Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer binding of ...
Transcript of Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer binding of ...
This document is downloaded from DR‑NTU (https://dr.ntu.edu.sg)Nanyang Technological University, Singapore.
Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer bindingof malachite green
Zhou, Yubin; Chi, Hong; Wu, Yuanyuan; Marks, Robert S.; Steele, Terry W. J.
2016
Zhou, Y., Chi, H., Wu, Y., Marks, R. S., & Steele, T. W. J. (2016). Organic additives stabilizeRNA aptamer binding of malachite green. Talanta, 160, 172‑182.
https://hdl.handle.net/10356/80594
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2016.06.067
© 2016 Elsevier. This is the author created version of a work that has been peer reviewedand accepted for publication by Talanta, Elsevier. It incorporates referee’s comments butchanges resulting from the publishing process, such as copyediting, structural formatting,may not be reflected in this document. The published version is available at:[http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2016.06.067].
Downloaded on 14 Dec 2021 13:05:34 SGT
* Abbreviations
MG, malachite green; MGOH, malachite green carbinol base; MGA, malachite green
aptamer; ACN, acetonitrile; DMSO, Dimethyl sulfoxide; EtOH, ethanol.
1
Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer binding of 1
malachite green 2
Yubin Zhoua, Hong Chia, Yuanyuan Wua, Robert S. Marksa,b, Terry W.J. Steelea,* 3
a School of Materials Science & Engineering, College of Engineering, Nanyang 4
Technological University, 50 Nanyang Avenue, Singapore 639798, Singapore 5
b Department of Biotechnology Engineering, Faculty of Engineering Sciences, Ben 6
Gurion University of the Negev, P.O. Box 653, Beer Sheva 84105, Israel 7
* Corresponding Author: 8
Terry W.J. Steele: [email protected], 9
Tel.:65-65927594, fax: 65-67909081. 10
Abstract 11
Aptamer-ligand binding has been utilized for biological applications due to its specific 12
binding and synthetic nature. However, the applications will be limited if the binding 13
or the ligand is unstable. Malachite green aptamer (MGA) and its labile ligand 14
malachite green (MG) were found to have increasing apparent dissociation constants 15
(Kd) as determined through the first order rate loss of emission intensity of the MGA-16
MG fluorescent complex. The fluorescent intensity loss was hypothesized to be from 17
the hydrolysis of MG into malachite green carbinol base (MGOH). Random screening 18
organic additives were found to reduce or retain the fluorescence emission and the 19
calculated apparent Kd of MGA-MG binding. The protective effect became more 20
apparent as the percentage of organic additives increased up to 10% v/v. The 21
mechanism behind the organic additive protective effects was primarily from a ~5X 22
increase in first order rate kinetics of MGOHMG (kMGOHMG), which significantly 23
changed the equilibrium constant (Keq), favoring the generation of MG, versus 24
MGOH without organic additives. A simple way has been developed to stabilize the 25
apparent Kd of MGA-MG binding over 24 hours, which may be beneficial in 26
stabilizing other triphenylmethane or carbocation ligand-aptamer interactions that are 27
susceptible to SN1 hydrolysis. 28
Keywords 29
2
Malachite green aptamer, malachite green, ligand hydrolysis, adaptive binding, 30
equilibrium 31
1. Introduction 32
Oligonucleotide aptamers have been widely studied in biological applications such 33
as biosensing [1-4], cell imaging [5, 6], drug/siRNA delivery [7, 8] and in vivo 34
therapeutics [9], due to their specific recognition, adaptive binding and synthetic 35
nature [10, 11]. Compared to antibodies, aptamers possess advantages such as low 36
molecular weights, facile modification and low immunogenicity [12, 13]. However, 37
lability of ligands affects the binding stability with aptamers, limiting their 38
applications [14]. In this study, malachite green aptamer (MGA) with its labile ligand 39
malachite green (MG) was chosen as a model system to study the aptamer-ligand 40
binding stability over time based on MG’s enhancement of fluorescence upon aptamer 41
adaptive binding. The MGA-MG complex is fluorescent due to an extended π-system 42
of the MG that is forced to become planar by the dynamic binding of the MGA [15, 43
16]. 44
MGA has been utilized for sensing the banned fungicide MG [17] with a limit of 45
detection down to 5 nM [15]. Detection of such low concentrations is due to the 46
unique enhanced quantum yield (2000X) upon MGA adaptive folding around MG as 47
seen in Fig. 1B [16]. MG is currently employed in as a dye in paper, leather, inks, 48
waxes, and textiles and is known for its use in algal inhibition in fish farming, 49
although this practice has been banned in most developing countries due to acute 50
toxicities in fish and humans [18]. MG belongs to a large family of triphenylmethane 51
compounds that have considerable economic importance, as they are used in the 52
printing industry (to brighten carbon black), sensor applications and as chrome dyes 53
for wool and color formers in self-replicating/thermoresponsive papers. The latest 54
known commercial statistics shows over 25 kilotons of product per year of various 55
triphenylmethanes with unknown amounts ending in industrial waste waters and 56
treatment plants [19]. Thus there exists a need for development of stable, fast, and 57
accurate sensor development towards triphenylmethane derivatives, all of which are 58
more or less susceptible to hydrolysis attack. Detection assays must then incorporate 59
aspects of portability, specificity, and sensitive quantitation of MG in a range of 60
aqueous environments. Additionally, it has been reported that MG can convert to its 61
derivatives such as malachite green carbinol base (MGOH) [20, 21] and 62
3
leucomalachite green [22], which affects the sensitivity and specificity of the MGA-63
MG binding complex (Fig. 1A). 64
Fig. 1
65
However, assessments of temporal Kd of MG to MGA and prevention of MG 66
hydrolysis (and related triphenylmethane derivatives) have not been investigated to 67
our knowledge, despite the economic importance of detecting triphenylmethane 68
derivatives in dye industrial wastewaters and within the food supply. 69
In this work, the adaptive binding behavior of MG to its RNA aptamer was 70
assessed by for temporal fluorescence with various organic additives added to prevent 71
the decreasing fluorescence intensities. The apparent dissociation constant, Kd was 72
determined to be comparable to the reported value of 200 nM [23] at time 0. 73
However, the fluorescence intensity and the apparent Kd decreased as a function of 74
time, but stabilized after 5 h, which suggested a change in equilibrium in the RNA 75
aptamer or MG. We noted that when organic additives were initially employed to 76
dissolve various triphenylmethane dyes, the Kd was less sensitive to time. 77
Investigation of the organic additives allowed more sensitive and reproducible 78
