November - December 2008 Canyon Echo

EEEEExplorxplorxplorxplorxplore, enjoe, enjoe, enjoe, enjoe, enjoyyyyy, and pr, and pr, and pr, and pr, and protect the planetotect the planetotect the planetotect the planetotect the planet

Canyon EchoLLLLLIFEIFEIFEIFEIFE ONONONONON THETHETHETHETHE E E E E EDGEDGEDGEDGEDGE

www.arizona.sierraclub.orgwww.arizona.sierraclub.orgwww.arizona.sierraclub.orgwww.arizona.sierraclub.orgwww.arizona.sierraclub.org Grand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon Chapter November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008

On the Margins, On the BorderOn the Margins, On the BorderOn the Margins, On the BorderOn the Margins, On the BorderOn the Margins, On the BorderBy Sandy Bahr

Border policy is affecting Arizona’sBorder policy is affecting Arizona’sBorder policy is affecting Arizona’sBorder policy is affecting Arizona’sBorder policy is affecting Arizona’senvironment. See inside to find out how.environment. See inside to find out how.environment. See inside to find out how.environment. See inside to find out how.environment. See inside to find out how.

There is nothing about the U.S. borderwith Mexico that is uncomplicated, norare there any easy answers to the policyissues. What we do know is what doesn’twork – tall walls that block wildlifemovements and cause flooding but onlyadd a minute or two to most people’scrossing; policies such as the NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement, whichonly serve to undercut environmental

Sandy is the Chapter’s ConservationOutreach Director.

protections and exacerbate the economicdisparities; and measures such as REALID that allow one appointed individualto waive a plethora of environmentalprotection laws.

Border traffic and Border Patrolactivities to deter undocumented immi-gration have resulted in severe damage tofragile borderlands. Rare and uniquespecies such as the Sonoran pronghorn,jaguar, ocelot, and many others arethreatened by these actions. Border wallshave resulted in significant flooding on theBuenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge andin communities such as Nogales, Sonora,threatening people and wildlife alike.

Laws that are critical to protect theair, land, water, plants, and animals arebeing waived with little or no thought tothe damage the activities will cause. Goneare the protections afforded by the

Endangered Species Act, the Clean Air Act,and the Clean Water Act, among others.

To address the environmentallyharmful activities and policies, theSierra Club is engaged in a BorderProtection Campaign. We are seeking torestore and protect areas that have beendamaged by the wall in the San PedroRiparian National Conservation Area,Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge,and other sensitive lands. Working withCongressman Raúl Grijalva, we are seekingto repeal the section of Real ID that allowsthe Secretary of Homeland Security towaive environmental laws to constructdamaging infrastructure.

While the Sierra Club has a positionof neutrality on immigration, we havenever been neutral on environmentaldestruction. We seek to protect and restorethese amazing borderlands, including ourspectacular wildlife refuges, wilderness, andthe rare and unique San Pedro RiparianNational Conservation Area.

SSSSSavavavavave Se Se Se Se Some Gome Gome Gome Gome Grrrrreen!een!een!een!een!

Help us save save trees, money, and energy! It’s easy! Just signup to receive the electronic version of the Canyon Echo...in color!

Signing up is simple: just fill out the short form online athttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/echo/paperlessform/form.aspor send an email with your full name and membership ID(8-digit number located on the mailing label) [email protected].

Please note:Please note:Please note:Please note:Please note: If you choose this option, you will not receive a paper copy ofthe newsletter. You will receive an email alert when the latest issue is available.

TOP LEFT: Border wall. Photo by Kai Wiedenhofer. TOP RIGHT: Border wall across landscape.Photo by Matt Clark. BOTTOM: Deer unable to cross the border. Photographer anonymous.

On the WebSierra Club Home PageSierra Club Home PageSierra Club Home PageSierra Club Home PageSierra Club Home Pagewww.sierraclub.org

Sierra MagazineSierra MagazineSierra MagazineSierra MagazineSierra Magazinewww.sierraclub.org/sierra

Online NewsOnline NewsOnline NewsOnline NewsOnline Newswww.sierraclub.org/news

Chapter Action NetworkChapter Action NetworkChapter Action NetworkChapter Action NetworkChapter Action Networkgrandcanyon.sierraclubaction.org

On the Web

3 3 3 3 3 Wild Versus Wall Film

6 6 6 6 6 Borderlands at Risk

7 7 7 7 7 Effects on Wildlife

8 8 8 8 8 Effects on Public Lands

9 9 9 9 9 Effects on Communities

1 01 01 01 01 0 Chapter/Group Elections

1 41 41 41 41 4 Group Happenings

1 51 51 51 51 5 Hikes and Trips

11111 66666 Service Outings

Inside

Make your voice heard. VOTE ON NOV. 4!Don’t forget to vote in Chapter and Group elections, too! See pg. 10–13.

TTTTTo vieo vieo vieo vieo view a map of the U.S.-Mw a map of the U.S.-Mw a map of the U.S.-Mw a map of the U.S.-Mw a map of the U.S.-Mexico borexico borexico borexico borexico border and arder and arder and arder and arder and areas affected beas affected beas affected beas affected beas affected byyyyyborder policies, visit http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border/map.asp.border policies, visit http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border/map.asp.border policies, visit http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border/map.asp.border policies, visit http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border/map.asp.border policies, visit http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border/map.asp.

Grand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon Chapter

wwwwwwwwwwwwwww.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org

Arizona ChaptArizona ChaptArizona ChaptArizona ChaptArizona Chapter Aer Aer Aer Aer Action Directction Directction Directction Directction DirectorororororyyyyyConservationConservationConservationConservationConservation Outreach Director Outreach Director Outreach Director Outreach Director Outreach DirectorSandy Bahr 602-253-8633 [email protected] Program AssistantConservation Program AssistantConservation Program AssistantConservation Program AssistantConservation Program AssistantTiffany Sprague 602-253-9140 [email protected] Canyon Conservation Program CoordinatorGrand Canyon Conservation Program CoordinatorGrand Canyon Conservation Program CoordinatorGrand Canyon Conservation Program CoordinatorGrand Canyon Conservation Program CoordinatorStacey Hamburg 928-774-6514 [email protected] Desert National Monument OrganizerSonoran Desert National Monument OrganizerSonoran Desert National Monument OrganizerSonoran Desert National Monument OrganizerSonoran Desert National Monument OrganizerThom Hulen 602-254-0695 [email protected] Conservation Program CoordinatorBorder Conservation Program CoordinatorBorder Conservation Program CoordinatorBorder Conservation Program CoordinatorBorder Conservation Program CoordinatorDan Millis 520-620-6401 [email protected] Regional OfficeSouthwest Regional OfficeSouthwest Regional OfficeSouthwest Regional OfficeSouthwest Regional OfficeRob Smith 602-254-9330 [email protected]

(x) Group Ex-ComMembers

(xc) 2008 ChapterExecutive Committee(Ex-Com) Members

BECOME INVOLVED:Contact a

representative inyour area to voiceyour concerns and

to participate inlocal activities.

VVVVVol. 4ol. 4ol. 4ol. 4ol. 44 No. 64 No. 64 No. 64 No. 64 No. 6November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008November/December 2008

Canyon Echo (ISSN 0164-7024) ispublished bimonthly for Sierra Club

members by the Sierra ClubGrand Canyon Chapter,

202 E. McDowell Rd., Ste. 277,Phoenix, AZ 85004.

Phone: 602-253-8633Fax: 602-258-6533

POSTMASTERPOSTMASTERPOSTMASTERPOSTMASTERPOSTMASTER Send address changes to Sierra Club

Member Services, c/o Canyon Echo, P.O. Box52968, Boulder, CO 80322-2968.

Periodicals postage paid atPhoenix, AZ. Printed at Valley Newspapers.

Copyright Sierra Club Grand CanyonChapter, Canyon Echo 2008.

EDITOREDITOREDITOREDITOREDITORTiffany Sprague602-253-9140

[email protected]

DEDICADEDICADEDICADEDICADEDICATED VTED VTED VTED VTED VOLOLOLOLOLUNTEERSUNTEERSUNTEERSUNTEERSUNTEERSOutings EditorOutings EditorOutings EditorOutings EditorOutings Editor

Jerry Nelson602-279-4668

[email protected]

PhotographersPhotographersPhotographersPhotographersPhotographersSergio Avila, Sandy Bahr, Priscilla Benbrook,Victoria Bevolden, Tom Carlson, Matt Clark,

Roy Emrick, Scott Mittelsteadt, Scott Sprague,Sean Sullivan, Kai Wiedenhofer

Mailing OrganizersMailing OrganizersMailing OrganizersMailing OrganizersMailing OrganizersBill Gill, Jerry Nelson

Publications CommitteePublications CommitteePublications CommitteePublications CommitteePublications CommitteeBob Ball, Priscilla Benbrook, Jon Findley,Kurt Florman, Jack Foster, Chris Gehlker,

Tricia Gerrodette, Renée Guillory,Jerry Nelson, Mike Smith

Publications ChairPublications ChairPublications ChairPublications ChairPublications ChairCarole Piszczek-Sheffield

[email protected]

WebmasterWebmasterWebmasterWebmasterWebmasterDawson Henderson

[email protected]

SUBSCRIPTIONSSUBSCRIPTIONSSUBSCRIPTIONSSUBSCRIPTIONSSUBSCRIPTIONSAnnual dues to the Sierra Club are $39

(including $1 for the Canyon Echo). Subscriptionrate for non-members is $10. Send check payable

to Sierra Club - Canyon Echo,202 E. McDowell Rd., Ste. 277

Phoenix, AZ 85004.

ADVERTISINGADVERTISINGADVERTISINGADVERTISINGADVERTISINGAdvertising is sold on a first-come, space-

available basis. The editor reserves the right torefuse any advertisements, and inclusion of

advertisements does not imply endorsement bythe Sierra Club. All interactions betweenadvertisers and consumers are solely the

responsibilities of those parties.

SUBMISSIONSSUBMISSIONSSUBMISSIONSSUBMISSIONSSUBMISSIONSSend electronic copies to the editor. Indicate

copyright or Creative Commons preference. Fordisks and hard copies, please label with yourname and the file name. Send a S.A.S.E. for

return of disk. We are not responsible for lost ordamaged items. Writer’s guidelines can be

obtained by contacting the editor. All rights topublication of articles in this issue are reserved.

The deadline is the first day of the monthfirst day of the monthfirst day of the monthfirst day of the monthfirst day of the monthpreceding the two months of the issue. Opinions

expressed in the Canyon Echo are those of thecontributors and do not necessarily reflect the

official views or policies of the Sierra Club.

CHAPTER OFFICES & COMMITTEE CHAIRSCHAPTER OFFICES & COMMITTEE CHAIRSCHAPTER OFFICES & COMMITTEE CHAIRSCHAPTER OFFICES & COMMITTEE CHAIRSCHAPTER OFFICES & COMMITTEE CHAIRSChairperson/Chairperson/Chairperson/Chairperson/Chairperson/Council:Council:Council:Council:Council: Jim Vaaler (xc) 602-553-8208 [email protected] :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair : Dale Volz(xc) 480-892-5102 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Elna Otter (xc) 520-212-9736 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: David McCaleb 602-840-7655 [email protected]:Fundraising:Fundraising:Fundraising:Fundraising: Jenny Roberts (xc) 480-488-2256 [email protected]:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation: Don Steuter (xc) 602-956-5057 [email protected] Chair:Nominations Chair:Nominations Chair:Nominations Chair:Nominations Chair: Michelle Pulich-Stewart 623-217-4093 [email protected] Chair:Political Chair:Political Chair:Political Chair:Political Chair: Lynn DeMuth 480-345-2626 [email protected] Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair: Bev Full (xc) 480-595-2306 [email protected] Chair:Energy Chair:Energy Chair:Energy Chair:Energy Chair: Jon Findley (xc) 480-756-2916 [email protected] Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair: Chris Gehlker 602-866-9024 [email protected] Chair:Elections Chair:Elections Chair:Elections Chair:Elections Chair: Tom Cadden 602-971-1528 [email protected] Chair:Publications Chair:Publications Chair:Publications Chair:Publications Chair: Carole Piszczek-Sheffield (xc)928-204-1517 [email protected] (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large): Tom Martin (xc) 928-556-0742 [email protected]

2008 Group Voting Representatives to Chapter Ex-Com:2008 Group Voting Representatives to Chapter Ex-Com:2008 Group Voting Representatives to Chapter Ex-Com:2008 Group Voting Representatives to Chapter Ex-Com:2008 Group Voting Representatives to Chapter Ex-Com:Palo Verde:Palo Verde:Palo Verde:Palo Verde:Palo Verde: Blair McLaughlin Saguaro:Saguaro:Saguaro:Saguaro:Saguaro: Louis LantzPlateau:Plateau:Plateau:Plateau:Plateau: Jim McCarthy SSSSSedona/Verde Valleedona/Verde Valleedona/Verde Valleedona/Verde Valleedona/Verde Valley:y:y:y:y: Marlene RaynerRincon:Rincon:Rincon:Rincon:Rincon: Keith Bagwell YYYYYaaaaavvvvvapai:apai:apai:apai:apai: Tom Slaback

PPPPPALALALALALO VERDE GRO VERDE GRO VERDE GRO VERDE GRO VERDE GROUP—PHOENIXOUP—PHOENIXOUP—PHOENIXOUP—PHOENIXOUP—PHOENIX http://arizona.sierraclub.org/paloverdehttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/paloverdehttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/paloverdehttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/paloverdehttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/paloverdeChair:Chair:Chair:Chair:Chair: Blair McLaughlin (x) 602-618-8591 [email protected]/ICO:Vice-Chair/ICO:Vice-Chair/ICO:Vice-Chair/ICO:Vice-Chair/ICO: Jim Vaaler (x) 602-553-8208 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Anna Tufo (x) 623-937-9471 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: Dan Cline 480-921-9242 [email protected]:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation: Don Steuter (x) 602-956-5057 [email protected]:Outings:Outings:Outings:Outings: vacantInner City Outings:Inner City Outings:Inner City Outings:Inner City Outings:Inner City Outings: Lisa Vaaler (x) 602-468-4158 [email protected] Chair:Programs Chair:Programs Chair:Programs Chair:Programs Chair: vacantPolit ical :Polit ical :Polit ical :Polit ical :Polit ical : John Sadowsky 480-839-6193 [email protected]:Energy:Energy:Energy:Energy: Jon Findley (x) 480-756-2916 [email protected]:Membership:Membership:Membership:Membership: Michael Brady (x) 480-990-9165 [email protected] (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large): Sherry Celine (x) 602-840-4611 [email protected]

Jerry Nelson (x) 602-279-4668 [email protected]

PLAPLAPLAPLAPLATEATEATEATEATEAU GRU GRU GRU GRU GRO6UP—FLAO6UP—FLAO6UP—FLAO6UP—FLAO6UP—FLAGSTGSTGSTGSTGSTAFFAFFAFFAFFAFF http://arizona.sierraclub.org/plateauhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/plateauhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/plateauhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/plateauhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/plateauChair/Programs:Chair/Programs:Chair/Programs:Chair/Programs:Chair/Programs: Jim McCarthy (x) 928-779-3748Vice Chair:Vice Chair:Vice Chair:Vice Chair:Vice Chair: Tom Martin (x) 928-556-0742 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: Sharon Galbreath 928-774-1571 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Mimi Torres (x) 928-226-8438 [email protected] Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair: Frank Schaffner 928-556-1564Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large): Kim Crumbo (x) 928-638-2304 [email protected]

Norm Wallen (x) 928-779-1192 [email protected]

RINCON GROUP—TUCSONRINCON GROUP—TUCSONRINCON GROUP—TUCSONRINCON GROUP—TUCSONRINCON GROUP—TUCSON http://arizona.sierraclub.org/rinconhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/rinconhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/rinconhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/rinconhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/rinconCo-Chair/TCo-Chair/TCo-Chair/TCo-Chair/TCo-Chair/Transporransporransporransporransportation:tation:tation:tation:tation: Keith Bagwell (x) 520-623-0269 [email protected]/Borderlands:Co-Chair/Borderlands:Co-Chair/Borderlands:Co-Chair/Borderlands:Co-Chair/Borderlands: Sean Sullivan (x) 520-250-9040 [email protected]:Programs:Programs:Programs:Programs: Isabel Segovia 520-250-1441 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Joy Herr-Cardillo (x) 520-622-1752 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: Jenny Neeley (x) 520-903-0899 [email protected] Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair:Membership Chair: vacantConservation Chair:Conservation Chair:Conservation Chair:Conservation Chair:Conservation Chair: Matt Hogel (x) 520-231-2517 [email protected] Outings:Inner-City Outings:Inner-City Outings:Inner-City Outings:Inner-City Outings: Matt Nelson 520-404-7992 [email protected] ical/Merchandise:Polit ical/Merchandise:Polit ical/Merchandise:Polit ical/Merchandise:Polit ical/Merchandise: Lee Oler 520-791-9246 [email protected] Chair:Newsletter Chair:Newsletter Chair:Newsletter Chair:Newsletter Chair: Linda Aaronson [email protected] Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair:Outings Chair: Mitch Stevens 520-647-3823 [email protected]:Webmaster:Webmaster:Webmaster:Webmaster: Bart Beck 520-885-8326 [email protected] (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large):Ex-Com (At-Large): Roy Emrick (x) 520-326-7883 [email protected]

Cory Lee Jones (x) 520-991-8899 [email protected]

SSSSSAAAAAGUGUGUGUGUARARARARARO GRO GRO GRO GRO GROUP—NORTHOUP—NORTHOUP—NORTHOUP—NORTHOUP—NORTH MARICOPMARICOPMARICOPMARICOPMARICOPA A A A A COUNTCOUNTCOUNTCOUNTCOUNTY Y Y Y Y http://arizona.sierraclub.org/saguarhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/saguarhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/saguarhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/saguarhttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/saguaroooooChair/Outings:Chair/Outings:Chair/Outings:Chair/Outings:Chair/Outings: Bev Jones-Full (x) 480-595-2306 [email protected]/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings: Louis Lantz (x) 480-488-4581 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Jean Miyake (x) 480-502-1485 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: Urb Weidner 602-595-3301 [email protected]:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation: Randy Collins 970-215-3132 [email protected]:Hospitality:Hospitality:Hospitality:Hospitality: Norma Hand (x) 480-595-9977 [email protected] Club:Film Club:Film Club:Film Club:Film Club: Lynne Cockrum-Murphy (x) 602-569-6078 [email protected] ical :Polit ical :Polit ical :Polit ical :Polit ical : Joel Sinclaire (x) 480-502-9614 [email protected]:Publicity:Publicity:Publicity:Publicity: Doug Murphy 602-569-6078 [email protected]:Membership:Membership:Membership:Membership: Mary Zedick (x) 602-841-5889 [email protected]:Webmaster:Webmaster:Webmaster:Webmaster: Elizabeth Diethelm 480-585-6089 [email protected]

