NatioNalities PaPers · Book Symposium on Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the Mountains...
4
Volume 47 • Number 3 • May 2019 • ISSN 0090-5992 NATIONALITIES PAPERS The Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 27 Oct 2020 at 18:51:44, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.
Transcript of NatioNalities PaPers · Book Symposium on Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the Mountains...
Na
tio
Na
litie
s P
aP
er
sV
olu
me
47
• Nu
mb
er 3
• Ma
y 2
01
9
For further information about this journal please go to the journal website at: cambridge.org/nps
C O N T E N T S
Special Issue on Ukrainian StatehoodBringing the State Back In: Studying Ukrainian Statehood in the 20th CenturyMarkian Dobczansky and Simone Attilio Bellezza 335
Reconciling the Irreconcilable? Left-Wing Ukrainian Nationalism and the Soviet RegimeChristopher Gilley 341
What Was Soviet and Ukrainian About Soviet Ukrainian Culture? Mykola Kulish’s Myna Mazailo on the Soviet StageMayhill C. Fowler 355
Rehabilitating a Mythology: The Ukrainian SSR’s Foundational Myth After StalinMarkian Dobczansky 366
Making Soviet Ukraine Ukrainian: The Debate on Ukrainian Statehood in the Journal Suchasnist’ (1961–1971)Simone Attilio Bellezza 379
Political Affi nities and Maneuvering of Soviet Political Elites: Heorhii Shevel and Ukraine’s Ministry of Strange Affairs in the 1970sOlga Bertelsen 394
Articles
Identity, Contingency, and Interaction: Historical Research and Social Science Analysis of Nation-State ProliferationLynn M. Tesser 412
Trapped in the Past: Memories of Georgian Internally Displaced Persons on the Margins of SocietyMalkhaz Toria, Nino Pirtskhalava, Elene Kekelia, and Konstantine Ladaria 429
State, Nation, and the National Flag in Post-Soviet Lithuania: Legitimating Identities of the State in Institutional and Social DiscoursesEgle Kesylyte-Alliks 445
State Ownership and “State-Sharing”: The Role of Collective Identities and the Sociopolitical Cleavage between Ethnic Macedonians and Ethnic Albanians in the Republic of North MacedoniaArianna Maria Piacentini 461
The Dark Side of the Moon: Nationalism, Human Rights, and the Erased Residents of SloveniaBarbara Gornik 477
The Peculiarities of Traditional Marriage Rituals of the Dungan Diaspora: A Comparative-Historical AnalysisZulfi ya Imyarova 492
Book Symposium on Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the Mountains 506
Vo l u m e 4 7 • N u m b e r 3 • M a y 2 0 1 9 • I S S N 0 0 9 0 - 5 9 9 2
NatioNalities PaPersThe Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity
NPS_47_3_Cover.indd 1 13-06-2019 14:59:08
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 27 Oct 2020 at 18:51:44, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.
NatioNalities PaPerseditor-in-chief
Harris MylonasGeorge Washington University, USA
managing editorDanielle Judith Price
book review editorRoland Spickermann - University of Texas of the Permian Basin, USA
associate editorsŞener Aktürk - Koç University, Turkey
Zeynep Bulutgil - University College London, UKPaul Goode - University of Bath, UK
Aviel Roshwald - Georgetown University, USA Myra Waterbury - Ohio University, USA
editorial boardFiona B. Adamson - SOAS, University of London, UK; Hugh Agnew - George Washington University, USA; Dominique Arel - University of Ottawa, Canada; Monika Baar - University of Leiden, The Netherlands; Laia Balcells - Georgetown University, USA; Lowell Barrington - Marquette University, USA; Ceren Belge - Concordia University, Canada; Max Bergholz - Concordia University, Canada; Stefano Bianchini - Alma Mater Studiorum, University of Bologna, Italy; Florian Bieber - University of Graz, Austria; Rogers Brubaker - University of California, Los Angeles, USA; Fotini Christia - Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA; Bridget Coggins - University of California, Santa Barbara, USA; Karl Cordell - University of Plymouth, UK; David Crowe - Chapman University and Elon University, USA; Keith Darden - American University, USA; Bhavna Davé - SOAS, University of London, UK; Stephen Deets - Babson College, USA; Emily Greble - Vanderbilt University, USA; Alexandra Goujon - University of Bourgogne, Dijon, France; Henry Hale - George Washington University, USA; Erin Jenne - Central European University, Hungary; Natalie Koch - Syracuse University, USA; Maria Koinova - University of Warwick, UK; Dominika Koter - Colgate University, USA; Marlene Laruelle - George Washington University, USA; Siniša Malešević - University College, Dublin, Ireland; George Th. Mavrogordatos - University of Athens, Greece; Brendan O’Leary - University of Pennsylvania, USA; Olga Onuch - University of Manchester, UK; Srdja Pavlović - University of Alberta, Canada; Peter Rutland - Wesleyan University, USA; Michael Rywkin - The City College of CUNY, USA; Gwendolyn Sasse - University of Oxford, UK; Edward Schatz - University of Toronto, Canada; Oxana Shevel - Tufts University, USA; Regine Spector - UMass Amherst, USA; Djordje Stefanovic - Saint Mary’s University, Canada; David Szakonyi - George Washington University, USA; Gerard Toal (Gearóid Ó Tuathail) - Virginia Tech, USA; Peter Vermeersch - University of Leuven, Belgium; Elpida Vogli - University of Thrace, Greece; Timothy William Waters - Indiana University, USA; Theodore R. Weeks - Southern Illinois University, USA; Susan L. Woodward - The Graduate Center, City University of New York, USA; Stefan Wolff - University of Birmingham, UK
