Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler...

29
Near Detector at a Neutrino Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL

Transcript of Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler...

Page 1: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Near Detector at a Neutrino FactoryNear Detector at a Neutrino FactoryNear Detector at a Neutrino FactoryNear Detector at a Neutrino Factory

Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

Paul SolerUniversity of Glasgow/RAL

Page 2: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

2

ContentsContents

1. Physics motivation Neutrino Factory1.1 Neutrino oscillations1.2 Neutrino factory1.3 Neutrino factory physics reach

2. Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory2.1 Flux normalization2.2 Cross-sections2.3 Parton Distribution Functions2.4 Charm production2.5 Sin2w

3. Near detector requirements4. NOMAD-STAR, an R&D prototype5. Near detector ideas

Page 3: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

3

1.1 Neutrino Oscillations1.1 Neutrino Oscillations Neutrino oscillations well established Neutrino flavour mixing: Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata

(PMNS) matrix

Atmospheric neutrinos: SuperKamiokande

1)2(sin45 232

23

23223 102.3 eVm

3

2

1

U

e

ijijijij sandcwhere

cs

sc

iδecs

sccs

sc

U

sin,cos

0

010

0

00

010

001

0

0

001

100

0

0

1313

1313

2323

23231212

1212

Page 4: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

4

1. Neutrino Oscillations1. Neutrino Oscillations

Solar neutrinos (SuperKamiokande, Sudbury, Chlorine and Gallium Experiments) and KamLand reactor experiment:

1.3446.0tan 1210.007.012

2

256.05.0

212 109.7 eVm

Sudbury KamLand

Page 5: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

5

1. Neutrino Oscillation fits1. Neutrino Oscillation fits

Consistent picture emerging Global fit provides 23, 12, m12

2 and m232

13 not known, mass hierarchy not known,CP violation phase not known.

Page 6: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

6

1.2 Neutrino Factory1.2 Neutrino Factory Matter-antimatter asymmetry

of the universe: baryogenesis (CP violation in quark sector), leptogenesis (CP violation in lepton sector)

e

e

e

e

Conceptual design: neutrinos produced from muon decay in storage ring. Rate calculable by kinematics of decay (Michel spectrum)

Neutrino factory: very long baseline oscillation experiments to measure 13, mass hierarchy and leptonic CP violation

Page 7: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

7

1.3 Neutrino Factory physics reach1.3 Neutrino Factory physics reach Far detector (3000-7000 km) can

search for “wrong-sign” muons in appearance mode (for example, Large Magnetic Detector)

Background: charm production, charge misidentification.

Qt = P sin2 cut eliminates backg at 10-6

Large Magnetic Detector

iron (4 cm) + scintillators (1cm)

beam20 m

20 m

B=1 T

40KT40KT

e

e

50%

50%

wrongwrongsignsignmuonmuon

e

detectordetector

not detected

De

e

De e

NC

CC

Hadron decay

Other Detectors: liquid argon TPC, water Cherenkov, emulsion can search for either e, or appearance

Page 8: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

8

1.3 Neutrino Factory physics reach1.3 Neutrino Factory physics reach Can detect sign of m2

32 due to matter effects

Determine 13 and CP phase simultaneously: need ~1021 muons/year

Optimal CP phase sensitivity ~6000 km but

can obtain >5 sensitivity for ~1000-8000 km

Page 9: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

9

2. Near detector aims2. Near detector aims To achieve physics goals of neutrino factory, need to establish near

detector for near/far ratio. Long baseline neutrino oscillation systematics:

– Flux control and measurement for the long baseline search.– Neutrino beam angle and divergence– Beam energy and spread– Control of muon polarization– Measurement of charm backgrounds

Near detector neutrino physics:– Cross-section measurements: DIS, QES, RES scattering– sin2W - sin2W ~ 0.0001– Parton Distribution Functions, nuclear shadowing S from xF3 - S~0.003 _– Charm production: |Vcd| and |Vcs|, D0/ D0 mixing– Polarised structure functions– polarization– Beyond SM searches General Purpose Detector(s)!!

Page 10: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

10

2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.)2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.)

e

e

e

e

Neutrino beams from decay of muons:

Spectra at Production (e.g. 50 GeV) Number CC interactions

Polarisation dependence

P=+1: gone!

Need to measure polarization!!

Page 11: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

11

2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.)2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.)

Rates:— E = 50 GeV

— L = 100 m, d = 30 m— Muon decays per year: 1020

— Divergence = 0.1 m/E

— Radius R=50 cm

100 m

E.g. at 25 GeV, number neutrino

interactions per year is:

20 x 106 in 100 g per cm2 area.

With 50 kg 109 interactions/yr

Yearly event rates

High granularity in inner region

that subtends to far detector.

