neuro.dob.jpneuro.dob.jp/masunaga.docx · Web view平成30年(行サ)第15号...

Click here to load reader

Transcript of neuro.dob.jpneuro.dob.jp/masunaga.docx · Web view平成30年(行サ)第15号...

3015



12








14
2
xiv
ii
312171~81

56211118
14
14 () () ()
14
1562 () () () () () () () () () () ()11 () () () () ()

562111721562111981

5
1[footnoteRef:2] [2: 3199068324 3199953725 1962932664027720181328]
562
1111

(1)(2)34
(1) 562
Key Word
11562
11 12
(2)

1
11
562
1
11
15
1524562111
45
13.00
562111981
56
(1) 15[footnoteRef:3] [3: 2296150320036201417652016326258819871993292319981702201321732016551185 2008199032532623323641026262012 2011624282018/3 No.450 5041 201519 6141201621 ]
(2) 8[footnoteRef:4] [4: 23.1.2813463025.3.261225.3.252185361125.3.1825.3.18D1-Law.com1425.3.6218431525.11.2861714951327.3.25226823]
(3) 5811[footnoteRef:5] [5: 3030272530302323191911558 ]
108[footnoteRef:6] [6: 2926292621161010101010 ]
68
(1)(4)68
(1) 21200982920178492[footnoteRef:7]562111 [7: 922204612129211https://www.ippyo.org/topics/saiban.htmlPDF ]
(2) 78232425262729614562111562111[footnoteRef:8] [8: 927823242526272966 6 23242526272966 29201714 92 3031329URLhttps://blg.hmasunaga.com/hmadmeqdd/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/b0813e57084a8f2986bb11f27ccc5362.pdf 28112128URLhttps://blg.hmasunaga.com/hmadmeqdd/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/20161214001.pdf 2751126 2015]
(3) 29201714305621111314
5621111

1
13.00291.979918
1 591910
2219471720052120092420126123592
12914611720052020082420121201911232219471201972
(1) 591

(2) 61591
61 () () () () ()
(3)(1)(2)


13.001.97930
15151014
(1) 611113

(2) 611214****66
15
22194781 19472010201032131
2319487232131
25195011932132231
261951101232231
2619511213 32231
* 27195271332231
* 36196163832431
* 37196244032431
* 50197567532431
19891211632631
419926123PKO32231
* 619941128324
1019981014332631
142002715432631
* 172005816231932031
(3)
31
10 3 4

13.001.97930
2426 () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
11416
(1) 2466103368266891374
() () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () ()

1

(2) 591 () () ()(910
() () () () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
(3)
606167
B 10149
9591
9 51303250251253
1 () () 51303250251253
(4)(1)(3)
13.001.97930
96111617
(1) 961

961 () ()
(2) 1 () () 51303250251253
1
(3)(1)(2)
13.001.97930
(4)

13.001.9791718
(1) 13.00
(2) 302911.979
(3) 9171
(4)(1)(3)
13.001.97930
29(3)2021 () ()1824
55

43
307 (2)()d 6465
30
7
77 () () () () () () ()
(3)2023


13.08
2772
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()27

() (2)20 () () ()7 () () () () () () () () () () ()
29 () () () () () () () ()2 () () () () ()3.08277 () () ()1 () () () () () () () () () ()
29
() () () () () () () ()
77
() () () () () () ()
29
() ()29

29 () ()29
(4)2324
() () ()
6610337161
267
689138018138119



35
29
2426
2948.4.252430
1 2426292527
(1) 245


6610336633685


689137213747


29342730
(1) 24 () () () () () () () () ()661033685
26 () () () () () () () () ()68913747
2426 () () () () () ()68913747
(2) 29
3
(4) (3)29(2)282426292426
2426(1)(2)2526 () ()
(3)2929 () () () () () () () () ()292426
(5) 29
(1)(2)25262426


293048.4.257681
48.4.255 () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () 7980
(6)(1)(5)30
13.00(1)(2)25262426 () () () () () () () () ()
13.001.979918
292242623146
2623136
266891376(14)7
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()

42466103370(60)52
2466103370(60)5

242
31322452672

() () () () ()3126
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
2[footnoteRef:9] [9: 7 25273262 3262 256781550(68)6 9235414333 29 21 238313529 1920162234 4 () () () () () () () 4) 1431424=520105870 2920194135 91-520191536 16 16) 1424520104624201296 26 July 2016 No.430 127 23 ]
2
9813640
2452672

() () () () () () () () () () ()[footnoteRef:10] [10: 929 143 299272018.1 9138 299278913639 3.08 (3) (4) 22426229292426 9235414333 29 21 1432018154-3-12813052252440 26 24) 24) 5201247 282018/3 No.450 5041 11 2992720181No.448 12342 28120181No.756 9643 28 237715344 30306527 299273029(2018)5745 3031 ]
981
3639981981 () () () () () () () () ()
981981
29224262 3132[footnoteRef:11]4146 [11: 8913639 3.08 ]
4146
29.9.277080228637
3
2924262
2992452672 () ()28
313524262
31323132
266891376(14)7
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()
29 () ()
29242623132 3135263640981
4345
[footnoteRef:14]28 [14: 72018 45028 48.4.252745475 ]
2928276023136[footnoteRef:15]43447681 [15: 1432018154-3-12812952252340 26 29927891361041 ]
2945
2945262 31327681
4546
29.9.272297215708215371527731
29.9.2722864142