determination of MG, which is a simple strategy with little to no impact on Kd. The 79
increase in stability minimizes deviations in triphenylmethane detection and facilitates 80
the further development of RNA aptamer-based applications. More importantly, the 81
discovery of kinetic stabilization of the MGA-MG model may provide a simple 82
method of stabilization for triphenylmethane, triarylmethane, or other carbocation-83
susceptible ligands that are known to undergo hydrolysis. 84
2. Materials and methods 85
2.1. Materials 86
Desalted RNA aptamer (MGA) (5’-87
GGAUCCCGACUGGCGAGAGCCAGGUAACGAAUGGAUCC-3’) was purchased 88
from AITbiotech Pte Ltd Singapore. Malachite green oxalate (MG) and malachite 89
green carbinol base (MGOH) were purchased from Sigma Aldrich, Singapore. 90
Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) was purchased from Alfa Aesar, USA. Ethanol (EtOH) 91
was purchased from Fisher Scientific, Singapore. HPLC grade acetonitrile (ACN) was 92
purchased from Tedia, USA. Polystyrene microplates (96-well) were purchased from 93
Corning, USA. All chemicals and materials were used as received. 94
4
2.2. Kd determination of MG to MGA 95
Binding buffer (pH = 6.7 unless otherwise specified) which consisted of 5.65 mM 96
NaH2PO4, 4.35 mM Na2HPO4, 10 mM MgCl2 and 1 mM NaCl was prepared 97
according to the literature [23, 24]. The effect of pH on binding was studied and the 98
results (Fig. S1) indicated that the suitable range for binding was pH 6-8.5. Thus, pH 99
at 6.7 was chosen for comparison to literature [23]. Malachite Green Aptamer (MGA) 100
was denatured at 95 ℃ for 1 min prior to the binding experiment. The binding of MG 101
to MGA was determined by fluorescence enhancement [16]. Kd was determined 102
varying concentrations of MGA with MG concentration (150 nM) held constant in 103
binding buffer with or without organic additive present at 25 ℃. MG fluorescence was 104
immediately assayed or time delayed from 0.5-24 h in 96-well polystyrene plates with 105
a Tecan Microplate spectrofluorometer (Infinite M200, Tecan Asia PTE LTD, 106
Singapore) at ex/em setting of 620 nm/656 nm. Based on the MG fluorescence 107
enhancement upon aptamer binding described above [16], fluorescence intensity of 108
MG (in fixed concentration) rises with increasing MGA concentration, and reaches a 109
plateau when 100% MG are bound. Thus, the fluorescence signal of MG against 110
added MGA concentration can be utilized for monitoring the binding. By combining 111
the change in fluorescence intensity with the known concentrations of MGA and MG 112
in the binding system, dissociation constant Kd value can be determined by the non-113
linear fitting in section 2.3 based on the literature by Wang et al [25, 26]. 114
Additionally, to test the recovery effect of organic additive on fluorescence (of 115
MGA-MG complex) after reduction, DMSO was added into the MGA-MG binding 116
complex 5 h after the binding was performed. 117
2.3. Fitting of dissociation constant Kd 118
The equation (Equation 1) used for fitting of Kd is displayed below, which is based 119
on previous investigations by Wang et al [25, 26].: 120
F = F0 + (Fmax − F0) ×([MG]0 + [MGA] + 𝐾d) − √([MG]0 + [MGA] + 𝐾d)2 − 4[MG]0 × [MGA]
2 × [MG]0 (1)
F and F0 are fluorescence units (FLU) in the presence and absence of aptamer, 121
respectively. Fmax is the FLU value upon 100% binding to aptamer. [MG]0 and 122
[MGA] are the initial concentrations within the binding system, and the Kd is the 123
dissociation constant. Non-linear fitting and statistical analysis were performed by 124
OriginPro 9.1. 125
2.4. HPLC-DAD study on stability of MG 126
5
An Agilent 1200 series high-performance liquid chromatography system with 127
diode array detector (DAD) was used to monitor the stability of MG. A UltisilTM C18 128
column (Welch Materials Inc.) of 5 µm and 4.6 × 250 mm was used for 129
chromatographic separation. The system was operated with a mobile phase flow rate 130
of 1.0 mL•min-1, and the diode array detector was set to continuously wavelength 131
scans of 200 to 800 nm with λmax of 265 and 620 nm for MGOH and MG, 132
respectively. Fresh MG (30 µM) in binding buffer was injected (20 µL) at 0 h and 24 133
h and MGOH (30 µM) as a standard in acetonitrile was injected (20 µL) at 0h. Elution 134
profile was 50 % mobile phase A (25 mM ammonium acetate, pH 6.8) / 50 % mobile 135
phase B (acetonitrile) for 5 min, a gradient to 15 % A / 85% B from 5 to 15 min, a 15 136
% A / 85% B from 15 to 18 min, followed by a ramp back to initial conditions from 137
18 to 21 min and held for 4 min thereafter. 138
2.5. Kinetic study on conversion between MG and MGOH 139
MG and MGOH were dissolved in pH 6.7 binding buffer with or without 10% 140
(V/V, the same to all description on percentage of organic additive in this article) 141
organic additive respectively. Then the sample was transferred to a quartz cuvette and 142
placed in a Varian Cary 50 UV-Vis spectrophotometer. The UV-Vis spectra were 143
recorded every 5 min for 12 hours. Absorbance maximum of MG at 618 nm was used 144
to calculate the change of MG. The decrease in MG at MGMGOH and the increase 145
in MG at MGOHMG were fitted by OriginPro 9.1 with first order equation. 146
2.7 Statistics 147
All statistics were performed with OriginPro 9.1 (OriginLab Corporation, 148
Northampton, MA 01060 USA). Linear regressions R2 were determined by ordinary 149
least squares. Statistical differences between two groups were performed by Student’s 150
t-test with significance level P < 0.05 (two-tailed test). 151
3. Results 152
3.1. Fluorescence intensity and apparent affinity of MGA-MG diminish over time 153
Based on the fluorescence enhancement of MG, the initial dissociation constant (Kd) 154
is determined to be 200 nM as seen in Fig. 2A and 2B, which compares well to the 155
analysis by Costa et al [23]. However, fluorescence intensity and apparent Kd of MG 156
decrease with time, but reach a plateau at 5 h as shown in Fig. 2A. At 24 h, 40.8% of 157
the fluorescence intensity at maximum [MGA]/ratio (6000 nM, MGA:MG = 40:1) 158
remains while the apparent Kd increases > 10000 nM. The fluorescence intensity at 159
maximum [MGA]/ratio undergoes a first order decay with k = 2.5×10-4 s-1 (Fig. 2C). 160
6
This decrease is attributed to the hydrolysis of MG in aqueous environment. Minute 161
changes in pH are also ruled out, as only minor shifts in Kd are seen across pH 6-8.5 162
(Fig. S1). Thus, the shifts in Kd are attributed to the flattened asymptote to linear-163
profiles after FLU decay. 164
Fig. 2
165
3.2. Organic additives prevent fluorescence decay while retaining Kd 166
Binding buffer with 3%-10% v/v acetonitrile (ACN), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) 167
or ethanol (EtOH), additives typically employed to increase solubility of organic 168
ligands, is mixed into the MGA-MG binding experiments (Fig. 3) towards assessment 169
of temporal fluorescent intensity. The MGA-MG fluorescence displays observable 170
increases across the largest concentrations/ratios of MGA:MG. With organic 171
