North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

download North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

of 48

description

Kayaking to Canaan and more

Transcript of North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    1/48

    JSTANDARD.COM

    201483

    AUGUSTVOL. LXXXIII NO.

    NORTH JERSEY

    Teaneck nativeDov Neimands

    solo sea voyagefrom Barcelona

    JewishStandard

    1086TeaneckRoad

    Teaneck,NJ07666

    CHANGESERVICEREQUESTED

    Page

    JCCS GRANFRIENDS CLOSE GENERATION GAP page 6

    NEW JERSEYS LONE SOLDIERS page 10

    STUDYING CHILD MARTYRDOMpage 12

    MOSES, MONOLOGUE MEET OFF BROADWAY page 37

    Kayaking toCanaan

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    2/48

    2 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    August 20th

    Christopher Cross

    Saturday September 13th

    Tusk

    October 5th

    Macy Gray

    September 28th

    The Wiggles

    November 8th

    National Acrobats of Peking

    November 16th

    Pinkalicious

    November 30th

    Wild Kratts Live

    October 14th

    Englebert Humperdinck

    October 15th

    America

    October 22nd

    Vienna Boys Choir

    Friday September 19th

    The John K Band

    Saturday September 20th

    Black 47 with guest The Bill Weevils

    Saturday September 27th

    Asia

    August 21st

    Pink Floyds Dark Side of the Moon

    August 25th

    Deep Purple

    September 3rd

    Michael McDonald & Totosponsored by Benzel-Busch

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    3/48

    Page 3

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    PUBLISHERS STATEMENT: (USPS 275-700 ISN 0021-6747) is publishedweekly on Fridays with an additional edition every October, by the New

    Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ 07666.

    Periodicals postage paid at Hackensack, NJ and additional offices.POSTMASTER: Send address changes to New Jersey Jewish Media

    Group, 1086 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ 07666. Subscription price is$30.00 per year. Out-of-state subscriptions are $45.00, Foreign coun-

    tries subscriptions are $75.00.

    The appearance of an advertisement in The Jewish Standard does not

    constitute a kashrut endorsement. The publishing of a paid politicaladvertisement does not constitute an endorsement of any candidate

    political party or political position by the newspaper, the Federation orany employees.

    The Jewish Standard assumes no responsibility to return unsolicited

    editorial or graphic materials. All rights in letters and unsolicited edito-

    rial, and graphic material will be treated as unconditionally assigned forpublication and copyright purposes and subject to JEWISH STANDARDs

    unrestricted right to edit and to comment editorially. Nothing may be

    reprinted in whole or in part without written permission from the pub-lisher. 2014

    NOSHES .................................................

    OPINION ................................................

    COVER STORY ............. ............ ...........

    HEALTHY LIVING &

    ADULT LIFESTYLES ..........................

    TORAH COMMENTARY ............. ......

    CROSSWORD PUZZLE ....................

    ARTS & CULTURE ..............................

    CALENDAR ..........................................

    OBITUARIES ........................................

    CLASSIFIEDS ......................................4

    REAL ESTATE ............. ............ ............. 4

    CONTENTS

    Candlelighting: Friday, August 15, 7:37 p.m.

    Shabbat ends: Saturday, August 16, 8:38 p.m.

    lPARIS In a penthouse office with a

    view of the Eiffel Tower, Olivier Kass-

    abi uses a ceramic spoon to extract a

    small scoop from a jar labeled Russian

    caviar.

    Placing a clutch of black globules on

    the base of his thumb, Mr. Kassabi licks

    it off, savoring every fishy drop of the

    salty liquid inside the dark beads as

    they pop in his mouth.

    As recently as a few months ago,

    Russian caviar would have been strictly

    off-limits for an observant Jew like Mr.

    Kassabi. Sturgeon, the endangered fish

    species whose eggs are harvested to

    produce caviar, is not kosher according

    to most contemporary Orthodox rabbis.

    Thats what led Mr. Kassabi to import

    and market a caviar substitute that he

    hopes satisfies not just the growing

    demand among observant Jews for af-

    fordable delicacies, but also the desire

    for sustainable foods with minimal envi-

    ronmental impact.

    In the age of mass media and glo-

    balization, Jewish communities are

    much more exposed to fine cuisine, Mr.

    Kassabi said. People see special dishes

    on food blogs and they want a taste.

    Mr. Kassabi is not the only business-

    man aiming to tap into what people in

    the food world see as a growing demand

    among observant Jews for gourmet

    foodstuffs that meet their dietary needs.

    Last year, the Brooklyn-based Black

    Diamond Caviar started marketing a

    caviar substitute from a non-endan-

    gered kosher fish called bowfin that is

    caught in Louisiana. And in February, Le

    Rafael became the first kosher restau-

    rant in France to earn two stars from

    the vaunted Michelin Guide.

    All over the world, average restau-

    Yazidi child in Israel for surgerylWisam was born in northern Iraq

    17 months ago with life-threatening

    congenital heart disease. His family

    is one of 200,000 Yazidis who have

    escaped to the mountains near their

    hometown of Sinjar under persecu-

    tion by the Islamic State, the al-Qae-

    da terrorist group offshoot formerly

    known as ISIS. (The Yazidis follow an

    ancient faith based on Zoroastrian-

    ism.)

    Despite the tragedy playing out

    at home, Wisams father accepted

    an invitation to bring the toddler to

    Israel for free life-saving treatment at

    the Wolfson Medical Center in Holonthrough the Israeli humanitarian or-

    ganization Save a Childs Heart. The

    father and son arrived in June, and

    Wisams surgery was performed on

    July 10 by Dr. Lior Sasson.

    Earlier this summer, SACH doc-

    tors performed free heart surgery on

    five ailing Palestinian children from

    the West Bank and from Gaza. A free

    weekly cardiology clinic for Palestin-

    ian children has continued to stay

    open even as Holon, along with the

    entire Tel Aviv area, frequently en-

    dured air-raid sirens warning of mis-

    sile launches from Gaza.

    About half the children admitted to

    Wolfson through SACH for free treat-

    ment come from Palestinian areas,

    Jordan, Iraq, and Morocco.

    A SACH spokeswoman said that

    Wisams father is staying at his recov-

    ering sons bedside as he desperately

    waits to hear news about his wife and

    newborn twins. ISRAEL21C.ORG

    Wisam and his dad at Wolfson

    Medical Center.

    The roe aheadRussian science brings caviar to kosher tablerant goers are becoming more de-

    manding because of the popularization

    of the culture of gourmet dining, and

    kashrut keepers are no exception to

    this trend, said Guy Cohen, one of the

    owners of Le Rafael, which is testing

    Mr. Kassabis substitute caviar. Clients

    have become very demanding and we

    are rising to the challenge.

    Mr. Kassabis caviar interest was

    piqued last year when he read that a

    company in Saint Petersburg called

    Tzar Caviar was developing a caviar

    substitute through a process known as

    molecular engineering in which a fishbouillon is made to resemble the con-

    tents of sturgeon eggs in taste and con-

    sistency. The liquid is then compressed

    into a membrane that looks like the soft

    shell of a fish egg.

    The result is a kosher product that its

    producer claims more closely resem-

    bles real caviar than most other kosher

    fish roes on the market.

    Overcoming Tzar Caviars fear of

    compromising the secrecy of its pro-

    duction methods took some time, Mr.

    Kassabi said. But within a few months

    he was able to arrange for kosher

    supervision from the chief rabbi of

    Saint Petersburg, Menachem-Mendel

    Pevzner.

    Mr. Kassabi and his partner, Yohann

    Assayag, have sold hundreds of jars of

    Tzar Caviar since they began market-ing the product earlier this year. The

    demand is especially strong in France,

    where the ostentatious nature of Jew-

    ish weddings and other festivities is

    so renowned it is the stuff of parody,

    most famously in the character of

    Coco, an overzealous Frenchman

    (portrayed by the Jewish comedian

    Gad Almaleh) determined to give his

    son the best bar mitzvah the world

    has ever seen.

    The partners have also sold Tzar

    Caviar to Jewish delis in New York and

    expect to begin shipping to Israel in the

    coming months.

    This stuff is flying off the shelf, than

    God, Mr. Kassabi said.

    Meanwhile, French media were inte

    ested in Tzar Caviar not for its kashru

    but because of its relative affordabil-

    ity. Tzar Caviar is 15 percent cheaper

    than real caviar, selling in France for

    just under $41 per 50 grams. It also

    has a longer shelf life and is produced

    without exploiting any endangered

    species. Traditional caviar production

    has rendered some sturgeon species

    near extinction, according to the Wor

    Wide Fund for Nature.Assayag was surprised when Tele

    Matin, a leading French daytime telev

    sion program, didnt bring up the ko-

    sher issue at all in an interview, asking

    only about the production process an

    pricing.

    Tzar Caviar hit the market just

    months after Raymond Mizrahi began

    marketing his own kosher caviar sub-

    stitute in New York. Mr. Mizrahi shares

    the notion that observant Jews are

    demanding more because of exposur

    to new culinary pleasures, but believe

    that most kosher substitutes have com

    up short.

    Kosher caviar substitutes are noth-

    ing new. Youve always had salmon ro

    said Mr. Mizrahi, the owner of Black

    Diamond Caviar. But it tends to beha

    like a plastic bubble and certainly notlike the finer black kinds. And you hav

    other kosher black caviar, too, but the

    are of poorer quality.

    High-end black caviar or its substi-

    tute, Mr. Mizrahi said, will not leave a

    black streak on a white plate.

    Mr. Mizrahi couldnt vouch for Tzar

    Caviars taste, but Mr. Kassabi claims

    the product is nearly identical.

    I dont know what real caviar taste

    like, but experts who do said its nearl

    indistinguishable from Tzar Caviar, Mr

    Kassabi said.

