Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer...

22
1 The Royal Marsden Change Presentation title and date in Footer dd.mm.yyyy Women's cancers Breast cancer introduction 57 Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies – Q&A with Panel Presented by Dr Ian Chau with Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms Ramani Sitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 73 years old male Jan 12 presented with epigastric pain and weight loss of 5 pounds OGD showed ulcer in lesser curve between 42 and 46cm Biopsy showed moderately differentiated intestinal type adenocarcinoma HER2 negative Previously fit and healthy Still coaching for the London Irish Rugby Club PS=1 The Royal Marsden Staging CT T3N1

Transcript of Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer...

Page 1: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

1

The Royal Marsden

Change Presentation title and date in Footer dd.mm.yyyyWomen's cancers Breast cancer introduction 57

Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies – Q&A with Panel

Presented by Dr Ian Chau with

Mr Satvinder Mudan

Dr Sameer Zar

Dr Angela Riddell

Ms Ramani Sitamvaram

The Royal Marsden

Case history 1

– 73 years old male

– Jan 12 presented with epigastric pain and weight loss of 5 pounds

– OGD showed ulcer in lesser curve between 42 and 46cm

– Biopsy showed moderately differentiated intestinal type adenocarcinoma HER2 negative

– Previously fit and healthy Still coaching for the London Irish Rugby Club

– PS=1

The Royal Marsden

Staging CT T3N1

Page 2: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

2

The Royal Marsden

What further staging investigations would you recommend?

1) Endoscopic ultrasound

2) PET scan

3) Laparoscopy

4) Others

The Royal Marsden

Case history 1 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N1 gastric antral tumour

– Feb 12 PET/CT → T3N0M0

The Royal Marsden

Case history 1 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N1 gastric antral tumour

– Feb 12 PET/CT → T3N0M0

– Feb 12 Laparoscopy → tumour starting at level of

OGJ involving cardia and extending along lesser

curvature to the incisura

– Plan: (extended total gastrectomy)

Page 3: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

3

The Royal Marsden

What treatment would you recommend?

1) Surgery alone

2) Surgery followed by adjuvant chemotherapy

3) Surgery followed by adjuvant chemoradiation

4) Peri-operative chemotherapy

5) Neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by surgery

6) Neoadjuvant chemoradiation followed by surgery

7) OthersPlanned for EOX chemotherapy × 4 cycles followed by surgery

The Royal Marsden

Multimodality treatment in operable gastric cancer

Pre-operative

chemotherapy

Surgery

Post-operative

chemotherapy

Surgery

Post-operative

chemoradiation

Surgery

Post-operative

chemotherapy

The Royal Marsden

Multimodality treatment in operable gastric cancer

Pre-operative

chemotherapy

Surgery

Post-operative

chemotherapy

Page 4: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

4

The Royal Marsden

Neoadjuvant and peri-operative chemotherapy in OGJ and gastric cancer

– UK MAGIC trial1

– FNLCC 94012 – FFCD 9703 trial2

– EORTC 40954 trial3

1. Cunningham, et al. NEJM 2008; 2. Ychou, et al. J Clin Oncol 2011; 3. Schuhmacher et al. J Clin Oncol 2010

The Royal Marsden

MRC MAGIC Study

2-year survival

(%)

5-year survival

(%)

Median survival

(months)

CSC 50 36 24

S 41 23 20

Benefit to CSC arm 9 13 4

HR= 0.66, 95% CI: 0.53–0.81 p=0.0001

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

Time from randomisation (months)

0 12 24 36 48 60 72

163 250

190 253

Events total

CSCS

PF

S r

ate

PFS*

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

Time from randomisation (months)

0 12 24 36 48 60 72

149 250

170 253

Events totalOve

rall

su

rviv

al

rate

CSCS

Overall survival

Cunningham, et al. NEJM 2006

HR= 0.75, 95% CI: 0.60–0.93 p=0.009

The Royal Marsden

FNLCC ACCORD 07-FFCD 9703 trial

FP (q28d)5FU 800 mg/m² CI x 5

days

CDDP 100 mg/m² d1

Resectable

adenocarcinoma of the lower third oesophagus, OGJ (64%) or stomach.