addtives, > 9000 FLU are observed at [MGA] above 3000 nM as seen in Fig. 3A-C, 172
about 40% higher than 5500 FLU at time 0 h in Fig. 2A. This suggests MGMGOH 173
conversion is present even before the time 0 h measurements in Fig. 2A were taken. 174
The addition of organic additives changes the equilibrium constant, decay kinetics, or 175
both. In other words, known stocks of [MG] can never truly be prepared in aqueous 176
solutions, because of the fast hydrolysis equilibrium. To further quantitate the effects 177
of organic additives, the apparent Kd values are calculated and presented in Fig. 3D. 178
The apparent Kd shows a strong correlation with percentage of ACN, but weak to 179
moderate correlation in either DMSO or EtOH. Thus, only ACN weakens the overall 180
Kd, while DMSO and EtOH show little to no changes in Kd. 181
Fig. 3
182
3.3. Organic additives retain over >80% of fluorescence intensity after 24 h 183
The stability of MGA-MG binding after 24 h in the organic additive-buffers is 184
investigated towards preventing fluorescence decay. Fig. 4A-C illustrates the MGA-185
MG Kd fittings at 0 h and 24 h in the presence of ACN from 3 - 10% v/v. Similar 186
trends are found for DMSO and EtOH (data not shown). Fig. 4B,C summarize the 187
apparent Kd and FLUs at the highest [MGA]/ratio at 0 h and 24 h vs. conc. of organic 188
additive. FLU and apparent Kd are less prone to decay or increase, respectively, as the 189
organic additive increases, suggesting a change in Keq, decay kinetics, or both. For 190
example, with no additives, the FLU at maximum [MGA]/ratio decreases to 40.8% of 191
7
the original value and the apparent Kd increases ~ 65-fold after 24 h, Fig. 2A. The 192
addition of the 8-10% v/v DMSO additive shows no statistical difference in FLU units 193
after 24 h (at the 40:1 ratio), but a slight shift in the overall binding profile (which 194
incorporates all FLU ratios), doubles the Kd. EtOH has the inverse effect. Overall, 195
organic additives cause considerable shifts on the FLU decay kinetics as shown in 196
Table 1. The first order decay kinetics, as measured by FLU, decreased as the v/v% 197
increased from 3 to 10%, which indicates organic additives shifted the Keq 198
(MGMGOH) towards MG, and increasing the overall conc. of the fluorescent 199
MGA-MG complex. 200
Fig. 4
201
Table 1
202
3.4. Loss of MG fluorescence is attributed to hydrolysis, formation of MGOH 203
HPLC in-line with a diode array absorbance detector allows the quantification and 204
identification of MG derivatives through their absorbance spectra. MG (λmax = 620 205
nm) and MGOH (λmax = 265 nm) absorbance spectra are displayed in the Fig. 5A,B 206
insets. HPLC chromatogram overlays of MG 0 h, MG 24 h, MGOH standard is shown 207
in Fig. 5A. Under the HPLC separation conditions (see Methods), MG 0 h displays a 208
major peak at 11.1 min with a minor observed peak at 18.2 min attributed to the 209
MGOH (malachite green carbinol base). 210
Fig. 5
211
The MG peak decreases 36.3 % after 24 h (Fig. 5A) while the MGOH peak 212
increases 38.6%, nearly the same amount as seen in Fig. 5B. The MGOH peak in the 213
MG 0h sample has 19% AUC compared to the 30 µM standard MGOH; in other 214
words 5.7 µM MGOH is detected in the (as prepared) 30 µM MG 0h sample. In the 215
MG 24h sample, MGOH conc. nearly triples to 17.1 µM, and there is no observed 216
formation of other minor peaks during 0-25 min elution. By plotting 100% MG at 217
10,000 FLU (Fig. 4C), 81% MG at 5,500 FLU (Fig. 2A and 5B), and 43% MG at 218
2,000 FLU (Fig. 2A and 5A,B), a reasonable linear fit of R2 = 0.86 is noted. 219
3.5. Organic additives shift the Keq towards MG formation 220
8
The kinetics of conversion (without aptamer) of MGMGOH and MGOHMG 221
with and without 10% v/v organic additive (ACN, DMSO, EtOH) is conducted by 222
following the lambda max of MG, as seen in Fig. 6. The recorded wavelength scans 223
from 400 nm to 800 nm are seen in Fig. S2, which show similar results as noted in the 224
HPLC characterization above, that MG cannot be prepared pure in aqueous solutions 225
due to a t1/2 of ~19 min (ln 2/6.2× 10-4 s-1), while MGOH can (t1/2 = 2.8 h). In buffer 226
without any organic additive, the conversion of MGMGOH occurs nine times faster 227
(Fig. 6A, kMGMGOH = 6.2× 10-4 s-1) than the conversion of MGOHMG (Fig. 6B, 228
kMGOHMG = 0.69× 10-4 s-1). Additionally, the conversion of MGMGOH reaches 229
equilibrium after 2 h, while the conversion of MGOH to MG does not reach 230
equilibrium even after 12 h, as seen in Fig. 6B. When MGMGOH in the presence 231
of 10% organic additives (Fig. 6A), the kMGMGOH is retarded by 23%, 9%, and 5% 232
for ACN, DMSO, and EtOH, respectively. From the FLU decay kinetics, the aptamer 233
retards the kMGMGOH by 60% with no additives present (Fig. 2C and 6A). 234
Surprisingly, the conversion of MGOHMG in the presence of 10% organic 235
additives (Fig. 6B) displays a comparably large shift in kMGOHMG. Organic additives 236
increased kMGOHMG over buffer by 360%, 450%, and 460% for ACN, DMSO, and 237
EtOH, respectively. This acceleration on MGOHMG conversion by organic 238
additives results in a large shift in Keq compared to the MG in buffer or buffer + 239
MGA. This shift in Keq is summarized in Table 2. To investigate any effects the 240
aptamer has on kMGOHMG, various ratios of MGA were mixed with freshly prepared 241
MGOH and the MGA-MG fluorescent complex was monitored over time under 242
various MGOH:MGA ratios. At high ratios of 20 and 40:1, there was no statistical 243
difference in the FLU rate of MGA-MG fluorescent complex formation versus the 244
ABS rate of MG formation, as seen in Fig. S3. Thus, high aptamer ratios have no 245
effect on kMGOHMG kinetics. 246
Table 2 summarizes kMGMGOH in different additives and in the presence and 247
absence of aptamer (MGA). The molecular properties of water and organic additives 248
are also listed for any evident correlations. Without aptamer, organic additives had 249
only a slight effect on MGMGOH conversion. However, in the presence of 250
aptamer, the conversion was 40% slower, indicating the protective environment the 251
aptamer provides the MG in terms of hydrolysis. More importantly, this protection 252
effect combined with the organic additives provides a synergistic outcome towards the 253
stable formation of the MGA-MG fluorescent complex. The adjusted kMGMGOH as 254
9
measured by FLU was 500% slower in 10% ACN and 2950% slower with 10% EtOH. 255
No significant decay in fluorescence was observed with the addition of 10% DMSO, 256
preventing any measurement of kMGMGOH under these conditions. Additionally, 257
Pearson’s R values indicate strong correlations between kinetic constant and intrinsic 258
properties of the organic additives. We speculate that this may allow prediction of 259
even more effective additives. Without aptamer, no distinct correlation between 260
kinetic constant and intrinsic properties is observed (0.5 > R > -0.5). However, in the 261