SEDONA/VERDE VALLEY GROUPSEDONA/VERDE VALLEY GROUPSEDONA/VERDE VALLEY GROUPSEDONA/VERDE VALLEY GROUPSEDONA/VERDE VALLEY GROUP http://arizona.sierraclub.org/sedonahttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/sedonahttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/sedonahttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/sedonahttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/sedonaChair/Editor:Chair/Editor:Chair/Editor:Chair/Editor:Chair/Editor: Marlene Rayner (x) 928-203-0340 [email protected] :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair :Vice-Chair : Bob Donahue (x) 928-639-1885 [email protected]:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Nancy Baer 928-204-2353 [email protected]:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer:reasurer: Bertha Cook (x) [email protected]:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation:Conservation: Brian Myers (x) 928-204-1703 [email protected]:Education:Education:Education:Education: Dennis Rayner (x) 928-203-0340 [email protected]:Outings:Outings:Outings:Outings: Nancy Reynolds 928-649-3065 [email protected]

YYYYYAAAAAVVVVVAPAPAPAPAPAI GRAI GRAI GRAI GRAI GROUP—PRESCOOUP—PRESCOOUP—PRESCOOUP—PRESCOOUP—PRESCOTTTTTTTTTT http://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapaihttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapaihttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapaihttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapaihttp://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapaiChair/Conservation:Chair/Conservation:Chair/Conservation:Chair/Conservation:Chair/Conservation: Tom Slaback (x) 928-778-4233 [email protected]/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings:Vice-Chair/Outings: Carolyn York (x) 928-541-1952Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary:Secretary: Joe Wenzel (x) 928-771-0838 [email protected]:Political:Political:Political:Political: Bob Grossman (x) 928-778-4919 [email protected]:Outings:Outings:Outings:Outings: Gary Beverly 928-636-2638 [email protected]:Membership:Membership:Membership:Membership: Doris Cellarius 928-778-6724 [email protected]

Canyon Echo

GRANDCANYONCHAPTER

TTTTTu c s o nu c s o nu c s o nu c s o nu c s o n

P r e s c o t tP r e s c o t tP r e s c o t tP r e s c o t tP r e s c o t t

F l a g s t a f fF l a g s t a f fF l a g s t a f fF l a g s t a f fF l a g s t a f f

PPPPPALALALALALO O O O O VERDEVERDEVERDEVERDEVERDE

YAYAYAYAYAVVVVVAPAPAPAPAPAIAIAIAIAI

SEDONA/ VERDESEDONA/ VERDESEDONA/ VERDESEDONA/ VERDESEDONA/ VERDEVVVVVALLEALLEALLEALLEALLEYYYYY

P h o e n i xP h o e n i xP h o e n i xP h o e n i xP h o e n i x

PLPLPLPLPLAAAAATEATEATEATEATEAUUUUU

SAGUAROSAGUAROSAGUAROSAGUAROSAGUARO

RINCONRINCONRINCONRINCONRINCON

NNNNNooooovvvvvember/Dember/Dember/Dember/Dember/December 2008ecember 2008ecember 2008ecember 2008ecember 2008 Canyon EchoCanyon EchoCanyon EchoCanyon EchoCanyon Echo


33333

GGGGGrand Canyrand Canyrand Canyrand Canyrand Canyon Chapter – on Chapter – on Chapter – on Chapter – on Chapter – WhatWhatWhatWhatWhat’’’’’s Gs Gs Gs Gs Going Ooing Ooing Ooing Ooing On?n?n?n?n?UUUUUranium Franium Franium Franium Franium Film Scrilm Scrilm Scrilm Scrilm Screening: A Legacy of Deening: A Legacy of Deening: A Legacy of Deening: A Legacy of Deening: A Legacy of Destrestrestrestrestructionuctionuctionuctionuction

SSSSSaturaturaturaturaturdaydaydaydayday, N, N, N, N, Nooooovvvvvember 15ember 15ember 15ember 15ember 155:30–8:00 p.m.5:30–8:00 p.m.5:30–8:00 p.m.5:30–8:00 p.m.5:30–8:00 p.m.

NNNNNorororororthern Arizthern Arizthern Arizthern Arizthern Arizona Uona Uona Uona Uona Univnivnivnivniversityersityersityersityersity’’’’’s Cline Librars Cline Librars Cline Librars Cline Librars Cline Library (Fy (Fy (Fy (Fy (Flagstafflagstafflagstafflagstafflagstaff )))))

Join us for a screening of Poison Wind, Homeland, and River that Harms, followed bydiscussion with community members impacted by uranium mining in the southwest,activists fighting the resurgence of mining, and Poison Wind’s producers. Also, livemusic by Clan/Destine. Donations for the Havasupai post-flood rebuilding effortsappreciated! Hosted by Sierra Club, Center for Biological Diversity, and NAU’sGraduate Association of Political Science.

For more information, contact Stacey Hamburg at 928-774-6514 [email protected].

WWWWWelcome aboarelcome aboarelcome aboarelcome aboarelcome aboard, Dd, Dd, Dd, Dd, Dan Man Man Man Man Millis!illis!illis!illis!illis!

Please join us in welcoming Dan Millis as the Sierra Club’s new border projectorganizer. Dan will be working for the Grand Canyon Chapter out of theRincon Group’s Tucson office and will be focusing on implementing theChapter’s Campaign to Restore and Protect the U.S./Mexico Border Region.He will work to inform the public about the impacts of border activities aswell as the unprecedented powers given to the Secretary of Homeland Securityvia Section 102 of the REAL ID Act. This work will include providinginformation and outreach materials about the dangers, negative environmentaljustice ramifications, and environmental degradation of our country’s borderwith Mexico. Dan has strong organizing skills, has worked extensively withvolunteers, and is very knowledgeable about the borderlands and border issues.He can be reached at [email protected].

This summer, the Border Campaignof the Sierra Club finished a 20-minutevideo, Wild Versus Wall, about theenvironmental effects of the current borderpolicy. This video covers the ecologicaleffects of enforcement and infrastructurein the four states that share boundarieswith Mexico.

Tucson-based filmmaker Steev Hisebegan working on the film in January2008. He traveled to Texas and Californiato interview land managers, scientists, andactivists working to limit the ecologicalimpacts of border wall construction.

“I have been covering border issues insouthern Arizona for a while,” said Hise.“One of the great things about this projectwas traveling to other places along theborder and to see how people concernedabout the recent border militarization have

the same outlook as people do here. Theyare also trying to stop the Departmentof Homeland Security from runningroughshod over natural resources andconstitutional rights.”

Hise gathered footage from a diversearray of sources, including some of theBorder Patrol’s own employment videosthat show agents blazing along on off-roadvehicles. Numerous photographerscontributed images of the rich ecosystemsand species that are affected by borderinfrastructure projects, and local biologistslent their eyes and ears to the factualbackground of the habitats at stake. SeanSullivan and the border campaigncommittee worked alongside Hise to refinethe script, participate in interviews, andlink the narration to the broader SierraClub message: Homeland security is

important, but so are the environmentallaws that protect our homeland integrity.

The video premiered in Tucson inSeptember at a successful fundraiser thatCongressman Raúl Grijalva attended.Congressman Grijalva congratulated theBorder Campaign for a job well done, and Greta is a Sierra Club volunteer.

Wild VWild VWild VWild VWild Vererererersus Wsus Wsus Wsus Wsus WallallallallallBy Greta Anderson

Annual SAnnual SAnnual SAnnual SAnnual Sierra Club Hierra Club Hierra Club Hierra Club Hierra Club Holiday Poliday Poliday Poliday Poliday PararararartytytytytySSSSSaturaturaturaturaturdaydaydaydayday, D, D, D, D, December 13, 7 pecember 13, 7 pecember 13, 7 pecember 13, 7 pecember 13, 7 p.m..m..m..m..m.

4433 N. 874433 N. 874433 N. 874433 N. 874433 N. 87ththththth St., Scottsdale St., Scottsdale St., Scottsdale St., Scottsdale St., Scottsdale

Join us to celebrate the holiday season at a large central Scottsdale party house.BYOB and a quality potluck dish to share (please no pre-packaged snacks).Barbeque grill and crock-pot plug-ins available. Dress for the coldest; party isoutdoors with three firepits for warmth. Requested $5 donation.

For more information, directions, or to volunteer with clean-up on Sunday,contact Julia at [email protected].

Border wall trudging across the landscape. Photo by Sean Sullivan.

we promised to continue to push forpositive legislation on this issue. Moreinformation and a short version of thefilm can be found online at http://arizona.sierraclub.org/border.

Help Protect Ironwood Forest National MonumentSunday, November 23, 2008

8 a.m. – 3 p.m.

Our ongoing battle withbuffel grass continues. We willassist the Bureau of LandManagement with removingbuffel grass, a non-nativeinvasive grass, from a portionof the Ironwood ForestNational Monument nearTucson. We will remove thebuffel grass with bars andpicks – large and small – andbag it for disposal. The planis to work for 3–4 hours, havea lunch break, and finish upno later than 3 p.m. There willbe an orientation session onidentifying the grass and how

to safely remove it, plus a briefing on the monument and the vegetation. TheSierra Club will provide lunch. Wear closed-toe shoes and please bring water,a hat, sunscreen, some work gloves, and lots of energy. You may want to bringa sweatshirt as well as it could be cool in the early morning.

For more information and to RSVP, contact Sandy Bahr at602-253-8633 or [email protected].

Removing buffelgrass from Ironwood ForestNational Monument. Photo by Sandy Bahr.

Volunteer and Member Recognition PicnicSunday, November 16, 2008

11:30 a.m. – 2:30 p.m.North Mountain Recreation Area (Pima Ramada)

Join us for this fun Potluck and Volunteer/Member Awards Recognition Picnic andenjoy a beautiful fall day at NorthMountain. The Chapter will provide drinks,plates, and utensils. This is a free event– all you need to bring are your friendsand family and the dish you wish to

share. We will also have a silent auction.

Please RSVP to [email protected] or602-253-9140. Directions provided when you RSVP!

The event will be followed by a short interpretive hike.We hope you can join us!

Sierra ClubSierra ClubSierra ClubSierra ClubSierra Club Grand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon ChapterGrand Canyon Chapter


4

Sandy is the Chapter’s Conservation Outreach Director.

Cast of CharactersCast of CharactersCast of CharactersCast of CharactersCast of Characters

Jenny NeeleyJenny NeeleyJenny NeeleyJenny NeeleyJenny NeeleyInspirational VInspirational VInspirational VInspirational VInspirational Voluntoluntoluntoluntolunteereereereereer

For many years Jenny led the environmental charge on borderissues when she worked at Defenders of Wildlife. At that time,back in 2005, environmental groups were largely silent on theborder issue, even when Congress was gearing up to facilitatethe destruction of the borderlands through REAL ID. Jenny,being strong-willed and stubborn, fought every step of the wayto bring attention to this issue. She now continues this work forthe Rincon Group.

Jenny left Defenders of Wildlife to pursue a career in law.She now takes time in her busy schedule to volunteer with theBorderlands Committee of the Rincon Group, sits on theExecutive Committee of the Group, and is also the RinconGroup’s Treasurer. Jenny’s work on borderlands protection isinspiring, to say the least. Much of the work in which the SierraClub is currently engaged is a result of the foundation laid byJenny Neely. She is a remarkable asset for the Rincon Group,the Grand Canyon Chapter, and the borderlands. Thank you,Jenny. Our hat is off to you!

Water is essential for life. Arid lands such as Arizona’sdrive home that fact. Many of our species are adapted toliving with little water, but most of our communities arenot. Desert species take advantage of the smallest amountsof water and have evolved to conserve it, including plantsthat conduct transpiration at night and animals thatsqueeze every drop of moisture out of their food, so theirneeds for free-standing water are limited, if needed at all.Kangaroo rats and saguaro cacti are examples of speciesthat are adapted to arid lands.

To fuel growth, urban sprawl, green lawns, irrigatedagriculture, golf courses, and the myriad of activitiesinappropriate to our dry state, Arizona has killed many ofits rivers and streams. That means most of the native lifethat depends on those rivers and streams is in trouble –threatened, endangered, or, at a minimum, listed as a

What’s Up With WWhat’s Up With WWhat’s Up With WWhat’s Up With WWhat’s Up With Watatatatater?er?er?er?er?

species of concern. This is why 21 of the 36 fish specieshistorically native to Arizona are listed as threatened orendangered, and one species has gone extinct.

It is for these reasons and more that water is one ofthe Grand Canyon Chapter’s key priorities and why wehave a water issues group that works to advocate forprotection of water resources throughout the state.Volunteers are working actively to protect the San Pedro,Verde, Santa Cruz, and Colorado rivers, among others.People are acting to clean up Fossil Creek and to ensurethat this amazing effort at restoration is successful. Weare working to prevent excessive groundwater pumpingfrom drying up base flows for rivers and streams that arestill flowing and to keep Clean Water Act protectionsfor our Arizona waters.

The heart of our water issues work is the Upper VerdeWater Sentinels, a program that focuses on water qualityand quantity at seven sites along the upper and middleportions of the Verde River. We look at levels of E. coli,arsenic, phosphorous, and nitrogen about every othermonth and at sedimentation twice a year. Prescott-basedvolunteers measure flows every month at three sites, andwe do periodic clean ups on the Verde and its tributaries.

Jenny Neeley at Basaseachi Fall National Park, Mexico.Photo by Sergio Avila.

Those of us who love the wilderness seem to have aspecial attraction for the big predators – grizzlies, wolves,mountain lions, jaguars! Is there hard science behind ourwilderness advocacy for the big critters with claws andteeth? In Where the Wild Things Were, William Stolzenburgshows us how the top predators run things. Without thecarnivores, we find “deer hell,” an ecological meltdown.

In Arizona, we know the legend of the Kaibab Plateau,where killing off the wolves and lions and excluding humanhunters gave rise in the early 1900s to starving mule deer.It got so bad in the 1920s that cowboys and park rangersattempted to herd the deer south through Grand Canyonin hopes that they would find greener pastures on theSouth Rim. Deer can’t be driven, but they can starve bythe thousands – an ecological catastrophe that many ofus learned about in Aldo Leopold’s A Sand CountyAlmanac. With just a little hindsight, the “balance ofnature” seems to be such an obvious concept.

Stolzenburg takes us to distant wilderness areas, buthe also brings the issues to our suburban cul-de-sacs.Coyotes, it turns out, are the “keystone predator” thatmaintains the ecological community. In the case of westernsuburbia, the coyotes prey on our domestic kitty cats.The “little monsters,” as Stolzenburg calls them, representa mid-level niche of carnivores that can wreak havoc if notcontrolled themselves. Coyotes lunch on our kitties,teaching us to have the good grace to keep Puff in thehouse where she belongs. Songbirds thrive in my ownMesa housing development where coyotes have modifiedour cat-owner behavior from the day we moved in.

In Yellowstone, the rivers are healthier since the wolvescame back. No longer are too many elk chewing downthe willows and trampling the banks. Have the wolf packskilled so many since their brief return? It’s not so muchthe number they kill as it is the behaviors they teach. Elklearn to avoid being trapped near swift water. They canoutrun the pack in the open meadow, but browsing onthe willows along the Lamar could be fatal. Theuncontrolled elk herd once ran roughshod across themeadows of Yellowstone. Now the wolves instill a healthyfear and engender greater wildlife diversity: beaver, grizzlies,pronghorn, and eagles all do better when the valley is“managed” by the wolf pack.

Stolzenburg discloses his bias on the first page: heloves the “great flesh eating beasts.” We can go with himto Yellowstone and the Kaibab and enjoy the armchairadventures. We can also appreciate his love for the sciencebehind predator ecology – which gives us a solid place tostand when we argue the value of Mexican gray wolves inthe White Mountains.

Grand Canyon Chapter ’sGrand Canyon Chapter ’sGrand Canyon Chapter ’sGrand Canyon Chapter ’sGrand Canyon Chapter ’sBook CornerBook CornerBook CornerBook CornerBook Corner

WHERE THE WILD THINGS WEREBy William Stolzenburg, Bloomsbury, Lon-don, England, 2008. 291 pages.

Reviewed by Will Moore

Will is a Sierra Club member.

For more information and to find out how you canvolunteer for the Sierra Club’s water activities in

Arizona, please contact Sandy Bahr at602-253-8633 or [email protected].

Stephen Haskie at Fossil Creek cleanup. By Victoria Bevolden.

By Sandy Bahr



5

The Grand Canyon Chapter also wishes to thank allThe Grand Canyon Chapter also wishes to thank allThe Grand Canyon Chapter also wishes to thank allThe Grand Canyon Chapter also wishes to thank allThe Grand Canyon Chapter also wishes to thank allof the other generous and kind support receivedof the other generous and kind support receivedof the other generous and kind support receivedof the other generous and kind support receivedof the other generous and kind support received

from those who chose to remain anonymous.from those who chose to remain anonymous.from those who chose to remain anonymous.from those who chose to remain anonymous.from those who chose to remain anonymous.

FFFFFriends ($1–29)riends ($1–29)riends ($1–29)riends ($1–29)riends ($1–29)Renee GuilloryRick JohnsonLynn MarcusCarroll Munz

Hitched to Everything Else inHitched to Everything Else inHitched to Everything Else inHitched to Everything Else inHitched to Everything Else inthe Universe ($30–49)the Universe ($30–49)the Universe ($30–49)the Universe ($30–49)the Universe ($30–49)Ernest and Eve Simon

Keep Close to Nature’s HeartKeep Close to Nature’s HeartKeep Close to Nature’s HeartKeep Close to Nature’s HeartKeep Close to Nature’s Heart($50–99)($50–99)($50–99)($50–99)($50–99)Sarah King

The Morning Stars SingThe Morning Stars SingThe Morning Stars SingThe Morning Stars SingThe Morning Stars SingTTTTTogeogeogeogeogether ($300+)ther ($300+)ther ($300+)ther ($300+)ther ($300+)Dale and Christine Volz

Thank You to Our Donors!Thank You to Our Donors!Thank You to Our Donors!Thank You to Our Donors!Thank You to Our Donors!Continued thanks to the Earth Friends Wildlife Foundation for their support of our conservationwork here in Arizona. We hope to match their $10,000 challenge grant 10:1 and raise a total of$100,000 this year. Your donations help us meet that goal and will stay in Arizona to supportour work to protect our land, air, and water and the wildlife that depend on it all. Please be asgenerous as you can to help us meet this challenge and to leverage your dollars to do even more.

Giving Appreciated Securities to The Sierra Club FoundationGiving Appreciated Securities to The Sierra Club FoundationGiving Appreciated Securities to The Sierra Club FoundationGiving Appreciated Securities to The Sierra Club FoundationGiving Appreciated Securities to The Sierra Club FoundationBy Lori Sullivan

A charitable gift of long-term appreciated securities avoids capital gains taxes and,in most cases, the donor obtains a charitable income tax deduction equal to the marketvalue of the securities subject to IRS limitations.

If you have long-term appreciated securities (stocks, bonds, mutual funds) thatyou have owned for at least one year, you may want to consider contributing them as agift to the Grand Canyon Chapter’s Sierra Club Foundation (SCF) account.

Donating appreciated securities that you have held longer than one year allows youto do the following:

• Avoid all capital gains tax on the appreciation of the securities you donate.• Take a charitable income tax deduction for the full current market value of the

asset (if the gift exceeds 30% of your adjusted gross income, the excess may becarried forward for five years).

