ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. ·...

30
ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7 I To, The Director (Non-Coal Mining), Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, lndira Paryavaran ilhavan, Jor Bag road, New Delhi Date: L7.04.2017 Project No. J-11015/47 I 20LLl lA.il lul Sub: Submission of additional information as sought by EAC members during gth REAC meeting held on 22"d August, 20!6 for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (110.07 ha) of M/s. Orient Abrasives Ltd. located at village Moti Balachod, Taluka Abdasa, District Kutch, Gujarat. [Project No. J- ttols I 47 I 2o11-rA.r r (M)l Ref: 1. Minutes of the gth REAC meeting held on 22nd August 2016, agenda item no. 2.7. 2. our letter no. oAL/MoEFCC/Rata/2015-16 dated t1-.07.20]..6. 3. Our letter no. OAL/MoEFCC/Rata/2016-17 dated 29.03.20L7; acknowledged on 30.03.2017. Respected Sir, With reference to the above subject, our project for EC proposal was considered in 7th REAC meeting on 22nd June,2016 & gth REAC meeting on22"d August, 2OL6for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (110.07 ha.) of M/s. Orient Abrasives Ltd. located in village Moti Balachod, Taluka Abdasa, District Kutch, Gujarat and additional documents was sought vide Minutes of the gth REAC meeting held on 22nd August, 2016. Our project EC proposal for production capacity for Rata Talab Bauxite Mine is L,L},O22 TPA for utilization in the integrated Velue ADDtrroN & Cepnvr Powrn GrrurnanoN PIANT, which is Providing Employment opportunity to 1000 people. Our company had faced enormous difficulty in running the PLANT due to Raw Material Shortage, Quality Raw Materials and its consistent supply. Sustenance of Value Addition Plant on low capacity mine production is not economically viable. Very low Mine production capacity are economically difficult to conduct Mining Operations considering the Compliance of environment measures like Reclamation and Rehabilitation, CSR, huge overhead cost of Project Operations the process of obtaining Environment Clearance is normally takes 4 to 5 years which ultimately causing huge overhead financial losses. Our company future depends on timely clearance of EC, which is pending since 2010 onwards. Our project clearances will Generate huge Employment Opportunitieslob Opportunities in the local villages and directly contributing to the Micro Rural Economics. Works: GIDC, lndlus. Area Porbandar - 360577. Gujarat, lndia Ph. : +9'1-286-222178819 Fax: +91-286-2222719 Mining Division : Orient Abrasives Ltd. Orient House, Yogeshwar Nagar, Khambhalia - 361305. Dist. Devbhoomi Dwarka. (Gujarat) Tele/Fax : +9 1 -2833-2347 56 r i

Transcript of ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. ·...

Page 1: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854

No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7 I

To,

The Director (Non-Coal Mining),

Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change,

lndira Paryavaran ilhavan,

Jor Bag road,

New Delhi

Date: L7.04.2017

Project No. J-11015/47 I 20LLl lA.il lul

Sub: Submission of additional information as sought by EAC members during gth REAC meeting held

on 22"d August, 20!6 for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (110.07 ha) of M/s. Orient Abrasives Ltd.

located at village Moti Balachod, Taluka Abdasa, District Kutch, Gujarat. [Project No. J-

ttols I 47 I 2o11-rA.r r (M)l

Ref: 1. Minutes of the gth REAC meeting held on 22nd August 2016, agenda item no. 2.7.

2. our letter no. oAL/MoEFCC/Rata/2015-16 dated t1-.07.20]..6.

3. Our letter no. OAL/MoEFCC/Rata/2016-17 dated 29.03.20L7; acknowledged on 30.03.2017.

Respected Sir,

With reference to the above subject, our project for EC proposal was considered in 7th REAC meeting on

22nd June,2016 & gth REAC meeting on22"d August, 2OL6for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (110.07 ha.) of

M/s. Orient Abrasives Ltd. located in village Moti Balachod, Taluka Abdasa, District Kutch, Gujarat and

additional documents was sought vide Minutes of the gth REAC meeting held on 22nd August, 2016.

Our project EC proposal for production capacity for Rata Talab Bauxite Mine is L,L},O22 TPA for utilization

in the integrated Velue ADDtrroN & Cepnvr Powrn GrrurnanoN PIANT, which is Providing Employment

opportunity to 1000 people.

Our company had faced enormous difficulty in running the PLANT due to Raw Material Shortage, Quality

Raw Materials and its consistent supply. Sustenance of Value Addition Plant on low capacity mine

production is not economically viable.

Very low Mine production capacity are economically difficult to conduct Mining Operations considering

the Compliance of environment measures like Reclamation and Rehabilitation, CSR, huge overhead cost

of Project Operations the process of obtaining Environment Clearance is normally takes 4 to 5 years

which ultimately causing huge overhead financial losses.

Our company future depends on timely clearance of EC, which is pending since 2010 onwards. Our

project clearances will Generate huge Employment Opportunitieslob Opportunities in the local villages

and directly contributing to the Micro Rural Economics.

