Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ......

56
1 ON SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF TYPE Nk+M AND MATHEMATICAL CONNECTIONS WITH SOME SECTORS OF THE STRING THEORY Odoardo Volonterio 1 , Michele Nardelli 2 1 Politecnico di Milano Piazza Leonardo da Vinci, 32 20133 Milano, Italy 2 Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II, Largo S. Marcellino, 10 80138 Napoli, Italy Abstract In this work we have described a new mathematical application concerning the discrete and the analytic functions: the Volonterios Transform (V Transform) and the Volonterios Polynomial. We have descrive various mathematical applications and properties of them, precisely the series development of the type Nk+M. Furthermore, we have showed also various examples and the possible mathematical connections with some sectors of Number Theory and String Theory.

Transcript of Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ......

Page 1: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

1

ON SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: SERIES

DEVELOPMENT OF TYPE Nk+M AND MATHEMATICAL CONNECTIONS WITH

SOME SECTORS OF THE STRING THEORY

Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli

2

1 Politecnico di Milano

Piazza Leonardo da Vinci, 32

20133 Milano, Italy

2Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra

Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II, Largo S. Marcellino, 10

80138 Napoli, Italy

Abstract

In this work we have described a new mathematical application concerning the discrete and the analytic functions:

the Volonterio’s Transform (V Transform) and the Volonterio’s Polynomial. We have descrive various mathematical

applications and properties of them, precisely the series development of the type Nk+M. Furthermore, we have showed also various examples and the possible mathematical connections with some sectors of Number Theory and String Theory.

Page 2: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

2

Index

ON SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF TYPE Nk+M AND

MATHEMATICAL CONNECTIONS WITH SOME SECTORS OF THE STRING THEORY ....................................................... 1

VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF TYPE Nk+M ............................................... 4

Generalized definition of transform V .................................................................................................................... 6

Generalized definition of inverse transform V…….………………………………………………………………………………………………… 6

RELATION BETWEEN THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM, OF LAPLACE AND ZETA……………………………………………………….8

Definition and properties of the Volonterio’s polynomials……………………………………………………………………………………10

Page 3: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

3

Transformed V of a discrete periodic function…… ……………………………………………………………………………………………23

SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF THE TYPE Nk+M ......................................................................................................... 26

Assumption . ......................................................................................................................................................... 26

Proof..................................................................................................................................................................... 27

CASE 1 (N < M): ................................................................................................................................................. 31

CASE 2 (N = M) .................................................................................................................................................. 33

CASE 3 (N > M) .................................................................................................................................................. 34

PARTICULAR CASES............................................................................................................................................... 35

Case with ........................................................................................................................................ 35

Case with ........................................................................................................................ 37

EXAMPLES ............................................................................................................................................................ 37

Example 1 ......................................................................................................................................................... 37

Example 2 ......................................................................................................................................................... 38

Example 3 ......................................................................................................................................................... 39

Example 4 ......................................................................................................................................................... 40

ON SOME MATHEMATICAL CONNECTION WITH SOME SECTORS OF STRING THEORY…………………………………………..42

References…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..56

Page 4: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

4

VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF TYPE

Nk+M

Definition 1 (transformed generalized V)

The transform V of a discrete function is an analytic function of a real variable (or complex) through which it is

possible to pass from the world of discrete or finite mathematics in the world of differential mathematics.

The transformed V provides an overview higher than it can provide a generating function.

The transformed canonical is distinguished from generalized because its existence is based on continuous functions

and infinitely differentiable for t = 0 while the generalized is based on a continuous function and infinitely

differentiable at (where for we obtain obviously the transform canonical).

The properties of transformation and anti-transformation of the transform V are independent from the fact that we

consider the transformed canonical or generalized.

Definition 2 (inverse generalized transform V)

The inverse transform V of an analytic function of a real variable t continues in the zero and infinite times

differentiable at t = 0 (canonical) or at t = x (generalized) (in other words a function developable in MacLaurin

or Taylor series ) is a discrete function defined in through which it is possible the transition from the

differential world to the world of discrete or finite mathematics.