Page 12: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

12

2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.)2.1 Flux normalisation (cont.) Neutrino flux normalisation by measuring: Signal: low angle forward going muon with no recoil Calculable with high precision in SM

Same type of measurement as for elastic scattering on electrons:

ee

)(2)( 2

22

22

LABinEmG

mq

msG

dy

edeF

W

WFCC

2412

104.02

)( cmGeV

EEmGe eF

CC

ee ee

)()(

ee )()(

)1(22 ymE ee

E.g. CHARM II obtained value of sin2W from this

Page 13: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

13

2.2 Cross sections2.2 Cross sections Measure of cross sections in Deep Inelastic (DIS), Quasi-

Elastic (QE) and Resonance Production (RES). Coherent background to many interactions) Different nuclear targets: H2, D2

Nuclear effects, nuclear shadowing, reinteractions

With modest size targets

can obtain very large

statistics

Page 14: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

14

2.3 Parton Distribution Functions(s)2.3 Parton Distribution Functions(s) Unpolarised and Polarised

Structure functions S from xF3 - S~0.003 Sum rules: e.g. Gross-Llewelyn

Smith polarization: spin transfer from

quarks to — NOMAD best data— Neutrino factory 100 times

more data

Page 15: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

15

mixing: doubly Cabbibo suppressedSM very small, new physics

Babar: Rmix<4x10-3 (90% CL) hep-ex/0408066

2.4 Charm Production2.4 Charm Production Charm production: Measure of Vcd and strange quark content nucleon

Measure charm vs pt (background to oscillations) 6-7% of cross-section at 20 GeV3% CC events:

about 3x107 charm states per year

...,,,, 00 csDDDD

McFarland

00 DD

Clean tagged sample

Page 16: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

16

2.5 sin2.5 sin22 ww

Elastic scattering off electrons:

Deep inelastic scattering: NC/CC Good statistical accuracy on sin2W (~0.5x10-4) but hadron uncertainties dominate

sin2W ~ 0.0001

ee ee ,

)(

,

)(

2231241106.1)( cmgg

GeV

Ee RLCC

36.0)()(

)()(

eCCCC

eNCNCR

Page 17: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

17

High granularity in inner region that subtends to far detector. Very good spatial resolution: charm detection Low Z, large Xo Electron ID Does the detector have to be of same/similar technology as far detector?

3. Near detector requirements3. Near detector requirements

Does not need to be very big (eg. R~50-100 cm)

Possibilities:— silicon or fibre tracker in a

magnet with calorimetry, electron and muon ID

(eg. NOMAD-STAR??)— Liquid argon calorimeter:

problems with rate

NOMAD-STAR (Silicon TARget)

Page 18: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

18

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR R&D in NOMAD for short baseline detector based on silicon:

NOMAD-STAR (NIMA 413 (1998), 17; NIMA 419 (1998), 1; NIMA 486 (2002), 639; NIMA 506 (2003), 217.)

Total mass: 45 kg of B4C target (largest density for lowest X0)

Page 19: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

19

Aim of NOMAD-STAR: reconstruct short lived particles in a neutrino beam

to determine capabilities detection: use impact parameter signature of charm decays to mimic

impact parameter ~ 62 m, normal charged current (CC) interactions ~30 m

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 20: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

20

Longest silicon microstrip detector ladders ever built: 72cm, 12 detectors, S/N=16:1

Detectors: Hamamatsu FOXFET p+ on n, 33.5x59.9 mm2, 300 m thick, 25 m pitch, 50 m readout

VA1 readout: 3 s shaping

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 21: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

21

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 22: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

22

CC event

Primary vertex

Secondary vertex

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 23: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

23

Most chips stable, but some chips showed varying level of noise

Maybe the same as charge build-up seen in Babar?

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 24: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

24

Increase noise in some ladders affected some efficiencies: compensated by clustering algorithm with cuts as function of ladder

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

S/N

16

10

Page 25: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

25

Vertex resolution: y = 19 m Impact parameter resolution: 33 m

Double vertex resolution: 18 m from Ks reconstruction

Pull:~1.02

x~33 m

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

x~18 m z~280 m

Page 26: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

26

Charm event reconstruction:– Implementation of Kalman filter – Constrained fit method to extract charm signatures

Used NOMAD-STAR to search for charm events: marginal statistical accuracy, but was a good proof of principle

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 27: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

27

Efficiency very low: 3.5% for D0, D+ and 12.7% for Ds+ detection because

fiducial volume very small (72cmx36cmx15cm), only 5 layers and only one projection.

From 109 CC events/yr, about 3.1x106 charm events, but efficiencies can be improved.

4. NOMAD-STAR4. NOMAD-STAR

Page 28: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

28

Passive target can provide target mass, but affects vertex and tracking reconstruction efficiency due to scatters

Improve efficiency by having fully active silicon target. For example: 52 kg mass can be provided by 18 layers of Si 500 m

thick, 50 x 50 cm2 (ie. 4.5 m2 Si) Optimal design: fully pixelated detector (could benefit from Linear

Collider developments in MAPS, DEPFET or Column Parallel CCD). Could also be with 3D detectors or silicon strips.

Other technologies:– Liquid argon TPC in a magnetic field: maybe rate is a problem – Scintillating fibre tracker– Standard gas TPC with target (likeT2K near detector), …

International Scoping Study (ISS) for a neutrino factory (July 2005 to August 2006): aim to define the scope of physics parameters, neutrino factory machine technology and detector technology needed to launch a full design study 2007-2010. Near detector will be considered within detector working group.

5. Near Detector Ideas 5. Near Detector Ideas

Page 29: Near Detector at a Neutrino Factory Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005 Paul Soler University of Glasgow/RAL.

Vertex 2005, Chuzenji Lake, Nikko, Japan. 10 November 2005

29

Vertex for CP.

Conclusion Haiku: unique form of very compact and succint

Japanese poetry that captures the essence and beauties of nature.

Haiku poems consist of 3 verses of 5 syllables, 7 syllables and 5 syllables. Maximum exponent of Haiku poetry: Basho Matsuo (17th century).

My own (humble) attempt at a Haiku poem:Leptogenesis,

Oscillations to find,