NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER...

26
AWWA/AMTA© 1 NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER REUSE Ben Freeman Hydranautics – A Nitto Group Company Antoine Leroux, Albert Shen, Osman Kung

Transcript of NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER...

Page 1: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 1

NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION

WASTEWATER REUSE Ben Freeman

Hydranautics – A Nitto Group Company Antoine Leroux, Albert Shen, Osman Kung

Page 2: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 2

Outline

• Introduction • Case Study 1 • Case Study 2 • Conclusions

Page 3: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 3

Introduction

• 2010 Water Consumption = 450 MGD*

• 2015 Projected Water Consumption = 533 MGD*

* Assumes production of single 300 mm silicon wafer requires ~2000 gallons of water.

Source: Sage Concepts Market Report

Page 4: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 4 4

Semiconductor Manufacturing Process (Back side)

BG

DC

Page 5: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 5

Back grinding (BG) and Dicing (DC)

Source: www.adt-dicing.com

Source: GRINDING OF SILICON WAFERS: WAFER SHAPE MODEL AND ITS APPLICATONS (Sun, 2005)

Back grinding WW Characteristics

Particle Size (µm)

0.1 - 0.3

Turbidity (NTU)

>1,000

Dicing WW Characteristics

Particle Size (µm)

0.2 - 2

Turbidity (NTU)

>100

Backgrinding + Dicing WW (left) and Dicing WW only (right)

Page 6: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 6

Ultrapure Water Process

Feed water Degassing UV EDI Ion-

exchange

Tank UV Ion-exchange

Subsystem

Use point Final filter

UF

UF Pre-treatment

RO Pre-treatment

BG/DC wastewater

recycle/reuse

UF Treatment

RO Treatment

RO Pre-treatment

• Reduction of source water consumption results in: • Lower source water and wastewater disposal

cost • Potential reduction in primary treatment system

sizing

Page 7: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 7

System 1

200 micron Filter

6 HYDRAcap MAX 60

Feed water Degassing UV EDI Ion-

exchange

Tank UV Ion-exchange

Subsystem

Use points Final filter

UF

UF Pre-treatment

RO Pre-treatment

RO Pre-treatment

BG/DC WW Only

Page 8: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 8

System 1 Parameter Unit Value

System capacity m3/hr 15 Module type Hydranautics HYDRAcap® MAX 60

Number of racks 1 Number of modules per rack 6 Gross operating filtration flux LMH 32

Concentrate bleed flow m3/hr 1.5 Filtration cycle duration min 45

Physical cleaning method Air scour without backwash Air scour flow rate per module m3/hr 4 Chemical cleaning frequency Two 0.1% NaOH maintenance cleans per day

System Recovery % 90

HYDRAcap® MAX 60 Overview Flow path Outside to inside Membrane material TIPS PVDF

Membrane configuration Hollow fiber

Membrane area 840 ft2 (78 m2)

Fiber ID/OD 0.6/1.2 mm

Pore size 0.08 µm

Page 9: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 9

1. Backwash

BW Filtrate In

BW Waste Out

Physical Cleaning Methods

Page 10: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 10

BW Filtrate In

BW Waste Out Air

2. Backwash + Air Scour

Physical Cleaning Methods

1. Backwash Vent

Page 11: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 11

BW Waste Out Air

2. Backwash + Air Scour 3. Air Assisted Liquid BW + Air

Scour

Low pressure air

Physical Cleaning Methods

1. Backwash Vent

Page 12: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 12

Waste Out Air

2. Backwash + Air Scour 3. Air Assisted Liquid BW + Air

Scour

Low pressure air

Physical Cleaning Methods

1. Backwash

4. Air Scour

Vent

Page 13: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 13

System 1 – Physical Cleaning Process

Feed Drain

Air

Filtrate

Concentrate/ Air Vent

Air Scour Step Typical Duration (s)

1 Stop Filtration 0

2 Air Scour 60

3 Air Scour and Drain

60

4 Refill 60

5 Resume Filtration

0

Page 14: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 14

Feed Drain

Air

Filtrate

Concentrate/ Air Vent

Air flow: 12 – 15 m3/h per module Air pressure: 0.7 bar

Air Scour Step Typical Duration (s)

