Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that...

34
8 APRIL 2020 Nine opportunities for life insurers to emerge from the crisis stronger Opportunities in Life

Transcript of Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that...

Page 1: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

8 APRIL 2020

Nine opportunities for life insurers to emerge from the crisis stronger

Opportunities in Life

Page 2: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

1

About this paper

In April 2020 BCG conducted a quick survey amongst its life insurance experts in the major

global markets. Focus of the survey was on the short and medium term opportunities to

improve the business.

We are presenting here in a condensed way nine topics of relevance, loosely grouped into the

categories Growth, Margin and Balance Sheet.

The appendix section is dedicated to the Chinese insurers' and regulator's response, given that

the country was the first to experience severe economic disruption and related opportunities.

The contacts of the contributing experts are provided on page 24 of this document.

Page 3: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

2

Insurers should already take steps to ensure their businesses thrive in the medium-term

Execution clarity

Team health

& safety

Business

strength

Financial

resilience

Now Tackle immediate priorities

Near-term Prepare for the rebound

Medium-term Pursue structural enhancements

• Crisis response teams

• Engage / Communicate

• War room scenarios and

adaptive planning

• Reinforce purpose

• Personalized client engagement

• Agent capacity optimisation

• Agent restart

• Digitized sales

• Pricing optimization

• Portfolio optimization

• Client lifetime value mngnt.

• New personalized propositions

• Omni-channel transformation

• AI based pricing

• M&A opportunities

• Business continuity assurance1

• Cybersecurity

• Operational flexibility (e.g.

ring-fence closed books)

• Customer centre optimization

• Remote working capabilities

• Smart operations

• New ways of working

• Advanced claim settlement

• Cash and liquidity

• Balance sheet stress test

• Cost discipline

• Margin improvement: cost

transformation and productivity

• Adapted UW policies

• Anti-Fraud defence

• Hedging and financing strategy

• New risk framework

1. Short term measures: Reduce transmission, re-balance workload, upgrade infrastructure to support report working, etc.Source: Boston Consulting Group

Page 4: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

3

Impact of COVID-19 on Life insurers

Balance sheet IncomeOverall

New business to profit in

Protection and guaranteed

savings

Unprotected savings likely to

be most affected in sales in

the short term

Guaranteed savings in force

are affected by

• expanding credit spreads

• further drop in risk-free

rates

• hit in equity valuations

• potentially further

reduction in lapse rates

Capital VolumeLiquidity Pricing ClaimsRetention Expenses CollectionAuM

Source: Boston Consulting Group

Business line

Protection(mortality, disability,

critical illness, ...)

Off-B/S savings (unit linked, defined

contribution, ...)

On-B/S savings (trad. guarantees,

defined benefits, ...)

Key: Positive impact on insurer… Negative impact on insurer… UnclearNo impact for insurer

Page 5: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

4

Life insurers can take action now to position themselves properly for the medium term—9 opportunities

Note: B/S = Balance SheetSource: Boston Consulting Group

Now Tackle immediate priorities

Near-term Prepare for the rebound

Medium-term Pursue structural enhancements

Business line

Protection(mortality, disability,

critical illness, ...)

Off-B/S savings (unit linked, defined

contribution, ...)

On-B/S savings (trad. guarantees,

defined benefits, ...)

