Los Angeles Air Force Base Vehicle to Grid (V2G) Pilot Project
Naval District Washington Smart Grid Pilot Program · Naval District Washington Smart Grid Pilot...
Transcript of Naval District Washington Smart Grid Pilot Program · Naval District Washington Smart Grid Pilot...
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 2
Naval District Washington
Smart Grid Pilot Program CAPT Ken Branch
Regional Engineer for Naval District Washington
Commanding Officer of Naval Facilities Engineering Command Washington
16 January 2013
3
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 3
BLUF
Charged in with an energy focus
Discovered/realized cyber risks are huge/paramount
issues
Discovered/realized the ROI to meet energy mandates
is low… but
Discovered/realized that interoperability of the
“structure” allows a greater ROI (EM + UM + FM +
SecM + SpM, + …)
“Smart Base/Smart Region” is the road to a real ROI
4
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 4
Commander, Naval Installations Command
Region Naval District Washington (NDW)
Geographically located in multiple states to
address interstate utility regulatory issues
NDW Footprint
• Joint Base Anacostia Bolling
• NAS Patuxent River MD
• NSA Annapolis MD
• NSA Bethesda MD
• NSA South Potomac VA
• NSA Washington DC
25,652 acres
3,129 buildings
2,822 non-building structures
1,029 utilities
10 runways
6 hangers
44 piers-wharfs
3 small arms training
21 small boats
• Total Plant Replacement Value (PRV) $14B
• Operations & Maintenance Budget $500M/yr
• Reimbursable Budget $15M/yr
Thousands of every day “events”
5
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 5
NDW SmartEnergy CONOPS
• Reduce energy costs without impacting mission, thereby also reducing energy consumption
• Reduce O&M costs without impacting mission
• Change operational behavior regarding energy to allow transparent decisions regarding
energy-saving opportunities
Objective/
Results
Actions
Analysis / Diagnosis
Data/Status
Results What overall objectives does NDW want to
accomplish?
Actions What key actions will help accomplish this?
Analysis What key information does NDW need to
support the actions?
Data What critical raw data is needed to
develop the analysis?
Ob
jecti
ves
A
pp
roa
ch
• The NDW SmartEnergy CONOPS defines analysis of collected data to determine appropriate
actions in support of the Region‟s overall objectives.
CO
NO
PS
System Components require accreditable, Cyber-secure Data Flow
6
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 6 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Initial Operational Capabilities
1. The real-time ability to efficiently collect, transport, and synthesize Installation-level Energy consumption and load demand
information
2. The real-time ability to analyze, determine and deploy the most appropriate actions that will reduce Installation-level
Energy consumption
3. The real-time ability to identify energy system losses, faults, and business opportunities to execute Installation-
level actions to reduce energy costs, reduce utility system(s) energy loss and/or consumption, and/or improve
reliability, initial demand side management, and recommissioning activities
4. The real time capability to capitalize on distributed generation opportunities, present and future, to deliver
prioritized Base mission readiness support, intelligently reduce load demand, and deliver energy reliability at
the lowest Total Ownership Cost
5. The real-time capability to assess the physical and business situation of the total energy systems’
situation, the capability to forecast system condition, system operations and future energy market to
determine, direct, and enact the systems’ optimal Microgrid(s) design and operation to protect
generation, prioritize mission support and capitalize on energy market opportunities
6. The capability to store generated energy, transform kinetic energy to stored potential energy, and
effectively utilize stored energy for critical infrastructure, base load reduction, and/or energy sales
7. The capability to diagnose the energy market, predict future base and external energy
demand, and capitalize on the SMART Capabilities in order to design and execute the most
efficient energy procurement and/or sale scenarios, best road forward on Goals and
Statutory (present and future) requirements
8. TBD – Still in discovery
9. TBD – Still in discovery
10. The ability to “plug-in” to the National SMART Grid and achieve a better
bottom line and improved mission readiness
7
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 7
NDW Guiding Principles
The Capabilities shall enable the means to
achieve a better financial “bottom line.”
The Capabilities shall enable the means to
achieve improved Mission Readiness AND shall NOT
risk Mission Readiness through information
technology.
The capabilities shall enable recognition of new opportunities and enable
the ability to LEAP forward when new technologies, new regulatory changes, … new anything appear.
