Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and...

10
NGU-BULL 436, 2000 - PAGE 103 Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses, with emphasis on the massifs of the Inner Sogn-Voss area in western Norway JAN EG IL WANVI K Wanvik, J.E. 2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their indus trial uses, w it h emphasis on th e massifs of t he Inner Soqn- Vo ss area in western Norw ay. Norges geologiske undersokelse Bulle tin 436, 103-112. Anorthositic rocks are common in several geological provinces in Norway. Many occur at scattered localities in different parts of th e country, but th e two largest anorthosite complexes in western Europe are situated in western Norway. These two Precambrian massifs, t he Inner Soq n-Voss province (- 1700 Mal. and the Rogaland prov ince (- 930 Ma) have been investig ated for use as a raw material for various indust rial applications . Anorthosite with a high anorthite content (An >70) is easily soluble in mineral acids, and the bytownite plagioclase of the Soq n anorthosite makes it well suited for industrial processes based on acid leaching. The high alumini um content, ca. 31% A1 2 0 3 , has made th ese occurrences interesting for various industrial applications, especially as an alternative raw material for the Norwegian aluminium industry. With this goal in mind, geological investigations and processing studies have been carried out at various times during the past centu ry. At present, a refined process utilising bot h t he silicon and t he calcium contents of the anort hosite has renewed industrial int erest in th eseacid soluble anort hosites. Jan Egil Wanvik, Geol ogical Survey of Norway, N-7491Trondheim, Norway. Introduction Anorthositic rocks are commo n in several geological prov- inces in Norway and occur at many localit ies in diff erent parts of the country (Fig. 1). Most of th e bodies are of relatively small size, but a few are of appreciably larger dimensions. Amon g these are the Bergen Arc anorthosites (Kolderup & Kolderup 1940), and most promine ntly, t he 500 km 2 Roga- land province and the 700 km 2 Inn er Sogn -Voss prov ince. These are th e two largest anorthosite occurrences in w este rn Europe and are of considerable interest for indust rial applica- ti on s. Anorthosite isan almost monomi neralic, feld spathi c roc k with a great variety of industrial applicatio ns (Table 1). Anortho site massifs are known to host i mpo rtant ore depos- it s such as ilm enit e and are, in many cases, excellent sources for high-quality rock aggregate and also for dim ension- stone. The exploitation of anorthosite for industrial mineral product s is growi ng, and th e potential for futu re production of aluminiu m and other important constituent s fro m anorthosites is considered to be quit e con sid erabl e. It is prim arily the high aluminium content of th e Sogn anortho site which makes it att ract ive for a vari ety of indus- trial end uses.The aluminium content can be utilised in vari- ous processes. Most i mporta ntly, ano rt hosite can be leached with mineral acids in order to facilitate the liberation of alu- minium. Simultaneously, the calcium component is liber- ated, and is th us available for other pot enti al applications. Laboratory investigations(Graff 198 1) have shown th at pl agi- oclase (albite NaAISi 3 0 8 - ano rth ite CaAI 2Si 2 0 8 ) has a solub il- ity which is highly dependent upon the An content of plagi- oclase (Fig. 2). Anorth osite with An<so is almost non-soluble Egersund Fig. 1. Distr ibu tion of anort hosites (red) in Norway. Modified afte r Qvale (1982b). Boxed area - Fig. 3.

Transcript of Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and...

Page 1: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

NGU-BULL 436, 2000 - PAGE 103

Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses, withemphasis on the massifs of the Inner Sogn-Voss area inwestern Norway

JAN EGILWANVI K

Wanvik, J.E. 2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their indus trial uses, w it h emphasis on th e massifsof t he Inner Soqn­Vo ss area in western Norw ay. Norges geo logiske undersokelse Bulle tin 436, 103-112.

Anorthosit ic rocks are common in several geological provinces in Norway. Many occur at scattered localit ies indifferent parts of th e country, but th e two largest anort hosite complexes in western Europe are situated in westernNorway. These two Precambrian massifs, t he Inner Soq n-Voss province (- 1700 Mal. and the Rogaland prov ince (­930 Ma) have been investig ated for use as a raw material for various indust rial applications . Anorthosite w ith a highanorthite content (An >70) is easily soluble in mineral acids, and the bytownite plagioclase of the Soq n anorthositemakes it well suited for industrial processes based on acid leaching. The high alumini um content, ca. 31% A120 3, hasmade th ese occurrences interesting for various indust rial app licat ions, especially as an alternative raw material fort he Norwegian alumi nium industry. With th is goa l in mind, geological invest igati on s and processing studies havebeen carried out at various t imes during the past centu ry. At present , a refined process ut ilising bot h t he silicon andt he calcium contents of the anort hosite has renewed industrial int erest in th eseacid soluble anort hosites.

Jan Egil Wanv ik, Geol ogical Survey of Norway, N-7491Tron dheim, Norwa y.

IntroductionAnorthosit ic rocks are common in several geological prov­inces in Norway and occur at many localit ies in different partsof the country (Fig. 1). Most of th e bodies are of relati velysmall size, but a few are of appreciably larger dimen sion s.Amon g these are the Bergen Arc anor thosites (Kolderup &Kolderup 1940), and most prominently, t he 500 km2 Roga­land prov ince and the 700 km2 Inner Sogn -Voss prov ince.These are th e two largest ano rthosite occurrences in weste rnEurope and are of considerable interest for indust rial applica­tion s.

Anorthosit e is an almost monomineralic, feld spathi c rockwit h a great variety of indust rial appl ications (Table 1).