Innovate in Protection and protected savings1

Move to Underwriting 2.04

Shift to

digital/

hybrid

sales

models

2

Unify

balance

sheet

mgmt

Reset

your

cost

base

6

7

Engage

your

customer

base

5

Provide

estate

advisory

services

3

Use

consoli-

dation

and

trans-

action

window

8

Step up in

alter-

native

assets

9

Page 6: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

5

In-force mgmt. Run-off

How BCG can help—our service offering

Pursuit of Profitable

Growth

Reinventing

Distribution

Pivot to

Digital

Evolving Product

and Solution Needs

Leveraging New Data

Sources and Analytics

Efficiency and In-Force

Management

Increasing Regulatory

Complexity

Ways of Working

& Talent

Preparing for Downturn/

Low Interest Rates

Re-invigorate life insurance agency

Legacy Mana-gement 4.0

S II internal model validation

Risk measurement model

Agile

Strategic Work-force Planning

Digitalization and workforce planning

Consumer privacy

Pure digital product Demand centric growth

Insights from Insurance Pools

Distribution strategy/SFE

Digital Customer Journey

Fraud reduction—use case

Insurance excel-lence benchmark

In focus to respond to

COVID opportunities

Future of underwriting

60+/ecosystem play Portfolio analy-sis/TSR analysis

Data analyticsin life insurance

Page 7: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

6

Getting beyond emergency mode of recent headlines

Covid-19: Life insurers likely to be hit by adverse

market movements than the rise in claims

Fitch Ratings said it “expects the recent

outbreak of novel coronavirus infections to put

some pressure on Chinese insurers’ profitability

in the near term, but that earnings pressure will

be manageable”

Life Insurers Go Slow on

New Policies to Limit Coronavirus Risk

U.S. life insurers are trying to curb their own

risks to coronavirus by imposing waiting periods

for applicants who have traveled to regions with

widespread outbreaks, industry experts said

Door May Be Closing On

Life Insurance Buyers Amid COVID-19

We could see the collapse of individual life and

health insurance companies—ratings agency

Fitch has already warned that life insurance

companies could be particularly hard hit by the

combination of falling stock markets and

increasing mortality

The Insurance Information Institute, in its first

quarter “Global macro outlook,” reported that

“COVID-19’s impact on global growth and the

insurance industry is likely deeper and wider

than the current consensus and could last well

into the third quarter and beyond”

Insurers across Southeast Asia, including the

Philippines, are seen taking a hit from

potentially higher payouts and slowing

consumer spending amid the COVID-19 outbreak

Insurance credit rating agency AM Best

Major U.S. life insurance providers have struggled as

COVID-19 continues to spread throughout the

country. However, while it's likely that many of

these companies will face policy losses as the

number of COVID-19-related deaths grow, they also

face a threat from collapsing bond rates, which had

hit historic lows earlier in the third week of March

Life insurers braced for hit as bond market buckles

Insurers’ shares have fallen faster than the wider

stock market. In Europe, Allianz, Axa and Legal and

General are down by more than 40%. In the US,

Prudential Financial and MetLife have fallen by more

than half, while Brighthouse has lost almost two-

thirds of its value. Rating agency Fitch has

downgraded its outlook on life insurers in the US, UK

and continental Europe to negative

Page 8: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

7

Growth

Nine opportunitiesfor life insurers

Margin

Assets

and capital

Innovate in Protection and protected savings

• Especially in the 60+ segment

Shift to digital/hybrid sales models

• Equip the agents

• D2C and through partners

Provide estate advisory services

• Revisit clients’ pension plans

1

2

3

Move to Underwriting 2.0

• Predictive models, tele-UW, AUS

Engage your customer base

• Now or never: Loans, premium holidays, data and trust,

upselling

Reset your cost base

• It was high before COVID already…

4

5

6

Unify balance sheet management

• Bring together solvency, risk, liquidity and ALM steering

Use consolidation and transaction window

• Grow size and/or capabilities and review portfolio

Step up in alternative assets

• As central banks embark on bond buying frenzy

7

8

9

Page 9: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

8

COVID as trigger to address needs of underserved 60+ segment

Seniors are hungry for life...

• Stay fit and young

• Live in home of choice

• Finally realize my dreams

• Enjoy life: Spend, travel, learn

• Continue working

• Fight cancer, dementia, loneliness

• Leave a legacy

...but heavily impacted by Covid

Source: Swiss Re, BBC, NYT, Guardian, BCG

Unprecedented

awareness for

protection

Insurers traditionally

with no relevant

offering for seniors

• Biometric risks beyond 60

incl. impaired lives

• Healthier living/prevention

services

• Longevity risk &

decumulation solutions

• Accident and health cover

• Care & home services

• Access to medical facilities

in emergencies/pandemics

Opportunity to address needs

1

Page 10: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

9

Overhaul new product launch approach

Complex processes and products: Sequential approach,

committee decision bodies, legacy IT/processes, regulatory

req’s, limited modularity,...