Works:GIDC, lndlus. AreaPorbandar - 360577.Gujarat, lndiaPh. : +9'1-286-222178819Fax: +91-286-2222719

Mining Division :

Orient Abrasives Ltd.Orient House, Yogeshwar Nagar,Khambhalia - 361305.Dist. Devbhoomi Dwarka. (Gujarat)Tele/Fax : +9 1 -2833-2347 56

r

i

Page 2: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDct N. 124299DL197 1P1C005854

We have submitted the Additional information for Query no. !,2 & 4 sought by the EAC during gth REAC

meeting held on 22nd August, 2016 vide our letter dated 11.07.2016 (Annexure A). We have submitted a

request letter dated 29.03.20!7 to MoEF&CC, New Delhi (Annexure B), to consider our project in Nextmonth's agenda, as our mine was inspected by The Director, MoEF&CC, Regional office, Bhopal on

03.O1.2OL7. Site inspection report has been sent to MoEF&CC, New Delhi from Regional office, Bhopal

on L1,.04.20L7. Our copy of lnspection site report is enclosed herewith as Annexure C for your ready

reference. Details of query no. 4 sought by the EAC during 9th REAC meeting is as below:

Query No. 3: lt appears that mine had been operated even after the submission of Board Resolution thatviolation of EPA will not be done in future. An inspection report from Regional Office of MoEFCC shall be

obtained to ascertain the violation.

Compliance:

. Director, Regional office, MoEF&CC, Bhopal, Shri B.B. Barman had inspected the mine on 03.01.2017.o Site inspection report has been submitted by the Director, MoEF&CC, Regional office, Bhopal vide

their letter no.3-27/276(ENV)/217 dated 11.04.2017 (Annexure C).

o Mining production has been suspended and we have obtained a certificate from District Geologist,

Kutch stating that our Rata Talab mining production has been suspended since December 2015

(Annexure D).

r To Comply with mine safety, road maintenance work, plantation work, exploration work, etc. werecarried out considering the fact that mining lease operation discontinuance for more than 2 year

period as per Rule 20 of Mineral Concession Rule 2016, lease will be lapsed. (Annexure E).

We request your goodself to consider our EC proposal additional information compliance and kindly

recommend our project for grant EC.

Thanking you,

Yours faithfully,

Encl: As above + CD enclosed including annexures.

Works:GIDC, lndlus. AreaPorbandar - 360577.Gujarat, lndiaPh. : +91 -286-22217 BBl9Fax: +91-286-2222719

Mining Division :OrientAbrasives Ltd.Orient House, Yogeshwar Nagar,Khambhalia - 361305.Dist. Devbhoomi Dwarka . (Gujarat)Tele/Fax : +9 1 -2833-2347 56

Page 3: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

ORIEIYT ABRASTVES LIMTTEDNo. OAL,tlIoEF CC/Rata/201 5-1 6/

To,

The Director (Non-Coal Mining),Minisny of Environment, Forest & Climate Change.Indira Paryavaran Bhavan,Jor Bag road,Nerv Delhi

sub; submissiott of additional information rvas souglrt by the EAC members during the 7,h REACmeeting on 22'd June 2016 for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (l 10.07 ha), village-Moti Balachor,Taluka-Abdasa, District-Kachchh, Gujarat.

Respected Sir,

with reference to the above subject, our project for EC proposal was considered in 7s REAC meeting on 22,1 June2016 for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine (110.07 ha.) of M/s. orient Abrasives Ltd. iocarecl in village Moti Balachor,Taluka-e-bdasa, Disfrict Kachchh, Gujarat for etth;ncement of producrion capacity to 1,10,022 TpA.our Ec proposal for production capaciry for Rata Talab Bauxite Mine is i,10,022 TpA, including High gracle andLow grade material with very' less skipping ratio. Ir was consider.d';'i-#;t;il and additionalinformation

"vas sought" our replies for these queries are enclosed as separate sheet (Annexre.R-l) along with this

N4/s' orient Abrasives Limited is integrated to vntuE ADDITToN & CA?TIIE power< GENERATT'N pLANT,Providing Employment opportrmity to 1000 people is able ro continue irs operation.

our company had faced enormous difficulry in running the PLANT, facing Raw Material shortage, euali[, haw)laterials and its consistent suppiy.

Sustenance of value Addition Plant on lorv capacity mine production and regular quality supplv of Raw material tothe value Addirion Industry located in Forbandar District of Gujarat State is literally being hampered.

very lor'v Mine production capacity had econornically difficult to conduct Mining operations considering thccompliance of environment measues like Reclamation and Rehabilitation, csR, huge overhead cost of projectoperations the process of obtaining Environment clealance is normally takes long time period rvhich ultimatelycausing huge over head financial losses.

3i,T.[-'.',TJ,fffiru'ff,[Jil:.'.1"ff::,i:::f#:fvment opportunirv/ Job opportunirv in the rocar vllages and

our company future depends on timely clearance of EC, rvhich is pending since 2010 onrvards.we request your goodself to consider oar EC proposal additional informafion compliance and kindly grant EC.Thanking you.

Yours faithfully,For, Orient Abrasives Ltd.

I/F- ------'\__-.F /C1

Ceneral fiIAnager -" Mines

Date 11.07,2016Project No. J-ttOtSHl n0r0llA.fr (i}{)

{S,.16=_ -rt?i

&j,i",..

