Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation …...Idaho Power Company, 2. Weather Modification...
Transcript of Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation …...Idaho Power Company, 2. Weather Modification...
A Comparison of Weather and Research Forecast Model Precipitation Forecasts versus Observed SNOTEL Precipitation
V. Holbrook1, M, Kunkel1, D. Blestrud1, S. Parkinson1, A. Edwards2, B. Waller 2, L. Rasley 3 1. Idaho Power Company, 2. Weather Modification Incorporated 3. Boise State University
Water Year Precipitation Results
WRF versus SNOTEL/Geonor Precipitation Observations
Data
Cumulative seasonal WRF 24-hour precipitation forecasts are accurate with the following exceptions: Elevation of model forecast point is much lower/higher than SNOTEL or other complex terrain issues.
Cloud seeding is being conducted. SNOTEL observation errors: SNOTEL precipitation gauges become capped during periods of wet snow. Some SNOTEL pillow errors are: Melt at beginning and ending of season. Blowing and drifting snow. Ice covered pillow where new precipitation will not stay on the pillow.
In the river basins affected by cloud seeding (Payette, Boise, and Upper Snake), the model did not account for cloud seeding and underestimated the amount of precipitation. Average error for SNOTELs outside of these basins for WYs 2013-2015 was 5% (overestimation) while the average for the SNOTELS in the Payette was -7% (underestimation). The delta in precipitation of 12% is similar to the ongoing results of an IPC target/control analysis...most of which is related to the IPC cloud seeding program.
The daily (midnight to midnight) WRF-GFS forecast precipitation values were accumu-
lated from Nov 1 through Mar 31. WRF-NAM forecast data was used to augment the
data if WRF-GFS model runs were not available. In Water Year 2012, WRF used the
WDM6 microphysics scheme but with upgrade to WRF version 3.3.1 the microphysics
changed to SBU-YLIN for the subsequent years. Table 1 shows the sum of the error by
year for precipitation forecasts for the SNOTEL sites. Both Water Years 2012 and 2014
had similar precipitation but there was a major reduction in error most likely related to
the different microphysics package. SNOTEL data was obtained from the NRCS web-
site.
IPC has installed 7 high resolution Geonor precipitation gauges in the Payette River basin...three of which are collocated with SNOTEL gauges. Figure 2 (Deadwood Summit) and 3 (Brundage Basin) are observed and forecast data for the first 15 days of December 2015. Deadwood Summit: No significant difference between SNOTEL pillow and IPC Geonor gauges. SNOTEL precipitation gauge capped with first storm. WRF-GFS 50%+ underestimation...model not compensating for seeding effect.
Brundage Basin: WRF-GFS forecast over 2 inches more than observed at the SNOTEL precipitation gauge. SNOTEL pillow data even farther behind due to ice covered pillow with wet snow not staying on pillow on Dec 7
th.
Since model precipitation was close to observed precipitation before Dec 7th,
Introduction
Figure 2. Observed minus WRF-GFS forecast precipitation for SNOTELs in the Snake River Plain for Nov1 through Mar 31 in WYs 2012-2015. Positive values indicate model forecast precipitation greater than
Table 1. WRF and observed SNOTEL average precipitation for all 89 SNOTEL sites in the Snake River basin and percent error for the four water years.
Water Year WRF (in) Observed (in) % Error
2012 22.49 19.33 16.3
2013 17.14 16.87 1.6
2014 20.82 20.02 4.0
2015 16.96 16.98 -0.2
Figures 3 and 4. Deadwood Summit/Brundage Basin WRF forecast and observed precipitation for first two weeks of December 2015
The Idaho Power Company (IPC) Atmospheric Science group is responsible for weather support to IPC Load Service Operations, Operations Hydrology, Stream Gauging, and Reliability groups. The support consists of cloud seeding operations and forecasts, temperature and precipitation forecasts for the River Forecast System (RFS), wind farm power forecasts, load and solar forecasts, and forensic meteorology. IPC is a hydroelectric based utility serving customers throughout southern Idaho
and eastern Oregon. Knowledge of the winter snowpack is critical to IPC opera-
tions and the company uses the RFS model to predict flows along the Snake
River to optimize hydroelectric operations. A significant portion of the observa-
tion network in the mountains is from 89 SNOw TELemetry (SNOTEL) sites
(Figure 1) spread across a 6 state region. The RFS also uses 6 hourly forecasts
of temperature and precipitation obtained from a 1.8 kilometer resolution
Weather and Research Forecast (WRF) model run at the University of Arizona.