    CNAAN LIPHSHIZ/JTA WIRE SERV

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    4/48

    Noshes

    4 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    schmutz, schtum, or even tuchus

    Yiddish words meaning dirt, silence, and behind added to the new fifth

    edition official Scrabble dictionary, making them kosher for play in the word game.

    Want to read more noshes? Visit facebook.com/jewishstandard

    say it works pretty well,while others say that itis too sweet and formu-laic. The screenplay isby ELANMASTAI, 39, aVancouver native whohas finally got noticedwith this film, which hasracked up a lot of Cana-dian awards. His father,MOSHE, is big in real

    estate, and one of his sis-ters works for VancouverJewish Family Services.His maternal grandmoth-er fled Austria in 1939and went to England, aKindertransport child.(This film opened in afew theaters last Fridayand in a few more today.Look for on-demand/DVD viewing if it doesntopen near you).

    Its rare for aprominent TV jour-nalist to casually

    gives us bits about his orher Jewish background.Journalists prefer to askquestions, not answerthem, and they tend tobe buttoned-up abouttheir private life. But Iguess RICKKLEIN, 37,the political director ofABC News, was in anexpansive mood when

    he recently spoke to theHill, a political news web-site. Klein, a Long Islandnative, a Princeton grad,and the father of twoyoung sons, droppedthese Jewish nuggets:I will never forgive D.C.for its lack of diners andsolid Jewish deli optionsand I was big into dramaclub in high school. Iplayed Tevye in Fiddleron the Roof, under thestage name Ricky Klein.

    N.B.

    Odeya Rush

    AT THE MOVIES:

    Odeyas a rushin The Giver

    Daniel Radcliffe

    Elan Mastai Rick Klein

    The Giver is adystopian action-adventure film

    based on a multi-award-winning young adultnovel of the same name.In the future, humankindapparently has solvedall its problems butone young man, Jonas(Brenton Thwaites), dis-covers that this harmony

    comes at a terrible price.ODEYARUSH, 17, whowas born in Haifa, playsJonas friend and loveinterest, Fiona. Odeya,whose first name meansThanks to God in He-brew, moved to Americawhen she was 9 (herfather took a job with anAmerican security com-pany). The Giver hasa great supporting cast,including Jeff Bridges,Meryl Streep, TaylorSwift, and AlexanderSkarsgrd. (Opens widetoday August 15)

    Rush has acting abil-ity; she is blessed aswell with striking blueeyes and lips just a littlesmaller than AngelinaJolies. Her first promi-nent role was in a 2012Disney film, The OddLife of Timothy Green,a modest hit. She is theco-star of a big budgetfilm, Goosebumps,which is set to open nextsummer. Its inspired bythe best-selling series ofchildrens novels byR.L.STINE, 70. Stine, playedby JACKBLACK, 44, is

    a main character in thefilm. Rush plays Stinesdaughter, Hannah. Theplot twist is that theelder Stine keeps theGoosebumps monsterslocked up in his booksuntil a teen friend ofHannahs lets them out.By the way, Rush wonthe Olay Fresh EffectsBreakout Star Award at

    the recently aired 2014Teen Choice Awards.

    What If, an Irish-Canadian romanticcomedy, shame-

    lessly uses as its advertis-ing tag line the questionCan men and womenreally be friends? I sayshamelessly becausethis was a question re-peatedly asked in thegroundbreaking 1989 filmWhen Harry Met Sally,written by the late NORAEPHRON. What If starsDANIELRADCLIFFE, 25,as Wallace, a nice guy.He meets Chantry, a verycute girl, played by ZoeKazan (a granddaughterof famous director EliaKazan). Wallace likesChantry romantically,but hides his feelingswhen he learns, early on,that she has a boyfriend.So, this films questionis: Can Wallace stay inthe really good friendzone forever or will heopen his heart and eitherget the girl or lose hisfriend?

    Smart critics are divid-ed on What If some

    Shatners orbitStar Trek inspired generations of astronauts and

    space engineers. So, when WILLIAMCaptain Kirk

    SHATNERtweets NASA and the European Space

    Agency, they respond quickly and politely. On August 2

    he asked NASA how it was doing and NASA responded

    that the space station was doing well and wished Shatn

    a happy weekend. On August 6, he asked the Europe-

    ans how they were doing and they responded that thei

    Rosetta space probe was just about to orbit a comet.(That mission on August 8.) Shatner responded that

    he didnt know about Rosetta. The European Agency

    replied that Rosetta has been on a 10-yr mission, to

    boldly go where no one has gone before.

    N

    William Shatner

    California-based Nate Bloom can be reached at

    [email protected]

    Special 2.99%Financing*

    Now thru September 2nd

    UNLIMITED MILEAGE WARRANTY

    2 MONTH PAYMENT CREDIT*

    2 YEARS PRE-PAID MAINTENANCE*

    *On select models

    Discover.

    benzelbusch.com

    t t t . :

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    5/48

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    We reserve the right to limit sales to 1 per family. Prices effective this store only. Not responsible for typographical errors. Some pictures are for design purposes only and do not necessarily represent items on sale. While Supply Lasts. No rain checks.

    646 Cedar Lane Teaneck, NJ 07666Tel: 201-855-8500 Fax: 201-801-0225

    VisitOurWebsiteat:

    www.thecedarmarket.com

    STORE HOURSSUN - TUE: AM - PM

    WED: AM - PMTHURS: AM - PMFRI: AM - HOURSBEFORE SUNDOWN

    Sign Up For YourLoyaltyCardIn Store

    e r L e T e e , J 7

    1 - - F : 1 - 1 -

    . t e e r r e t .

    i t e e r r e t.

    a r La T a c k , J 721-855-85 Fa:21-81- 225

    . t c a r a r k t . ci f t c a r a r k t. c

    R K E T

    A R K E T

    TERS ITI S:Thiscardisther ertyf edararket,Inc. andisintendedfrexclusiveusefthereci ientandtheirhusehldmem ers.ardisn ttransferale. ereservetherightt

    changerrescindthetermsandc nditinsfthe edararketl yaltyrgramat anytime,andithutntice.Byusingthiscard,thecardh ldersignifieshis/heragreementt theterms

    c n d i t i n s f r u se . t t e c m i n e d i t h a n y t h e r i s c u n t /S t r e u n / e r . * L y a l t y a r d

    m u s t e r e s e n te d a t t i me f u r c h a s e a l n githI frverificatin. Purchasecannte

    reversedncesaleis cmleted.

    CEDAR MARKET

    LoyaltyProgram

    E K E T

    FineFoodsGreat SavingsSale Effective

    8/17/14 -8/22/14

    FISH

    Morningstar

    PRODUCE

    `

    ea.

    ea.

    ea.

    Sweet

    PotatoRoll

    CrispDragon

    $

    $

    $

    DAIRY

    GROCERY

    FROZEN

    MEAT DEPARTMENT Smokin Hot Summer Sales... Let The Grillin Begin!

    SUSHISUSHIUSDA

    OrganicGirl Salads

    lb.CrabmeaRoll

    $Lb

    American Black Angus Beef

    Second CutBrisket

    $Lb

    Lb

    Bunches

    $Lb

    Save On!

    VealBreast

    Lb

    American Black Angus Beef

    LifterSteak

    $ Lb

    TurkeyBreast

    On The Frame

    $

    $Lb

    Lb

    $

    $

    $Lb

    American Black Angus Beef

    SteakFajitas

    ChickenThighs

    American Black Angus Beef

    BonelessCholent Meat

    /$PKGS./$

    Save On!HassAvocados

    Farm Fresh

    /$Broccoli

    Sweet

    /$GrapeTomatoes

    Snow White

    /$Fresh

    /$

    RomaineLettuce

    Sugar

    /$

    SweetCantaloupes

    Sweet to Eat!

    /$

    ItalianPrune Plums

    Hot House

    /$English

    Cucumbers

    SalmonFillet LB

    Flounder

    with SeafoodLB

    *New Item*SwedishMatjesHerring

    BlueberryCheeseBlintzes PAC

    PROVISIONS

    Save On!

    $BAKERY

    MeltawayChocolateBabka

    CinnamonLoafBabka

    $18

    16

    HomemadeHeavyCocoshCake

    $16

    $

    AaronsClassicFranks

    13.5Z

    $

    SolomonSliced BeePastrami &

    Corned Bee

    6OZ

    USDAOrganicBananas

    CelloMushrooms

    FISH

    HOMEMADE DAIRY

    SuperFamilyPack

    SuperFamilyPack

    Ready to Grill

    MarinatedChicken Thighs

    Cedar Markets MeatDept. Prides Itself On

    Quality, Freshness AndAffordability.We Carry TheFinest Cuts Of Meat AndThe Freshest Poultry...

    Our Dedicated ButchersWill Custom Cut Anything

    For You... Just Ask!

    Fresh

    GroundChuck

    $

    $

    $

    Super Family Pack

    EA

    $

    Save On!

    WessonCanola Oil

    48 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    DominoSugar

    LB

    $

    Save On!

    Truvia NaturalSweetner

    CT

    $

    Save On!

    CarolinaBrown

    Rice

    LB

    In Oil Or Water

    Bumble BeeChunk Light

    Tuna

    5 OZ

    /$

    Save On!

    B&G KosherDill Pickles &

    Spears

    24 OZ

    Yellow &Spicy Brown

    GuldensMustard

    12 OZ

    /$

    Save On!Gefen SlicedOlives

    7 OZ

    $Original & ThickerBone Suckin

    Sauce

    16 OZ

    /$64 OZ

    Save On!Natures Own

    Apple Juice

    /$

    Whole Kernel &Cream

    LibbysCorn

    14.75/15 OZ

    /$

    AssortedClear Choice

    Seltzer

    LT

    /$

    Assorted

    Betty CrockerFruit Roll

    Ups

    PK

    /$

    Save On!