presence of aptamer, kinetic constant has a strong correlation with molecular polar 262
surface area (MPSA) (R > 0.99) and a strong inverse correlation to additive volume (R 263
< -0.99). The 10% DMSO is excluded in calculation due to its unavailable kinetic 264
constant. The lack of decay follows the strong correlation of the intrinsic molecular 265
properties of DMSO (small MPSA and relatively large volume). 266
Fig. 6
267
Table 2
268
3.6 Organic additives reverse decay of fluorescence through MGOH dehydration 269
The shift in Keq values as seen in Table 2 suggests that organic additives can 270
immediately change the reaction kinetics to favor MG as the major equilibrium 271
product. This hypothesis is challenged by the addition of 3-10% v/v DMSO to 272
MGA:MG aqueous buffer solutions that have reached a stable FLU after 5 h of 273
incubation. Fig. 7 displays FLU recovery of 3 and 5% DMSO after 1 and 12 h 274
incubation. The results support an immediate shift in Keq by organic additives, with a 275
minimum of 5% v/v DMSO to recover the 0 h fluorescence intensity after 12 h. 276
Higher conc. of DMSO yielded FLU values that approached 10,000 FLU units (at 277
MGA:MG ratios > 20:1), similar to the values seen in Fig. 4C (data not shown). 278
Fig. 7
279
4. Discussion 280
MG and its aptamer have been utilized for various applications such as cell 281
imaging and probing for RNA nanoparticles based on enhanced fluorescence of MG 282
after induced binding [14, 27, 28]. However, due to the known instability of MG in 283
10
aqueous buffers, MG and MGA-MG binding will decrease over time. However the 284
temporal Kd or fluorescent intensity of the MGA-MG complex is seldom reported. 285
Wang et al. has experimentally and theoretically argued that MGA prevents MG 286
hydrolysis by measuring absorbance maxima in bound vs. unbound MG—no data on 287
changes in fluorescence was described [29]. Decreased hydrolysis kinetics was also 288
observed by FLU measurements where MGA is in buffer and buffer + organic 289
additives, but our work differs in conclusions drawn. Additionally, we also monitored 290
the apparent Kd of MGA-MG over time, and found that fluorescence intensity 291
decreased while apparent Kd increased over time. Moreover, we report for the first 292
time how the presence of common organic additives prevented temporal shifts in 293
fluorescence intensity and Kd within a 24 h timeframe. This stabilization is beneficial 294
for MGA-based applications towards accurate and repeatable detection assays based 295
on MG’s fluorescence enhancement by MGA [30, 31]. Finally, a synergistic 296
stabilization mechanism is proposed based on both fluorescence and absorbance 297
kinetics combined with previous reports on MG kinetics in aqueous environments [32, 298
33]. 299
4.1. Hydrolysis of MG to MGOH prevents aptamer binding 300
The Kd was determined by MG’s unique fluorescence enhancement upon induced 301
aptamer binding, but when the FLU signal decays, the dissociation constant will be 302
directly affected. The fluorescent response of MG upon binding to MGA is illustrated 303
in Fig. 2. In Fig. 2A, the increase in apparent Kd and subsequent decrease in 304
fluorescence intensity through 24 h (at 40:1 ratio) indicate an unstable association 305
between MGA and MG. In two preliminary experiments, MG and MGA were 306
separately added into the MGA-MG complex respectively after 24h to isolate the 307
cause of fluorescence decay. The addition of fresh MG recovered the fluorescence 308
intensity instantly, but continued to decay. The addition of fresh MGA displayed no 309
fluorescence recovery (Fig. S4). Such behavior indicated that the decrease in FLU 310
was due to events centered on MG but not the aptamer, ruling out RNA misfolding or 311
degradation. To investigate integrity of MGA in binding buffer (containing 10 mM 312
Mg2+) over 48 h, gel electrophoresis on MGA over time was performed. As seen in 313
Fig. S5, no obvious change in the MGA band was observed from 0 h to 48 h. The 314
binding interactions of RNA aptamers to ligands are dynamic and do not follow a 315
typical ‘lock and key’ static enzyme mechanism, but follows an ‘induced fit’ 316
mechanism that more closely resembles RNA folding around the ligand, where both 317
11
the RNA and ligand have induced changes in structure [34]. Thus, a clear explanation 318
of how RNA folding changes after a ligand hydrolysis event hasn’t been explored, but 319
creates another level complexity best removed if possible, which is yet another reason 320
for the addition of the organic additives shown herein. HPLC investigations display 321
only MG and MGOH as the major reactants and products. The 1:1 conversion of MG 322
peak to MGOH peak combined with the UV profile spectra confirms the conversion 323
of MG to MGOH with no other peaks of interests detected [21, 35, 36]. No other MG 324
variants (i.e. leucomalachite green, dimers) were detected, nullifying any 325
hypothesized side reactions. Another hypothesis, that aptamer prevented 326
MGOHMG dehydration, was proven false, as pure MGOH was incubated with 327
varying ratios of aptamer, with increasing fluorescence noted as MG was formed at 328
the predicted kinetics. The observation that FLU decay is completely reversible by 329
organic additives (see Fig. 7) speculates that MG undergoes a time dependent change 330
in electronic resonance or charge redistribution within the aptamer binding pocket. 331
This would lower the quantum yield or shift its fluorescent planar ‘induced fit’ 332
configuration. As seen in Fig. 8, we speculate that the hydrolysis intermediate, MG-333
OH2, is responsible for the FLU decay through electronic and charge redistribution 334
within the aptamer binding pocket, as the C+-OH2 carbocation is further stabilized and 335
becomes the preferred resonance structure. Shifts in MG 13C NMR peaks have 336
confirmed this shift in charge distribution between unbound and bound MG [34]. 337
However, due to the long timescale requirement of 13C measurements, MG 338
intermediates are unlikely to be distinguished from MG. Alternatively, the RNA base 339
stacking forces may be weakened through the more hydrophilic C+-OH2 carbocation, 340
relaxing the induced fluorescent planar geometry [37]. The addition of organic 341
additives prevents or reverses it. 342
Fig. 8
343
The hydrolysis of MG resulted in a significant impact in the apparent Kd (Fig. 2A), 344
due to the less available MG, reduced affinity MG-OH2 transition state, or both. The 345
binding of one ligand to MGA will reduce the competitiveness, even with ligands of 346
higher affinity, due to the induced fit model [23]. Thus, competitive binding 347
experiment (between MG and MGOH to MGA) was conducted by simultaneously 348
introducing various ratios of MGOH:MG with a fixed amount of MGA. As shown in 349
12
Fig. S6, up to 7-fold (limited by aqueous solubility) molar excess of MGOH was 350
added into a fixed MGA:MG ratio, but no significant changes were observed in FLU 351
(no competitive binding) of the MGA-MG complex. Even when MGOH and MGA 352