Discussion of Water Year Graphs
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
P
r
e
c
i
p
i
t
a
t
i
o
n
(
i
n)
Day
IPC Met Gauge Precip SNOTEL Precipitation Gauge SNOTEL Pillow WRF-GFS Precipitation
Deadwood SummitWRF Model Forecast and Observed Precipitation (Dec 2015)
Brundage BasinWRF Model Forecast and Observed Precipitation (Dec 2015)
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
P
r
e
c
i
p
i
t
a
t
i
o
n
(
i
n)
SNOTEL Precipitation Gauge SNOTEL Pillow WRF-GFS Precipitation
Figure 1. Location of SNOTELs used in IPC RFS model.
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
Cozy
Cov
eBa
nner
Sum
mit
Dead
woo
d Su
mm
itM
ores
Cre
ek Su
mm
it
Atlan
ta Su
mm
itGr
aham
Gua
rd S
ta.
Gale
naGa
lena
Sum
mit
Jack
son
Peak
Trin
ity M
tn.
Vien
na M
ine
Crab
Cre
ekIsl
and
Park
Lake
view
Rid
geW
hite
Elep
hant
Blin
d Bu
ll Su
mBa
se C
amp
Gras
sy L
ake
Lew
is La
ke D
ivide
Philli
ps B
ench
Snak
e Ri
ver S
tatio
nSlu
g Cre
ek D
ivide
Big C
reek
Bear
Bas
inBr
unda
ge R
eser
voir
Bear
Sadd
leBo
stet
ter R
.S.
Cam
as C
reek
Divi
deDo
llarh
ide
Sum
mit
Garfi
eld
R.S.
Give
out
Hilts
Cre
ekHo
wel
l Can
yon
Hynd
man
Long
Vall
eyCh
ocol
ate
Gulch
Lost
-Woo
d Divi
deM
ud Fl
atM
agic
Mou
ntain
Mill
Cree
k Sum
mit
Oxfo
rd Sp
ring
Prair
ieSo
ldie
r R.S
.Se
cesh
Sum
mit
Sedg
wick
Pea
kSo
uth M
tn.
Som
sen
Ranc
hSh
eep M
tn.
Squa
w Fl
atSt
ickne
y Mill
Swed
e Pea
kVa
n W
yck
Wes
t Bra
nch
Wild
hors
e Di
vide
Wils
on C
reek
Aner
oid L
ake
Blue
Mou
ntain
Spr
ing
Bow
man
Sprin
gsBo
urne
Coun
ty Li
neEil
erts
on M
eado
ws
Emigr
ant S
prin
gsFis
h Cr
eek
Gold
Cen
ter
High
Rid
geLa
ke Cr
eek R
.S.
Luck
y Str
ikeM
t. Ho
war
dM
oss S
prin
gsSc
hnei
der M
eado
ws
Silvie
sTip
ton
Taylo
r Gre
enW
olf C
reek
Bear
Cre
ekBi
g Ben
dBu
cksk
in L
ower
Draw
Cre
ekDi
sast
er P
eak
Gran
ite P
eak
Jack
Cre
ek U
pper
Lam
ance
Cre
ekPo
le Cr
eek R
.S.
Seve
ntys
ix Cr
eek
Taylo
r Can
yon
Gros
Ven
tre S
umm
itSa
lt Ri
ver S
umm
itTo
gwot
ee Pa
ssTo
uche
t
I
n
c
h
e
s
SNOTEL
Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation (in) for SNOTELs in Water Year 2015
Eastern Idaho
SNOTELS located in Cloud Seeding Regions
Payette Boise
Idaho Oregon Nevada Wyoming
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
Cozy
Cove
Bann
er Su
mmit
Dead
wood
Summ
itMo
res C
reek
Summ
it
Atlan
ta Su
mmit
Grah
am Gu
ard St
a.Ga
lena
Galen
a Sum
mit
Jackso
n Pe
akTri
nity M
tn.
