NRG Contribution to LEADER WP1.1 Status

NRG Contribution to LEADER WP1.1Status

LEADERPetten, Netherlands

Ferry [email protected]

2Petten • 2 November 2011

Contents

• Introduction• Roadmaps v3

– Guinevere– MYRRHA– ALFRED– PROLFR– ELFR– LEADER Overview– LFR Deployment

• Conclusions


IntroductionRoadmap visualisation

• Purpose– Provide overview of timing of main developments– In addition

• Identification of critical path

• Identification of costly developments

• Identification of developments with high risk

• Approach– Roadmapper Workbench Excel based tool from Albright

Strategy Group– Limited level of detail to enable keeping an overview

• Outcome– Roadmap visuals which can be used in presentations to

(potential) stakeholders and which are easy to update during and after the project


IntroductionRoadmaps under Consideration

• It was agreed with WP1 and WP1.1 coordinators to include roadmaps for:

– LFR Zero Power GUINEVERE (LFR/ADS)

– LFR ETPP MYRRHA (LFR/ADS)– LFR E&T ELECTRA (LFR)– LFR ETDR ALFRED (LFR)– LFR Prototype PROLFR (LFR)– LFR FOAK ELFR (LFR)


IntroductionRoadmap Construction

• Three levels– Level 1

• Main roadmap elements (e.g. reactor, fuels, materials)

– Level 2• Secondary roadmap elements / subdivisions of main roadmap

elements, e.g. fuel qualification, fuel fabrication

– Level 3• Individual developments / subdivisions of secondary roadmap

elements, e.g. fuel irradiation, fuel safety tests


IntroductionInput Data

• Input data– Begin time– End time / duration– Cost estimate (range)– Risk (low / medium / high)

• Initial guess provided by NRG based on information from SNE-TP, ESNII, EUROTRANS, MYRRHA, EISOFAR Fuel Roadmap, ELSY and LEADER projects

• Data review by LEADER experts to be identified this meeting

• Continuous update during the LEADER project


IntroductionItems for Discussion

• Confirmation/identification of main and secondary roadmap elements

• Confirmation/identification of individual developments

• Input data content review


RoadmapsGUINEVERE

LEADER GUINEVERE Table

14 December 2010

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

Reactor

GUINEVERE Design

GUINEVERE Construction

Primary System

Primary Components

ADS Components

Subcritical Core

Target

Secondary System

Secondary Components

Heat Rejection

Fuels

Fuel Qualification

Fabrication

Materials

Target Material

Other Materials

Coolant

Analyses

Analysis

Licensing

License

Safeguards

Proliferation

Dvlpmt Begins Costs

Feasibility Risk Event

©2008-2010 Albright Strategy Group, LLC

Detail

Civil

Construction Commissioning

Reactor Vessel

Piping

Pump

HEX

Fuel Handling

DHR

Design

Solid Lead Target

Piping

Eng. & Constr.

Irradiation

Safety Tests

Fuel Elements

Lead

VENUS

Water

Economic

Neutronic

Thermal Hydraulic

Structural PRA

'Exp. License' Site Selection

Proliferation Resistance

<50K <250K <1M <10M <50M <100M <500M <1B >1B

High Medium Low


RoadmapMYRRHA

LEADER MYRRHA Table

2 November 2010

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025

Reactor

MYRRHA Design

MYRRHA Construction

Primary System

Primary Components

ADS Components

Subcritical Core

Target

Beam

Secondary System


Heat Rejection

Fuels

Fuel Qualification

Fabrication

Materials

Cladding

Vessel

Internals

Control Rods

Coolant

Analyses

Analysis

Licensing

License

SA Tools & Exp.