Page 5: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

5

DEFINITION OF TRANSFORM V

Let a discrete function, then we can define the transformation as follows:

(1.1)

CONDITION OF EXISTENCE AND UNIQUENESS OF THE TRANSFORM V

To ensure the condition of existence of the transform must be ensured the following relation:

(a)

where is the radius of the convergence while e is the Eulero-Nepero constant.

The relation (a) is a necessary condition that has been demonstrated exploiting the condition of the root of Cauchy-

Hadamard while the condition of uniqueness can be attributed to the properties of series of powers where e is the

Euler-Nepero constant.

Definition 1 of inverse transform V

We define with inverse transform of the discrete function obtained by the following definition:

(b)

Definition 2 of inverse transform V

Or by the following formula alternative to the (b):

(c)

where necessary and sufficient condition because (c) is valid is that is satisfied the condition where is the

radius of convergence (a).

Page 6: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

6

Definition 3 of inverse transform V

(1.2)

or, for Nk 0k (see c):

0

1 cos12

:, dkeVkktVT iR

(d)

Generalized definition of transform V

As follows, we define the generalized transformed :

1.3

Generalized definition of inverse transform V

We define as generalized inverse transform of the discrete function obtained by the following definition:

1.4

This definition is particularly useful in all those cases where the function can not exist in 0.

Another alternative definition is the following:

1.5

Page 7: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

7

Fundamental properties of the transform V

Among the generalized transform and the canonical transform, is useful to keep in mind the following identity:

1.6

1.7

1.8

Page 8: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

8

RELATION BETWEEN THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM, OF LAPLACE AND ZETA

We consider the following definitions of Gamma function, Laplace’s Transform and Zeta Transform:

1.9

we have:

1.10

thence:

1.11

1.12

but, for the left-hand side we note that:

1.13

thence:

1.14

while, for the right-hand side putting:

1.15

putting we have:

1.16

1.17

Page 9: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

9

vice versa

1.18

more generally, in the case of generalized transform V, we have:

1.19

1.20

Page 10: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

10

ADDITIONAL DEFINITIONS

In order to read and interpret tables in complete sense clarifications is needed on the functions and abbreviations

that have been introduced and also will be essential of the examples that follow after the tables. In any case, before

proceeding to the list of transformations is useful to consider the following relations, definitions and functions.

Definition of operator

With the symbol we define the following operator:

(1.21)

where its application iterated n times on a determined function is expressed by the operator of the application

in the following way

for example, we consider ttV sin ,thence:

Definition and properties of the Volonterio’s polynomials

(1.22)

other formulas to determine the polynomial (see TF N° 4 and 20) are the following:

(1.23)

or by the following recursive formulas:

(1.24)

(1.25)

or:

(1.26)

From the above definition, by the Volonterio’s transform:

Page 11: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

11

(1.27)

Definition of Bernoulli’s Polynomial:

The Bernoulli’s polynomial (see TF N° 21) is:

(1.28)

The generating function of the Bernoulli’s polynomial is:

(1.29)

Definition of Eulero’s Polynomial: Eulero’s Polynomial (see TF N° 22):

(1.30)

The generating function of the Eulero’s polynomial is:

(1.31)

Definition of Laguerre’s Polynomial:

Laguerre’s Polynomial (see TF N° 15 and N° 23)

(1.32)

Definition of the Bessel’s Polynomial of the first kind:

(1.33)

Definition of the Hermite’s Polynomial

(1.34)

Page 12: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

12

PROPERTIES OF THE TRANSFORM V

PF

N.

Function

Definition

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

Page 13: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

13

TRANSFORMATION V OF SOME KNOWN FUNCTIONS

TF

N.

Function

Definition

1

2 (idem for 1)

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

Page 14: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

14

TRANSFORMATION V OF SOME KNOWN FUNCTIONS

TF

N.

Function

Definition

23

24

25

26

27

28

with

29

Page 15: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

15

FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF THE INVERSE TRANSFORM V

PA

N.

Function

Definition

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

Page 16: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

16

INVERSE TRANSFORM OF KNOWN FUNCTIONS

AF

N.