Imperatives to Smart Grid Strategic Success
Guiding Principle 1 Guiding Principle 2 Guiding Principle 3
8
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 8
09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
1. The real-time ability to efficiently collect, transport, and synthesize Installation-level Energy consumption and load demand
information
2. The real-time ability to analyze, determine and deploy the most appropriate actions that will reduce Installation-level
Energy consumption
3. The real-time ability to identify energy system losses, faults, and business opportunities to execute Installation-
level actions to reduce energy costs, reduce utility system(s) energy loss and/or consumption, and/or improve reliability, initial demand side management, and recommissioning activities
4. The real time capability to capitalize on distributed generation opportunities, present and future, to deliver
prioritized Base mission readiness support, intelligently reduce load demand, and deliver energy reliability at the lowest Total Ownership Cost
5. The real-time capability to assess the physical and business situation of the total energy systems’
situation, the capability to forecast system condition, system operations and future energy market to determine, direct, and enact the systems’ optimal Microgrid(s) design and operation to protect
generation, prioritize mission support and capitalize on energy market opportunities
6. The capability to store generated energy, transform kinetic energy to stored potential energy, and
effectively utilize stored energy for critical infrastructure, base load reduction, and/or energy sales
7. The capability to diagnose the energy market, predict future base and external energy
demand, and capitalize on the SMART Capabilities in order to design and execute the most efficient energy procurement and/or sale scenarios, best road forward on Goals and
Statutory (present and future) requirements
8. TBD – Still in discovery
9. TBD – Still in discovery
10. The ability to “plug-in” to the National SMART Grid and achieve a better
bottom line and improved mission readiness
Accredited architecture allows for secure command and control
Smart Grid Foundational
Capabilities
Foundational Capabilities
enable the first three
NDW Smart Grid Pilot
Operational Capabilities
9
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 9
Energy & Cybersecurity
“Cyberspace has fundamentally transformed the global economy. Cyberspace is the new
frontier, full of possibilities to advance security and prosperity in the 21st century. And yet,
with these possibilities, also come new perils and new dangers... The most destructive
scenarios involve cyber actors launching several attacks on our critical infrastructure at
one time, in combination with a physical attack on our country…They could contaminate
the water supply in major cities or shutdown the power grid across large parts of the
country.” - Secretary of Defense Leon E. Panetta, 11 October 2012
Select Guidance:
• “Energy security is having assured access to reliable supplies of energy and the ability to protect and
deliver sufficient energy to meet operational needs afloat and ashore. Shore energy security for Navy
is the mitigation of vulnerabilities related to the electrical grid, including outages from natural disaster,
accident and physical and cyber attack.” - OPNAVINST 4100.5e
• Per the Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, federal entities are required to:
– Cost-effectively reduce Government information technology security risks through documentation,
certification, and accreditation by identifying and managing risks of cyber vulnerability.
NDW planned its architecture using a Defense in Depth/Layered Defense strategy to reduce
cyber vulnerabilities, above all other considerations, based on analysis of perceived risk
10
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 10
Shore Sensor System Platform Network (SSSPN) ● Secure local network that connects to secure wide area network (PSNet)
● NDW Platform IT architecture reduces redundancy (both N3 and N4 systems utilize the same architecture)
● Platform IT (per DoDD 8500.2) refers to special purpose systems that are not directly connected to
Internet (each Platform IT system must be individually accredited)
● Video Perimeter Monitoring System (VPMS)
● Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI)
● Enterprise Industrial Control Systems (EICS)
● Navy Access Control Systems (NACS)
● OSD EEIM Working Group endorsed the Platform IT approach for EICS
Secure Wired/Wireless Network ● Developed for PEO Ships and used for AMI deployment
● Reconfigured AMI to support multiple Platform IT systems
● Greatly reduced infrastructure cost/impact (implemented less intrusive technology solution)
Other Navy Regions & DoD can Leverage Network Approvals ● Minimize conflicts and redundancies (standard architecture)
● Minimize time spent to develop accreditation package (approx. 3 years per package)
● Minimize number of packages required (legacy systems accounted for in NDW standard architecture)
● Opportunity to leverage DoD Information System Certification & Accreditation Reciprocity Memo