Anorthosite massifs are known to host important ore depos­it s such as ilm enite and are, in many cases,excellent sourcesfor high -quality rock aggregate and also for dim ensio n­stone. The explo itat ion of anorthosite fo r industrial mineralproducts is growing, and th e potential for futu re product ionof aluminiu m and other importan t const it uents fro manorthosites is considered to be quite considerable.

It is prim arily th e high aluminium conte nt of th e Sognanorthosite w hich makes it attract ive for a vari ety of indus­trial end uses.The alumi nium con te nt can be util ised in vari­ous processes. Most importantly, anort hosite can be leachedwith min eral acids in order to facili tate the liberation of alu­minium. Simultaneou sly, th e calcium component is liber­ated, and is th us available for other potenti al applicat ions.Labo ratory investigations(Graff 198 1) have shown th at plagi­oc lase (albite NaAISi30 8 - ano rth ite CaAI2Si 20 8) has a solub il­ity w hich is highly dependent upon the An conte nt of plagi­

oclase (Fig. 2). Anorth osite w ith An<so is almost non-soluble

Egersund

Fig. 1. Distr ibu tion of anort hosites (red) in Norway. Modified afte r Qvale(1982b). Boxed area - Fig. 3.

Page 2: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

NGU-BULL 436,2000 - PAGE 104 JAN EGIL WANVIK

Processing Products Uses Specifics

Physical. Plagioclasegrainswithcrystal Aggregates Light coloured road surfaces, gardens,structure intact

(dryor wetmineral Building materials Concreteelements,dimensionstone,industrialfloors

processing) Abrasives Scouringpowder, toothpaste, sa ndblasting

Fillers, extenders, coatings Paint, plastics, rubber

Chemical Aluminium chlorides Aluminiummetal

Aluminiumoxide(alumina) Flocculent Waterandwastewater treatment

(acid or alkaline Aluminiumsulphate(alum) FlocculentJsizing Papermanufacture

leaching) Calcium carbonate Binder Asphalt

Calcium nitrate Catalyst Organic reactions

Calciumsilicate Aluminaspeciality products

Ammonium nitrate Cellulose insulation

Silica gelsand sols Cement components

Sodiumsilicates Cosmeticsandpharmaceuticals

Sodiumcarbonate Food processing

Nitrogen fertiliser

Specia lity metallurgical uses

Syntheticwollastoniteand zeolite

Silica residue Fi llers andextenders Polyesterandepoxyresins, Poly-urethanevarnishes

Coating Whiteenamel

Absorbent Kittylitter, radioactivepactides

Siliconproduction

Cement additive

Melting Fullyorpartial meltingof Ceramics Floorandwalltiles,electricalporcelain,plagioclase grains bioceramics, ceramic glazes

Glass fibre

MineralWool Rockwool

Welding f1 uxes

AI-productioncells Cryolitebathinsulation

Directreduction AI-S-alloys,AI- andSi-metal.

Table 1. Various industrial uses ofanorthosite. Norwegian commer­cial and tested uses markedin ital­ics.

in minera l acids, whereas labradorit e plagioc lase (AnSO-70) ispart ly soluble . Only anorthos ites cont ain ing plagioclase wi thmore than 70% An (bytownite) are proven to be fu lly solub le.Such basic anorthos ites are relative ly rare, but the large mas­sifs in the Sogn-Voss region conta in immense quantit ies ofeasily soluble anorthosites wi th an AI20 3 content of about31 %. This makes th ese bytown ite-anor thos ites a potent ialalternat ive to imported bauxite asa source of alum inium orefo r the large Norwegian alumini um industry, and they havebeen evaluated for th is purpose at variou s times since early inth e 20th century.

Main Norwegian anorthosite depositsWith regard to indu strial uses it is adequate to grou p

anorthosites into tw o categories ; acid soluble and not acidsoluble.

Large areas of th e Voss-Sogn massifs (Figs. 3 and 6) are ofoutstand ing quality concerning acid solub il ity, making the mideally suited for several industrial app licat ions (see below).

Acid-soluble anorthosite might also be present in someof the much smaller occurrences in Norway, but none of theother major anorthosite deposits are composed of solub leplagioclase (Qvale 1982b). The - 75 km2 Bergen Arcanorthos ites, for examp le, are dominated by a plag ioclasewith An<so (Kolderup & Kolderup 1940).

The anorthosit es of th e 500 km2 Rogaland province (Fig.1) are dominated by andesine - plagioclase (An4o- so) (Duch­esne et al. 1987) and are thus also insoluble in acids. Thisanort hosite complex is best known for its large norite-hostedilmeni te deposit at Tellnes. However, the anorthosite itself

Page 3: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

JAN EGIL WANVIK NGU -BUL L 436,2000 - PAGE 105

,

20 kmo

6 •

Mjolfjell

drill ing were carried out in Kinsedal by Norsk Hydro (Carstens1942). The work culm inated in the buil ding of a compl eteplant fo r und ergrou nd mining , transport and shipping ofanorthosite. Up to 300 men were employed there and some15,000 tonn esof rock were produced before sabotage endedthe work in 1945.

In the mid 1960s, und erground mining of whit eanorthosite began in Neereydal (Figs.4, 7 and 8) in the alteredzone along th e thrust at the base of the Gudvangen-Mjolfjellmassif. Production has continued since th at t ime. Productshave includ ed white road aggregate, white concrete ele­ments, and abrasives for use in toothpaste and cleaningagents. Annu al production has varied between 10,000 and100,000 to nnes of anorthosite. Part of the production hasbeen exported, and the most recent development is the ship­ping of anorthosite to a Swedish producer of mineral wool.