Function

Definition

1 1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

GENERALIZED TRANSFORMATION OF NOTE FUNCTIONS

GTF

N.

Function

Definition

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Page 17: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

17

GENERALIZED TRANSFORMATION OF NOTE FUNCTIONS

GTF

N.

Function

Definition

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

with

Page 18: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

18

GENERALIZED TRANSFORMATION OF NOTE FUNCTIONS

GTF

N.

Function

Definition

29

30

Page 19: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

19

GENERALIZED INVERSE TRANSFORMATION OF NOTE FUNCTIONS

GAF

N.

Function

Definition

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

Page 20: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

20

From the GAF n.16, we observe:

1.35

Where, especially, if we want to use this property we must remember to run the rest of the calculations with a seed

equivalent based on the properties (1.6), (1.7) and (1.8).

1.36

1.37

Page 21: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

21

Example

PROBLEM

Solve the following equation to the finite difference of the 2nd order.

(1.38)

Now, to solve such a simple equation to the finite difference of the second order homogeneous with constant

coefficients may be used various methods, including the method of the generating function and the method using

the transform realized here.

* * * * *

SOLUTION

a) METHOD OF THE GENERATING FUNCTION

We consider the following generating function:

(1.39)

(1.40)

(1.41)

(1.42)

(1.43)

taking into account the following observations:

(1.44)

From which we get the new generating function (have already been considered the initial conditions):

(1.45)

Page 22: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

22

b)RESOLVING METHOD BY TRANSFORMED V

Calling with T this transformation from the variable to the variable and placing with

, we obtain:

(1.46)

(1.47)

The characteristic equation associated is:

(1.48)

i.e., the solution of the differential equation with the initial settings is:

(1.49)

where now anti-transform, obtaining the solution searched:

(1.50)

Page 23: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

23

Transformed V of a discrete periodic function:

Let be a particular discrete function in which is valid the following relation:

1.51

Thanks to the Fourier series in the discrete domain:

1.52

we can apply the transformation V to the (1.52) as in (1.53):

1.53

for the transformations tables, we obtain:

1.54

1.55

1.56

Now replacing of the (1.52) in the eq. (1.56) we obtain the eq. (1.57):

1.57

1.58

Page 24: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

24

thence expanding the term ,we obtain:

1.59

Now, for the same definition of transformed we have:

1.60

i.e. for thence e namely:

1.61

1.62

from which we deduce the following relations:

1.63

1.64

In the particular case where the period N of the periodic discrete function is very large or even tending to infinity, we

proceed as follows:

Page 25: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

25

where the step is namely thence rewrite the (1.63) as follows:

1.65

and for we have thence rewrite the eq. (1.65) as follows:

(1.66)

i.e.:

(1.67)

Given that is the transformed of , we obtain the equality:

(1.68)

from which, we have that:

(1.69)

(1.70)

Page 26: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

26

SERIES DEVELOPMENT OF THE TYPE Nk+M

Assumption The intent is to find a form equivalent to the infinite sum below with and :

(2.1)

We will solve this problem by using the Volonterio’s Transform.

In these proofs and examples we will consider the convergence problem inherent in the solutions and criteria

adopted.

Page 27: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

27

Proof

Consider the following examples with and needed to understand the proof that will follow, where

is a discrete periodic function of value 1, of period shifted by M.

Table 1

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

4 7 10 13 16 19 22 25 28 31 34

Table 2

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35

0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0

Thence for the (2.0) and to the Tables 1 and 2 where the relation between and is we obtain the

following Table:

Table 3

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

-4/3 -1 -2/3 -1/3 0 1/3 2/3 1 4/3 5/3 2

0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

With the Table 3 is easy to understand the following equivalence:

(2.2)

Now for the definition (1) of the Volonterio’s Transform, we can write the following relation (see tables and

definitions attached):

(2.3)

Of course the relation (2.3) is the one that will lead us to obtain the generalized solution of the expression (2.1).