Accelerate product innovation and pursue mobile-

first through agile, cross-functional teams and

modular product logic (including new risks, e.g., 60+)

Today: From slow product development cycles...

...to agile customer-centric product innovation in the

"new normal"

Source: Society of Actuaries (2017), company publications, BCG

Peers from Greater China provide an example of how

to quickly launch new relevant offers within

days/weeks

Life product development typically takes months to yearsMedian new product development duration in US (in weeks)

39 weeks 45 weeks 48 weeks 52 weeks

Term Insurance Indexed ULWhole life Universal life

Limited customer centricity: Push instead of pull; no/limited

appetite for new protection offerings, e.g., impaired life, 60+

Capture unprecedented health awareness and

provide low-cost/free COVID coverage to create

leads for future up-/cross-selling

Bundle for relevance, providing worry-free product

bundles for SMEs (combining both Life and Non-Life

offerings, e.g., for work resumption)

1

Page 11: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

10

Clear potential for many insurance companies to accelerate product innovation

New product Product revision

Note: Phases of product development process not always in exact order performed by all companies. Length of bar means duration of the phase. Left edge of bars means estimated start time of the phase.Source: Society of actuaries (2017), BCG

0 10 20 30 40400 6010 20 30 50

Marketing plans

Traditional rider development

Total time

Idea generation

Reinsurance

Product pricing

Product concept/feasibility

Underwriting guidelines

Assumption development

Product planning & design

Update IT-Day 1

State/regulatory filings

Update business procedures

Average Fastest

weeks weeks

Term insurance

development time

Additional acceleration potential

through agile cross-functional teams

and product simplification/ modularity

1

Page 12: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

11

Chinese insurers quickly included extra

COVID-19 coverage in existing policies

and introduced standalone COVID-19

products

New products or integra-tion in legacy products

Source: Taikang Life, BCG

For example, Taikang Life introduced a low-

cost one-year COVID-19 protection product

with a fixed price (irrespective of risk profile,

no health questionnaire) in early February

2020

Eligible from 30

days to 70 years

Coverage for one

year only

Coverage for

accidental

death/disability

Coverage for

disability/death

from COVID-19

Sum assured: RMB

200k (USD 28k)

Premium: RMB 100

(USD 14)

Fast innovation in Greater China during Covid-19

1

Page 13: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

12

Asian insurers offering free COVID-19

protection (low sum assured) to capture

customer data and generate leads for

cross-/up-selling

Product innovation as marketing lever

A

B

A B

Source: Tencent, Prudential, BCG

Prudential: Free COVID-19 coverage (HKD

10K for infection, HKD 100K death) for

first 500K registrations in Pulse health

app for Hong Kong residents

Tencent Insurance: Free COVID-19

coverage (RMB 10K for serious infection,

RMB 50K for death), underwritten by

Taikang Life

1

Page 14: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

13

COVID-19 provides a radical environment to force insures to accelerate digital transformation

1.7

0.60.3

2.6

2.0 2.2

Zhong An Taikang

Online

SD Bao

+53%

+233% +633%

Digital players still had strong growth

momentum under COVID-19…

• Overall risk awareness

has increased

• More open to online

sales without F2F

…as their digital capability enables

them to capture the opportunity

• Strong digital

capability became

more important for

online sales &

services to capture

opportunity

Source: Lit. research, BCG analysis

Demand

side

Supply

side

Key

implication

• Many insurers started

to transform their

business models and

accelerate digital

transformation

2019 Jan-Feb 2020 Jan-Feb

GWP, CNY B

2

Page 15: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

14

Defining moment for non-traditional sales to capitalize on D2C and B2B2C

2014

35

IFA/broker

5

2015

4

20172016

3

2018

Tied agents

Bank

Direct

Other

Help/Support existing

B2B2C partners

Set-up/Enlarge digital sales

connections with bancs (e.g.,

Anivo in Switzerland now heavily

growing bancassurance)

