Ontario Superior Court - McCarthy Tétrault · 05/15/15 [2015] O.J. No. 2500, 2015 ONSC 3125...
Transcript of Ontario Superior Court - McCarthy Tétrault · 05/15/15 [2015] O.J. No. 2500, 2015 ONSC 3125...
Page 1
The French version will be available soon.
Ontario Superior CourtAppellate Cases Argued by Active McCarthy Tétrault Lawyers
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
1. ONSC Ontario (Ministryof CommunitySafety andCorrectionalServices) v DeLottinville
05/27/15 [2015] O.J. No.2684, 2015ONSC 3085
Parla, JulieBlanchard,Alexandre
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Human rights law –applications by respondentsin two human rightscomplaints for judicialreview of interim decisionsby Tribunal dismissed
2. ONSC Takashima vOntario Collegeof Teachers
05/15/15 [2015] O.J. No.2500, 2015ONSC 3125
Leonard, DavidBlanchard,Alexandre
Respondent ON Appeal Ontario College ofTeachers DisciplineCommittee appeal
3. ONSC Cyriac vBernstein
02/13/15 [2015] O.J. No.678, 2015 ONSC592
Grace, Keary Applicant ON JudicialReview
Health law – Application bytwo surgeons from decisionof respondent Boardconfirming decision ofInquiries, Complaints andReports Committeecautioning applicantsregarding use of theirnames in advertisingcontrary to regulationsdismissed
4. ONSC Dixon v. Ontario(Director, Ministryof theEnvironment)
12/29/14 [2014] O.J. No.6170, 2014ONSC 7404
Cruz, DarrylPellegrino, Eric
Respondent ON Appeal Constitutional law –Canadian Charter of Rightsand Freedoms – Legalrights – life, liberty andsecurity of person –personal autonomy –appellants sought review ofissuance of renewal energyapprovals for threecommercial wind turbine
Page 2
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
projects
5. ONSC WabauskangFirst Nation v.Ontario (Ministerof NorthernDevelopment andMines)
08/24/14 [2014] O.J. No.3994, 2014ONSC 4424
Hall, Geoff Respondent ON JudicialReview
Judicial Review – Directorof Mine Rehabilitation –appeal to suspend or quashdecision
6. ONSC Nutakki v. HealthProfessionsAppeal andReview Board
08/19/14 [2014] O.J. No.4391
Cruz, DarrylCharach,Dorothy
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Health Professions Appealand Review Board – judicialreview -
7. ONSC Security NationalInsurance Co. v.Hodges
07/14/14/ [2014] O.J. No.3328, 2014ONSC 3627
Flisfeder, Marc Respondent ON JudicialReview
Insurance law – accidentbenefits – application byinsurer for judicial review ofDelegate’s decisionupholding arbitrator’sdecision that insuredsuffered catastrophicimpairment dismissed
8. ONSC Ontario Collegeof Teachers v.Mullins
04/24/14 [2014] O.J. No.1929, 2014ONSC 2502
Leonard, DavidD’Souza,Shane
Respondent ON Appeal Appeal of DisciplineCommittee – burden ofproof – assessment ofcredibility
9. ONSC KeatleySurveying Ltd. vTeranet Inc.
03/26/14 [2014] O.J. No.1450, 2014ONSC 1677
Morrison, PaulSookman,BarryParla, Julie
Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – class orrepresentative actions –common interests andissues – appeal by KeatleySurveying from judgmentdenying motion forcertification of classproceeding allowed
Page 3
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
10. ONSC Scene HoldingInc. v. Moos
03/04/14 [2014] O.J. No.1046, 201 ONSC1378
Hall, GeoffLewis, Atrisha
Respondent ON Appeal Business Corporations Act -
11. ONSC Ostrander PointGP Inc. v. PrinceEdward CountyField Naturalists
02/20/14 [2014] O.J. No.772, 2014 ONSC974
Cruz, DarrylPellegrino, Eric
Respondent ON Appeal Administrative law – judicialreview and statutory appeal– reasonableness – appealby three parties fromEnvironmental ReviewTribunal decisions allowedin part
12. ONSC Muskoka Lakes(Township) v.Ontario (Ministerof NaturalResources)
08/22/13 [2013] O.J. No.3856, 2013ONSC 5380
Finkelstein,NeilBlock, EricD’Souza,Shane
Respondents ON JudicialReview
Judicial review - Leasecrown lands
13. ONSC Liberman v.College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
06/13/13 [2013] O.J. No.2717, 2013ONSC 4066
Hubbard, ChrisFeiner, Jeff
Appellant ON Appeal Health law – Health careprofessionals – governmentof – regulatory colleges orgoverning councils –Disciplinary proceedings
14. ONSC Martin v.AstraZenecaPharmaceuticalsPLC
03/08/13 [2013] O.J. No.1182, 2013ONSC 1169
McLaughlin,FrankKain, Brandon
Respondents ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – parties – classor representative actions –certification – costs –assessment or fixing ofcosts – appeal – appeal byplaintiffs from order denyingcertification of class actionand awarding costs todefendants dismissed
15. ONSC Hefzi-Yekta v.HealthProfessionsAppeal andReview Board
12/19/12 [2012] O.J. No.6141, 2012ONSC 6981
Burt, GlynnisP.Ship, Adam
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Judicial Review – HealthProfessions Appeal andReview Board – standard ofreview - reasonablenes
Page 4
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
16. ONSC McIntyre v.Ontario Collegeof Teachers
11/09/12 [2012] O.J. No.5313, 2012ONSC 5957
Zayid, CarolineD’Souza,Shane
Respondent ON Appeal Employment law –Discipline and terminationof employment – Civilprocedure – Appeal byMcIntyre from a decision ofthe Discipline Committee ofthe Ontario College ofTeachers dismissed
17. ONSC Banner v.College ofPhysicans andSurgeons ofOntario
10/03/12 [2012] O.J. No.4644, 2012ONSC 5547
Findlay, Kate Applicant ON JudicialReview
Judicial Review – Inquiries,Complaints and ReportsCommittee of the College ofPhysicians and Surgeons
18. ONSC R. v. Schmerl 09/17/12 Marques, Elder Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law – SummaryConviction Appeal
19. ONSC Wilcock v.Ontario (HealthProfessionsAppeal andReview Board)
02/21/12 [2012] O.J. No.961, 2012 ONSC1249
Leonard, DavidA.Graham, MoyaJ.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Judicial Review – HealthProfessions Appeal andReview Board – jurisdiction– Complaints Committee ofthe College of Physiciansand Surgeons
20. ONSC Sterling StudioLofts Inc. v.Toronto (City)Chief BuildingOfficial
01/23/12 [2012] O.J. No.515, 2012 ONSC273
Mercer,Malcolm M.
