213"#,u�!"��J5.,-��)i"6K9)/5.�Q"�&�&�1��6R FE1-&0)�KM�~�#1+fg�Qx-�Q(�&=�6�+&:;�DF13(w�z8* ���K_)i�Q"�&*�i%8*Bw�J���gO6�H(�&= #(�}$�!&0)213";p)i&�)�8�"#1-f )iBGO61<8�8d)i}I�i��&��$�!& $ O6�-8�8*�:8t&=�#(=1- #,3���~x<�Q(�&=��vj1+Dc&=�#��!(�(9�!"#,3�QB7�Q"#&QR�bd"48* 6K��~�GKH�-8*��fc��&�(9�!"$80���+&�� $��-8[)i"65A)/KH�!&=�J5�}6�M�i1-f�R

I b�D,$¸O$�-8�8*�:8[&���(�13 #,-�C8*1-BG���:5I,3�S�7r�}� #&g"�1-&E�tx<�Q(=&���v�s1!D�&=�#���!(�(9�!"#,3�QBG�H".&g1!D���%.O#�H(�LOI���!"��J8H;<fg�E&=(_�!"$8d�/�+&�� $ U &�1 $ � )2"�&=�#�S8�5<)i(��:KM&0)i1-"�}.%G��8* ���K_)i�Q"�&*�i%G8*Bw�:�T���!BG13 #"�&g8*1&��$�!&�"#1��+L�D��3KM��1!D�&������!(=(_�!"�,-�HBG�Q".&�)�8�K�(�1A8�8*�J5�R

^

Page 13: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

P$1-(��G8* ���K_)i�Q"�&*�i%w8*Bw�J���O��H(�&= #(�}$�!&0)i1-";<)i&�)�8�"#13fo)iBGO61A8�8d)2}.�2��&=�6�!& $¸O6�38�8*�J8�&=�#(�13 #,3��!"e�:5I,3��1!DP&����4�+(�(_�+"#,3�QBG�H"#&Q;�}� #&78*&0)T���EO61<8�8d)i}I�i�~&��$�!& $�)i"#&=�Q(_8*�:KM&7� �+L/D��-K��A;�fc�#�H"1-"#��1!D�&=�#���!L�D��-K��J8cK�1-".&9�J)i"I)i"#, �P)�8[O$�!(_�:���2����&=17&����K8AL��Jv<)/8HRgWA17f���O6�H(*D/1-(=BC;�13"#��BG1-(=�O6�Q(�&= #(=}6�!&0)i1-"pR

I b�D $¸O6�38�8*�J8[&=�#(=1- �,-�48*13BG�/�+L�D��3KM��1!D�&=�#���!(�(9�!"�,-�HBG�Q"�&�1!D��#%<O#�H(�OI���+"#�:8Q;Ifc�c&�(9�!"68d���+&��$ � &�1)$ ¦ � $¶� �� )2"u&=�#� �45A)i(��JK�&*)i13"u}#%C�C8* ���K_)i�H"#&0�2%z8*Bw�J���[�!B71- #"�&�8*1~&=�6�+&�"#1�!L�D��3KM��1!D�&=�#�t�+(�(_�+"#,3�QBG�H"#&�)�8cKM(=1<8�8*�:5�R

Äh��5I1w"�1-&�"#�H�J5l&=1wK�1-BGO� #&=�t&�������v$�3KM&yx-�:�i #��1!D��� R�b0"lD��-K�&�&������T)i"#� $¸)�8�O��H(�&� �(�}$�!&=�J513"I�i%~fc�#�H"j�w5I�H,-�H"#�H(_�-K�%�)�8E�H"6K�1- �"I&=�Q(=�J5�;$&=�I)�8c5I�Q,3�Q"��Q(9�-K�%�)/8y8*1!�ix.�:5w�i1IKH�J���2%<;�)dR �ARg13"I�i%~&����13(_5I�H('1-"u&=�#���#%<O#�H(�OI���+"#�:8P)i"#x-1+�2x-�:5C)i"�&�����K� #(�(=�Q"#&�5.�Q,3�Q"#�H(_�3KM%j)�8�KM13BGO# #&=�:5�R´«E"$KM�G&����5.�Q,3�Q"#�H(_�3KM%G)/8y8*1!�ix-�J5�;<fc�� 68*���!,A�J)i"4&=�#�P)i".)2&0)��J���T)i"#� $CR

¢C1-(=��O#(=�JK9)/8*���2%<;p)�Dy8*�Hx.�H(_�J��O�1!)i".&_8cà �� ��!(=��1-"�&=�#��&=1-O�1+Dc&=�#��O#(0)213(*)i&0%´½A ��Q �� �°f�)i&=�

&=�#��8��!BG��O#(*)i13(*)i&�%-;If���K�1-"$8*&�(= 6KM&��!"4�+ Iv<)T��)��!(=%�O#(0)213(*)i&0%~½- #�H #� � U fc���Q(=��&=�#��O#(*)i1-(0)2&0)i�J8c�+(��K�1-BGO� #&=�J5u�3KQK�1-(95<)i"#,C&=1|����)2"�� $ U r $±&�(9�!"$8d�/�+&��:5z)i"u&����Q7h5<)i(��JK�&0)213"�s9R����#�G1-".�2%´O61+)2"�&_8)i"68*�H(�&=�J5l)2" �/U��+(���&���1<8*��f�)i&��j&=�#�G8��!BG��rd�!"654�I)i,3�#�J8*&Ms�O#(*)i13(*)i&�%�)i" � §{)i"|&=�6�+&�fE�J%3;$&�����+BG1- �"#&�1!D�&����27�&=(_�+"68d���!&0)i1-"~5I1<�:8�"#1-&�Bw�!&=&��H(g8d)i"6K��E&=�#��1-".�2% �!L�D��3KM�:8m)2"G&��#�M�-L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��+(�(_�+"#,3�QBG�H"#&'1!DE�#%.O��Q(=OI���!"#�:8�O#(=�J8*�H"#&�)i" � U �+(��C�J���E�-5 G��3KM�H"#&'&=1 �´�!"$5²&=�. 68�KH�!"�"#13&G}6�K�(�1<8�8*�:5ufc�#�H" $�BG13x-�J8�&=1'$ U!RlÄ �#�Q" ��U7)�8t�HBGO#&0%-;fc��KH�!"�,-1z}$�-K9�j&=1z&����� $8*��1!D��GRb�Dg8*1-B7�tO61!)i"#&98��6�+x!��&=�#��8��+BG�tO�(*)213(*)i&�%G)i" � U ;{fg�tK�(��:�!&=���!"j�+ Iv<)T��)��!(�%C½- #�H #��� � &=1�8*1!�ix.�&=�I)�8�5.�Q,3�Q"��Q(_�3KM%<;��!"$5uO�1A8�8d)2}.�2%h�z½- #�Q �� � ¦ R`P$(=1-B &�����(��:�-8*1-"$8��+}61-x-�A;�DF13 #(7½A ��Q ��J8��+(��8* ���K_)i�Q"�&:R� %�� o a 1�* _^V��5]¶g 3�����tK�1-BGO.�2��v.)i&=%G1!D�&��.)/8y�J�i,-13(*)i&=�#B¿KH�!"l}6���!"$�J�i%.kH�J5~�-8�DF1+���21+fy8HR

WA&=�QO´`�)�8cKM13BGOI�i�Q&=�:5w)i"jq�rdnc�i13,cns�&0)iBG�t�+"65� 68*�J8cq'r0ns�8*O6�3KM��}.%�5��HBGBw� �IRWA&=�QO9�-��)/8c5.1-"��P)i"jq�rdn�s�&*)iBG�-RWA&=�QO9�!}~&_�+�.�:8�q�rd·[�i13,gn�s[&*)iBG��}.%X5p�HBGBw� ��RWA&=�QO9�-K��!"$5��-5~�!(��'5I1-"��P)i"4K�1-"$8*&_�+"#&g&0)2B7�AR]�&P�J�3K9�|)i&��H(_�!&0)i1-"u1+D�W-&��HOe�l�~"#�Hf¡&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(�1-"u)�8��-5#5.�J5j&�1C&=�#�~�y�M���+ #"6�:%z&�(*)��+"#,- �L