Page 28: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

28

We consider the following known relationship [A.V. Oppenheim R.W. Schafer – Elaborazione numerica dei segnali (Digital Signal Processing) –

Franco Angeli Editions]:

(2.4)

and more in general with M

N we define the following expression:

(2.5)

of the (2.4) we must narrow the field to only non-negative integers, namely the (2.4) there must return the zero for

each integer value negative, so we have to rewrite (2.4) as follows:

(2.6)

where is a step discrete function of Heaviside defined as:

(2.7)

furthermore, we observe that:

(2.8)

Now placing we deduce the discrete function

(2.9)

and then through the observation (2.8):

(2.10)

Or the equivalent expression:

(2.11)

Page 29: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

29

So to utilize the transformed V is useful to rewrite (2.10) in the following way:

(2.12)

then we can rewrite the relation (2.3) as follows:

and thence:

(2.13)

From the PF N. 9 which is given here for convenience:

(2.14)

we have:

(2.15)

While for the PF N.5 which is given here with :

(2.16)

and thence:

(2.17)

We obtain finally the following equivalence:

(2.18)

To facilitate the understanding of the examples that follow will call with

Page 30: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

30

and with :

manipulating the in the following way:

(2.19)

we observe that the inside bracket of the (2.19) is precisely the function

(2.20)

Page 31: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

31

CASE 1 (N < M):

Example 1.1: where k goes from 0 to 3

-2 -1 0 1

-2 1 4 7

1 1 1 1

/ / /

thence:

(2.21)

Example 1.2: with k from 0 to 10:

-3 -2 -1 0 1

-1 3 7 11 15

1 1 1 1 1

/

/ /

thence:

(2.22)

Page 32: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

32

Example 1.3: where k goes from 0 to 9

-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3

-2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

/

/ / / /

thence:

(2.23)

Page 33: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

33

CASE 2 (N = M)

Example 2.1: where k goes from 0 to 4

-2 -1 0 1 2 3

-5 0 5 10 15 20

1 1 1 1 / /

/ / / / /

thence:

(2.24)

Example 2.2: where goes from 0 to 6

-2 -1 0 1 2 3

-7 0 7 14 21 28

1 1 1 1 / /

/ / / / /

thence:

(2.25)

Page 34: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

34

CASE 3 (N > M):

Example 3.1: where k goes from 0 to 4

-2 -1 0 1 2 3

-9 -2 5 12 19 26

1 1 1 1 1 1

/ / / / / /

thence:

(2.26)

***

In general from these observations by induction we conclude for deduction the following equivalence:

(2.27)

Where with represent the function that returns the integer part of , and then we can rewrite the (2.18) in a

simpler form:

(2.28)

where if and in particular for 0M we have thence:

(2.29)

Page 35: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

35

PARTICULAR CASES

Case with

Case with :

(2.30)

It can be shown easily from (2.2) and (2.3) that the function satisfies the following differential equation:

(2.31)

thence:

(2.32)

we have for the TF N.2 , furthermore we have:

(2.33)

thence:

(2.34)

after several steps we obtain:

(2.35)

where here we separate the real part from the imaginary part:

(2.36)

it follows:

Page 36: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

36

(2.37)

and thence:

(2.38)

In particular for we have:

(2.39)

From 2.33 it is shown that:

and

Putting we obtain

but and thence

Page 37: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

37

Case with

Rewriting the eq. (2.18) as follows:

(2.40)

in this eq. we replacing the following expression and thence

(2.41)

***

EXAMPLES

Example 1

Calculate

Solution

We consider with N=2 and M=1 and we replace in the (2.41) obtaining:

(2.42)

the third summation of the (2.42) is null because M<M, thence:

but

then we proceed in the steps:

Page 38: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

38

(2.43)

(2.44)

(2.45)

(2.46)

for the TF.5 we have:

(2.47)

(2.48)

Example 2 Calculate . We shall see how in this example the Volonterio’s polynomials lend themselves to providing a

generalized solution of this problem.

Solution

In this case is M=0 thus the last term of the (2.30) is null:

(2.49)

For the TF. N.4 we obtain:

Page 39: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

39

(2.50)

where is the Volonterio’s polynomial of order n.