Safeguards

Proliferation

Dvlpmt Begins Costs



Pre-Conceptual | EUROTRANS, CDT, ESNIIBasic | ESNIIDetail | ESNII

Civil | ESNII

Construction | ESNII, EUROTRANS D1.68| ESNII

Reactor Vessel | EUROTRANS D1.68

Piping

Pumps | EUROTRANS D1.68

HEX | EUROTRANS D1.68

LBE Purification | ELSY D10

Fuel Handling System | EUROTRANS D1.68

Oxygen Control | ELSY D10

ISI&R | EUROTRANS D1.68

DHR | EUROTRANS D1.68

Design | Paper work

Safety Tests | GUINEVERE

Target System | EUROTRANS D1.68

Accelerator | EUROTRANS D1.68

Piping | ELSY D10

Eng. & Constr. | ELSY D10

Irradiation | EISOFAR D10Safety Tests | EISOFAR D10

FR-MOX Fuel | EISOFAR D10

Fuel Elements | EISOFAR D10

15-15 Ti Qualification | Irradiation / CDT D1.4

316L Qualification | Irradiation / CDT D1.4

T91 Qualification | Irradiation / CDT D1.4

B4C Qualification | Irradiation / CDT D1.4

LBE | EUROTRANS D1.68

Economic | Paper work

Neutronic | Core optimization, shielding

Thermal Hydraulic | Operations, DBC, DEC, SA

Structural | Seismic, Vibration

PRA | Input required from other analyses

Constr. License | LEADER D29Site

Preparation PSAR SAR | Input required from analyses

EIA | ~ EIA for Gen III

Safety Analysis | RELAP

Seismic | FEM available

SGTR | Needs upscaled experiments compared to LIFUS with LBE

Thermal Fatigue | High risk because of conductivity and experiments required

DHR | Needs experimental validation

Source Term | Approach to be developed

Proliferation | Paper work

<50K <250 <1M <10M <50M <100 <500 <1B >1B

High Mediu Low


RoadmapPROLFR

LEADER PROLFR Table

17 May 2011

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040

Reactor

PROLFR Design

PROLFR Construction

Primary System

Primary Components

ECS


Heat Rejection

Fuels

Fuel Qualification

Fabrication

Materials

Cladding

Vessel

Internals

Control Rods

Coolant

Analyses

Analysis

Licensing

License

SA Tools & Exp.

Safeguards

Proliferation

Dvlpmt Begins Costs



Pre-Conceptual Basic Detail

Civil

Construction Com

Reactor Vessel

Piping Pumps

Steam Generator

Lead Purification

Fuel Handling System

Oxygen Control

ISI&R

DHR

Piping

Turbine Generator

Electrical Equipment

Eng. & Constr.

Irradiation (MOX) Irradiation (MA-MOX)

Safety Tests (MOX) Safety Tests (MA-MOX)

FR-MOX Fuel

FR-MA-MOX Fuel Fuel Elements

T91 Qualification

316LN Qualification

SA-516 Gr. 70 Qualification

B4C Qualification

Lead

Economic

Neutronic

Thermal Hydraulic

Structural

PRA

Constr. Lic. Site Selection Preparation

PSAR SAR

EIA

Safety Analysis Code

Seismic

SGTR

Thermal Fatigue

DHR

Source Term


<50K <250K

<1M <10M <50M <100M

<500M

<1B >1B

High Medi Low


RoadmapELFR

LEADER ELFR Table

17 May 2011

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050

Reactor

ELFR Design

ELFR Construction

Primary System

Primary Components

ECS


Heat Rejection

Fuels

Fuel Qualification

Fabrication

Materials

Cladding

Vessel

Internals

Control Rods

Coolant

Analyses

Analysis

Licensing

License

SA Tools & Exp.

Safeguards

Proliferation

Dvlpmt Begins Costs




Civil

Construction Com

Reactor Vessel Piping Pumps

Steam Generator Lead Purification

Fuel Handling System Oxygen Control

ISI&R

DHR

Piping Turbine

Generator

Electrical Equipment

Eng. & Constr.

Irradiation (MA-MOX) Safety Tests (MA-MOX)

FR-MA-MOX Fuel Fuel Elements

T91 Qualification

316LN Qualification

SA-516 Gr. 70 Qualification

B4C Qualification

Lead

Economic Neutronic

Thermal Hydraulic

Structural

PRA

Constr. Lic. Site Selection

Preparation

PSAR SAR

EIA

Safety Analysis Code

Seismic

SGTR

Thermal Fatigue

DHR

Source Term


<50K <250K

<1M <10M <50M <100M

<500M

<1B >1B

High Medi Low


RoadmapLFR Deployment

• Adapted according to D29 rev1.1 october 2011• Including a schedule for ELECTRA

LEADER LFR Deployment Table

2-November-2011

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050

GUINEVERE

GUINEVERE Design

GUINEVERE Construction

MYRRHA

MYRRHA Design

MYRRHA Consortium

MYRRHA Construction

ELECTRA

ELECTRA Design

ELECTRA Consortium

ELECTRA Construction

ALFRED

ALFRED Design

ALFRED Consortium

ALFRED Construction

PROLFR

PROLFR Design

PROLFR Consortium

PROLFR Construction

ELFR

ELFR Design

ELFR Consortium

ELFR Construction

Dvlpmt Begins Deployment



Detail

Civil


Civil

Agreement

Construction


Civil

Agreement

Construction LEADER D29


Civil

Agreement

Construction


Civil

Agreement

Construction


Civil

Agreement

Construction

Basic Detail Const Com

High Mediu Low


The End

“Thanks for your attention”

NRG Contribution to LEADER WP1.1 Status

Documents

Transcript of NRG Contribution to LEADER WP1.1 Status