On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT...

37
A MANITOBA PERSPECTIVE On-Farm Research Across Time and Space Megan Bourns On-Farm Network Agronomist Manitoba Pulse and Soybean Growers

Transcript of On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT...

Page 1: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

A MANITOBA PERSPECTIVEOn-Farm Research Across Time and Space

Megan Bourns

On-Farm Network AgronomistManitoba Pulse and Soybean Growers

Page 2: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Outline

Evolving into the future

Into the Research

Overview: MPSG’s OFN

On-farm research –why do we care?

Page 3: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Why On-Farm Research?

Agronomic recommendations are generated from small plot research

• Limited seasons of data• Limited number of

locations • BUT very rigorous and

intensive data collection/analyses

Limited time and space

Page 4: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Why On-Farm Research?

On-farm research assesses outcomes across time and space

• Greater number of sites • Larger geographic range• Can be conducted over

several years• BUT limits to intensity of

data collectionOFN soybean fungicide trials 2012-2019

Identifying patterns and probability of response

require more sites in more places

Reality: each field is unique

*This drives the need for on-farm research

Page 5: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Why On-Farm Research?

Small plots: strive for uniformity

On-farm trials: encompassvariability or go within variability

At what scale are management decisions made?

Page 6: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Variability: A Field Scale Reality

The scale of your question should reflect the scale at which management decisions are made

Is the producer treating the field as one

area?

Is the producer treating

management zones

differently?To date, this is how the OFN has approached asking and answering questions

Page 7: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

MPSG’s On-Farm Journey

• MPSG began funding on-farm research in 2010

• OFN was officially launched in April 2014

• 335 trials to date

Page 8: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

WHAT:

Network of on-farm pulse and soybean research

Fully funded & directed by MB pulse and soybean growers

GOAL:

Test new products & practices for pulse and soybean

Straightforward, reliable research

By farmers, on their farms

Page 9: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Conducted on-farm, with farmersParticipatory

Produces data that are unbiased, accurate and robustPrecise

Results guide management decisions, improve productivity and profitability of the farm operation

Proactive

3 Key Principles:

Page 10: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Dataset Builders:

Common question Treatments

applicable to multiple operations

Intended to be combined across time and space

One-offs:

Very specific to one farm operation

Treatments not consistent across operations

Data from each trial stands alone

Trial Classifications

Ex. Soybean fungicide efficacy trials

Ex. Dry bean tillage system trial

Page 11: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Trial Selection

• Trial ideas develop from: Observations Questions from

producers/agronomists Discussions with

producers/agronomists• 335 trials to date 11 different types of

questions 4 different crops Range of dataset size

Page 12: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

• Inform grower decision at a farm level

On-Farm Network Research Outcomes

Page 13: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

• Inform grower decision at a farm level

• Inform management recommendations at a regional level

On-Farm Network Research Outcomes

Page 14: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

• Inform grower decision at a farm level

• Inform management recommendations at a regional level

• Investigate patterns and probabilities of response across time and space

OFN soybean fungicide trials 2012-2019

On-Farm Network Research Outcomes

Page 15: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Into the Research

Explore these trial types in more detail

New in 2020: tillage system trial, dry bean

Page 16: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Getting More from On-Farm TrialsSOYBEAN ROLLING TRIALS

OBJECTIVE: quantify the agronomic and economic impacts of soybean rolling on non-stony fields

PARTICIPANT GROUPS: MPSG, PAMI, U of M, AAFC

RolledUnrolled

Page 17: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Getting More from On-Farm TrialsSOYBEAN ROLLING TRIALS

MPSG U of M PAMI AAFC

Surface roughness scanning

Cost/economic

gain of rolling

Sediment traps,

modelling

Facilitate trial setup and

harvest

Evaluate agronomics and economics of rolling non-stony land

Page 18: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

• Have a slightly different focus, not a true replicated strip trial

• Difficult to get producers to leave multiple unrolled strips

• Even if they did…would rolled vs unrolled yield data alone really give us the best picture?

Getting More from On-Farm TrialsSOYBEAN ROLLING TRIALS

Page 19: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

• Sediment movement, surface roughness & economics of rolling are important considerations as well get this through collaboration

• On-farm trials don’t always need to be the simplest form of investigation there is room to do more, to get more

Getting More from On-Farm TrialsSOYBEAN ROLLING TRIALS

Page 20: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

On-Farm Trials: Adaptive Science

• Practical research to answer practical questions

• With on-farm trials, you can adapt your science perhaps more than in small plot research

• Room for creativity as long as scientific principles remain sound

Sound Scientific Principles

Reliable Statistical Analysis

Meaningful Results

Page 21: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Adaptive Science: An ExampleStrip-till vs. Conventional Till – Dry Beans

What’s your question?• Comparing tillage? fertility the same, tillage different• Comparing fertility? tillage the same, fertility different…OR…• Comparing systems? fertility & tillage as a package