Putting and we have :

(2.51)

(2.52)

(2.53)

Here we can connect with the Ramanujan’s equation concerning the number 8, that is a Fibonacci’s

number and is linked to the physical vibrations of the superstrings, i.e.

ttttt

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

tkWw

wt

wx

sinh1cosh3

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

1/1, 2

2

'

'4

0

'

32

0

2

2

. (2.53b)

Example 3

Calculate .

Solution

(2.54)

(2.55)

Page 40: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

40

(2.56)

(2.57)

Now to calculate the transform, we use the TF No. 17:

(2.58)

Thence:

(2.59)

After some calculations we have:

(2.60)

Example 4

Calculate

Solution

We'll see how this example is related to the Laguerre’s polynomials.

(2.61)

(2.62)

(2.63)

from the TF N. 15 we have:

(2.64)

then replacing:

Page 41: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

41

(2.65)

Putting N=2 and M=3 we have :

(2.66)

(2.67)

(2.68)

(2.69)

(2.70)

This last equation can be connected with the Euler Gamma Function and with the number linked to the physical

vibrations of the bosonic strings, i.e. 24.

Indeed, with regard the number 24, this is related to the “modes” that correspond to the physical vibrations of the

bosonic strings by the following Ramanujan function:

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

24

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

.

Thence, we have the following expression:

Page 42: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

42

tttttt

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

tk

kW

w

wt

wx

sinh96cosh18

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

:,42

72 23

2

'

'4

0

'

3

2

2

2

.

(2.70b)

ON SOME MATHEMATICAL CONNECTION WITH SOME SECTORS OF STRING THEORY

In 1968 Veneziano proposed the following heuristic answer

ts

tstsA

,

(3.1)

with ss '0 .

Euler Gamma function has poles in the negative real axis at integer values ns

with residue

nsnssss

ns

s

ss

1...21

11

nsn

nns

1

!

1

(3.2)

Hence, at fixed t , the amplitude has infinitely many poles at ,0s

for nss '0

or

2

'

0nM

ns

(3.3)

with residue

Page 43: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

43

nsn

nttt

nstn

t

ntsA

nns

1

!

...211

!

1,4

. (3.4)

In the bosonic string the simplest vertex operator is the one for the tachyon state 0N hence '/42 M .

We have:

pzzzVdgzedgp s

Xip

s ;,;0 22V. (3.5)

With regard the 4-point tachyon amplitude, we have the following equation:

lj

pp

lj

m

i

i

m

s

i

iii

m lj

zzzdCSLVol

gpp

'

1

22

,2,

. (3.6)

Setting 4m we end up with

lj

pp

lj

i

is

i

iii

lj

zzzdCSLVol

gpp

'4

1

22

4

,2,

. (3.7)

After fixing the CSL ,2 invariance by putting the insertion points at z,1,0 and 4z

we end up with

3231 ''224 1pppp

i

is zzzdpg

(3.8)

using Gamma function identities this expression can be given a nice form. One must use the integral representation

cba

cbazzzd

ba

111

21

22222

(3.9)

where 1 cba . With this, (3.8) can be shown to be equal to

4/'24/'24/'2

4/'14/'14/'124

uts

utspg

i

is

(3.10)

in terms of the Mandelstam variables

Page 44: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

44

221 pps ;

232 ppt ;

241 ppu (3.11)

which satisfy on shell (i.e. use the tachyon mass '/422 Mpi )

4

1

22

'

16

i

ii Mputs (3.12)

We can write also the following mathematical connection:

3231 ''224 1pppp

i

is zzzdpg

4/'24/'24/'2

4/'14/'14/'12

uts

utspg

i

is

4

1

22

'

16

i

ii Mp (3.13)

This expression can be related with the following Ramanujan’s modular equation linked with the “modes” (i.e. 8 that

is also a Fibonacci’s number) that correspond to the physical vibrations of the superstrings:

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

18

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

. (3.14)

Thence, we have the following relationship:

3231 ''224 1pppp

i

is zzzdpg

4/'24/'24/'2

4/'14/'14/'12

uts

utspg

i

is

4

1

22

'