Appellant ON Appeal Municipal law - DemolitionPermit – Building Code Act-
21. ONSC Ellis v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
06/30/11 [2011] O.J. No.30202011 ONSC 4134
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Judicial review — fitness topractice
22. ONSC Aris v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
03/18/11 [2011] O.J. No.14002011 ONSC 1202
Leonard, DavidE.D'Souza,Shane
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Judicial review —suspension of certificate ofqualification andregistration
Page 5
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
23. ONSC Kritzinger v.Ontario (Ministryof Health andLongterm Care)
03/09/11 [2011] O.J. No.13722011 ONSC 1547
Freedlander,Jeffrey
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Judicial review —unauthorized payment
24. ONSC Martin v.Astrazeneca PLC
12/07/09 2009 CanLII68476[2009] O.J. No.5265259 O.A.C. 155
Morrison, F.PaulMcLaughlin,Frank J.
Appellant ON Appeal Class action — priority —certification motion — class— summary judgmentmotion
25. ONSC 1413910 OntarioInc. (c.o.b. asBulls EyeSteakhouse &Grill) v.McLennan
04/30/09 [2009] O.J. No.1828309 D.L.R. (4th)75658 B.L.R. (4th)183249 O.A.C. 3332009CarswellOnt2444178 A.C.W.S.(3d) 120
Hall, Geoff R.Parla, Julie K.
Respondent ON Appeal Corporations, partnershipsand associations law —corporations — oppressionremedy — grounds —oppressive or unfairlyprejudicial conduct
26. ONSC Mignacca v.Merck FrosstCanada Ltd.
02/13/09 2009 CanLII10059[2009] O.J. No.82195 O.R. (3d) 269247 O.A.C. 32271 C.P.C. (6th)350176 A.C.W.S.(3d) 362009CarswellOnt1248
Finkelstein,Neil
Appellant ON Appeal Multi-jurisdictional classactions — principles ofcomity — certification —stay — abuse of process
Page 6
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
27. ONSC Dionne v.Workplace Safetyand InsuranceAppeals Tribunal
10/29/08 [2008] O.J. No.433793 O.R. (3d) 6188 Admin. L.R.(4th) 62247 O.A.C. 322008 CanLII56004172 A.C.W.S.(3d) 125
Scott, WilliamG.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Employment law —workers' compensation —right to sue
28. ONSC Ontario Collegeof Teachers v.Leger-Legault
10/21/08 [2008] O.J. No.4155242 O.A.C. 126172 A.C.W.S.(3d) 117
Zayid, CarolineFeiner, Jeffrey
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Judicial review — disciplinecommittee
29. ONSC Gore v. Collegeof Physicians andSurgeons ofOntario
09/26/08 [2008] O.J. No.3757299 D.L.R. (4th)670242 O.A.C. 1892 O.R. (3d) 195169 A.C.W.S.(3d) 89885 Admin. L.R.(4th) 582008CarswellOnt5654
Matheson,Andrew B.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Affirmed byCourt ofAppeal[2009] O.J.No. 2833;2009 ONCA546; 96 O.R.(3d) 241;310 D.L.R.(4th) 354;251 O.A.C.49; 95Admin. L.R.(4th) 99;2009CarswellOnt3887
Health law — health careprofessionals — discipline— judicial review —government of — particularprofessions — doctors —three applications forjudicial review of decisionsof College of Physiciansand Surgeons of Ontario —common to all threeapplications was theinterpretation of ss. 75 and76 of the health professionsprocedural code —applications dismissed
30. ONSC GreenlightCapital, Inc. v.Stronach
07/10/08 2008 CanLII34359 (ONS.C.D.C.)91 O.R. (3d) 24147 B.L.R. (4th)
Steep, R. PaulFeiner, JeffreyE.
Appellant ON Appeal Oppression remedy —reasonable expectations —application — shareholders— privatization
Page 7
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
215240 O.A.C. 86[2008] O.J. No.2749168 A.C.W.S.(3d) 912008CarswellOnt4093
31. ONSC Cotton v. Collegeof Nurses ofOntario
06/03/08 2008 CanLII2667487 Admin. L.R.(4th) 171238 O.A.C. 270[2008] O.J. No.2172168 A.C.W.S.(3d) 6502008CarswellOnt3256
Burt, GlynnisP.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Health law — professionalresponsibility — discipline
32. ONSC Ontario (Alcoholand GamingCommission) v.ArenaEntertainmentInc. (c.o.b. Circa)
03/25/08 [2008] O.J. No.1167167 A.C.W.S.(3d) 131
Mogil, Eli Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law — liquorcontrol — licensing —liquor control boards
33. ONSC Pieters v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
02/11/08 [2008] O.J. No.527164 A.C.W.S.(3d) 552
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Professional responsibility— discipline — teachers —standing
34. ONSC Ontario (Ministryof CorrectionalServices) v.Goodis
01/29/08 [2008] O.J. No.28989 O.R. (3d) 457290 D.L.R. (4th)102
Lonsdale,Christine L.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Government law —freedom of information —legislation — provincial —bars — confidentialinformation — solicitor-
Page 8
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
233 O.A.C. 24577 Admin. L.R.(4th) 1332008 CanLII2603163 A.C.W.S.(3d) 6432008CarswellOnt 365
client privilege
35. ONSC Rosenhek v.Windsor RegionalHospital,
01/28/08 2008 CanLII2614[2008] O.J. No.300232 O.A.C. 325164 A.C.W.S.(3d) 553
Steep, R. PaulHubbard,Christopher M.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Professional responsibility— health care — doctors —administrative law —jurisdiction of the court toreview — public hospitals— health law — health careprofessionals — discipline— hospital investigationinto physician conduct
36. ONSC Lomas v. RioAlgom Limited
