Nuclear Research andHigher Education: a Disposable Part of Fundamental National Infrastructure?

2 r4.ijs.si

Research and higher education a disposable part of fundamental national infrastructure?

Leon Cizelj Head, Reactor Engineering Division, Jožef Stefan Institute Associate Profesor of Nuclear Engineering, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana

REMOO 2014, Ljubljana, Slovenia

3 r4.ijs.si

Disclaimer

• I am a nuclear engineer • I do promote:

• Nuclear safety, • Research and research based education, • Competitive, environmentally friendly and

sufficient energy sources • Robert Stone‘s movie Pandora‘s Promise.

„You can not be against climate change and nuclear energy at the same time.“

REMOO 2014, Nov. 2014, Ljubljana, Slovenia

Does this imply that I promote nuclear energy?

http://www.google.si/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CAcQjRw&url=http://www.traversecityfilmfest.org/tcff-2013-day-5-pandoras-promise-and-were-the-millers/&ei=pdFcVL-JBY7zavmggvgP&bvm=bv.79184187,d.d2s&psig=AFQjCNGafh2AAr1UbbfeHs_QCiNdXGjHDQ&ust=1415455460438836

4 r4.ijs.si

Disclaimer I do support environmentally and economically sustainable safe nuclear energy. An important note: Nuclear power plant is with us for a century of more. This implies huge changes in:

• the scientifical and technical knowledge; • the society (>25 governments, LJ >8 states).

Nuclear energy should therefore strive for the use of the best available people, science, knowledge, technologies and operational experience. REMOO 2014, Nov. 2014, Ljubljana, Slovenia

5 r4.ijs.si

Overview

• About the Reactor Engineering Divison

• Background and Motivation

• The Basic Question(s)

• Some (Anecdotal) Evidence of Possible Answers

• Summary


6 r4.ijs.si

Overview





• Summary


7 r4.ijs.si

Reactor Engineering Division Today

(the sole) coherent research group focusing on nuclear safety and nuclear engineering in Slovenia.

Research and pedagogical core of

the School of Nuclear Engineering (Faculty of mathematics and physics, University of Ljubljana)

Technical and scientific support

organization to the national nuclear regulatory body (URSJV)


http://www.google.si/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&docid=5bDajDKtJlAqwM&tbnid=tkHzXX5jTcp3tM:&ved=0CAUQjRw&url=http://www.eurosafe-forum.org/&ei=OIaxUoOQCoWl0QWnk4DABQ&bvm=bv.58187178,d.bGQ&psig=AFQjCNGrbKhvKeJ8R1-4LFCrMbuwPM1pXg&ust=1387452317582867

8 r4.ijs.si

Turbulent Flows Around the Nuclear Fuel Elements


International project by OECD/NEA: • Started in 2011 • Issue: dominant position of the fuel

manufacturers reduce lack of knowledge elsewhere!

• Experiment MATiS-H by KAERI:

• Blind simulations: 25 teams/12 nations • R4 within top 5!

Lee et al, Nucl Engnrng Design (2014) 279, 3-18

Krško NPP 2013

http://www.kaeri.re.kr:8080/english

9 r4.ijs.si

Cooling of Divertor of Fusion Reactor by Multiple Impinging Jets


Draksler et al, Int J Heat and Fluid Flow (2014), 46, 147-157

10 r4.ijs.si

Intergranular Stress Corrosion Cracks The Major Ageing Mechanism in NPP

Reconstruction of crystal grains from diffraction contrast tomography Applicable also in medical physics