$r'

ii:

AffiHEXURE AJlr

,d,r tRegistered Office & Works :GIDC, lndlus. AreaPorbandar - 360577.Gujarat, IndiaPh. ; =91-286-222178819Fax i +91-286-2222719

Mining Division :

Orient Abrasives Ltd.Orient House, Yogeshwar Nagar,Khambhalia - 361305.

Llrl-l.l

:td.ir* ,

.i. ,.

. j!j,

\..iTror

- rjn: l

Dist. Devbhoomi Dwarka . (Gujarar)Tele/Fax' +91 -? R?.3-2?,a7 \A

Page 4: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 5: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 6: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

2

4.

we undertake additional Greenbelt work in the safety/buffer zone

bank surrounding the catchment area and downstream area over an

along the

extent of

5.

6,

)-z ne-

We undertake to carry protective measures for Environment such as plantation

of Fruit bearing saplings at 2500 nos. per hectare. Also in addition, plantation ofNative plants & Awareness programme as per conservation plan involving

Forest Department and Gram Panchayat. Greenbelt will also be developed in

statutory barrier.

we hereby undertake to engage go% of Manpower and machineries

requirement from Local villages Moti Balachod, Nani Balachod & Kanday.

Company undertakes to take up CSR activities for supporting School education,

Medical carnps, water supply, for Fodder supply to Gaushala, skill development

training programme, at a cost of Rs.16.5 Lakh over a period of 5 years,

we hereby undertakes that Mining will be carried out by semi mechanized

mining sorting and sizing will be carried out through local labours, trucks and

machineries hired from local villagers, which will create additional employment

opportunities.

8. We hereby undertake to donate the existing infrastructure office, rest shelter

and labour quarters to Balachod village Gram Panchayat for their community

development activity at the end of the Mine life.

Date: .:lrr \,:. \;'r"'('

Place; Jam-KhambhaliaFo r, O risnt U,glqtivet"S$U$EQe.

7.

a

Page 7: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 8: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 9: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 10: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 11: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 12: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 13: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 14: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 15: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 16: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 17: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 18: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 19: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 20: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 21: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 22: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

$RI Xrh;"i' ARITASIVHS [,tr tI NTEBi:ii'.1 t.,l+:!i!Irt, : :l,r I i:)I {lill585,{

l':1 '91"

No.0&[,/MoEtCClRata/eO16-1# r,;.,.,',, t'

To,

The Dkector (Non-Coal Mining),Mlnistry cf Environnrent, Fsrest & Climate Ci?nge,lndira Paryav*ran Bhavqn,Jor BEg road,

New Delhi

Sefr

Respe$ed Sir,

with reference t* the above subiect, our project for EC proposal was considered in 7th REAC mseting on z2ndJune' 2016 & gth RSAC meeting on 22d Augurt, 201s for our Rata Talab Bauxite Mine {110.07 ha"} of M/s, ori*ntAbrasivts Ltd' locBted in village Moti Balachod, Taluka,Abdasa, Distrfst Kutch, Gujarat and additionat documentswas sought vide Mi*ut*s of the gs REAC meetirig h*!d on 7?s Au6ust, ?01.6 {Ann*xure t}.

Gur pr6j*fi EC proposal for productior capacity for Rata Talab Eauxite Mine is 1.,1"0,0?2 TpA for utiluatisn in theintegrated verus Aoomoru & capnvr Pcwrt Gsxenrxon pl-Arur, whirh is Froviding Ernp,loyment opportuility to1000 peaple.

our comp*ny had faced enormous dlfficulty in running the PLAF{T due to &aw Material shortage, Quality RawMaterials and its consistent supply" Su$tenance sf value Additisn plant on low capacity mine production is nateconomically viable.

very low Mine praduction rapacity *re economically difficulr to csndu(t Minins operaticns *onsid*ring theCompliance nf environment measures like &eciamatinn and Rehahllitation, CSR. huge overhe*d cost of projectoperBtions the rrrocess of obtainin6 Environment clearance is normalty takes 4 to 5 years which ultirnatelycausing huge overhead flnancial losses.

our cornpany future depends on tintely clearance of EC, which is pending rinse ?0L0 onwards. our projec-tclear*nces will Generate huge Empl*ymert Opportunities,/Job Opporttrnlties in rhe tocal villages and dirertlycontributing to the Micrq Rural ficonomim,

*a F-{t. *1fl, r'

1' ^ Ju,n na"t;-,,, ifi.l".-s,\ro' i8s. "' . r,1- '"' "'

, ' 1,1.,,, ,,:,*# sate: a$.03.2o1?, ., t*',,., , "'' ,[r#*o;u.t No, J-11015/4ilasr$h"ll {M}

AT{NEXURE B

;1;i

"d)$_-v b"luU_

Works :

i"lllli. ir ljai.i i.rij..:lrlrir;rt',i:r. ;lilrl,l,,r:,!Jl-r r: lrrlL,irf I i

'r r..:(r-i.irr, ,-,1

submlssirn of additionar informrticn as sought by sAC nre*bers during gtr REAC msetinsireld cn 72od August. ?s16 for our nata trarab fiauxite Mine {110.07 ha} of Mls. orientAbr*sives Ltd" located at villag* Moti Barachnd, Taluka Abdasa, oi$trint Kutch, 6ujaralfPrsjest No. J-xxo15/4ilt0il-ffi.fi IMUL' Mlnutes of the gth RIAC meetinB herd on zzd August zoi5, agenda itsm no, z.r.2" Our letter no. OAUM$ErCCIRBIa/201S,16 dated tt.t]7.2016

Mlnlng Dlvirlon:0rient **brabivBs Ltd.Orient llouse, Yogestwar Nagar,Klrarnbhaha - 3G13OS.Drsl.levbhoomr Dwarka . ((iujaral )IeleiFax : +91,2833-234I56

Page 23: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7
Page 24: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

ANNEXURE C

SPEED POS T

LIT{fr TK6F'n xr-tu qTqiil,] *-sq qr,'

GOVERNIIENT OF INDIA llegionalOfflce, W'estet'n Regior:.