01/23/08 2008 CanLII259689 O.R. (3d) 130[2008] O.J. No.28289 O.R. (3d) 130290 D.L.R. (4th)363233 O.A.C. 5865 C.C.P.B. 108163 A.C.W.S.(3d) 5472008CarswellOnt 472
Finkelstein,Neil
Appellant ON Appeal Reversed bythe ONCA(Lomas v.Rio AlgomLtd. [2010]O.J. No. 932;2010 ONCA175; 99 O.R.(3d) 161;316 D.L.R.(4th) 385;259 O.A.C.333; 81C.C.P.B. 1;186A.C.W.S.(3d) 665;2010CarswellOnt
Civil litigation — Rule 21 —pension and benefits —private administration
Page 9
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
1327)
37. ONSC McLaine v.London LifeInsuranceCompany
12/18/07 [2007] O.J. No.5035233 O.A.C. 27553 C.P.C. (6th)1352007CarswellOnt8294162 A.C.W.S.(3d) 888
Morrison, F.PaulSteep, R. PaulLeonard, David
Respondent ON Appeal [2008] O.J.No. 2360;239 O.A.C.293; 168A.C.W.S.(3d) 41; 59C.P.C. (6th)235; 2008CarswellOnt3579
Civil procedure — classactions — certification —preferable procedure —common interests —financial institutions — realproperty law — mortgages— mortgage agreement —terms
38. ONSC Duval v. Collegeof Nurses ofOntario
10/19/07 [2007] O.J. No.3992230 O.A.C. 193161 A.C.W.S.(3d) 159
Zayid, CarolineR.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Health law — disciplinecommittee — penalty —professional misconduct
39. ONSC Mulligan v.LaurentianUniversity
08/17/07 2007 CanLII33761[2007] O.J. No.3135159 A.C.W.S.(3d) 525
Sutton,Thomas N.T.Feiner, JeffreyE.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Affirmed byMulligan v. LaurentianUniversity,2008 ONCA523; 302D.L.R. (4th)546, 241O.A.C. 11
University admission —procedural fairness —flagrant violation of therules — policy — research— universities
40. ONSC Smith v. NationalMoney Mart Co.
04/02/07 [2007] O.J. No.216030 E.T.R. (3d)1632007CarswellOnt2177
Morrison, F.PaulBrown, John P.Zayid, CarolineR.Hubbard,Christopher M.
Appellant ON Appeal Class action — certification
Page 10
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
41. ONSC Flora v. Ontario(Health InsurancePlan, GeneralManager)
01/15/07 [2007] O.J. No.9183 O.R. (3d) 721278 D.L.R. (4th)45219 O.A.C. 14256 Admin. L.R.(4th) 2062007CarswellOnt 103168 A.C.W.S.(3d) 230
McKendry,Jennifer A.
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Constitutional law —Canadian Charter of Rightsand Freedoms — legalrights — life, liberty andsecurity of person —principles of fundamentaljustice — health law —health insurance,government — claims —entitlement — insuredservices — cadaveric —liver — transplant —treatment
42. ONSC Siadat v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
01/10/07 [2007] O.J. No.6583 O.R. (3d) 401278 D.L.R. (4th)130219 O.A.C. 283154 A.C.W.S.(3d) 383
Zayid, CarolineR.Grace, Keary
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law — thehearing — procedure —particulars — production —human rights law —discrimination — context —exceptions — duty toaccommodate — scope
43. ONSC Sears HoldingsCorporation v.OntarioSecuritiesCommission
10/11/06 [2006] O.J. No.429684 O.R. (3d) 61216 O.A.C. 17921 B.L.R. (4th)311152 A.C.W.S.(3d) 4292006CarswellOnt6272
Steep, R. PaulSutton,Thomas N.T.
Intervenor ON AdministrativeAppeal
Securities regulation —mergers and acquisitions —takeover bids
44. ONSC Serhan Estate v.Johnson &Johnson
06/15/06 [2006] O.J. No.242185 O.R. (3d) 665269 D.L.R. (4th)279
Zayid, CarolineR.
Appellant ON Appeal SCC refusedleave toappeal:[2006]S.C.C.A. No.
Civil procedure — parties— class or representativeactions — certification —common interests — tortlaw — suppliers of goods
Page 11
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
213 O.A.C. 29828 C.P.C. (6th)8324 E.T.R. (3d)265149 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1972006CarswellOnt3705
494 — product liability —distributors —manufacturers
45. ONSC White v. Assn. ofProfessionalEngineers ofOntario
05/25/06 2006 CanLII17320210 O.A.C. 160[2006] O.J. No.206855 C.L.R. (3d)1062006 CanLII17320148 A.C.W.S.(3d) 6462006CarswellOnt3203
Black, WilliamD.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional responsibility— professional misconduct— discipline — penalties —engineers
46. ONSC Reynolds v.Kingston (City)Police ServicesBoard
05/24/06 [2006] O.J. No.2039267 D.L.R. (4th)409212 O.A.C. 29939 C.C.L.T. (3d)257148 A.C.W.S.(3d) 3992006CarswellOnt3105
Ortved, W.Niels F.
Appellant ON Appeal ReversedReynolds v.Kingston(City) PoliceServicesBoard [2007]O.J. No. 900
Civil procedure —disposition without trial —dismissal of action —appeals by the defendantphysician from an orderrefusing the appellant'smotion to strike therespondent's claim againsthim and from an orderallowing the respondent'smotion to amend heramended statement ofclaim
Page 12
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
47. ONSC Williams v. Wai-Ping
12/21/05 [2005] O.J. No.618627 C.P.C. (6th)83144 A.C.W.S.(3d) 7512005CarswellOnt7573
Leonard, DavidE.
Appellant ON Appeal Medical malpractice —negligence — pleadings
48. ONSC Kalin v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
05/24/05 [2005] O.J. No.209775 O.R. (3d) 523254 D.L.R. (4th)503198 O.A.C. 20130 Admin. L.R.(4th) 289139 A.C.W.S.(3d) 6822005CarswellOnt2095
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law —boards and tribunals —evidence — professions —teachers — professionaldiscipline
49. ONSC Kent v. ConquestVacations Co.
02/01/05 [2005] O.J. No.312194 O.A.C. 302136 A.C.W.S.(3d) 831
Reddon,Andrew J.
