Navigating Shareholder Dynamics: Relationships, Policies ...€¦ · • Plan –Established...
Transcript of Navigating Shareholder Dynamics: Relationships, Policies ...€¦ · • Plan –Established...
Navigating Shareholder Dynamics:
Relationships, Policies and Process
Mary Vermeer Andringa, Vermeer Corporation
Preston Root, Root Family Corporation
Todd Litzsinger, Follett Corporation
Jill Shipley, Abbot Downing
Follett History
Then - Now
#1 Content Distributor in PreK-12 &
Higher Education
SchoolsNumber of
130k
in North America
80k
SchoolsNumber of
Follett is in
1,200+
Number of
Studentswe reach through these stores
45M
Number of
Retail Stores2009 to present
MANAGE RESOURCES FEED AND FUEL IMPROVING INFRASTRUCTURE
Vermeer is a family-owned
and operated agricultural
and industrial equipment
manufacturer making a
real impact in a
progressing world,
committed to helping
others be EQUIPPED TO
DO MORE®
Harry Vermeer Gary Vermeer
Root Family History
Root Family History
Challenge
What was the challenge your
family faced and the key
dynamics involved?
Follett Challenge
Board - Refresh
Board Refresh:
#1 – Cohesive Approach (Ownership / Board)
#2 – Shareholder Value
Compounding Dynamics:
#1 – Family Control
#2 – Ownership Reality
#3 – Board Size / Makeup
• A family that was historically close, became historically distant; for the
next 35 years, there was minimal contact between the two branches, and
ownership of Vermeer was handled very differently by the two families
• Gary Vermeer family shareholders groomed to work in the company and
engage in ownership decisions
• Harry Vermeer family shareholders groomed to be silent owners –
supportive and grateful to hold stock but given little opportunity to
participate, beyond one seat on the Board of Directors filled by a G1 or
G2
Vermeer Challenge:
The Harsh & Distant Reality1974 – 2009
Two Branches…
…Becoming “One” Vermeer© Family Business Network-North America
Root Family Challenges
• In rapidly expanding families and their businesses, attempting to initiate predictable process for resolving conflict
• Becoming more responsible and agile in highly emotional issues; sometimes unspoken
• Perpetual consensus adds tension to complex emotional issues
Solution & Impact
What was the solution your
family implemented to deal
with the challenge and what
was the resulting impact?
Follett Solution & Impact
• Follett Family Ownership Group (FFOG)
• Ownership Breakout
• Vote
• Family/Ownership Voice
Vermeer Shareholder Relations
Development2009
• Ownership Council task force established
2010• First annual Vermeer family camp
• Quarterly Vermeer family communicator & shareholder handbook
2011• Established Ownership Council
2012• Buy/sell agreement development
• Family employment policy task force & shareholder director policy
2013• Updated family employment policy
• Buy/sell agreement
2014• Family office task force & review-renew-refocus
• Living out healthy family business governance
2015• Implemented first Vermeer family 5-year strategy planning process
• Transitions of Chair to Chair Emeritus and CEO to Chair/CEO
Vermeer Family Governance Map
Vermeer Ownership Council
• Structure– Annual shareholder meetings to elect board members (6
independent directors, 5 family directors, 4 next-generation family
observers)
– Shareholder learning forums – webcasts, dinner forums, executive
team presentations, product demonstrations
– Family camp – long weekend held annually
• Plan– Established Ownership Council to address key shareholder issues
such as buy/sell, estate planning, family governance and objective
setting
– Evaluating family office for all shareholders (could include tax
preparation, insurance negotiations, career testing for direct
descendants and married-ins)
Root Family Solutions & Impact
• Practical and diplomatic team to advocate for all parties
• How to introduce areas of concern for all parties
• Advocacy implies cooperation
• Small even-numbered team implies harmony
Root Family Team Members
prestonroot.com
• Family and non-family are both useful
• Diplomatic yet practical
• Highly engaged listening skills
• Connected to family and business
• Always present
• Family services staff ideal candidate
Lessons Learned
Follett Lessons Learned
• Involvement / Engagement
• Branch Communication
• It works for now…
Vermeer Lessons Learned
• Rebuild trust through relationship – never underestimate
the power of one-to-one interactions; take time to listen and
talk to each other; offer support and seek to understand
• Treat
– Business like a business
– Family like a family
– Ownership with respect
Business First, Family Always
Root Lessons Learned
• Contentious and dangerous issues changed
from dangerous and uncomfortable to
manageable
• Success on 2 or 3 major issues will validate
advocacy concept
prestonroot.com
Root Family
Family Soccer Game
PRACTICALEXAMPLES
Family Education
Philanthropy
Shareholder Relations
Accounts Receivable
Family Gatherings
Root Family
“THIS COULD GET COMPLICATED”
Summary
• There is not one “right way”
• Conflict is normal
• Direct, open and honest communication is critical
• Formal governance helps – find the right solution
for you
• Do not underestimate the power of having fun
together