    GefenChoc & Vanilla

    Wafers

    14.1 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    RealemonJuice

    15 OZ

    $

    Save On!Apple & Eve

    Apple JuiceBox Drinks

    PK

    Save On!

    CrystalGyser

    Water

    GAL

    /$

    Original &Citron Lemon

    PerrierSparkling

    Water

    LT

    /$

    Save On!Smuckers

    SqueezeGrape Jelly

    20 OZ

    /$

    Save On!Kleenex

    Facial TissuesWhite

    CT

    $

    Save On!

    SoloPartyCups

    9 OZ

    /$

    Original & Homestyle

    FloridasNatural

    Orange Juice

    59 OZ

    Save On!

    SsipsIced Tea

    59 OZ

    $

    Save On!Natures Yoke

    NaturalBrown Eggs

    PK/$

    Save On!Farms

    CreamerySour Cream

    16 OZ

    /$

    AssortedLaYogurt

    Yogurts

    6 OZ

    /$

    AssortedSabra

    Hummus

    10 OZ

    /$

    AssortedSabra

    Salads

    8 OZ

    $

    AssortedAmish

    OrganicMilk

    64 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    Barneys

    Franks N Blankets& Egg Rolls

    6-9.6 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    Morning Star

    Chick NNuggets

    10.5 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    MendehlsonsOriginal

    Pizza

    SLICE-36 OZ

    /$

    Birds EySteam Fres

    Mixed Vegetabl

    12 OZ

    Save On

    KinereOnion Ring

    32 O

    $

    Honey BBQorBuffalo

    Aarons

    ChickenWings

    24 OZ

    /$

    Assorted

    McCainFries

    19-32 OZ

    $

    Save On!

    Real KosherChopped Beef

    Liver

    12 OZ

    Lb

    FrozenDucks

    $

    $

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    6/48

    Local

    6 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    A friend indeedIntergenerational program at JCC enriches seniors, children

    LOIS GOLDRICH

    Watching the face of an elderly person

    surrounded by smiling 3-year-olds is

    amazing, says Judi Nahary. So amazing,

    in fact, that the Kaplen JCC on the Pali-

    sades in Tenafly has created a program

    speciically designed to multiply those

    interactions.

    According to Ms. Nahary, director of

    the JCCs senior adult services depart-

    ment, the joy such meetings bring both

    the seniors and the children explains the

    success of the centers GranFriend pro-

    gram, which brings older visi tors into

    the many classrooms of the JCCs nurs-ery program.

    Working with Jo Sohinki, the director of

    the early childhood department which

    serves some 300 youngsters during

    the past year Ms. Nahary began match-

    ing members of her programs with nurs-

    ery classes. Since then, GranFriends has

    taken on a life of its own, with increasing

    numbers of seniors eager to join the 10

    now participating.

    GranFriends are sent to classrooms

    with 3-, 4-, and 5-year-olds.

    There were requests from the

    younger classes, with 2-year-olds, but it

    would have been more challenging, Ms.

    Nahary said.

    GranFriends range in age from 85 to

    95, and each one is assigned to a spe-ciic class. Its a collaborative effort,

    Ms. Nahary said, noting that she and Ms.

    Sohinki meet regularly to discuss class

    schedules. Then each week the Gran-

    Friend visits their class to read a book,

    tell a story, or join an ongoing activity.

    The result, while not surprising, still is

    heartwarming, she said.

    A relationship forms between the

    kids in that class and their senior, she

    added. Its remarkable.

    So far, seniors have been eligible to par-

    ticipate if only they are mobile enough to

    go up and down the stairs leading to the

    classrooms. But next year, the program

    will try to bring child ren to visi t t hose

    seniors who cant get around.At times, some seniors get to feel like

    a burden, like theyre not contributing,

    she said. But this gives them a sense

    of purpose, like theyre still able to do

    something. Some, she said, teach the

    children about the Jewish holidays, or

    about their backgrounds in Europe, or

    about Jewish traditions.

    The program is not one-sided. It adds

    so much to the kids lives, Ms. Nahary

    said. And it gives them an additional

    level of compassion. Their own grandpar-

    ents may not be as old or frail. Theyre

    very careful with them.

    Also, she said, for some children such

    as the Israeli youngsters whose grandpar-

    ents are far away this adds somethingspecial to their lives.

    Recreational therapist Marlene Cer-

    agno, who escorts the seniors to the

    classrooms, calls the program amazing.

    You just cant believe what a fabulous

    program this turned out to be, she said.

    The seniors feel so good, and the kids

    get so exci ted to see them. Our senio

    wait in the hallway for their bus. If a cla

    is coming or going, they call out to the

    senior. It gives me goose bumps. Its ju

    the cutest thing.

    Its gained so much momentum, s

    added. More seniors are requesti

    GranFriends, and they ask every day

    its their turn to visit. They also ask if w

    can increase the number of times th

    visit the classes.

    The children are so enthused abo

    the program that some parents are ve

    eager to meet their childs special senio

    who often i s called by a special name

    the class.Rob Schirmacher of Lodi, father

    4-year-old Daniel, said, My son doesn

    open up to people he doesnt know, b

    with Bubbe Dawn, there was an insta

    connection. Now he has a grandma,

    mima, and a bubbe.

    In fact, Mr. Schirmacher said, the on

    time Daniel would speak about school

    when he would share stories about Bub

    Dawn. Even during a Shabbat sing, whe

    parents would participate, Daniel wou

    just wave and s it with her. Hi s broth

    Mikey even came to the JCC to meet he

    Ceragno said that when teachers a

    excited about the program, they cr

    ate additional opportunities for intera

    tion. For example, they invite their cla

    senior visitor to join holiday parties, ietrips, and graduations.

    Debbie Shenkin, one of those teac

    ers, said that Rabbi Z Rabbi Zeli

    Block of Englewood has been su

    a wonderful GranFriend to my clas

    The children enjoy listening to all h

    stories, and it really created a spec

    Bubbe Dawn with her class. Daniel, with blue stripes on his sleeves, is beside her.

    GranFriend Robert Cohen sits in a class of 4-year-olds. Rabbi Z gets a hug from some of the kids in his class.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    7/48

    Loca

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    One Child -One Hour -Unlimited PossibilitiesBecome a Reading Buddy

    Volunteer one hour a week and help a child learn to read.

    Contact Beth Figman for more information

    201.820.3947 | [email protected]

    Bergen

    ReadsBerg

    en

    Reads

    www.jfnnj.org/bergenreadsOF NORTHERN NEW JERSEYJewish Federation

    JEWISH COMMUNITY RELATIONS COUNCIL

    generation al bond. As a retired rabbi ,

    Rabbi Z also brought a unique and per-

    sonalized approach to teaching my class

    about the Jewish holidays. The children

    grew very fond of him and we developed

    a real classroom community where the

    children and Rabbi Z began sharing per-sonal experiences. The GranFriend pro-

    gram was an amazing experience for the

    entire class, and both generations ben-

    eited from the visits.

    For his part, Rabbi Z was equally

    enthusiastic.

    When I was irst approached to par-

    ticipate, I felt challenged because I had

    no idea how I was going to teach and

    share information with children who

    are almost 100 years younger than me,

    he said. But once I began visiting this

    lovely group of children, the experience

    did more for me than it did for them.

    It reawakened such feelings of love for

    children and their honesty; feelings that

    were always there in me, bu t dormant,

    and visiting the children in their class-rooms brought those feelings back. From

    a physiological point of view, I think this

    program provides a healthy way for

    seniors to connect in new ways and enjoy

    new experiences. You can teach an old

    dog new tricks!

    Nursery school teacher Debbie

    Freesman, whose class of 3-year-olds

    adopted Bubbe Dawn last year, is

    equally pleased with the intergenera-

    tional program.Bubbe Dawn embraced the children

    wit h trem endo us warmth and enthu-

    siasm, she said. She visited our class

    weekly and participated in various activi-

    ties, including hamantashen baking and

    story time. Her visits were illed with

    hugs, giggles, and an abundance of con-

    versation. The children were fa scinated

    by her stories and she loved listening to

    anything they wanted to share. At the

    end of the year, the children decided to

    donate the tzedakah funds that they col-

    lected throughout the year to the senior

    adult program at the JCC.

    Bubbe Dawn aka Dawn Diamond of

    Fort Lee said she thought the whole

    program was a wonderful idea.

    The children were a delight to bewith. Ms. Debbie, the head teacher, was

    a friendly person and made me feel very

    welcome and included in the program. I

    was a very good cook, but I never baked;

    the children taught me how to bake when

    we mad e ham ant ash en tog eth er for

    Purim. I felt very good when the children

    called me Bubbe Dawn and was sad when

    the program ended, but Im looking fo

    ward to next fall when Ill be Bubbe Daw

    to a new class.

    GranFriend Helen Gorki of Fort L

    was very proud of her children part

    ularly one youngster who reads alrea

    and does puzzles well too.I love the teachers; they were unb

    lievably nice. I like children. Without th

    program, I wouldnt have the opportun

    to be with children. Im happier with t

    children than I am with the adults. I ca

    wait till school starts to see my kids agai

    It makes them feel like a million d

    lars, Ms. Ceragno said, recalling

    incident where children passing by t

    senior lounge came running in to gre

    their senior.

    I saw tears in his eyes, she sai

    Theres something about childr

    that brings so much happiness and jo

    We need to increase intergeneration

    programs. The JCC has also begun

    Gramper/Camper program for

    young campers, she said.Weve started to build on this init

    tive because weve had so much succe

    The program will continue and will g

    bigger and better.