Respondent ON Appeal Motion forcosts: [2005]O.J. No.1311
Contracts — breach ofcontract — quantum ofdamages
50. ONSC College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario v. Shi-Yuen
01/26/05 2005 CanLII2037194 O.A.C. 145[2005] O.J. No.234136 A.C.W.S.(3d) 760
McKendry,Jennifer A.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Administrative law — thehearing — procedure —production — judicialreview and statutory appeal— standard of review —reasonableness — boardsand tribunals — disclosureby — professionalresponsibility — discipline— appeals and judicial
Page 13
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
review — standard ofreview — professions —health care — doctors
51. ONSC Cressman v.Ontario Collegeof Teachers
01/25/05 [2005] O.J. No.565249 D.L.R. (4th)749194 O.A.C. 2622005 CanLII1406136 A.C.W.S.(3d) 665
Zayid, CarolineR.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Professional misconduct —teaching — certificate ofqualification
52. ONSC Hartjes v.Carman
12/20/04 [2004] O.J. No.559753 C.C.L.T. (3d)1952004CarswellOnt9807
Black, WilliamD.
Appellant ON Appeal Health law — health careprofessionals —professional liability —negligence — causation —duty of care
53. ONSC Ontario Collegeof Teachers v.Bhadauria
06/09/04 2004 CanLII16867[2004] O.J. No.2468187 O.A.C. 296131 A.C.W.S.(3d) 875
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional responsibility— discipline — teachers —misconduct
54. ONSC George v.College ofNurses of Ontario
05/11/04 2004 CanLII8616[2004] O.J. No.2694131 A.C.W.S.(3d) 993
Zayid, CarolineR.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Medicine — nurses —discipline — judicial review
55. ONSC Li v. College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
04/30/04 2004 CanLII185282004 CanLII27472
Meredith,Heather L.
Applicant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Medicine — discipline forprofessional misconduct —judicial review, appeals —practice — stay of
Page 14
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
[2004] O.J. No.1828130 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1217
proceedings
56. ONSC Ontario Collegeof Teachers v.Webb
03/08/04 2004 CanLII10689[2004] O.J. No.1134130 A.C.W.S.(3d) 99
Leonard, DavidE.
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Education — teachers —discipline — suspension —discipline, judicial review —when available — standardof review
57. ONSC Ontario (Ministryof CorrectionalServices) v.Ontario(Information andPrivacyCommissioner)
01/26/04 [2004] O.J. No.894
Lonsdale,Christine L.
Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed bythe ONCA([2005] O.J.No. 66);reversed bythe SCC([2006]S.C.J. No.31; [2006]A.C.S. no31; 2006SCC 31;2006 CSC31; [2006] 2S.C.R. 32;[2006] 2R.C.S. 32;271 D.L.R.(4th) 407;350 N.R.154; J.E.2006-1357;148A.C.W.S.(3d) 832;EYB 2006-107360)
Access to information —access to records —exemption — solicitor-clientprivilege
Page 15
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
58. ONSC Stetler v.Agriculture, Foodand Rural AffairsAppeal Tribunal
12/18/03 [2003] O.J. No.5203179 O.A.C. 398127 A.C.W.S.(3d) 810
Morrison, F.Paul
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Appeal([2005] O.J.No. 2817; 76O.R. (3d)321; 200O.A.C. 20936 Admin.L.R. (4th)212; 141A.C.W.S.(3d) 157;2005CarswellOnt2877
Administrative law — thehearing and decision — thetribunal — effect ofmembers of tribunalbecoming witnesses —boards and tribunals —judicial review — standardof review — failure to dealwith issues raised
59. ONSC Wilson v. TheCollege ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
11/05/03 2003 CanLII18154[2003] O.J. No.4236178 O.A.C. 258126 A.C.W.S.(3d) 716
Hubbard,Christopher
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional responsibility— discipline — negligence— misconduct
60. ONSC Lee v. College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
08/26/03 [2003] O.J. No.338266 O.R. (3d) 592231 D.L.R. (4th)335175 O.A.C. 227125 A.C.W.S.(3d) 166
Porter, DavidM.
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Health law — professionaldiscipline — administrativelaw — denial of naturaljustice due to failure torequire production andtranscription of relevantevidence
61. ONSC Ontario(Children'sLawyer) v.Ontario(Information andPrivacyCommissioner)
08/14/03 [2003] O.J. No.352266 O.R. (3d) 692231 D.L.R. (4th)727177 O.A.C. 18 Admin. L.R.(4th) 251
Lonsdale,Christine L.
Friend of theCourt
ON JudicialReview
Affirmed bythe ONCA([2005] O.J.No. 1426; 75O.R. (3d)309; 253D.L.R. (4th)489; 196
Barristers and solicitors —duty to client — disclosureof client's file upon request— Crown — examination ofpublic documents
Page 16
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
45 R.F.L. (5th)285125 A.C.W.S.(3d) 193
O.A.C. 350;29 Admin.L.R. (4th) 86;17 R.F.L.(6th) 32;2005 CanLII11786; 138A.C.W.S.(3d) 778;2005CarswellOnt1419)
62. ONSC Stanley v.Ontario (HealthProfessionsAppeal andReviewBoard)
05/26/03 [2003] O.J. No.2196172 O.A.C. 565 Admin. L.R.(4th) 112123 A.C.W.S.(3d) 762
Reddon,Andrew J.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Administrative law —review of health professionsappeal and review boarddecision
63. ONSC Mussani v.College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
05/20/03 [2003] O.J. No.195664 O.R. (3d) 641226 D.L.R. (4th)511172 O.A.C. 12 Admin. L.R.(4th) 123106 C.R.R. (2d)281123 A.C.W.S.(3d) 380
Ortved, W.Niels F.Matheson,Andrew B.