were the initial conditions (Fig. S3), the formation of MG and the subsequent MGA-353
MG fluorescent complex still matched absorbance kinetics (buffer-only kMGOHMG), 354
suggesting there is no competitive or non-specific interactions from buffer containing 355
primarily MGOH. The failed affinity of MGOH to MGA is speculated to be from 356
MGOH’s neutrally charged structure, as long range electrostatic forces provided by 357
cationic amines need to be present [15, 24]. 358
4.2. Organic additives shift Keq with limited impact on Kd 359
Organic additives are known to increase the Kd of molecular recognition elements 360
[15]. Towards MGA-MG binding at time 0 h, the organic additives increased Kd in the 361
following additive order: ACN > EtOH > DMSO. The lowered affinity was 362
proportional to the additive concentration, but increased the fluorescence intensity of 363
MGA-MG complex (Fig. 3A-C, compared to Fig. 2A). This paradox can be explained 364
by the shift in Keq and by noting that freshly prepared MG solutions always contained 365
various concentrations of MG and MGOH, as seen in Fig. 5. Fig. 6 demonstrates how 366
organic additives slow MGMGOH while accelerating the MGOHMG 367
conversion. Hence, the presence of organic additives results in synergistic shift 368
towards MG, thus enhances the formation of MGA-MG based fluorescence. Although 369
the aptamer binding is normally performed in aqueous only environments, the 370
presence of organic additives simplifies the Keq towards MG and allows a much 371
longer window of measurement towards assay development and may extend the 372
application of aptamers and more exotic ligands, i.e. modifications of hydrophobic 373
prodrugs for delivery [38]. Indeed, 40% of ‘new chemical entities’ developed by the 374
pharmaceutical industry are practically insoluble and organic additives are often 375
added to mimic in vivo solubility parameters, widening the window of application and 376
selection of ligands with poor aqueous solubility [39-42]. Additional benefits include 377
the facilitated competitive binding of organic ligands and antibacterial properties. 378
The loss of fluorescence intensity and increase in Kd were prevented upon addition 379
of organic additives. This discovery provides a simple way to stabilize aptamer 380
binding, which is beneficial for applications that rely on MGA for accurate detection 381
of MG. This inhibition strategy may also be applied to other triphenylmethane 382
compounds that are susceptible to hydrolysis, for instance, to stabilize aptasensors of 383
13
crystal violet [43-46]. To date, more than 105 triphenylmethane compounds ((Ph)3-C) 384
and 9,000 substructures of MG have been reported to date (SciFinder). 385
Triphenylmethane compounds have been commercially and analytically used as 386
bacteriological stains, pH indicators, therapeutic agent and food dyes [45]. However, 387
the use of some triphenylmethane compounds has been banned for farming due to 388
their potential toxicity, thus the detection and monitoring of triphenylmethane 389
compounds is of consumer importance [17]. Additionally, it is well known that the 390
triphenylmethane and other triarylmethane structures can form carbocations, which is 391
susceptible to nucleophilic attack (i.e. hydrolysis). The discovery in this work paves a 392
way to stabilize aptamer binding to ligands with triphenylmethane or similar 393
carbocation structures. 394
Moreover, the decreasing trend of rate constants with increasing additive 395
concentration (Table 1) shows a strong correlation. In other words, the rate constant 396
may be tuned by the type of organic additive, which may benefit alternative designs 397
for in-line or flow aptasensors, i.e. sensing within specific time frames. 398
4.3. Synergistic stabilization of ligand by aptamer and organic additives 399
To further understand the MG hydrolysis and MGOH dehydration, kinetics in both 400
directions was evaluated independently without aptamer by absorbance (Fig. 6). The 401
results indicate a relatively fast hydrolysis reaction from MG to MGOH in pH 6.7 402
buffer (Fig. 6A-B). The larger rate constant (compared to the one in aptamer binding 403
in Fig. 2C) indicates the aptamer can interfere with MG hydrolysis, but not prevent it 404
completely. Wang et al. has shown that the MGA could prevent MG well from 405
hydrolysis over time due to the steric hindrance effect [29]. However, our results 406
showed the protective effect is weaker, which is likely due to the difference in 407
experimental method of kinetics and affinity evaluation. Wang et al. evaluated MG 408
hydrolysis through changes in MG’s absorbance maxima, while we based ours on 409
fluorescence. Absorbance changes may not be apparent between complexed MG and 410
the intermediate MG-OH2, thus accounting for their perceived observation of 411
complete quenching of hydrolysis. If the bound intermediate MG-OH2 is responsible 412
for the FLU decay, Wang’s results provide further evidence that MG-OH2 413
intermediate can still provide enough affinity interactions to keep the aptamer folded, 414
while MGOH cannot. Without aptamer, the organic additives had a slight inhibition 415
on kinetics of MG to MGOH (Fig. 6A), but catalyze the dehydration of MGOH to 416
MG (Fig. 6B). Addition of organic additive not only accelerated the conversion of 417
14
MGOH to MG, but the conversion appeared to shift the equilibrium in favor of MG 418
(Table 2). The impact on kinetics and equilibrium defines how the organic additives 419
stabilized the fluorescence intensity of the MGA-MG complex over 24 h. 420
Synergistic stabilization on MG was observed by the combination of rates changes 421
through the organic additives and aptamer (Table 2). Pearson’s R correlation shows a 422
strong correlation between rate constants and the molecular properties of the organic 423
additives in the presence of aptamer. Less polar surface area, larger solvent volume, 424
or a combination of both, correlates with decreasing rate constants of MG hydrolysis. 425
These results are supported by Wang et al, showing minimal space between the 426
MGA-MG interface and the prevention of hydroxyl ion attack, which is an unlikely 427
mechanism of hydrolysis in a pH 6.7 buffer [29, 32]. Nguyen et al. argued that MGA 428
can change the conformation and charge distribution of MG upon binding [34], which 429
may result in a shift of hydrolysis kinetics and thermodynamics. However, it has not 430
yet been reported what the impact of organic additives may have on the stability of 431
MG inside the aptamer binding pocket. In this study, the results show that organic 432
additives; 1) Shift equilibrium to MG in the presence of aptamer, 2) had minor effect 433
on MG hydrolysis without aptamer, 3) catalyze MGOH dehydration and 4) had only 434
minor shifts on affinity and Kd. Based on these primary 4 observations, a mechanism 435
is proposed in Fig. 8. At pH 6.7, MG undergoes slow hydrolysis to intermediate MG-436
OH2, which transforms to MGOH immediately. Without MGA, the rate constants 437