    When I was firstapproached to

    participate,Ifelt challengedbecause I hadno idea how Iwas going to

    teach and shareinformationwith

    children whoare almost 100years younger

    than me.RABBI ZELICK BLOCK

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    8/48

    Local

    8 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Telephone Reassurance -a friendly voice

    General oce help, ling & mailings

    Special Projects

    Be a Friendly Visitor

    Deliver Kosher Meals on Wheels

    Tele-Care, teach computer skills to our elders

    For more informaton

    Please call JFS at

    201-837-9090

    Are you looking to give back to the community? Is your child looking for a Mitzvah/Community Service Project?

    Become a JFS Volunteer today!

    1485 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ 0766

    www.jfsbergen.org

    NCSY summer programs make adjustments

    Despite missiles from Gaza, Orthodox UnionIsrael trips for teens provide fun, opportunities

    ABIGAIL KLEIN LEICHMAN

    Its gorgeous up here, said Alisa Neu-

    groschl, one of 550 North American teens

    taking part in eight summer programs in

    Israel sponsored by NCSY, the youth move-

    ment of the Orthodox Union.

    The Bergenield 16-year-old was speak-

    ing from the Upper Galilee, far from the

    Hamas rockets raining down on Israels

    southern and central regions. Theyre

    keeping us up north for safety reasons,

    and weve been doing touring and hiking,

    she said.

    Operation Protective Edge oficially

    started just one day before the campers

    arrived in Israel on July 9, but the missileire had been intensifying over the previ-

    ous week. David Cutler, NCSYs director

    of summer programs, saw that a fast and

    major overhaul of the programs carefully

    planned six-week itineraries was necessary.

    Certainly the teens would not be able to run

    a day camp in Sderot, as students have done

    other years, now that the Code Red sirens

    were blaring constantly there.

    The Sderot kids did, in fact, have their

    NCSY fun day, but it was in Jerusalem

    rather than in Sderot. In cooperation with

    a social-welfare organization in the Gaza

    border town, a full bus of children came

    for the day.

    We were able to turn the situation into

    an unbelievably positive experience, said

    Mr. Cutler, who kept up daily contact with

    parents. What we were able to accom-plish under these conditions is because

    of our wonderful staff and the magic

    performed by our tour provider. It could

    have been a tough summer, and it was

    incredibly meaningful.Alisa was a participant in GIVE (Girls

    Israel Volunteer Experience), which had

    a packed schedule of good deeds that r

    the gamut from running two carniva

    for underprivileged children in Safed clowning in several Jerusalem hospit

    after a lesson from a professional medic

    clown.

    Its amazing that were able to com

    to Israel and give back to the commu

    ties, said Alisa, who is a student at t

    Maayanot Yeshiva High School for Girls

    Teaneck. A lot of us have basic Hebre

    and there are also Israeli counselors o

    the program who help us communicat

    As long as youre having fun and smilin

    you dont have to talk much; the childr

    and the elderly just enjoy your presence

    Mr. Cutler said there were just eight ca

    cellations between the eight different pr

    grams. A ninth program intended for Isra

    targeted speciically to public-school teen

    was canceled when half the 400 registranbacked out; the other half joined an NC

    program on the U.S. West Coast rather th

    going to Israel.

    In all, more than 50 teenagers fro

    North Jersey took part in Israel NCSY pr

    grams this summer.

    Jonathan Schwa rtz man of Teanec

    a 16-year-old Torah Academy of Berg

    County student, said one of the hig

    lights of BILT Boys Israel Leadersh

    Training was the Gadna military tra

    ing camp where they did team-buildi

    activities and had the opportunity to

    commanders.NCSY Kollel campers sing at the Western Wall. NCSY

    What we were able to accomplishunder these conditions is because o

    our wonderful staff and the magiperformed by our tour provider. I

    could have been a tough summer, andit was incredibly meaningfu

    DAVID CUTL

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    9/48

    Local

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    The most advanced

    radiation treatment

    for cancer is here.

    OUR TRUE BE A M HA S A RRI V E D

    Integrated

    technologies

    enhance continuous

    patient monitoring

    Real-time tracking

    and correction

    during prostate

    cancer treatment

    More positioning

    options for breast

    cancer treament

    Shorter treatment

    times offer less

    disruption

    For advanced radiation therapy to treat cancer,

    turn to Englewood Hospital and Medical Center,

    where our team of radiation oncology experts

    delivers precise treatment using the cutting-edge

    capabilities of the latest generation of the

    TrueBeamTM system. Not only is our TrueBeam

    the most modern, it is set apart by powerful

    new-to-market technologies that can target tumors

    more precisely, treat more complex cancers, and

    provide superior safety. For added comfort,

    todays most up-to-date TrueBeam is located

    within a newly constructed ultramodern center

    that offers extended hours and easy access.

    Were investing in world-class cancer care:

    close to home where you need it most.

    For more information, please call 201-894-3125.

    I think the situation in Israel this summer inspired

    me, he said. It made me happy that I could support

    Israel at such an amazing time.

    Shana Adler, 16, of Teaneck described on GIVEs

    blog that on one Jerusalem day of the trip her group

    packed food at Ohr Meir & Bracha, an organization

    that supports victims of terror attacks; danced and

    sang with clients at Melabev, a day program for peo-

    ple with Alzheimers disease, and threw a carnival

    for children at Zichron Menachem, which supports

    youngsters with cancer.

    We did everything from face painting, to sand art,and basketball games. It was an amazing sight to see

    huge smiles appear on the faces of these children, as

    we hung out with them, she reported.

    For many of the campers, the fast of Tisha BAv was

    especially meaningful. They went to the Western Wall

    as the fast day was ending, sitting on the ground in a

    large circle singing songs appropriate to the day.

    Girls on the Michlelet program organized a wedding

    at a Beit Shemesh event hall for an indigent couple

    identiied by Rivka Yudin, the programs director

    and also the daughter-in-law of Rabbi Benjamin Yudin

    of Fair Lawn through a partner organization. The

    girls found sponsors, threw a bridal shower, made cen-

    terpieces, and even served as waitresses at the recep-

    tion and the guests were unaware of the tzedakah

    element of the affair.

    Though the kids did not get to go south, they did not

    forget about the soldiers of the Israel Defense Forces.Many troops are deployed in the Galilee and Golan, so

    GIVE participants drove up to a base with an ice cream

    truck to serve cold treats, while NCSY Kollel partici-

    pants made and distributed tzitzit ritual fringes.

    And, of course, plenty of fun was built into every

    programs itinerary water parks, barbecues, sports,

    concerts, color war, scavenger hunts, chocolate-mak-

    ing, and even a flash mob before they all ended on

    August 12.

    Its the best experience Ive ever had in my entire

    life, Alisa said.

    NCSY GIVE campers bring ice cream to soldiers

    in the north. NCSY

    To be included in the

    2015 Guide to Jewish LifeCall 201-837-8818

    or email [email protected]

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    10/48

    Local

    10 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Going home as a lone soldierYoung American-Israeli Tenafly woman talks about her choices

    ABIGAIL KLEIN LEICHMAN

    Doctors Orna and Arie Rosen did not

    intend to get stuck in the United States

    for 28 years.

    They expected to return to their native

    Israel soon after coming to America to gain

    experience in their subspecialties. How-

    ever, they ended up working here he as

    a head and neck surgeon in Hackensack,

    she as a neonatologist at Monteiore Chil-

    drens Hospital in the Bronx and raising

    their two children in Tenafly among a large

    Israeli expatriate community.

    But it seems that now the second gen-

    eration is leading the way back home.

    Earlier this week, Orna and her daugh-

    ter, Roni, flew to Israel on separate flights.

    Roni was one of 108 future lone soldierson a Nefesh BNefesh charter flight mak-

    ing aliyah through Tzoim Garin Tzabar,

    a program intended to ease the way for

    Israeli citizens living abroad who choose

    to return to perform military service with

    their peers in Israel.

    Im coming 11 hours ahead of her

    because I want to be at the Garin Tzabar

    ceremony at Tel Aviv University on August

    13, Dr. Rosen said. Well have only one

    day together to run some errands, because

    from the reception theyll take them to

    where they are being housed.

    Roni Rosen will be living at the absorp-

    tion center in Raanana, not far from many

    of the relatives she visited every summer

    growing up.

    Now 22, Ms. Rosen was active in the

    Tenafly chapter of the Israel Scouts prgram , Tzo im, whic h spon sors Gar

    Tzabar. Last June, she graduated fro

    Brandeis University with a degree in bi

    oy; she plans to apply to medical schoo

    in Israel and in the United States.

    If I decide I want to stay in Israel, I

    go to medical school there if I get in, M

    Rosen said. She is a trained emergen

    A special Nefesh BNefesh flight brought new IDF members to Israel.

    Roni Rosen of Tenafly flew to Israel t

    become a lone soldier in the IDF.

    Working with lone soldiersYoung Teaneck woman recalls summer at Michael Levin center

    JOANNE PALMER

    Lone soldiers Israel Defense Force members

    whose parents do not live in Israel or cannot sup-

    port them have been much in the news this harsh

    summer.

    Estimates put the number of lone soldiers at about

    5,800, and add that at least 750 of them are Ameri-

    can. Two of those lone soldiers Max Steinberg, 24,

    from California, and Nissim Sean Carmeli, 21, from

    Texas died this summer as they fought for Israel

    in Gaza.

    Despite the idealism that brings young recruits to

    the IDF, and that sustains them as they ight, it is a

    hard path that they have chosen. Luckily, there are

    organizations, including the New Jersey branch of

    the Friends of the IDF, that work to meet some of

    their needs.

    In Israel, the Lone Soldier Center in Memory ofMichael Levin provides, as its vision statement says, a

    warm, supportive, inclusive community for lone sol-

    diers before, during, and after their service. The

    young man whose name the center carries, a Philadel-

    phia native, moved to Israel, joined the IDF as a lone

    soldier, and died in Lebanon in 2006 at the hands of

    Hezbollah. He was 21.