Throughout most of the 20th century, the major potentialend-use of the Sogn-type anorthosite has been consideredto be as an alternative alumin ium raw mater ial to bauxite,based on the solubility of this anorthosite typ e in mineralacids. Leaching wi th acids, such asHCI and H2S04 is very wellestablished in the Norwegi an Anort al process (Kvande 1987,Braaten 1991). In the mid 1970s, the form ation of the Interna­t ional Bauxit e Association (IBA) triggered Elkem A/S andArdal og Sunndal Verk AlS into renewing th eir interest inanorthosite asan alternative aluminium raw material. Duringthe period 1976-1982, majo r geological investigations andprocess development were carried out on the Sogn

Fig. 3. Anorth osit ic rocks of Inner Sogn and Voss.

100

907050

40 60 80An of plagioclase

30

20

10

~ Oligoclase Andesine Labradorite Bytownite<{ :

0 1..== ==;== :=:...,....-- ---,.---.:..- --.-- ----.o

100

0:80«

"§.Q0 60~0

.Sq 40«"0Qls:o 20roQl--l

Norwegian investigations anddevelopmentsHistorical perspectiveThe potenti al for explo itation of the anorthosite for variou spurposes has been evaluated at different t imes since thebeg inning of the 20th century. Goldschmidt (1919) was thefirst to propose the idea of ut ilising anorthosite as a rawmaterial for the production of alum inium and aluminium incomb inat ion wi th other elements.Two yearsearlier, he intro­duced his idea to AlS Elekt rokemisk Industri and also carriedout the first regional investigation of the anorthosites of theInner Sogn area (Goldschmidt 1917). Goldschmidt found thatthe massif in th e Neereydal area contained th e best quality ofeasily solubl e anorthosite. He also located a deposit inKinsedal, east of Lustrafjord, which was suitable for a leach­ing process to liberate the aluminium com pon ent .lnvestiga­tions in Kinsedal continued until 1920.

Interest for anorthosite as an alternat ive raw material foraluminium production was revived during the second world

war. Extensive field invest igati ons, sampling and diamond

has several industrial applications. The altered , white varietyis mined for aggregate and filler purposes, and an attract ive,massive brown variety wi th blue labradorescence in someplagioclase crystals is quarried as dimensi on stone (Heldal &

Lund 1995).A summary of the anorthosite occurrences in Norway has

been given by Ovale (1982a). In th is report Ovale also gives acomp rehensive overview of the geology and mineralogy ofthe Sogn-Voss anorth osite provinces. Wanvik (1999) pre­sented an overview of the same area wi th emphasis on thecrit eria and geographical variations regarding potentialindust rial use.

Fig. 2. Plot of so lubili ty vs. ano rth ite content of plagioclase. Mod ified af­

ter Graft (1981) and Qvale (1982al .

Page 4: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

NGU -BULL 43 6,2000 - PAGE 106

Fig. 4. Anorthosite in Nee roydalen near Gudvangen, as seen from Stal­heim. Mangeritic gneissesare located below the anortho site of the well­known Jordalsnut .

anorthosite by the joint ventu re com pany li S Anortal (Wan­vik 1981, Braaten 1991). The main obj ect ive of th e fieldworkwas to locate a deposit containing at least 100 million tonnesof readily solub le anorthosite, which contains on ly minoramou nts of mafic min erals. Areas wi th top-quality rock werelocated and drilled at two separate locat ions; the Hyllandfield and the Kaldafjell field , south of Neeroydal (Fig. 7). TheGeolog ical Survey of Norway has cont ributed to the projectwith important field investig at ions on a regio nal scale (Qvale1982b).

The Anortal project was successful concerning adequateraw mater ial and the developm ent of a technically viableprocess, and thus the main issues of establ ishing a possibleNorwegian alternat ive to im ported bauxite was solved. Theproject , however, was termin ated, as th e concept was notfound to be commercially compatib le wi th existing bauxite­based alumina produc t ion.

Recent developmentsAt th e start of the 1990s, the com pany AIS Polymer (nowPolymer Norg e AS) introduced the concept of produci ng apo lymeric coagu lant (polyaluminium chlorid e) for cleaningdrinking water and waste water, employ ing anorthosite asthe raw material. The process involves acid leaching of th e

JAN EGIL WANVIK

raw material and thus adopts parts of the processing resultsdevelop ed in the Anortal project. New alte rnat ive sites forquarrying suitable anorthosite have, in this conne ction beenlocated by th e Geolog ical Survey of Norway (Wanvik 1997,1999). The comp any is at present carrying out a pilot-scaleprocessing development in Poland. Results so far have beenvery encouraging. The highl y po lluted waste water fromPolish and East Europ ean industry is seen as th e main targetfor the prod uct.

In 1993, a Norwe gian company (Borgestad Fabrikker A.S.)wished to test the high AI and Ca Sogn anorthosite as a rawmaterial for a new refractory prod uct designed asa sea lant ofaluminium electr olyt ic cells in the alumi nium industry(Brantzzeq et al. 1993, Feereyvik 1994).The high melt ing pointof the calcic plagioclase fro m the Sogn anor tho site is, in thiscase, advantageous compared to the lower mel ting po int ofthe more Na-rich anorthosi te of the Egersund region .Although the project init ially seemed very promising, it hasmet wi th prob lems relating to the viscosity of the sealantproduct and is th us so far onl y part ially successful.