• For tax deduction purposes, base the value of your gift on the average salesprice of the stock on the date of transfer.

• Direct your gift to a specific fund or purpose.• Have the satisfaction of making a significant gift now.• Give a larger gift than you thought possible.• Supplement your income stream with a life income gift and benefit the SCF

later (contact the Planned Giving department for various options).

Giving Appreciated Securities to the Sierra ClubGiving Appreciated Securities to the Sierra ClubGiving Appreciated Securities to the Sierra ClubGiving Appreciated Securities to the Sierra ClubGiving Appreciated Securities to the Sierra ClubWhile a gift of appreciated securities to Sierra Club is not deductible as a charitable

gift for tax purposes, it is a high impact way to support the Club’s lobbying efforts withlittle out-of-pocket expense. A transfer of low basis stock to Sierra Club allows the stockto be sold with no capital gains tax on the proceeds, supporting the theory of “buyinglow and gifting high!”

Lori is the Deputy Director of Planned Giving for Sierra Club.

Thank you to everyone who participated in the Fossil Creekcleanup on September 27, 2008! Approximately 60 volunteersremoved 1,280 pounds of trash from the creek and roadside.Thank you to all participating organizations, including theArizona Ecumenical Council Earth Care CommissionArizona Ecumenical Council Earth Care CommissionArizona Ecumenical Council Earth Care CommissionArizona Ecumenical Council Earth Care CommissionArizona Ecumenical Council Earth Care Commission, andTTTTTonto Nonto Nonto Nonto Nonto National Fational Fational Fational Fational Forororororestestestestest for their assistance, and thanks also toSunflower MarketsSunflower MarketsSunflower MarketsSunflower MarketsSunflower Markets for their generous fruit donation.

Volunteers enjoy a bountiful lunch after the Fossil Creek cleanup.Photo by Victoria Bevolden.

Thank yThank yThank yThank yThank you, Fou, Fou, Fou, Fou, Fossil Cossil Cossil Cossil Cossil Crrrrreek Cleanup veek Cleanup veek Cleanup veek Cleanup veek Cleanup volunteers!olunteers!olunteers!olunteers!olunteers!

How to DonateHow to DonateHow to DonateHow to DonateHow to DonateIn an effort to make a stock transfer as effortless as possible, both the Sierra Club

and The Sierra Club Foundation have accounts at Charles Schwab.Please contact the Gift Planning Hotline at [email protected] or

800-932-4270 to inform us of your gift and to receive complete transfer instructions.Please provide the following information: name and address; anticipated date of transfer,brokerage information; restrictions on the purpose of the gift, if any; name of stock andnumber of shares; date stock was acquired; and special instructions (such as denotingthe gift is for the Grand Canyon Chapter’s Sierra Club Foundation account).

Please review your tax situation with your financial advisors before implementingany particular gift strategy.

Peter and Betty BengtsonSandy BahrJoni BoshRoy EmrickJon FindleyRick FreasBev FullRenée GuilloryThom HulenTom LazzelleFran and Bert Litman

Thank yThank yThank yThank yThank you to our Pou to our Pou to our Pou to our Pou to our Political Aolitical Aolitical Aolitical Aolitical ActionctionctionctionctionCommittee donors!Committee donors!Committee donors!Committee donors!Committee donors!

Scott MittelsteadtJanice MyersLee OlerDonald PiersonJenny RobertsKathy RoedigerScott and Tiffany SpragueDon SteuterJim VaalerDale and Christine Volz

OfficeOfficeOfficeOfficeOfficeThanks ToThanks ToThanks ToThanks ToThanks To

Priscilla BenbrookVictoria BevoldenRoberta Delaney

Sarah KingDale Volz

If you are interested in assisting in the office, please contact TiffanySprague at 602-253-9140 or [email protected].



6

Our Arizona Borderlands at RiskOur Arizona Borderlands at RiskOur Arizona Borderlands at RiskOur Arizona Borderlands at RiskOur Arizona Borderlands at Risk

Scott is a member of the Lower Rio Grande ValleySierrans and the No Border Wall Coalition.

Jenny is a member of the Rincon Group’sBorderlands Committee and attends law

school at the University of Arizona.

By Jenny Neeley

CherCherCherCherChertttttofofofofoff Pf Pf Pf Pf Paaaaays the Border Wys the Border Wys the Border Wys the Border Wys the Border Wall’s Price in Human Livall’s Price in Human Livall’s Price in Human Livall’s Price in Human Livall’s Price in Human Liveseseseses

In 2007, in response to a lawsuitby the Sierra Club and Defenders ofWildlife, a U.S. district court ordered ahalt to construction of the border wallthrough the San Pedro Riparian NationalConservation Area. Department ofHomeland Security (DHS) SecretaryMichael Chertoff responded, “I have to sayto myself, ‘Yes, I don’t want to disturb thehabitat of a lizard, but am I prepared topay human lives to do that?’” He thenwaived 19 federal laws, using the un-precedented power granted him by theREAL ID Act to override the judge’s order,and immediately resumed construction ofthe border wall through the last free-flowing river in southern Arizona. This pastApril he issued another waiver, which sweptaside well over 30 laws to enable theconstruction of walls along the southernborder.

Secretary Chertoff ’s statement wasintended to mislead the American peopleinto believing that the environmentaldamage caused by border walls is thenecessary cost of protecting U.S. citizens.When confronted with a “lizards vs.humans” choice, almost anyone willdefend the latter. But it is a lie, and Chertoffknows it.

By Scott Nicol

While the walls built along the U.S.-Mexico border since the 1990s have donetremendous environmental damage, theyhave not saved human lives nor reducedthe number of undocumented immigrantswho enter the country each year. Fourmonths before Chertoff claimed that if wedo not build walls we must be “preparedto pay human lives,” the CongressionalResearch Service found that the border wall“did not have a discernible impact on theinflux of unauthorized aliens coming acrossthe border.”

The border wall has instead causedthousands of deaths. In 2006 the U.S.Government Accountability Office (GAO)looked at the border wall’s human toll sincethe erection of the first California sectionsin the mid 1990s. They found that,although the number of border-crossingdeaths had been declining in the 1980sand early 1990s, deaths began increasingin 1995 and almost doubled by 2005. Acorresponding increase in the number ofillegal entries did not occur.

This increase in deaths occurredbecause the border walls did not stoppeople from entering the U.S.; they onlyrerouted them. Confronted with an 18-foot high wall near San Diego, desperate

immigrants did not turn around and gohome. They went around it. Rather thancrossing in safer urban areas, thousandsinstead came in through the desert. As aresult, more than 5,000 have died fromdehydration and exposure, and it isestimated that thousands of bodies lieundiscovered.

The border wall does not present theU.S. with a choice of either saving theenvironment or saving human lives. The

wall takes a terrible toll on both. The realchoice is whether or not to build morewalls, knowing that they will do irrepa-rable environmental damage and causethousands more to die. By choosing tobuild more walls, Michael Chertoff hasshown that he is in fact “prepared to payhuman lives.”

Border wall with road on both sides. Photo by Matt Clark.

Ladder by border wall. Photo by Tom Carlson.

Known for its ruggedisolation and stark beauty,Arizona’s border region islargely comprised of pro-tected federal lands. Arizona’sborderlands include nationalmonuments, wildlife re-fuges, national forests, andwilderness areas, and theyrepresent some of the mostunique and valuable wildlifehabitats in the nation.These areas provide stunningexamples of the incrediblebiodiversity and naturalbeauty found in the border-lands region.

Until the mid-1990s,this area remained largely unaffected byun-documented immigration, as mostborder crossings took place in urban areas.However, this changed when Border Patrolbegan to redirect migrant traffic into theremote deserts of Arizona. It is estimatedthat over half of undocumented migrantsfrom Mexico now cross through Arizona’sdeserts, mountains, and rivers.

To visit public lands along the bordertoday is to see first-hand the result of thisquestionable strategy. The damage causedby migrants is undeniably significant:foot and vehicle traffic has created milesof illegal roads, and trash dots thelandscape. However, these impacts are faroutweighed by the damage being causedby Border Patrol activities. Road and wallconstruction, 24-hour lighting, and dailyoff-road vehicle patrols are damaging fragiledesert vegetation, fragmenting importantwildlife habitat, and interrupting criticalmigration corridors for cross-border species.While trash can be picked up and foot trails

restored, the enforcement activities are hereto stay and the impact is profound.

No one denies that security along thenation’s borders is a priority, but, like allfederal agencies, the Department ofHomeland Security (DHS) should beresponsible for conducting its operationsin a lawful and transparent fashion.Environmental laws, such as the En-dangered Species Act and the NationalEnvironmental Policy Act, govern theactions of federal agencies and give thepublic a voice in the process. Border Patrol’scompliance with these laws is critical,especially now when the agency has shiftedits major operations onto some of ournation’s most spectacular and fragile publiclands.

However, thanks to an unprecedentedwaiver authority granted to DHS, anyeffort to comply with these and otherimportant federal laws has been com-pletely abandoned. In 2005, the REALID Act was passed by Congress. Section

walls and infrastructure across almost 500miles in all four border states.

It is clear after 15 years that un-documented immigration is not a problemthat can be solved at the border. Withouta comprehensive effort to address the rootcauses of immigration, migrants willcontinue risking their lives to cross theborderlands. The wildlife and wildlandsfound along the border will continue tosuffer unless Congress rescinds Section 102of the REAL ID Act and sends a clearmessage that the DHS is not above thelaw.

102 of this Act givesthe Secretary of DHSsweeping and un-precedented authorityto exempt the agencyfrom all applicablelaws when buildinginfrastructure along theborder.

Since the REAL IDAct was signed, DHShas used the waiverauthority four times,most recently in April2008. Stunning in itsscope, this waiver setaside 38 laws to build

In 2007, Congressman Raúl Grijalva introduced the In 2007, Congressman Raúl Grijalva introduced the In 2007, Congressman Raúl Grijalva introduced the In 2007, Congressman Raúl Grijalva introduced the In 2007, Congressman Raúl Grijalva introduced the Border LandsBorder LandsBorder LandsBorder LandsBorder LandsConservation and Security ActConservation and Security ActConservation and Security ActConservation and Security ActConservation and Security Act, H.R. 2593, which seeks to protect our, H.R. 2593, which seeks to protect our, H.R. 2593, which seeks to protect our, H.R. 2593, which seeks to protect our, H.R. 2593, which seeks to protect ourborderlands.borderlands.borderlands.borderlands.borderlands. H.R. 2593 takes a common sense approach to border policy andattempts to correct current harmful policies. If passed, the act will better protectsensitive ecosystems along the border and will ensure that migratory routes usedby animals such as the jaguar remain open and viable.

It is time to support a better solution to border security. H.R. 2593 will dothe following:

• Repeal section 102 of the REAL ID Act and require compliance withfederal, state, and local laws meant to protect clean air, water, wildlife,culture, health, safety, and quality of life.

• Provide experts at the Department of Homeland Security with the abilityto decide whether walls, vehicle barriers, or virtual fences would be mostappropriate along the border.

• Give land management agencies and local, state, and tribal officials avoice in border infrastructure decision-making.

• Fund initiatives that will help mitigate damage to borderland wildlifeand resources.

Please support this bill and contact your representative and urge him/herPlease support this bill and contact your representative and urge him/herPlease support this bill and contact your representative and urge him/herPlease support this bill and contact your representative and urge him/herPlease support this bill and contact your representative and urge him/herto co-sponsor H.R. 2593.to co-sponsor H.R. 2593.to co-sponsor H.R. 2593.to co-sponsor H.R. 2593.to co-sponsor H.R. 2593. Representatives Grijalva and Pastor are currently theonly members of the Arizona Congressional delegation who support the bill.



7

Border WBorder WBorder WBorder WBorder Wall Harms Wildlifall Harms Wildlifall Harms Wildlifall Harms Wildlifall Harms WildlifeeeeeBy Matt Clark

Matt is the Southwest Representative forDefenders of Wildlife.

Protecting Habitat on Both Sides of the BorderProtecting Habitat on Both Sides of the BorderProtecting Habitat on Both Sides of the BorderProtecting Habitat on Both Sides of the BorderProtecting Habitat on Both Sides of the Border

Sergio is a Wildlife Biologistwith Sky Island Alliance.

The border wall is a classic example ofhabitat fragmentation – one of the leadingcauses of species extinction. As human-created barriers such as highways andwalls bisect the land, onceintact wildlife habitat becomesfragmented and less permeableto wildlife movements. Oneof the insidious consequencesof fragmentation is that itcreates smaller, more isolatedhabitat patches and wildlifepopulations – the negativeeffects of which may not becomeapparent for decades. Isolatedwildlife populations are prone tomore dramatic fluctuations fromyear to year, are less resilient tonatural disturbances, have ahigher probability of localextinction, and are robbed ofthe crucial genetic interchangethat keeps wildlife populationshealthy. Fragmentation mayalso preclude access to watersources, seasonally-available foodresources, and new territories.The importance of maintainingand/or restoring habitat connectivity is afundamental principle that has emergedfrom wildlife conservation sciences in thepast two decades.

The border wall is causing habitatdestruction, degradation, and fragmenta-tion at a regional scale for a wide array ofwildlife – creatures that do not recognizearbitrary political boundaries. Numerouscross-border wildlife linkages have alreadybeen severed by the wall; the wall itself isredirecting traffic into adjacent habitats.Clearly, more scientific research is neededto quantify these impacts.

Several on-the-ground examples havebeen documented:

In southern California, 1.9 milliontons of dirt are being used to fill

Smuggler’s Gulch in order to construct awall across this steep canyon. Thisthreatens to increase sediment flows intothe ecologically-sensitive Tijuana RiverEstuary, which provides habitat for fourfederally-listed endangered birds: the light-footed clapper rail, the California least tern,the least Bell’s vireo, and the Californiabrown pelican.

Both deer and javelina have beendocumented along the wall in the vicinityof the San Pedro Riparian NationalConservation Area, apparently unable tocross the border because of the wall.

A Compatibility Determination forthe then-proposed border wall on theBuenos Aires National Wildlife Refugeconcluded the wall was not compatible

with the refuge’s mission andregulations, stating: “The barrierwould fragment habitat on therefuge, thereby adversely affectingthe ecological integrity of therefuge’s natural resources…. Thebarrier would adversely affectendangered species (jaguar),migratory birds (pygmy-owls), andimportant habitats (Arivaca Creek)on the refuge, thereby conflictingwith stated management goals forthe refuge....” A controversial landswap was orchestrated, and the wallwas built anyway. Border Patrolrecently documented an aggravatedmountain lion on the refugeunsuccessfully attempting to getthrough the border wall to theMexican side of its habitat.

A recent Biological Opinionfrom the U.S. Fish and WildlifeService states, “Shifting [illegalalien] activity has already occurred

in Arizona and California as a result of fenceconstruction or increased [Customs andBorder Protection] staffing.” The wallcontinues to funnel traffic and disturbanceinto remote, rugged, and ecologicallysensitive areas. The Biological Opinionprovides eight documented examples ofthis phenomenon, some of whichare anticipated to negatively affectthreatened and endangered species suchas the Sonoran pronghorn, jaguar, Mexicanspotted owl, and Chiricahua leopard frog.

The Sky Island region, a vast area ofisolated mountain ranges surrounded bydeserts and grasslands, is well known forits unique biodiversity and natural beauty.This region is the confluence of four majorecosystems: the Rocky Mountains, theSierra Madre Occidental, and the Sonoranand the Chihuahuan deserts. Located alongthe U.S.-Mexico international border, theregion is important at a continental levelfor its migration corridors and habitats fordiverse fauna.

The Sky Islands are the merginggrounds of tropical and temperate climates,where southern and northern species findtheir outermost distribution ranges. Variedclimate, geology, and rugged topographymake for a wide diversity of plants, insects,amphibians, reptiles, and resident andmigratory birds. Historically, grizzly bearsand Mexican gray wolves roamed in thisregion, and, in the last decade, several wildjaguars have been recorded in the SkyIslands of southeastern Arizona andsouthwestern New Mexico. At least fourmale jaguars have been recorded andmonitored since 1996 in the borderlands,the last one as recently as 2007. Possiblyusing the linkages that connect largeexpanses of habitat, such as between the

By Sergio Avila

Tumacacori Highlands and Sierra LaEsmeralda or possibly the San Pedro River,as migrating corridors, individual catshave traveled from source populations inSonora, Mexico, into the U.S. Those andother international biological corridorsprovide essential permeability for wildlifemigration and colonization.

Habitat fragmentation and destruc-tion are serious threats to wildlife speciesliving in the border region. Wildfelines, including jaguars and mountainlions, prefer dense vegetation for protection,ambushing their prey, feeding, anddispersing. The construction of a barrier,such as the border wall, affects wildlifepopulations, endangered or not. Thisinfrastructure will disrupt, segment, andisolate plant and wildlife populations onboth sides of the border, potentiallyaffecting the border region ecosystems as awhole.

In February 2007, Sky Island Allianceinitiated wildlife surveys using remotecamera traps and tracking transects onprivate properties of northern Sonora.The Cuatro Gatos Project goal is to buildcooperative relationships with landownersin order to facilitate ongoing scientificresearch, encourage large predator

conservation, and protect patches of habitatthroughout the region.

Sky Island Alliance has recorded over20 species of wild mammals in the region.In March 2007, another tropical cat, theocelot, was captured by the cameras; todate we have identified two individualsliving only 25 miles south of the border.There are five records of ocelots in Arizona,the latest from 1967, and 36 in Sonora.These results turned into conservationaction when Sky Island Alliance andRancho El Aribabi signed a conservation

Javelina at border wall. Photo by Matt Clark, Defenders of Wildlife.

agreement to protect and restore 10,000acres of riparian, desert, and upland wildlifehabitat. Rancho El Aribabi, located only30 miles south of the border, hosts over30 endangered or threatened species of floraand fauna and leads the steps towardconserving native species and habitats innorthwest Mexico. We look forward tomore partnerships with landowners topromote the protection of habitat as a seriesof protected wildlife corridors.

Ocelot photographed by remote camera near the border. Photo courtesy of Sky Island Alliance.



8

Ephemeral TEphemeral TEphemeral TEphemeral TEphemeral Trashrashrashrashrash

Roy is an active Sierra Club member andPresident of Friends of Buenos Aires NWR.

No WNo WNo WNo WNo Waaaaay ty ty ty ty to To To To To Treat a Rreat a Rreat a Rreat a Rreat a Refugeefugeefugeefugeefuge

Randy has lived in the Arizona border regionfor 18 years and works as San Pedro CampaignManager for the Center for Biological Diversity.

By Randy Serraglio

Last spring my partner and I hikedup Ramsey Canyon, the renowned birdhaven in southeastern Arizona, with theintent to probe the dark heart of theHuachuca Mountains for thetantalizing treasure of massmigration. Unfortunately, inthe deserts and Sky Islandsof the Arizona border region,the thrilling beauty of avianmigration is accompaniedby the grinding tragedy ofhuman migration.

In the first couple ofmiles, we were so bedazzledby tanagers and trogons andflycatchers busily plyingriparian thickets and flittingthrough oak canopies that wemade little headway. Whenwe stopped for lunch wellafter noon, we sized up theremains of the day and decided to pushthrough to our original goal, the crest ofBear Saddle and its sweeping vista of theheadwaters of the San Pedro River innorthern Mexico.