' ' +-'tsF 'lzlrdrrjT rTEl=l

Wnz[{Uf F qT q:flEzf ^Kenctrila parvavaran Bharan"'

)II\lSTl{y 0f ENVlRONMtiir-T& FOR},STS Tq'T 1is q0 :/[-ink Road \o ']

E-;,iffi'*r +r/Rav i Shankar Nagar,"-tr{q

q{d qlqra (q0co}/Bhopal-462016(M.P.)

.rt{: 07i5- 24650s4, +s's' 07s5&246i0s4

FireNo.3_27l20r6(ENV)f 8rT e,oEFF

"il::l.,tmffr**"*'l ti

Shri Surenclla KuntiirDirector'.l\'linistrv o['Environnrent. Forcst & Climate Changc.lrtdila Pary"avarart Bharvan..lrrr Ba,llt Rt,a.l. Alig.urrl.\cri [)e ilri- i iU(r(r-l

SLrh: Strbrnission ot'reporr tbr Rata Taiab Bauxitc Mine i-rl \lr's. Oricnt Abrasives Ltd. (Area 110.07

ha. ) S.no. l;5rP. Village i\{oti Balachod. taluka Abdasa. District Kutch. Ciqarat

I{et: Sumtnan r"ecord: trf'?'r' rneeting rrt't,.\C ot \{ining project held on lf JLtne & ll iune. 1016 anrl

ietter tri' PP dated 08 07.1(,) I 6. I 0. I 0.10 1 6 arrd 10.01.10 I I regalrlinq.

\ rr-

\\'ith rclcrence t'l the lrbovq. kindlr llrrcl ircreuith a iLnrnrar\ rcport in [h* abo'.'e proiect.

:.(l A copt ol'tlris reporl is lreing foruarcled to R(). GPP['B, Kutclr iCuiarat) also *'ith i'equeil\ 11]

plo'. lde ca-r:r.inrcirt5 ,'Obscrva1.ion rr ithin tri.o r.rccks. iianl .

-i.0 This has the apprtrvai of the competent authoriry'.

\ rrrrl Euil.hlrrlli,/t I>*1\. r

(8.8. Barm:rn)Scientist'G'

Copv to:

l. Shri R.P. Gupta. Regional Otllcer. GPCR. Kataria Crrmplex. tlrst iloor. llangalam Char Rasta.

\icar Inconre tax trl'}jcc. Sanskar r'agar. BlrLri- Kutch Guiarat-i70 00 l- lvith requests to kindllgo through the report and conrments/ observations if An\. nrav kindlr be conrnrunicateduithin trro wecks of reccipt ol'this lettcrlreJrort to both IIoEF&CC. New Delhi and ROBhopal.

2. Mf Orient Abrasives Ltd., "'Orient House". Dattani Nagar, Yogeshrvar Nagar. Jamkhambhalia^

1r/istrict Devbhoomi D'rvarka. Gujarat.

h

nNY/"\\

(B.B.llarman)Screntist'C'

ir

Page 25: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

Details of the Project (Area,Location, Accessibility, etc.)

Name of mine: Rata Talab Bauxite MineProject No: J-11015/47/2011-IA.II(M)Lease Area: 110.07 HaProduction Capacity: 1,10,022 TPALocation of Mine: S. No. 275/P of Village Moti Balachod, TalukaAbdasa, Dist Kutch, Gujarat. Mine lease is located between N23°12'46.7"to N23°13'36.7" latitude and E69°09'52.5" to E69°10'56.6" longitude.

- -,

\. I-('23..··,~··J

S.No. Details asked

Summary of inspection toMis. Orient Abrasives Limited

Rata talab Bauxite MineJ-l1015/47/2011-IA.II (M)

Submission

Accessibility:• Lease area is accessible through state highway (SH 49) along Bhuj­

Na1ia road and after crossing railway line. Western part of theembankment over Naira river. Western part of the lease is accessiblethrough Bhuj-Nalia road upto Bhimpar village.

• Nearest Railway Station is Bhuj about 54.5 kms in East directionfrom the site.

• Nearest Airport is Jamnagar about 54.5 km away in NEdirection from the site.

• Mundra is the nearest Sea Port, which is about 70 km away in SEdirection from the lease area.

2 Date of Lease grant Lease was granted on dated 14.09.1973 and executed on 03.06.1974, afterthat mining operation was reportedlv carried out.