Liberat ion of the aluminiu m component is still the mainissue of a process(Fig. 5) that has recent ly been developed bythe Norwegian Insti tute for Energy Technology (IFE) (Raheimet al. 1998, Raheim 1999).IFEwas responsible for the process­ing developm ent in the Anortal project. In th is new refinedconcept, more or less all components (AI, Ca and Si) of therock are ut ilised, yie ldin g prod ucts such as calcium carbon ­ate, ammon ium nitr ate and silica-products in add ition to thealumi nium oxide. In addi tio n, the process incorporates theconsum pt ion of CO2, and since this can be obtained from theemissionsof natural gaspower plants, such a clean, 'total-uti­lisatio n' process can be considered to have a very good envi ­ronm ental profile. At present the insti tute is seeking anindustry partn er in order to be able to deve lop th is projectfurther.

The leach residu e from an acid process is a white, highlypo rous, low-density, amor phous silica gel. The residue has apoten t ial use asa filler and extende r in th e paint, plast ics andpaper industries, aswell as a bind ing mater ial in cement pro­duction.The very high porosity might also make it suitable asan absorbant of various prod ucts, including radioact ive par­ti cles.

This high -Si residue is also interest ing as an alterna tiveraw material in a new innovativ e industrial process, which atpresent is being devel oped by the company Norweg ian Sili­con Refinery AS. Both AI and Si are being produced in arefined, continuous, electrical melt ing operation with feld­spar as the raw material (Stubergh 1994, 1996). The siliconproduct is of solar cell quality and th e high silicon content ofth e plagio clase of th e Egersund anorthosite is suitable forsuch a process, as well as the residue of leached Sognanor thosite.

As a raw material for the product ion of ceramics andsanitary po rcelain, a low melt ing poi nt is advantageous. Forth is app licatio n, white anorthosite from Hellvik, near Eger­sund, is shipped to European customers (internet reference:ht tp:/ /www.edelsplitt.no).

Sintering proc esses have also been attempted wi th

Page 5: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

•Silica residuum

;Vater cleaning , Filler Leaching in nitricHNO, I Production of IAdditives concrete ~ acid

Raw material for Filtration I nitric acid

silicon producti on •I I- o },.)'gen

Precipi tation n nnProduction alntnininm .. NH,

alnmina - hvdr oxideProducti~ of IFiltration

3l1lll1 Olll a

I

Fill er in paper Industrial CO.- source:production Precipitati on

Env iron men tal 1- calcium carbonate Gas power plantchemical Filtration Hydrogen production

Cement producti on Ammonia production

nn~ Heet r ecwer

Cement production

~/ Evaporation of --eRaw materialwater

f-- Production ofNitrogen fertilizer ammonium nitrate

JAN EGIL WANVIK

A nor thosite(Ca A~ Si. O J

SOIU"ce for calci um ,alumlniuman d silica

Fig. 5. The Norwegia n Inst itute for Energy Technology has deve loped anew COrbased con cept of uti lising several com ponents of the Soqn

anorthosite.

Acid Ot her Qu ant it yUse so lubi - AI Fe Ca LOI

Iity cr iteria needed

AI production high high low large

AI t Si t Ca high high low large(COr free gaspower process)

Water cleaning high high low not quartz medium

Si t Al produc- high low high Si, low largetion (electroly- P, Band Ksis)

Refractory high low high low not quartz small

Ceramics low low low melt ing mediumpoint

Mineral wool high high low Si medium

Aggregates whiteness, medium!mechanical largequalit ies

Dimension fracturing, smallstone block size,

colour

Tabl e 2. Imp ortant characterisation crit eria for ano rthosite used in d iff er­

ent appl icat ion s.

NGU- BULL 436,2000 - PAGE 107

anorthosite (Dolan et. al. 1991). However, thesehave proven to be energy intensive, and testingusing the Norwegian Pedersen proc ess (Kvande1987) has not been fou nd to be of commercial

interest.The most recent app lication of anorthosite in a

high-th ermal proc ess is fo r mineral wool pro duc ­ti on. The Swedish com pany Paroc AB, operating3 rockwool factories , has now started using Nor­weg ian ano rthosite in their product ion. In this case,it is the high-AI variety, which is interesting; thus

favouring th e Sogn ty pe.Concern ing more direct applica tions, the white

altere d variety of both the Sogn and th e Rogalandanorthosite has been min ed/qu arried for aggre­gat e for some decades. Macadam, fo r use in th e to player of asphalt, in Norway and abroad, is th e pri ­

mary prod uct , with its white colour and goodmec hanical properties as th e main advantage. Inaddition , concrete elements, for exterior walls aswe ll as street/ traff ic applicati ons, have been pro­du ced wi th thi sw hite anorthosite as a vital ingredi­

ent . The w hite variety from both region s has alsobeen used asan additi ve in washing powd er and asa grinding agent in toothpaste.

Unaltered anor thosite is att ract ive both asdimension stone and aggregate. Melleg ren &Dalseg (1981) have described future plans for theop ening of a giant aggregate quarry near Jessinqf-

jord. Product ion from this quarry, in the southern most part ofth e massif, is prin cipally designa ted for dire ct export. Exportis also the main issue wi th the successful, new, dimensionstone qu arry operated by the comp any Granit -1893 AS inbro wn anorthosite west of Egersund.