As we climbed away from Ramsey’sperennial water, the birds declined in

diversity. A flock of pine siskin numberingin the hundreds raised an impressivehissing racket as it flowed from treetop totreetop through the forest. On this trail

segment, we also encountered evidence ofhuman migration, traveling the samedirection and threatening to outnumberthe siskin. Arrays of trash marked thehollows where camps had been made andmeetings arranged. All manner of articleslay there, from empty tins of frijoles and

drink containers boasting of “electrólitos!”to toiletries and perfectly good clothes.

We stopped at one such makeshiftmini-dump to gather our breath in the

thinning air and ourthoughts on the matter.What misconceptions(or lies) compel peopleto carry such items asdeodorant and designerjeans for miles throughthe wilderness, only todrop them here? More-over, considering mytightening tendons andthe incipient blisterson my toes, what onearth compels people tocome this way in thefirst place?

After a dozen yearsof work on border-

related issues in Arizona, I have that answerreadily at hand: our tax dollars at work.Since the mid-’90s, the federal governmenthas pursued a strategy of choking offtraditional routes of surreptitious migrationinto the U.S. near ports of entry andconsciously pushing border crossers into

The border wall has had a majornegative impact on wild lands insouthern Arizona. The major andmost obvious effect is its preventionof wildlife migration. Another is thegreat drain on staff time. Wildliferefuges are already underfunded by thisadministration, so diverting staff timefrom management issues to wall issuesfurther erodes daily operations.

A temporary vehicle barrier wasinstalled along the southern boundaryof the Buenos Aires National WildlifeRefuge (NWR), southwest of Tucson,somewhat over a year ago. The Feds hadcontrol of a 60-foot wide strip alongthe border except for a 0.8-mile longsegment. In order to build the wall, theyrammed through an EnvironmentalAssessment, saying that a wall wouldn’tmake much of a difference because abarrier was already in place. The RefugeManager at the time, Mitch Ellis, had asay for only the 0.8 miles, which hadbeen a private ranch that extended allthe way to the border and was includedin the Refuge purchase in 1985. Mitchfound that the wall was not compatiblewith the mission of the Refuge. Thatdecision took time and courage. TheDepartment of Homeland Security(DHS) got the U.S. Fish and WildlifeService to do a land swap for the ranchproperty. They then built a wall sinceMitch no longer had jurisdiction.The Refuge has not received land inexchange.

Since Mitch left, the acting managerhas had to deal with all sorts of issues

with DHS and Border Patrol on theRefuge. The virtual-wall towers are justthe latest episode of such dealings. Whilenot as obtrusive as a physical wall, roadsto the towers for construction andmaintenance do impact the land, as doall of the related activities.

The bollard “pedestrian barrier”along the refuge border has four-inchgaps that stop all wider animals. Thewall only slows humans – it does notstop them (even I could shinny part ofthe way up). For construction, the landis stripped bare for at least 100 feet fromthe wall. Even after construction, amaintenance road remains.

The recruiting billboards forBorder Patrol show young, macho guysstanding next to four-wheel drivevehicles on pristine desert. The messageI get is “join us and joyride in the desertat taxpayers’ expense.” I’ve seen it happenon the Refuge, and local residentscomplain about the noise and dust near

homes. Border Patrol is aware of theproblem and says it is going to do somesensitivity training.

Buenos Aires isn’t the only Arizonaborder refuge to be affected. Among themain features of the San BernardinoNWR, east of Douglas, are its springs.I was there a couple of years ago afterthey had started stripping the landfor a permanent vehicle barrier. Theconstruction vehicles had churnedthrough some of the springs, leavingdeep, muddy tracks. I shudder to think

The Canyon Echo encourages its contributors to license their work through CreativeCommons. This set of icons indicates that the contributor has chosen the CreativeCommons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license:

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike License. To view a copy of this license,visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.5 or senda letter to Creative Commons, 543 Howard Street, 5th Floor, SanFrancisco, California 94105.

All other contributions, including photos, cartoons, and written work, fall under standardcopyright restrictions.

By Roy Emrick

LEFT: Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge. Photo by Scott Sprague. RIGHT: Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge at the border. By Roy Emrick.

more remote areas as a calculated deter-rent. The recent blitz of incredibly costlyand environmentally-damaging wallconstruction is the latest iteration of thisone-dimensional interdiction policy.

While this strategy has utterly failedto control undocumented immigration, ithas succeeded in steamrolling fundamentallegal protections for the environment andcausing direct harm to border ecosystems.The fence fragments and destroys habitat,blocks wildlife movements that are crucialto the healthy biological functionsof various species, and threatens todramatically and permanently alter thehydrology of precious water courses suchas the San Pedro.

Trash is a significant facet of theproblem, especially since migrant trails nowpass through far more environmentallysensitive areas than ever before. But trashis ephemeral – it can be cleaned up. Thefar greater ecosystem-level impacts of thewall may persist for generations, if notindefinitely.

Sierra Club members removing trash from the border area. Photo by Sean Sullivan.

of what it looks like now after the wallbuilders have been there.

DHS and Border Patrol like to sayhow much trash the border crossersdeposit. It is indeed awesome. However,I and many other folks, includingmembers of Sierra Club, have andcontinue to clean up the trash. Theenvironmental damage done by the wallwill take decades to heal, if the wall isever removed. In the meantime, thetraffic continues.



9

Broken Promises, Broken HomeBroken Promises, Broken HomeBroken Promises, Broken HomeBroken Promises, Broken HomeBroken Promises, Broken HomeFFFFFor the Tor the Tor the Tor the Tor the Tohono O’odham, the borohono O’odham, the borohono O’odham, the borohono O’odham, the borohono O’odham, the border wder wder wder wder wall threatall threatall threatall threatall threatens land and lifens land and lifens land and lifens land and lifens land and life we we we we waaaaaysysysysys

Priscilla graduated from Arizona State Universitywith degrees in Conservation Biology and English.She is a member of the Kaw Nation of Oklahoma.

Sierra Club has always opposed theNorth American Free Trade Agreement(NAFTA). Fifteen years after its inception,NAFTA has proven to be the predicteddisaster. Trained career jobs, with livingwages, were lost in all three countries(Canada, U.S., and Mexico). In the case ofthe U.S. and Canada, those jobs were lostand not to return. In Mexico’s case, over 2million jobs were lost in the agriculturalsectors and 28,000 small businesses wentout of business due to the lift on taxes andtariffs that enabled Wal-Marts and heavilysubsidized crops to overcome the Mexicaneconomy. Those jobs were replaced by verylow-wage, high-impact industrial workalong the northern border of Mexico.

Almost overnight, millions of Mexicanfarmers (mostly from the southern partsof Mexico) migrated north for work in theMaquila (industrial manufacturer) sector.The working environment that exists inmaquiladoras (factories in Maquila sectors)includes 10 hours or more a day, 50 hoursor more a week, no pension, no raises,exposure to violently harsh chemicals andpolluted air – all for $6–10 a day.

Since NAFTA was created, local andnational labor, environmental, consumer,family farm, religious, and other civilsociety groups have petitioned Washingtonto do something to mitigate impacts ofNAFTA and other Free Trade Agreements(FTAs). Although it has been a long andslow process, Washington is starting tolisten.

With the momentum of the currentelection, the hope for a new administration,and the possibility of making a progressivechange in international trade policy,

NAFTNAFTNAFTNAFTNAFTA turns 15, and WA turns 15, and WA turns 15, and WA turns 15, and WA turns 15, and Washingtashingtashingtashingtashington is Son is Son is Son is Son is Startartartartarting tting tting tting tting to Listo Listo Listo Listo Listen!en!en!en!en!

a proposal has been made.Introduced by Sen. SherrodBrown (D-OH) and Rep.Michael Michaud (D-ME), theTrade, Reform, Accountability,Development, and Employ-ment (TRADE) Act is designedto explain what a successful andaccountable trade agreementlooks like. The initiative kept thefollowing in mind: economicjustice and promotion of basichuman rights, environmentalwell-being, and healthy andsustainable communities. Spe-cifically, it will lay down thefoundation for the review andrevision of dated policies(NAFTA, FTAs, etc.), thedefinition of “responsible” or“good” trade policies, what mustand must not be included in future U.S.trade agreements, and the oversight andenforcement of labor and environ-mentallaws concerning trade policies. Sierra ClubNational has endorsed the TRADE Actand has been lobbying for support inWashington.

Matt is the Rincon Group’s Conservation Chair.

By Matt Hogel

From-the-ground perspective. Photographer anonymous.

Recycle your CFLs!

Although compactfluorescent lightbulbslast much longer thanincandescents, theycan burn out. Don’tjust throw them away!

A number of places offerrecycling services, includingHome Depot, Ace Hardware,and many others. For moreinformation, visit http://www.sierraclub.org/cfl.

On July 12, 2008, a moderatemonsoon storm dumped 1.5–2.0 inchesof rain in 90 minutes near Lukeville,Arizona. Located on the southern borderof Organ Pipe Cactus National Mon-ument, Lukeville is adjacent to the TohonoO’odham reservation and the U.S.-Mexico“pedestrian fence.”

Storms of such magnitude are standardin the area, occurring approximately everythree years. The desert is equipped to dealwith such extremes; however, with the newwall erected, havoc broke loose. The north-

south flow of several drainages wasimpeded, causing water and debris tocollect along the U.S. side of the wall.Water levels along the fence reached sevenfeet. Bottlenecked, the drainages overflowedtheir banks, resulting in severe erosion andsilt deposition.

For the Tohono O’odham, theecological devastation caused by the wallparallels the cultural crisis it leaves in itswake. Formerly known as the Papago, theTohono O’odham (“Desert People”) haveresided in the area for thousands of years.

The land they called Papagueria wasinitially bisected under the 1853Gadsden Purchase, which created theU.S.-Mexico border.

The REAL ID Act appears to aimat irrevocably deepening the chasm.Secretary of Homeland SecurityMichael Chertoff wasted no time inerecting his bully pulpit on O’odhamland. O’odham sovereignty wassquelched before the first shovel hitthe ground. The insults continued.

Sacred sites were desecrated.In 2007 contractors so brazenlydefiled an ancient burial ground thathuman remains were observed in theequipment’s tire tracks. The Nation’s

communication seemed perpetuallydestined for Chertoff ’s circular file. Whenconcerns were expressed about the impactof construction on jaguar habitat andcultural sites, the O’odham Council wasignored.

Also waived was the American IndianReligious Freedom Act (AIRFA). AIRFAacknowledges the rights of the O’odhamto travel safely and freely across the bordervia traditional routes. Many of the routesare ancient pilgrimage routes to still-usedceremonial sites such as Quitovac in

Mexico. The 15-foot tall steel-posted“pedestrian fence” will all but stop suchmovement.

According to Ofelia Rivas, anO’odham elder and activist, “the sealingof the international boundary is the demiseof the remaining O’odham way oflife...legal cultural genocide.”

During an April 28, 2008, testimonybefore Congress, Tohono O’odham nationchairman Ned Norris, Jr. proclaimed that“we did not cross the 75 miles of borderwithin our reservation lands. The bordercrossed us.” Indeed.

Baboquivari is a sacred mountain of the Tohono O’odham people. Photo by Priscilla Benbrook.

TTTTTAKE AAKE AAKE AAKE AAKE ACTION!CTION!CTION!CTION!CTION!

If you believe the U.S. has the ability to trade across borders and, at the sametime, defend environmental quality and sustainability of a community, protectlabor and civil rights, and make communities better as a whole, we urge you tocontact Chris Slevin in Senator Brown’s office ([email protected])or Kim Glas in Representative Michaud’s office ([email protected]) andvoice your support of the TRADE Act initiative. More co-sponsors are needed toget this initiative on the table for review.

By Priscilla Benbrook

ConservationChair: Don Steuter

[email protected]

EnergyChair: Jon Findley

[email protected]

Environmental JusticeChair: Keith Bagwell

[email protected]

MiningChair: Don Steuter

[email protected]

National Parks & WildlifeRefuges

Chair: Ken Langton520-749-3829

[email protected]

WaterVolunteer Opportunity

WildernessChair: Michelle Pulich Stewart

[email protected]

WildlifeChair: Halina Szyposzynski

[email protected]

Get Involved!Get Involved!Get Involved!Get Involved!Get Involved!

The battle for more responsible trade,manufacturing, and consumer policies hasbeen a long one, but we are gainingground. We need you to participate andvoice your support. Together, we set thestandards in which we can live together.



10

ELECTION BALLELECTION BALLELECTION BALLELECTION BALLELECTION BALLOOOOOTTTTT

Sierra Club Elections202 E. McDowell Ste. 277Phoenix, AZ 85004-4536

After voting, place your ballot in an envelope and put yournamenamenamenamename, membership number membership number membership number membership number membership number (9-digit number on yourEcho address label), , , , , and address address address address address outsideoutsideoutsideoutsideoutside on the front,upper left corner of the envelope. Then mail it to PPPPPostmarostmarostmarostmarostmark deadline fork deadline fork deadline fork deadline fork deadline for

ballots is Dec. 8!ballots is Dec. 8!ballots is Dec. 8!ballots is Dec. 8!ballots is Dec. 8!

MMMMMake yake yake yake yake your membership count our membership count our membership count our membership count our membership count – VVVVVOOOOOTE in STE in STE in STE in STE in Sierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Grrrrroup Eoup Eoup Eoup Eoup Elections!lections!lections!lections!lections!

VVVVVoooooting Rights (and Rting Rights (and Rting Rights (and Rting Rights (and Rting Rights (and Responsibilities)esponsibilities)esponsibilities)esponsibilities)esponsibilities)

Keith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith Bagwell

KKKKKenneth Penneth Penneth Penneth Penneth P. Langton. Langton. Langton. Langton. Langton

TTTTTom Mom Mom Mom Mom Mararararartintintintintin

David McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCaleb

Elna OtterElna OtterElna OtterElna OtterElna Otter

DDDDDale ale ale ale ale VVVVVolzolzolzolzolz

Single JointSingle JointSingle JointSingle JointSingle Joint(Member(Member(Member(Member(Membership Tship Tship Tship Tship Type)ype)ype)ype)ype)

Vote for no moreVote for no moreVote for no moreVote for no moreVote for no morethan 5 candidatesthan 5 candidatesthan 5 candidatesthan 5 candidatesthan 5 candidates

All MemberAll MemberAll MemberAll MemberAll Members Vs Vs Vs Vs Vooooottttteeeeefor Chapter Executive Committeefor Chapter Executive Committeefor Chapter Executive Committeefor Chapter Executive Committeefor Chapter Executive Committee

Check the box below for Check the box below for Check the box below for Check the box below for Check the box below for whetherwhetherwhetherwhetherwhether your your your your yourmembership is membership is membership is membership is membership is SingleSingleSingleSingleSingle or or or or or Joint.Joint.Joint.Joint.Joint.

SingleSingleSingleSingleSingle JointJointJointJointJoint

Part 1:Part 1:Part 1:Part 1:Part 1:

Part 2:Part 2:Part 2:Part 2:Part 2:

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

Palo VerdePalo VerdePalo VerdePalo VerdePalo VerdeVote for no more than 5

RinconRinconRinconRinconRinconVote for no more than 3

PlateauPlateauPlateauPlateauPlateauVote for no more than 3

Matthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew Hogel

Cory JonesCory JonesCory JonesCory JonesCory Jones

It is time once again to exercise that most basic, andvital, right of citizens and members: voting.

As has been stated many times, this November 4election could be the most important in recent history.The country faces a myriad of decisions on peace and war,economic stability, and healthcare and education. We areat the tipping point of reversing climate change before theglobal environment is forever altered. The existence ofthousands of species hangs in the balance.

Who will fight for the environment in Congress andin the Arizona legislature? That’s your call – and it’s timeto elect candidates who have pledged to protect wild landsand wildlife, support alternative and renewable energysources, and work to protect our air and water.

Another important upcoming election is that forGroup and Grand Canyon Chapter leaders. Please reviewthe candidate statements in this issue of the Canyon Echo.Take the time to learn about the candidates and makeyour choice for leadership in your Group or Chapter. Theseare the folks who give countless hours to make and reviewlocal and state Sierra Club policy, manage the budget, anddetermine conservation priorities.

Don’t forget to vote now and in every election. Yourparticipation is vital for our future.

~Grand Canyon Chapter Political Committee

Sierra Club ElectionsSierra Club ElectionsSierra Club ElectionsSierra Club ElectionsSierra Club ElectionsWho can vote?Who can vote?Who can vote?Who can vote?Who can vote?All current Sierra Club members in good standing (dues paid) living in Arizona.

How do I vote?How do I vote?How do I vote?How do I vote?How do I vote?It’s EASY— Just mark and mail the ballot in today!

1) Review the biographies for the Chapter and your Group candidates on pg. 11–13.2) On the ballot, mark whether you have a Single or Joint (household) membership.3) Vote by marking the box space(s) beside the candidates of your choice. Vote for no more than the

number of candidates indicated under the Chapter or Group name.4) After voting, cut out your ballot and place it in an envelope and put your namenamenamenamename, membershipmembershipmembershipmembershipmembership

numbernumbernumbernumbernumber, and addr, and addr, and addr, and addr, and addressessessessess outsideoutsideoutsideoutsideoutside on the front in the upper left corner for a return address. Your membershipnumber is the 8-digit number above your name on your newsletter mailing label. Deadline: December 8.Deadline: December 8.Deadline: December 8.Deadline: December 8.Deadline: December 8.Ballots postmarked later than December 8 OR without a name and address will not be counted.

Why are there two boxes following each candidate’s name?Why are there two boxes following each candidate’s name?Why are there two boxes following each candidate’s name?Why are there two boxes following each candidate’s name?Why are there two boxes following each candidate’s name?The second vote column is for joint memberships (two people living in the same household that aremembers). If you fill in the “SSSSS” box, your vote will count onceonceonceonceonce. If you have a joint membership, fill in the“JJJJJ” box and your vote will count twicetwicetwicetwicetwice for one person. If you have a joint membership, and the twomembers want to vote for different candidates, check the “S” box twice in the same section. Do not checkDo not checkDo not checkDo not checkDo not checkboth the S and the J boxes.both the S and the J boxes.both the S and the J boxes.both the S and the J boxes.both the S and the J boxes.

What do I need to remember when marking the ballot?What do I need to remember when marking the ballot?What do I need to remember when marking the ballot?What do I need to remember when marking the ballot?What do I need to remember when marking the ballot?Do not put your name on the ballot.Do not put your name on the ballot.Do not put your name on the ballot.Do not put your name on the ballot.Do not put your name on the ballot. Names and joint memberships will be verified before countingfrom your return address on the outside of the envelope. Ballots will be counted after the deadline(December 8). All members may vote for Chapter Executive Committee members, but members mayonly vote for their group in their respective residential location.

Can I vote at my group meeting?Can I vote at my group meeting?Can I vote at my group meeting?Can I vote at my group meeting?Can I vote at my group meeting?Yes. If you are voting at your group meeting, please place each ballot in a separate envelope. To savepostage, all envelopes may be mailed in a large envelope to the above address. Legible machine copies ofthe ballot may be used.