Reciprocity savings of ~ $200k/accreditation package (hundreds of systems exist)
Platform Network
11
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 11
Advanced Metering Infrastructure
• AMI is configured to collect consumption data in near real-
time (15 minute intervals)
• Data increases transparency of network-wide consumption
to enable culture change
• Empowers accurate Measurement & Verification (M&V) on
Financed Projects (increases contracting opportunities)
• Leaping beyond energy mandates to enable enhanced
command and control -
50
100
150
200
250
300
Elec
tric
al E
ner
gy In
ten
sity
[An
nual
kW
h/s
qft
]
Individual Metered Buildings
Dahlgren Annual Electrical Energy Intensity by Building
Average
Accredited AMI System – 1st in Navy
Accredited Platform Network (SSSPN) allows
alignment with Business Systems - 1st in Navy
Measurement & Verification (M&V) accuracy
due to Platform Network data access
Anticipated Return on Investment (ROI)
Measure
12
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 12
Enterprise Industrial Control Systems
• EICS encompasses several types of control systems, including supervisory control and data
acquisition (SCADA) systems, and direct digital control systems (DDC)
• NDW solution connects and integrates disparate building automation & lighting systems into
a single enterprise system (developed under the Small Business Innovative Research (SBIR) program)
• Enhances cyber security while leveraging legacy investment (independently evaluated)
• Operate buildings more effectively with remote monitoring and controls (allows for labor savings)
• Regional deployment with performance specifications for full/open competition (pending)
• Enabling ESTCP projects: Occupancy based operations
Developed Middleware Architecture to solve
EICS integration requirement
Foundation for additional sensors and building
systems integration
The ONLY Fleet Cyber accredited system
in Navy (est. savings $200k/package)
Operate
Installation Operations Center
Management Consoles
AMI
Region Operations CenterManagement Consoles
ICS
DDC
SCADA
Feeder Relay
Transmission
Relay
AMI COMServer
Supervisory
Controller
ICS Server
Installation Boundary Region Boundary
Region
ICS Server
Region
VPMS Server
Supervisory
Controller
Equipment
Controller
Middleware
Panel
En
erg
y P
an
el
Cameras
SSSPNShore Sensor System
Platform Network
(LAN)
PSNetPublic Safety Network
(WAN)
Equipment
Controller
DAS
(Data Acquisition
Server)
AMI Meter
VPMS
VPMS Server
SCADA VPMS DDC AMI
SCADA VPMSDDCAMI
VPMS Data Flow
ICS Data Flow
AMI Data Flow
Legend
*ESTCP – Environmental Security Technology Certification Program *ESTCP – Environmental Security Technology Certification Program
13
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 13
Commissioning
• In-house Commissioning Team returns buildings to
designed operational capability (allows for effective response
to alarms and enables continuous commissioning)
• Team performs air and water system balancing
• Commissioning enables: • Identification of future energy projects / repairs based on
building performance or current use
• Recommendations on additional sensors for remote
operations and condition based maintenance
• Demand response opportunities
• eROI funded Regional deployment of Middleware
Panel installation and commissioning
• Enabling ESTCP projects: Chiller Optimization
e.g. continuous commissioning
*
Identified opportunity for condition based
maintenance capability, moving from reactive to
predictive maintenance
Anticipated ROI after building commissioning
Reduce Energy Use
*ESTCP – Environmental Security Technology Certification Program
14
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 14
Demand Side Management
• PJM, the regional transmission organization, covers all bases in
the NDW Region (allows wholesale DSM contract)
• NDW Middleware Architecture is Open Automated Demand
Response (ADR) compliant and leverages industry standards,
minimize conflicts and redundancies
• Region has current DSM agreement with expansion capability
• Building Command and Control allows additional capacity to be
enrolled without generation
• Enabling ESTCP projects: pre-programmed response with AMI and
EICS systems
Deployed Open ADR System to enable DSM
for all connected buildings
1000+ buildings across 10+ sites
Real-time DSM capability enables local and
wholesale demand response
Annual Savings of $40-60K per megawatt
based on demand reduction
PJM Service Area
Reduce Cost
*ESTCP – Environmental Security Technology Certification Program
15
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 15
Initial Command & Control
Objectives
SmartGrid Capability 1: The real-time ability to efficiently collect, transport, and synthesize
Installation-level Energy consumption and load demand information.
COLLECT
DATA
TRANSPORT
DATA
Database
SYNTHESIZE
DATA INTO
INFORMATION
SmartEnergy
Dashboard
SmartGrid Capability 2: The real-time ability to analyze, determine and deploy the most
appropriate actions that will reduce Installation-level Energy consumption
ANALYZE
INFORMATION
Human Required
to Perform Action in
Field?