Table 2 giv esan ind icative overview ofthe main criteria ofanor thosite as th e raw material in vario us relevant industrialapplications. Furthe r detai led information on the indust rialuses of anorthosites has been give n by Dolan et al. (1991) inthe context of th eir thorough study of Canadiananor thosites .

The Sogn-Voss occurrencesGeologyThe anorthositic rocks of the Inner Sogn-Voss region belon gto th e Jotun Nappe, a thick block of Proterozoic crystallinerocks lyin g in a NE-SW trendi ng faulted trench. Below th ebasal thrust there are younger schists, phyllites, quartzit esand gneisses overly ing Precamb rian basement gne isses.TheJotu n Nappe itself is subdivided into several separate sheets.

The ano rthosit ic rocks are situ ated wi thin an upper unitto gether wi th gabbroi c rocks and, in northern areas, alsogranodioritic rocks.They belong to the Middle Alloc hthon ofthe Caledonides.The calcic character of the Sogn anort hositeis a common feature of Archaean anorthosites (Ashwa I1993).However, t he Sogn anorthosite is generally considered to beof Proterozoic age, probably ca. 1700 Ma (Sigmond 1988).

The anorthositic rocks mainly occu r in two distinct geo-

Page 6: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

Fig. 6. Variati on in content of (a) dark min erals and (b) acid so lubil ity in th e various areas of the Sogn ano rthositic massifs.

o00

zClcCoCrr..,.w9'IVooo

10 kmI

• >HU1y',

• 70- 110%

• 611-70 %• <60'Yo

• <30%Ill; with ~ ra lludiurltic dyk l'S

Anorthosi tes o/ /III11'r .'logll atul Vo ss

Acid su luhlc AI,O , in % of tut ul AI,O ,

"/lOrda", -.~<i

Hcrmanv vvrk

\'· 7

~ .

B

J ,,, I·,.lll ft '.·..

"

.;rSOG ' f . '~ . f ./O/I /)

\I"~/",,J.J,,·

hr/ho'

Ilk

Ifl~m

I

• >.' 5 %• 22.5 - -'5 'Y..

15 - 22.5 %o 10 -1 5 %o 5 - 10 %III wit h ~ ra ll nd in ri te dyk es

• ~a hhroC untcn t o f ma li c m in erals

Anorthosites oflnner Sogn and /lrl ss

Aurlund

FMm

\

: S"I:J"IK.f·/ ~ " _ ' . .J<)~/,,""

"Halt/a/ " .'"':<I

..

: ~ . L

I' · 7

A

11k

"

Page 7: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

JAN EGIL WANVIK NGU-BULL 436 ,2000 - PAGE 109

Location Si02AI20 Fe20 Ti02 MgO CaO Na2 K20 P20S LOI Acid solub .

3 3 °Kaldafjell, drillcores 50.0 29.6 1.4 0.15 0.7 13.7 3.1 0.27 0.02

1982, 202samples 50.05 30.53 0.65 0.16 0.82 13.70 3.46 0.25 0.02

Fresh, Ncer0ydal 48.99 30.70 0.68 0.10 0.42 14.22 3.00 0.16 0.08 0.77 42.05

Fresh, Brandsetdal 49.75 31.02 0.43 0.07 0.08 14.18 2.94 0.14 0.08 0.55 41.6'1

Fresh, 0vsthusdal 49,39 30.55 1.05 0.14 0.63 14.09 3.15 0.16 0.03 0.59 42.63

Altered white,Jordalsnut 48.15 29.43 0.41 0.08 0.02 15.65 2.21 0.19 0.06 2.24 12.1

Altered white, Fyrde 48.69 29.77 0.60 0.10 0.12 13.83 3.25 0.31 0.06 1.69 32.9

Minefines, Ncemydal 48.19 29.4 1.46 0.24 0.83 13.58 3.02 0.27 0.08 2.40 15.3

Table 3. Major elements and acid solubility of typic al samples from the Gudvangen-Mjolfjell massif (wt %, XRF).

graphical areas (Figs. 3 and 6). The southe rn area, betwee n

Gudvangen and Mj0lfj ell, consistsof a single large massif andseveral smaller satel lite bodies. The northern area, whichextends from Dyrdal in oute r Neereyfjord to Kinsedal in Lus­t rafjord, is domi nated by one large massif, separated into 4-5separate bodies by th e Sognefjord. Several satel lite bodiesare also present. In addition to Qvale (1982b) and Wanvik(1999), information on parts of th e sout hern areas have beenpublished by Hedal (1945), Dugstad (1965) and Bryhni et al.(1983).

In th e Fresvik area (west of th e northern part of th e Aur­landsfjord), th e upper sheet of the Jotun Nappe displays aprimary intrusive layering seen on a regional scale (Bryhni etal. 1977); wi th alternat ing anorthosite and gabbro layerswiththicknesses from tens to hundreds of metres. Theanorthosites th emselves are inte rnally isoclinally fold ed, andthu sthe total t hicknessof the massifs can be as much as 2000m, as observed, fo r example, on the eastern side of the Aur­landsfjord.

The anorthositic massifs display large variations in theirconten t of mafi c minerals (Fig. 6). Areas with properanorthosite « 10 % mafic minerals) are to tally dominant inth e southern Nzereydal-Mjelfje ll area. In the northern areas,leucogabbr o (10-35% mafic min erals) predominates,anorthosite-gabbro (22.5-35 % mafics) is also prom inent ,whereas anort hosite is restricted to only min or local occur­rences. In th e more pure, and most commercia lly int erestinganorthosite areas, the dark minerals consist of epidote andbrown amphibole wi th minor amounts of garnet, biotite andsericite. The leucogabbro contains less epidote, but clinopy­roxene, in places altered to green amphibole, as well assomegarnet, are common constituents. The latter minerals formpatches, spots and bands, depending on the type and gener­at ion of the anor thosit ic rock.