PPPPPararararart 3: t 3: t 3: t 3: t 3: VVVVVooooote ONLte ONLte ONLte ONLte ONLY fY fY fY fY for Yor Yor Yor Yor Your Grour Grour Grour Grour Group Electionsoup Electionsoup Electionsoup Electionsoup Elections

Kim CrumboKim CrumboKim CrumboKim CrumboKim Crumbo

MMMMMimi imi imi imi imi TTTTTorrorrorrorrorreseseseses

Rachel Rachel Rachel Rachel Rachel TTTTTsososososo

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

Derek FowlerDerek FowlerDerek FowlerDerek FowlerDerek Fowler

David McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCaleb

Blair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlin

Scott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott Mittelsteadt

Don SteuterDon SteuterDon SteuterDon SteuterDon Steuter

JJJJJim im im im im VVVVVaaleraaleraaleraaleraaler

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SaguaroSaguaroSaguaroSaguaroSaguaroVote for no more than 4

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

Beverly FullBeverly FullBeverly FullBeverly FullBeverly Full

Louis LantzLouis LantzLouis LantzLouis LantzLouis Lantz

Norma HandNorma HandNorma HandNorma HandNorma Hand

Joel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel Sinclaire

Dennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis Rayner

Marlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene Rayner

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

Sedona/Verde ValleySedona/Verde ValleySedona/Verde ValleySedona/Verde ValleySedona/Verde ValleyVote for no more than 2

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

SSSSS JJJJJ

Gary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary Beverly

Robert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. Grossman

YYYYYaaaaavvvvvapaiapaiapaiapaiapaiVote for no more than 2

MMMMMake yake yake yake yake your membership count our membership count our membership count our membership count our membership count – VVVVVOOOOOTE in STE in STE in STE in STE in Sierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Gierra Club Chapter & Grrrrroup Eoup Eoup Eoup Eoup Elections!lections!lections!lections!lections!



11

Meet the Chapter Executive Committee CandidatesMeet the Chapter Executive Committee CandidatesMeet the Chapter Executive Committee CandidatesMeet the Chapter Executive Committee CandidatesMeet the Chapter Executive Committee CandidatesKeith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith BagwellKeith BagwellMembership #42044629

I have proudly served on this Executive Committee for the last four years as theRincon Group representative as I have been Rincon Group Executive Committee chairor co-chair. Next year, I plan to serve as Rincon Group Conservation Committee chairinstead, but I desire to continue as a member of the Chapter Executive Committee. Ihave served on the Rincon Group Executive Committee since January 2001, and, beforethat, I was an environmental reporter for a Tucson newspaper for more than 12 years. Ihave broad knowledge of and interest in environmental issues, from wilderness to urbanpollution and from endangered species to leapfrog sprawl. I am strongly committed toclean and benign energy sources; I have served many years as Rincon’s (public)transportation expert, and I helped create and still serve on Sean Sullivan’s BorderlandsCommittee. I am dedicated to the principles and people of the Sierra Club, its GrandCanyon Chapter, and its Rincon Group, and I ask for your vote in this election.

KKKKKenneth Penneth Penneth Penneth Penneth P. Langton. Langton. Langton. Langton. LangtonMembership #15799889

Misguided development continues to destroy natural areas and ignores the economicbenefits of conservation. I am a candidate because I want to build a conservation-basedcommunity and preserve our wild areas. I bring the experience and leadership skillsthat I honed as a Sierra Club leader and university professor. I served as your ChapterChair for three years, and I currently chair the Chapter’s Wildlife Refuges and NationalParks Conservation Committee. Previously, I served in Michigan as Group Chair, ChapterChair, and Coordinator of the State National Forest Committee. Later, I was electedChair of the Sierra Club’s national Chapter Chairs Forum. As a professor at the Universityof Michigan, I served on the Executive Committee of the Environmental Studies Program.More recently, I have served on three national Governing Committees of the SierraClub. Locally, I am a member of the Rincon Group, where I work on national wildliferefuges and national parks.

Conservation requires a persistence and dedication that often takes years. Our rewardin the interim is the personal, unobserved sense of integrity that comes from being inthe right fight.

TTTTTom Mom Mom Mom Mom MararararartintintintintinMembership #42971697

For the past three years, it has been an honor to serve on the Grand Canyon ChapterExecutive Committee, while serving the last five years on the Plateau Group ExecutiveCommittee. I also serve on the Sierra Club’s National Recreation Issues Committee asSecretary and the National Canyons of the Colorado River Committee.

We moved to southern Arizona in 1957, and ten years later my folks started takingme hiking in the Grand Canyon. For the last twelve years I have served the South Rimcommunity as Physical Therapist at the Grand Canyon Clinic. (Please stop in and sayHello!)

If re-elected to the Chapter Executive Committee, I look forward to continuing towork on statewide growth, resource protection, and water issues, as well as Grand CanyonNational Park issues such as the upcoming Backcountry Management Plan revision,ongoing Overflights issues, river, and gateway community issues.

David McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebMembership #40829837

I became a member of Sierra Club in 1996 and am presently serving as the ChapterTreasurer. I first moved to Arizona in 1960, grew up in the desert outside of Phoenix,and have considered it my home ever since. I have lived out of the state several times foreducation and work, but this time away has only strengthened my appreciation for thewonders of Arizona. Since I permanently moved back to the state in 1994, I have beendistressed by the rate of change taking place, which is putting our beautiful land andresources at risk of being destroyed forever.

As a biologist, hiker, and semi-retired executive, I would bring to the ExComm myyears of management experience, an awareness of the wonders of the natural environment,and a commitment to do my best to keep Arizona a special place. I believe that one ofour greatest challenges is managing our resources and the environment while copingwith the expected influx of new residents. I would work with the ExComm and allmembers to preserve our state to ensure that we all can continue to enjoy living here.

Elna OtterElna OtterElna OtterElna OtterElna OtterMembership #27519989

I have been on the Chapter Executive Committee for 6 years and was on the ExCommof the Rincon Group for 7 years where I served as secretary for more than 5 years. I livein the country on the San Pedro River. Some of my major interests in the club center onissues that affect the river – grazing, water, and endangered species. I am currently theChapter Secretary. Until recently, I also served as chair of the Chapter water group.

Because extensive foreign travel convinced me of the reality and universality ofglobal warming, I attended Al Gore’s training in Nashville. Since then, I have written anumber of articles on the topic, in addition to speaking to various groups throughoutArizona. My background in physics has provided me with a good background for someof the more technical aspects of these issues.

In addition to the Sierra Club, I am a member of a group dedicated to land restorationon the San Pedro and participate with groups concerned with border issues.

DDDDDale ale ale ale ale VVVVVolzolzolzolzolzMember #30900049

I am not “that wrinkly, old, white-haired” guy running for the Chapter ExecutiveCommittee (ExCom), although I suppose two of those descriptors do apply. While thatmight be sufficient to keep Paris and her ilk from voting for me, you should feel confidentin keeping me on the ExCom. I have been an Arizona resident since 1973, a Sierra Clubmember since 1993, served on the ExCom since 2001, served as a past Chapter Treasurerfor over three years, and have served as the Chapter PAC treasurer since 2004.

I have grown increasingly impatient with those who would defile creation andsacrifice the health and safety of others for selfish and short-sighted gain. I realize thatmy dear Edward Abbey was wrong when he asserted that we will outlive the bastards,because I realize that they keep reproducing, influencing others, and will always bewith us. The challenge for us, therefore, is to continuously energize new activists willingto battle that evil and uncompromisingly promote the protection of our planet. As thelargest grassroots, volunteer-based environmental organization in the state, Sierra Clubis uniquely situated to lead the battle. I ask for your vote to help me assure that it does.

FFFFFOR RENTOR RENTOR RENTOR RENTOR RENT..... Cabin and Airstream trailers at Blue River Wilderness Retreat nearAlpine, AZ. In the pines at 6400’, along perennial streams, bordered by NationalForest, near Blue Range Primitive Area, outstanding hiking, fishing, birding, andwildlife viewing. Reasonable rates by week or month. www.blueriverretreat.com– [email protected] – 928-339-4426

TRATRATRATRATRAVEL VEL VEL VEL VEL to nourish your Spirit. GuatGuatGuatGuatGuatemalaemalaemalaemalaemala Mayan Mysteries – March 8–16,2009 – $2,099.00, ancient pyramids, markets, Lake Atitlan, villages. KenyaKenyaKenyaKenyaKenyaTTTTTanzaniaanzaniaanzaniaanzaniaanzania Safari – July 6–18 - $4,599.00 Witness the Great Migration! Contact:Gayle Lawrence 727-785-5563. Tour details: www.ajourneyofdiscovery.com.

THERAPEUTIC MASSAGETHERAPEUTIC MASSAGETHERAPEUTIC MASSAGETHERAPEUTIC MASSAGETHERAPEUTIC MASSAGE by John I. Evans. For optimum sports/work/activityperformance, injury/chronic pain relief, over 12 yrs. exp., Muscle Relief Technique/deep tissue/stretching. 480-495-0898, [email protected]. Sierra Clubmember-licensed-certified-insured.

(Classified ad rates are $16 for 30 words or less each issue, $0.50 for each additional word.Reaches more than 13,000 readers in Arizona. To place an ad, mail or email your copy to the editor.We do not accept personals. Please make check payable to Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter.)

Classified AdsClassified AdsClassified AdsClassified AdsClassified Ads

1. Publication Title: Canyon Echo2. Publication Number: 0164-70243. Filing Date: September 3, 20084. Issue Frequency: bimonthly5. No. Issues Published Annually: 66. Annual Subscription Price: $107. Complete Mailing Address of Known Officeof Publication: Sierra Club Grand CanyonChapter, 202 E. McDowell Rd. Ste 277,Phoenix AZ, Maricopa County, 85004-4536.8. Complete Mailing Address of GeneralBusiness Office of Publisher: Sierra ClubGrand Canyon Chapter, 202 E. McDowell Rd.Ste 277, Phoenix AZ, 85004-4536.9. Names and Addresses of Publisher and

Editor: Publisher: Sierra Club Grand CanyonChapter, 202 E. McDowell Rd. Ste 277,Phoenix AZ, 85004-4536; Editor: TiffanySprague, 202 E. McDowell Rd. Ste 277,Phoenix AZ, 85004-453610. Owner: Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter11. Known Bondholders, Mortgages, andOther Security Holders Owning or Holding 1%or More of Total Amount of Bonds, Mortgages,or Other Securities: None12. Tax Status: Has not changed duringpreceding 12 months.13. Publication Title: Canyon Echo14. Issue Date for Circulation Data Below:Sept/Oct 08

16. Publication of Statement of Ownership: Nov/Dec 200817. Signature: Tiffany Sprague, Editor 9/3/2008

Statement of Ownership, Management & CirculationStatement of Ownership, Management & CirculationStatement of Ownership, Management & CirculationStatement of Ownership, Management & CirculationStatement of Ownership, Management & Circulation

11,500 11,000

5,736 5,455

5,161 5,148

10,897 10,604

0 0

0 1

44 44

10 10

3 2

200 200

257 256

346 140

11,154 10,860

11,500 11,000

97.7% 97.6%

15.Extent and Nature of Circulation15.Extent and Nature of Circulation15.Extent and Nature of Circulation15.Extent and Nature of Circulation15.Extent and Nature of Circulation Average No. Copies Each IssueDuring Preceding 12 Months

No. Copies of Single IssuePublished Nearest to Filing Date

a) Total Number of Copies (Net press run)

b) Paidand/orRequestedCirculation

1) Paid/requested outside-county mailsubscriptions stated on Form 35412) Paid in-county subscriptions statedon Form 35413) Sales Through Dealers and Carriers,Street Vendors, Counter Sales4) Other Classes Mailed Through theUSPS

c) Total Paid and/or Requested Circulation

d) FreeDistributionby Mail

1) Outside-County as Stated on Form 3541

2) In-County as Stated on Form 3541

3) Other Classes Mailed Through USPS

e) Free Distribution Outside the Mail

f) Total Free Distribution

g) Total Distribution

h) Copies Not Distributed

i) Total

j) Percent Paid and/or Requested Circulation



12

PPPPPALALALALALO O O O O VERDE GRVERDE GRVERDE GRVERDE GRVERDE GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

DDDDDerererererek Fek Fek Fek Fek FooooowlerwlerwlerwlerwlerMembership #41716656

My environmental activism started at as a teenager in New Zealand when myfamily painted anti-nuclear signs. We hung them on the side of the sailboat that mydad built and sailed out into the harbor to protest nuclear powered US and UK warshipsentering our waters. New Zealand became nuclear free in the mid-eighties, and I amproud of this.

Having dual citizenship, I moved to Phoenix almost 15 years ago and have been amember of the Sierra Club, the Nature Conservancy, and Greenpeace most of thatperiod.

I strongly support sustainable energy policies, sugar based ethanol being one ofthese. I am a recycler and would like to see deposit programs like California has introducedinto our state. I believe strongly in water conservation and would like to see publicawareness and state legislation that support it. Finally, I am in favor of protecting openspaces and the flora and fauna the make this state so beautiful.

David McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebDavid McCalebMembership #40829837

I became a member of Sierra Club in 1996 and am presently serving as the ChapterTreasurer. I first moved to Arizona in 1960, grew up in the desert outside of Phoenix,and have considered it my home ever since. I have lived out of the state several times foreducation and work, but this time away has only strengthened my appreciation for thewonders of Arizona. Since I permanently moved back to the state in 1994, I have beendistressed by the rate of change taking place, which is putting our beautiful land andresources at risk of being destroyed forever.

As a biologist, hiker, and semi-retired executive, I would bring to the ExComm myyears of management experience, an awareness of the wonders of the natural environment,and a commitment to do my best to keep Arizona a special place. I believe that one ofour greatest challenges is managing our resources and the environment while copingwith the expected influx of new residents. I would work with the ExComm and allmembers to preserve our state to ensure that we all can continue to enjoy living here.

Blair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinBlair McLaughlinMembership #40110274

I am proud to have served on the Palo Verde Group Executive Committee as thegroup Chair for the past two years. I feel we have taken a step forward in our organizationalstructure and committee productivity, accountability to our members and the Chapter,and our message of conservation. Along with many other very dedicated volunteers, Iplan to push forward and continue my work organizing our group as a means to expandour message of protecting and enjoying Arizona.

Scott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtScott MittelsteadtMembership #41572614

I would like to ask the members of the Palo Verde Group to consider me for anopen position on the group’s Executive Committee. I have been a Sierra Club memberfor 15 years and have been active in the Chapter since 1998 when I joined the Citizen’sGrowth Management Initiative. That campaign introduced me to the complexenvironmental issues involving Maricopa and Pinal counties, as well as the inner workingsof the Grand Canyon Chapter. Since then I have been a member of the Chapter ExecutiveCommittee, involved in the Wilderness, Wildlife, Water, Energy, and PublicationsCommittees, and at various times have chaired the Water and Publications committees.

There are a host of issues affecting our part of the state. I believe three elements ofour mission are most critical – environmentally friendly lawmakers at all levels, thedevelopment of clean energy industries and power production, and a re-working of theurban/suburban communities that promote sustainable living, efficient use of our land,and the expansion of transit options that eliminate dependency on the automobile. Thegroup is well positioned to influence our governments toward these ideas, and I hopeyou will allow me to be a part of that effort.

Don SteuterDon SteuterDon SteuterDon SteuterDon SteuterMembership #23812444

I’ve been interested in conservation since participating in the first Earth Day eventin a small college town in the Midwest. Since 1989, I have been an active club member,serving as the Palo Verde Group Conservation Chair since 1990 and as the ChapterConservation Chair for the past 7 years. I also presently serve as the Chapter’s MiningCommittee Chair. Even when political winds blow cold, we manage some victories,and meanwhile plan bigger ones when fortune shines again. Vote for me and I’ll continuethe effort.

JJJJJim im im im im VVVVVaaleraaleraaleraaleraalerMembership #11880851I first joined the SC in 1973 and soon became active at the group level doing membershipwork. At the same time, I began to lead SC outings in Arizona and to date have led atleast 200 outings. I have served on the Palo Verde Group Executive Committee on at

Meet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group Candidatesleast three separate occasions over the years and have come to the conclusion that grassroots activism best starts at the group level. Over the years I have worked on a wide arrayof public land issues, chief among them wilderness, and have come to view my work onand for the land as a wellspring for my continued enthusiasm in performing volunteerwork for the Sierra Club. Volunteer work not only provides a benefit to our society butalso gives meaning to our personal lives. I look forward to serving.

RINCON GRRINCON GRRINCON GRRINCON GRRINCON GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

Matthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew HogelMatthew HogelMembership #43579197

I am currently the Conservation Chair and an ExComm board member of theSierra Club Rincon Group. I seek re-election as an ExComm board member for RinconGroup. With a background in Latin American studies and foreign policy, I haverepresented the club well at community meetings and city council committee meetings.I have advocated for policies and initiatives that conserve resources and energy to enhancea community’s ability to sustain itself while defending the environmental, human, andcivil rights that are neglected by current local and national policy – i.e. Real ID Act,Patriot Act, NAFTA, etc.

Cory JonesCory JonesCory JonesCory JonesCory JonesMembership #42119988No statement provided.

PLPLPLPLPLAAAAATEATEATEATEATEAU GRU GRU GRU GRU GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

Kim CrumboKim CrumboKim CrumboKim CrumboKim CrumboMembership #41293096

I feel that the Sierra Club is an especially influential conservation group that getsimportant things done in this state. I would like to continue my direct involvementwith the Club. I am currently the Director of Conservation for the Grand CanyonWildlands Council. From 2000 to 2005 I served as the Northern Representative forthe Arizona Wilderness Coalition and Wilderness Coordinator for the Grand CanyonWildlands Council. I have strived to develop and maintain professional relationshipswith other conservation groups, legislators and their staff, and agency personal, as wellas general public outreach.

I served 20 years with the National Park Service in Grand Canyon as the riverranger and later as Wilderness Coordinator. I spent 10 years as professional river guideand two years as the Utah Wilderness Coordinator for the Sierra Club. Prior to that, Ispent four years with the Navy’s SEAL Team One completing two combat deploymentsto Vietnam.

I received a B.S. in Environmental Studies from Utah State University, withpostgraduate work in outdoor recreation. I received the National Park Service’s “Director’sWilderness Management and Stewardship Award” and The Wilderness Society’s“Environmental Heroes Award.” I also earned several combat decorations, including aBronze Star.

MMMMMimi imi imi imi imi TTTTTorrorrorrorrorresesesesesMembership #43745653

I have been on the Plateau Group Ex-Com since January 2006. I have acted asgroup secretary and am active in the Save the Peaks Coalition. I graduated from NAU inDecember 2007 with a degree in Political Science. As a student I was very involved withcampus activism. I acted as President of both Campus Climate Challenge and theSociety of Environmental Communicators and was a founding member of Animal RightsNow. My proudest accomplishment was winning a campaign to get recycled toiletpaper and paper towels on campus. Please vote to keep me on the Ex-Com.