Simonovski & Cizelj, Comp Mat Sci (2011) 50, 1606-1618

http://www.manchester.ac.uk/

http://www.cea.fr/

11 r4.ijs.si

Intergranular Stress Corrosion Cracks The Major Ageing Mechanism in NPP


Simonovski & Cizelj, Engnrng Fract Mech (2013) 110, 364-377

12 r4.ijs.si

Hydrogen Combustion Experiment in HYKA A2 (LACOMECO)


http://www.kit.edu/

13 r4.ijs.si

Steam explosions R4 Model Integrated in the IRSN Code MC3D


http://www.cea.fr/

14 r4.ijs.si

Overview





• Summary


15 r4.ijs.si

Background, Motivation Maturity and stability of the industry and regulators

The electricity from the nuclear fission: • is abundant and competitive low carbon energy; • has one of the lowest impacts to the public health and

environment. This is a consequence of:

• large and long term efforts of the nuclear industry to sustain and improve the safety of the nuclear power plants.

• systematic support and occasional leadership by the competent regulatory authorities and academia worldwide.

Scientific and technical evidence clearly supports the above facts. REMOO 2014, Nov. 2014, Ljubljana, Slovenia

16 r4.ijs.si

Background, Motivation Dwindling Added Value of Research and Higher Education?

Nuclear industry and regulators unparalleled safety record, levels of stability and maturity. A possible perception:

• further research cannot bring much added value to the safe operation of the plants;

• higher education might be fully substituted by professional training;

• could be reinforced by the economic recession. A possible substantiation:

• Post Fukushima improvements of the NPP largely include the implementations of technologies that were available before Fukushima.


17 r4.ijs.si

Background, Motivation Public acceptance is the key challenge of nuclear

One of the key remaining challenges for the nuclear industry is the dwindling public acceptance. Possible perception:

• General public does not believe the facts about the nuclear energy. A possible substantiation: Public opinion (in the most of the EU countries):

• highly values and trusts the information received from the scientists; • does not have much confidence in information provided by industry,

regulators, media, government, even international organizations such as IAEA

• Ref: Eurobarometer 324, 2010


18 r4.ijs.si

Background, Motivation Is partnership of academia and industry a way out?

Nuclear industry and regulators unparalleled safety record, levels of stability and maturity. One of the key remaining challenges for the nuclear industry is the dwindling public acceptance. Public opinion trusts the information received from the scientists. Does this make an opportunity for strong partnerhips of academia and industry?


19 r4.ijs.si

Overview





• Summary


20 r4.ijs.si

The Basic Question(s)

Are research and higher education an essential part of fundamental national infrastructure? Yes No

Who is responsible to maintain the appropriate infrastructure (including research and education)? Government Industry Regulator Market


21 r4.ijs.si

The Basic Question(s)

Are research and higher education an essential part of fundamental national infrastructure? Yes o No

Who is responsible to maintain the appropriate infrastructure (including research and education)? Government Industry Regulator Market


All stakeholders to work closely together and support each other to create and implement the necessary knowledge and knowhow. Longterm effort! A lot of money and top level experts!

22 r4.ijs.si

Overview





• Summary


23 r4.ijs.si

Privatized rail infrastructure in UK (1996) On the problem of new (and not fully explored) interfaces

Train Derailment at Hatfield, UK. 4 casualties, over 70 injured. The main causes:

• Shortcommings of the maintenance of the infrastructure (fatigued rail broke)

• Failing of the regulatory oversight • Full report @

www.railwaysarchive.co.uk/docsummary.php?docID=465


24 r4.ijs.si

Before privatization/liberalization in 1996


Single business entity

Balanced interface between the wheels and the track: Observable wear before hidden fatigue

25 r4.ijs.si

After privatisation/liberalization in 1996


Business entities 1, 2, 3….

Infrastructure

Opportunity for externalization of

costs

Unbalanced interface between the wheels and the track: Hidden fatigue before observable wear

26 r4.ijs.si

After the accident in 2000


Business

Infrastructure


costs

Unbalanced interface between the wheels and the track: Hidden fatigue before after observable wear

REGULATORY PATCH

http://www.google.si/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CAcQjRw&url=http://www.itespresso.fr/microsoft-patch-tuesday-cest-charge-pour-la-rentree-67770.html&ei=YyliVLuGBsPYasGCgfAN&bvm=bv.79189006,d.d2s&psig=AFQjCNEQl_JFXHTPw24y7wAYvj9IGKlSlA&ust=1415805633497713

27 r4.ijs.si

Possible Nuclear Parallels


Business

Infrastructure

TIME REGULATORY

PATCH

INDUSTRY

ACADEMIA


28 r4.ijs.si

Similarities With Fukushima?