���!&0)i1-"�&��� 68�&=�I)�8�8*&=�HO|)/8��MvI�JK� #&=�J5u�P&0)iBG�J8HR|«EO6�Q(9�!&0)213"68t13"u&=�#��O#(0)213(*)i&�%z½A ��Q ��~�!(��w5I13"#�)i"jq�r/�i1-,�n�s[&*)iBG��r��Qx-�Q"�)�Dg�! .v.)���)/�+(�%~O#(0)213(*)i&�%�½A ��Q ��J8y�!(��t $8*�J5l&=1�8*1!�ix-�t5.�Q,3�Q"��Q(_�3K_)i�:8�s_;{&=�#�5.�Q&=�Q(�B')2"$�!&0)213"�1!D�tO61+)i"#&�à � ��� )/8g5I13"#��)i"~q�rd·[�i1-,[n�s�&0)2B7�E}#% 5��QBGBw� ���!"65�&=�#��K�1-B7O# #&9�!L&0)213"l1+D�&=�#��O�(*)i1-(*)i&=%G1!D���&��H&�(_�+�#�:5I(�13"l&9�!�<�J8�K�1-"68*&9�!"�&g&*)iBG�-R��g�# 68�&=�#��1-x-�Q(9�J����K�1<8*&�1!DgWA&=�HO��)/8yq�r��=·��i1-,[n�s9R

Z��-K��l)2&=�QB¿)2"j&�����O#(*)i1-(0)2&=%C½A ��Q ���K�1-(�(=�J8*O61-"$5#8�&=1l�~&=(*)/�+"#,+�2��13"|&=�#��}61- �"65��!(�%z1!Dg&�����:�2(=�J�35I%�K�1-"68*&=(� $KM&=�J5�&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(9��R�]P87&=�#�C&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(9�´�!(=�l(=�QO61-(=&��:5²)i"o�h8*�#�����T)i"#,|1-(95I�Q(Q;&=�#�:8*��&�(*)��+"#,!�i�:8tDF13(�B �4&=1-O61+�i1-,!)�KH�J��8*O#���Q(��-;��!"65u}�%´Z� I�i�Q(:ºV8�(��M���!&0)i1-"�&����Q(���)�8��+&'BG1<8*&7���)i"#�:�!(c"� #B'}#�Q(�1!D�8* 6K���&�(*)��+"#,!�i�:8HR�W-1w&����t8d)ikQ��1!D�&=�#��O�(*)i1-(0)2&=%w½A ��Q #��)�8cqGr0ns_R�� ��g�e#�:�� �jM�!�"FM�HC!I! >9.FPQ!#4Z(/.0*94?'97 �6!#7J'9XZ4?'9R" H�.0'949]YXZ7J'9"1.0*94 *G+�n 5:*9.F4?"F(�7JRO.F49].F4�·65�7J'Y4:!K(EK'Y4`$C!<E/*9P35�XZ"1!I>aX9(/.04�]Gq'r��*·��213,gns " .0PQ! '94?>�q�rdn�s !KNO"1HI' (^5:'9EI! � M�!#H,!c�<.�()"FM�!f(/.��/!Q*,+f" M�!*9X�"85�XZ" b

` @

Page 14: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

� � � !-�����´����� Q�D�P� �"!bd"l&=�#��8*O��:K_)��J�mKH�-8*��1!D�1-".�2%w&0f�1'O.�/�+"#�:8H;.)i&g)/8�O�1<8�8d)i}I�i��&�1�8*O6�Q�:5� #O~&����t�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#BCR����.)/8[)�8)i"�D��-K�&P�',-�H"#�Q(9�J��)ikJ�+&*)i1-"~1!D�&����t�:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B�D/1-(�&�fg1'O6�+(_�J���i�M�OI���+"#�J8M�¡�!"65 �GRTSV®[1!)�X-X+a

b0"»®[1!)�8�8*1-"�"6�+&:ºV8~O6�!O6�H(:SV®[1!)�X-X+a�;c)i&lfy�-8w8*�#13fc"�&=�6�+&�&����u&=�#(��H�u5A)iBG�Q"$80)i13"6�J�t>[13(�13"#1:?@5A)/�+,-(_�+B r0�+"65l&=�# 68�&=�#���y�M���! �"6�!%w&�(0)/�+"#,3 I���!&0)i1-"�s[1!D�� � � � � KH�!"4}6�t13}#&9�J)i"#�:5l}.%~8* �O��H(�L)iBGO61<8d)i"�,�&=�#��&0f�1 �+L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:�I>�1-(=1-"�1:?@#5<)��!,3(_�+Bw81+D{�#�z�!"$5�� � R�bd&�f�)��T�#}6�c8*�#13fc"�)2"�&�����+O#O6�H"65<)�v~&=�6�+&c&=�#��8d)i&� $�!&0)213"�D/1-(�"#1-"~O6�+(_�J���i�M��O.���!"#�:8[)�8c½A I)i&=�t8d)iB�)��/�+(�Ç�&����t�+Ld5A)2BG�H"68d)i13"6�J��y�M���+ #"6�+%G&�(*)��+"#,- .���!&0)213"l)/8�13}#&9�J)i"#�:5�}�%w8= �O��H(*)iBGO61A80)i"�,G&=�#�t>[13(�13"#1Q? @5A)/�+,-(9�!Bw8c1!D�� � �+"65� � D/1-(P&����7�.%<O6�Q(�}61+��)/KtBG�H&�(0)/K�r�(��JKH�J���i�J5l)2"j&=�#�G�!O�O��H"65<)�v{s_R �E13f��HxA�H(:;# 68d)i"#,�&�����8*O$�-K��71+DK9)2(9K_�i�J8H;+)i&m)�8�O61<8�8d)i}I�i��&�1�5I�H(*)ix.�[BG13(��c&�(_�3KM&9�!}.�2��r/�T)i"��J�+(Hs5<)��!,3(_�!Bw8�&��$�!&gKH�!"�}6�� 68*�:5')2"$8*&��:�-51+D�&=�#�t�.%<O6�Q(�}61+��)/K�1-"��J8HR

5��Q&/�Æ�!"$5 �Æ}6�G&�����&=f�1~O.�/�+"#�:8��!"65´5I�H"#1-&=���g&=�#��K�1-BGB71-"|��)i"#�Q��� ��Rw]P8P)i"u&=�#�O�(��JK��J5A)i"#,�8*�JK�&0)213";I&����tK��#1+)/K���1+D��7K_)i(_K9�i��Êc)2"9� 5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:8c�GO6�Q"$K_)��1!Dg8*O��#�H(��J8�Ç�&����t8*�H&1+Dg8*O#���Q(��:8�)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)2"�,�� �:�213"#,�Ê+RE���#��)i".&��H(_8*�:KM&0)i1-"l1+D�&=�I)�8EO��Q"$K_)���fg)2&=� � )�8��7O6�Q"6K9)���1!DK9)2(9K_�i�J8�)2" �GR�W-1$;<&=17�tO61+)i"#&�Êc1!D#3 �´fc�yKQ�!"w�-8�8*1#K_)��!&=������)i"#���3rdÊJs�)i"3 � R�¾�8d)i"#,t� G0 $5<)�K_)i1- $8K��#1+)/K��l1+D�K�1<1-(95<)i"6�+&��:87)i"��©�+"65 � &��.)/8G&=(_�!"$8dDF13(�Bw�+&*)i1-"�)/8G&=(*)ixA)��J�dR ¢C13(��4O#(=�JK9)/8*���i%.;�}#%K��#131<8d)i"#,w)2"j&=�#��&�f�1�8*%I8*&��HBw8�1+DcK�1<1-(95<)i"6�+&��:8�1!Dg&=�#��OI���!"��J8H;{&=�#��1-(0)2,+)i"|13"��g�+"65�g�38E&=�#�7�Ld�:v.)�8H;I&����tO6�Q"$K_)��1!D�K_)i(_K9�2�:8�)2"Q3 � 5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:5�}�%G&����tO61!)i"#&�Êy1!D�K�1�13(_5<)i"$�!&=�J8�rA< BV=^BV?�s�)i"3 � )�8��v$�3KM&0�i%t&=�#����)i"#��Ar0Ê:s{O$�!(_�:�T�i���I&=1�&=�#� =�L��Jv<)�8O$�-8�8d)i"#,P&���(�1- �,-�t&=�#��O61!)i"�&p1+DpK�1<1-(95<)i"6�+&��:8rA< B =MBV?�s�)i"X3 � ;#8d)i"6K����p)�8�&��#��(_�35<)�KQ�:���:v.)�8�1!D�&=�#�tO6�H"6K9)T��rd8*�Q��WA�:KM&0)213"��IRT`��!"$5�P)i,3 #(���\-s9Rb0"~&����t8*�:½A ��M�d;E34���+"653 � f�)����}6�P)�5I�H"#&0)T¨$�J5��!"$5l5.�Q"�1-&=�J5�3�R