Rachel Rachel Rachel Rachel Rachel TTTTTsososososoMembership #44391477

I am running in hopes of being a part of the Plateau Group Ex-Com. I have a longhistory with the Sierra Club, going back to 1993 when I did a 6-month internshipwith the Sierra Club Legal Defense Fund in Tallahasee, FL, working on protecting seaturtle habitat. Northern Arizona has been my home since 1994. I first came to AZ as apart of my undergraduate degree program to do a cooperative work study programworking with Navajo and Hopi elders who were working on the issues of coal and waterin Black Mesa. I fell in love and stayed.

I have a BA in Environmental Communications from Antioch College, anotherdegree in Elementary Education from Prescott College, and I am now working on mythesis in the Master of Arts in Sustainable Communities Program here in Flagstaff atNAU. I am also a volunteer with the Save the Peaks Coalition and a coordinator withOutta Your Backpack Media.



13

SASASASASAGUGUGUGUGUARARARARARO GRO GRO GRO GRO GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

SEDONA-VERDE SEDONA-VERDE SEDONA-VERDE SEDONA-VERDE SEDONA-VERDE VVVVVALLEALLEALLEALLEALLEY GRY GRY GRY GRY GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

Meet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group CandidatesMeet the Group Candidates

Beverly FullBeverly FullBeverly FullBeverly FullBeverly FullMembership #10337194

Bev is a current board member and a founding member of the Club. She currentlyserves as chair. She has served on the Chapter Excom for 7 years, is past Chapter Secretary,current Chapter Outings Chair, past Chapter Political Chair, and current member ofthe Political Committee. She does fund raisers for both Chapter and Group.

Louis LantzLouis LantzLouis LantzLouis LantzLouis LantzMembership #41757428

Louis is a current board member and a founding member of the Club, past chair,and now Vice-Chair. Louis is an outings leader and fund raiser. He manages themembership e mail lists and sends out bulletins about our events. He is host to manyClub events.

Norma HandNorma HandNorma HandNorma HandNorma HandMembership #43397937

Norma is a current board member and a founding member of the Club. She servesas hospitality chair. She plans and helps execute fund raising activities and meetings.Norma and her husband Richard have provided their home for many Club events.

Joel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel SinclaireJoel SinclaireMembership #43053545

Joel is a current board member and has served as our Political Chair. He representsthe Group at Chapter political meetings. Joel has been active in many of our fundraising and service projects.

Dennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis RaynerDennis RaynerMembership #42704722I am a retired organic chemist (PhD Princeton 1967) with interest in environmentaland scientific education. Because of this interest in education, I volunteered to beEducation Chair for the Sedona-Verde Valley Group for the past year, while serving onthe Executive Committee. In that capacity I have assisted the Group in those efforts toeducate our members and the public on issues such as solar/renewable energy, theNational Scenic area designation for Sedona, and others.

Gary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary BeverlyGary BeverlyMembership #11123716

As a member of the Yavapai Group Executive Committee, I will work to increasemember participation in the group; achieve Wild and Scenic River status for the UpperVerde River; improve the management of the Prescott National Forest public lands,especially the Upper Verde River; create a forest stewardship program to assist PNFwith maintaining clean, enjoyable, and safe public recreational areas in the publiclands; and improve public access to public lands.

Save the Verde!

Robert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanRobert E. GrossmanMembership #43828525

I was in the Prescott Natural Forest Friends (PNFF) for about 15 years beforejoining the Sierra Club in 2006. I have been working to reduce grazing on the PNF,even getting a permit rescinded. I prevailed on the PNF to place 4 exclosures on aproject to gage grazing impact. I have maintained trails and observed motorized vehiclesdamage trails. I have performed range transact measurements on the PNF. I have beeninvolved with the emissions of small particulates from the Drake cement plant project.I participated in flow measuring of the Verde River. I plotted all the inflows to BanningCreek, a secondary input to the Verde. I have been on the Granite Creek and VerdeRiver clean-up crews. Before retiring I spent 5 years in the Office of NEPA Affairs, USDept. of Energy, where I observed that technology, economics, and public perceptionsare equal factors in achieving environmental goals.

My being on the Executive Committee would help Sierra Club reach its goals.

Marlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMarlene RaynerMembership #43069525As Chair of the SCSVVG for the past year, I have instituted a quarterly newsletter andworked to hold plenty of educational programs (which usually take place just beforethe Group’s regular monthly meeting). We have had programs on Solar Photovoltaics,Permaculture, Zero Waste, grey water, the National Scenic Area designation for Sedonaarea, preserving dark skies, and wastewater issues in Sedona. We have also tried to helppreserve Sedona by cooperating with other local organizations to prevent growth thatdestroys the beauty of Sedona; this means attending and participating in Planning andZoning and City Council meetings. I have written articles on renewable and solarenergy for various Yavapai County publications at the request of our supervisor, ChipDavis. It has been a wonderful experience which I would like to continue!

Spending time at GrandCanyon is always a treat. However,it couldn’t have been better thanthis summer’s archaeology surveywith the Sierra Club. The firstevening we gathered at thecampground and met StaceyHamburg, a leader for the trip.Her enthusiasm for our partic-ipation in this unique project wasapparent, and all was off to a greatstart.

After a wonderful breakfastcooked by Chef Hertha Woody,the park archeologist, Ian Hough,met us to go over the task athand. We were to explore andidentify artifacts and features at anewly discovered Navajo and/or Havasupai camp that wasaccidently found by a GrandCanyon resident while walking his dog.We followed Ian into the juniper forestwith our flags, compasses, and additionalarcheology paraphernalia. After a shortwalk, we came across what looked like asmall pile of timber. Ian explained that itwas a hogan at least 100 years old!

We surveyed hogans, sweat lodges, andanimal corrals. We flagged artifacts on the

ground and documented features withphotos and written descriptions. Oneteam member found an arrowheadapproximately 4,000 years old! And it goteven better. We spent one entire day withtribal elders from the nearby city ofCameron on the Navajo Nation. Theseelders were remarkable not only inappearance but also in wealth of

knowledge of the uses for the areas andthe camps that were discovered. With theoldest in her late 80s, they all hiked intothe woods in colorful skirts and blouses, aswell as their biggest and finest turquoisejewels. When we sat down near the mainhogan, one of the elders, Ruth, spokepassionately in Navajo about her child-hood in the area, about herding goats andpicking piñon. She spoke with such passionand commitment to the land and theNavajo way of life that it brought her totears.

We documented at least three camps,nine features, and hundreds of artifacts.This being my fourth Sierra Club vol-

By Christine Mitsoff

PreserPreserPreserPreserPreserving the Pving the Pving the Pving the Pving the Pastastastastast

Christine is an active Sierra Club member.

YAYAYAYAYAVVVVVAPAPAPAPAPAI GRAI GRAI GRAI GRAI GROUPOUPOUPOUPOUP

Navajo elders. Photo by Victoria Bevolden.

unteer trip, it was definitely the best ofthem all. The trip leaders were exceptional,and Ian was an excellent teacher. Heeducated us on the proper techniques forfinding artifacts and how to handle,document, and preserve them.

If you are visiting Grand Canyon,don’t forget to take a moment to turnaround and look at the desert behind you.That is where people lived not long ago.The desert has a wonderful story to tell.We were lucky enough to be amongpeople who know how to listen for themessage.

Name

Address

City State ZIP

Sierra ClubP.O. Box 52968Boulder, Colorado80322-2968

MOVING?Paste the current mailing label here and write

in new address below.(Please allow 4–6 weeks processing time.)



14

Happenings ArHappenings ArHappenings ArHappenings ArHappenings Around the Sound the Sound the Sound the Sound the StattattattattateeeeeWelcome!Welcome!Welcome!Welcome!Welcome! Six Groups make up the Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter (see pg. 2 for listings). Conservation, political and legislative activism, administra-tive work, and outings are a few ways we work to protect this amazing state. And there are many more! All the events and meetings listed belowAll the events and meetings listed belowAll the events and meetings listed belowAll the events and meetings listed belowAll the events and meetings listed beloware open tare open tare open tare open tare open to membero membero membero membero members ints ints ints ints interesteresteresteresterested in learning more about the Sierra Club.ed in learning more about the Sierra Club.ed in learning more about the Sierra Club.ed in learning more about the Sierra Club.ed in learning more about the Sierra Club. We aim to make this world a better, more livable place. WWWWWe neede neede neede neede needyyyyyour help!our help!our help!our help!our help! You can find out more at our website: www www www www www.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org.arizona.sierraclub.org – click on “Meetings and Events.” Schedules are subject to change.

KKKKKeeping Greeping Greeping Greeping Greeping Groups in the Loopoups in the Loopoups in the Loopoups in the Loopoups in the LoopMeetings are open to the public. For directions or more information,

please call or email the contact person listed.

Chapter AnnouncementsChapter AnnouncementsChapter AnnouncementsChapter AnnouncementsChapter Announcements

3748.

Plateau Group Plateau Group Plateau Group Plateau Group Plateau Group (Flagstaff and surrounding area)(Flagstaff and surrounding area)(Flagstaff and surrounding area)(Flagstaff and surrounding area)(Flagstaff and surrounding area)

NOV 12 (WED) 1:30 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meetings.NOV 12 (WED) 1:30 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meetings.NOV 12 (WED) 1:30 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meetings.NOV 12 (WED) 1:30 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meetings.NOV 12 (WED) 1:30 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meetings.The group meets to discuss conservation and business issues at the Sierra Club office,408 E. Route 66 in Flagstaff (behind Babbitt Ford). Everyone welcome. If you havequestions, call Jim McCarthy at 928-779-3748.

JAN 6 (TUE) 1 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meeting.JAN 6 (TUE) 1 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meeting.JAN 6 (TUE) 1 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meeting.JAN 6 (TUE) 1 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meeting.JAN 6 (TUE) 1 p.m. Conservation and Executive Committee meeting. Thegroup meets to discuss conservation and business issues at the Sierra Club office, 408E. Route 66 in Flagstaff (behind Babbitt Ford). Come meet your new executive committee.Everyone welcome. If you have questions, call Jim McCarthy at 928-779-3748.

Saguaro Group Saguaro Group Saguaro Group Saguaro Group Saguaro Group (North Maricopa County)(North Maricopa County)(North Maricopa County)(North Maricopa County)(North Maricopa County)

DEC 14 (SUN) 4 p.m. Holiday Party and Potluck.DEC 14 (SUN) 4 p.m. Holiday Party and Potluck.DEC 14 (SUN) 4 p.m. Holiday Party and Potluck.DEC 14 (SUN) 4 p.m. Holiday Party and Potluck.DEC 14 (SUN) 4 p.m. Holiday Party and Potluck. Hosted by Bev Full. We do theturkey. Contact Bev for information and directions at [email protected].

NOV 3 (MON) 5:30 p.m. Political Committee meeting.NOV 3 (MON) 5:30 p.m. Political Committee meeting.NOV 3 (MON) 5:30 p.m. Political Committee meeting.NOV 3 (MON) 5:30 p.m. Political Committee meeting.NOV 3 (MON) 5:30 p.m. Political Committee meeting. Meet at the Sierra Club’sPhoenix office or call in. This will be the last meeting before election day! If you’re interested inparticipating during the 2008 campaign season, now’s the time! We need lots of volunteerswho can help work on campaigns! Contact Lynn DeMuth at [email protected]. The committeewill not meet in December.

NOV 5 (WED) 5:30 p.m. Publications Committee meeting.NOV 5 (WED) 5:30 p.m. Publications Committee meeting.NOV 5 (WED) 5:30 p.m. Publications Committee meeting.NOV 5 (WED) 5:30 p.m. Publications Committee meeting.NOV 5 (WED) 5:30 p.m. Publications Committee meeting. Have an idea? Help planfuture issues of the Canyon Echo! Contact Carole Piszczek-Sheffield at 928-204-1517 [email protected] or Tiffany Sprague at 602-253-9140 or [email protected] more information.

NOV 19 (WED) 6:30 p.m. Wildlife Committee meeting.NOV 19 (WED) 6:30 p.m. Wildlife Committee meeting.NOV 19 (WED) 6:30 p.m. Wildlife Committee meeting.NOV 19 (WED) 6:30 p.m. Wildlife Committee meeting.NOV 19 (WED) 6:30 p.m. Wildlife Committee meeting. Help plan fun wildlife outings,learn about wildlife research and agency policies, and meet some great folks who share yourconcern for Arizona’s critters. Meet at the Sierra Club office at 202 E. McDowell Rd., Ste. 277,Phoenix, or you may participate via conference call if preferred. Please contact HalinaSzyposzynski at [email protected] or Sandy Bahr at 602-253-8633.

NONONONONOV 2V 2V 2V 2V 24 (MON). Cop4 (MON). Cop4 (MON). Cop4 (MON). Cop4 (MON). Copy deadline fy deadline fy deadline fy deadline fy deadline for Januaror Januaror Januaror Januaror January/Fy/Fy/Fy/Fy/Februarebruarebruarebruarebruary y y y y CanCanCanCanCanyyyyyon Econ Econ Econ Econ Echohohohoho. . . . . ***Pleasenote that the deadline has been moved up due to the holiday crunch. Theme TBD. Articles, art,photographs, poetry, essays, and brief epiphanies are welcome. Contact the editor beforesubmitting at 602-253-9140 or [email protected] to discuss word count, photosto include, licensing, issue topics, and to request submission guidelines.

NOV 25 (TUE) 6 p.m. Energy Committee meeting.NOV 25 (TUE) 6 p.m. Energy Committee meeting.NOV 25 (TUE) 6 p.m. Energy Committee meeting.NOV 25 (TUE) 6 p.m. Energy Committee meeting.NOV 25 (TUE) 6 p.m. Energy Committee meeting. Discuss various energy activities,including Cool Cities and renewable energy campaigns nationally and locally. Everyone isinvited to participate, no matter how much or how little you know about energy issues. Location:Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter office, 202 E. McDowell in Phoenix (2nd floor conferenceroom in the SE corner of the Quality Inn Suites). Please contact Jon Findley at 480-756-2916or [email protected].

DEC 3DEC 3DEC 3DEC 3DEC 31 (WED) 2–7 p.m. 1 (WED) 2–7 p.m. 1 (WED) 2–7 p.m. 1 (WED) 2–7 p.m. 1 (WED) 2–7 p.m. (stop by anytime) CanCanCanCanCanyyyyyon Econ Econ Econ Econ Echohohohoho Mailing P Mailing P Mailing P Mailing P Mailing Pararararartytytytyty..... Club volunteerssave the Chapter thousands of dollars every year by preparing the Canyon Echo for mailing.Thank you! The job is easy to learn and takes only a few hours once every two months. We allhave a great time. Any amount of time that you’re available is appreciated. Contact JerryNelson at 602-279-4668 or [email protected] or Bill Gill at [email protected] for locationand other details.

Palo Verde Group Palo Verde Group Palo Verde Group Palo Verde Group Palo Verde Group (Phoenix and suburbs)(Phoenix and suburbs)(Phoenix and suburbs)(Phoenix and suburbs)(Phoenix and suburbs)

NOV 11 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Conservation Committee meeting. NOV 11 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Conservation Committee meeting. NOV 11 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Conservation Committee meeting. NOV 11 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Conservation Committee meeting. NOV 11 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Conservation Committee meeting. The ConservationCommittee meets to discuss preservation, forest protection, wildlife and endangeredspecies, energy conservation, growth management, etc. Contact Don Steuter at 602-956-5057 or [email protected]. ExExExExExecutivecutivecutivecutivecutive Committe Committe Committe Committe Committee meeee meeee meeee meeee meeting, 8 p.m.ting, 8 p.m.ting, 8 p.m.ting, 8 p.m.ting, 8 p.m. TheExecutive Committee meets to review group policies, outdoor activities, finances, andother business. Contact Blair McLaughlin at 602-618-8591 or [email protected] for both meetings: Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter office, 202 E. McDowellRd., Phoenix (2nd floor conference room in the SE corner of the Los Olivos-Quality InnSuites). No mee No mee No mee No mee No meetings in Decembertings in Decembertings in Decembertings in Decembertings in December.....

NOV 18 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Arizona Bird Conservation Initiative.NOV 18 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Arizona Bird Conservation Initiative.NOV 18 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Arizona Bird Conservation Initiative.NOV 18 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Arizona Bird Conservation Initiative.NOV 18 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Arizona Bird Conservation Initiative. Would you liketo make a significant contribution to understanding how changes in habitat and theenvironment are affecting birds in Arizona? Learn new birding skills and enjoy the greatoutdoors? Join Troy Corman, Avian Monitoring Coordinator with the AZ Game and FishDepartment and editor of The Arizona Breeding Bird Atlas, and Greg Clark of Wild at Heartas they describe how ordinary folks are helping with the AZ Coordinated Bird MonitoringProgram. Located at The Phoenix Zoo, 455 N. Galvin Pkwy, Phoenix. From the parking lot,cross the bridge, go through the doors, and follow the signs to the Education building onthe left. For more information, contact Sherry Celine at 602-840-4611 [email protected].

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 16 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Annual P6 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Annual P6 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Annual P6 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Annual P6 (TUE) 6:30 p.m. Annual Poooootluck Dinner Ptluck Dinner Ptluck Dinner Ptluck Dinner Ptluck Dinner Pararararartytytytyty. . . . . Join us to celebrate theholiday season. Enjoy the band Europa and learn aerobic folk dancing that is too muchfun. Bring a salad, main dish, appetizer, vegetable side dish, or dessert; please no chipsand dip. Located at The Phoenix Zoo, 455 N. Galvin Pkwy, Phoenix. From the parking lot,cross the bridge, go through the doors, and follow the signs to the Education building onthe left. For more information, contact Sherry Celine at 602-840-4611 [email protected].

Yavapai Group Yavapai Group Yavapai Group Yavapai Group Yavapai Group (Prescott and surrounding area)(Prescott and surrounding area)(Prescott and surrounding area)(Prescott and surrounding area)(Prescott and surrounding area)

NONONONONOV 5, DEC 3, JV 5, DEC 3, JV 5, DEC 3, JV 5, DEC 3, JV 5, DEC 3, JAN 7 (WED) 6 p.m. ExAN 7 (WED) 6 p.m. ExAN 7 (WED) 6 p.m. ExAN 7 (WED) 6 p.m. ExAN 7 (WED) 6 p.m. Executivecutivecutivecutivecutive Committe Committe Committe Committe Committee meeee meeee meeee meeee meetings.tings.tings.tings.tings. All YavapaiGroup members are urged to attend. For info and directions, contact Tom Slaback at 928-778-4233.

NOV 19 (WED) 6 p.m. Film Nite.NOV 19 (WED) 6 p.m. Film Nite.NOV 19 (WED) 6 p.m. Film Nite.NOV 19 (WED) 6 p.m. Film Nite.NOV 19 (WED) 6 p.m. Film Nite. Meet at 6 p.m. for food and conversation before theenvironmentally-themed movie begins at 7 p.m. Check website (http://arizona.sierraclub.org/yavapai if we have it fixed) or contact Tom Slaback at 928-778-4233 for what’s showing.