3

4

Date of Commencement ofmining operationMethod of Operation

Lease was executed on 03.06.1974 and after that mining operation wasreportedly commenced.Semi Mechanised Open Cast Mining (OTFM)In general bauxite 'is soft in nature & can be easily excavated by excavator.The part of bauxites horizon is of compact nature & require drilling &blasting and it will be carried out with the help of Jack hammer &compressor. Management infonned that they intend to eliminate blastingand alternative method (for mineral extraction such as, ripper dozer/rockbreakers etc. will be practiced wherever practicable. Controlled blastingpractice will be adopted, if required. PP also informed that Blasting will becarried out under the supervision of statutory persons as per the Mines Act.The PP is doing sizing & shorting manually and dispatch of bauxitemineral is by trucks.

5 Basis ofOperation As reported, Lease was granted on dated 14.09.1973 and executed on03.06.1974, after that mining operation was carried out. Based onapproved Mining Plan from IBM and Intimation given to IBM, CGM,DGMS from commissioning of mining operation. Monthly, Annual returnssubmitted to CGM, IBM, DGMS. Advance royalty was stated to havebeen paid to government before dispatch of material. After generatingonline royalty, the material dispatch from mine site commences.

ToR Granted for Rata Talab Bauxite Mine on 15.01.2015 for 1,10,022

TPA.

ToR application submission date: 10.01.2011ToR revised application date: 08.03.2014.

ToR Grant date

ToR application6

7

8 Final EIA & EC presentation As reported, Final EIA submitted on 09.05.2016. EC presentation was heldduring June 22-23, 2016 and August 22-23,2016.

9 Minutes of EC meeting andadditional information

EAC sought following additional information/action:i) The species selected for green belt should be revised as per the CPCB

guidelines. Also the number of saplings for Greenbelt d'evelopment aretoo less for the area in which plantation is to be carried out. Therevised plan needs to be submitted.

ii) A detailed time bound action plan along with the budgetary provisionfor issues raised during the Public Hearing shall be submitted.

iii) It appears that mine had been operated even after the submissionof Board Resolution that violation of EPA will not be done in

Page 26: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

future. An inspection report from Regional Office of MoEF '.shall be obtained to ascertain the violation. -~

jv) A detailed report on management of water body/seasonal river passingthrough the mine lease area.

Month wise production detail has been provided separately.

"I

1. PP ~eplied thatthey will get theCTE & CC&Afrom the Boardand after that theywill start theProductionactivity.

2. It has been statedthat PP hasPartiallyconstructedfencing III themine boundaryarea, some part isnot done and PPinformed thatthey will fencetheir mining leasearea and as perBoard'srecommendationthey will developthe Green' BeltArea III theupcomingMonsoon Season.

Reply

PP replied that theywill not carry out anymining activities attheir unit withoutobtaining priorpermission from thecompetent authority.

1. PP replied thatthey are regularlydoing plantationactivity in theirr

1. Production- ~houid be-started

only afterobtained CC&Afrom Board.

2. Fencing workshould becompleted,wherever isincomplete aswell as Greenbeltshould bedeveloped innext monsoon.

Violation Noticefrom GPCB

1. Fencing shouldbe donesurrounding theplantation and

During the time ofvisit, Miningactivities were not inoperation, whichshould not be carriedout without obtainingprior pennission ofCompetent Authority.

Date

01.02.2017

17.10.2015

29.07.201-6

2

3

Sr.No.

Inspection of the mine was carried out on 03.01.2017.Officials present during the inspection are:i) Shri B. B. Barman, Director, MoEF, Regional office, Bhopal.ii) Shri R. P. Gupta, Regional Officer, GPCB, Bhuj.iii) Shri Kirti Rathod, Mining Engineer.iv) Shri Gunanand Roy, Dy. General Manager (Mines)v) Shri Keyur Rajpura, Dy. Manager (Geology)Board resolution has been submitted to MoEF&CC vide PP letter dated10.10.2014 stating that violation will not be repeated in future.

After ToR 1,05,050 MT production has been carried out. The PP statedthat due to safety measure the mineral production were carried outand all the low grade rejects were taken into production and recordedas production thereby conserving the mineral. This seems to be aviolation.

10 Site Inspection

11 Details of undertakingsubmitted, if any, before andafter ToR

12 Details of Operation carriedout after ToR

13 Monthwise Production­Dispatch quantity and stock.

14 Chronology of Action takenby GPCB

Page 27: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

mine. mine lease area.2. Mining

..activIty

must be started- only after 2. PP agreed to

obtaining EC obtainfrom competentauthority andCTE/CC&Afrom Board.

IS Details of Show cause NilNotice/Closure notices issuedby GPCB, ifany.

16 Details of Court case GPCB has filed Criminal Case vide case No. 742/2016 dated 05.12.2016(Credible Action) number, and the matter is sub-judice.date, etc.

17 Certificate of discontinuance Department of Geology & Mining has issued a certificate vide letter no.issued by The Geologist! JKK/ML/74/922 dated 09.02.2017 for discontinuance of production &Govt. authority. dispatch ofBauxite mineral since December, 2015.

18 Details of inspection carried • GPCB inspection/violation letter has been provided separately.out by Govt. authority, • DGMS Inspection/violation letter has been provided separately.Violation letters issued byDGMS, IBM, GPCB and itsaction taken.