Resection

FP x2/3

4-6 weeks

FP x3/4

or no treatment

4-6 weeks

Resection

n=113 n=111

Ychou, et al. J Clin Oncol 2011

5-year DFS: 19% vs 34%

5-year OS: 24% vs 38%

Page 5: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

5

The Royal Marsden

Case history 1 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N1 gastric antral tumour

– Feb 12 PET/CT → T3N0M0

– Feb 12 Laparoscopy → tumour starting at level of

OGJ involving cardia and extending along lesser

curvature to the incisura

– Plan: (extended total gastrectomy)

– Feb-Apr 2012 Enrolled into STO3 study

– Randomised to peri-operative ECX

– 14 Jun 2012 Laparoscopic total gastrectomy

The Royal Marsden

ST03 (MAGIC-B) trial design

– Primary endpoint: overall survival

– Target recruitment: 1,100 patients (80% power to detect 10% increase in 5-year survival from 40% to 50%)

ECX x3 ECX x3Surgery

Patients with resectable cancer

of type 2 and 3OGJ and stomach

(n=1,100)ECX x3

+bevacizumab

ECX x3+

bevacizumab

SurgeryBev

q3 weeksx6

The Royal Marsden

Revised STO 3 trial design

Type 2 and 3

OGJ and gastric adenocarcioma

HER 2 negative

HER 2 positive

ECX x 3 Surgery ECX x 3

ECX x 3

+Bevacizumab

SurgeryBev q3

weeks x6

ECX x 3

+Bevacizumab

To detect 10% increase in 5-yr survival from 40% to 50%; 80% power; 2-sided α=0.05

To detect HR of 0.68 with 5-yr survival of control at 30%; 80% power; 2-sided α=0.05

ECX x 3 Surgery ECX x 3

ECX x 3+

Bevacizumab

Surgery Lapatinibx18 weeks

ECX x 3+

lapatinib

n=370

n=11,000

Page 6: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

6

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2

– 58 years old female

– May 11 presented with dysphagia and backache

– OGD showed ulcerated tumour at 22cm

– Biopsy showed invasive carcinoma which in part is clearly squamous with a component of poorly differentiated adenocarcinoma- thus considered to be adenosquamous carcinoma

– PMH: hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia

– Smoked 20-30 cigarettes per day for 30 years

– Height = 162cm Weight = 51.8kg

– PS=1

The Royal Marsden

Staging CT T3N0

The Royal Marsden

What further staging investigations would you recommend?

1) Endoscopic ultrasound

2) PET scan

3) MRI scan

4) Others

Page 7: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

7

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N0 mid-oesophageal tumour

– EUS → T3N1

– Jun 11 PET/CT → T3N0M0

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N0 mid-oesophageal tumour

– EUS → T3N1

– Jun 11 PET/CT → T3N0M0

The Royal Marsden

What treatment would you recommend?

1) Surgery alone

2) Surgery followed by adjuvant chemotherapy

3) Surgery followed by adjuvant chemoradiation

4) Definitive chemoradiation alone

5) Neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by definitive

chemoradiation

6) Peri-operative chemotherapy

7) Neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by surgery

8) Neoadjuvant chemoradiation followed by surgery

9) Others

Page 8: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

8

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N0 mid-oesophageal tumour

– EUS → T3N1

– Jun 11 PET/CT → T3N0M

– Jun 11 enrolled into the SCOPE trial

The Royal Marsden

UK NCRI SCOPE trial design

– Histologically confirmed T1-4 N0-1 carcinoma of the oesophagus (adenocarcinoma or squamous cell or undifferentiated carcinoma) or Siewert Type 1 OGJ tumour or Type 2 with no more than 2 cm mucosal extension into the stomach

– Not suitable for surgery either for medical reasons or through patient choice

– Primary endpoint: Overall survival

– To detect an improvement in 2 year OS from 35% to 47.5% (Hazard Ratio [HR] =0.71) with 80% power at a 5% significance level a total of 420 patients (269 events) are required

R Cisplatin +

capecitabine

×2 cycles +

cetuximab

n=210

n=210

Cisplatin +

Capecitabine +

Conformal RT 50Gy in 25#

Cetuximab

Cisplatin +

capecitabine

× 2 cycles

Cisplatin +

Capecitabine +

Conformal RT 50Gy in 25#

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2 (cont’d)

– CT → T3N0 mid-oesophageal tumour

– EUS → T3N1

– Jun 11 PET/CT → T3N0M

– Jun 11 enrolled into the SCOPE trial

– Randomised to neoadjuvant cisplatin/capecitabine

followed by chemoradiation

– Jul-Sep 11 received neodjuvant chemotherapy × 2

cycles followed by CRT

– Weight ↓ to only 44kg

Page 9: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

9

The Royal Marsden

When would you assess response after chemoradiation?