DEC 7 (SUN) 5 p.m. Annual Christmas Party potluck dinner and gift exchange.DEC 7 (SUN) 5 p.m. Annual Christmas Party potluck dinner and gift exchange.DEC 7 (SUN) 5 p.m. Annual Christmas Party potluck dinner and gift exchange.DEC 7 (SUN) 5 p.m. Annual Christmas Party potluck dinner and gift exchange.DEC 7 (SUN) 5 p.m. Annual Christmas Party potluck dinner and gift exchange.Meet at the Prescott Canyon Estates Clubhouse for set up at 5 p.m. and dinner at 6 p.m.Gift exchange follows. Please limit gift value to no more than $5 with an enviro theme(think of humorous or whacky, too). For info and directions, contact Tom Slaback at 928-778-4233 or [email protected].

Be sure to check out our day hikes into the Upper Verde River in the “Enjoy andExplore” section. On Oct. 28 the City of Prescott put out to bid a new contract for haulingaway our sewage sludge (it is being placed along the headwaters of the Verde River).They have included a new section in the contract prohibiting it from being hauled to siteswithin a floodway. However, they have also included a section claiming that the city,mayor, and council have no responsibility for the sludge once it is hauled away.

We are in need of a volunteer to fill the position of Group Treasurer. We are alsolooking for volunteers to help in our monthly measuring of the flow in the upper threesites of the Verde River. We normally attempt to do this at the middle of the month. To getinvolved, contact Tom Slaback at 928-778-4233 or [email protected].

Rincon Group Rincon Group Rincon Group Rincon Group Rincon Group (Tucson and surrounding area)(Tucson and surrounding area)(Tucson and surrounding area)(Tucson and surrounding area)(Tucson and surrounding area)

Monthly programs are held at the Northwest Neighborhood Center located at 2160 N.6th Ave., just south of Grant Rd. next to Mansfield Park. Please contact Isabel Segovia at520-250-1441 or [email protected] for more information or if you would like to getinvolved with the program committee!

NOV 13 (THU) 7 p.m. Pima County’s Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan/NOV 13 (THU) 7 p.m. Pima County’s Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan/NOV 13 (THU) 7 p.m. Pima County’s Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan/NOV 13 (THU) 7 p.m. Pima County’s Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan/NOV 13 (THU) 7 p.m. Pima County’s Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan/Multi-species Conservation Plan Ecological Monitoring Program Design. Multi-species Conservation Plan Ecological Monitoring Program Design. Multi-species Conservation Plan Ecological Monitoring Program Design. Multi-species Conservation Plan Ecological Monitoring Program Design. Multi-species Conservation Plan Ecological Monitoring Program Design. JoinBrian Powerll with the University of Arizona to learn about how Pima County is planning tomonitor local conservation efforts.

DEC 11 (THU) 7 p.m. Sierra Club Conservation Efforts in Southern Arizona.DEC 11 (THU) 7 p.m. Sierra Club Conservation Efforts in Southern Arizona.DEC 11 (THU) 7 p.m. Sierra Club Conservation Efforts in Southern Arizona.DEC 11 (THU) 7 p.m. Sierra Club Conservation Efforts in Southern Arizona.DEC 11 (THU) 7 p.m. Sierra Club Conservation Efforts in Southern Arizona.Join the Rincon Group and learn about all of the various issues we are working on thatface southern Arizona. Topics will include border issues, the regional water study, City ofTucson environmental initiatives, and much more. You will have the chance to get involvedwith what we are currently working on as well as let us know about other issues that needattention. Holiday refreshments and snacks will be provided.

NOV 6 (THU) 6 p.m. Sedona Constructed Wetland Complex. NOV 6 (THU) 6 p.m. Sedona Constructed Wetland Complex. NOV 6 (THU) 6 p.m. Sedona Constructed Wetland Complex. NOV 6 (THU) 6 p.m. Sedona Constructed Wetland Complex. NOV 6 (THU) 6 p.m. Sedona Constructed Wetland Complex. Constructedwetlands or artificially created ponds, marshes, and lakes have been used for decades todisburse and cleanse treated municipal effluent, industrial wastes, and agricultural runoff.Join Cliff Hamilton, Sedona Councilman, to learn about the potential for Sedona to developa constructed wetland complex near the city’s Wastewater Treatment Plant using thecity’s treated wastewater that would benefit our residents, visitors, wildlife, and theenvironment. Located at the Sedona Public Library Community Room.

DEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SAT) 6 p.m. HolidaT) 6 p.m. HolidaT) 6 p.m. HolidaT) 6 p.m. HolidaT) 6 p.m. Holiday Py Py Py Py Poooootluck Appetluck Appetluck Appetluck Appetluck Appetizer Ptizer Ptizer Ptizer Ptizer Pararararartytytytyty. . . . . Bring hearty finger food for6. Located at 70 Whitetail Lane, Sedona. RSVP to 928-203-0340.

Sedona/Verde Valley GroupSedona/Verde Valley GroupSedona/Verde Valley GroupSedona/Verde Valley GroupSedona/Verde Valley Group



15

EnjoEnjoEnjoEnjoEnjoy and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizona

See Outings continued on pg. 16

NONONONONOV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” Saturdadadadaday morningy morningy morningy morningy morningexercise hike, North Phoenix Mtn.exercise hike, North Phoenix Mtn.exercise hike, North Phoenix Mtn.exercise hike, North Phoenix Mtn.exercise hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Preserve Preserve Preserve Preserve Preserve (6 mi., 1000’ EC). Tired of spendingmoney on gas? Want to get together with somefellow hikers to have fun and stay in shapefor that planned future special hike or climb?Here’s a chance to enjoy the views of thesprawling Phoenix metropolitan area and doat least a little huffing and puffing along theway. We will also have an opportunity to learnabout the geology and plant and animal life ofthe Phoenix Mtns. at the North Phoenix Mtn.Visitor Center. Lunch afterward at a localrestaurant. I wear at least light weight hikingboots for my exercise hikes, but lots of folkswear running shoes. It’s your feet. Rememberto bring enough water and an energy snack.Dogs welcome. Contact Sharon Fairchildat 602-997-1178 or [email protected]

NONONONONOV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAT) “B+” LaBarge Mtn. DaT) “B+” LaBarge Mtn. DaT) “B+” LaBarge Mtn. DaT) “B+” LaBarge Mtn. DaT) “B+” LaBarge Mtn. Day Hiky Hiky Hiky Hiky Hikeeeee(8 mi., 1800’ EC). On this mostly on-trailpeakbag, we will ascend to the rarely visited5077’-high summit of LaBarge Mtn. in theeastern Superstitions. We’ll gain 1200’ ofelevation on the J F Trail and the other 600’on the off-trail stretch. Expect steep andslippery slopes, abundant brush, andspectacular views. Gloves recommended.High-clearance vehicles required. Drive 60 mi.from Tempe. Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

NONONONONOV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAV 1 (SAT) “B” AraT) “B” AraT) “B” AraT) “B” AraT) “B” Aravvvvvaipa Canaipa Canaipa Canaipa Canaipa Canyyyyyon Easton Easton Easton Easton East(10 mi., little EC). Discover a beautiful oasis inthe middle of the Sonoran Desert. Soaringand colorful rock walls, lush vegetation, aperennially flowing stream, and abundantwildlife are the drawing cards. We will discussriparian ecology and study the fascinatinggeology showcased in this unique gorge.We will explore a side canyon and observesuch wonders as hanging gardens, flourishingsprings, and a spectacular natural arch.There are 7 permits available. ContactMitch Stevens at 520-991-1199 [email protected]. TTTTTucsonucsonucsonucsonucson

NONONONONOV 2 (SUN) “V 2 (SUN) “V 2 (SUN) “V 2 (SUN) “V 2 (SUN) “AAAAA” Plat” Plat” Plat” Plat” Plateau Peau Peau Peau Peau Point Roint Roint Roint Roint Ruinsuinsuinsuinsuinsor Ror Ror Ror Ror Ruination? uination? uination? uination? uination? (12 mi. RT, 3100’ EC,moderate pace). Grand Canyon National Park,South Rim. This is an exploratory hike downthe Bright Angel Trail to Indian Gardens andbeyond to find some reputed ruins belowPlateau Point. Some off-trail hiking with mildexposure is anticipated. We will be comparingand contrasting periods of natural quiet withthe intrusive disruption of noise from airtourists. Weather permitting. Contact Roband Kathleen Jones at 928-214-0043 [email protected]. Flagstaff Flagstaff Flagstaff Flagstaff Flagstaff

NONONONONOV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAT) “B+” Quien Sabe PT) “B+” Quien Sabe PT) “B+” Quien Sabe PT) “B+” Quien Sabe PT) “B+” Quien Sabe Peak Daeak Daeak Daeak Daeak DayyyyyHike Hike Hike Hike Hike (12 mi., 1200’ EC). On this strenuousand exploratory on and off-trail hike north ofCave Creek, we’ll ascend to one of the area’shigh points: the 4884’ summit of Quien SabePeak. Expect steep and slippery slopes, viciousvegetation, possibly wet feet, and superbviews. Drive 40 mi. one-way from Scottsdale.Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

NONONONONOV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAT) “C” Mtn. BikT) “C” Mtn. BikT) “C” Mtn. BikT) “C” Mtn. BikT) “C” Mtn. Bike Ride Fe Ride Fe Ride Fe Ride Fe Ride FourourourourourPeaks Area Peaks Area Peaks Area Peaks Area Peaks Area (10 mi. RT). We willcycle on roads at the base of beautifulFour Peaks mountain range located out-side of Fountain Hills. This is an easy bikeride with little elevation change...totallyfun. Show up with dirt bike, helmets, andgreat attitude. Contact Donna Butler [email protected]. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

NONONONONOV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAV 8 (SAT) “C+” FT) “C+” FT) “C+” FT) “C+” FT) “C+” Fremont Saddle/Loneremont Saddle/Loneremont Saddle/Loneremont Saddle/Loneremont Saddle/LonePine Point, Superstition Wilderness Pine Point, Superstition Wilderness Pine Point, Superstition Wilderness Pine Point, Superstition Wilderness Pine Point, Superstition Wilderness (6+mi. RT, 1200’ EC). Trail is worn down to bedrockfrom overuse, so there will be some minor

scrambling. Tremendous views of Weaver’sNeedle from Fremont Saddle/Lone PinePoint. Interesting geology and history. Pleasebring lunch/snacks and at least 64 oz. ofwater, wear sturdy hiking boots, and bring ahat along to keep the sun off. Maximumnumber of participants: 15 (including leader).In the event of rain, hike will be cancelled.Contact Sharon Fairchild at 602-997-1178or [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 9 (SUN) “V 9 (SUN) “V 9 (SUN) “V 9 (SUN) “V 9 (SUN) “AAAAA” Grand Can” Grand Can” Grand Can” Grand Can” Grand Canyyyyyon Corridoron Corridoron Corridoron Corridoron CorridorLoop-de-Loop Loop-de-Loop Loop-de-Loop Loop-de-Loop Loop-de-Loop (15 mi. RT, 3500’ EC,moderate pace). From the South Rim of theGrand Canyon, we will day hike down the SouthKaibab to the Tip-off, lateral across the Tonto

Trail to Indian Gardens, and return to therim on the Bright Angel Trail. We will continueobserving natural quiet vs. the disquietingnoise pollution of air tours so we mayformulate letters to the Park Service aboutnatural quiet in the Grand Canyon back-country. Weather permitting. Contact Roband Kathleen Jones at 928-214-0043 [email protected]. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

NOV 12 (WED) “C” Bev’s WeekdayNOV 12 (WED) “C” Bev’s WeekdayNOV 12 (WED) “C” Bev’s WeekdayNOV 12 (WED) “C” Bev’s WeekdayNOV 12 (WED) “C” Bev’s WeekdayHikHikHikHikHike. e. e. e. e. Hike the Black Canyon Trail. Lunch afterin Black Canyon City. Dogs welcome. ContactBev Full at [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) “B+” PT) “B+” PT) “B+” PT) “B+” PT) “B+” Peralta/Reralta/Reralta/Reralta/Reralta/Red Ted Ted Ted Ted TanksanksanksanksanksLoop (Superstition Wilderness) HikeLoop (Superstition Wilderness) HikeLoop (Superstition Wilderness) HikeLoop (Superstition Wilderness) HikeLoop (Superstition Wilderness) Hike(14 mi. RT, 2100’ EC). Join us for thissomewhat fast-paced loop through the scenicwilds of the Superstitions. We will start atthe Peralta Trailhead, hiking in on Dutchman’sTrail as we pass Miners Needle. Then headingeast onto Whiskey Spring Trail leads ustoward Coffee Flat Mtn. Following around toRed Tanks Trail. After lunch and renewed vigorwe will head up the Dutchman’s Trail to viewone of the largest saguaros in the world,which has a reported 50+ arms! Continuingon will give us spectacular views of WeaversNeedle. The final leg, Bluff Springs Trail,will take us back to Peralta. Afterward,dinner and conversation in Apache Junction.Limit 15. Contact Darrell Foster [email protected] (preferred) or 602-569-5549. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) “B” BoT) “B” BoT) “B” BoT) “B” BoT) “B” Boyntyntyntyntynton Canon Canon Canon Canon Canyyyyyon on on on on (6mi. RT, 500’ EC). Get out your smudge sticks!Boynton Canyon is one of the most scenic ofthe box canyons that make Arizona Red RockCountry so famous. It’s also a very popularNew Age “vortex” – a sort of energy fieldemanating from inner earth. Whether or notyou subscribe to this bit of modern mysticism,you’ll no doubt agree that some sort of magicexists here among the towering buttes,crimson cliffs, and natural desert gardens.Contact Michael Brady at 602-534-1355.PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) “B” BarnharT) “B” BarnharT) “B” BarnharT) “B” BarnharT) “B” Barnhardt Candt Candt Candt Candt Canyyyyyon Daon Daon Daon Daon DayyyyyHike Hike Hike Hike Hike (8 mi., 1600’ EC). Learn the naturalhistory of the Mazatzals as we walk theBarnhardt Canyon Trail on this rocky trek up tothe junction with the Sandy Saddle Trail. Alongthe way there will be towering cliffs, waterfalls,precarious stream crossings, and picturesquecanyon vistas. Contact Ted Tenny at 480-396-3389 or [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) “B+” NorT) “B+” NorT) “B+” NorT) “B+” NorT) “B+” North Pth Pth Pth Pth Peak of Chalkeak of Chalkeak of Chalkeak of Chalkeak of ChalkMtn. Day Hike Mtn. Day Hike Mtn. Day Hike Mtn. Day Hike Mtn. Day Hike (12 mi., 800’ EC). This hikewill take us to the summit of the north peak ofChalk Mtn. near Horseshoe Dam. Much of thehike will be fairly level on a dirt road. But wewill have an interesting ascent over steep

terrain and through vicious vegetation. Glovesrecommended. We also may hike throughmud, weeds, and sand. Drive 43 mi. fromScottsdale. Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) “C” WT) “C” WT) “C” WT) “C” WT) “C” Woodchutoodchutoodchutoodchutoodchute Te Te Te Te Trail,rail,rail,rail,rail,Mingus Mtn. Mingus Mtn. Mingus Mtn. Mingus Mtn. Mingus Mtn. (5–6 mi. RT, 600’ EC). Hikingtime: 3 hours. This trail on the south sideof Woodchute Mtn. was established alongwhat was once a bulldozer track. The bulldozerwas used to create several cattle wateringtanks on Woodchute Mtn. The top of themountain is an open stand of second growthponderosa pine, the original forest havingbeen completely cut years ago. When thecopper mines at Jerome were in operation,loggers obtained shoring timbers for the minesfrom this mountain. They transported the logsby way of a chute extending down the north

side of the mountain to loading platforms forthe narrow gauge railroad which servedJerome. That railroad track is now Forest Road318. There are splendid panoramic views fromthe mountaintop in all directions. Bring waterand lunch. Contact Nancy Reynolds at 928-649-3065 or [email protected]

NOV 16 (SUN) “C” Papago Park Mtn.NOV 16 (SUN) “C” Papago Park Mtn.NOV 16 (SUN) “C” Papago Park Mtn.NOV 16 (SUN) “C” Papago Park Mtn.NOV 16 (SUN) “C” Papago Park Mtn.Bike Ride. Bike Ride. Bike Ride. Bike Ride. Bike Ride. Meet at Papago Park at the northend of the zoo parking lot at 10 a.m. Durationof event will be about 2 hours. Beginningmountain bike riding lesson for people whohave the fat tire bikes and would like to domore with them than just ride the canals.Experience the trails from a differentperspective. Discover why trail riding is sucha fun and growing activity. This session willcover trail biking etiquette and how tobecome familiar and comfortable with yourbike on trails. Our integration with nature willbe emphasized. Discover how trail ridingcan have minimal impact on the environmentcompared to other trail users. Contact RonHarris at 602-955-8927 or [email protected]

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 16 (SUN) “C” Hope Cam6 (SUN) “C” Hope Cam6 (SUN) “C” Hope Cam6 (SUN) “C” Hope Cam6 (SUN) “C” Hope Camp Tp Tp Tp Tp Trail inrail inrail inrail inrail inRincon VRincon VRincon VRincon VRincon Valleallealleallealleyyyyy, Saguar, Saguar, Saguar, Saguar, Saguaro National Po National Po National Po National Po National Parararararkkkkk(6 mi. RT, 200’ EC). Take a break before theholidays and explore a seldom-visited area ofSaguaro National Park. This route follows anold road through beautiful saguaro stands atthe foot of Tanque Verde Ridge. The areabecame part of the park in 1991 and isexpected to receive increasing numbers ofvisitors as the population in the Rincon Valleygrows. Over lunch we can review the status ofthe park’s Comprehensive Trails Plan. Limit18. Contact Meg Weesner for details at 520-290-1723 or [email protected]. TTTTTucsonucsonucsonucsonucson

NONONONONOV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAT) “B+” MarT) “B+” MarT) “B+” MarT) “B+” MarT) “B+” Martinez Cantinez Cantinez Cantinez Cantinez CanyyyyyonononononDay Hike Day Hike Day Hike Day Hike Day Hike (10 mi.). North of the Gila Riverand east of Florence lies an area of dramaticand colorful canyons, mesa, and buttes. Onthis trek we will explore the lower end of oneof these canyons, rock hopping and sandslogging our way through the gorge. We’ll alsostop to explore a large and remarkable archin the canyon. Expect steep and slipperyslopes, thorny vegetation, and possibly wetfeet. Gloves recommended. High-clearancevehicles required. Drive 60 mi. from Tempe.Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

Escudilla Mountain from Hulsey Lake. Photo by Scott Mittelsteadt.

The Sierra Club is a nationwide organization with active local outings for members andnon-members. Please join us as we make friends and explore life-enriching interests.Simply find an outing by date and phone the contact for directions, reservations, time, andadditional information.RESTRICTIONS: RESTRICTIONS: RESTRICTIONS: RESTRICTIONS: RESTRICTIONS: NO FIREARMS, RADIOS, OR PETS (unless noted otherwise).Outings are by reservation. Call early (group limit 20). Each hike is rated for degree ofdifficulty and risk by the leader.