19 An Undertaking that mining Copy of Fresh Undertaking dated 17.03.2017 has been provided.activity will not be donewithout obtaining permissionfrom the authority.

20 Reason for Violation done /Purpose of production Reason for operation cited are as below:obtained and present status. • Machinery and labours were engaged from nearby villages on

three year_contract basis, which is as per the DGMS direction/guidelines,removing the machinery and manpower the management had to pay idlehire charges and labour wages even if production operation are stopped.

• Government permission for low grade bauxite take long durationwhich involves in re-handling cost and the same were despatched withRoyalty challan obtained from the Geology Department.

• Regional officer, GPCB, Kutch has inspected the mine on 01.02.2017and noted that all mining activities have been stopped and instructednot to start mining activities without obtaining permission fromcompetent authority.

• ToR has been granted on 15.01.2015. As per PP, due to safetymeasure the mineral production were carried out and all the low graderejects were taken into production and recorded as production therebyconserving the mineral. Since the contract labour were engaged andmanagement had to pay the labour wages on production. Lastproduction was in November 2015. Production has been suspendedsince December 2015.

• Therefore, there has been violation despite resolution letter of PPdated 10.10.2014 as mentioned at 51. 11 above till November,2015.

• PP submitted a fresh resolution that they will not repeat violation/start operation without EC.

Page 28: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

q[4,

{i."rt*tl(rrL6-u)di,RQ.-a qqLd.ar ldt..fluLd$+il tRqLg.ttotat

+fl\L-t,

Ropr , gE9 {leeL-fl ia qLerq'is crt.t-[ dLEuLda,,tFL.r-il q.L6-r.lcLa[])i'r*r{ rtL0 s'rilx't?*-1q rir qliry O.lLat oirt g'i..tL 0r.6.cr.

+iec.[ : (t)r,tL.ttl dr.?y.cr.?ot s t1 tguLa.(t)r,rLq-il ct.r.oi .o?.?ot9 -ft tgr,tL.L.

AHzuHXUffiH }t. {tss/ai.t}i"eiexi \.t xojlrtt t Lt+ril-{} S{.t'I,

t?rt? [Q.uL-t +ti" u[i.'r uLg,dlc-erL +itr uat, g%-sqe.Ot. L,- .O?..?Otg

%ztc{L?ct +ttPt %QtLcttL{ i }tLrti. EES dlc_etrnr i,t-ct_st+t,t_ ctrglEr-tl qLeLiStd[ 'LL.rtL u{ i.teq rL1 j .*z.ce.oc rr+ctLrtr .i';.o}ffir.,1|'i,,s-[.Le1r])

+LrErulli dr.oy.1o.q.kes ,.r1 ?o .Ld .LLi'iigt ii* i.i"*ag 3?r.?l,rcrc,t.c3.oi.tc,x -r.r. tir sL'l r"LL.te r].r,tr oi.it dt.10.c3.tck3 ct?rl,:tr.?c.oi{.?o9.,: -il tlaue ut{l sL.{qL\il &aur &.

ut,t *LLdt'lcretlu +r-qQ. a,tLt qL& s.l*.u,Lt_l.ctq q.l oi,t(tLdt sle ?a,rrg liet ,LLRrqrLs'i. qL-r ard.i (Jc\rs-r_[i.** qu *,.gn ..{ie E ryeii uLrr-r.l 6r,rlt1-i_,crEl ? gz'ort1 qtd[tL ilrirrLi $rn i, ,iro.u. Geu-u urlqrqz ,,(MOEF) {q.+.trtL 6qq'j..L.tL) "t[aL U"d6t U]ttBtq?,t UtltctLrti. r,tLQ. U.

" +tld' i{}ttgtq"l uLqqLq[ itL{ t} i uLr] 6E.t .tttt-t'l.Le.[c .,t-.rQ. qLgs'l{*qr-rotq p{I qLl+Ls.rriil r,titeLttt aq.{ta stl- it1'Lai4ar 3.1r{} r,trii tg sie &1

s{{tL ir{ 3rt r,rLri GcqLan ,i* tq'r tq'r }[Lq-* ,trlrtsr{rrs airL ui.-tL trr{.t[

}:ll-n stctl. qjsuLtsa

"ti]r.rg Ge+ret-l\sLu uu i.t*.*tr-rctq q.l .,,iq ,rLg.r u3eL

l"l[q, rr.tllt-t'l Oso {gc-[-t ctp{L ? 3rot-i[ tgr,tL.L-fl. qt"/lr,tLi. a+Li qtrJ6Ect tLtlt'l,Le{lurL lEJ qrrLsi +sd " ,{q[q*iL Bct,.?-+L urrlgLtr>.. ,r (MOEF)ttq.t..tttL 6qqi.L qL) ?,tr ]tqr*rq". i..,o,r,i r,tLae r] * tgla,t e{r.{.

t?rr? Hflr-t ui. q[\ry qLst

Page 29: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

No: JKK/ML/74/922,

Office of The Geologist,

Geology & Mining Department,

Jilla Seva Sadan, Bhuj - Kutch

Date:09.02.2017To,

The Manager (Mines),

Orient Abrasives Ltd.,

GIDC Area,

Porbandar.

Sub: Regarding No Production of Bauxite Mineral, from December 2015, for the Bauxite

Mining Lease located in village Moti Balachhod in Kutch District.