The Sogn anorthosite is characte rised by a high-An plagi­oclase (AnSS-80)' The southern Gudvan qen-Mjalfj ell Massifhas been shown to be parti cularly calcic (An6S-78) while th enorth ern region s are less calcic (An40-60 dominates) (Qvale1982b). Based on regional fie ld stud ies, Qvale (1982b)divided the Sogn anorthositic rocks into 9 sub-types, repre­senti ng four different generations. Of these only the second

generation with granular coarse- to medium-grain ed

anorthosite is attr active for industr ial uses. The Gudvangen­Mj01fjell massif is do minated by thi s sub-ty pe.The other vari­et ies, dominant in the other massifs, generally show too highconte nts of dark minerals to be considered as commerciallyattractive.

One of the more geologica lly (but not commercially)interesting types is a late-generation corona anorthosite thatoccurs in several parts of the massifs. Lens-shaped aggre­gates of mafic minerals , up to 10 cm in size, commonlyappear as well developed corona textures. Primary oli vinereacted w ith plagioclase, result ing in a dunite core sur­rounded by zones of orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene, amp hib­ole, garnet and spinel in th e outer rim (Griff in & Heier 1970,Griffin 1971).

Along th e th rust base of th e upper Jotu n Nappe sheet(Fig.8), th e rocksare st rongly deformed. Where anorthosite ispresent in this thrust zone, as in the Gudvanqen-Mjelfje!lMassif, the primary rock has been saussurit ised, resulting inthe formation of albitic plagioclase and epidote minerals.Since the An content is low (An20)' this anorthosite is not acidsoluble .This low solubili ty , 12-15% (of total rock) as opposedto 41-42% in unaltered rock, is ind icated in Table 3.This tab lealso shows th at alteratio n does not pro duce a significantchange in the major element composi t ion of th e anorthosite.

Geological criteria in relation toindustrial applicationsThe types of mineralogical and geological factor s to look fo rwhen evaluating an anorthosite deposit depends on the enduse. Apart f rom th e plag ioclasecomposition, the low contentof dark minerals and a minimal number of dykes of otherrocks wi thin the anor thosites are favourable factors in allcases.

In view of th e high conten t of mafic minerals in majorparts of th e Sogn anorthosites (Fig. 6), only rest ricted areasare of industrial int erest. In th e Gudvanqen-Mj olfj ell Massift hough, a conte nt of 5-10 % dark minerals dom inates, andthe best areas have only 3-5 % mafics.

Dykes of other rocks are very common within theanorthosites of the Jotun Nappe. The most prominent areearly gabbro and garnet-amph ibolite dykes occurr ing as lay-

Page 8: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

NGU -BULL 436, 2000 - PAGE 110

.-

Dominated by goodqualityanorthositc

Topquality areas

Anorthosite gabbro

Gabbro

..-.bor ~ Anorthositc mine0 "

flggl fI1J'. Proposednationalpark

Fig. 7. Location of the high quality Gudvangen-Mjo lfje ll massif.

ers and lenses of varying th ickness and frequency. These area majo r negative factor against exploitation in many areas.Their widespread occurrence, for example in the Gudvan­qen-Mje lfje!l massif, excludes many areas for exploitat ionwhich ot herw ise are of opt imum anorthosite quality . Map­ping of swarms of th ese dykes (Ottesen 1979) has show n th atthe anorthosite massifs are intensely fo lded . Among otherdykes, granodioritic int rusion s are the most com mon . Ordi­narily th ey are not frequent and thus do not greatly affectanorthosite quality, but in northern and nort heastern areas,they are very common (Fig. 6). Thinner, granitic pegmatitedykes also occur , but they are sporadic and do not influenceanorthosite qual ity .

The high An content of the plagioclas e is characte ristic ofth e Sogn anorthosite, and is the most imp ortant facto r mak­ing these deposits especially attractive. Since Goldschmidt'sdays it has been known that on ly high -An plag ioclase is solu­ble in minera l acids. Such high-An plagioclase is thus essen­ti al for applicat ions requiring liberation of AI and other ele­ments from anorthosite . During the Anorta l projec t Gjelsvik(1980) stated that leachability is a function of the Si:AI ratio ,

JAN EGILWANVIK

which must be below about 1.5:1 to prevent thedissolut ion of AI ions being masked by an insolublesilicate st ructu re. The condi tion th at appears to benecessary for acceptable dissolution is the collapseof th e silicate str ucture as AI ions are leached fromit.

Due to th e regional variations of the An contentof the Sog n anorthosi te, only smaller areas in thecentr al and northern regions have optimum solu­bil ity characte ristics. The remainder is only moder­ately to poorly soluble (Fig. 6); ano rthi te contentsbetween 40 and 60 dominate in these areas. Theplagioclase in the Gudvanqen-Mjelfjell massif, onthe other hand, is dominated by An65-78 and mostpart s of this massif are of very high solubility. The

/ " altered anorthosite at the thrus t base of the massifis a clear exception.