2772 () () () () () () ()
2924262 () ()
2426 () ()
2929
4648.4.25 2745477681
514753
25160
47535160
5114753
(1) 391964555119766019852514145130322351160717603951100603
21511
511
198115130325270

5130225472
[footnoteRef:16] [16: 5130325270253711 () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () () ]
(2) 51151 515130325371981 5130325371981
29 (4) 556030325371981
295611/3
295611/3 5130325068251(69)252(70)25371
(3) 51156615[footnoteRef:17]1 [17: 5130325472274921]
6511981
612
(4) 9[footnoteRef:18]3 [18: 60395112413611261383 33 583791274311287452 128644128745 583791268261273312 2672993010266891416(54)1422(60)729771116614611731539No.1458 2019.5 676910 276 697208131920853238 2712 697209032820973358 25325218536 1125112625326 122511286171495 13 24525 6610338878340696 3406963420110 34201103428118 No.380 201254046 113231 () 13 2012101 ]
53
51197631201943511603243
511

5361
5360
(1) 30102911.9792429
(2) 2567815224062769720592978
() () () () () () () () () () () () () ()

(3)A 303 () ()(2)5354232527
B 2925273
C 292325273981
981981
D

(4) 5560
295560
295611/3


(i) 289[footnoteRef:20] [20: 29.9.27168512017/10/23 214647]
(ii)


70717071
(1) 555729981
981
11112

58[footnoteRef:21] [21: 583791273311287(45)2 ]



(2) 29242930
2325273[footnoteRef:22]5960 [22: 26755689138321 263 689138927139634 139634140543 1405431416541416541422604 261599 2655]

121 100%3012192019621No.2403 130132
6061
5360
6166
56211111 562111
232011415211.0669[footnoteRef:23]48 [23: 201141529 http://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/ugoki/h23/110415-2.html http://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/kaigijoho/kentoukai/pdf/110415.pdf48 1.066]
11.011H222010/8/2549
11.0000850[footnoteRef:24] [24: 2526272930 11.0114URLhttps://www2.ippyo.org/pdf/kaso/syugiin_kaso.pdf4911.00008610URLhttps://www2.ippyo.org/pdf/kaso/sangiin_kaso.pdf50]
51051
(1) 1964Reynolds v. Sims 377 U.S. 533 1964[footnoteRef:25]19State15.62 19 [25: 1964615Reynolds v. Sims 377 U.S. 533 State10698.0366.731105.767115.6 115.5646,731104,767]
(2) StateStateUnited States of America501StateState1()()636410
States11
() State27122696,34505696,3442711696,345696,344[footnoteRef:26]23 [26: State2014.8.7 https://www.flsenate.gov/PublishedContent/Session/Redistricting/Plans/h000c9057/h000c9057_pop_sum.pdf]
() State191646,371646,37211646,372646,371[footnoteRef:27]211212 [27: StateVieth v. State 195 F. Supp. 2d 672 (M.D. Pa. 2002)200248Act 11StateAct 11a plan3Act 34341]
() State33686,3930[footnoteRef:28]221222 [28: Egolf v. Duran, No. D-101-cv-201102942 State2012192010State33]
782 (2013.4.4) 530

(3) FederalState
StateStateState
State

State


State
113.0011
56211114State
(1) 66 2010[footnoteRef:29] [29: State37,253,9562010 State563,626 166.1 State1 166.1 137,253,956÷563,6261]
13(1)[footnoteRef:30]State2StateState2State2 [30: 13 1 2 17 6 1 Article 1 Section 3 paragraph 1: The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State, chosen by the Legislature thereof, for six Years; and each Senator shall have one Vote.]
(2)
17924256121441004187147
116673
Karcher v. Daggett 462 U.S. 725 1983[footnoteRef:31]20 [31: Karcher v. Daggett, 462 U.S. 725 (1983)20 198362210.9930State4527,472State6523,7983,674=527,472 523,798StateState]


Karcher v. Daggett 462 U.S. 725 198320
51

(1) 3(1)(3)68













732
20222848%7376
23424525626727852820162849

2820162022125,342,3772748.3%2 60,536,72046523450.3%2 574
50%50%
282016202248.3%50.3%2.0%=50.3%48.3%
21200946.4%2574
202248.3%50.3% 234
56211118
2239.6%29201745.1%5


URL https://blg.hmasunaga.com/2019/03/20/post-24140/
46528917623450.3%
1114960,536,720
(85)176×60,536,720÷125,342,377
60,536,720
234 233289()176()÷20.5
60,081,946
14884.4
232.4233 ×

50%50%
7475202248.3%50.3%2%2%50.3%48.3%
29201745.1%


48.4.2527454751



44.4.2235685
(1) 55







(1) 48.4.2551
(2) 29 () ()242624243
29
292426

2948.4.25 () () () () () () () () () () ()
24262