YES
NO
DEPLOY
APPROPRIATE
ACTIONS
MAXIMO
Work Order
for Physical
Response
Controller at
Operations
Center (Base
or Region)
SCADA
DDC
MAXIMO
Components
& Conditions
- Component
Character & Condition
- Capital Investment
(planned & underway)
MAXIMO
Components
& Conditions
- Component
Character & Condition
- Capital Investment
(planned & underway)
□
□
□
□
□
□
□
16
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 16
NDW Smart Grid Pilot Projects
Initial Pilot Locations: NSA South Potomac
•NSF Dahlgren (Virginia)
•NSF Indian Head (Maryland)
Pilot Deployment Locations Remainder of NDW Installations
• Capability 1 – 22 projects
• PSNet transport, closed-open connectivity,
Accreditation, Wired & Wireless SSSPN,
Interconnect Agreement, Configured data
alignment, connection of meter data
• Capability 2 – 16 projects
• Common architecture, standard screens,
DDC/SCADA, expanded Platform Network
for EICS, operations center optimization,
MAXIMO alerts and trend analysis
• Capability 3 – 43 projects
• Additional MAXIMO capability for space
mgmt, predictive maintenance, integrated
dashboard (OGC enabled), advanced bldg
analytics on system losses, sub-metering,
sensor integration, recommissioning,
advanced SCADA, VPMS
• Capability 4 – 6 projects
• Energy Mgmt System Integration
• Guiding Principal 2 – 12 projects
• Gates, Lenel, OSSI, Cyber Security, ELMR,
EICS (SCADA/DDC)
• ESTCP* – 4 projects
*ESTCP – Environmental Security Technology Certification Program
17
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 17
Command & Control
Interoperability Ashore
Leveraged existing ATFP
capabilities/architecture Driving towards Navy
energy goals through
making decisions with
real-time data
GRX Heat Maps enabled with AMI data
Currently Operational/Funded in Naval District Washington
N4/NAVFAC N3/ATFP
Unfunded Areas for
Expansion of Capability Set
18
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 18
Conclusion
The cyber security achievements & capabilities being
pursued are Navy Fleet norms; but not shore, nor DoD,
nor Federal
Capabilities 1 & 2 Business Process Reengineering
(BPR) is underway. Expansion requires further definition
& development… time & leadership
19
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 19
QUESTIONS?
20
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 20
BACK UP
21
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 21
Capability Maturity Matrix
Capability 0 Initial Capability Future Capability Improve & sustain
Don’t just fix it, improve it
Measure and fix
Fix it BEFORE it fails
• Optimize Readiness
and Total Ownership
• Optimize Microgrid
• Energy Storage
Fix it AFTER it fails,
• Operational Analysis
• Initial Prioritization at
the Component Level
• Data, Information,
Security, Analysis &
Actions
• Initial Prioritization at
the Facility Level
or not ($)…
People Putting out fires
Individual role focus
Innovative,
Deployable, Agile
Processes Incompatible,
Conflicting, Redundant
Navy/DOD-wide,
Modern, Industry
Compatible
Systems Isolated
Stove-piped
Sustainable,
Adaptable, Agile
Technology Dated
Untapped
Exploratory,
Innovative, Agile
Governance Unregulated Multi-base and external,
Cyber-Secure, Agile
Retu
rn o
n I
nvestm
en
t
Reactive
Planned
Predictive
Reliable
En
terp
rise
22
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 22
Capability 2 Capability 1 Capability 3 Capability 4
Data Information & Security Data Analysis and Actions Operational Analysis Optimize Readiness and
Total Ownership
The real-time ability to efficiently
collect, transport, and synthesize
Installation-level Energy consumption
and load demand
The real-time ability to analyze,
determine and deploy the most
appropriate actions that will reduce
Installation-level Energy consumption.
The real-time ability to identify energy
system losses, faults, and business
opportunities to execute Installation-
level actions to reduce energy costs,
reduce utility system(s) energy loss
and/or consumption, and/or improve
reliability.
The real time capability to capitalize
on distributed generation
opportunities, present and future, to
deliver prioritized Base mission
readiness support, intelligently
reduce load demand, and deliver
energy reliability at the lowest Total
Ownership Cost.