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Affirmed byCA [2004]O.J. No.5176; 74O.R. (3d) 1;248 D.L.R.(4th) 632;193 O.A.C.23; 22Admin. L.R.(4th) 53; 125C.R.R. (2d)340; 136A.C.W.S.(3d) 156;2004CarswellOnt5433
Medicine — discipline forprofessional misconduct —punishments — revocationof licence — civil rights —liberty — limitations on —choice of work — securityof the person —professional occupations —right to practice — freedomof association — regulationof professionals — crueland unusual treatment orpunishment — application— disciplinary proceedings— Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —practice — who may raiseCanadian Charter of Rights
Page 17
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
and Freedoms issues —time for deciding CanadianCharter of Rights andFreedoms issues
64. ONSC Humber Heightsof EtobicokeRatepayers Inc.v. Toronto DistrictSchool Board
04/17/03 2003 CanLII37678 (ONS.C.D.C.)171 O.A.C. 21[2003] O.J. No.1381122 A.C.W.S.(3d) 198
Baron, Erica J. Respondent ON Judicialreview
Education law — duty to actfairly — schoolcommissions and boards
65. ONSC Smith v. Ontario(EnvironmentalReview Tribunal)
03/24/03 [2003] O.J. No.10321 C.E.L.R. (3d)245
Hamilton, Doug Respondent ON JudicialReview
Environmental law —grounds of appeal —standard of review
66. ONSC MacDiarmid v.College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
01/23/03 [2003] O.J. No.277119 A.C.W.S.(3d) 842
Porter, DavidM.
Applicant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Health law — professionaldiscipline — powers ofdisciplinary body, re:penalties
67. ONSC Markson v.Ontario Collegeof Teachers
01/20/03 2003 CanLII9308[2003] O.J. No.278186 O.A.C. 339119 A.C.W.S.(3d) 770
Sinha, Awanish Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Education — teachers —discipline of — appeals
68. ONSC Toronto DistrictSchool Board v.Ontario(Informationand PrivacyCommissioner)
10/15/02 [2002] O.J. No.4631
Lonsdale,Christine L.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Crown — examination ofpublic documents —disclosure of parties'representation tocommissioner — freedomof information
Page 18
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
69. ONSC D.P. v. Wagg 10/04/02 [2002] O.J. No.380861 O.R. (3d) 746222 D.L.R. (4th)97165 O.A.C. 20926 C.P.C. (5th)37797 C.R.R. (2d)3242002 CanLII23611117 A.C.W.S.(3d) 452002CarswellOnt3288
Batner, Sarit E. Appellant ON Appeal Varied by D.P. v. Wagg,[2004] O.J.No. 2053; 71O.R. (3d)229; 239D.L.R. (4th)501; 187O.A.C. 26;184 C.C.C.(3d) 321; 46C.P.C. (5th)13; 120C.R.R. (2d)52; 2004CanLII39048; 130A.C.W.S.(3d) 1098
Evidence — disclosure andproduction of documents —health law — health careprofessional — civildiscovery
70. ONSC J.G. v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
06/13/02 [2002] O.J. No.23291 Admin. L.R.(4th) 285
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law —professional misconduct —teachers — decisions of thetribunal
71. ONSC VitapharmCanada Ltd. v. F.Hoffmann-LaRoche Ltd.
04/10/02 [2002] O.J. No.1400212 D.L.R. (4th)563159 O.A.C. 20420 C.P.C. (5th)6518 C.P.R. (4th)267113 A.C.W.S.(3d) 966
Houston,Donald
Appellant ON Appeal Appealed tothe ONCA([2003] O.J.No. 868; 223D.L.R. (4th)445; 30C.P.C. (5th)107; 23C.P.R. (4th)454; 121A.C.W.S.(3d) 425).Leave toappeal to the
Procedural law — pre-trialprocedure — discovery —class proceedings
Page 19
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
SupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed([2003]S.C.C.A. No.245,11/27/2003)
72. ONSC WesteindeConstruction Ltd.v. MurleeHoldings Ltd.
02/18/02 [2002] O.J. No.934
Morrison, F.PaulHall, Geoff R.
Appellant ON Appeal Civil procedure — appeals— construction law —building contracts — terms— price — damages —general damages
73. ONSC Assn. ofProfessionalEngineers ofOntario v.Duester
12/21/01 [2001] O.J. No.5102
Black, WilliamD.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional occupation —discipline — professionalmisconduct — engineers
74. ONSC Henderson v.College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
12/21/01 [2001] O.J. No.5137155 O.A.C. 72110 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1151
Steep, R. Paul Applicant ON JudicialReview
Affirmed, 65O.R. (3d)146, 172O.A.C. 337,228 D.L.R.(4th) 598 ,(Ont. C.A.,June 5,2003)
Regulated healthprofessions — medicine —discipline for professionalmisconduct — conductunbecoming a member —sexual improprieties —procedure, notice —contents and sufficiency ofnotice — curing of defects
75. ONSC Williams v.Mutual LifeAssurance Co.;Zicherman v.Equitable LifeInsurance Co.of Canada
12/14/01 [2001] O.J. No.4952152 O.A.C. 34434 C.C.L.I. (3d)31617 C.P.C. (5th)103[2002] I.L.R. I-4052
Morrison, F.PaulPeebles, DanaM.
Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed byONCA:[2003] O.J.No. 1160and 1161;Applicationfor leave toappeal to theSupreme
Class actions — lifeinsurance policies —negligent — appeal fromdismissal of certificationmotion —misrepresentation
Page 20
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
110 A.C.W.S.(3d) 427
Court ofCanadadismissed,January 22,2004 ([2003]S.C.C.A. No.280 and 283.
76. ONSC Zemelman v.Feder
04/30/01 [2001] O.J. No.185754 O.R. (3d) 15148 O.A.C. 35613 C.L.R. (3d) 8411 C.P.C. (5th)170105 A.C.W.S.(3d) 372
Cruz, Darryl A. Appellant ON Appeal Mechanics' liens — practice— evidence — affidavits —jurat
77. ONSC Divinec v.526799 Ontarioltd. (c.o.b. EuropaCatering)
03/15/01 [2001] O.J. No.925104 A.C.W.S.(3d) 180
Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Landlord and tenant — thelease — breach by tenant— rent
78. ONSC Musson v.College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario
10/27/00 [2000] O.J. No.4013140 O.A.C. 132
Porter, DavidM.Leonard, DavidE.