kMGMGOH (hydrolysis) and kMGOHMG (dehydration) favor MGOH as the major 438
equilibrium product (Fig. 8A). Since [OH-] equals to 5.0 × 10-8 M at this pH, thus 439
kOH*[OH-] << kH2O and results in kobs ≈ kMGMGOH [47] (Fig. 8B). As proposed in Fig. 440
8C, MGA retards MG hydrolysis (where aptamer is in excess of MG) by retarding the 441
conversion of MG-OH2 to MGOH, which results in a decreased kMGMGOH, as 442
summarized in Table 2. However, this inhibition effect by MGA is insufficient to 443
make kMGMGOH ≤ kMGOHMG, and thus the conversion still favors to MGOH 444
generation, suggested by fluorescence decrease of MGA-MG complex over time as 445
displayed in Fig. 2A. With the presence of organic additives, kMGOHMG increases by 446
few hundred percent (as shown in Fig. 6B), which results in kMGMGOH ≥ kMGOHMG 447
combining with the effect from MGA. The synergistic effect of aptamer and organic 448
additives (decrease of kMGMGOH and increase of kMGMGOH) results in a Keq favoring 449
prevention of MG hydrolysis (Fig. 4) and MGOH dehydration. MGOH dehydration 450
and observed Keq was challenged by repeating the FLU decayed experimental 451
15
conditions in Fig. 2A, with the addition of DMSO (3-10% v/v) post decay. The 452
results in Fig. 7 show that a minimum of 5% v/v DMSO was enough to recover the 0 453
h fluorescence after an incubation time of 12 h. Higher conc. of DMSO yielded FLU 454
values that approached 10,000 FLU units (data not shown). 455
5. Conclusions 456
Aptamers as new materials for pharmaceutics and diagnostics have unique 457
advantages as molecular recognition elements. However, the aptamer-ligand affinity 458
is seldom investigated long term. In this work, we investigated the fluorescence 459
intensity of aptamer-malachite green complexes over 24 h and quantified the kinetics 460
of malachite green hydrolysis under various environmental conditions. The loss of 461
fluorescence intensity and increase in apparent Kd was due to the hydrolysis of 462
malachite green into speculated intermediates and malachite green carbinol base, as 463
indicated by spectrofluorometry, HPLC-diode array detector, and absorbance spectra. 464
Organic additives prevented the decay of the fluorescence intensities and were found 465
to minimize shifts in apparent Kd. A mechanism was proposed and challenged that 466
suggests shifts in Keq prevent the formation of malachite green carbinol base, or if 467
formed, cause dehydration back into the malachite green. This work demonstrated a 468
synergistic effect of both aptamer and organic additive on the prevention of 469
carbocation hydrolysis, allowing larger time frames for aptamer biosensor assays. 470
Acknowledgments 471
This work was supported by the Ministry of Education Tier 1 Grant RG54/13: 472
“Photochrome Aptamer Switch Assay: A Universal Bioassay Device”; and the 473
Campus for Research Excellence and Technological Enterprise (CREATE) 474
programme (13-04-00364 А), which is supported by the National Research 475
Foundation, Prime Minister’s Office, Singapore. 476
Appendix A. Supplementary materials 477
Please refer to the individual file for supplementary data. 478
479
References 480
[1] Y. Mao, J. Liu, D. He, X. He, K. Wang, H. Shi, L. Wen, Aptamer/target binding-481
induced triple helix forming for signal-on electrochemical biosensing, Talanta 143 482
(2015) 381-387. 483
16
[2] E. Babu, P. Muthu Mareeswaran, V. Sathish, S. Singaravadivel, S. Rajagopal, 484
Sensing and inhibition of amyloid-β based on the simple luminescent aptamer–485
ruthenium complex system, Talanta 134 (2015) 348-353. 486
[3] S.Y. Toh, M. Citartan, S.C.B. Gopinath, T.-H. Tang, Aptamers as a replacement 487
for antibodies in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, Biosens Bioelectron 64 (2015) 488
392-403. 489
[4] Y. Wang, Z. Ye, J. Ping, S. Jing, Y. Ying, Development of an aptamer-based 490
impedimetric bioassay using microfluidic system and magnetic separation for protein 491
detection, Biosens Bioelectron 59 (2014) 106-111. 492
[5] T. Moore, H. Chen, R. Morrison, F. Wang, J.N. Anker, F. Alexis, 493
Nanotechnologies for Noninvasive Measurement of Drug Release, Mol Pharmaceutics 494
11(1) (2014) 24-39. 495
[6] Q. Wu, L. Wu, Y. Wang, Z. Zhu, Y. Song, Y. Tan, X.-F. Wang, J. Li, D. Kang, 496
C.J. Yang, Evolution of DNA aptamers for malignant brain tumor gliosarcoma cell 497
recognition and clinical tissue imaging, Biosens Bioelectron 80 (2016) 1-8. 498
[7] B. Sivakumar, R.G. Aswathy, Y. Nagaoka, S. Iwai, K. Venugopal, K. Kato, Y. 499
Yoshida, T. Maekawa, D.N. Sakthi Kumar, Aptamer conjugated theragnostic 500
multifunctional magnetic nanoparticles as a nanoplatform for pancreatic cancer 501
therapy, RSC Advances 3(43) (2013) 20579-20598. 502
[8] J. Wu, C. Song, C. Jiang, X. Shen, Q. Qiao, Y. Hu, Nucleolin Targeting AS1411 503
Modified Protein Nanoparticle for Antitumor Drugs Delivery, Mol Pharmaceutics 504
10(10) (2013) 3555-3563. 505
[9] V.K. Sharma, P. Rungta, A.K. Prasad, Nucleic acid therapeutics: basic concepts 506
and recent developments, RSC Advances 4(32) (2014) 16618-16631. 507
[10] J. Ping, Y. Zhou, Y. Wu, V. Papper, S. Boujday, R.S. Marks, T.W.J. Steele, 508
Recent advances in aptasensors based on graphene and graphene-like nanomaterials, 509
Biosens Bioelectron 64(0) (2015) 373-385. 510
[11] J.-J. Zhang, J.-T. Cao, G.-F. Shi, K.-J. Huang, Y.-M. Liu, S.-W. Ren, A luminol 511
electrochemiluminescence aptasensor based on glucose oxidase modified gold 512
nanoparticles for measurement of platelet-derived growth factor BB, Talanta 132 513
(2015) 65-71. 514
[12] A. Chen, S. Yang, Replacing antibodies with aptamers in lateral flow 515
immunoassay, Biosens Bioelectron 71 (2015) 230-242. 516
[13] S.L. Richards, A.T. Cawley, R. Cavicchioli, C.J. Suann, R. Pickford, M.J. 517
Raftery, Aptamer based peptide enrichment for quantitative analysis of gonadotropin-518
releasing hormone by LC–MS/MS, Talanta 150 (2016) 671-680. 519
[14] V. Papper, O. Pokholenko, Y. Wu, Y. Zhou, P. Jianfeng, T.J. Steele, R. Marks, 520
Novel Photochrome Aptamer Switch Assay (PHASA) for Adaptive Binding to 521
Aptamers, J Fluoresc 24(6) (2014) 1581-1591. 522
[15] S.L. Stead, H. Ashwin, B. Johnston, A. Dallas, S.A. Kazakov, J.A. Tarbin, M. 523
Sharman, J. Kay, B.J. Keely, An RNA-aptamer-based assay for the detection and 524
analysis of malachite green and leucomalachite green residues in fish tissue, Anal 525
Chem 82(7) (2010) 2652-60. 526
[16] J.R. Babendure, S.R. Adams, R.Y. Tsien, Aptamers Switch on Fluorescence of 527
Triphenylmethane Dyes, J Am Chem Soc 125(48) (2003) 14716-14717. 528
[17] W.C. Andersen, S.B. Turnipseed, C.M. Karbiwnyk, R.H. Lee, S.B. Clark, W.D. 529
Rowe, M.R. Madson, K.E. Miller, Multiresidue method for the triphenylmethane dyes 530
in fish: Malachite green, crystal (gentian) violet, and brilliant green, Anal Chim Acta 531
637(1–2) (2009) 279-289. 532
17
[18] H. Wan, S. Weng, L. Liang, Q. Lu, J. He, Evaluation of the developmental 533
toxicity of leucomalachite green administered orally to rats, Food Chem Toxicol 534