�� ���

Pp)i,- �(���\<Çg¬g�-8*��1!D�&=f�1'OI���+"#�J8WA �O#O61<8*�G"#13f &=�6�!&tÈ.ÉMÊM�~)�8��C�y�M���! �"6�!%C&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(�1-"pR���fc1lKH�-8*�:8�Bw�+%41.KQK� #(wÇ�&=�#(=�Q�

1+D�&�����x<�Q(=&*)�KM�:8��+(���)i"l&=�#��8��+BG��O.�/�+"#���!"$5l1-"��P)i"4&�����13&����Q(:;#1-(c&=�#�H(����+(���&�f�17x.�H(�&*)�K��J8�)2"

`-`

Page 15: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

�:�-K���O.���!"#�-Rb0"�&=�#�E¨6(98*&�KQ�38*�A;-�i�Q&�È$;IÉy�+"65�Êc}6��&=�#��x<�Q(�&0)�KM�:8�)i"�� �!"$5���}���&����EDF13 #(�&=��x-�Q(�&=�Mv')2" �GR

������)i"#&=�Q(_8*�:KM&0)i1-"~1!D�&=�#�G8*O#���Q(��'K_)i(_K� #Bw8�K�(*)i}I)i"#,�È.É�ÊH�wf�)i&=���¡)�8c&�����K_)i(_K9�i��K_)i(_K� #Bw8�K�(*)i}I)i"#,È<ÉMÊG(��HO#(��:8*�Q".&=�J5z)i"`3e}#%z�4x-�H(�&=�Mv �41+Df� � � Rl���#��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"u1!D�&=�#��8*O��#�Q(=��f�)i&�� ��)�8(��HO#(=�J8*�H"#&=�J57)i"�3z}�%���O61+)2"�&g&��$�!&gBG $8*&��T)i��1-"~&����E�T)i"#��O6�+(_�:�T�i�M�&=1'&����/=�Ld�:v.)�8c�!"$5�O6�38�8d)i"#,&=�#(�13 #,3����Rw���.)/8c�T)i"#�G�I)i&_8 �����u)i"´�!&�BG1<8*&P&�fg1wO61+)2"�&_8�(=�QO�(��J8*�H".&*)i"#,�&=�#��O�1A8�8d)2}.�2���HBGO#&=%��v�&=(��HBw�J�K9)2(9K_�i�J8�)2" �GR������tr0�+&gBG1<8*&Ms�&�f�1PD��3KM�:8[1+D ��� � �.)2&g}�%�&=�#�E��)2"���KM13(�(��:8*O61-"$5w&=1�&=�#�&=f�1'O61A8�8d)2}.�2��O�1!)i"I&98��#R

b0"�&����j8*�JK�1-"$5eKH�-8*�-;[�i�H&wÈ_B_É`\ �©�!"$5oÊRB�� \ �GR P$1-(7�h8d)iB�)T���+(G(��:�-8*13";g&����4K9)i(_K_�i�:8fc�.)�KM�4�+(��t&=�#��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"l1+D�&=�#��8*O��#�Q(=�tf�)i&��9� �+"65 � ��)2��1-"j�!"4�:5I,3�t1!DD�j���´�!"$5���� �(��:8*O6�JK�&0)2x<�M�i%-R����#�:8*��&=f�1'O�1+)2".&98�1!D&3|�!(��t13"l&=�#��8��!BG����)2"���O$�!(_�:�T�i����&=1w&=�#�/=�L��Jv<)/8HR

W3)i"6K��~�J���E(��M�i�Hx.�+"A&���)2"��J8G�+(���O6�+(_�:�T�i�M�E&=1´&=�#��=�L��Jv<)/8H;�&�����O#(�13}I�i�QB KH�!"�}6�~8*&� $5<)i�J5u)2"O�(�10G0�JK�&*)i13"l1-"C��O.�/�+"#����1!D+3jO��Q(=O6�Q"$5<)�KM .�/�+(c&=1G&=�#��=�Ld�:v.)�8HR

]�&�&=�I)�8�&0)2BG�-;<)2&�)�8�O61<8�8d)i}I�i��&�1�5I�:8�KM(*)i}6��&����t�J�i,31-(*)i&=�#BCRD���c��r&H,!K(^5�bD�k� � s�)/8cK�1-B7O# #&=�J5)i"l&=�#��K�1<1-(95<)i"6�+&���8*%�8*&=�QB¿5.�J8�K�(*)i}��:5l�+}61-x-���!"$5w)�8�O#(�1>G*�:KM&=�J5�1-"�&�1��tR�IJ��5<)�8*&*)i"#,3 I)�8*�l&=�#�D/(�13"#&PO#(�1RG0�JK�&*)i13"����� � r&HI!K(^5�bU������ sc)dR �ARw&=�#��O�(�1RG*�:KM&0)i1-"u1+Dc&=�#��D��3KM�:8�1!Df�j� � rCH,!2( 5�b �k� � sx-)/8d)i}I�i�7D/(�13B &=�#��O�1+)i"I&'r @ B_��B @ s�§��!"$5z&=�#�G}6�3K_�CO#(=1HG0�:KM&0)213"�� �� � rCH,!2( 5�b � ���� s�rd�-8P8*�Q�H"D/(�13B r @ B : �B @ s=s_RÄh��KH�!"j"#1+f (��J8*&9�!&=��&������+}61-x-��D��-K�&_8HRKP$13(��:�-K��lx<�Q(=&���v ��1!D ���� � 1-( � ��c� r&H,!K(^5Lb ������13( � ���� s�r�fc�I)�KM�´KM13(�(��:8*O61-"$5#8�&=1z�~�y���/�+ #"$�!%zK_)i(_K9�2�wK_)i(_K� #Bw8�K�(*)i}I)i"#,z8*13BG��&�(*)��+"#,!�i��È<ÉMÊ�)2"� r&HI!K(^5�b ��s�s�&=�#�H(��t�+(���r0�+&cBG1A8*&Hs�&�fg1�O�1<8�8d)i}I�i�������/�+ #"$�:%�&=�H&�(_�+�#�:5I(_�IRg������&0fg1'O61!)i"#&98�)i"��rCHC!K(^5�b+�tsg&=1wK�1-BGO.�2�H&���&�����&=(*)��!"�,!�i�tÈ<ÉMÊP�!(���(��HO#(��:8*�Q"�&��:57)2" ��}#%G&=�#��D��3KM�:8�1!DD������ �+"65� �� � r&HI!K(^5�b � �� � 1-()� ���� s[KM13"#&9�J)i"I)i"#,'&=�I)�8�x.�H(�&���vpR