Vienn
a Mine
Crab
Cree
kIsl
and P
arkLa
kevie
w Rid
geW
hite E
lepha
ntBli
nd Bu
ll Sum
Base
Camp
Grass
y Lak
eLe
wis L
ake D
ivide
Philli
ps Be
nch
Snak
e Rive
r Stat
ionSlu
g Cre
ek Di
vide
Big Cr
eek
Bear
Basin
Brun
dage
Rese
rvoir
Bear
Sadd
leBo
stette
r R.S.
Cama
s Cre
ek Di
vide
Dolla
rhide
Summ
itGa
rfield
R.S.
Giveo
utHil
ts Cr
eek
Howe
ll Can
yon
Hynd
man
Long
Valle
yCh
ocola
te Gu
lchLo
st-W
ood D
ivide
Mud F
latMa
gic M
ount
ainMi
ll Cre
ek Su
mmit
Oxfor
d Spr
ingPr
airie
Soldi
er R.
S.Se
cesh
Summ
itSe
dgwi
ck Pe
akSo
uth M
tn.
Soms
en Ra
nch
Shee
p Mtn
.Sq
uaw
Flat
Stickn
ey M
illSw
ede P
eak
Van W
yckW
est B
ranch
Wild
horse
Divid
eW
ilson C
reek
Aner
oid La
keBlu
e Mou
ntain
Sprin
gBo
wman
Sprin
gsBo
urne
Coun
ty Lin
eEil
ertso
n Mea
dows
Emigr
ant S
pring
sFis
h Cre
ekGo
ld Ce
nter
High R
idge
Lake
Cree
k R.S.
Lucky
Strik
eMt
. How
ardMo
ss Sp
rings
Schne
ider M
eado
wsSil
vies
Tipto
nTa
ylor G
reen
Wolf
Cree
k
Bear
Cree
kBig
Bend
Bucks
kin Lo
wer
Draw
Cree
kDis
aster
Peak
Gran
ite Pe
akJac
k Cre
ek U
pper
Lama
nce C
reek
Pole
Cree
k R.S.
Seve
ntysi
x Cre
ekTa
ylor C
anyo
n
Gros
Vent
re Su
mmit
Salt R
iver S
ummi
tTo
gwot
ee Pa
ssTo
uche
t
I
n
c
h
e
s
SNOTEL
Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation (in) for SNOTELs in Water Year 2014
Eastern Idaho
SNOTELS located in Cloud Seeding Regions
Payette Boise
Idaho Oregon Nevada Wyoming
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
Cozy
Cov
eBa
nner
Sum
mit
Dead
woo
d Su
mm
itM
ores
Cre
ek Su
mm
it
Atlan
ta Su
mm
itGr
aham
Gua
rd S
ta.
Gale
naGa
lena
Sum
mit
Jack
son
Peak
Trin
ity M
tn.
Vien
na M
ine
Crab
Cre
ekIsl
and
Park
Lake
view
Rid
geW
hite
Elep
hant
Blin
d Bu
ll Su
mBa
se C
amp
Gras
sy L
ake
Lew
is La
ke D
ivide
Philli
ps B
ench
Snak
e Ri
ver S
tatio
nSlu
g Cre
ek D
ivide
Big C
reek
Bear
Bas
inBr
unda
ge R
eser
voir
Bear
Sadd
leBo
stet
ter R
.S.
Cam
as C
reek
Divi
deDo
llarh
ide
Sum
mit
Garfi
eld
R.S.
Give
out
Hilts
Cre
ekHo
wel
l Can
yon
Hynd
man
Long
Vall
eyCh
ocol
ate
Gulch
Lost
-Woo
d Divi
deM
ud Fl
atM
agic
Mou
ntain
Mill
Cree
k Sum
mit
Oxfo
rd Sp
ring
Prair
ieSo
ldie
r R.S
.Se
cesh
Sum
mit
Sedg
wick
Pea
kSo
uth M
tn.
Som
sen
Ranc
hSh
eep M
tn.