    Leora Kagedan of Teaneck, 20, graduated from the

    Frisch School in Paramus, spent her gap year in Israel,

    and inished her freshman year at Brandeis University in

    the spring. This summer, she returned to Israel throughthe Boston branch of an internship program called

    Onward Israel.

    The program sets everyone up with a different

    internship, based on their interests, Ms. Kagedan said.

    Im not sure about my major, and I wanted to ind a

    good organization that helps people. That was the Lone

    Soldier Center, where she had a front-row seat well,

    not exactly a seat, the job didnt involve much sitting still

    to the drama taking place in Israel and Gaza.

    Ms. Kagedan arrived in Israel on June 1, for Shavuot,

    and began working at the Jerusalem-based centera week later. On June 24, three teenagers Naftali

    Fraenkel, Gilad Shaer, and Eyal Yifrah were kid-

    napped, and on June 30 their bodies, dead since June

    24, were discovered. That was the catalyst for the sit-

    uation in Gaza that is winding down, with 64 Israeli

    soldiers and about 1,600 Palestinians dead so far.

    If you wanted to help the IDF, it was the right time

    to be at the Lone Soldier Center.

    It didnt feel so crazy at the beginning, when the

    boys were kidnapped, but then when we heard that

    they were dead, and then the rockets started, it got

    crazy, Ms. Kagedan said. But I had been in Israel a

    bunch of times, including during Pillar of Defense in

    2012, so it wasnt so shocking to me.

    Ms. Kagedan went to the three teenagers joint

    funeral. I have never been around so many people

    at the same time in my whole life, she said. And

    everyone was doing the same thing. There was tons ofsinging. Very few people there knew any of the three

    boys. It was insane getting home after it was over took

    forever but somehow it was energizing.

    It was all of Am Israel the people of Israel

    together, with one purpose. Everybody was there of

    all backgrounds, religious, not religious everyone was

    together, she said.

    That feeling of unity that has so struck visitors to

    Israel this summer was evident to Ms. Kagedan as well.

    There are rallies all the time, she said. Id be walking

    Leora Kagedan with David Moed of Englewood and

    Davidi Ronen of Teaneck, old friends from home who are

    now lone soldiers.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    11/48

    Loca

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    EACH YEAR, ABOUT A THOUSAND LONE SOLDIERS FROM AROUND THE WORLD JOIN ISRAELS DEFENSE FORCES.

    This year, some have died defending Israel in the Gaza War. You can help support them by giving

    to the Michael Levin Lone Soldier Memorial Fund.

    To learn more about supporting the Michael Levin Lone Soldier Memorial Fund,which helps these amazing heroes, please visit:

    WWW.AHEROINHEAVEN.COM

    ABOUT THE FUND:Michael was a lone soldier who was killed during the

    war with Hezbollah. His parents set up this fund to

    support the thousands of lone soldiers in the IDF.

    These are brave men and women who leave behind

    everything and everyone they know to become

    soldiers in the IDF.

    o learn more, visit FJC.org or call 1-888-GIVE FJC or 212-714-0001Tis advertisment is sponsored by FJC, A Foundation of Philanthropic Funds.

    520 8th Avenue, 20th Floor, New York, NY 10018

    HELP SUPPORT LONE SOLDIERS

    YOUR TAX-DEDUCTIBLE GIFT OF:$3600 Buys Shabbat Meals for 100 Lone Soldiers

    $500 Furnishes a Lone Soldiers Apartment

    $180 Gives Support and supplies to those

    fghting in the South

    $75 Buys a Backpack

    $36 Gives General Support

    Soldiers from the Elite Egoz Unit Take Their Final Te

    by Israel Defense Forces / Flic

    to work the center is on the always-bustling

    Ben Yehuda Street and Id see it. You really

    felt the unity.

    The center received huge numbers of sup-

    plies for lone soldiers, brought from around

    the world. It was overwhelming, she said;

    one day she counted hundreds of pairs ofsocks. People came in to see what they could

    do. Parents of lone soldiers came to Israel to be

    closer to their children.

    Many of Ms. Kagedans friends were them-

    selves lone soldiers. She remembers that a

    friend told her how good it was to see people,

    she said. Not anyone in particular, just ran-

    dom strangers, walking freely. He had been in

    Gaza, and he didnt see anyone not in his unit,

    because all the people who lived there had run

    away, she reported. When she was able to take

    a trip down south, to a big base that allowed

    visits, My friends looked so happy to be with

    friends, she said. They were talking about the

    army, but they also had normal conversations

    about the outside world.

    It was funny they were asking me about

    what was going on in the world, and I said, Youwere there, and that is all the world is talking

    about.

    It was crazy, Ms. Kagedan concluded.

    When I was younger, I would always hear

    about soldiers, but they werent my age. But

    now that is my age.

    I was never scared for myself I was in

    Yerushalayim Jerusalem, she said. But my

    friends were at war. That didnt leave my mind.

    Not for a second.

    medical technician and twice she volunteered in Hon-

    duras with the Brandeis Medical Brigade.

    She planned on joining the Israel Defense Forces

    through Garin Tzabar long before Operation Protec-

    tive Edge began this summer. It happened so close

    to the date that there was no turning back, she said.

    But Ive been in Israel when times were not very sta-ble and I think I know what its like. Its not as big a

    threat as you see in the news, but also the war kind

    of strengthened my resolve to go. If anything, this is

    when Israel needs soldiers the most.

    She had wanted to take a year off between college

    and medical school anyway, she continued, and being

    in Israel seemed like the most natural choice. We go

    almost every year to see family, and I always loved

    going to Israel. Im the only one in my family who

    wasnt born there.

    Ms. Rosen joined Tzoim in eighth grade and

    became a c o-head counselor by the ti me she was

    a senior at Tenafly High School, where she also co-

    founded the Israeli Cultural Club and captained the

    hockey team.

    We are totally Israelis, Dr. Rosen said. We speak

    Hebrew at home so our children, Ido and Roni, are

    fluent. We are not religious but we keep the traditionsand the culture, and Roni is very aware of her roots.

    She wants to go and live in Israel in order to make a

    decision about where to live her life, and we are totally

    supportive of this.

    About 20 young adults are in Ms. Rosens particular

    garin, or seed group. That includes two other Brandeis

    graduates and another joined a religious garin. (One

    of the garin members lives in Teaneck but declined to

    be interviewed for this article.)

    Tzoim Garin Tzabar requires attendance at four

    seminars where the future soldiers can get to know one

    another and learn a bit about the IDF. Ms. Rosen is among

    the older members of the group; many teens join right

    after high school.

    Initially I wanted to do it three years ago with one ofmy best friends, after my freshman year of college, but I

    decided it would be better to inish my degree irst, she

    said. That gave me time to think about it more and decide

    if I really want it.

    According to her mother, Ms. Rosens desire to ser

    Israel only grew stronger as time passed. She wants

    even more now, and shes not afraid of anything, D

    Rosen said. She is the kind of g irl who will do what s

    wants to do, and we adore her for that.

    The planeload of 338 new Israelis landed on Tuesdand was greeted by dignitaries including President Reuv

    Rivlin, Interior Minister Gideon Saar, and Jewish Agen

    Chairman Natan Sharansky.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    12/48

    Local

    12 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Killed in the name of GodFair Lawn scholar studies medieval Jewish child martyrs

    LARRY YUDELSON

    Jews rejected child sacriice

    3,500 years ago, read the

    headline in ads signed by

    Elie Wiesel and placed in

    newspapers around the world by Rabbi

    Shmuley Boteachs Our World organiza-

    tion. Now its Hamas turn.

    But that may be stretching the truth.

    In the 12th century not even a thou-

    sand years ago, making it recent by the

    standards of Jewish history Jews boasted

    of making martyrs of their children, delib-

    erately killing them rather than allowing

    them to be converted to Christianity.

    It was an era in which Jews were

    besieged by Christian mobs demandingtheir conversion or death, a horror recalled

    by the radical jihadist army of the Islamic

    State in Iraq and Syria and its massacres of

    non-Muslims.

    Child martyrdom among Jews in the

    Middle Ages is the core of the historical

    research of Dr. Julie Goldstein, who has

    just returned from nine months in Israel,

    where she had post-doctoral fellowships

    at Hebrew University and Tel Aviv Univer-

    sity. She earned her doctorate at New York

    University.

    Dr. Goldsteins research into medieval

    history seemed more relevant than ever in

    the last few weeks of her stay, when bomb

    alerts had her family huddling in their

    apartment safe room and her Facebook

    page was illed with debates over child vic-tims in Gaza.

    (Dr. Goldstein went to Israel with four

    children and returned with ive; the oldest

    is 12 and the youngest is four months old.

    Her husband, Rabbi Uri Goldstein, has led

    the Orthodox Congregation Ahavat Achim

    in Fair Lawn since 2006.)

    Dr. Goldsteins focus on child martyr-

    dom came after a doctoral course asked

    students to look through different theo-

    retical lenses at the historical sources they

    were researching and see what we came

    up with, she said.

    As she worked, she was coping with the

    death of a nephew. All over my sources, I

    just saw dead children, she said.

    Then she noticed that the historical

    sources with the dead children were fromthe 12th century. They told the experiences

    of the Jews during the First Crusades a gen-

    eration earlier, at the very end of the 11th

    century in France and Germany. This led

    her to write about childhood in the 12th

    century, but the broader topic was set

    aside as what began as a chapter on child

    martyrdom ballooned into 400 pages.

    Dr. Goldstein considers herself a cul-

    tural historian, dealing with what people

    wrote, rather than a social historian, who

    would look at the actual treatment of chil-

    dren. Shes interested in exploring what

    the chronicles from the mid-12th century

    say about the Jewish communitys under-

    standing of its children. Those accounts

    accuracy is a different question.

    These accounts were written a half a

    century after the acts that were purported

    to happen, she said. These are probably

    survivor accounts, which adds other levelsof complication. There is survival guilt.