49(12) (2011) 3031-3037. 535
[19] T. Gessner, U. Mayer, Triarylmethane and Diarylmethane Dyes, Ullmann's 536
Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA2000. 537
[20] B. Samiey, L. Motamedi, Kinetics of malachite green fading in water–ethanol–2-538
propanol ternary mixtures, Int J Chem Kinet 43(8) (2011) 441-453. 539
[21] D. He, X. He, K. Wang, J. Cao, Y. Zhao, A Photon-Fueled Gate-Like Delivery 540
System Using i-Motif DNA Functionalized Mesoporous Silica Nanoparticles, Adv 541
Funct Mater 22(22) (2012) 4704-4710. 542
[22] K. Mitrowska, A. Posyniak, J. Zmudzki, Determination of malachite green and 543
leucomalachite green in carp muscle by liquid chromatography with visible and 544
fluorescence detection, J Chromatogr A 1089(1–2) (2005) 187-192. 545
[23] J.B. Da Costa, A.I. Andreiev, T. Dieckmann, Thermodynamics and Kinetics of 546
Adaptive Binding in the Malachite Green RNA Aptamer, Biochemistry-us 52(38) 547
(2013) 6575-6583. 548
[24] J. Bernard Da Costa, T. Dieckmann, Entropy and Mg2+ control ligand affinity 549
and specificity in the malachite green binding RNA aptamer, Mol BioSyst 7(7) (2011) 550
2156-63. 551
[25] Y. Wang, J. Killian, K. Hamasaki, R.R. Rando, RNA Molecules That 552
Specifically and Stoichiometrically Bind Aminoglycoside Antibiotics with High 553
Affinities†, Biochemistry-us 35(38) (1996) 12338-12346. 554
[26] Y. Wang, R.R. Rando, Specific Binding of Aminoglycoside Antibiotics to Rna, 555
Chem Biol 2(5) (1995) 281-290. 556
[27] M. Strackharn, S.W. Stahl, E.M. Puchner, H.E. Gaub, Functional Assembly of 557
Aptamer Binding Sites by Single-Molecule Cut-and-Paste, Nano Lett 12(5) (2012) 558
2425-2428. 559
[28] K.A. Afonin, M. Viard, A.Y. Koyfman, A.N. Martins, W.K. Kasprzak, M. 560
Panigaj, R. Desai, A. Santhanam, W.W. Grabow, L. Jaeger, E. Heldman, J. Reiser, W. 561
Chiu, E.O. Freed, B.A. Shapiro, Multifunctional RNA Nanoparticles, Nano Lett 14(10) 562
(2014) 5662-5671. 563
[29] T. Wang, J.A. Hoy, M.H. Lamm, M. Nilsen-Hamilton, Computational and 564
Experimental Analyses Converge to Reveal a Coherent Yet Malleable Aptamer 565
Structure That Controls Chemical Reactivity, J Am Chem Soc 131(41) (2009) 14747-566
14755. 567
[30] D.M. Kolpashchikov, Binary malachite green aptamer for fluorescent detection 568
of nucleic acids, J Am Chem Soc 127(36) (2005) 12442-12443. 569
[31] D.M. Kolpashchikov, M.N. Stojanovic, Boolean Control of Aptamer Binding 570
States, J Am Chem Soc 127(32) (2005) 11348-11351. 571
[32] R. Cigen, The influence of temperature on the prtolytic equilibriums and reaction 572
rate constants of basic tryphenylmehtane dyes, Acta Chem Scand 14 (1960) 979-993. 573
[33] S. Dasmandal, H.K. Mandal, S. Rudra, A. Kundu, T. Majumdar, A. Mahapatra, 574
Kinetic exploration supplemented by spectroscopic and molecular docking analysis in 575
search of the optimal conditions for effective degradation of malachite green, Rsc 576
Advances 5(48) (2015) 38503-38512. 577
[34] D.H. Nguyen, S.C. DeFina, W.H. Fink, T. Dieckmann, Binding to an RNA 578
aptamer changes the charge distribution and conformation of malachite green, J Am 579
Chem Soc 124(50) (2002) 15081-4. 580
[35] B. Samiey, M. Zafari, Kinetics of Malachite Green Fading in Water-ethanol-1-581
propanol Ternary Mixtures, J Chin Chem Soc-taip 59(1) (2012) 32-39. 582
18
[36] S. Chen, Y. Jiang, Z. Wang, X. Zhang, L. Dai, M. Smet, Light-Controlled Single-583
Walled Carbon Nanotube Dispersions in Aqueous Solution, Langmuir 24(17) (2008) 584
9233-9236. 585
[37] J. Flinders, S.C. DeFina, D.M. Brackett, C. Baugh, C. Wilson, T. Dieckmann, 586
Recognition of planar and nonplanar ligands in the malachite green-RNA aptamer 587
complex, Chembiochem 5(1) (2004) 62-72. 588
[38] N. de-los-Santos-Álvarez, M.J. Lobo-Castañón, A.J. Miranda-Ordieres, P. 589
Tuñón-Blanco, Modified-RNA Aptamer-Based Sensor for Competitive Impedimetric 590
Assay of Neomycin B, J Am Chem Soc 129(13) (2007) 3808-3809. 591
[39] J. Lee, M. Jo, T.H. Kim, J.-Y. Ahn, D.-k. Lee, S. Kim, S. Hong, Aptamer 592
sandwich-based carbon nanotube sensors for single-carbon-atomic-resolution 593
detection ofnon-polar small molecular species, Lab on a Chip 11(1) (2011) 52-56. 594
[40] Y. Ito, S. Fujita, N. Kawazoe, Y. Imanishi, Competitive Binding Assay for 595
Thyroxine Using in Vitro Selected Oligonucleotides, Anal Chem 70(16) (1998) 3510-596
3512. 597
[41] K.T. Savjani, A.K. Gajjar, J.K. Savjani, Drug solubility: importance and 598
enhancement techniques, ISRN Pharm 2012 (2012) 195727. 599
[42] D. Sharma, M. Soni, S. Kumar, G. Gupta, Solubility enhancement—eminent role 600
in poorly soluble drugs, Research Journal of Pharmacy and Technology 2(2) (2009) 601
220-224. 602
[43] C. Baugh, D. Grate, C. Wilson, 2.8 A crystal structure of the malachite green 603
aptamer, J Mol Biol 301(1) (2000) 117-28. 604
[44] L. García-Río, J.R. Leis, J.C. Mejuto, A. Navarro-Vázquez, J. Pérez-Juste, P. 605
Rodriguez-Dafonte, Basic Hydrolysis of Crystal Violet in β-Cyclodextrin/Surfactant 606
Mixed Systems, Langmuir 20(3) (2004) 606-613. 607
[45] B. Samiey, Z. Dalvand, Kinetics of Fading of Some Triphenylmethane Dyes: 608
Effects of Electric Charge, Substituent, and Aqueous Binary Mixtures of Dimethyl 609
Sulfoxide and 2-Propanol, Int J Chem Kinet 46(1) (2014) 60-70. 610
[46] Y. Wu, S. Zhan, H. Xing, L. He, L. Xu, P. Zhou, Nanoparticles assembled by 611
aptamers and crystal violet for arsenic(iii) detection in aqueous solution based on a 612
resonance Rayleigh scattering spectral assay, Nanoscale 4(21) (2012) 6841-6849. 613
[47] B.M. Fox, G. Hallas, J.D. Hepworth, D. Mason, The hydrolysis of brilliant green 614
and some derivatives. I. A kinetic and equilibrium study of the hydrolysis of brilliant 615
green, J Chem Technol Biot 30(1) (1980) 317-323. 616
617
618
19
Tables 619
620
Table 1. Decay rate constant (kMGMGOH) of fluorescence intensity at maximum 621
[MGA]/ratio with various percentages of organic additives. 622
Media kMGMGOH (×10-4) (s-1)
3% Acetonitrile 3.1±0.4
5% Acetonitrile 2.6±0.1 8% Acetonitrile 1.3±0.2
10% Acetonitrile 1.0±0.1
3% Dimethyl sulfoxide 2.7±0.6 5% Dimethyl sulfoxide 0.2±0.3*
8% Dimethyl sulfoxide < 0.01, NSD
10% Dimethyl sulfoxide < 0.01, NSD 3% Ethanol 4.0±2.1
5% Ethanol 1.5±0.1
8% Ethanol 0.4±0.1
10% Ethanol 0.2±0.1 * Fitting coefficient of determination R2 < 0.6. NSD: No statistical difference was seen between 0 and 623
24 h FLU. 624
625
20
Table 2. Rate constant (kMGMGOH) of MG hydrolysis with 10% percentages of 626
organic additives in the presence and absence of aptamer (maximum [MGA]/ratio), 627
and the theoretical properties of water and additives. 628
Media With aptamer Without aptamer Solvent Molecular
properties#
kMGMGOH (×10-4)
(s-1) Keq
kMGMGOH (×10-4)
(s-1) Keq
Molecular Polar
Surface
Area (MPSA)
(Å2)
Volume
(Å3)
buffer 2.5±0.2 3.62 6.2±0.1 8.99 Water 29.3 19.3 10% Acetonitrile 1.0±0.1 0.40 4.8±0.1 1.92 Acetonitrile 23.8 46.1
10% Ethanol 0.2±0.1 0.06 5.9±0.1 1.84 Ethanol 20.2 54.0
10% Dimethyl sulfoxide
NSD* < 0.05* 5.7±0.0 1.84 Dimethyl sulfoxide
17.1 71.4
Pearson’s R
correlation, kMGMGOH vs.