1) Immediately following completion of

chemoradiation

2) 1 months after completion of chemoradiation

3) 3 months after completion of chemoradiation

4) 6 months after completion of chemoradiation

Planned for EOX chemotherapy × 4 cycles followed by surgery

The Royal Marsden

Case history 2 (cont’d)

– Dec 11 → CT showed favourable response

– Repeat EUS → ulcerated mucosa, no clear tumour

– Bi0psy → no evidence of residual carcinoma

– May 12 repeat OGD and biopsy → no evidence of

malignancy

– Oct 12 to Jan 13 further weight loss

– Jan 13 disease relapse in primary tumour

– Performance status too poor for further active anti-

cancer treatment

The Royal Marsden

Case 3

– Referred from Cyprus, 60yr old man

– Upper Abdominal discomfort for several months

– CT had shown dilated pancreatic duct in distal

pancreas-IPMN

– Distal pancreatectomy and splenectomy, 2009

– Positive margin

Page 10: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

10

The Royal Marsden

Case 3

– Repeated attacks of pancreatitis

The Royal Marsden

April, 2012

The Royal Marsden

Case 3, Pseudocyst and phlegmon

Page 11: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

11

The Royal Marsden

Case 4

– Male 64 yrs

– Left renal colic, October 2011

– CT mass in distal pancreas

– Ca19.9-23, CEA 7

The Royal Marsden

Case 4, Tail of pancreas with spleen and colon

invasion, October 2011

The Royal Marsden

Single liver metastasis, Oct 2011

Page 12: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

12

The Royal Marsden

Case 4

– Inoperable

– Locally advanced, vascular invasion, invasion

into splenic hilum, transverse colon

– Single liver metastasis in segment 6/9 border

– Performance status

– Very good

The Royal Marsden

Case 4

– Commenced on FOLFIRINOX

The Royal Marsden

Systemic chemotherapy in advanced pancreatic cancer:

Clinical Benefit ORR 1-year OS

Gemcitabine (n=63) 23.8% 5.4% 18%

5FU (n=63) 4.8% 0% 2%

p=0.002 p=NS p=0.002

Burris et al J Clin Oncol 1997

Page 13: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

13

The Royal Marsden

Phase III trials of gemcitabine ±cytotoxic drugs

Trial Treatment arms n Overall survival p

Median 1-year

Heinemann et al Gem/Cisplatin 95 7.5 months 25.3% 0.15

(2006) Gemcitabine 95 6.0 months 24.7%

Louvet et al Gem/Oxaliplatin 157 9.0 months 35% 0.13

(2005) Gemcitabine 156 7.1 months 28%

Rocha Lima et al Gem/Irinotecan 173 6.3 months 20% 0.789

(2004) Gemcitabine 169 6.6 months 20%

Abou-Alfa et al Gem/Exatecan 175 6.7 months 23% 0.52

(2006) Gemcitabine 174 6.2 months 21%

Oettle et al Gem/Pemetrexed 283 6.2 months 21% 0.848

(2005) Gemcitabine 282 6.3 months 20%

Heinemann et al J Clin Oncol 2006; Louvet et al J Clin Oncol 2005;

Rocha Lima et al J Clin Oncol 2004; Abou-Alfa et al J Clin Oncol 2006;

Oettle et al; Ann Oncol; 2005

The Royal Marsden

Phase III trials of gemcitabine ± platinum compounds

Trial Rx arms n RR Overall survival p

Median 1-year

Louvet et al GEM 156 17% 7.1 months 28%

(2005) GEMOX 157 27% 9.0 months 35% 0.13

Heinemann et alGEM 256 14% 6.7 months NR

(2007) GEM + PLAT 255 22% 8.3 months NR 0.031

Poplin et al GEM (30 min)275 6% 4.9 months 16%

(2009) GEM (FDR) 277 10% 6.2 months 22% 0.04

E6201 GEMOX 272 9% 5.7 months 21% 0.22

Louvet et al J Clin Oncol 2005; Heinemann et al Ann Oncol 2007;