Projects Underway
Steam Trap
EICS
AMI
CIRCUITS
CICMS
OSD ICS Working Group
OSD EEIM Working Group
SSSPN
ICS (SCADA/DDS)
SSSPN
EICS
BPR
PMO
CICMS
Steam Trap
SSSPN
EICS
MAXIMO
CEMS
EIS Enhancement
STMS
CICMS (Extension)
BPR & PMO
AVIBS
STMS
Microgrid
NDW Energy Management
System Integration
EICS
Capability Snapshot
23
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 23
LEGISLATION - EXECUTIVE ORDERS SECNAV / NAVY GOALS
Reduce
Consumption
• Electric- 3% per year or 30% by 2015 (EISA „07-
E.O.13423)
• Water-2% per year or 16% by 2015 (E.O. 13423)
•50% ashore by 2020
compared to 2003 baseline
(Navy)
Renewables • Purchase renewable electric: 3% now and 7.5% by
FY13 (EPAct‟05)
• At least 50% of renewables from new sources (E.O.
13423)
• 25% or greater of electric energy use from
renewables by 2025
•50% of energy consumed
provided through alternative
sources (SECNAV)
•50% of installations “net-zero”
by 2020 using alternatives
(SECNAV)
Vehicles • Reduce annual petroleum consumption by 20% by
2015 (EISA „07)
•50% by 2015 in commercial
vehicle fleet (SECNAV)
Sustainable
Facilities
• Lease spaces req‟d to have Energy Star label (E.O.
13514)
• Energy and water audits on facilities on 4yr cycle
(EISA‟07)
• Buildings designed 30% better than ASHRAE
standards
• 15% of building inventory to be sustainable by 2015
(LEED or similar) (E.O. 13423)
• 100% of buildings designed after 2020 must be “net-
zero” by 2030
•50% DON installations will be
“net-zero” by 2020 (SECNAV)
Navy Shore Energy Mandates
24
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 24
The Small Business Innovation
Research (SBIR) Program
Problem:
Navy
Approach:
Market gap for ICS products/devices that are compliant with DoD/DHS cyber-security
standards
Engage with SBIR Program to develop a solution
SBIR
Mission: To promote technological innovation and economic growth through the investment of
Federal research funds in small US businesses.
SBIR
Goals: The Small Business Innovation Research program funds early-stage R&D at small
technology companies and is designed to: • Stimulate technological innovation by small US businesses
• Strengthen the role of small businesses in meeting Federal research and development needs
• Increase private-sector commercialization of innovations derived from Federal research and
development funding
• Foster and encourage participation in innovation & entrepreneurship by socially and
economically disadvantaged persons
Phase I: Feasibility Study, Proof of Concept
Phase II: Full Research and Development Effort
Phase III: Commercialization Stage • The government expects that a company will be able to turn the research and development of
the Phase II contract into a commercially viable product.
• Within the DoD community, technological innovation creates jobs, increases productivity and
spurs economic growth and competition. It also gives the technological edge to our
Warfighter, an edge that can save lives.
25
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 25
Are
as
of
Co
lla
bo
rati
on
Federal Agencies Other DoD Agencies
Academia Private Industry
External Collaboration
• OSD
• CYBERCOM
• Navy Fleet CYBERCOM
• SPIDERS
• National Defense University
• OASN (EI&E)
• JFHQ-NCR
• Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
• General Services Administration
• Department of Homeland Security
• National Renewable Energy Laboratory
• National Institute of Standards and
Technology
• Department of Energy
• Idaho National Labs
• 3eTI
• Tridium
• Boeing/Siemens
• IBM
• Johnson Controls
• LinkVisum/PwC
• NAVIGANT
• Schneider Electric
• Virginia Natural Gas
• Weston
• Lawrence Berkley National Lab
• MIT
• Rutgers University
• University of Virginia
• Utah State University
* Active principle partners
26
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 26
Securing Critical Assets
● Physical security Requirements
• Video surveillance system
• Video analysis and automated
intruder detection/alert
• Access control
• Improve public safety
• Safeguard against terrorist attacks
● Virtual Perimeter Monitoring System (VPMS™)
• Foundational Network for Sensor Systems
• Critical Infrastructure Protection for:
• Base Perimeter & Gates
• Water Towers / Wells, Tank Farms
• Substations, Wastewater, Pumping Stations
• Broad Deployments across U.S. Navy
Force Protection
27
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 27
Platform Network Policy & IA
Concerns
• PLATFORM IT - Derived from DoDD 8500.1, Paragraph E2.1.16.4,
Platform IT: – Refers to computer resources, both hardware and software, that are physically part of,
dedicated to, or essential in real time to the mission performance of special-purpose
systems. PIT does not include general purpose systems.