MPSA
+0.999** +0.189
Pearson’s R correlation,
kMGMGOH vs.
Solvent Volume
-0.991** -0.293
* No statistical difference in 0 and 24 h FLU values under 10% DMSO additive. 629
**: 10% Dimethyl sulfoxide is excluded in the correlation due to its unavailable kinetic constant. 630
#: Calculated by Molinspiration Cheminformatics 2015: www.molinspiration.com. 631
632
21
Figures 633
634
635
Fig. 1. A: Structure of malachite green aptamer (MGA), malachite green (MG) and 636
malachite green carbinol base (MGOH). B: Binding of MG to MGA, with 637
fluorescence obtained. 638
639
22
640
Fig. 2. A: Kd determination of MGA to MG in aqueous buffer from 0 to 24 h. B: An 641
illustration of the fitting of Kd (R2> 0.99). F0 and Fmax: the fluorescence intensity at 642
zero and infinite aptamer [MGA]; [MG]0 and [MGA]0: initial concentrations of MG 643
and MGA, respectively; Kd: dissociation constant. D: Normalized fluorescence decay 644
at the highest MGA concentration/ratio for MG. The fluorescent decrease has a high 645
correlation to first order decay. 646
647
648
23
649
Fig. 3. Apparent Kd in organic additives at time 0 h. A: In 3% and 10% ACN. B: In 650
3% and 10% DMSO. C: In 3% and 10% EtOH. D: Comparison of the apparent Kd 651
values * = p < 0.05: significant difference vs. apparent Kd with 0% organic additive. 652
Generally, the apparent Kd increases with the percentage of organic additives, while 653
acetonitrile displayed the largest shifts. 654
655
24
656
Fig. 4. A: Kd determination of MG to MGA with different percentage of ACN at 0 h 657
and 24 h. B: Plots of calculated Kd values vs. %v/v additive at 0 h and 24 h. C: 658
Fluorescence intensity at maximum [MGA]/ratio at 0 h and 24 h with various 659
percentages of organic additives. The decrease of fluorescence intensity and increase 660
of apparent Kd after 24 h becomes smaller and smaller as the percentage of organic 661
additive increases from 3% to 10%. NSD = no statistical difference, p < 0.05. 662
25
663
Fig. 5. HPLC of MG, MGOH and the monitoring of the conversion of MG. A: 664
Detection wavelength = 620 nm. B: Detection wavelength = 265 nm. As time goes on, 665
the MG peak decreases while the MGOH peak increases, which indicates the 666
conversion of MG to MGOH. 667
668
26
669
Fig. 6. Kinetic evolution between MG and MGOH. A: MG converts to MGOH in 670
binding buffer and with 10% organic additives. B: MGOH converts to MG in binding 671
buffer and with 10% organic additives. The kinetics of MG to MGOH is much larger 672
than MGOH to MG in binding buffer, while organic additives induces a slightly 673
smaller kinetics of the conversion of MG to MGOH, but a much larger kinetics of the 674
conversion of MGOH to MG. 675
676
27
677
Fig. 7. Addition of DMSO into MGA-MG complex at 5h. Fluorescence of MGA-MG 678
complex decreases significant at 5h, while the addition of DMSO at 5h recovers the 679
fluorescence. Stronger effect of recovery occurs while higher percentage of DMSO is 680
added. 681
682
28
683
Fig. 8. A: Equilibrium and intermediates of MG, MG-OH2 and MGOH. B: Rate of 684
MG elimination. At pH 6.7, [OH-] is 5.0 × 10-8 M and thus, kOH*[OH-] << kH2O [47]. 685
C: Proposed mechanism of the conversions between MG+, MG-OH2+ and MGOH in 686
the presence of MGA. In the absence of MGA, the rate constants kMGMGOH 687
(hydrolysis) and kMGOHMG (dehydration) favor MGOH as the major equilibrium 688
product (A). While excess MGA is present, it retards MG hydrolysis, which results in 689
a decreased kMGMGOH. With the presence of organic additives, kMGOHMG increases 690
by few hundred percent (C), resulting in a “stabilizing” effect. 691
692
1
Electronic Supplementary Information (ESI)
for
Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer binding of malachite
green
Yubin Zhoua, Hong Chia, Yuanyuan Wua, Robert S. Marksa,b, Terry W.J. Steelea,*
a School of Materials Science & Engineering, College of Engineering, Nanyang
Technological University, 50 Nanyang Avenue, Singapore 639798, Singapore
b Department of Biotechnology Engineering, Faculty of Engineering Sciences, Ben
Gurion University of the Negev, P.O. Box 653, Beer Sheva 84105, Israel
* Corresponding Author:
Terry W.J. Steele: [email protected],
Tel.:65-65927594, fax: 65-67909081.
2
Method for electrophoresis of MGA
MGA in binding buffer (containing 10 mM Mg2+) over 48 hours were analyzed by
electrophoresis. Samples were stained with AMRESCO EZ-Vision® One (with amaranth
indicator) and loaded on 2% agarose gel, and then electrophoresed at 100 V for 40
minutes in pH = 8.0 1X tris-acetate-EDTA (TAE) buffer. BioLabs 100 bp DNA ladder
(100-1517 bp) was used as marker for reference. The gel was visualized under 365 nm
UV exposure.
3
Fig. S1. Binding curves (A) and apparent Kd values (B) in different pH at time 0. The
result indicates that the suitable pH for the binding experiment is 6-8.5.
4
Fig. S2. UV-vis spectra of conversion between MG and MGOH as a function of time. A:
MG converted to MGOH. B: MGOH converted to MG.
5
Fig. S3. Rate constant of MGOH to MG (kMGOHMG) in binding buffer in the presence of
MGA.
6
Fig. S4. Fluorescence intensity of MGA-MG complex (32:1) at 24 h binding and with the
subsequent addition of original amount of MG (blue square) and MGA (red circle).
7
Fig. S5. Agarose gel electrophoresis of MGA in different time points in binding buffer
(with Mg2+ presented).
8
Fig. S6. Competitive binding of MGOH with MG to MGA. No significant change in
fluorescence intensity of MGA-MG was observed in the presence of 7-fold excess of
MGOH (poor solubility of MGOH in water limits the maximum ratio to 8X in our
experimental setup).