Ref: (1) Your Letter dated 24.06.20L6 and

(2) Letter dated 06.02.20L7

Gentlemen,

It is to inform with "Jay Bharat"; that the Government has granted a Mining Lease for Bauxite

Mineral at Survey Number 275/p, over an area of L10.07.00 Hectares at village Balachod Moti, Taluka

Abdasa, District Kutch. This Lease was granted on 04.10.1973 for a period of 20 years, and its Lease deed

was executed on A3.O6.L974. Application dated 10.03.1993 & 29.05.2013 for its Renewal is underprocess.

As per Monthly Returns for this Mining Lease, submitted by On Line and submitted Hard Copies,

that there is no Production-Dispatches from December 2015. As per above reference No. 1 and 2 thiscertificate is being issued for obtaining "Environment Clearance Certificate" as under:

TO WHOMSOEVER IT MAY CONCERN

This Certificate is being issued that Monthly Returns by Online as well as its Hard copies

submitted to this office from December 20L5 for the above said Mining Lease. According to the records

verified with this office, fou have stopped production and dispatch of Bauxite Mineral from December

2015.

As per above reference No. 1 and 2, considering the applications for above said Mining Lease,

this certificate is being issued only for the purpose to obtain "Environment Clearance Certificate"(MOEF), which may be noted.

f;#@tndhrrn'(=*-s\o\,

*--::i {=,J

(*+rt'1*)

sd/-

Geologist,

Geology & Mining Department

Bhuj (Kutch)

'-'' l'''t'-t I -

,"I-Prlf*'f\,a$F'^E -1[

{a'{*ii**'*"'st 'rqAe3-\a\ '&i.t:i''

=,1*

'.Ii;\ -S t" + 'r

EFoz

J

t

oo. \i')* I

le],f

ldli4rfi1,

w#i'",!'r{*i*u

Page 30: ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITEDenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/online/EC/... · 2017. 5. 4. · ORIENT ABRASIVES LIMITED ctN. 124299DL197 1P1C005854 No. OAL/MoE FCClRata/20 t6-t7

ANNEXURE EIHE Ci\Zli'l"lE OIr tNI)lA : Lx't'tt,\Otil)tNAI{}. ll',rtt ll S11 . l{i}l

I:-\lines * ithin a peri.d of nincty cra1,s liom the tratc o1'r.eceipt or'such appricati.r.\Iodification attcl revicrv of the mining plan.' ( l) 'l'he nrining plap o.ce a1'r,r.r.,ccl s5all

'c su[r.jccr rtr rur ierr

i11.'::::*'"" at an interr"al olc'cr)'tir:e.vears starting t,'.,,r',,ii.'J*..,,j1 .*..u,in,., .l'rlrc duir.c\ccrrcLl rrriuirr!

{2) At least onc huncirecl.eightl clal's belbre rhe orpir.r or'e'cr'-, li, ci.rcar.s per.ircl spcciricti i, su5-rrrrc { r}. rlrciesscc shall subtrit a nrini.g. plari tbr nrini,g,.pJ'aii(;;1s-ri;.-.'i*r';u".r'rlr.r, suhserirric:,r -\..r.s rr.crrirrcri i,acc.rclancc *'ith ruie r.-;. *,hich shalr be disposld oI in acc.rcrancc rr itrr rurc r 6.{i) A holdcr ol'a nrining lcasc mal scek modiilcati.ns in thc app',rc.d mining plan as arc c.rrsidr.rcd cr'etiic.l.keeping i, vierv changcs in rhe business cn',i'onmenr.,,r.r,,rli,i.l;lii,iing in.r"rr" in pr,iiucri,n cupircirr..r.irrthc interest o1'salt and..scientillc mining. conservation ol.nriner.:rls. Iirrlthe f.rr.otectitln ol.er.rr ir.onn.rcrrit or. iirrrttlhet'reas.n to be specilied in r'riring by: thc holcle'ol'a rni.ing t.rr.i. ,t,,r nr.clifrcatiorr to. rrrinirrr ,l,n sl*iilhre anpror,cd by,thc approving aurhoriiy that appror.,cd thc inLtialinining ptrn('1) ln case ol'm.dilloatitlns t. a mining plan. thc pr.r'isi.ns Il'rulc l(: shall appl.r. rnrrturi,t.tlrttrlt(li.\.(51 ln casc .l'a sjstcm establishcrj b-r thc Statc (ior.e'nrrcnt. the m.rlillcati.n ,l'nrinin!l plirn slrirll hc irritccolclancc rr ith suclr sl,stcnt.

