NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste...

27
NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines Advances in Air Pollution Control Technology MARAMA Workshop May 19, 2011

Transcript of NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste...

Page 1: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines

Advances in Air Pollution Control TechnologyMARAMA Workshop

May 19, 2011

Page 2: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Outline

• Types of Gas Engines• 3-Way NSCR• SCR• Field Experience

Page 3: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Types of Gas Engines

• Rich Burn - Excess amount of fuel to air(exhaust contains < 1% O2)

• Lean Burn - Excess amount of air to fuel(exhaust contains > 4% O2)

Page 4: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

NOx Control Technologiesfor Gas Engines

4SRB:• 3-Way (NSCR)

2SLB and 4SLB:• SCR (Selective Catalytic Reduction) – Urea

and Ethanol

Page 5: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

NSCR Systems

Page 6: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

0102030405060708090

100

14.5 15.0 15.5 16.0 16.5 17.0 17.5

NOxCOTHC

Rich Stoich LeanA/F Ratio (Mass)

% Conversion

NSCR Performance Curve

Page 7: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

3-Way NSCR Catalytic Convertersfor Stationary Gas Engines

Page 8: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Stationary Engine Gas Compression

Page 9: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

3–Way NSCR Performance and Cost

Typical Rich Burn Engine for Gas Compression• Engine Type & Model: Waukesha P9390 • Engine HP: 1980• Expected NOx reduction: 98%+• Target NOx 0.15 g/bhp-hr • Expected CO reduction (HAP’s) 76%+

• Offered in both silenced and non silenced versions to meet state regulations and NESHAPS

• Silenced versions pricing = approx $18.00 per Hp. • Non-silenced version pricing = approx. $ 15.00 per Hp.

Page 10: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

SCR Systems

Page 11: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Typical V-SCR NOx Activity

lower

V2O5 Content

150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550

high

medium

kNO

x

Page 12: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

V-SCR Operating Temperatures

200°C 350°COperating Temperature

400°F 1000°F600°F 800°F

Typical High Dust Applicationsin Power Plants

Simple Cycle Gas Turbines

Combined Cycle Power Plants

IC Engines

SINOx® Low TemperatureCatalyst

SINOx® High TemperatureCatalyst

Tail End Applications inPower Plants, Waste Incinerations

Standard SINOx®

or Coated Catalyst

550°C

Page 13: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Ethanol SCR NOx Performance

E85 Reductant, Inlet NOx=500ppm, C1:NOx=5

0

20

40

60

80

100

100 200 300 400 500

Temperature (Celsius)

NO

x C

onve

rsio

n (%

)

Page 14: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Coated Metal Honeycomb Catalyst

CONFI DENTI AL

Page 15: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Extruded SCR Catalyst

Page 16: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

IC Engine SCR System

SCR Catalyst CO Oxidation Catalyst

(optional) Catalyst Housings Mixing Duct Injection Lance Urea Injection Control

System Air Purge On-site Training/Start-up

Service (O&M Manual)

OxidationCatalyst

Page 17: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

SCR Catalyst Housing for IC Engines

Stainless steel construction

Access door for inspection/ maintenance

Designed for even flow distribution

Ports available for monitoring ∆P and T

Extra space available for additional catalyst

Page 18: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Urea Injection Control Panel

Electronics located in the top of the panel

Instrumentation in the bottom of the panel

Precise control of urea delivery

Redundant magnetic gear driven pumps

Urea or aqueous ammonia compatible

Page 19: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Urea Injection System

Control Panel

Injection Schemes

Piping Panel

Page 20: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

SCR System Controls

Electronics located in the top of the panel Touch screen operator interface PC based with Intel processor Feed forward, feed back/closed loop injection control SCADA compatible Data storage capability with Ethernet access External Communication- RS-485, RS-232 I/Os accessed for remote monitoring and data

collection. ModBus communication protocol

Page 21: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Injection Lance

Pipe in pipe arrangement- urea in center pipe Air utilized for cooling and atomization Urea and air mix in the injection nozzle Layer of insulation around air pipe Small urea droplet size facilitates the SCR reaction

Page 22: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Budgetary Cost of SCR System

$60,000

$70,000

$80,000

$90,000

$100,000

$110,000

$120,000

$130,000

$140,000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500

Power (hp)

SC

R B

udge

tary

Pri

ce

$42/hp

$150/hp

Page 23: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

SCR Installations

Page 24: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Gas Compressor SCR/CO System Installations

Engine Model

EngineHp

NOxg/bhp-hr

CO*g/bhp-hr

NOx Reduction

CO* Reduction

CAT G3516

1340 1.5 1.88 90% 90%

CAT G3608

2370 0.7 2.5 90% 90%

CAT G3612

3550 0.7 2.5 90% 90%

CAT G3616

4735 0.7 2.5 80% 90%

These engines are installed and operating at Loudon Compressor Station,Clarksburg, WV and Lodi Compression/Storage, Sacramento, CA

*Installed prior to HAPs requirement

Page 25: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Lodi Gas Compression/StorageKirby Hills, CA

• Engines - CAT G3516• Installed 2006

Page 26: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Hotel & Casino CHP Plant (SCR/CO)

Page 27: NOx Control for Stationary Gas Engines - MARAMA End Applications in Power Plants, Waste Incinerations Standard SINOx ® or Coated Catalyst 550 C Ethanol SCR NOx Performance E85 …

Contact Information

Wilson [email protected]

484-320-2119Cell 484-354-8155