Alteration of the anorthosite is a common phe­nomenon, caused by local defor matio n of theanorthosite massifs.The plagioclase is crushed andsaussurit ised, with alteration to a more alb itic plagi ­oclase. Amp hibo le, clinopyroxene and garnet havebeen part ly replaced by epidote, biot ite, chloriteand mu scovite. Some quartz and calcite may alsobe present . This gneissic, altered variety is easy torecognise and has a dull, fine-gra ined wh itishappearance.The most intense alteration took placewithin th e thrust zones at the base of theanorthosite massifs, wh ere up to hundreds ofmetres might have been affected (Fig.8). Higher upin the anort hosites, deformation and alterat ion isprimarily restricted to narrow shear zones, up to afew m thick. Outside of such zones, saussuri ti satio nis restricted to grain boundaries in massiveanorthosites, and has resulted in a beehive textureon weathere d outcrops. The low-An rims of th egrainsprotrude at the surface, wh ile the more calcic

cores are weathered and erod ed.The colour of the anorthosite varies and gives no definite

indication of quality. Even though altered low-An anorthositeis white (fine-grained and wi th dull lustre ). unaltered typesmight also be white (medium- to coarse-grained and crystal­line). Grey and violet-grey varietie s are most com mon, butdark violet and dark bro wn varietiesalso occur. These two lat­ter types are normally high in An, and for most industria l usesth ey are excellent; but they are found to often contain largeamou nts of microscopic inclusion s of iron oxides and thismight be disadvantag eous in som e applicat ions.

Environ mental issuesThe Sogn anor thos ites are situated in a very picturesque partof Norway. The Nzereyfjord region in part icular is consideredto be very special wi th its narrow fjord and steep mountains,and is visited by numerous tou rists every year. Large parts ofthis area are thus now proposed as a new national park,inc luding some of the most interesti ng parts of the Gudvan­qen-Mjel fje!l massif (Fig. 7). Thisposesdefinite restr ict ions on

Page 9: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

JAN EGIL WA NVIK NGU-BULL 436,2000 - PAGE 111

a II \'U.A'Ut'l t:I ,nJ lJ(JO b

NGU ~

County/communeborder

Glasha~mar

r.:I:

__L _

SW

Ovsthusnipa

I

Aurlund ; Vo~s

Vertical pro file along the Naroy valley

Hyllandtcltct

.\1angcritic rocks

Acid-leachable anonbositc

Vallev bottom

c==J White. non-soluble anonhos itc

NE

SE

100m.u ..\.I .

--- - --; - -

t erticai praf ile a/the auonhasite massif;111he ,\'um~r valley

,JOIUH LS:\I "1

N W

Fig. 8. Vertical sect ions (a) across and (b) along th e Neereydal, showing the altered thrust (border) zone at the baseof th e anorthosite massif. Diamonddrillholes of investig ated areasare marked wit h red lines in sect ions.

open mine quarrying, and th e location s selected as beingmost favourable for mining during the Anort al project mightth en become inaccessible in th e future. Furthermo re, theanorthosite area to the south of th e proposed park is alreadyoccupied as a mili tary t raining area (Fig. 7). Thus, the Sognanorthosite provide s a 'good' example of th e diff iculti es oneoften is confr onted wi th today when prospecting for newminera l depo sits. Luckily, more recent invest igations haverevealed th at high -quality, acid-soluble anorthosite is acces­sible even with regular underground min ing from theNeereydal valley, and that such minesare possible to operatein a narrow 'open' zone along th e bottom of th e valley.

Conclusions and future perspectivesAs an almost monomineralic feldspar resource, anorthositehas a varied spectrum of indu strial applications. Especiallythe Sogn anorthosite has a long and int eresting history ofvarious companies involved in investigation s to utili se thi slarge resource. Indu strial applic ation s of anorthosite areexpected to increase in scope and possibilities in the future.The very large depo sits in Sogn and Rogaland are situatedclose to the coast, and are thu s favourable for boat transport.The acid-soluble, high -An Sogn anorthosite and themedium-An Rogaland anorthosite thu s provide Norway withan excellent base for various commercially int eresting futureindu strial applicat ions.

AcknowledgementsI want to t hank Nigel Cook, Tom Heldal, Idunn Kjolle and the late Brian A.Sturt for suggest ions and corrections regardi ng bot h ling uist ic issuesand the structure and content of the manuscript itself. Special thanks arealso due to Tor Arne Karlsen, who ini tia ted my wri ting of thi s art icle.Finally I want to expre ss my appreciation for hav ing the good fortune ofenjoying many days duri ng several periods in thi s mo st beautiful part ofNorway.

ReferencesAshwa l, L. D. 1993: Anortho sites. Springer Verlag, Berlin-Heide lberg. 422

pp.Braaten, O. 1991: The Ano rtal Project in Retrospect. Ketil Motzfeldt Sym­

posium , NTH 1991, 2Spp.Brantzzeq S.R., Paulsen K.A., Siljan O. & Thovsen K., 1992:Experienceswith

anor thite powder-based penetration barrier in 12S kA SoderbergCell Cathod es. Light Metals 1993, 309-314.

Bryhni, I., Brastad, K. &Jacobsen, V.w . 1977: Jotundekket og dets und er­lag i Sogn. Norgesgeologiske undersekelse Rapport 1560128, 73 pp.

Bryhni , I., Brastad, K. & Jacob sen, V.w . 1983: Subdivi sion of th e Jotun

Nappe Complex bet ween Aurland sfjorde n and Neereyfjorden , SouthNorway. Norges geologiske undersekelse 380,23-33.

Carste ns, C.W. 1942: Rapport over Asen labradorstensfelt i Sogn . Report

to Norsk Hydro, 7pp .Dolan, M.L., Hains, D.H. & Ash, D.R.1991: High Alum ina Rocks in Ont ario.