CIJ:\pI-ER VI: EXI,tRy OF A IilNtN(; LFl,\.St_Auction ;lost crpirv of a rrtini,g lcasc'- on tlre expir.r or'thc lr',sc pc'iod. thc r,i'irro Icasc slrull hc ,r.r ul) r()i.aucti.n as pcr thc p'.cedurc .p..ill"d in thc Act ancl ,.uics ,rr..r",i,"r.lrni.,..Iliglrt of first relusal'- ( l) ]'he holdcr o1'a mining Icasc grantccl rir. cupri.,c purposc shal harc r5c r.i!1rr,1.rrr.sr'c-l'usal

al the tinre of'atrctiort held firr rr.t t.rr" uti.r the Jrpir., ,,r rr-..i.'r." perriocl in rhc lirll.rri'rs r.:*rr,tr.:(a) t. bc eligible to cxet'cise thc .ight ol'tl.st relirsal. Iirc lcrssee shaJl coi,pr.,, r'it]r thc ctrntri(iorrs .r.tiremining iease. thcr Act and rhe rulcs rnadc thcrrcundcr till its cxpir.;,(h) p'ior to publication ol'thc notice inviting tendcr. thc Stlrc Cor.crnrncnt slrall eirc u noticu r() rl.rc lcsscc

'etltri.ing the lcssce

1o,sn,?c.ili' his rvillinlncss .r.nrn-* illir!rcss [{} cxcrcisc thc righr .l' rlr.sr r.e iirsiil inrv.iting. rvithin a pcr.i.d ot.rhir.ty da1,s ol.r-.c,cei,t.1.such n.tici::(c) Lhe notice inr,itinq tcnder.shali spccitj, that thc.lcsscc hoiJing rhc Ir.rasc lrrior.to c.rpiri, ol.thc ntinirrr ltusehas ttle right of'fi'st relusal and inoti ,tru spccif.v lris *iliirgircss ,rr,ror-,,,ilt;,r_ercss sirccili"r;l;,.'];,i,;i'i:sub-cJaLrse ( b). il'an1,;

(d) upiin conclusion 0i'the second roun<l ol'aucti.n. llrc- SLrrte (i.r ernnrcn[ .shal] issue a n,licc 1., rl:c Jcssecsccking rvt'itten conflrmation of his u'iilingness to cxcrcisc the rigrrt ol'Iir.st r.lirsal rrithirr . ,eri.tj .1.scr.cn da),s ol'c.nc:lusion.l'tire scc,.d rourid ol.aLrcti...,n,- '- " - "*"

(c) thc notice givr-'n under clausc (d) shall bc ackno$'lcrlgcd hr t.hc lcsscc and \.lro shall. r|irlrirr u Pcr.iod,1.1ilicenc1a1'sol'rccciptol'thcnoticcissre,Jrn.i.rclausi.rdl..t., .ir.thcrighLoi'llrsr'clirsrl irrrrr.irirrgr.the State ctl'crnnlent. l'ailing rvhich it shall bo con.slnrEcl rhar thc iessee is,.1 clcsir..uq trl.crcrr.:irinr rhi,.ight ol-lirst rc{'usal a,d the p'cf'c.r'ed biclcier shall be crrtitrct.r r,, , ,,,ining lcasc i, ,,," ,,r,,n,,.,]il.i]iili;:,i'iitht: ivlineral (Auction) I{ules" 20l5: and

(1) il'the lessee cxcrcises the right ol. lirst. re lirsal in [crms ,.,i.clrrs" (c) antl muLchcs Lhc hisltcst llrral ol.lur.p'ice' the iesscc shali,cleenred.t. bc the preren'c.r ui,r.i" -t,, ,,i".;;;i,;;;;r;;.; o:",'.;',;.Jlr;:rcir:r rrccr.*,rraliel the second rottncl ol'aLtction and shall b(: cnlitleci to thc rninirg lease in tlrc nranrcr 'r

.r irlctl irr rhcNlincral (Auction) Rulcs. 2015. i

Cl IA pTER \/t I : LA pSIi, S U RIiUN t) Ii * O lr .t,t., t{ I I I N,_\.t,r ON

L:rpsirrg of the mirrinq lease'- ( I) Subicct to the conditions o1' rhis r.ulc r'hcrc nrining .pc.ur.i.nr rlr.c r]()lJ{r:r.'rnre,cccl trithirt a pe}iod oltrvo j'aott iionr'irra ciatc ol'cxccuti()n ()r'thc nrining lcrr.sc..r is tli.rc.rrtinrrctl,rirr..cr-'niittutlus period ol'Lrrro,v'ears alterl corrln-rcnccrncnl ol'such opcrations. {.hc nrininq lcasc sSail lapsc.:lt'l hc lapsing of'a miriing lea-se shall be recordcd thlou-qh an ordtl issLrcd b-r. thc Slarc Cor ur.nrcrr urtl shrrll"ls,,r f,c ct'rntmunicated to the lessee .

i-:i Where a lessec is unablc t() commcncc thc mining opcralions rvirhin a pcriod tli.t\r() \.car.s Irrurr titc Jatc ul.t\'i!-'r"llon ol'tlre rninine Iease tlr cliscontinuation ot'nrining i)l)er,tions ti,r', ",rr,r.,, r,.ir,,,r,ii,,i, .,,r'i,.,,,. hs ,*rrs-::::t an application to thc Statc (i<l'crnmcnt. cxplaininu ih"',..rr,,n. ri,, tt,,-1r.,,,.,. :,;].;;;;;;":;;;,,,;;ir;"j:;' -i .-)::ii--\ o1- such per.iod 0[' Lrr,rt t,cars :

Pi-ovidcd rvhcrc the lessec has lailcd to makc Lhc applicarirrn rvithin rhc tirnc sripulatccl alr.r c. rlrc ltrscq:- l::lsc on expir; ol'the period ol.tw,o ,r,ears.

I

F

18.

r9.

r