• Per the Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002,
federal entities are required to: – Cost-effectively reduce Government information technology security risks through
documentation, certification, and accreditation by identifying and managing risks of cyber
vulnerability.
– Individually accredit each Navy network
• Shore Sensor System Platform Network (SSSPN)
• Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) Network
• Industrial Control Systems (ICS) Network
– ICS inventory must be accomplished (July 2013 deadline) in
order to initiate development of the ICS accreditation
packages
– Navy Installation Industrial Control Systems Inventory Instruction,
20 June 2012
28
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 28
Installation Operations Center
Management Consoles
AMI
Region Operations CenterManagement Consoles
ICS
DDC
SCADA
Feeder Relay
Transmission
Relay
AMI COMServer
Supervisory
Controller
ICS Server
Installation Boundary Region Boundary
Region
ICS Server
Region
VPMS Server
Supervisory
Controller
Equipment
Controller
Middleware
Panel
En
erg
y P
an
el
Cameras
SSSPNShore Sensor System
Platform Network
(LAN)
PSNetPublic Safety Network
(WAN)
Equipment
Controller
DAS
(Data Acquisition
Server)
AMI Meter
VPMS
VPMS Server
SCADA VPMS DDC AMI
SCADA VPMSDDCAMI
VPMS Data Flow
ICS Data Flow
AMI Data Flow
Legend
NDW Pilot Architecture
Cyber risk blocked at
middleware panel
Inherent vulnerability in SCADA & DDC systems
Cyber Risk Area
29
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 29
Other Architecture
AMI
Region Operations CenterManagement Consoles
ICS
DDC
SCADA
Feeder Relay
Transmission
Relay
Supervisory
Controller
Installation Boundary Region Boundary
Region
ICS Server
Supervisory
Controller
Equipment
Controller
JACE
ICSPlatform Network
(LAN)
PSNetPublic Safety Network
(WAN)
Equipment
Controller
Regional DAS
(Data Acquisition
Server)
AMI Meter
SCADA DDCAMI
ICS Data Flow
AMI Data Flow
Legend
Switch
Local DAS Server
Cyber risk blocked at
Platform Network
Inherent vulnerability in SCADA & DDC systems
No architecture for N3/N4
integration. Strictly
focused on controls
Cyber Risk Area
30
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 30
Enterprise Accreditation Status
Collab 1
Ech II
Validation Collab 2 IATT PRA Suitability for Enterprise Deployment
NDW
Type Accredited for all Navy Installations,
following the approved architecture
NW
Collab 1
Ech II
Validation Collab 2 IATT PRA Suitability for Enterprise Deployment
Weston Accredited for NDW, HI, Midlant
Schneider NW, SE, MW, OCONUS
American Systems SW
Collab 1
Ech II
Validation Collab 2 IATT PRA Suitability for Enterprise Deployment
NDW N/A
Type Accredited for all Navy Installations,
following the approved architecture
NW
ICS
AMI
Platform Network
31
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 31
Future National Smart Grid
Consumer
Future National SMART Grid
Local SMART Grid
"... the new smart grid, a new superhighway of connectivity that will allow reliable
transmission of renewable energy; allow consumers to have real information in real
time about how they're consuming their energy and allow them to adjust... [and
enable] new manufacturing initiatives -- the people building smart toasters, smart
washers, smart dryers."Vice President Joe Biden Addressing the Recovery Act at the Brookings Institution
September 3, 2009
32
2013 ADC INSTALLATION INNOVATION FORUM | PAGE 32
NDW Smart Grid Pilot Team
Principle Members
Strategy/Execution
Regional Authority
N00
RDML Patrick Lorge
Commandant, Naval District Washington
N3
Richard Robishaw
Regional Operations Director
N4
CAPT Ken Branch
NDW Regional Engineer & Commanding Officer, Naval Facilities Engineering
Command Washington
N6
Jeff Johnson
Regional Chief Information Officer
Program Management
Utilize emerging technologies and smarter management practices for buildings and utilities that demonstrate a positive
Return on Investment, that can be replicated across the Navy, and, ultimately, facilitate integration into
a National Smart Grid supporting Shore Energy Security.