Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. ·...

17
„Network Theory and Computer Modeling in the Study of Religion“, International Workshop August 29–September 4, 2016, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest Origins of Mithraism: Historical Backgroud Aleš Chalupa (in collaboration with Jan Fousek, Eva Výtvarová, Adam Mertel and Tomáš Hampejs) Department for the Study of Religions, Faculty of Arts, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic, [email protected]

Transcript of Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. ·...

Page 1: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

„Network Theory and Computer Modeling in the Study of Religion“,International Workshop August 29–September 4, 2016, EötvösLoránd University, Budapest

Origins of Mithraism:Historical Backgroud

Aleš Chalupa (in collaboration with Jan Fousek, Eva Výtvarová, Adam Mertel and Tomáš Hampejs)

Department for the Study of Religions, Faculty of Arts, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic, [email protected]

Page 2: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Research Problem

• The origins of Mithraism (also known as the Roman cult of Mithras or the Mysteries of Mithras).

Page 3: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras)

• Mithras: an old Indo-European deity

• Known from:• India • Persia • Asia Minor• Rome

• Period of existence: cca 75-400 CE

• Attested in all provinces of the Roman Empire

• Three typical „structures“: 1) mithraeum, 2) tauroctony, 3) seven grades of initiation

Page 4: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 5: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 6: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 7: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 8: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

When?

How?

Where?

Page 9: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

When?

• The earliest Mithraic evidence comes from 75-125 CE.

• No securely dated evidence of the Roman cult of Mithras before this period.

Page 10: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

How?

• Various scenarios (closely connected with the identification of the region from where the Roman cult of Mithras started to spread)

• Transformation (slow gradual process of „cultural hybridization“)

• Invention

Page 11: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Where?

• Different candidate regions…

• Persia (Cumont 1899, 1913)

• Asia Minor (Will 1978, Turcan 1993, Gordon 1978, Beck 1998 etc.)

• Bosporan Kingdon (Beskow 1978)

• Balkan Peninsula (Wikander 1951)

• Rome and Ostia (Clauss 1990)

Page 12: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 13: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Current state of the problem

• The question of the origins of Mithraism cannot be decided at present time.

• Competing hypotheses that do not allow verification (missing evidence)

• Early evidence is widely dispersed and points to no obvious „place of origin“.

Page 14: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known
Page 15: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

The geographical distribution of Mithraic evidence, which possibly derivesfrom the early period of the cult's existence (□ = mithraeum; ∆ =inscription;☆ = literary text).© Adam Mertel.

Page 16: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Current state of the problem

• How was this wide and rapid transmission of Mithraism possible?

• The essential role of Roman army in the early spread of Mithraism

- Classical hypothesis of Franz Cumont (1899, 1913)

- Recently questioned by Richard L. Gordon (2009)

Page 17: Origins of Mithraismbirot.web.elte.hu/network2016/The_Origins_of_Mithras.pdf · 2016. 9. 7. · Mithraism (the Roman Cult of Mithras) •Mithras: an old Indo-European deity •Known

Thank you for your attention!