Squa
w Fl
atSt
ickne
y Mill
Swed
e Pea
kVa
n W
yck
Wes
t Bra
nch
Wild
hors
e Di
vide
Wils
on C
reek
Aner
oid L
ake
Blue
Mou
ntain
Spr
ing
Bow
man
Sprin
gsBo
urne
Coun
ty Li
neEil
erts
on M
eado
ws
Emigr
ant S
prin
gsFis
h Cr
eek
Gold
Cen
ter
High
Rid
geLa
ke Cr
eek R
.S.
Luck
y Str
ikeM
t. Ho
war
dM
oss S
prin
gsSc
hnei
der M
eado
ws
Silvie
sTip
ton
Taylo
r Gre
enW
olf C
reek
Bear
Cre
ekBi
g Ben
dBu
cksk
in L
ower
Draw
Cre
ekDi
sast
er P
eak
Gran
ite P
eak
Jack
Cre
ek U
pper
Lam
ance
Cre
ekPo
le Cr
eek R
.S.
Seve
ntys
ix Cr
eek
Taylo
r Can
yon
Gros
Ven
tre S
umm
itSa
lt Ri
ver S
umm
itTo
gwot
ee Pa
ssTo
uche
t
I
n
c
h
e
s
SNOTEL
Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation (in) for SNOTELs in Water Year 2013
Eastern Idaho
SNOTELS located in Cloud Seeding Regions
Payette Boise
Idaho Oregon Nevada Wyoming
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
Cozy
Cov
eBa
nner
Sum
mit
Dead
woo
d Su
mm
itM
ores
Cre
ek Su
mm
it
Atla
nta
Sum
mit
Grah
am G
uard
Sta
.Ga
lena
Gale
na S
umm
itJa
ckso
n Pe
akTr
inity
Mtn
.Vi
enna
Min
e
Crab
Cre
ekIs
land
Par
kLa
kevi
ew R
idge
Whi
te El
epha
ntBl
ind
Bull
Sum
Base
Cam
pGr
assy
Lak
eLe
wis
Lake
Div
ide
Phill
ips
Benc
hSn
ake
Rive
r St
atio
nSl
ug C
reek
Div
ide
Big
Cree
kBe
ar B
asin
Brun
dage
Res
ervo
irBe
ar S
addl
eBo
stet
ter R
.S.
Cam
as C
reek
Div
ide
Dolla
rhid
e Su
mm
itGa
rfie
ld R
.S.
Give
out
Hilts
Cre
ekHo
wel
l Can
yon
Hynd
man
Long
Val
ley
Choc
olat
e Gu
lchLo
st-W
ood
Divi
deM
ud F
lat
Mag
ic M
ount
ain
Mill
Cre
ek S
umm
itO
xfor
d Sp
ring
Prai
rieSo
ldie
r R.S
.Se
cesh
Sum
mit
Sedg
wick
Pea
kSo
uth
Mtn
.So
mse
n Ra
nch
Shee
p M
tn.
Squa
w F
lat
Stick
ney
Mill
Swed
e Pe
akVa
n W
yck
Wes
t Bra
nch
Wild
hors
e Di
vide
Wils
on C
reek
Aner
oid
Lake
Blue
Mou
ntai
n Sp
ring
Bow
man
Spr
ings
Bour
neCo
unty
Line
Eile
rtso
n M
eado
ws
Emig
rant
Spr
ings
Fish
Cre
ekGo
ld C
ente
rHi
gh R
idge
Lake
Cre
ek R
.S.
Luck
y St
rike
Mt.
How
ard
Mos
s Spr
ings
Schn
eide
r Mea
dow
sSi
lvie
sTi
pton
Tayl
or G
reen
Wol
f Cre
ek
Bear
Cre
ekBi
g Be
ndBu
cksk
in L
ower
Draw
Cre
ekDi
sast
er P
eak
Gran
ite P
eak
Jack
Cre
ek U
pper
Lam
ance
Cre
ekPo
le C
reek
R.S
.Se
vent
ysix
Cre
ekTa
ylor
Can
yon
Gros
Ven
tre
Sum
mit
Salt
Rive
r Sum
mit
Togw
otee
Pas
sTo
uche
t
I
n
c
h
e
s
SNOTEL
Observed Minus WRF Model Forecast Precipitation (in) for SNOTELs in Water Year 2012
Eastern Idaho
SNOTELS located in Cloud Seeding Regions
Payette Boise
Idaho Oregon Nevada Wyoming