Appellant ON JudicialReview
Health law — professionaldiscipline — administrativelaw — jurisdiction ofexecutive committee ofCollege of Physicians andSurgeons of Ontario tomake interim order
79. ONSC Ontario (Speakerof the LegislativeAssembly) v.Ontario (HumanRightsCommission)
07/07/00 [2000] O.J. No.3416196 D.L.R. (4th)136140 O.A.C. 19101 A.C.W.S.(3d) 264
Finkelstein,Neil
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Affirmed byOntario(Speaker oftheLegislativeAssembly) v.Ontario(Human
Crown — Crown privilegeor prerogative —parliamentary privilege —administrative law —boards and tribunals —jurisdiction of particularboards and tribunals —provincial Human Rights
Page 21
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
RightsCommission), [2001] O.J.No. 2180; 54O.R. (3d)595; 201D.L.R. (4th)698; 146O.A.C. 125;33 Admin.L.R. (3d)123; 85C.R.R. (2d)170; 105A.C.W.S.(3d) 841
Commission
80. ONSC Toronto (City) v.C.U.P.E., Local79
05/05/00 [2000] O.J. No.1570187 D.L.R. (4th)323134 O.A.C. 4823 Admin. L.R.(3d) 7296 A.C.W.S. (3d)98546 W.C.B. (2d)232
Kapur, Sunil Respondent ON JudicialReview
Affirmed bythe ONCA([2001] O.J.No. 3239; 55O.R. (3d)541; 205D.L.R. (4th)280; 149O.A.C. 213;37 Admin.L.R. (3d) 40;45 C.R. (5th)354; 2001CanLII24114; 107A.C.W.S.(3d) 426; 51W.C.B. (2d)16) and theSCC ([2003]S.C.J. No.65; [2003]
Labour law — publicservice labour relations —grievances — evidence andproof
Page 22
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
A.C.S. no65; 2003SCC 64;2003 CSC64; [2003] 3S.C.R. 149;[2003] 3R.C.S. 149;232 D.L.R.(4th) 443;J.E. 2003-2109; 179O.A.C. 201;59 W.C.B.(2d) 333;120 L.A.C.(4th) 284)
81. ONSC Knoll v. DraxisHealth Inc.
04/17/00 [2000] O.J. No.1333132 O.A.C. 18245 C.P.C. (4th)33796 A.C.W.S. (3d)565
Morrison, F.Paul
Appellant ON Appeal Practice — costs —security for costs —considerations — whereplaintiff resident out ofjurisdiction, bars to thegranting of an order —amount of security —grounds for reducingamount of security —company law — actionsagainst corporations anddirectors — action foroppressive conduct —security for costs
82. ONSC Sclater v. OntarioCollege ofTeachers
02/21/00 2000 CanLII26989[2000] O.J. No.1428132 O.A.C. 32296 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Zayid, CarolineR.
Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law —College of Teachers —fitness to practice decision
Page 23
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
615
83. ONSC Patel v. OntarioCollege ofPharmacists
02/03/00 [2000] O.J. No.256130 O.A.C. 29194 A.C.W.S. (3d)1012
Matheson,Andrew B.
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional occupations —pharmacists — discipline —punishments, suspension.
84. ONSC Meredith v.LeboeufProperties Inc.
01/28/00 [2000] O.J. No.209
Brown, John P. Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Landlord and tenant —regulation — powers ofboard or officers —jurisdiction
85. ONSC Ontario (AttorneyGeneral) v.Ontario PublicServiceEmployees Union
10/08/99 [1999] O.J. No.3779180 D.L.R. (4th)54957 C.L.R.B.R.(2d) 145127 O.A.C. 7819 Admin. L.R.(3d) 31791 A.C.W.S. (3d)757
Kapur, Sunil Applicant ON JudicialReview
Reversed bythe ONCA([2000] O.J.No. 4602; 52O.R. (3d) 77;195 D.L.R.(4th) 376; 66C.L.R.B.R.(2d) 92; 26Admin. L.R.(3d) 15; 101A.C.W.S.(3d) 753)
Employment — labourrelations — standard ofreview — bargaining unit
86. ONSC STB AirTerminals Ltd. v.Greater TorontoAirports Authority
09/21/99 [1999] O.J. No.3552
Cruz, Darryl A. Appellant ON Appeal Injunctions — variation ofinterim or interlocutoryinjunction
87. ONSC Paskie (PublicTrustee of) v.CanadianAmateur BoxingAssn.
08/29/99 [1999] O.J. No.326445 O.R. (3d) 765126 O.A.C. 24490 A.C.W.S. (3d)853
Peebles, DanaM.
Appellant ON Appeal Medical law — negligence— appeal from masterdecision permitting latedelivery of jury notice
Page 24
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
88. ONSC Ontario PublicServiceEmployees'Union v. Ontario(AttorneyGeneral)
09/17/98 [1998] O.J. No.4304
Kapur, Sunil Respondent ON JudicialReview
Labour and employment —arbitration — jurisdiction —factual findings
89. ONSC Strazdins v.Caledon (Town)
07/21/98 [1998] O.J. No.3586
Reddon,Andrew J.
Respondent ON JudicialReview
Administrative law —application to quash —municipal law
90. ONSC Hoffman v. Harris 06/24/98 [1998] O.J. No.4250
Brown, John P. Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners — negligenceor fault
91. ONSC Alcan AluminiumLtd. v. SanwaBusiness CreditCorp.
06/22/98 [1998] O.J. No.2581
Hamer, David Respondent ON Appeal Practice — discovery —what documents must beproduced — privilegeddocuments, attorney-clientcommunications
92. ONSC Girard v. GeneralHospital of PortArthur
06/17/98 [1998] O.J. No.6137
Cruz, Darryl A. Appellant ON Appeal Leave toappeal to theOntarioCourt ofAppealrefused([1998] O.J.No. 4091,10/13/1998)
Medicine — liability ofpractitioners — negligenceor fault
93. ONSC Assn. ofProfessionalEngineers ofOntario v.Karmash
05/27/98 [1998] O.J. No.2161109 O.A.C. 33439 C.L.R. (2d)16579 A.C.W.S. (3d)1266
Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional responsibility— engineers — discipline— what constitutesprofessional misconduct —harassment anddiscriminatory conduct —punishments, suspension— disciplinary proceedings— appeals
Page 25
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
94. ONSC Hudson's BayCo. v. White
04/15/98 [1998] O.J. No.23831 C.P.C. (5th)333
Vegh, George Appellant ON Appeal Damages — exemplary orpunitive damages —entitlement
95. ONSC Anderson v.Wilson
02/20/98 [1998] O.J. No.67137 O.R. (3d) 235156 D.L.R. (4th)735107 O.A.C. 27418 C.P.C. (4th)20877 A.C.W.S. (3d)1142
Leonard, DavidE.