Company 1, 2, 3….

Infrastructure


costs?

REGULATORY PATCH

INDUSTRY

ACADEMIA


29 r4.ijs.si

Pickering nuclear

The Ontario Hydro „meltdown“ (1997) Missmanaged safety culture (=infrastructure)?

Long standing, but not resolved, management, process and equipment issues in Ontario Hydro (one of the world largest nuclear utilities with 19 NPP at the time). Internal investigation ordered by the utility management: no intervention by the national regulator. Full report @ http://www.ccnr.org/hydro_report.html Results

• Immediate shutdown of 7 out 19 reactors (2 remained out of service until today)

• Huge losses (economy and people) • Nearly 20 years needed to recover


http://www.ccnr.org/hydro_report.html

30 r4.ijs.si

The Ontario Hydro „meltdown“ (1997) Some remarks from the report Employees lack a questioning attitude; Decisions are dominated by a production mentality and managers feel excessive pressure to continue planned evolutions. At times, personnel cannot comply with the established processes or procedures It's acceptable to cut corners. It is not acceptable to make waves. Those who have made waves have been fired or sidelined. Serious shortages of key management, supervisory and some technical skills exist… Design basis documentation is not accurately maintained. The practice of offering critical services, such as training and engineering, on a "fee for service" basis has created an attitude that the groups providing the service are not a part of the team.


31 r4.ijs.si

The Ontario Hydro „meltdown“ (1997) Some remarks from the authors of the report

"The issue of culture is that nuclear tries to keep everything confined within it. [They] won't tell anybody anything. That's not just the Canadian culture, it's the nuclear culture.„ Carl Andognini "Good teams can turn bad over 10 years if they're not self-checking and probing.„ John Zwolinski "We've been telling you that for a number of years. Over and over again, sir.„ Maurice Brenner "There's people in management that shouldn't be in management and they don't want to be in management, but it's the only way they can get more money.„ Carl Andognini http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/ontario-hydro-meltdown/


http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/ontario-hydro-meltdown/





32 r4.ijs.si

Closure of San Onofre NPP (Ca, 2013) Missmanaged Design Bases (=infrastructure)?

2 Units of San Onofre NPP closed in 2013: • Replaced steam generators in 2009 • Never reached full power after replacement

Decision economic, not safety Root cause as seen by NRC:

• Desing bases in FSAR outdated • Poor oversight by NRC • Full report see

world-nuclear-news.org http://www.world-nuclear-news.org/RS-NRC-overlooked-San-Onofre-steam-generator-problem-09101401.html


33 r4.ijs.si

Overview





• Summary


34 r4.ijs.si

Summary Our common goal: environmentally and economically sustainable safe nuclear energy. Nuclear industry and regulators unparalleled safety record, levels of stability and maturity. One of the key remaining challenges for the nuclear industry is the dwindling public acceptance. Public opinion trusts the information received from the scientists. Does this make an opportunity for stronger partnerships between academia and industry?


35 r4.ijs.si

Summary

Nuclear energy should strive for the use of the best available people, science, knowledge, technologies and operational experience. Excellent infrastructure is vital to support that. Relying on the markets may result in additional risks. Excellent infrastructure (including research and education) is concern of all stakeholders.


36 r4.ijs.si

Nuclear Research andHigher Education: a Disposable Part of Fundamental National Infrastructure?

Education

Transcript of Nuclear Research andHigher Education: a Disposable Part of Fundamental National Infrastructure?