No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K....

42
1 Simulation of block copolymer interfaces Andrei Zvelindovsky School of Computing, Engineering and Physical Sciences University of Central Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom

Transcript of No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K....

Page 1: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

1

Simulation of block copolymer interfaces

Andrei Zvelindovsky

School of Computing, Engineering and Physical Sciences

University of Central Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom

Page 2: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

2

BCP

ODT

Structure Dynamics

Page 3: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

3

Model

A

B

SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau

noise

I=A,B

ODT

Structure Dynamics

I

I FD

t

2

Page 4: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

4

Cell dynamics simulation

δψ

ψδFM

t

ψ 2

r'rr'rr'rr(r)

Gdd

BDHdF

22

2

432

432

ECAH

Ohta-Kawasaki, 1986

● T. Kawakatsu,

Stat. Phys. of Polymers, 2004,

Springer

Page 5: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

5

Block copolymers under external fields

Outlook

• Thin films

• Shear

• Vesicles

• Electric field

Page 6: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

6

Outlook

• Thin films

• Shear

• Vesicles

• Electric field

Page 7: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

7

Dynamic AFM

SBS film

A. Knoll,

K. Lyakhova,

A. Horvat,

G. Krausch,

A. Sevink,

AZ,

R. Magerle

(2004)

Nature Materials

Page 8: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

8

contour lines

Thin films Experiment vs Simulation

SFM

A. Knoll,

A. Horvat,

K. Lyakhova,

G. Krausch,

A. Sevink,

AZ

R. Magerle

(2002)

Phys. Rev. Lett.

K. Lyakhova,

A. Horvat,

AZ ,

A. Sevink

(2006)

Langmuir

Page 9: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

9

A. Knoll,

A. Horvat,

K. Lyakhova,

G. Krausch,

A. Sevink,

AZ

R. Magerle

(2002)

Phys. Rev. Lett.

Page 10: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

10

Thin film simulation

ABA-block

copolymer

A. Knoll,

K. Lyakhova,

A. Horvat,

G. Krausch,

A. Sevink,

AZ,

R. Magerle

(2004)

Nature Materials

Page 11: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

11

Details: Experiment vs Simulation

Nucleation

Experiment

Simulation

A. Knoll,

K. Lyakhova,

A. Horvat,

G. Krausch,

A. Sevink,

AZ,

R. Magerle

(2004)

Nature Materials

Page 12: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

12

Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition

A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, A. Horvat, G. Krausch, A. Sevink, A. Zvelindovsky, R. Magerle (2004) Nature Materials

Annihilation

Experiment

Simulation

A

Details: Experiment vs Simulation

Page 13: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

13

Outlook

• Thin films

• Shear

• Vesicles

• Electric field

Page 14: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

14

sh

ea

r ra

te

Block copolymer spheres in shear flow

Experiment I.W. Hamley, et al.

J. Chem. Phys. (1998)

polymer

M. Pinna, A. Zvelindovsky, S. Todd, G. Goldbeck-Wood

(2006) J. Chem. Phys.

Page 15: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

15

Ordering under shear

shear rate

M. Pinna, A. Zvelindovsky, S. Todd, G. Goldbeck-Wood

(2006) J. Chem. Phys.

Page 16: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

Double layer

Single layer

Y-T Hong, D. H. Adamson,

P. M. Chaikin, R. A. Register,

Soft Matter 5 (2009), 1687.

y

z

polymer

Page 17: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

Double layer

Poster P.24

Pinna M., Zvelindovsky A. V., Guo X., Stokes Ch. L.,

Soft Matter 7 (2011) 6991.

Page 18: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

Single layer “puzzle”

Pinna M., Zvelindovsky A. V., Guo X., Stokes Ch. L.,

Soft Matter 7 (2011) 6991.

Page 19: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

19

Outlook

• Thin films

• Shear

• Vesicles

• Electric field

How

?

Page 20: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

20

Dynamics

A

B

2

2

zG I

I

Electric field

z E

I

I FD

t

2G

noise

I=A,B

external fields

I

I FD

t

2

Page 21: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

21

Lamellae in electric field

A. Böker, H. Elbs, H. Hänsel, A Knoll, S Ludwigs,

H. Zettl, V. Urban, V. Abetz, A. Müller, G. Krausch (2002) Phys. Rev. Lett.

Page 22: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

22

Lamellae in electric field

Experimental scattering function

ODT

A

B

A. Böker, H. Elbs, H. Hänsel, A. Knoll, S. Ludwigs,

H. Zettl, V. Urban, V. Abetz, A. Müller, G. Krausch (2002) Phys. Rev. Lett.

Kinetic or Thermodynamic factors ?

Page 23: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

23

E

AZ, A. Sevink (2003) Phys. Rev. Lett.