Strip-till

Banding

Conventional Till

Broadcasting

Page 22: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Adaptive Science: An Example

Rep 5

Rep 6

Rep 3

Rep 4

Rep 1

Rep 2

Standard Trial Layout

• Randomization• Replication • Cover large field area

Comparing tillage systems:• Plan was to follow this

“traditional” randomized, replicated layout

…BUT…

• Equipment widths presented a problem

Modified Trial Layout• Randomized• Replication • Cover large field area

Page 23: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Going Deeper into the DataSOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS

OBJECTIVE: quantify the agronomic impacts of seed treatment on soybean

Page 24: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Going Deeper into the DataSOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS

OBJECTIVE: quantify the agronomic impacts of seed treatment on soybean

YIELD Disease pressure Insect pressure

Page 25: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Going Deeper into the DataSOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS

2.3 2 1.75.3 -1.4

-0.6 -0.2-2.1

-0.12.6

0.9

0.5

-0.8

0.4-0.7

-0.30.1 0.3

0.3

0.00.9 -0.4

0.2 -0.80.6 2.8

2.6

2.3

-0.1

0.4-0.2

-1.6

0.3-0.2

0.7

0.5

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

15SS

T01

15SS

T02

15SS

T03

15SS

T04

15SS

T05

15SS

T06

15SS

T07

15SS

T08

15SS

T09

15SS

T10

16SS

T01

16SS

T02

16SS

T03

16SS

T04

16SS

T05

16SS

T06

16SS

T07

16SS

T09

16SS

T10

17SS

T01

17SS

T02

17SS

T03

17SS

T04

17SS

T05

17SS

T06

17SS

T07

17SS

T08

17SS

T09

18SS

T01

18SS

T02

18SS

T03

18SS

T04

18SS

T05

18SS

T06

18SS

T07

18SS

T09

Yiel

d (b

u/ac

)

Sum of Treated - 2015 Sum of Treated - 2016 Sum of Treated - 2017Sum of Treated - 2018 Sum of Untreated - 2015 Sum of Untreated - 2016

*

**

* * * * *

*

What is driving the yield differences?

Page 26: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Going Deeper into the DataSOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS

Treated

Untreated

• Are there yield differences? What is driving those differences (or lack of differences)?

• Testing the efficacy of a seed treatment … were there pests there to begin with?

• Scouted for insects and diseases this year Assessing presence/severity of

diseases in the lab (U of M)

Page 27: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Going Deeper into the DataFUNGICIDE TRIALS

• Testing the efficacy of a fungicide treatment on soybean, pea, dry bean

• What is disease pressure like?

• SCALE issue focus your data collection Sample from a

representative transect

Page 28: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Grower-First ResearchINOCULANT TRIALS

OBJECTIVES: Single vs. Double: quantify the agronomic impacts of single inoculant (seed-applied) compared to double inoculant (seed-applied + in-furrow) in soybean

*minimum 2-year soybean history

Single vs. None: quantify the agronomic impacts of single inoculant compared with no inoculant in soybean

*minimum 3-year soybean history

New in 2019: single vs. none in dry bean

Page 29: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Grower-First ResearchINOCULANT TRIALS

Single vs. Double:(min. 2-year soybean history)

• 2 out of 35 site-years with yield response

Single vs. None:(min. 3-year soybean history)

• 0 out of 29 site-years with yield response

Page 30: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Grower-First ResearchINOCULANT TRIALS

Dry beans:Single vs. None

• No yield difference• No difference in

nodule number, position or dry bean growth/vigour

Page 31: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Grower-First ResearchINOCULANT TRIALS

• This has helped develop the check-list for single inoculation of soybean• Now would like to

develop one for no inoculation

• Eventually, develop one for dry beans?

Page 32: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Into the Research: Takeaways

Getting more from on-farm trials Collaboration facilitates a well-rounded story

On-farm trials are adaptive science

Ask practical questions, adapt scientific approach to find practical solutions

Deeper into on-farm trial data

Opportunity to be selectively intensive in data collection

Grower-first research

Finding answers for producer-centric questions

Page 33: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Evolving into the Future• Continue asking “WHY?”• More fully explain the

results of our hypotheses Collaboration Interdisciplinary

approach Selective intensification

of data collection

• Develop resources to enable producers to conduct quality on-farm research independently

Page 34: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Challenges & Opportunities

Challenges

Producer engagement

Data intensification: HOW & WHERE

Facilitating collaborations

Opportunities

Expand utility and value of on-farm data

Engage interdisciplinary collaboration

Investigate patterns & probabilities

Page 35: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

OFN Database

Page 36: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

OFN Database

Page 37: On-Farm Research Across Time and Space · Going Deeper into the Data. SOYBEAN SEED TREATMENT TRIALS. 2.3. 2. 1.7. 5.3-1.4-0.6-0.2-2.1-0.1. 2.6. 0.9. 0.5-0.8. 0.4-0.7-0.3. 0.1. 0.3.

Questions?