16

i

ii Mp

Page 45: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

45

4

2710

4

21110log'

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

12

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

. (3.15)

We note that this relationship ca be related also with the eq. (d), i.e. the inverse transform of tV

, thence we

obtain this further mathematical connection:

0

1 cos12

:, dkeVkktVT iR

3231 ''22 1pppp

i

is zzzdpg

4/'24/'24/'2

4/'14/'14/'12

uts

utspg

i

is

4

1

22

'

16

i

ii Mp

4

2710

4

21110log'

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

12

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

. (3.15b)

b)the open string scattering

With regard the open string scattering, the amplitude is computed with operator insertions along the boundary of

the disk which maps onto the real axis of the complex plane. The equation of the amplitude is:

4

1

ˆˆ4 4111 ...,2 i

xXipxXip

is eedx

RSLVol

g

4

1

'226

,2 i

pp

lj

jii

i

is ji

xxdxpRSLVol

g

.

(3.16)

For a given ordering, the residual symmetry can be used to fix 3 points to xxxx 321 ,0,0

and 4x . The

resulting expression contains a single integration for 10 x

Page 46: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

46

1

0

'2'24 32211

pppp

s xxdxg

. (3.17)

This integral is related to the Euler Beta function (thence with the Euler Gamma function)

1

0

11 1,ba

baxdxxbaB

ba

. (3.18)

Whence, using now the tachyon mass '/12 M one recovers the Veneziano amplitude

ts

tsgs

'1

'1'14

. (3.19)

Thence, we have the following possible mathematical relationship between 3.16), (3.17) and (3.19):

4

1

ˆˆ4 4111 ...,2 i

xXipxXip

is eedx

RSLVol

g

4

1

'226

,2 i

pp

lj

jii

i

is ji

xxdxpRSLVol

g

1

0

'2'2 32211

pppp

s xxdxg

ts

tsgs

'1

'1'1

. (3.20)

Also this relationship can be related with eq. (d), thence we obtain this further mathematical connection:

0

1 cos12

:, dkeVkktVT iR

4

1

ˆˆ4111 ...

,2 i

xXipxXip

is eedx

RSLVol

g

4

1

'226

,2 i

pp

lj

jii

i

is ji

xxdxpRSLVol

g

1

0

'2'2 32211

pppp

s xxdxg

ts

tsgs

'1

'1'1

. (3.20b)

c) Four point amplitude for the tachyons from CFT

The ground state tachyons in the twisted sector corresponds to:

Page 47: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

47

N

kM 12

(3.21)

For the near marginal tachyons, in the large N limit, which are in the thkN sector, the vertex operator in the

1,1 representation is,

zzeeeeezzV xikzH

N

kizH

N

ki

,, .

~11~

1,1

. (3.22)

The four point amplitude for these lowest lying tachyons can now be computed by taking two vertices in the

0,0representation and two in the 1,1 representation.

C

FFFF VTeTezzVVTeTezzVzdC 0~

,1~

, 1,1

~

1,11,1

~

1,1

2

. (3.23)

The constant 24

scCgC , where

2

sCis related to cg

by

2

2 4

c

sg

C

. (3.24)

This amplitude can now be computed and is given by,

C

ts

zF

zzzdkkCI

2

22

22

31

1.

, (3.25)

where zF is the hypergeometric function,

1

0

111

1;1;1, N

k

N

kN

k

yzydyyzN

k

N

kFzF

, (3.26)

and 221 kks , 232 kkt , 213 kks

.

Page 48: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

48

In the large N approximation,

232 /...3

1

2

11 NkOzzz

N

kzF

. (3.27)

Note that the terms proportional to Nk / in (3.27) shift the s-channel pole. There is an additional factor of 221.kk ,

due to which the contact term from any of the terms of (3.27) apart from 1, would at least be of 2/ NkO . With this

observation, the integral can now be performed for 1zF .

21

21

22

221

22.2

2

31 tsts

tsts

kkCI

21

21

221

221

21

21

112

4

14

2222

tsts

tsts

tsmugc

. (3.28)

Now using 24muts ,

21

21

221

221

21

21

8322

4 2

222222

tsts

tsts

mtst

ms

s

mtgI c

. (3.29)

where we have to expand the gamma functions.

