On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group...

64
On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas B¨ achle Vrije Universiteit Brussel DMV-PTM Mathematical Meeting 17. - 20.09.2014, Pozna´ n

Transcript of On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group...

Page 1: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

On the Normalizers of Subgroupsin Integral Group Rings

Andreas Bachle

Vrije Universiteit Brussel

DMV-PTM Mathematical Meeting

17. - 20.09.2014, Poznan

Page 2: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Notations

G finite group

R commutative ring with identity element 1

RG group ring of G with coefficients in R

U(RG ) group of units of RG

Page 3: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Notations

G finite group

R commutative ring with identity element 1

RG group ring of G with coefficients in R

U(RG ) group of units of RG

Page 4: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Notations

G finite group

R commutative ring with identity element 1

RG group ring of G with coefficients in R

U(RG ) group of units of RG

Page 5: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Notations

G finite group

R commutative ring with identity element 1

RG group ring of G with coefficients in R

U(RG ) group of units of RG

Page 6: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Notations

G finite group

R commutative ring with identity element 1

RG group ring of G with coefficients in R

U(RG ) group of units of RG

Page 7: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G )

G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 8: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇

G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 9: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇ G

· Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 10: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇ G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 11: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇ G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 12: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇ G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 13: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem

NU(RG)(G ) ⊇ G · Z(U(RG ))

We say that G (together with the ring R) has the normalizerproperty, if

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )),

abbreviated (NP).

Page 14: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G )

conj(u) : G → G

g 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 15: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G )

conj(u) : G → Gg 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 16: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G ) conj(u) : G → G

g 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 17: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G ) conj(u) : G → G

g 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 18: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G ) conj(u) : G → G

g 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 19: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is an automorphism problem

u ∈ NU(RG)(G ) conj(u) : G → G

g 7→ gu

Set AutRG (G ) ={

conj(u) | u ∈ NU(RG)(G )}≤ Aut(G )

Lemma

(NP) holds for G ⇐⇒ AutRG (G ) = Inn(G ).

Hence we want to controlInn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Page 20: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 21: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G )

≤ A

≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}

Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 22: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G ) ≤ A ≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}

Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 23: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G ) ≤ A ≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}

Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 24: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G ) ≤ A ≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}

Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 25: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G ) ≤ A ≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 26: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Some tools

We want to control

Inn(G ) ≤ AutRG (G ) ≤ A ≤ Aut(G ).

Candidates for A:

Autc(G ) = {ϕ ∈ Aut(G ) | ∀ x ∈ G : ϕ(x) ∼G

x}

and – if G is finite and R is G -adapted –

AutCol(G ) =

{ϕ ∈ Aut(G )

∣∣∣∣ ∀ p ∀P ∈ Sylp(G ) ∃ g ∈ G :ϕ|P = conj(g)|P

∣∣∣∣

}Lemma

AutZG (G )/

Inn(G ) is an elementary-abelian 2-group. (Krempa)

AutRG (G ) ≤ Autc(G ), AutRG (G ) ≤ AutCol(G ).

Page 27: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,

finite 2-constrained groups G, where G/

O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2

(Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 28: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,

finite 2-constrained groups G, where G/

O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2

(Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 29: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,

finite 2-constrained groups G, where G/

O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2

(Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 30: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,

finite 2-constrained groups G, where G/

O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2

(Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 31: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,finite 2-constrained groups G, where G

/O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2 (Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 32: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,finite 2-constrained groups G, where G

/O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2 (Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,

periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 33: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Positive results

Theorem

(NP) holds for

X finite groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroups(Jackowski, Marciniak, 1987)

X finite groups G with R(G ) 6= 1(Li, Parmenter, Sehgal, 1999)

X finite quasi-nilpotent groups,finite 2-constrained groups G, where G

/O2(G ) has no chief

factor of order 2 (Hertweck, Kimmerle, 2001)

X locally nilpotent groups,periodic groups with normal Sylow 2-subgroup

(Jespers, Juriaans, de Miranda, Rogerio, 2002)

Page 34: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

... but

Theorem (Hertweck, 1998)

There is a metabelian group of order 225 · 972 = 315 713 650 688not satisfying (NP).

Page 35: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

... but

Theorem (Hertweck, 1998)

There is a metabelian group of order 225 · 972 = 315 713 650 688not satisfying (NP).

Page 36: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)

= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G . We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 37: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)

= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G .

We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 38: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G )

· CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G .