    They might be glorifying the martyrs to

    build their community.

    Yet with all these caveats, the stories told

    by these texts are horrifying and in large

    measure echoed by the parallel Christian

    sources, written in Latin, which also tell of

    Jews martyring themselves and their chil-

    dren, she said.

    With mobs of Christians roaming France

    and Germany threatening Jewish commu-

    nities with death if they did not submit

    themselves to baptism or in some cases,

    massacring them without even offering

    that choice some Jewish communities

    killed their children and themselves, taking

    pride that they died as martyrs to sanctify

    Gods name.

    Its not always clear the mobs are rightoutside the door when they decide to mar-

    tyr themselves, Dr. Goldstein said. Some-

    time they hear rumors about another town

    or another country. They dont want to let

    it get to the point of an ultimatum. They

    say, We will express our loyalty to the one

    God, they say the Shema, and they slaugh-

    ter themselves and their children.

    One theme that emerged from Dr.

    Goldsteins research was the ritual natuof this martyrdom. Jews portray martyri

    their children as a kind of ritual. Their a

    blessings that are recited, based on t

    blessings on sacriices offered in the Te

    ple. They talk about children being tak

    in front of the synagogue, and their blo

    sprinkled on the ark. Theres a strong ri

    alistic component. They talk of bringi

    the children to the slaughter as if to t

    bridal canopy, she said.

    With the accounts written by survivo

    sometimes you get sense theres som

    ambivalence. Maybe they ran away

    didnt want to martyr themselves. Som

    times, theres one lone, rebellious voi

    that very clearly says outrightly, I do n

    want to martyr myself, she said.

    In one account, Hes a little boy namAaron. His mothers name is Rachel. S

    hears the Crusaders are coming. Her so

    Isaac, like all the Isaacs in the accounts,

    passive. He submits. He is silent. May

    because he is very young.

    Or maybe because he has been cast in t

    role of the Biblical Isaac who acquiesced

    his fathers binding him on the altar.

    The older daughters, Bella and Adorn

    like other women, are almost fanatica

    obsessed with the idea of martyrin

    Please do it, they say. Let us sharpen t

    knife for you. Theyre singing songs

    praise for God.

    Then theres this boy Aaron who say

    Mommy, please no. He runs away. H

    hides in a bureau. He very vehement

    does not want to be slaughtered. Hmother drags him out and slaughters h

    anyway, she said.

    These very evocative images opposi

    this, she suggests, might be a bit of

    inkling of the mentality of the people wr

    ing this.

    But if there were reservations abo

    martyring children, beneath the surface

    the chronicles, at the forefront was a cle

    Kids in those daysJews and Christians had differentviews of childhood in the Middle Ages

    LARRY YUDELSON

    What is a child?

    In the Middle Ages, said Dr. Julie Gold-

    stein, the answer to that question would

    depend on whether you were Jewish or

    Christian.

    Christians see children as born in orig-

    inal sin, and Jews dont, she said. It has

    an impact on how children are treated.

    The younger you are the closer you

    are to original sin, so you kind of have

    to be whipped into shape as you grow

    up, she said, summarizing the Christian

    approach.

    During this period, she continued,

    Christians have a fear of children. Chil-

    dren are magical and scary. There arelots of stories about demon children,

    changelings.

    Christians are scared of them and try

    to distance themselves. Theyre warned

    against being around children too much,

    she said.

    Jews, however, are obsess ed with

    educating children, or more speciically,

    boys. They see them as raw material for

    the inscription of knowledge. Theyre not

    only educating children, but giving them

    lots of religious responsibility. Even chi

    dren as young as 4 are responsible fo

    performing certain mitzvot. They form

    this almost monastic existence for chil

    dren, who are sent off for intense schoo

    ing, away from their families, under thtutelage of a rabbi.

    Jews see children as somewhat mag

    cal too, but they write about children

    who get to go up to heaven to get all th

    knowledge they need, so it will slowly

    unfold when theyre back on earth. They

    really view children or more specii

    cally, in the texts she studies, boys a

    this massive reservoir of intellectual and

    religious potential, she said.

    Cultural historian Dr. Julie Goldstein has just completed post-doctoral fellow-

    ships in Israel, where she researched 12th-century Jewish child martyrs.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    13/48

    Loca

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    SpeakHebrewL

    earn t

    o

    OF NORTHERN NEW JERSEY

    Jewish Federation

    Take an Ulpan class and improve your Hebrew

    Ulpan is an educational model for teaching

    conversational Hebrew. Our classes use the

    Israeli Ulpan method, including materials for

    teaching and improving Hebrew language skills,

    conversation, comprehension, reading, and

    writing. Courses are taught at all levels in small,

    interactive classes by experienced teachers.

    To register visit www.jfnnj.org/ulpanor please call Joyce 201-820-3907

    Hurry!EarlyBird

    Registrationends

    Sept.29

    Ulpan begins October 20

    conviction among both Jews and Christians that theside whose child was martyred was the side that was in

    the right and which side it was became a focal point in

    the discourse between Jews and Christians.

    Jews represented Judaism as the right religion

    through presenting their children as the ultimate child

    martyrs, she said.

    With her dissertation looking at the 12th century com-

    pleted, Dr. Goldstein now is looking at the presentation

    of child martyrdom throughout Jewish history.

    There were already images of it in the ancient

    period, she said, most notably the story in Maccabees

    of the woman whose seven sons were martyred by

    Antiochus.

    After the 12th century, the theme of child martyrdom

    receded. Echoes returned in Holocaust imagery of holy

    children who have been slaughtered by the Nazis, or at

    the hands of Jewish adults. And then theres deinitely

    the Zionist imagery of the akeidot the bindings, theterm used to refer to Abrahams near sacriice of Isaac

    of the soldiers. Its a national narrative, its a religious

    narrative, she said.

    Yet Dr. Goldstein has also been witness to the

    new anti-martyrdom movement playing out on her

    Facebook page. No longer a mark of pride, fortodays Jewish community the willingness of Hamas

    to martyr children on behalf of jihad is evidence of

    Palestinian evil.

    The war provided her with her own mind-bog-

    gling moment in which her oldest son became

    almost sacriicial.

    The rocket siren had sounded, so we went into

    the safe room. It was the irst or second time. He and

    his brother slept in that room. He knew how to close

    the door, which had a jiggly handle that had to be

    manipulated a certain way.

    The 12-year-old said he would be in charge of clos-

    ing the door. The family gathered in the room, all

    very nervous and the door would not close.

    Were Americans. Were not as nonchalant as the

    Israelis. We took it very seriously. For us it was life or

    death. This door had to close. It wasnt closing.

    Without skipping a beat, he said, Ill go outsideand close it.

    What he was saying, and he understood it fully, is

    Im going to sacriice myself. Ill close the door and

    stand on the outside and youll all be safe.

    That was really poignant to me, she said.

    Dr. Julie Goldstein and her husband, Rabbi Uri Goldstein,

    with their five children, during their stay in Israel.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    14/48

    Local

    14 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Learn what it takesto be a Jewish leaderJewish Federation of Northern New Jersey offers its you

    leadership course for Jewish high school sophomores a

    juniors. The course aims to teach students the skills th

    will need to ensure a Jewish future. Part of the curriculuwill introduce them to prominent American and I sra

    leaders as well as to Israeli teen peers.

    The course is held on Sunday mornings at the Berg

    County High School of Jewish Studies in Teaneck, beg

    ning September 14. Some students will be selected later f

    a partially subsidized trip to Israel. The deadline to apply

    September 2 and an interview i s required. Call Bess Ad

    at (201) 4880834, email her at [email protected], or go

    www.bchsjs.org.

    Teanecks Beth Sholommakes cards for IDF soldiers

    Earlier this month, the Tikkun 4 Kids group at Congre-

    gation Beth Sholom in Teaneck made pop-up cards to

    send to IDF soldiers. The project, supervised by con-

    gregant Elana Daniels Goldberg and made by a group

    of more than 25 children, included messages of love

    and support for IDF troops. CBS member Ami Green-

    stein delivered the cards in Israel.

    Ilana Picker and Ingrid Goldfein lead Tikkun 4 Kids,

    CBSs social action group for children. Past activities

    include visiting residents at the Jewish Home at Rock-

    leigh and making lunches for volunteers helping with

    rebuilding efforts after Hurricane Sandy.

    JEC hosts teacher trainingfor unique engineeringand social programThe Jewish Educational Center

    of Elizabeth hosted the annualSET3 (Science, Engineering,

    and Technoloy, Teamwork,

    Training) teacher training

    series, led by JEC faculty vet-

    eran Joel Javitt. In SET3, teams

    of eighth-graders compete to

    solve an engineering problem

    that also provides a social ben-

    eit. Students build a working

    prototype machine, and in the

    process learn how to work inteams, to make written and

    oral presentations, and to use

    math problem-solving skills for

    real world problems.

    Mr. Javitt, who used to work

    at AT&T/Bell Labs, developed

    SET3 for the Center for Initia-

    tives in Jewish Education.

    COURTESY JEC

    Four synagogues, one school get security grantsFive local Jewish institutions have received more than

    $235,000 in grants from the federal Department of

    Homeland Security. All told, DHSs Nonproit Security

    Grant program awarded $13 million in grants around

    the country, with an estimated $12 million of themgoing to Jewish institutions.

    Since the program was established by Congress in

    2005, it has disbursed more than $150 million.

    Two Bergen County Jewish institutions received the

    maximum allowable grant of $75,000; Congregation

    Netivot Shalom in Teaneck and the Moriah School in

    Englewood.