Poplin et al J Clin Oncol 2009

The Royal Marsden

ACCORD 11/ PRODIGE 4 trial design

R

GEMCITABINE

1000mg/m2 weekly ×7 followed by 1 weeks’ rest

and then weekly ×3 q4 weeks for 6 cycles

FOLFIRINOX

Oxaliplatin 85mg/m2 & leucovorin 400mg/m2

Irinotecan 180mg/m2

5-FU 400mg/m2 bolus then 2400mg/m2 over

46 hours q2 weeks for 6 months

n=169

n=167

– Primary endpoint: overall survival

– Target recruitment: 360 patients (80% power to detect an increase in median survival from 7 to 10 months; HR=0.70; 2-sided α =0.05)

Conroy et al N Engl J Med 2011

Page 14: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

14

The Royal Marsden

FOLFIRINOX Median S(t) = 11.1 months

GEM Median S(t)= 6.8 months

ACCORD 11/PRODIGE 4: Survival

FOLFIRINOX Median PFS(t)= 6.4 months

GEM Median PFS(t)= 3.3months

Overall survival Progression free survival

Conroy et al N Engl J Med 2011

The Royal Marsden

Case 4, Tail of pancreas with vascular invasion,

January 2012

The Royal Marsden

January 2012

Page 15: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

15

The Royal Marsden

March 2012

The Royal Marsden

Case 4

– 9 cycles of FOLFIRINOX

– Proceeded to operation

– Disal pancreatectomy, splenectomy, transverse

colon

– No lesion visible on intraoperative ultrasound in

liver

The Royal Marsden

Case 4

– Liver resection based on pre-chemotherapy scans

– Histopathology- Tumour necrosis

Page 16: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

16

The Royal Marsden

Case 5

– 52 years old male

– Oct 2012 Presented with 2 months’ history of epigastric discomfort, significant weight loss of 3 stones

– Sep 2012 OGD→ polypoid mass

– Biopsies→ chronic gastritis

– PS =1

– CT→

The Royal Marsden

Peritoneal

metastases

Primary

tumour

The Royal Marsden

Case 5

– 52 years old male

– Oct 2012 Presented with 2 months’ history of epigastric discomfort, significant weight loss of 3 stones

– Sep 2012 OGD→ polypoid mass

– Biopsies→ chronic gastritis

– PS =1

– CT→ 8.5 ×6.3 cm large necrotic mass over distal pancreas connected to spleen and colon with separate peritoneal deposits

– Serum CA19-9 = 75,020

– US guided biopsy of peritoneal nodule →moderately differentiated highly desmoplastic metastatic adenocarcinoma consistent with pancreatic primary

Started on chemotherapy with FOLFIRINOX

Page 17: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

17

The Royal Marsden

Case 5

– Cycle 1 day 2 severe lethargy, retching and nausea

– Day 4 persistent vomiting, dehydration →admitted into RMH for iv hydration

– Over the next 2 days, developed large bowel obstruction

The Royal Marsden

The Royal Marsden

Case 5

– Cycle 1 day 2 severe lethargy, retching and nausea

– Day 4 persistent vomiting, dehydration →admitted into RMH for iv hydration

– Over the next 2 days, developed large bowel obstruction

– Emergency laparotomy, small bowel resection, omental resection of metastasis and formation of end ileostomy

– Slow but steady post-operative recovery

– Weight ↓ from 55kg to 43kg in six weeks

Dec 2012 commenced on GEMCAP chemotherapy

Page 18: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

18

The Royal Marsden

NCRI GEM-CAP trial in advanced pancreatic cancer

GEM GEM-CAP

ORR 12.4% 19.1% p=0.03

Cunningham et al. J Clin Oncol 2009

The Royal Marsden

Forest plot of meta-analysis of published

randomized controlled trials (including current

trial)