1 Stop Filtration 0

2 Air Scour 60

3 Air Scour and Drain

60

4 Refill 60

5 Resume Filtration 0

System 1 – Physical Cleaning Process

Page 15: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 15

Feed Drain

Air

Filtrate

Concentrate/ Air Vent

System 1 – Physical Cleaning Process

Air Scour Step Typical Duration (s)

1 Stop Filtration 0

2 Air Scour 60

3 Air Scour and Drain

60

4 Refill 60

5 Resume Filtration 0

Page 16: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 16

System 1 – Physical Cleaning Process

Feed Drain

Air

Filtrate

Concentrate/ Air Vent

Air Scour Step Typical Duration (s)

1 Stop Filtration 0

2 Air Scour 60

3 Air Scour and Drain

60

4 Refill 60

5 Resume Filtration 0

Page 17: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 17

System 1 – Physical Cleaning Process

Feed Drain

Air

Filtrate

Concentrate/ Air Vent

Air Scour Step Typical Duration (s)

1 Stop Filtration 0

2 Air Scour 60

3 Air Scour and Drain

60

4 Refill 60

5 Resume Filtration

0

Page 18: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 18

System 1 – Operating Performance

• Flux ~ 20 gfd • Stable TMP – Avg. 4 psi • Consistent Filtrate Turbidity

<0.075 NTU

Page 19: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 19

System 2 Overview

2-5 ppm Chlorine

DC/BG Wastewater + Cooling Tower

Blowdown

200 micron Filter

Feed water Degassing UV EDI Ion-

exchange

Tank UV Ion-exchange

Subsystem

Use points Final filter

UF

UF Pre-treatment

RO Pre-treatment

RO Pre-treatment

6 HYDRAcap MAX 60

Page 20: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 20

Case Study 2 Parameter Unit Value

System capacity m3/day 432

Module type Hydranautics HYDRAcap® MAX 60

Number of racks 1

Number of modules per rack 6

Gross operating filtration flux LMH 35-40

Concentrate bleed flow m3/hr 1.5

Filtration cycle duration min 45

Physical cleaning method Air scour with backwash Air scour flow rate per

module m3/hr 4

Chemical cleaning frequency Two caustic maintenance cleans per

day (0.1% NaOH)

System Recovery % ~85

Page 21: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 21

System 2 - Feed Water Quality

• Turbidity = 1100 NTU • ~98% of particles larger than 0.1 micron

Page 22: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 22

System 2 – Operating Performance

• Constant TMP ~ 2 psi • 1st Year Filtrate Turbidity <0.1 NTU

Page 23: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 23

System 2 - Module Autopsy • After ~1 year of operation, turbidity exceed 0.1

NTU • Tensiometry revealed slight strength decline

• Most likely due to improper draining

Page 24: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 24

System Cost Comparison Without Reuse

With Reuse – BW Free Operation (System 1)

With Reuse – Operation with BW (System 2)

Source Water and Sewer Cost - $/mo. 8,140.31 1,866.24 2,214.80

Chem Cost - $/mo. 128.65 128.65

Energy Cost - $/mo 129.60 129.60

Operator - $/mo 1,200.00 1,200.00

Total ($/mo) 8,140.31 3,324.50 3,673.06

Difference ($/mo) 4,815.81 4,467.25

System Cost < $150,000 $150,000 Simple Payback Period < 31 months 33.6 months

Page 25: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 25

Conclusions

• Backwash free operation is capable of sustaining stable permeability, even when treating very high feed water turbidity

• Advantages of BW free system – Reduced OPEX through increased recovery – Reduced CAPEX through elimination of BW

pump, tank, associated piping • Proper drain piping arrangement critical

Page 26: NOVEL ULTRAFILTRATION OPERATING PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER …membranes.com/wp-content/uploads/Documents/Technical... · 2019. 1. 7. · PROCESS FOR SILICON WAFER PRODUCTION WASTEWATER

AWWA/AMTA© 26

Conclusions

• BG/DC WW can be segregated from other use point wastewaters to optimize reuse potential and reduce CAPEX of primary UPW system by decreased equipment sizing

• Test operation without concentrate bleed – Payback period reduced by ~0.5 months for

every 1% increase in recovery