Build/Enter new

ecosystems

Develop new partnerships. e.g.,

with online shopping (Flipkart)

prevention and health platforms

Grow D2C capabilities

E.g., redirect marketing spend to

digital channels to generate direct

leads

2

Situation: Life insurance customers in the past very

loyal to their sales channel—until now …

Opportunity: D2C channels and B2B2C ecosystem plays

accelerated by the current lockdowns

D2C sales with minor role in the past

German sales channel mix in life insurance in %

7

2015

5

Direct 1

6

2014

6

2017

6

2016 2018

Tied agents

IFA/broker

Other

USA sales channel mix in life insurance in %

1. Includes tele-sales and direct mail; Source: LIMRA, BCG

Page 16: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

15

Become a marketing led organization

Radically rethink your

marketing and sales tactics

2

29%

D2C partnership -

adding term, family

income, and serious

illness products

Up to $3.4Bn price raised eyebrows (Nov 19)2

Gig-model for agents – telesales is their core

• Lead generation analytics engine

• Targets middle market customers

Life insurance companies traditionally

have focused on how their products

and marketing resonate with

distribution

End customers have not been the

priority…

…so insurers loose sight of their

end clients needs

Carriers beginning to shift focus

Incumbents double

down on

partnerships

…and thinking about

the intersection of

technology and

distribution

InsurTechs capitalize

on demand from

COVID fear1

1. Increase in digital applications or sales due to COVID; 2. $2.3Bn base price with potential to rise another $1.1Bn in potential earnoutSource: Life Annuity Specialist, BCG

B2B2C - offering life

insurance sales through

one of India's largest e-

retailer

250% 10x

42%

Page 17: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

16

Advisors can provide peace of mind and more advisory to stressed clientele

1. Legg Mason; 2. Alight; 3. Cerulli, 4. JD Power Survey of US consumers asking about change in perception of life insurance due to COVID-19; 5. US Only, LIMRA advisor pulse survey (Mar 2020); Source: Legg Mason, Alight, LIMRA, BCG

Clients under immense stress—beyond health, their worries

extend from cash flows to asset allocations

Provide confidence and advisory—guidance on broader financial

situation and best practices (subject to regulatory conditions)

• life insurance impression more positive for 22% of customers4

1 in 3 Have made emotional

decisions in their 401K they

later regretted1

16x on Feb 28Increase in net trading activity

within 401K accounts2

Don’t have an official source

for information on their 401K

plan340–50%

Situation: Market volatility causes immense financial

stress to clients

Opportunity: Customer touchpoints increasing, use

these to provide advisory services and peace of mind

3

Jackson National's partnership gives

agents and advisors access to a tax

optimization tool that is

product/investment strategy agnostic

Agents in Japan with systematic reach

out to customers via phone to confirm

support in any insurance related

questions and quick benefits claiming

28%

16%

20%

55%29%

52%

Way you communicate

Communication Frequency

Yes-a great extent NoneYes-somewhat

Agents see COVID impacting customer touchpoints

Page 18: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

17

Life insurers can expand usage of simplified underwriting to meet demand

1. Increase in app usage and appointment volumes reported in response to COVID (Mar 20,2020); 2. Hannover ReSource: Life Annuity Specialist; Quartz, Forbes

Insurers can ease thresholds on simplified UW

• Raise policy limit threshold (e.g., 1mn to 2.5m)

• Sell small policy today, that increases with full UW

Consumers are comfortable engaging on their medical information via tele-health apps – activity up1