Cunningham et al. J Clin Oncol 2009

The Royal Marsden

1:1, stratified by KPS, region, liver metastasis

Planned N = 842

•Stage IV

•No prior treatment for

metastatic disease

•KPS ≥ 70

•Measurable disease

•Total bilirubin ≤ ULN

nab-Paclitaxel125 mg/m2 IV qw 3/4 weeks

+

Gemcitabine1000 mg/m2 IV qw 3/4 weeks

Gemcitabine1000 mg/m2 IV qw for 7/8 weeks

then qw 3/4 weeks

� Primary endpoint:

– OS

� Secondary endpoints:

– PFS and ORR by

independent review

(RECIST)

� Safety and tolerability

– by NCI CTCAE v3.0

• With 608 events, 90% power to detect OS

HR = 0.769 (2-sided α = 0.049)

• One interim analysis for futility

• Treat until progression

• CT scans every 8 weeks

MPACT Study Design

Von Hoff et al. ASCO 2013

Page 19: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

19

The Royal Marsden

Overall Survival

Von Hoff et al. ASCO 2013

The Royal MarsdenPFS by Independent Review

Von Hoff et al. ASCO 2013

The Royal Marsden

Exome sequencing of pancreatic cancer

Grimmond et al. Nature 2012

Page 20: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

20

The Royal Marsden

Exome sequencing of pancreatic cancer

Grimmond et al. Nature 2012

The Royal Marsden

The Royal Marsden

Same fate as the patients

Page 21: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

21

The Royal Marsden

Phase III trials of gemcitabine ±targeted therapy

Trial Treatment arms n Overall survival p

Median 1-year

Bramhall et al Gem/Marimastat 120 5.52 months 18% 0.70

(2002) Gem/placebo 119 5.47 months 17%

Van Cutsem et al Gem/Tipifarnib 341 6.4 months 27% 0.75

(2004) Gem/placebo 347 6.07 months 24%

Moore et al Gem/Erlotinib 285 6.24 months 23% 0.038

(2007) Gem/placebo 284 5.91 months 17%

Bramhall et al Br J Cancer 2002, Van Cutsem et al J Clin Oncol 2004;

Moore et al J Clin Oncol 2007

The Royal Marsden

NCIC GEM-Erlotinib trial

R

GEMCITABINE

1000mg/m2 weekly ×7 q8 weeks, thereafter

weekly ×3 q4 weeks

Placebo

GEM-erlotinib

Gemcitabine 1000mg/m2 weekly ×7 q8 weeks,

thereafter weekly ×3 q4 weeks

Erlotinib 100/150mg po od

n=284

n=285

Moore et al J Clin Oncol 2007

The Royal Marsden

NCIC Gem-erlotinib overall survival

Page 22: Oesophageal and pancreatic cancer case studies –Q&A with Panel · Mr Satvinder Mudan Dr Sameer Zar Dr Angela Riddell Ms RamaniSitamvaram The Royal Marsden Case history 1 – 73

22

The Royal Marsden

The Royal Marsden

Phase III trials of gemcitabine ±targeted therapy

Trial Treatment arms n mPFS mOS

(months) (months)

Van Cutsem et al Gem/Erlotinib/Bev 306 4.6 7.1

(2009) Gem/Erlotinib 301 3.6 6.0

p=0.0002 p=0.2087

Kindler et al Gem/Bev 302 3.8 5.8

(2010) Gem/placebo 300 2.9 5.9

p=0.075 p=0.95

Rougier et al Gem/Aflibercept 271 3.7 6.5

(2013) Gem/placebo 275 3.7 7.8

p=0.8645 p=0.2034

Van Cutsem et al J Clin Oncol 2009; Kindler et al J Clin Oncol 2010;

Rougier et al Eur J Cancer 2013

The Royal Marsden

Phase III trials of gemcitabine ±targeted therapy

Trial Treatment arms n mPFS mOS

(months) (months)

Kindler et al Gem/Axitinib 316 4.4 8.5

(2011) Gem/placebo 316 4.4 8.3

p=0.5203 p=0.5436

Philip et al Gem/Cetuximab 372 3.4 6.3

(2010) Gem alone 371 3.0 5.9

p=0.18 p=0.23

Kindler et al Lancet Oncol 2011; Philip et al J Clin Oncol 2010