�m1'�:�-K9��)2"�&��H(_8*�:KM&0)213"�1+D��+"l�:5I,-����1!DD� �� � 1-()� ��c� r�(=�QO�(��J8*�H"#&0)i"#,7�!"��HBGO#&=%�K9)i(_K_�i�E)i"��O$�-8�8d)i"#,'&=�#(�13 #,-�~O61!)i"#&98�È.É:s�f�)i&=�~�!"��J5.,-�S���61+D ���� � 13(6� ���� r�(=�QO�(��J8*�H".&*)i"#,t�!"l�HBGO#&0%wK9)2(9K_�i�)i" �¡O6�3898d)i"�,G&=�#(�13 #,3�lO61!)i"#&98�ÊM��s[K�1-(�(=�J8*O61-"$5#8c&����t�y���/�+ #"6�:%w&��H&�(9�!���J5I(=1-"CÈ.ÉMÊM�$R���# $8E&=�#�G�:�2,31-(*)i&=�#B±KM13"68d)�8*&98E)2"´8* #O��Q(0)2B7O61<8d)i"#,�&�����K�1-"�x-�MvCO.�/�+"6�+('8* #}�5<)ixA)�8d)i1-"$8��!"$5

)i"4K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&0)i"#,w&=�#��(��J8* .�2&0)i"#,�8* #}�5<)ixA)�8d)i1-"$8HRI � �� � �!"65`� �� � ;I � �� � �!"65`� �� � ;I ����c� �!"65`� �� � ;I � �� � �!"65`� ���� RZ��-K��l1!D�&����J8*��8* �O6�Q(*)iBGO61A8d)2&0)i1-"68yKM13(�(��:8*O61-"$5#8c&�1w&=�#��&�(*)��+"#,- .�/�+&*)i13"41!Dg1-"��t1!D�&�����DF13 #(

fc�:5I,3�J8�5.�M¨$"#�:5|}#%C&�����&=f�1�OI���+"#�J8HR����#�:8*��8* #O6�H(*)iBGO�1<8d)i&*)i1-"$8�KQ�!"´}6��K�1-BGO# �&��:5z)i"�&*)iBG�q'r0nP���9s�fc���Q(��cnw)�8�&=�#�E"� #B�}��Q(�1+DpO61+)i"#&98m�+"657�m&����E"# �B�}��Q(�1+Dp&=�Q&=(_�!���J5.(_��)�D{1-"��E 68*�:8�&�����:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B¸1+D 1E I)i}6�38c�!"$5zWA��)�5I�M�dS 1�W<X-�+ap}$�-8*�:5�1-"~&����P)�5I�:��1+D���&=1-O61!�i13,!)�KQ�:��8*f��Q�HOR�S³Z 1�X-�+a���.)�8EK�1-B7OI�i�Mv<)2&=%�)/8�13O#&0)2B��J��fg)2&=�l(��:8*O6�JK�&�&�17&����P)i"#O� #&P�+"65�&=�#��1- �&�O� #&E8d)2kH�J8HR

`��

Page 16: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

�� ��g�e#�:��� �jM�!�"FM�HC!&!->9.0PQ!#4_(�.F*94?'97 �)!#7J'YXZ4?'9R�" H�.0'949]YXZ7J'9"1.0*94 *G+�n 5�*9.04?" (�78RO.F49]6.F4�� 5�7J'94?!K(EK'Y4 $&!EK*9P35�X�"1!�><.04�q�r��I�lnE�i1-,gnsD" .0PQ!f'94?>�q'r0ns�( 5�'YEI! � M�!TH,!��3. ( "FM�!(/.��/!f*G+"FM�!6*9X�"85�XZ" b

b0&P)/8P8*�#1-f�"z)i"u&=�#���+O#O6�H"65A)Tv|&��$�!&'K�1-BGO� #&0)2"�, � ��c� r0�+"65u8d)iB�)��/�+(*�i%4D/1-(�&=�#�G1-&=�#�Q(98�sc)�8)i"zD��3KM&P�J½- I)ix-�:�2�H".&y&�1�K�1-B7O# #&0)i"#,�&����7��%.O��Q(�}61+�T)�Kt>[13(�1-"�1:?@�5A)/�+,-(9�!B 1+Dg&�����8d)2&=�J8c)2"j1-"��71+D&=�#���$�J�ix.�:8�1+D^�¶��)iB�)i&��:5|}.%�0RwÄ ���Q" � )�8�O$�!(_�:���2���g&=1��Æ&=�#��O�(��:KM�H�J5<)i"�,z5<)�8�KM $8�8d)213"�KH�!"}6�t�:�-8d)��i%~�35#�!O�&��:5uÇ�O6�H"6K9)T��8c1!D�K_)i(_K9�2�:8��+(���"#13f»K�1-"$KM�H"#&=(*)�KPO6�H"6K_)���8c�!"$5l1-".�2%~13"#�QL_fc�:5I,3� N(��HBw�:)2"$8�(��M�i�Hx.�+".&yr�&=�#��8d�T)�K���}6�H&�fg�Q�H"�� �+"65 ��s_R

� �¿� ��� �g� ���� ��� !����� !�����4¨6(_8*&l�J�i,31-(*)i&=�#B KQ�+"�}6�´�-5��!O�&��:5�)i"»�h8*&�(_�:)i,-�#&0D/1-(�f��+(_5efc�:%�&=1²&��#�zKQ�38*�|1+D'O61!)i"#&98}6���213"#,+)2"�,~&=1�·��!L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:��OI���+"#�J8c1!DgÀ Á  REZ�vI&��H"68d)i1-"4&=1�·h`MLd5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��T)i"#�:8�)�8y�J��8*1�:�-8*%<Rw������,3�Q"��Q(_�:��1- �&*��)i"#��1+Dc&=�#�w�J�i,-13(*)i&���B±�!"654)2&98�&*)iBG��K�1-BGO.�2��v.)i&=%j�+(���"�1-&tKM�$�!"#,3�J5�;)dR �AR�·��3�i1-,�nmR

���#��KH�-8*��1!D�O61+)2"�&_8�1!D�À Á�Â�}6���213"#,+)2"�,G&=17·'Ã�Ld5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$�J��.%.O6�H(�OI���+"#�J8cr2Ã�J�.s�)/8�BG1-(=�5A) ��K� I�i&'8d)i"6K��7)i&�(=�J½- I)i(��J8y&�1CO6�H(*D/1-(=B )2"�&��H(_8*�JK�&0)213"u½- #�H(*)i�J8�}��Q&0fg�H�Q"´����)2"����+"65u�lKM13"#x!��vriÃ��o`+s�L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:��O61+�2%<&�13O6�AR

Äh�lO�(��:8*�Q"#&��²8*1!�i #&0)213"o&=1�&=�6�+&wO#(�13}I�i�HBC;c}6�38*�J5e13"�&=�#�~DF1+�T�i13f�)2"�,´(=�JK��Q"�&G(��:8* I�i&�}.%¢z�+&�13 �£8*�H�jSV¢z�!&9^�`Ma�R�� ��g�e#�:�� ���W���2g����� ��������4?!fEK'94 5�H,!,5�H,*TEI!2(C( 'A5�*978RO" *�5_!6>9!�� 4:!K> 'c( "FM�! .F4?"1!#HC(/!&ET"1.0*94[*G+n M�'Y7 + (^5_'9E&!K( *G+�À Á � .04|q�rdny�i1-,gns �^>9!#"1!#H�PQ.F4?.�(�"1.FE"! " .0PQ! 'Y4:>`X�(�.F49]~q'r0ns (^5:'9EI! (/*`" M�'9"F;]Y.! T!#4 '$#TX�!#H�R 7J.04:!K; "FM�! .04:"1!#HC(/!&E#" .0*94 5:*9.04?" (�$C!T"�� !I!T4�" M�! 7J.F4?! '94?>�"FM�! 5:*97JR " *�5_!`E&'94 $&!EK*YP5kXZ"1!&>a.F4�q&%#n U(' �)+*�(,.- " .0PQ!Ob/ +10 . (a'U5_'9H,'9PQ!#"1!THC;gn��&0 � n32 *�(4 ; '94?>`. + (^5:'9EI! '94?>U5�H,!,5�H,*TEI!K(&(�.F49]~q�r50 U7698 s +/*9H(�*9PQ!3��NO!K>;: 'YH,!Q'97�7J* ��!/>c; "FM�!1##XZ!#H�R EK'94�$&!f'94Z(�� !THI!�> .F4�"1.0PQ!�q&< => �@? )A*�(, rF�i13,gn�s+B U �DC b