Lamellae in electric field

simulation

ODT

6

8

Page 24: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

M. Pinna,

L. Schreier,

AVZ

(2009) Soft Matter

CDS

Lamellae in electric field

Page 25: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

25

Spheres in electric field

250 nm TEM

E

AFM

E

simulation

T. Xu,

AZ,

A. Sevink,

O. Gang,

B. Ocko,

Yu. Zhu,

S. Gido,

T. Russell

(2004)

Macromolecules

E

250 nm

Page 26: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

26

Cylinders in electric field

E

?

Page 27: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

27

simulation

E

TEM

Cylinders in electric field

T. Xu,

AZ,

A. Sevink,

K. Lyakhova,

H. Jinnai,

T. Russell

(2005)

Macromolecules tim

e

Page 28: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

28

simulation

E

TEM

Cylinders in electric field

T. Xu, AZ, A. Sevink, K. Lyakhova, H. Jinnai, T. Russell

(2005) Macromolecules

Intermediate stages of transition

Page 29: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

29

X

Y

X

Y

[110] -

[112] -

D. Ly, T. Honda, T. Kawakatsu, AZ

(2007) Macromolecules

Gyroid under electric field

Page 30: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

30

Y

X

Electric field along [111]

E

D. Ly, T. Honda, T. Kawakatsu, AZ

(2007) Macromolecules

Page 31: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

31

Gyroid: Electric field along [111]

5-fold connections

D. Ly, T. Honda, T. Kawakatsu, AZ

(2007) Macromolecules

Page 32: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

32

Gyroid: intermediates

Eskimergen, Mortensen, Vigild (2005)

Macromolecules

D. Ly, T. Honda, T. Kawakatsu, AZ (2007)

Macromolecules

Simulation

Page 33: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

33

Gyroid: Threshold of Electric Field T

ran

sitio

n t

ime

~ E 2

D. Ly, T. Honda, T. Kawakatsu, AZ (2007) Macromolecules

2/3

3/1

2/1

)(~~

~

)(~

C

C

TT

TT

Landau

Lifshitz-Slyozov

Page 34: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

34

Outlook

• Thin films

• Shear

• Vesicles

• Electric field

Page 35: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

35

Micelle-vesicle transition

J. Leng, S. U. Egelhaaf, M. E. Cates, Biophys. J. 85 (2003) 1624.

kinetic control

collapse coalescence growth

Ostwald ripening

& vesicle fusion

and fission closure

Page 36: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

36

Large-scale field-theoretical computer simulation on spontaneous vesicle formation

Spontaneous vesicle formation by SCFT based computer simulation

AiBj Gaussian chain in a one bead solvent

A B

S hydrophilic hydrophobic

Micelle-vesicle transition

A. Sevink, AZ (2005) Macromolecules

Page 37: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

37

Vesicles

A. Sevink,

AZ

(2005)

Macromolecules

20% of

A B

in a selectile

bad solvent

2 2

micro-

vs.

macrophase

separation

Page 38: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

38

Vesicle formation

uni-layer vesicle

time

A. Sevink, AZ (2005) Macromolecules

Page 39: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

39

Vesicle fusion

time

A. Sevink, AZ (2005) Macromolecules

Page 40: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

40

Vesicle fusion

uni-layer vesicle

time

A. Sevink, AZ (2005) Macromolecules

Page 41: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

41

A B 2 3

A B 2 5

L. Zhang, C. Bartels, Yi. Yu, H. Shen,

A. Eisenberg (1997) Phys. Rev. Lett.

TEM

Nano-structured particles

A. Sevink, AZ (2005)

Macromolecules

Page 42: No Slide Title · SCFT or Ginzburg-Landau K ... Kinetics of Cylinder-to-PL transition A. Knoll, K. Lyakhova, ... Landau Lifshitz-Slyozov . 34 Outlook

42

Contributors

Leiden University, NL

Agur Sevink

University of Bayreuth, Germany

Armin Knoll

Andriana Horvat

Alexander Böker

Larisa Tsarkova

Georg Krausch

Reading University

Ian Hamley Chemnitz University, Germany

Robert Magerle

MesoDyn team:

Hans Fraaije

Olaf Evers

Peter Altevoght

Bernard van Vlimmeren

Natasha Maurits

… ++

Eindhoven University, NL

Katya Lyakhova

UCLan, Preston

Marco Pinna

Dung Ly

Xiaohu Guo

Ludwig Schreier

UMass, USA

Tom Russell

SGI Origin 3800, SARA, Amsterdam

SGI Altix 3700, UCLan, Preston

UC Berkeley, USA

Ting Xu

Accelrys Ltd, Cambridge

Stephen Todd

Gerhard Goldbeck-Wood Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan

Toshihiro Kawakatsu

Tokyo Institute of Technology

Takashi Honda