Respondent ON Appeal Reversed bythe ONCA([1999] O.J.No. 2494; 44O.R. (3d)673; 175D.L.R. (4th)409; 122O.A.C. 69;36 C.P.C.(4th) 17; 89A.C.W.S.(3d) 441)
Practice — persons whocan sue and be sued —individuals andcorporations, status orstanding — class actions,members of class
96. ONSC Duffy et al. v.Gillespie et al.
12/15/97 [1997] O.J. No.500836 O.R. (3d) 443155 D.L.R. (4th)461105 O.A.C. 28317 C.P.C. (4th)9176 A.C.W.S. (3d)46
Ortved, W.Niels F.
Appellant ON Appeal Practice — juries and jurytrials — trials — severanceof issues — liability anddamages — properconsiderations.
97. ONSC Bercovici v.TransCanadaPipelines Ltd.
10/03/97 [1997] O.J. No.399274 A.C.W.S. (3d)279
Brown, John P. Appellant ON Appeal Limitation of actions —practice
98. ONSC Wells (LitigationGuardian of) v.Paramsothy
11/27/96 [1996] O.J. No.448632 O.R. (3d) 45298 O.A.C. 23368 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Ortved, W.Niels F.
Appellant ON Appeal Practice — discovery —examination, range of —non-parties — medicalmalpractice — plaintiffs'caregivers
Page 26
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
40
99. ONSC Lovekin v.Ontario (Ministerof MunicipalAffairs andHousing)
08/08/96 [1996] O.J. No.247033 M.P.L.R. (2d)225
Morrison, F.Paul
Applicant ON Judicialreview
Land regulation — land usecontrol, agricultural landprotection — practice —judicial review
100. ONSC Brock Universityv. Ontario(Human RightsCommission)
03/14/96 [1996] O.J. No.88391 O.A.C. 7136 Admin. L.R.(2d) 26761 A.C.W.S. (3d)1147
Reddon,Andrew J.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Administrative law —natural justice — delay
101. ONSC MacDonald v.Ontario Hydro
10/18/95 [1995] O.J. No.304826 O.R. (3d) 40186 O.A.C. 3710 C.C.P.B. 158 A.C.W.S. (3d)392
Finkelstein,Neil
Appellant ON Appeal Pension — directors — civilprocedure — statement ofclaim — striking out
102. ONSC Masters v.Ontario
05/30/94 [1994] O.J. No.113518 O.R. (3d) 551115 D.L.R. (4th)31972 O.A.C. 127 Admin. L.R.(2d) 15248 A.C.W.S. (3d)252
Stephenson,Jenny P.
Intervenor ON JudicialReview
Administrative law —Ontario governmentministers — prerogativepower of premier — natureof premier’s decision —investigation —employment relationship —harassment — resignation— release fromconfidentiality
103. ONSC Essa (Township)v. Guergis;Membery v. Hill
10/27/93 [1993] O.J. No.258115 O.R. (3d) 57322 C.P.C. (3d) 63
Finkelstein,Neil
Intervenor ON Appeal Practice — barrister andsolicitor — judicial policy —witnesses
Page 27
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
52 C.P.R. (3d)372
104. ONSC Chippewas ofKettle and StoneyPoint v. Ontario(Ministry of IndianAffairs)
10/18/93 [1993] O.J. No.2692[1994] 2 C.N.L.R.3344 A.C.W.S. (3d)170
Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Professions — barristersand solicitors —investigation of land claims— legal representation —conflicts of interests —Chinese walls — breach ofconfidentiality
105. ONSC Arthur v. SignumCommunicationsLtd.
08/25/93 [1993] O.J. No.1928
McLaughlin,Frank J.
Appellant ON Appeal Company law —oppression — shareholders'rights — double recovery —where shareholdersgranted relief fromoppression and granted anappraisal
106. ONSC Ontario HomeBuilders' Assn. v.York RegionBoard ofEducation
05/20/93 [1993] O.J. No.108613 O.R. (3d) 493at 496103 D.L.R. (4th)5562 O.A.C. 32115 M.P.L.R. (2d)140 A.C.W.S. (3d)788
Finkelstein,Neil
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Reversed bythe ONCA([1994] O.J.No. 192; 17O.R. (3d)103; 109D.L.R. (4th)289; 69O.A.C. 216;19 M.P.L.R.(2d) 1; 45A.C.W.S.(3d) 881))and theSupremeCourt ofCanada([1996]S.C.J. No.80; [1996]
Constitutional law —division of powers —Canadian Charter of Rightsand Freedoms — indirecttaxation — regulatoryscheme
Page 28
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
A.C.S. no80; [1996] 2S.C.R. 929;[1996] 2R.C.S. 929;137 D.L.R.(4th) 449;201 N.R. 81;35 M.P.L.R.(2d) 1; 4R.P.R. (3d)1; 65A.C.W.S.(3d) 33)
107. ONSC Canadian Unionof PublicEmployees(CUPE)v. Ontario
Hospital Assn.
02/18/91 [1991] O.J. No.20744 O.A.C. 3035 C.C.E.L. 4325 A.C.W.S. (3d)555
McLaughlin,Frank J.
Appellant ON Appeal Administrative law —pension committee —appeals — appeals frominterlocutory rulings —jurisdiction of court
108. ONSC ManufacturersLife PropertyCorp. v. Senkow
10/01/90 [1990] O.J. No.175675 O.R. (2d) 25473 D.L.R. (4th)38141 O.A.C. 37413 R.P.R. (2d)24323 A.C.W.S. (3d)211
Black, WilliamD.
Appellant ON Appeal Landlord and tenant —termination
109. ONSC Lawson v.Hospital for SickChildren
06/29/90 [1990] O.J. No.116574 O.R. (2d) 1171 D.L.R. (4th)55740 O.A.C. 564 C.C.L.T. (2d)
Ortved, W.Niels F.