We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 39: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G .

We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 40: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G . We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 41: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G . We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 42: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G . We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 43: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

The normalizer problem for subgroups

NU(RG)(G ) = G · Z(U(RG )) (NP)= NG (G ) · CU(RG)(G )

Let H ≤ G . We say that H ≤ G has the normalizer property, if

NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

(NP: H ≤ G ) for short.

We say that G has the subgroup normalizer property, (SNP), if(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for all H ≤ G , i.e.

∀ H ≤ G : NU(RG)(H) = NG (H) · CU(RG)(H),

Page 44: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is again an automorphism problem

Lemma

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds ⇐⇒ AutRG (H) = AutG (H).

Where

AutRG (H) = { conj(u) ∈ Aut(H) | u ∈ NU(RG)(H) } ,AutG (H) = { conj(g) ∈ Aut(H) | g ∈ NG (H) } .

Page 45: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is again an automorphism problem

Lemma

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds ⇐⇒ AutRG (H) = AutG (H).

Where

AutRG (H) = { conj(u) ∈ Aut(H) | u ∈ NU(RG)(H) } ,AutG (H) = { conj(g) ∈ Aut(H) | g ∈ NG (H) } .

Page 46: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

is again an automorphism problem

Lemma

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds ⇐⇒ AutRG (H) = AutG (H).

Where

AutRG (H) = { conj(u) ∈ Aut(H) | u ∈ NU(RG)(H) } ,AutG (H) = { conj(g) ∈ Aut(H) | g ∈ NG (H) } .

Page 47: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on H

Remark

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds, if Out(H) = 1.

Proposition

Let H ≤ G , H be cyclic. Then (NP: H ≤ G ) holds for arbitraryrings R.

Lemma (Coleman’s lemma, relative version)

Let H ≤ G , u ∈ NU(RG)(H) and p a rational prime with p 6∈ U(R),then there exists P ≤ H, such that |H : P| <∞, p - |H : P|and x ∈ supp(u) = {g ∈ G | ug 6= 0} with xu ∈ CU(RG)(P).

Page 48: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on H

Remark

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds, if Out(H) = 1.

Proposition

Let H ≤ G , H be cyclic. Then (NP: H ≤ G ) holds for arbitraryrings R.

Lemma (Coleman’s lemma, relative version)

Let H ≤ G , u ∈ NU(RG)(H) and p a rational prime with p 6∈ U(R),then there exists P ≤ H, such that |H : P| <∞, p - |H : P|and x ∈ supp(u) = {g ∈ G | ug 6= 0} with xu ∈ CU(RG)(P).

Page 49: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on H

Remark

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds, if Out(H) = 1.

Proposition

Let H ≤ G , H be cyclic. Then (NP: H ≤ G ) holds for arbitraryrings R.

Lemma (Coleman’s lemma, relative version)

Let H ≤ G , u ∈ NU(RG)(H) and p a rational prime with p 6∈ U(R),then there exists P ≤ H, such that |H : P| <∞, p - |H : P|and x ∈ supp(u) = {g ∈ G | ug 6= 0} with xu ∈ CU(RG)(P).

Page 50: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on H

Remark

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds, if Out(H) = 1.

Proposition

Let H ≤ G , H be cyclic. Then (NP: H ≤ G ) holds for arbitraryrings R.

Lemma (Coleman’s lemma, relative version)

Let H ≤ G , u ∈ NU(RG)(H) and p a rational prime with p 6∈ U(R),then there exists P ≤ H, such that |H : P| <∞, p - |H : P|and x ∈ supp(u) = {g ∈ G | ug 6= 0} with xu ∈ CU(RG)(P).

Page 51: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 1

Theorem

( SNP) holds for locally nilpotent torsion groups G and G -adaptedrings R.

Proposition

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for G finitely generated nilpotent H ≤ G atorsion subgroup and G -adapted rings R.

Proposition

(SNP) holds for G a finitely-generated torsion-free nilpotentgroups and all rings R.

Page 52: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 1

Theorem

( SNP) holds for locally nilpotent torsion groups G and G -adaptedrings R.

Proposition

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for G finitely generated nilpotent H ≤ G atorsion subgroup and G -adapted rings R.

Proposition

(SNP) holds for G a finitely-generated torsion-free nilpotentgroups and all rings R.

Page 53: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 1

Theorem

( SNP) holds for locally nilpotent torsion groups G and G -adaptedrings R.