[Will] stop requesting medical evidence as part of our

underwriting process … any new applications where a GP

report (GPR) is required will now be postponed as we will be

unable to offer cover until the strain on the health service is

resolved. Aviva

4

Situation: Medical facilities capacity strained for

traditional or paramedical UW due to COVID-19

Opportunity: Fully utilize automated underwriting and

teleunderwriting

50% 70% 158%

Tele-underwriting can help better identify risk factors

Nicotine

Cancer

TeleUnderwriting

Paramedical

"Yes" responses to impairment2

Page 19: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

18

Now or never: Engage with your customers ("in-force management")

Source: Case work; BCG analysis

5

"We have valid customer email and

cell phone number for only… "

"Customer enquiries

in March up .." 2x

1 in 6

So far: Little direct company to customer interaction

Direct reach-out for

Premium holidays

Policy loans

Buy-outs

Top-up covers, fitbits, etc.

Concerns, complaints, recommendations

...

Now is the time to engage with your customer base

Page 20: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

19

Reset your cost base

ChampionLaggard

-1 ppt

Mid-Tier

-3 ppt-5 ppt

20172010 20142011 2015

15.2

2012 2016

13.7

2013

14.7

2018

13.1 13.414.4

13.5 14.014.9

Source: BCG Insurance Pools; BCG DAI in Insurance study 2019

Use the “new normal” to fully digitize your business model

Digital leaders were able to lower their cost ratio in 2015-2018 much better than digital laggards

Expenses in % of premiums of life insurers in world top-22

markets

Acquisition Ratio Admin Ratio

6

Cost ratios of life insurers globally continuously rising Now is opportunity for radical cost reduction

Page 21: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

20

Unify balance sheet management

In a crisis some organizations discover that their near-perfect

fragmentation of functions, know-how, reporting systems and

responsibilities can compromise or paralyze decision making

Source: BCG Insurance Pools; BCG DAI in Insurance study 2019

We are trying to understand our

liquidity situation

ALM

Investment

management

Actuaries

Risk

management

Treasury

Finance

Regulatory

solvency

ALM

committee

Investment

committee

Risk

committee

Bring together solvency and liquidity steering with the

asset-liability management function

Extract key information into models that allow you to

run “what-if” scenarios

Prepare action plan for main adverse scenarios, define

triggers, communicate assumptions

7

Internal

model

Head of

Hedging

Page 22: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

21

Use down-turn to consolidate positions and dispose of volatile back books

• COVID already leading to depressed valuations for insurers

in Europe and US—e.g., JP Morgan adjusted EPS/DPS

by-8%/-4% for 2020e–2022e

Prepare for M&A to pick up under-capitalized players or to

enhance your capabilities: acquire digital assets, InsurTechs

Take advantage of suppressed valuations:

Weak-Economy Deals Outperform Strong-Economy Deals

COVID impact on life insurers’ valuations Opportunity

Source: 2019 Global M&A Strategic Study Conning; JP Morgan; Debevoise and Plimpton; Refinitiv; Datastream; BCG analysis

99.7

101.6

99.0

100.0

104.6

102.8

90

95

100

105

T+3T-3 Year 1 Year 2

Strong-economy deals

Weak-economy deals

3.8

Cumulative relative total shareholder return index of deals in FI and

insurance

120

4/1/2019 10/1/20197/1/2019

100

1/1/2019 1/1/2020 4/1/202060

80

140

EmergingAPACLife

MatureAPACLife

Global Life

NAMR Life

TSR Index life insurers

(2019=100)

MatureEuroLife100

Jan 23

Hubei lockdown

8

Page 23: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

22

01/2004/20190

07/19 04/202010/19

2

1

3

Step up in private assets to capture illiquidity premium/reduce asset volatility

Private assets provide opportunity for life insurers

• Illiquidity premiums for similar asset ratings (e.g.

commercial real estate loans, equity release mortgages,

infra debt)