Also here we can write the following relationship between (3.25) and (3.29):

C

ts

zF

zzzdkkCI

2

22

22

31

1.

Page 49: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

49

21

21

221

221

21

21

8322

4 2

222222

tsts

tsts

mtst

ms

s

mtgc

(3.30)

Also this expression can be related with the eq. (d) and with the Ramanujan’s modular equation concerning the

number 8 and thence, we obtain this further mathematical connection:

0

1 cos12

:, dkeVkktVT iR

C

ts

zF

zzzdkkC

2

22

22

31

1.

21

21

221

221

21

21

8322

4 2

222222

tsts

tsts

mtst

ms

s

mtgc

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

1

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

(3.30b)

d) expressions concerning the four tachyon amplitude in CSFT

With regard a closed analytical expression for the off-shell four tachyon amplitude in CSFT, Giddings gave an explicit

conformal map that takes the Riemann surfaces defined by the Witten diagrams to the standard disc with four

tachyon vertex operators on the boundary. This conformal map is defined in terms of four parameters ,,, .

The four parameters are not independent variables. They satisfy the relations

1 , 1

(3.31)

and

kk ,,2

12010

, (3.32)

where k,0

is defined by

Page 50: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

50

',',',2

,0 kFkKkEkKkFkEk

. (3.33)

In (3.33) kK and kE are complete elliptic functions of the first and second kinds, kF , is the incomplete elliptic

integral of the first kind. The parameters k,, 21 and 'k satisfy

2

22

k

, 22 1' kk , (3.34)

22

2

1

2sin

, 22

2

2

2sin

. (3.35)

By using the integral representations of the elliptic functions it is possible to write the equation (3.32) in a useful

form

41

11

1

1/ /

3242

24

242

2

tt

dtKtt

dtE

. (3.36)

To expand (3.36) for small

and we have to divide the integration region into three intervals in such a way that

the square roots in the denominators of (3.36) can be consistently expanded and the integrals in t performed. For

example consider the integral in the first term of (3.36) , it can be rewritten as

/ 1 /

1

22

422

2

42

4

22

242

2

2

111

1

11

1

11

1

1

1

ttt

dt

tt

t

dt

tt

dttt

dt

(3.37)

In each integral of the rhs the integration domain is contained in the convergence radius of the Taylor expansions of

the square roots containing

, so that they can be safely expanded and the integrals in t performed. With this

procedure one gets the following equation equivalent to (3.36):

0,

2

12

4

2

2 1122

2

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

kn

kn

k

n

k

knknkn

E

Page 51: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

51

0,

2

12

4242444

122

1

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

2

1

1ln22 kn

k

n

kn

kn

kn

knknkn

Knk

4322

1ln

221

2

32

42444

n

k

nn

kn

kn

knknnk

(3.38)

Thence, from (3.36) and (3.38) we can write the following mathematical relationship:

/ /

3242

24

242

2

1

11

1

1

tt

dtKtt

dtE

0,

2

12

4

2

2 1122

2

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

kn

kn

k

n

k

knknkn

E

0,

2

12

4242444

122

1

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

2

1

1ln22 kn

k

n

kn

kn

kn

knknkn

Knk

4322

1ln

221

2

32

42444

n

k

nn

kn

kn

knknnk

. (3.39)

Also this expression can be related with the eq. (d), and thence we obtain this further mathematical connection:

0

1 cos12

:, dkeVkktVT iR

/ /

3242

24

242

2

1

11

1

1

tt

dtKtt

dtE

Page 52: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

52

0,

2

12

4

2

2 1122

2

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

kn

kn

k

n

k

knknkn

E

0,

2

12

4242444

122

1

!!2

1

2

1

2

1

2

1

1ln22 kn

k

n

kn

kn

kn

knknkn

Knk

4322

1ln

221

2

32

42444

n

k

nn

kn

kn

knknnk

(3.40)

e) physical interpretation of the nontrivial zeta zeros in terms of tachyonic string poles