Proposition

(NP: H ≤ G ) holds for G finitely generated nilpotent H ≤ G atorsion subgroup and G -adapted rings R.

Proposition

(SNP) holds for G a finitely-generated torsion-free nilpotentgroups and all rings R.

Page 54: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 2

Proposition

Let G be finite metacyclic, N E G and G/

N cyclic, such that

I N is of prime order or

I G/

N is of prime order,

then (SNP) holds for G .

Proposition

(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 47.(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 659.

Page 55: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 2

Proposition

Let G be finite metacyclic, N E G and G/

N cyclic, such that

I N is of prime order or

I G/

N is of prime order,

then (SNP) holds for G .

Proposition

(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 47.(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 659.

Page 56: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Results as a question on G - 2

Proposition

Let G be finite metacyclic, N E G and G/

N cyclic, such that

I N is of prime order or

I G/

N is of prime order,

then (SNP) holds for G .

Proposition

(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 47.(SNP) holds for all groups of order at most 659.

Page 57: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

Let p be a prime and X a finite group. An automorphismϕ ∈ Aut(X ) is called p-central, if there is a Sylow p-subgroup P ofX such that ϕ|P = idP .

Proposition

Let H E G and H be a finite simple group. Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for H-adapted rings R.

Proposition

Let H be a p-constrained group with Op(H) = 1 for some prime p,and H E G or H = NG (P) for a P ∈ Sylp(G ). Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for rings R with p 6∈ R×.

Page 58: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

Let p be a prime and X a finite group. An automorphismϕ ∈ Aut(X ) is called p-central, if there is a Sylow p-subgroup P ofX such that ϕ|P = idP .

Proposition

Let H E G and H be a finite simple group. Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for H-adapted rings R.

Proposition

Let H be a p-constrained group with Op(H) = 1 for some prime p,and H E G or H = NG (P) for a P ∈ Sylp(G ). Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for rings R with p 6∈ R×.

Page 59: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

Let p be a prime and X a finite group. An automorphismϕ ∈ Aut(X ) is called p-central, if there is a Sylow p-subgroup P ofX such that ϕ|P = idP .

Proposition

Let H E G and H be a finite simple group. Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for H-adapted rings R.

Proposition

Let H be a p-constrained group with Op(H) = 1 for some prime p,and H E G or H = NG (P) for a P ∈ Sylp(G ). Then (NP: H ≤ G )holds for rings R with p 6∈ R×.

Page 60: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

The prime graph (or Gruenberg-Kegel graph) of a group X is theundirected loop-free graph Γ(X ) with

I Vertices: primes p, s.t. there exists an element of order p in X

I Edges: p and q joined iff there is an element of order pq in X

Proposition (joint with W. Kimmerle)

Assume that U is an isolated subgroup of the finite group G . ThenΓ(NV(ZG)(U)) = Γ(NG (U)).

Page 61: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

The prime graph (or Gruenberg-Kegel graph) of a group X is theundirected loop-free graph Γ(X ) with

I Vertices: primes p, s.t. there exists an element of order p in X

I Edges: p and q joined iff there is an element of order pq in X

Proposition (joint with W. Kimmerle)

Assume that U is an isolated subgroup of the finite group G . ThenΓ(NV(ZG)(U)) = Γ(NG (U)).

Page 62: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

The prime graph (or Gruenberg-Kegel graph) of a group X is theundirected loop-free graph Γ(X ) with

I Vertices: primes p, s.t. there exists an element of order p in X

I Edges: p and q joined iff there is an element of order pq in X

Proposition (joint with W. Kimmerle)

Assume that U is an isolated subgroup of the finite group G . ThenΓ(NV(ZG)(U)) = Γ(NG (U)).

Page 63: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Definition

The prime graph (or Gruenberg-Kegel graph) of a group X is theundirected loop-free graph Γ(X ) with

I Vertices: primes p, s.t. there exists an element of order p in X

I Edges: p and q joined iff there is an element of order pq in X

Proposition (joint with W. Kimmerle)

Assume that U is an isolated subgroup of the finite group G . ThenΓ(NV(ZG)(U)) = Γ(NG (U)).

Page 64: On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Ringshomepages.vub.ac.be/~abachle/slides/baechle_poznan_2014.pdf · On the Normalizers of Subgroups in Integral Group Rings Andreas

Thank you for your attention!