• Although surging demand also led to yield compression

• Lower volatility of asset portfolio

New capabilities required to succeed

• New capabilities related to structuring, execution for

direct origination

• New partnerships and manager oversight for 3rd party

origination

• General step-up in performance/risk measurement and

reporting capabilities, as well as ESG

Low for even longer … … requiring new capabilities in investments

1. PML: Property, Mortgages & Loans 2. Funds = Collective Investment Undertakings 3. Possibility to shift assets to illiquid/alternative assets subject to local regulationsSource: EIOPA, Thomson One - Eikon, BCG

Investor risk aversion and

government intervention

leading to ever lower

government bond yields …

10y US Treasury yields

(percentage)

… further compressing

investment returns for life

insurers with strong (public)

debt exposure

Asset allocation of EU life

insurers (Q3 2019, percentage)

Other 4

Gov bond 20

Corp bond 19

Funds2 39

PML1 7

Overall SAA

Equity 11

Multi-asset 15

Alternatives 9Other 7

Equity 32

Funds deep-dive

Debt 37

Deep-dive

9

Subject to regulatory context3

Page 24: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

23

"Next 18 months will reshuffle the field

more than the last ten years in total -

some will come out winners, others will

stay stuck in the past"

Page 25: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

24

Authors and contributors to this paper and their contacts

Managing Director &

Partner, Zurich

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, India

[email protected]

Partner, UK

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Japan

[email protected]

Pranay

Mehrotra Shaun Yow

Takashi

Horikawa Tim CalvertWalter Reinl

Consultant, Hong Kong

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Singapore

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, US

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Italy

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Iberia

[email protected]

Christoph Krieg Wei Chuan Lim Rob Sims Matteo Coppola Santiago Mazon Managing Director &

Partner, France

Wallaert.Charles-

[email protected]

Charles-Antoine

Wallaert

Knowledge Expert,

Germany

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, France

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Netherlands

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, China

[email protected]

Tatjana Bender Benoit Mace

Tijsbert

Creemers

Michelle Hu

SKA, Boston

[email protected]

Partner, US

[email protected]

Partner, US

[email protected]

Nick GagnonManaging Director &

Partner Poland

[email protected]

om

Norbert

Dworzynski Joe Khoury

Nathalia

BelliziaManaging Director &

Partner, US

[email protected]

GB Taglioni

Authors Contributors

Managing Director &

Partner, US

[email protected]

Managing Director &

Partner, Brussels

[email protected]

Consultant, Germany

[email protected]

Karolien

Gielen

Jonas HirzManaging Director & Partner,

Germany

[email protected]

Christopher

Freese

Page 26: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

25

Appendix—China's response

Page 27: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

26

COVID-19 resulted in limited direct damage to life/health insurance companies

NHSA: Notice about ensuring COVID-19 patients could get

sufficient medication and treatment

2. Ensure patients՚ medication and treatment will not be

influenced by affordability

• All treatment costs beyond the current reimbursement

from public health securities funds will be covered by

government budgets

• All medication and treatment items listed in the COVID-19

Treatment Guidelines will be included in reimbursable list

for a short time

NHSA1 released COVID-19 reimbursement policy,

reducing the compensation of commercial insurers

1. National Health Security Administration of ChinaSource: Lit-research; BCG analysis

Limited additional compensation paid by insurers

due to COVID-19

Compensation type Impact

Medical payment

Critical disease

compensation

Death compensation

• Limited amount of medical

payment as paid only after the

reimbursement of public health

securities funds

• Currently, COVID-19 is not

included in disease list of

almost all critical disease

insurance products in China

• Limited death compensation

as a result of low death rate

of COVID-19 patients

Page 28: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

27

Strict quarantine requirement in China resulted inshort-term decrease in new product sales …

Sales channel mix of life/health

insurance products in China

Strict quarantine requirements lead to

sales decrease in core sales channels

Others

(e.g., online)