“A” >16 miles or >3,000 ft. elevation change (EC)

“B” 8–16 miles and 1,500–3,000 ft. EC

“C” 3–8 miles, 500–1,500 ft. EC RT Round Trip

“D” <3 miles and 500 ft. EC OW One Way

Trip leader has absolute authority to question trip participants as to their equipment,conditioning, and experience before and during the trip. All participants on Sierra Cluboutings are required to sign a standard liability waiver. If you would like to read the liabilitywaiver before you choose to participate in an outing, please go to http://www.sierraclub.org/outings/chapter/forms or contact the National Outings Dept. at 415-977-5528 for aprinted version. Sierra Club liability covers leaders only. Each person is responsible for hisor her own first aid equipment. If you are injured, notify the leader immediately. If you leavethe trip, with or without the leader’s permission, you are considered to be on your own untilyou rejoin the group. Hikers are encouraged to carpool and share the driver’s fuel expense.Donations accepted from all participants at $1 (member) and $3 (nonmember). Moneyis collected by the leader and deposited with the group treasurer. For more information,call Beverly Full, 480-595-2306. Hikes and outings are also listed in the Rincon Groupand Palo Verde Group Sierra Singles newsletters.

Hiking Guidelines



16

EnjoEnjoEnjoEnjoEnjoy and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore Arizonay and Explore ArizonaOutings continued from pg. 15

NONONONONOV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAV 22 (SAT) “C” McDoT) “C” McDoT) “C” McDoT) “C” McDoT) “C” McDowwwwwell Mtn. Rell Mtn. Rell Mtn. Rell Mtn. Rell Mtn. RoadoadoadoadoadAdopt-a-Highway Cleanup Project Adopt-a-Highway Cleanup Project Adopt-a-Highway Cleanup Project Adopt-a-Highway Cleanup Project Adopt-a-Highway Cleanup Project (3 mi.RT, 300’ EC). Our 5-mi. stretch of scenic bluehighway meanders through the easternfoothills of McDowell Mtn. Regional Park.Nestled between Four Peaks and theSuperstition, McDowell, and Mazatzal Mtns.,there’s no finer place in the Sonoran Desert toprovide this community service. We’ll visit“McGinty’s Table Mesa,” from which a classicview of Four Peaks may be witnessed. We’llfinish before noon, leaving the afternoon free.Each trip participant receives an official Adopt-a-Highway t-shirt and gloves courtesy ofMaricopa County’s Adopt-a-Highway program!Contact Michael Brady at 602-534-1355.PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NONONONONOV 22–23 (SAV 22–23 (SAV 22–23 (SAV 22–23 (SAV 22–23 (SAT–SUN) “T–SUN) “T–SUN) “T–SUN) “T–SUN) “AAAAA” Lime Creek” Lime Creek” Lime Creek” Lime Creek” Lime CreekBackpack. Backpack. Backpack. Backpack. Backpack. This trip will be about 10 mi. and1000’ of elevation change per day. We willhike the full length of Lime Creek, starting nearHorseshoe Lake and ending at Ranch 51 onthe road north of Seven Springs Campground.Over half of this trip will be off trail in nature,with intermittent sections of old travelwayspresent. This is arguably the best InventoriedRoadless Area on Tonto National Forest andhas extremely lush riparian conditions as wellas archeological values that need to beprotected. Saturday night will be spent at the“Lime Creek Hilton.” Contact Jim Vaaler at602-553-8208 or [email protected]

NONONONONOV 29 (SAV 29 (SAV 29 (SAV 29 (SAV 29 (SAT) “B” CaT) “B” CaT) “B” CaT) “B” CaT) “B” Cavvvvve Creek Te Creek Te Creek Te Creek Te Creek Trail Darail Darail Darail Darail DayyyyyHike Hike Hike Hike Hike (10.4 mi., 1060’ EC). This highly scenichike follows Cave Creek downstream fromSeven Springs to Spur Cross Trailhead. Thishike has an overall elevation loss, but there issome uphill travel and hikers may get theirfeet wet at stream crossings. Its hardest partmay be the car shuttle and $3 user fee forSpur Cross Park. Drive 40 mi. from Scottsdale.Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

DEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SAT) “B” QuarT) “B” QuarT) “B” QuarT) “B” QuarT) “B” Quartz Ptz Ptz Ptz Ptz Peak Daeak Daeak Daeak Daeak Day Hiky Hiky Hiky Hiky Hikeeeee(3 mi., 2500’ EC). This hike goes to the 4052’summit of Quartz Peak in the Sierra EstrellaWilderness southwest of Phoenix. The goodnews is that you follow a trail. The bad news isthat the trail ends before the top and you haveto take an off-trail ridge route on which you’llencounter steep and slippery slopes andthorny plants galore (gloves recommended).Drive 48 mi. from Phoenix. High-clearancevehicles required. Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

DEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SADEC 6 (SAT) “B” Dutchman’s TT) “B” Dutchman’s TT) “B” Dutchman’s TT) “B” Dutchman’s TT) “B” Dutchman’s Trail/Blufrail/Blufrail/Blufrail/Blufrail/BluffffffSpring TSpring TSpring TSpring TSpring Trail Loop, Superrail Loop, Superrail Loop, Superrail Loop, Superrail Loop, SuperstitionstitionstitionstitionstitionWilderness HikeWilderness HikeWilderness HikeWilderness HikeWilderness Hike (9 mi.). A challenging loophike through the Superstition Wilderness. Hikebegins at Peralta Trailhead on the Dutchman’sTrail and connects with the Bluff Spring Trail.Depending on whether or not it has rainedand how much water there is, there maybe some rock hopping, etc. WonderfulSuperstition Mtn. panoramas. Please bringlunch/snacks, at least 64 oz. of water, and ahat and wear sturdy hiking boots. In the eventof rain, hike will be cancelled. Maximumnumber of participants: 15 (including leader).Contact Sharon Fairchild at 602-997-1178or [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

DEC 6–7 (SADEC 6–7 (SADEC 6–7 (SADEC 6–7 (SADEC 6–7 (SAT–SUN) “B” YT–SUN) “B” YT–SUN) “B” YT–SUN) “B” YT–SUN) “B” YelloelloelloelloellowwwwwMedicine Butte Car Camp Medicine Butte Car Camp Medicine Butte Car Camp Medicine Butte Car Camp Medicine Butte Car Camp (10 mi.,1500’ EC). This is an old Bureau of LandManagement (BLM) wilderness study area(WSA). The Bush administration has re-designated these areas as “areas havingwilderness characteristics.” This beautiful areaof pristine Sonoran Desert receives onlyminimal administrative protection from the

BLM. This area is within the “Sonoran DesertProtection Proposal study area.” The vastarc of mostly BLM lands west of the Phoenixmetropolitan area has many old BLMwilderness study areas within its boundary.Eventual wilderness designation for theseareas will be the only real way that these areascan be protected from off-road vehicle abuseand energy installations. Contact Jim Vaalerat 602-553-8208 or [email protected]

DEC 7 (SUN) Mtn. Bike Ride DEC 7 (SUN) Mtn. Bike Ride DEC 7 (SUN) Mtn. Bike Ride DEC 7 (SUN) Mtn. Bike Ride DEC 7 (SUN) Mtn. Bike Ride (10 mi. RT).Meet at Dreamy Draw Park at the parking lotat 10 a.m. Technical skill is beginning tointermediate; stamina: above average. This

Lower La Barge Box. As we eat our lunch wewill discuss the area’s diverse geology andhistory. This adventure requires strong, agile,hiking/scrambling abilities, without a fear ofslightly exposed heights. This is NOT a climband requires NO technical gear. Afterward,dinner and conversation in Apache Junction.Limit 15. Contact Darrell Foster at [email protected] (preferred) or 602-569-5549. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 13 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SAT) “B” O’Grady CanT) “B” O’Grady CanT) “B” O’Grady CanT) “B” O’Grady CanT) “B” O’Grady Canyyyyyon Daon Daon Daon Daon DayyyyyHikeHikeHikeHikeHike (7 mi., 1000’ EC). The northeast slopesof the Superstitions offer unique studies ofthe mountains and canyons, charismaticrock formations, and a charming and vivacious

NONONONONOV 1V 1V 1V 1V 15 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SA5 (SAT) 8:30 a.m. – 2 p.m. Wild at HearT) 8:30 a.m. – 2 p.m. Wild at HearT) 8:30 a.m. – 2 p.m. Wild at HearT) 8:30 a.m. – 2 p.m. Wild at HearT) 8:30 a.m. – 2 p.m. Wild at Heart raptt raptt raptt raptt raptor sheltor sheltor sheltor sheltor shelter – poster – poster – poster – poster – postelection spruce-up.election spruce-up.election spruce-up.election spruce-up.election spruce-up. Please join the Chapter Wildlife Committee as we unwindafter the campaign season and spruce up the Wild at Heart raptor rehabilitationcenter facilities in Cave Creek. Relying on volunteer support, Wild at Heart caresfor injured and displaced birds of prey, with most being rehabilitated and released.Participants will have a chance to admire the beautiful birds up close. We’ll doyardwork and exterior painting. Bring work gloves, sunscreen, and water andwear closed shoes. Tools, water refills, and lunch will be provided. Carpooling canbe arranged or folks can meet on-site. Please contact Halina at 602-749-2063or [email protected] for more information and to sign up. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

NOV 23 (SUN) 8 a.m. – 3 p.m. Ironwood Forest National MonumentNOV 23 (SUN) 8 a.m. – 3 p.m. Ironwood Forest National MonumentNOV 23 (SUN) 8 a.m. – 3 p.m. Ironwood Forest National MonumentNOV 23 (SUN) 8 a.m. – 3 p.m. Ironwood Forest National MonumentNOV 23 (SUN) 8 a.m. – 3 p.m. Ironwood Forest National Monumentinvasive species removal. invasive species removal. invasive species removal. invasive species removal. invasive species removal. Our ongoing battle with buffel grass continues. Wewill assist the Bureau of Land Management with removal of this non-native,invasive species from a portion of Ironwood Forest National Monument nearTucson. The plan is to work for 3–4 hours, have a lunch break, and finish no laterthan 3 p.m. There will be an orientation session on identifying the grass and howto safely remove it, plus a briefing on the monument and the vegetation. SierraClub will provide lunch. For more information and to RSVP, contact Sandy Bahr at602-253-8633 or [email protected]. TTTTTucsonucsonucsonucsonucson

ascent back out of LaBarge Canyon.Tremendous vistas of the Superstition Mtns.Wear hiking boots and bring lunch/snacks andat least 64 oz. of water. Remember hat tokeep sun off. In the event of rain, hike will becancelled. Contact Sharon Fairchild at 602-997-1178 or [email protected].

DEC 28 (SUN) “C” High Points of theDEC 28 (SUN) “C” High Points of theDEC 28 (SUN) “C” High Points of theDEC 28 (SUN) “C” High Points of theDEC 28 (SUN) “C” High Points of theCactus ForestCactus ForestCactus ForestCactus ForestCactus Forest (5 mi., 500’ EC). Hike to someof the high points in the Cactus Forest area ofSaguaro National Park East. We will follow theGarwood, Wildhorse, and Carillo Trails andstop for lunch in a scenic spot. Over lunch wecan review the history of the area and discussprotection strategies for Tucson’s backyardnational park. Limit 18. Contact MegWeesner for details at 520-290-1723 [email protected]. TTTTTucsonucsonucsonucsonucson

JJJJJAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAT) “C+” CorT) “C+” CorT) “C+” CorT) “C+” CorT) “C+” Coronado Mesa Daonado Mesa Daonado Mesa Daonado Mesa Daonado Mesa DayyyyyHike Hike Hike Hike Hike (5–6 mi. RT). On this off-trail hike wewill follow the rim of Coronado Mesa and enjoyrarely seen vistas of spectacular lower FishCreek Canyon in the Superstitions. Thoughmuch of the hike is relatively level, we will dosome up and down hill travel and encounterpainful plants. Gloves recommended. Call KenMcGinty at 602-265-2854. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

JJJJJAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAAN 3 (SAT) “B” Alder Saddle – BlackT) “B” Alder Saddle – BlackT) “B” Alder Saddle – BlackT) “B” Alder Saddle – BlackT) “B” Alder Saddle – BlackBear Saddle DaBear Saddle DaBear Saddle DaBear Saddle DaBear Saddle Day Hiky Hiky Hiky Hiky Hike e e e e (10 mi. RT, 1500’EC). This outing in the Four Peaks Wildernesswill take us into the upper end of AlderCanyon. Portions of the Alder Creek Trail werebadly damaged by the Lone Fire that occurredabout 12 years ago. The Alder Creek Trailwas the most scenic trail in the whole FourPeaks Wilderness Area. The part of the AlderCreek Trail going up to Alder Saddle from thenorth is still in good shape. I would like toevaluate that part of the trail that is south ofAlder Saddle. Some of the terrain may bechallenging. We won’t know until we get there.Contact Jim Vaaler at 602-553-8208 [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

JJJJJAN 1AN 1AN 1AN 1AN 10 (SA0 (SA0 (SA0 (SA0 (SAT) “T) “T) “T) “T) “AAAAA” Malpais Mtn. Da” Malpais Mtn. Da” Malpais Mtn. Da” Malpais Mtn. Da” Malpais Mtn. Day Hiky Hiky Hiky Hiky Hikeeeee(10–12 mi., 2400’ EC). Malpais Mtn. loomshigh above Geronimo Head in the SuperstitionWilderness near Tortilla Flat. This off-trail hikewill climb Geronimo Head and continue on tothe 4229’ Malpais summit. Expect superbviews and all manner of off-trail adversities:steep, rocky, and slippery slopes and viciousvegetation. This hike is for fast and stronghikers only. Gloves recommended. Drive 45mi. from Tempe. Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

will be a ride going east on trail 100. There area few interesting parts of the trail; however,most of the ride is beginning-intermediatelevel. We will ride about 2 hours. Call RonHarris at 602-955-8927 or [email protected]

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 13 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SAT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” SaturT) “C+” Saturdadadadaday Morningy Morningy Morningy Morningy MorningExercise Hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Exercise Hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Exercise Hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Exercise Hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Exercise Hike, North Phoenix Mtn.Preserve Preserve Preserve Preserve Preserve (6 mi., 1000’ EC). Tired of spendingmoney on gas? Want to get together withfellow hikers to have fun and stay in shape?Here’s a chance to enjoy the views of thesprawling Phoenix metropolitan area and doat least a little huffing and puffing along theway. We will also have an opportunity to learnabout the geology and plant and animal life ofthe Phoenix Mtns. at the North Phoenix Mtn.Visitor Center. Lunch afterward at a localrestaurant. I wear at least light weight hikingboots for my exercise hikes, but lots of folkswear running shoes. It’s your feet. Rememberto bring enough water and an energy snack.Dogs welcome. Contact Sharon Fairchildat 602-997-1178 or [email protected]

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 13 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SAT) “B” ThomT) “B” ThomT) “B” ThomT) “B” ThomT) “B” Thompson Ppson Ppson Ppson Ppson Peak Daeak Daeak Daeak Daeak DayyyyyHike Hike Hike Hike Hike (9 mi., 2100’ EC). This trek will ascendup a paved but extremely steep road to the3993’-high summit of Thompson Peak in theMcDowell Mtns. near Fountain Hills. On theway we’ll visit the Dixie Mine and see someinteresting petroglyphs. The summit offersunparalleled views of the Phoenix area to thewest and the mountains to the east. Drive 20mi. from Scottsdale. Call Ken McGinty at 602-265-2854. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 13 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SA3 (SAT) “T) “T) “T) “T) “AAAAA” Battleship Mtn.” Battleship Mtn.” Battleship Mtn.” Battleship Mtn.” Battleship Mtn.Summit Hike (Superstition Wilderness)Summit Hike (Superstition Wilderness)Summit Hike (Superstition Wilderness)Summit Hike (Superstition Wilderness)Summit Hike (Superstition Wilderness)(12 mi. RT, 2100’ EC). Join us for this verychallenging, somewhat fast-paced hike/scramble to the top of this prominentlandmark in the Western SuperstitionWilderness. We will start at the First Water TH,continuing on the trails of Second Water andBoulder Canyon before departing the trail toour scramble up to the summit of Battleship.The views from the peak will be incredible,including Weavers Needle, Canyon Lake, and

upper Sonoran ecosystem. On this moderatelypaced on and off-trail hike we’ll follow FirstWater Creek upstream and return by wayof O’Grady Canyon and an unmarked trailnorth of Tim’s Saddle. Come prepared forwet cobblestones, boulder scrambling(gloves recommended), prickly plant life,sweeping vistas, and comical canyons.Contact Ted Tenny at 480-396-3389 [email protected]. PhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenixPhoenix

DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 1DEC 17 (WED) “C” Be7 (WED) “C” Be7 (WED) “C” Be7 (WED) “C” Be7 (WED) “C” Bev’s Wv’s Wv’s Wv’s Wv’s Weekdaeekdaeekdaeekdaeekday Hiky Hiky Hiky Hiky Hike.e.e.e.e.Hike the Waterfall Trail. Lunch after in CaveCreek. Dogs welcome. Contact Bev Full [email protected]. Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix Phoenix

DEC 20 (SADEC 20 (SADEC 20 (SADEC 20 (SADEC 20 (SAT) “C+” Boulder CanT) “C+” Boulder CanT) “C+” Boulder CanT) “C+” Boulder CanT) “C+” Boulder CanyyyyyonononononTTTTTrail/LaBarge Canrail/LaBarge Canrail/LaBarge Canrail/LaBarge Canrail/LaBarge Canyyyyyon, Superon, Superon, Superon, Superon, SuperstitionstitionstitionstitionstitionWilderness Wilderness Wilderness Wilderness Wilderness (7.3 mi., 1000’ EC). HikeBoulder Canyon Trail from the Canyon LakeTrailhead to the junction with the SecondWater Trail (out and back). There will be amoderate ascent, a steep descent intoLaBarge Canyon, and, of course, the steep

FFFFFirst Aid irst Aid irst Aid irst Aid irst Aid TTTTTraining for Hraining for Hraining for Hraining for Hraining for Hike Leadersike Leadersike Leadersike Leadersike LeadersWWWWWednesdayednesdayednesdayednesdayednesday, N, N, N, N, Nooooovvvvvember 12ember 12ember 12ember 12ember 12

6–8 p.m.6–8 p.m.6–8 p.m.6–8 p.m.6–8 p.m.202 E. McDowell Rd., Phoenix (upper conference room)202 E. McDowell Rd., Phoenix (upper conference room)202 E. McDowell Rd., Phoenix (upper conference room)202 E. McDowell Rd., Phoenix (upper conference room)202 E. McDowell Rd., Phoenix (upper conference room)

To ensure that our hikes, backpacks, and other outings are both enjoyable and assafe as possible, the Sierra Club requires that all Sierra Club hike leaders have firstaid certification. If you are interested in becoming a hike leader or are a currentleader who needs a refresher, please mark your calendar and plan to attendthis first aid class. The cost is $20 per person. Scholarships are also available.The deadline to RSVP is NThe deadline to RSVP is NThe deadline to RSVP is NThe deadline to RSVP is NThe deadline to RSVP is Nooooovvvvvember 7, 2008. ember 7, 2008. ember 7, 2008. ember 7, 2008. ember 7, 2008. We hope you can make it!

To sign up or for more information, please contact Sandy Bahr at602-253-8633 or [email protected].

Sierra Service OutingsSierra Service OutingsSierra Service OutingsSierra Service OutingsSierra Service Outings

November - December 2008 Canyon Echo

Documents

Transcript of November - December 2008 Canyon Echo