The four-point dual string amplitude obtained by Veneziano was

RBxxdxsuAstAtsAA

,1,,,

11

4, (3.41)

where the Regge trajectories in the respective uts ,, channels are:

ss2

11

, tt

2

11

, uu

2

11

. (3.42)

The conservation of the energy-momentum yields:

043214321 kkkkkkkk. (3.43)

We have also that the sum

822 313221

2

3

2

2

2

1 kkkkkkkkkuts (3.44)

in mass units of m Planck = 1, when all the four particles are tachyons and one has the on-shell condition:

Page 53: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

53

22

3

2

2

2

1 mkkk

– 2m2Planck = – 2 (3.45)

in the natural units LPlanck = 1 such that the string slope parameter in those units is given by L2Planck = 1/2 and the

string mass spectrum is quantized in multiplies of the Planck mass mPlanck = 1.

From the conservation of energy-momentum (3.43) and the tachyon on-shell condition eq. (3.45) one can deduce

that:

4321

2

43

2

21 kkkkkkkk . (3.46)

Therefore, from eqs. (3.44) – (3.46) it is straightforward to show:

4332121321 21222222 kkkkkkkkkkuts

8412212212 33334321 kkkkkkkk (3.47)

This relationship among 84 2 muts will be crucial in what follows next. From eqs. (3.42), (3.44), and (3.47)

we learn that:

1 . (3.48)

There exists a well-known relation among the functions (Euler Gamma function) in terms of

functions

(Riemann zeta function) appearing in the expression for utsA ,,

when ,

fall inside the critical strip. In this

case, the integration region in the real line that defines utsA ,,

in eq. (3.41) can be divided into three parts and

leads to the very important identity

111,,, ButsA

(3.49)

where 1 and ,

are confined to the interior of the critical strip.

The derivation behind eq. (3.49) relies on the condition 1 eq. (3.48) and the identities

Page 54: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

54

2

cos2

cos2

cos4sinsinsin

, (3.50)

sin

11

, (3.51)

plus the remaining cyclic permutations from which one can infer

sin

, (3.52)

sin

, (3.53)

sin

. (3.54)

Therefore, eqs. (3.50) – (3.54) allow us to recast the left hand side of (3.49) as

2cos

2cos

2cos

4,,, ButsA

. (3.55)

And, finally, the known functional relation

zzz

zz

2

cos212, (3.56)

in conjunction with the condition 1 such that

22

is what establishes the important identity

(3.49) expressing explicitly the string amplitude utsA ,, either in terms of zeta functions or in terms of functions.

In conclusion, we have the following interesting relationship between the eqs. (3.41), (3.49) and (3.55):

RBxxdxsuAstAtsAA

,1,,,

11

4

Page 55: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

55

111,,, ButsA

2cos

2cos

2cos

4

, (3.57)

from which we can to obtain the following equivalent expression:

RBxxdxA

,

4

11

4

1

4

1 11

4

8cos

8cos

8cos

1

(3.58)

In this expression there are both π and 8, i.e. the number that is connected with the “modes” that correspond to the

physical vibrations of a superstring by the following Ramanujan function:

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

18

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

. (3.59)

Thence the final mathematical connection:

RBxxdxA

,

4

11

4

1

4

1 11

4

8cos

8cos

8cos

1

4

2710

4

21110log

'

142

'

cosh

'cos

log4

3

1

2

'

'4

0

'

2

2

wtitwe

dxex

txw

anti

w

wt

wx

(3.60)

Page 56: Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 SOME APPLICATIONS OF THE VOLONTERIO’S TRANSFORM: ... Odoardo Volonterio1, Michele Nardelli2 1 ... VOLONTERIO’S TRANFORM GENERALIZED AND SERIES

56

References

Odoardo Volonterio, Michele Nardelli, Francesco Di Noto – “On a new mathematical application concerning

the discrete and the analytic functions. Mathematical connections with some sectors of Number

Theory and String Theory”. Feb- 2014 http://empslocal.ex.ac.uk/people/staff/mrwatkin//zeta/nardelli2014.pdf