���#��)/5.�J�y1!D�1- �(g�J�i,-13(*)i&���B )/8�&=1'8*&9�!(�&�f�)i&=�7�T)i&=&*�i�EBG�HBG1-(=%G�!"$57(� �"�&����c�J�i,-13(*)i&���B �"#&0)��&=�#��K� #BG .�/�+&��:5�&0)iBG��1+Dg�J����&=�#��½- #�H(*)i�J8cO6�Q(0DF13(�BG�:548*1�D��!(y��v$K��Q�:5#8c&��#��O#(��HO#(�1.KM�:8�80)i"�,w&*)iBG��+"65l&=�#�tBG�HBG1-(=%C8*&�13(_�!,3�AR�]�&�&��$�!&yO61+)2"�&:;Ifc��KQ�+"j�J���i1!f�BG1-(���BG�QBG13(�%�Rg�g�# 68�f���(��:8*&9�!(�&�z"#�Hf¸O#(��HO#(=1IKM�:8�8d)2"�,´f�)i&=�o�z}I)i,-,3�Q('x<�J�i #��1!D�0jRh]y"65²(=�QO6�:�!&7&��$�!&7O#(�1.KM�:8�8�r��:�-K9��8* 6K��O�(�1IKM�:8�8Efg)T���}6�tKH�J���i�J5~�G8*&=�QO�sg #".&*)��m�J���&����t8d)iBGOI��)�KM�:8��6�+x!��}6�H�Q"CKM13"68*&=(� 6K�&��:5�R

5��Q&FE�r 0sg}��t&����7&0)iBG��8*O6�H"#&c)i"j8*&=�QO �;90 � }6�7&=�#��O6�+(_�+BG�Q&=�Q(�K9�#1A8=�H"j�!&P&=�6�+&P8*&��HOzD/13(&=�#��O#(=�QO�(�1#KM�:8�8d)2"�,7�!"65�� � }6��&�����". #B'}#�H(�1+D�8d)2BGO.�T)�K��J8gKM13"68*&�(= 6K�&��:5��!&g&=�6�!&�8*&=�QOpR�Äh���6�:x-�r � � Ã��o`!s�Ç

E�r *s � q�r50 UG698� sp�hqIHJ n{� � r/�i1-,gns�B U �0 U ¥ 2 *� 4� KLÄh�t&9�!�<�M0 � 8*1l�-8c&�1�}6�:���!"6K��t&=�#�GKM1A8*&y1!D�&����7O�(��HO#(�1IK��J8�8d)i"#,l�!"$5l&�����K�1<8*&E1!Dg&=�#��½A ��Q(0)2�:8O6�H(*D/1-(�BG�:54�!&E8*&=�QO� �Ç

`:�

Page 17: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

0 � ��� n{� � r/�i1-,gns B U ��� �� �A�@?��fc���Q(=� �

�`

`c� U2 *� 4b0"�13(_5I�H('&�1CD/ I��¨#����&������#%<O#1-&=�#�:8*�J8�1!D������Q13(��QB Y�;�)i&�)/8�"#�:KM�:8�8��!(�%´&=�6�+&�0 � � n 2 *�(4 §

&=�# $8H;6)�D=;��!&t8*&��HO =; � n6� � r/�213,gns+B U � � �� �A�5?�� � n�2 *�(4 fc�GKM�#131<8*� 0 � � n 2 *�(4 �!"$5|fg�7(= #"u&=�#��:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B &0)��T��&=�#�~�Q"$5²1+Dy&����4K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&0)i1-"�f�)i&���1- �&G(��:8*&_�+(�&0)2"�,´&=�#��O�(��QO�(�1IK��J8�8d)i"#,u8*&��HORÄh�E¨$(_8*&�8* #O�O61<8*��&��$�!&g&=�I)�8cKQ�38*��5I1<�:8["�1-&g�6�+O#O��Q"pR�b0&gD/1!���i1!fE8�D/(�13B¸&������MvIO#(��:8�8d)i1-"�1!D EPr *s

EPr 0s � q < � n{� �dr/�i1-,gns B U � �� ��� ����� � C� q < � n{� � r/�i1-,gns B U ���� U7698 � C

®[%�&9�!�-)2"�,�� � � n UG6�� � DF13(g8*1-B7�� � @ ;I�!"$5�8* #BGB�)i"#,�1-x-�Q(�&=�#����8*&=�QO$8�"��Q�:5I�:57&=1'KM13BGO# �&���:�T�&=�#��8d)iBGOI��)�KM�:8H;�fg��1-}#&9�J)i"l&=�#��1-x+�Q(_�:���KM13BGO# �&*)i"#,w&0)iBG��E�1!D�&=�#���:�2,31-(0)2&=�#B ÇE � q % � n � rF�i1-,[n�s B U � ��� UG698 ���� � / U n � � U7698 � � -

������"� #B'}#�H(c1!D�8*&��HO68���)�8�,!)ix.�H"�}I%z��� / U

� � � � � n U76�� n � � : `n � : ` r��$sfc�.)�KM��)iBGOI��)2�:8

n � � � q�r �n sj�!"65�� � q'r_`+sÄh��5I�:5I 6K���&��$�!&�Ç E � q � n � 698 � � 698 rF�i1-,[n�s B U � �

���#���J�i,31-(*)i&=�#B¿�!}613x-��(� #"$8c�-8c5.�J8�K�(*)2}��:5w)�D 0 � (��QBw�:)i"68c8*Bw�:�T�i�Q(y&=�6�+"4n 2 *�(4 ;I&��$�!&g)/80 � � n 2 *�(4� n6� � r/�213,gns B U � � �� �A�@?�� � n 2 *�(4

n6� � � n 2 *�(4 8A6-UG6 �)+*�(, �� � � n 2 *�(4 UG698 �

P$ #(�&=�#�H(�BG13(��E)i&�D/1!���i1-fy8�DF(=1-B r��$s�&��$�!&y��� *��U ' =��� ���+� � D/1-(�}I)i,G�H"#13 #,-�4x3�J�i #�:8[1!D�nmRb�Dy&=�I)�8'KM1-"$5<)i&0)213"h)�8�"#1-&7x-�Q(0)T¨$�J5�;�&��������-8*&78*&=�QO�&9�!�<�J8�q�r � �� � � :Ms�O�(��HO#(�1IK��J8�8d)i"#,|�+"65O6�H(*D/1-(�Bw8c�[O61!�i%A�i1-,A�!(0)2&=�#B�)�K�½A #�H(*)i�J8HR

]�O#O.�2%-)i"#,G&=�#�:8*��(=�J8* .�2&98�&�171- �(c)2".)2&0)��J�O#(�13}I�i�HBC;�f��P13}#&9�J)i"

`��

Page 18: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

�� ��g�e#�:������*94_(�"1H�XZE#"1.F49]Q"FM�! �6!#7J'9X�4:'9Rf"1H�.F'949]YXZ78'9"1.F*94a*G+gnU5:*9.F4?"F( E/*94_(�"1HG'Y.F4?!I><"1* $C!T78*94�]"1*�·wÃ��G>Y.FPQ!#4Z(/.0*94:'Y7��³Ã��� ! M�RC5�!#H 5�7J'Y4:!K(A*G+f(/*9PQ!�� XZE#7J.0>9!&'94����G>Y.FPQ!#4Z(/.0*94:'Y7L(^5_'YE�! EK'94�$&!>9*Y4:! .F4 "1.FPQ! '94?> ( 5:'9E�! E � q � ·�n � 6 � � � 6 ��·�� � � r/�i1-,�ns B U � ���M�!#HC! � .�(<'94?R 5:*c(�.F"1.! T!fEK*Y4_(�" 'Y4:"F;�). (<" M�!<(/.��/! *G+ " M�!Q*9X�"85�XZ"F;p� � � B�)i"�r���B_n32=�A�� 4 s '94?>t� � � � � : � �

'Y4:>��

``�� U2 =�A�� 4 < � � �

� +/*9H�à � �]BD�$§���� +/*9H�à � YOB9�cRMR:R C

� �����' �_� !�����Äh���$�!x-��O#(��:8*�Q"�&��:5u1- �&�O� #&�8*�Q"68d)i&0)2x-�~�:�2,31-(*)i&=�#Bw8tD/1-(�KM13"68*&�(= 6K�&*)i"#,|&����4�y�M���+ #"6�+%´&�(0)/�+"#L,3 I���!&0)213"j1!Dy8*O6�:K_)��:�g8*�H&98�1!DgO�1!)i".&_8E)i"´�!L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:�[8*O6�3KM�-RGWAO��JK9)�¨�KQ�:���2%<;{fc�#�H"j&����')i"#O� #&K�1-"$8d)/8*&98t1+DPn O61+)2"�&_8�8�KH�!&=&��H(��J5u&=�#(=1- #,3��·�O.���!"#�:8H;�f����$�!x-��8*��1-f�"u&��$�!&'&=�#��)2(7�y�M���! �"6�+%&=(*)��!"�,- I���+&*)i1-"´KQ�+"|}6�GK�1-BGO� #&=�J5l)2"´qGr��=·��i1-,gns�&*)iBG�G�!"65jq�rdnsy8*O$�-K��AR'�g�I)�8�&0)2BG��}61- �"65KH�!"j}���(��:5I $KM�:5z&=1lq�r0nE�i1-,gn����_sPr�fc�I)�KM�l)�8�13O#&0)2B��J��f�)i&��j(��:8*O6�JK�&P&�1�&����')i"�O# #&t�!"$5z&=�#�13 #&=O# #&Ms�fc�#�H"j· � ��R

���I)�8�(=�J8* I�i&P)/8��wDF �(�&=�#�Q(�8*&��HOerd�JD/&��H(�&=�#�wKQ�38*�71+Dc&0fg1�O6�!(9�J���i�M��OI���!"��J8HSV®[1!)�X-X+a/sc&=1-f��!(95#8&=�#��� ��K9)i�Q".&PK�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&0)i1-"41!Dg&=�#���y���/�+ #"$�!%�&=(*)��!"�,- .�/�+&*)i13"l)2"´�!"413 #&=O# �&�8*�H"68d)i&*)ix-��D��-8*�.)213")i"~�!L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)i1-"6�:��8*O$�-K��AR�Äh��}�����)2�Hx-�E&��$�!&�&����J8*��(��:8* I�i&_8��+(���1!D{)i"#&��H(��:8*&�)2"~8*�Hx.�Q(9�J�#O#(9�-K�&*)�KH�J��+O#OI��)�KQ�+&*)i13"68H;I�J8*O6�:K_)��J���i%�K�1-B7O# #&=�Q(�xA)�8d)i1-"~�!"$5�K�1-BGO� #&=�Q(0)2kH�J5�&�13BG1-,3(_�+O#�.%Gfc�#�H(���5#�+&_�'�+(��"$�!&= #(_�:�T�i%'5<)�8*&�(0)2}� #&=�J5�)i"7O.�/�+"#�:8HR������J8*��(��:8* I�i&98m�6�:x-�[}6�Q�H"��Mv�&=�H"65I�:5'&=1��.)2,3�#�H(�5A)2BG�H"68d)i1-"$8H;)�D�&����PO61+)i"#&98[}6�M�i13"#,'&�1�·'Ã�Ld5A)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:�8* #}68*O$�-K��J8�1+D��-L�5<)iBG�Q"$8d)213"6�:��8*O$�-K��AR�Äh�E�i�Q&��38c�!"13O6�Q"�½- #�:8*&*)i1-"´fc�#�H&����Q(�13 #('K�1-"$8*&�(� $KM&0)i1-"�KH�!"u}6��)2BGO�(�13x!�J54f�)i&��´(��J8*O6�:KM&�&�14·�§��!"$5|fg�(��:KH�J���#&�����Bw�:)2"�rd�!"$5'O�(�1-}$�!}I�i%'5<) ��K� I�i&Hs� #"$8*1!�ix-�J5t½- #�:8*&*)i1-"t)i"7&=�6�+&��+(��:��Ç . (�q�rdny�i13,gng���_s'94 X2595:!TH $&*YXZ4?>�+K*9H EK*94Z(/"1H�XZE#"1.F49]A"FM�! �6!#7J'9X�4:'YRA"1H�.F'949]YXZ78'9"1.F*94 *G+�n 5Z*9.F4?"F(�.F4 >��,>Y.FPQ!#4_(�.F*Y4:'Y7( 5�'9E&!f. +)" M�!Q"1H�.F'Y4�]YX�7J'9"1.F*94 E&*94Z(/. (/"F()*G+c�6" !#"1HC'OM�!I>9H,'� ����������������i��������_e! �g#"$�&%�' gke#g��kg�( )*���0�,+�e#�j� ����I)�8�8*�:KM&0)i1-"tO#(=�J8*�H"#&98m�+"��+O#O.�T)�KQ�+&*)i13"71+D{&�����8*O6�-K���1!D�K9)2(_K9�i�J8)i"�&����EK�1-".&=�MvI&�1!D�r�"#13"�Z� #LK9�T)�5.�J�!"�s$��%.O��Q(�}�1+�T)�K�,3�Q13BG�Q&=(�%�r0�g,-1<1I5E)2"�&�(=1<5. 6KM&0)i1-"�KH�!"�}6��D/1- �"65y)i"t®[�:�!(_5.1-"pº³8�}�1<1-�{SV®g�:�-X3�!a/s_R������BG1<8*&|K9�/�38�8d)�KQ�J��K�1-"ID/1-(=Bw�J�7BG1.5I�M��1!Dw&=�#�J�!L�5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$�J�t"#1-" Z� 6K9��)/5.�J�+" 8=O$�-K��or�1+D5�1-}$�-K��#�Hx�8*�<%6sy)�8�&=�#�CU�1+)i"6KH�!(�-�l �O#O6�H(G�6�:��D�OI���!"��lÀ � �/. 74�� 8 \ ¬ 0 8 � @21 f�)i&=�e&�����i1IKQ�:�BG�Q&=(*)�K��EJ� � Â'� � 6 Â'� �

� � §I&�����,-�H1I5I�:80)�KH8��+(���&������$�J��DFL�K9)2(9K_�i�J8�)2"�À � KM�H"I&=�Q(=�J5�13"�&=�#��(��:�J��:v.)�8�r���v$K��QO#&0)i1-"�"6�J���i%j&=�#��x-�Q(=&*)�KQ�:��8*&=(_�:)2,3�.&��$�J��D/L/��)i"#�:8Ms9;��+"65|&=�#�4rd8*1zKQ�:���2�:5 L_��%.O��Q(�}61+��)/K�N.s5A)/8*&9�!"$KM��}��H&0f��H�Q"�&=f�1'O61+)2"�&_8 �4B�� � \lÀ ��)�8H;� �Ol&=1��GK�1-"68*&9�!".&gD��-K�&�13(:;I&��#���i1-,A�!(*)i&=�#B¸1+D�&=�#�r�(��:�J��sgK�(�1A8�8=LF(_�+&*)i1wr �4B � � B�È_B_È � s � �

' ��' �43#5 � 3 ' � 3

�3 ' � f��#�H(��tÈ$;IÈ � �!(���&=�#��&=(_�-K��J8�13"�&�����(��J�:�m�Jv.)�8[1+D&=�#��,-�H1$5.�J8d)�KP&=�#(=1- �,-� � � � R

���#�c}I)�8*�JK�&*)i"#,���)i"#� ��1!D ���!"$5 � � )/8�&=�#�� �O#O6�Q(��6�J��D�1+Dp&=�#��K_)i(_K9�i�76¡KM�H"#&=�Q(=�J5713"�&=�#�E(=�J�:��:v.)�8c�!"$5l}6�M�i1-"�,!)i"#,7&�17&�����O6�H"6K9)T�mf�)i&�����)iB�)i&*)i"#,7O61!)i"#&98 �G�!"$5 � � r�W-�Q��P)i,3 #(���X.s9R