    Two synagogues in Franklin Lakes received grants:

    Barnert Temple got $23,500 and Temple Emanuel was

    awarded $19,0960. Temple Beth Or in Washington

    Township received $43,000.Among the criteria used by the Department of Home-

    land of Security in awarding the grants is whether the

    institution is closely allied with an organization that

    has been the subject of an attack by a terrorist organiza-

    tion inside or outside the U.S.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    15/48

    Local

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Rabbi Weil will address OU at shore weekend

    Rabbi Steven Weil

    Wyckoff temple welcomesits new school directorGonen Arad is the new religious

    school director at the Henry

    and Elaine Kaufman Learning

    Center at Temple Beth Rishon

    in Wyckoff.

    The Israeli-born Mr. Arad

    was educ ated in the United

    States; he earned a masters

    in Jewish education from the

    Hebrew Union College Jew-

    ish Institute of Religion. In the

    last 10 years, he worked in Jew-

    ish education in several East Coast communities.

    Beth Rishons president, Laura J. Freeman, said, We

    are thrilled to welcome Gonen Arad, a world-class educa-

    tor who will take our TBR religious school to a new level

    of excellence. Born in a kibbutz near Haifa, he grew upunderstanding the beauty and the beneits of living in a

    solid community that shares values and beliefs. Its that

    spirit, and that message, we want to bring to our school,

    and to families throughout northern New Jersey.

    Gonen Arad

    Assistant principalnamed in Glen RockJanic e Colmar is the new

    Glen Rock Jewish Centers

    Hebrew school assistant

    principal. Ms. Colmar has

    a masters in Jewish history

    and a certiication to admin-

    ister Schechter schools.

    Most recently, the Jew-

    ish Theological Seminary

    awarded her an honorary

    doctorate in Jewish educa-

    tion. She has also received

    several Solomon Schechter awards from the United

    Synagogue of Conservative Judaism. For informa-

    tion, email her at [email protected].

    Janice Kolmar

    Englewood Florist, Inc.47 E. Palisade Ave. Englewood, NJ

    (201) 871-1630www.englewoodfloristinc.com

    Flowers for All Occasions

    116MainStreet, FortLee

    201.947.2500www.inapoli.com

    Youasked for itfor the last20years and

    nowits here!ChefSamsBasil Vinaigrette

    HouseDressing isnowbottledtogo.

    Bring thisAd intoreceive aFreeBottle

    min. $40 purchase

    Expires6/30/13

    Sammys

    North Jerseys Premier Italian

    Steak, Seafood & Pasta Eatery

    Tuesday and ThursdayOur famous seafood specialCall for details

    ONLY

    $21.95

    ONLY

    $21.95

    ONLY

    $21.95

    Monday and WednesdaySteak Night special

    Come by Mon. through Sat.,4:00-6:00pm for our awesomeearly bird, complete mealwith drink

    Bring this Adin to receive a

    Free Bottle

    min. $40purchase

    Expires 9/2/14

    The Best Selection ofTalliot and

    Kippot anywhere.Exquisite Styles

    for Women, Men,Bar and Bat Mitzvah

    www.thetallislady.com [email protected]

    Lisa PrawerConvenient Bergen County Location 201-321-4995

    Beautifully Beaded, CrystaCrocheted, Suede, Lace

    Kippot, Tallit Clips

    Mention this ad for

    10% OFF

    In Fair Lawn, U.S. general defends IsraelLARRY YUDELSON

    Gen. Wesley Clark, the former NATO

    supreme commander and one-time Demo-

    cratic presidential candidate, had support-ive words for Israel last week.

    A country has a right to defend itself,

    General Clark told the Jewish Standard.

    Theres just no excuse, theres no

    rationale acceptable, for Hamass conduct.

    General Clark took the time to answer

    questions from the Jewish Standard last

    week, prior to an address to an American Legion group

    in Fair Lawn. He was there to endorse James Tedesco

    III, the Bergen County freeholder who is running for

    the county executive post. Both the general and the

    freeholder are Democrats.

    General Clark said, I think its a terrible tragedy that

    they Hamas manipulated these poor people in

    Gaza. They abused them. They used their homes to dig

    tunnels. They used their schools and their mosques

    to hide munitions and weapons in. They

    used their streets and backyards as iring

    positions.

    All with the knowledge that to defend

    itself Israel would strike back, he said.I know its asking a lot of the people of

    Gaza, but if they allow themselves to be

    taken over and manipulated by what is

    essentially a terrorist organization, then

    they have to understand that nations will

    do whats necessary to protect themselves

    and Israel has to do that.

    Israels no different than any other nation. Of course

    theyre going to take action against it. They should,

    General Clark concluded.

    In his speech to the American Legion, General Clark

    highlighted Mr. Tedescos decades as a volunteer

    ireighter.

    Anybody who puts in 38 years in public service is a

    veteran as far as Im concerned, he said.

    Gen. Wesley Clark

    www.jstandard.com

    Rabbi Steven Weil of Teaneck, senior man-

    aging director at the Orthodox Union, will

    be the guest speaker during the OU Com-

    munity Weekend at Congregation Broth-

    ers of Israel, 250 Park Ave., Long Branch,

    August 22 to 23 Parashat Reeh.

    On Friday night, Rabbi Weil will discuss

    Transcending the Judeo-Christian Ethic

    during a family dinner at the synagogue.

    For the Shabbat morning drasha at the

    synagogues 752 Ocean Ave. satellite, the

    topic will be In the Aftermath of the

    Apocalypse. In the evening, Rabbi Weil

    will examine Responsi bilit y at seudat

    shlishit in the synagogues Park Avenue

    location.

    The synagogue belongs to OU and is led

    by Rabbi Nasanayl Braun.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    16/48

    Editorial

    1086 Teaneck RoadTeaneck, NJ 07666(201) 837-8818Fax 201-833-4959

    PublisherJames L. Janoff

    Associate Publisher EmeritaMarcia Garfinkle

    EditorJoanne Palmer

    Associate EditorLarry Yudelson

    Guide/Gallery EditorBeth Janoff Chananie

    Contributing EditorPhil Jacobs

    About Our Children EditorHeidi Mae Bratt

    CorrespondentsWarren BorosonLois GoldrichAbigail K. LeichmanMiriam RinnDr. Miryam Z. Wahrman

    Advertising DirectorNatalie D. Jay

    Business ManagerRobert Chananie

    Classified DirectorJanice Rosen

    Advertising CoordinatorJane Carr

    Account ExecutivesPeggy EliasGeorge KrollKaren NathansonBrenda Sutcliffe

    International Media PlacementP.O. Box 7195 Jerusalem 91077Tel: 02-6252933, 02-6247919Fax: 02-6249240Israeli Representative

    Production ManagerJerry Szubin

    Graphic ArtistsDeborah HermanBob O'Brien

    BookkeeperAlice Trost

    Credit ManagerMarion Raindorf

    ReceptionistRuth Hirsch

    JewishStandard

    jstandard.com

    FounderMorris J. Janoff (19111987)

    Editor EmeritusMeyer Pesin (19011989)

    City EditorMort Cornin (19151984)

    Editorial ConsultantMax Milians (1908-2005)

    SecretaryCeil Wolf (1914-2008)

    Editor EmeritaRebecca Kaplan Boroson

    Fading away

    If things go as well as they can,

    the hostilities in Gaza andover Israels skies will fade

    away, ending, if we all are

    lucky, with a whimper rather than a

    inal series of bangs.

    Of course, this is not the irst time

    that we have assumed that the ight-

    ing was going to had to! end dur-

    ing the week to come, and each time

    we have been wrong. Still, each time

    it seems to have resumed with more

    creaky reluctance. And we also

    know that even when this operation

    is over, the situation will not have

    changed substantially. The hatred

    aimed not only at Israel but at Jews

    across the world is more clear and

    easier to call by name, and there is

    a great beneit to clear-sightedness,but it is ugly.

    And, of course, the strong, tough,

    intellectually fecund Israel is circled

    by concentric rings of vi olence and

    hate.

    But as everyone who has visited

    reports, there is unusual unity there

    now. The idea that Israel had the moral

    obligation to defend itself against rock-

    ets from its enemies is widely accepted.

    As Israeli historian Fania Oz-Salzberger,

    a moderate leftist and the daughter of

    novelist Amos Oz, wrote in the Times

    of Israel, imagine you had a neighbor

    who sits on his balcony, his baby on

    his lap, shooting into your childrens

    bedroom.

    Would you shoot back at him?Yes, you would.

    The fact that this simple analoy

    is controversial outside Israel does

    not keep it from being true, or from

    being widely accepted in Israel.

    Israelis might well be uniied

    because t he pressure from the out-

    side is pushing them closer together,

    but it seems that often, perhaps to

    their surprise, they discover, when

    they ind themselves at the same

    funerals or shivas or rallies, that they

    like each other. That often happens

    when people actually meet. It is hard

    to demonize someone who is palpa-

    bly human, genuine flesh and blood.

    Meeting each other, demystify-

    ing people unlike you, can happencloser to home as well. The JCC on

    the Palisades in Tenafly is matching

    some of its nursery school classes

    with elderly participants in its senior

    center; allowing 4-year-olds and

    94-year-olds to delight in each other.

    (See page 6.) The 4-year-olds have

    much to learn, and the 94-year-olds

    have much to teach. And childrens

    joy can be infectious.

    We are not naive. We do not think

    that roses stuffed into gun barrels

    will stop bullets from f lying. We do

    not think that if we could just all get

    together and love one another right

    now, war would end, with swords

    and guns and uniforms all scattered

    on the floor. But it would be a start.We hope that the unity at work in

    Israel now holds and grows.

    As we did last week, as a step in

    that direction, we urge that any of

    our readers who is able to spend

    the time and money it takes to go to

    Israel do so. Israels economy needs

    it, and its psyche needs it even more.

    They should feel free, though, to

    fly. As extraordinarily impressive

    as Dov Neimands trip is, kayaking

    across the Mediterranean to show

    your support of Israel is both way

    above and well beyond. (See page

    20.) Go but take the plane!