Total

Individual agents

Banks

100%

~ 60%

~ 30%

~ 10%

Individual agents and banks are the most important

channels of life/health insurance products in China

Individual agents

• Face-to-face communication

is the main method of

individual Agents to

sell products

• Their interaction with clients

were limited by extended CNY

holidays, self quarantine, and

other safety reasons

Banks

• Due to COVID-19, all banks

are required to close/limited

operation for essential needs

Source: Lit-research; BCG analysis

In the long run, demand

of life/heath insurance

in China will increase

• Critical public health

events will stimulate

residents' concern

regarding

uncertainty, which

creates more demand

of insurance

Page 29: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

28

... but Chinese companies responded rapidly to better weather the challenge

Service innovation Product innovationSocial responsibility

Insurers proactively promote their

online sales channel, enhance their

online capability for customer

service, and enable online

underwriting to improve online

service efficiency

To address corporate clients՚ concern

regarding returning to work normally,

insurers conducted series of product

innovations to help client to mitigate

the risk of their staffing infected

by COVID-19

70+ Chinese life/health insurance

companies included COVID-19 into

their coverage disease list to show

their social responsibility and reduce

the public panics with limited extra

compensation estimated

Source: Lit-research; BCG analysis

Page 30: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

29

BCG FY forecast

China insurers have continued to expand throughout corona crisis (Jan-Feb 2020)

151 222158 223

Feb DecJan

1,302 ~1,4004.4% 0.5%

4~5%

Source: Lit. research, BCG analysis

699943750

954

DecJan Feb

2,963 ~3,100

7.3% 1.2%

4~5%

……

2019 & 2020 Monthly cumulative GWP in China, CNY B

Non-life insurers Life insurers

BCG FY forecast

2019 2020

Page 31: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

30

Traditionally, insurance apps fail to

engage customers—some insurers use

the current situation to provide more

relevant content and increase traffic

Digital customer engage-ment through innovation

For example, AIA launched a COVID-19 alert

service on their mobile app (AIA Connect)

using GPS data to alert users of nearby

confirmed infections

Source: AIA, BCG

Page 32: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

31

Insurers in China move beyond individual

life—for example, offering work

resumption products covering both life

and non-life coverage

New SME work resumption bundles introduced in CN

Source: Company websites, press releases, BCG

Chang An Insurance and Jixiang Life offer a

joint “Resumption of Work” insurance to

facilitate business resumption after an almost

two-month standstill

Resumption of Work insurance

Comprehensive “worry-free” offering for SMEs to mitigate the

financial and health risks of COVID-19 (e.g., second infection wave)

when restarting business

Comparable products from other carriers, e.g.,

Coverage: Liabilities such as

production loss, employee wage

protection, and quarantine

expenses

Coverage: COVID-19 diagnosis

(health/critical illness),

employee accidents and

personal injuries

Page 33: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

32

Chinese gov't released policies to guide the life/health insurance market under the COVID-19 situation

1. China Banking and Insurance Regulatory CommissionSource: Lit-research; BCG analysis

Jan 27, 2020 • China Insurance Association proposed that all insurers in

China provide full supports to the national initiatives of

COVID-19

Feb 3, 2020 • CBIRC1 released a notice to ask insurance companies should

cover COVID-19 in their existing products, and provide more

convenient service to COVID-19 patients in claim, with

controllable risk exposure

Feb 11, 2020 • CBIRC released Notice of Promoting Virtual Customer Visits in

Insurance Industry

• The notice clearly defined the precondition of virtual

customer visit, and asked insurance companies to

standardize their virtual customer visit process, enhance the

customer identification, and protect the rights and interest

of customers

New policies published after the COVID-19 outbreak in China

As a next step, Insurance

Administration in China will

further regulate the

behaviors of online sales and

virtual service, which may

change the sales channel mix

of insurance in the future

Page 34: Opportunities in Life · health insurance companies—ratings agency Fitch has already warned that life insurance companies could be particularly hard hit by the combination of falling

bcg.com