`:Y

Page 19: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

�3

� 3 �

Pp)2,3 #(=�tXI������t}I)�8*�:KM&0)2"�,���)i"#� 6�1!D ���+"65 � � R

���# $8m1-"���KQ�+"~5I�M¨$"#��)2"�&=�#�� 68* $�J�6fy�:%t&=�#����%.O#�H(�}61+�T)�KE>[13(�13"#1:? @65<)��!,3(_�!B¶1!D��y¨6"I)i&=��8=�H&�²1+D�8d)i&=�J8m)2"GÀ �tR��g�#��K��M���61!D � \l�´)�8�&�����8*�H&g1!DpO61+)i"#&98m"#�:�!(��H(cr/)2"�&=�#���.%<O6�Q(�}61+��)/Kc8*�Q"68*�!s�&=1�t&=�6�!"~&�17�+"#%�13&����Q(gO�1!)i".&_8�)2"��ER��g�I)�8[)/8g�Gr���%.O#�H(�}61+�T)�KH�J���2%$sgK�1-".x-��vw8* #}$8*�Q&�1!D�À �7;-��)iB�)2&=�:5}�%´�!(9KQ8�1!DE}I)�8�8*�JK�&*)i"#,C��)i"#�J8HRu�����lx-�Q(=&*)�KM�:8��+(���&=�#�~KM�H"#&=�Q(987r/)i"e&=�#���#%<O#�H(�}61!��)�Kl8*�H"68*�!sP1!DK9)2(9K_�i�J8�r/)2"´}61-&=�u�#%<O#�H(�}61!��)�K��+"�Z� $K_��)�5I�:�!"´8*�Q"$8*�3syO$�-8�8d)i"#,l&���(�1- �,-�u&=�#(=�Q��8d)i&=�J8�1+Dc�E;��+"65f�)i&=�²�HBGO#&=%4)i"#&=�Q(0)213(_8H;�&=�6�+&�)/8�&=1|8��!%j&=�#�~K9)i(_K_�i�:8�K_)i(_K� #Bw8�K�(*)i}I)i"#,|�+"e1-(95<)i"6�+(�%h�������! �"6�:%&=(*)��!"�,!�i�t1!D�� �H"#&0)i(��M�i%w5I(_�+fc"�)i"68d)�5I�tÀ �tR�]�"4��v$�+BGOI�i��1+Dg8* 6K9�C�G5<)��+,-(_�+B°13"�¨$x.��O�1!)i".&_8[)�8,+)2x<�Q"7)i"�Pp)2,3 #(=��^�R�]�"#13&����Q(g�Mv#�!BGO.�2��1+Dp��%.O#�H(�}�1!��)�KE>[1-(=1-"�1:?@�5A)/�+,-(_�+B )i"�&=�#��BG1I5I����1!D&��#�U�1!)i"$KQ�!(�-��K9)i(_K_�i��)�8c5I(_�:f�"�)i"�Pp)i,- #(=��` @ R

Pp)2,3 #(��'^�Ç�] >[13(�1-"�1:?@m5<)��!,3(_�!B�)i"~&������#%<O#�H(�}61!��)�K�U�1+)2"$KQ�+( -���$�J��D�O.�/�+"#�FE1-f &=�#��5<)�8�KM $898d)i13"�)i"uWA�:KM&0)213"���8*�#13fy8[&=�6�+&y&����tK��M����8�1!D�&=�#���������! �"6�!%G&=(*)��!"�,- I���+&*)i1-"

1+Dw�²8*�Q&��Æ1!D78d)i&��:8�)i"N&�f�1²OI���+"#�J8X� �!"$5 �©)i"#&=�H(_8*�JK�&*)i"�,²�J�i1-"�, �'KH�!"N}��´5I�H&��H(�B�)i"#�:5}�%�8* �O6�Q(0)2BGO61A8d)2"�,´&0fg1z}#%j&=fg1C&�����D/1- �(7KM1-(=(��:8*O�13"65<)i"#,z��%.O��Q(�}�1!��)�K�>[13(�1-"�1:? @�5<)��!,3(_�+Bw8~Ç�i1IKQ�+&0)2"�,h&����lx<�Q(�&0)�KM�:8t1!DP13"#��)2"�&�1z&=�#�CKM���T��8�1!DP&=�#�413&����Q(Gfg)T���E,!)ix.��&=�#�~&��H&�(9�!�#�:5I(9�jf�)i&=�&=�#(��H��x<�Q(�&0)�KM�:8E)i"u1-"���OI���+"#�A;�fc�.)T�i��&=�#1A8*��f�)i&=�u&�f�1�x.�H(�&0)/K��J8c)2"´�J�3KM�jOI���!"���f�)��T�[}6��,+)2x-�H"}�%l)i"#&=�Q(98*�JK�&*)i1-"$8�1!D��J5.,-�:8HRC�g�I)�8�)/8�&=�#����v$�3KM&7�+"6�J�i13,- #�G1!D�O6�+O6�Q(:SV®[1!)�X-X+a�;�&������#%<O#�H(�}�1!��)/KBG�H&�(0)/K�}���)i"#,7(��QO.�/�3KM�:5�}�%G&��#��Z� 6K9�T)�5I�:�!"~1-"���fc���Q"9� �!"$5��¡�!(=��O$�!(_�:�T�i���0R

Pp)2"$�J���i%.;:)i&�8*�Q�HBw8fc13(�&=�tBG�Q"�&*)i1-"�"I)i"#,y���Q(=��&=�6�+&��+"#13&����Q(Q;-5A)����Q(=�Q"�&:;3K�1-"#"��Mv<)213"�}6�Q&=f��Q�H"�y�M���+ #"6�+%j&=(*)��!"#,3 I���!&0)i1-"or/)2"�&�����O.���!"#�!s9;��+"65u�#%<O#�H(�}61!��)�K�,3�Q13BG�Q&=(�%�r/)2"�8*O6�3KM�!sP�6�38�}6�Q�H"�:�2(=�J�35I%�"�1-&0)�KM�:54�!"65��MvIOI�i1!)i&=�J5�}�%Gb0,31-( ��)ixA)i"�)i"~�I)�8�&����J8d)�8HRTS �g)2xIX-�+a

`:�

Page 20: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

Pp)2,3 #(��G` @ �] >�1-(�13"#1Q? @5A)��!,-(9�!B�)i"4&=�#���.%<O6�Q(=}{1+��)/K�U�1!)i"6KH�!(�-��K9)2(_K9�i�

`!\

Page 21: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

j�,��KXfa �v_^V.l 9�V 1 V.X gwc«tR+W.K��.fc�+(�kH�!1-O.D-)/8�,3(_�+&���DF .�T�i%��3K9�."#1+f��i�:5I,3�J5�DF13(p�$�!xA)i"�,�O�(�13xA)�5I�:5y(=�MD/�Q(=�Q"$KM��&�1E¢z�!&=1- m£8*�Q�{S³¢z�+&_^I`Ha�+"65'D/1-(g�#���iOID/ I��5<)�8�KM $8�8d)213"68�fc�I)�K��7%-)2����5I�:57&�1�&����P�.)i,-�#�H(g5<)iBG�H"68d)i1-"$�J�6(��J8* .�2&QR����#�y�! #&=�#13(_8fc13 I��5��J��8*1���)2�<��&=1�&=�6�+"#��&=�#�c(��MD/�H(��Q�:8mDF13(�&����M)i(�KM13BGBG�Q".&98m&=�6�!&��#���2O��J5t)2BGO�(�13xA)i"#,P&����EO#(=�QL8*�H"#&9�!&0)213"|1+Dg&�����O6�+O6�Q('�+"65��-�:�!"�LdUm)i�Q(=(��G¢C�Q(*�i�H&�D/1-('8* �O#OI�i%-)2"�,~�.)2B fg)2&=�u�I)�8�Bw�+(�x.�����213 68)i"#&=�Q(9�-K�&*)ix-��5I(_�+f�)i"#,'O#(=�QO$�!(_�+&*)i1-"C8*%�8*&=�QB�����5I(_�:f R

� � � �[���c�' 6�1!� 6.����� ��%Q 6���� �.����+&+&� �"Q��%$)��$)��$)�%1G�:��()�q��+&��� �Y�X6����)� ;>$�?-�P? 6���1���+&� �/�q��'%()� $)+&���0���<3�1����q�

������6�35��6���� Q���������� �"!$#&%('*)�+-,$#�.0/210354�!.U)D [�D)a !.�/������� +&l����-�678�)Q� 9 8e�8:; =< =F8bQ 9 $)������$)��������!�>\Q�89�6� ��'�'*�����"!@?�Q���35�.$)�0�"!BA>Qnru� ��'*'<��6�1L!w���1CA`QEDF�/�*�.�"3 Q �.��'��<3 ���0��$)���

$?9�q���1/$)+ �5�+&�.'*����(P��$�$)�G=�'*�����2��'�()$)���*����+&�-���E3�$ +&�.6��q���0��$)����'H( ��$ +&���0��;/QHGI'J4;KL.01�%M1ON )EP��� �Q!$#R%MN;%('S� )EN TVU"1W�5�X1�%(.03�Q r $o�����L���"Q �/���'<��l�'��P���kr��3X�����<3 ��'"?J� ��$ ���2�MY"?]� ��U7Z2[�Q l.�����q�)35�J�.6�l�'��������"12�����MA �J�O��9���P896�l.'*���wQ

� 9 �"�7Z)D; Q\�%Q 9 ���q1G$)�wQ^]`_a1b+71W� ��1�%(.03��dceP 'f46KL.L1�%M1g+ .L� #;!a4�QhUi.LN&P5#jN;%M1g%M1�k;%l4H'*)m�nN;%S_a1L��N;%('lK�4�!�/��������()� �F=d�%� ��'<�(�!E�67Z D�Q

� 9 Aeo8�� qp�Q 9 ��6.( ()� �X��� ������1�r�QsAP������Q �G��� '�'<��l�'��P1G�"35$)+&��$)�����0��$)���I$�?\3�� '�'*�2����1C�X��������� �"Qt�uN;%S_wv,BKLN )EP v<!GU78xJ�W7o;yGU7z2[�!`�W7o8�)Q

� 9 $)�{Z2Z; |< =08bQ 9 $)�*�X��$)������"Q��G�������7���35$)��������6�3��0��$)��? ��$)+ ��'<������935��$)�X�F=����35���*$)�.�"Q���� �"!j#R%M1L.H}`'J4L'l� )�~Ui.0N�!a_w'lK�4�~�N )EP-�W��N;+&1F��.L�;K�1�4�4L'*)�+�!2�7�jx���yGU7�!B�67Z2Z�Q

� �%$�tj�8�� �p-Q �LQ A>Q.�%$�tG���0���"Q@�W)�%(.0�;P #jK�%('S� )�%M�bU"1L� �X1�%(.03�Q`<{$)���b����'�� ;�� �/$)�.�"!E�62�8�)Q� �J�aZ76 ��&Q � Q��%'<����� �X$)������1�r Q � Q��/�.$)�"Q ���.'*�<3 �����*$)�.��$�?7�q����1G$)+ �q��+&��'�����(o���i35$)+&��6.�q�����$)����'

( ��$)+&� ����;G! ����Q�GI'J4;KL.01�%M1�N )EPb��� �Q!$#R%MN;%('S� )EN T�U"1L� ��1�%(.03 !R�G[d[)a !E�W7Z7�Q� � 1G�;Z7o; �p-Q � 1G� '*�Xl���6��.��� �"Qs�-T�+&� .0'J%S_w��4-� )���� �X�0'*)EN;%M� .0'SN T�U"1L� �X1�%(.03�Q��/��������()� �F=d�H����':��(�!E�67Z2o�Q� ��� Z7�; �p�Q � 1/��'*�Xl���6��.��� �c����1Y�uQ <�Q � 6.�*l����"Q7r $)��$)'�$)( �<3 ��'�'�;k��#J��� ������(k���Y�����q����()� +&�����"Qe���C�����

,$3 �Q!E�;4L'{#���� )�]`_a1L� .03X�dc���� �Q!$#R%('{)�+�! ����()� �,D7Z7;y&�Rz)D�!B�67Z7�GQ� � A�Z2[; �p�Q � 1G� '���l���6.�������4����1�p-Q�AT��6���� �"Q����*��1/����(o��tG����� +&����$)�*�.�0�&���p�0�.��� �T1/��+&� �.����$ �.������1

��$)'��/����(b��������$)���u$5�23�������$)l�'�� + ���4�������.':���.�{QE�L)Wc;�5.0�XN;%('S� )��\.��;K�1�4�40'*)�+F�@1�%S%�10.�4�! U��7x D76yR�Ro�!<{6�'�;C�67Z2[�Q

� � A�2z; �p�Q � 1G� '���l���6.�������c����1 � Q ruQ�A��6�3M�)�{Q]�/��+&6�'<���0��$)�4$�?H����+&��'��:3��*��;�xu�b���"3������<�{6��7�0$435$)���-#J���0�1/� ()� �.� �q�����\3 ����� �e�*��()� $)+&���0���<3-��'�()$ ��������+&�"Q�������]j.�N )�4;N&K�%('S� )�4�� )�Ui.0N�!a_w'lK�45!j�x �7�;yE�Wz ��!</����6�����;e�672z�Q

� � �aZ2�; �p�Q � 1/� '���l.��6����.� ������1�?7Q��/� �<1/��'RQe�%$ ��$)��$)�u1G�:��()�q��+&������1>��X�q��.( ��+&� �����"Q GF'J4;KL.�1�%M1bN )EP��� �Q!$#R%MN;%('S� )EN T�U"1L� �X1�%(.03 !E�2x U7[;yR�2��!B�67Z7��Q

� � �8Z7�; � Q <�Q � 6.��l���������1C?�Q��/� �<1/��'RQ&�%$)+&��6�������(�3�$ �w�{$ '�6�����$)���,l.;k���35�*�.��$G3 ��'��X�"���q35�wQ�����,B1�K�� )EP�����|,$3 �"!$�;4L'{#��¡� )���� �Q!$#R%MN;%('S� )EN TEU"1�� �X1�%(.03"'{)�¢@� .�£6%��5¤�)I¥-1L'J+;_&%S4�!����()� �¦7z;y�7G!5< 6�����W7Z7��Q

� AT����8�� X<�QaAT���$)6@§���6�nQ��L�����"����$)�����*+&��d"������$ �P�{6������*� �Q��W78�)Q�AT��.6��q3����*�.��Q� r��18o7z; E8bQjr��"1/$)�{Q¨U"1W� ��1�%(.03;~�NOKW� �Q!$.�1�_a1L)�4L'{/21-K�� #�.�4;15Q�89$7�)���\r 6.l�'��:3������$)���"!jYJ��#�DJ$)���n!j�67o2z�Q

`:X

Page 22: Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay ...Output sensitive construction of the 3D Delaunay triangulation of constrained sets of points Jean-Daniel Boissonnat, Andr e Cerezo,

� ru�aZ2[; ��%Q r�Q�r���� �����q���q�&����1bA`Q ��Qn�/���+&$)�QI��� �Q!$#R%MN;%('l�5)EN T�U"1L� �X1�%(.03��-N )O�L)�%(.L�;P #aK�%('l� ).Q��/�������/=( ���F=(�%� ��'<��(.!E�67Z7[�Q

� ?J���8Z7�; ��Q2?]�J�/�*��Q��i)�+&1L� ��1�%(.03I�dcQKW� )a/ 1�k�!a� T 35_a1�P .�NQ'*)�_R30!$1L.6��� T 'SK����d4d!$N&K�1�Q&r���8������ �X�*�! �%$)+&��6���� ���35��� ��35�-89� ��������+&� �.��!�r�������35���0$)������J� ���������R; !�[�9� a !�< 6����X�67Z7�GQ

� �G� �{Z7�6 �?7Q��/� �<1/��'RQ��%$)���X�0�X6�35������(4����()��� �F=F1G�*+&��������$)����'�3�$ �a�)�5tk�/6.'*'��,���9'�$)( �����*����+&�<3735$)���,��� ��?�� 3��{Q���e����� ,$3 �"!$�;4L'{#���� )�]`_a1L� .03��dc��\� �Q!$#&%d'{)�+�!G���()� � �Rz � yR�a��D�!B�67Z7��Q

`:^