Respondent ON Appeal Medical malpractice —limitation periods
Page 29
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
30344 C.P.C. (2d)14621 A.C.W.S. (3d)1135
110. ONSC WeramInvestments Ltd.v. Ontario(SecuritiesCommission)
06/04/90 [1990] O.J. No.91839 O.A.C. 5221 A.C.W.S. (3d)439
Houston,Donald
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Administrative law —Ontario SecuritiesCommission —investigation — disclosureof information — exerciseof discretion
111. ONSC Ontario Hydro v.Ontario (LabourRelations Board)
06/12/89 [1989] O.J. No.97069 O.R. (2d) 26860 D.L.R. (4th)54233 O.A.C. 30289 CLLC 1236616 A.C.W.S. (3d)67
Finkelstein,Neil
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Varied by theONCA[1991] O.J.No. 99; 1O.R. (3d)737; 77D.L.R. (4th)277; 43O.A.C. 184;91 CLLC12129; 25A.C.W.S.(3d) 44;appealdismissed bythe SupremeCourt ofCanada:[1991] O.J.No. 99; 1O.R. (3d)737; 77D.L.R. (4th)277; 43O.A.C. 184;91 CLLC
Labour law — constitutionallaw — division of powers —certification — labourrelations — energy
Page 30
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
12129; 25A.C.W.S.(3d) 44
112. ONSC Palmer v. CarlingO'KeefeBreweries ofCanada Ltd.
01/16/89 [1989] O.J. No.3267 O.R. (2d) 16156 D.L.R. (4th)12832 O.A.C. 11341 B.L.R. 12813 A.C.W.S. (3d)205
Mercer,Malcolm M.
Respondent ON Appeal Corporations — oppressionremedy — shareholders —s. 247 of the OntarioBusiness Corporations Act
113. ONSC FuhrmanAutobody Ltd. v.Penny Fuels Inc.
01/09/89 [1989] O.J. No.14
Morrison, F.Paul
Respondent ON Appeal Re-entering and takingpossession of premises
114. ONSC LemarApartments Ltd.v. Ontario (FireMarshal)
05/16/88 [1988] O.J. No.64265 O.R. (2d) 14830 O.A.C. 210 A.C.W.S. (3d)253
Houston,Donald
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Fire safety — defect notice
115. ONSC Ventin v. OntarioAssn. ofArchitects
03/17/88 [1988] O.J. No.26228 O.A.C. 13029 C.L.R. 2289 A.C.W.S. (3d)271
Morrison, F.Paul
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Architects — discipline —professional misconduct —architect pleading guilty tocharge of professionalmisconduct
116. ONSC Canada HeatingLtd. v. BromptonManufacturingLtd.
11/02/87 [1987] O.J. No.98326 O.A.C. 31136 C.L.R. 1356 A.C.W.S. (3d)418
Mercer,Malcolm M.
Appellant ON Appeal Construction lien —subrogation — right ofsubrogation — sub-subcontractor bringingmechanics' lien actionagainst property owners,general contractor andsubcontractor — generalcontractor filing lien bond to
Page 31
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
take place of property
117. ONSC Pickard v.College ofNurses of Ontario
06/22/87 [1987] O.J. No.60325 O.A.C. 141
Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON AdministrativeAppeal
Professional responsibility— regulated healthprofessions — College ofNurses — acts ofprofessional misconduct —discipline committee —hearing and appeal —delivery and afterbirth careof child
118. ONSC Hodgkinson v.Hitch House Ltd.
04/23/87 60 O.R. (2d) 793 Scott, WilliamG.
Respondent ON Appeal Contract law — sale ofgoods — implied terms
119. ONSC Re ZurichInsurance Co.and OntarioHuman RightsCommission etal.
01/20/87 [1987] O.J. No.4458 O.R. (2d) 32519 O.A.C. 22023 C.C.L.I. 130[1987] I.L.R.83082 A.C.W.S. (3d)391
Finkelstein,Neil
Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Affirmed bythe ONCA70 O.R. (2d)639; 45C.C.L.I. 303;18 A.C.W.S.(3d) 637;and by theSupremeCourt ofCanada:[1992] S.C.J.No. 63;[1992]A.C.S. no63; [1992] 2S.C.R. 321;[1992] 2R.C.S. 321;93 D.L.R.(4th) 346;138 N.R. 1;
Human rights —discrimination on basis ofsex, age and marital status— insurance premiums
Page 32
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
J.E. 92-947;55 O.A.C.81; 12C.C.L.I. (2d)206; [1992]I.L.R. 1879;39 M.V.R.(2d) 1; 34A.C.W.S.(3d) 665
120. ONSC Crown Trust Co.et al. v. TheQueen in right ofOntario et al.
02/28/86 [1986] O.J. No.237454 O.R. (2d) 7926 D.L.R. (4th)4114 O.A.C. 137
Brown, John P. Appellant ON Appeal Public interest — CanadianCharter of Rights andFreedoms — Crown —immunity — constitutionallaw
121. ONSC Consolidated-BathurstPackaging Ltd.and InternationalWoodworkers ofAmerica, Local 2-69 et al.
05/15/85 [1985] O.J. No.259751 O.R. (2d) 48120 D.L.R. (4th)8410 O.A.C. 3416 Admin. L.R.3785 CLLC 1217731 A.C.W.S. (2d)113
Scott, WilliamG.
Applicant ON JudicialReview
Reversed byONCA[1986] O.J.No. 828;Appeal toSCCdismissed
Administrative law —natural justice — labourrelations
122. ONSC Pell v. Farber 01/22/85 [1985] O.J. No.960
Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Small claims —adjournment of trial toobtain legal representation— tort law — medicalmalpractice — negligence
123. ONSC Seaway TrustCo. v. PSAInsuranceBrokers Ltd.
06/13/84 [1984] O.J. No.12594 O.A.C. 128
Morrison, F.Paul
Respondent ON Appeal Promissory note payable ondemand
Page 33
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
124. ONSC DeVuono v.PrudentialInsurance Co. ofAmerica
01/14/83 [1983] O.J. No.2477[1983] I.L.R.627818 A.C.W.S. (2d)287
Morrison, F.Paul
Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure — appeals— onus of proof — causeof death
125. ONSC Ontario EnergyBoard v. UnionGas Ltd.
12/08/82 [1982] O.J. No.1388141 D.L.R. (3d)64117 A.C.W.S. (2d)208
Hamer, David Appellant ON AdministrativeAppeal
Affirmed bythe ONCA[1983] O.J.No. 3138; 42O.R. (2d)731; 150D.L.R. (3d)267; 3Admin. L.R.314; 21A.C.W.S.(2d) 388)
Public utilities — rates —retroactivity — OntarioEnergy Board
ONSCTotalAppeals:125