    JP

    16 JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    Opinion

    A military funeral in IsraelWhat it means to be a normal state and a Jewish one

    Awhile back, Yuval Hei-

    man went to the beach

    with his longtime girl-

    friend. Somehow their

    conversation turned to the risk

    of drowning, and he told her that

    such a death would have no value.

    It is far better, he mused, to die

    for a purpose, echoing the words

    attributed to the early Zionist hero,

    Joseph Trumpeldor, Tov lamut

    bad artzenu It is good to die for

    our country. Perishing while on

    a sacred mission, he surely believed, is to sanc-

    tify Gods name, perhaps the only Jewish value

    greater than life itself. That conversation was, per-

    haps, an Israeli exercise in confronting the real-

    ity that Israeli soldiers and at times many of thecountrys civilians as well have to be prepared to

    sacriice their lives in defense of the State of Israel.

    In the end, Yuval did make the ultimate sac-

    riice in the battle to ensure that his fellow citi-

    zens would be granted a respite from terrorism

    Hamas cynical and indiscriminate launching of

    rockets from within their own civilian neighbor-

    hoods to kill Israeli Muslims, Christians, and Jews.

    My son Aaron knew Yuval from his gap year at

    Yeshivat Maale Gilboa. Aaron and I both were in

    Israel this summer; he was stafing Ramah Israel

    Seminar for American Jewish teenagers and I

    was leading the AJCShalom Hartman Institute

    Christian Leadership Initiative for U.S. Christian

    scholars. So we were both there, together with

    hundreds of others, as Yuval was laid to rest at the

    military cemetery on Mount Herzl. In her euloy,

    Yuvals girlfriend told the story of her belovedsreflections as they sat on the beach. Hers was a

    strong and compassionate voice, like that of the

    other women who spoke, Yuvals mother and

    sisters.

    Despite dozens of earlier visits to Israel through

    multiple crises and wars, I never before had been

    to a military funeral. Witnessing the unbear-

    able collective anguish, it occurred to me that

    this Israeli-Zionist-Jewish-religious-military-state

    funeral would have been unthinkable before

    the founding of the State of Israel and the estab-

    lishment of the Israel Defense Forces, events

    that changed the course of Jewish history for-

    ever. The flag-draped cofin, the honor guard,

    wreath presentations from the relevant military

    branches, the presence of and comments by

    Israeli government leaders, and t

    three-gun salute were emblems o

    normal state.

    A military cantor chanting t

    traditional 91st Psalm led the s

    diers bearing the cofin on the

    shoulders. They lowered it into t

    grave and illed it in with earth. T

    cantor recited the El Malei Rach

    mim memorial prayer, Yuvals po

    humous promotion in rank w

    announced, and the family said t

    Mourners Kaddish. Perhaps t

    only concession to pre-Zionist, powerless Jew

    history was the absence of the elaborate dre

    uniforms and precision marching associated w

    serious armies. Maybe Israeli society does n

    want to get too comfortable with the formalitymilitary protocol and its disturbing resonance

    Jewish memory.

    The enemy was barely mentioned in the 9

    minutes of eulogies and tributes. Soldiers cri

    together with mothers and fathers who thoug

    of their own children.

    These Jews are not my Jewish grandparen

    from Bialystok. They have accepted both the se

    determining power of Jewish defense and t

    burdens and sometime the tragedies it impos

    They will not listen to lectures by those who qu

    tion their values, those who cannot distingui

    between targeting civilians and inadverten

    killing civilians whom terrorists use as hum

    shields. They mourn Gazas children and ev

    risk their own lives to minimize Palestinian civ

    ian casualties. They crave peace, but they live in

    dangerous neighborhood.The State of Israel has the power to defend its

    and the Jewish people. Yuval Heiman represen

    all that is positive in the recent course of Jewi

    history. He and so many others are willing to die

    defense of the State of Israel, and would go to t

    ends of the earth to save Jews, be they in Sder

    Addis Ababa, Paris, or New York. It is an hon

    just to live in their time.

    Yuval Heiman died on a sacred mission. H

    died to protect Jews in Israel and beyond. May

    memory and the memory of all of our fallen

    for a blessing.

    Rabbi Noam E. Marans of Teaneck is the

    American Jewish Committees director of

    interreligious and intergroup relations.

    Rabbi NoamE. Marans

    And, ofcourse, the

    strong, tough,intellectuallyfecund Israel

    is circled byconcentric rings

    of violenceand hate.

  • 7/13/2019 North Jersey Jewish Standard, August 15, 2015

    17/48

    Opinio

    JEWISH STANDARD AUGUST 15, 2014

    The abstracting of IsraelIts evil! Its perfect! No its human

    My new favor-

    ite defenders

    of Israel are

    a Pakistani-

    Canadian physician and an

    atheist who doesnt believe

    in Zionism.

    Ill explain. I was in Wood-

    stock, N.Y., over the week-

    end, where I saw a lone pro-

    tester carrying a sign that

    read, We are witnessing

    the Brutal Failure of Zion-

    ism and the Human Failure of the state

    of Israel.

    It wasnt exactly the kind of rioting

    they are seeing in Paris, but his message

    still was infuriating. I understand peoplewho are upset with the enormou s loss

    of life in the latest Gaza operation. I can

    respect those who disagree with Israeli

    policy and who demand human rights for

    Palestinians.

    But when the critics jump from pro-

    testing a military operation to question-

    ing the historical foundations or very

    existence of a sovereign state, Im done

    with the conversation. Over the decades

    my own government has done many

    things people abhor, but those decisions

    and actions dont discredit the idea of

    the United States or the human beings

    who make it up. If someone ever holds

    a rally to protest the slaughter in Syria,

    I dont expect to see signs talking about

    the failure of Syria or hear

    speakers calling for a return

    to the French mandate.

    Its all part of what I call

    the abstracting of Israel.

    You see it in how protesters

    use the word Zionism. Its

    our word, I know, but it has

    been co-opted by those who

    hate Israel. Unable to bring

    themselves to say the word

    Israel, they ind it a handy

    euphemism. And using

    Zionism as a curse turns the reality of

    Israel into the abstraction of a political

    idea. Debating Israels founding ideoloy

    allows you to ignore even dehumanize

    the eight million people who live thereand arent going to be argued out of their

    homes or country.

    Sometimes American Jews are guilty

    of this abstracting, but in a very different

    way. We defend Israels every move as if

    it is not run by an elected government

    but by an infallible Sanhedrin . We treat

    every military action as fully justiied, if

    not divinely blessed. We regard anyone

    who voices sympathy for the Palestinian

    plight as soft on terrorism. And we treat

    it not as a real country, but as a sort of

    Jewish identity clinic for Americans who

    cant igure out their own path.

    As a result, our Jewish institutions

    including our Jewish newspapers

    arent always the best places to have a

    sophisticated conversation about Israel.

    When they (okay, we) arent defending

    Israel from unreasonable attack, were

    boosting the morale of supporters, trying

    to earn new recruits, or comforting peo-ple who hear enough tough talk about

    Israel from the outside.

    So it was refreshing to see Israel

    defended by two people who seem to

    have no dog in this ight. Ali A. Rizvi

    describes himself as a Pakistani-Cana-

    dian writer, physician, and musician.

    All I know about him is that he wrote

    a piece for the Hufington Post called

    7 Things to Consider Before Choosing

    Sides in the Middle East Conflict. Rizvi

    is critical of the recklessness, negli-

    gence, and s ometime s out right cruelt y

    of Israeli forces. But he does ask his fel-

    low Muslims why the killing of Arabs by

    Jews garners so much more outrage than

    the mass killing of Muslims by Muslims.

    Why, he asks, does the world defend agroup Hamas whose charter calls for

    genocid e, and whose stratey rel ies on

    civilian casualties?

    Rizvi pulls off a balancing act that

    gives credit and blame to both the Israeli

    and Palestinian sides in the conflict.

    He acknowledges the legitimacy and

    restraint of Israel while criticizing settle-

    ment expansion, acknowledges the rights

    of both sides to a state while abhorring

    Hamass moral bankruptcy. Its dificult

    but essential reading.

    The noted atheist Sam Harris, mean-

    while, does not think Israel should exist

    as a Jewish state. But dont run away

    he doesnt believe any state should be

    organized around a religion (hes an

    atheist, remember) and admits that Isra

    is hardly a theocracy.

    That being said, he too defends Isr

    els right to defend itself, admires

    restraint in doing so, and decries tshocking anti-Semitic discourse in t

    Muslim world. And he is able to ho

    in his head two ideas that many othe

    somehow see as incompatible that

    the Palestinians have suffered terrib

    for decades under the occupation, an

    the Israelis are surrounded by peop

    who have explicitly genocidal intentio

    toward them. With those two asse

    tions he is ready to describe an obviou

    undeniable, and hugely consequent

    moral difference between Israel and h

    enemies. He explains it this way: Y

    have one side [Israel] which if it rea

    could accomplish its aims would simp

    live peacefully with its neighbors, a

    you have another side [Hamas] which

    seeking to implement a seventh-centutheocracy in the Holy Land.

    Neither Harris nor Rizvi would b

    the most likely speaker at your next s

    terhood breakfast although may

    they should be. Israel cant rely just o

    American Jews, evangelical Christian

    and members of Congress to defen

    the country. It needs clear-eyed outs

    ers who recognize Israel for what it

    a secular, pluralistic, and sometim

    flawed democracy trying hard to li

    up to its founding ideals in a very b

    neighborhood.

    Andrew Silow-C arroll of Teaneck is

    editor-in-chief of MetroWests New Jerse

    Jewish News .

    AndrewSilow-Carroll

    Not in our nameConfronting Jewish anti-Zionism

    Irecently went to Colum-

    bus Circle in Manhattan

    to savor the atmosphere

    at two riv