Recourses and Process Technology . Ontario Min istry of North ern

Development and Mine s, Indu strial Minerals 8ackground Paper l a, 130

pp.Duchesne, J.c., Michot, J. & Maquil, R. 1987: The Rogaland Intru sive

masses: Int roduct ion . The geology of sout hernmost Norw ay. Anexcursion guide. Norges geo logiske undersekelse Special Publication1.48-63.

Dugstad, P. 1965: Geologi ske undetsekelser i omradet omkring Stalheim ikommunene Vossog Aurland. Hovedoppgave Universitetet i Bergen,151 pp.

Fzereyvik, M. 1994: Chemical reactions and mi neral forma tion by sodium

aluminium flu oride attack on anor thite based refrac to ries. Avhand ling/ Institutt for uorganisk kjemi , Norges tekniske hogskole, Univer site­tet i Trondheim, nr. 75, 166 pp.

Gjelsvik, N. 1980:Extract ing alumin a from acid solu ble anorthosite by th eAnortal process. Light metals. Proceedings of the 109th AIME Annual

Meet ing in Las Vegas, Nevada, 133-148.

Goldschmidt , V.M. 1917: Beretn ing om labradorstensfelter i Sogn .lnter­

nal report Det NorskeAktieselskab for Elektrokemisk industri, Krist iania.31 pp .

Goldschmidt, V.M. 1919: Alum inium av norske raastoffe. Bergverksnyt .Tidsskrift for norsk qrubedriit, nr. 3, 12. Aargang. Kristian ia, 1-8.

Graff, P. R. 1981: Analy se og utluting av anorthositter. Norg es geologiske

undersekelse Rapport 186S. 115 pp .Griffi n, W.L. 1971: Genesis of Coronas in Anorth osites of the Upper Jotun

Nappe, Indre Sogn, Norway. Journal ofPetrology 12, 219-43.Griffi n, W.L. & Heier, K.5: 1970: Meta mo rphic reactions in Norw eg ian

ano rthosites. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift, Supplem ent 50,3 ,272-273.

Page 10: Norwegian anorthosites and theirindustrial uses, …Wanvik,J.E.2000: Norwegian anorthosites and their industrial uses,with emphasis on the massifsof the Inner Soqn Vossarea in western

NGU -BUL L 436, 2000 - PAG E 112

Heldal, T. & Lund, B. 1995: A regional st udy of the d imension-stone

pot ential in lab radori te-bea ring ano rthositi c rocks in the Rogaland

igneous complex. Norges geologiske undersekelse Bulletin 427, 123­

126.

Hodal, J. 1945: Roc ks of th e ano rt hosite kindred in Vossestrand , No rw ay.

Norsk qeoloqisk Tidsskrii t 24, 129-243

Kolderup, C.F. & Kolderup, N.-H. 1940: Geol ogy of the Bergen Arc System.

Bergen M useums Skrift er 20, 1-137 .

Kvande, H. 1987: Alte rna tives to the Bayer process. In: Proceedings of the

8' h International Ligh t Metals Congress, Vienna, Aluminium-Verlag

Gmbh, Dusseldorf, 70-75.

Mellegren, S. & Dalseg, O. 1981: A pot ential large scale Norwegian

ano rt hos ite qua rry. Mi ning Magazine (London). 145,472-473 .

Ott esen, J. 1979: Anortho sitt -m assivet mellom 0vst husdalen og Kvita ­

herb yrgj e.lnternal report, Elkem-Spig erverket NS, 8 pp . Arch ive NGU.

Ovale, H. 1982a: An orthositts loseli g het i syre. Norges geologiske under­

sokelse Rapport 1560/33 . 127 pp.

Ovale , H. 1982b: Jotundekkets anorthosi tter: Geo logi, mineralogi og

geokjemi. Norges geologiske undersekelse Rapport 1560/32 , 164 pp +Ap pendix..

JAN EGIL WANVIK

Raheirn , A. 1999: Bergart en anorthositt: Potens iale for ny ind ustri i Norge.

Kjemi nr. 6 12-13 .

Raheim, A., Hund ere, I.&Joha nsen, H. 1998: Frernqanqsmate for a irnrno­

bili sere CO2-kilde. Norsk patent nr. 302864 i navnet inst it utt for

energite knikk.

Sigmond, E. 1998: Bergg runnsgeologisk kart Odda, M 1:2S0 000, Norges

geologiske undersekelse.

Stubergh, J. 1994: Fremstilling av silisium og aluminium i en kont inu erl ig

prosess . Kjemi nr. 6, 13-15; nr.7, 21-23; nr.B, 40-42 &nr. 9, 13-15.

Stubergh, J.R. 1996: Prepara tion of pure sil icon by eleetrow inn ing in a

bytownite-c ryolite me lt. Metallurg ical and Materials Transactions B,

voI27B,895-900 .

Wanvik, J.E. 1981: Ma lmgeologisk oppsummering over I/S Anorta l's ra­

sto ff unde rsok elser av anorthositt i Voss og Indre Sogn . In ternal

Elkem report, 121 pp

Wanvik, J.E. 1997: Kje rneboringer i Glashammaren og Jordalsnut en,

Nzeroydal en Aur land kommune. Norges geologiskeundersckeise Rap­

port 97.038,58 pp .

Wanvik, H. 1999: Anortositt-ressurser i Ind re Sogn og Voss. Norges qeo­

logiske undersokelse Rapport 98. 150, 55 pp .