past editors:1972–1984: Stephen Horak - Eastern Illinois University, USA1985–1986: Orest Subtelny - York University, Canada1987–1998: Henry Huttenbach - The City College, CUNY, USA1999–2002: Nancy Wingfield - Northern Illinois University, USA2002–2009: Steve Sabol - University of North Carolina, Charlotte, USA2009–2013: Florian Bieber - University of Graz, Austria2013–2018: Peter Rutland - Wesleyan University, USA
Nationalities Papers is the place to turn for cutting edge multidisciplinary work on nationalism, migration, diasporas, and ethnic conflict. The journal’s geographical emphasis is on Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe, Russia, Ukraine, the Caucasus, and Eurasia. Our mission is to feature both theoretical and empirical work, and review articles. We publish high-quality peer-reviewed articles from historians, political scientists, sociologists, anthropologists, as well as scholars from other fields.
Instructions for Contributors can be found at cambridge.org/nps-ifc
Subscription information. Nationalities Papers is published six times a year (January, March, May, July, September, November) by Cambridge University Press, 1 Liberty Plaza, New York, NY 10006, USA.
The subscription price of Volume 47 (2019) including delivery by air where appropriate (but excluding VAT), is $1,773.00 (£1,071.00) for institutions print and online; $1,551.00 (£936.00) for institutions online only. Individual subscriptions are available at $408.00 (£248.00) for print only.
Orders, which must be accompanied by payment, may be sent to a bookseller, subscription agent or direct to the publisher: Cambridge University Press, Journals Fulfillment Department, 1 Liberty Plaza, New York, NY, 10006, USA; or Cambridge University Press, UPH, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 8RU, England. For single issues, please contact [email protected].
Advertising. For information on display ad sizes, rates, and deadlines for copy, please visit the journal homepage at cambridge.org/nps or contact [email protected]. ISSN: 0090-5992EISSN: 1465-3923© Association for the Study of Nationalities, 2019. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, in any form or by any means, electronic, photocopying, or otherwise, without permission in writing from Cambridge University Press. Policies, request forms and contacts are available at: http://www.cambridge.org/about-us/rights-permissions/permissions/permissions-requests/
Permission to copy (for users in the U.S.A.) is available from Copyright Clearance Center http://www.copyright.com, email: [email protected].
Postmaster. Send address changes to Nationalities Papers, Cambridge University Press, 1 Liberty Plaza, New York, NY 10006, USA.
On the Cover. Hungarian parade, March 29, 1920. Parade held in Washington today by delegations of Hungarians from all over the country to arouse sentiment in favor of Self-determination for Hungary. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA, Reproduction number LC-DIG-npcc-01289. Available at https://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2016827644/
NPS_47_3_Cover.indd 2 13-06-2019 14:59:09
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 27 Oct 2020 at 18:51:44, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.
NatioNalities papersthe Journal of Nationalism and ethnicityVolume 47 Number 3 May 2019
CoNteNts
special issue on Ukrainian statehood
Bringing the State Back In: Studying Ukrainian Statehood in the 20th CenturyMarkian Dobczansky and Simone Attilio Bellezza 335
Reconciling the Irreconcilable? Left-Wing Ukrainian Nationalism and the Soviet RegimeChristopher Gilley 341
What Was Soviet and Ukrainian About Soviet Ukrainian Culture? Mykola Kulish’s Myna Mazailo on the Soviet StageMayhill C. Fowler 355
Rehabilitating a Mythology: The Ukrainian SSR’s Foundational Myth After StalinMarkian Dobczansky 366
Making Soviet Ukraine Ukrainian: The Debate on Ukrainian Statehood in the Journal Suchasnist’ (1961–1971)Simone Attilio Bellezza 379
Political Affinities and Maneuvering of Soviet Political Elites: Heorhii Shevel and Ukraine’s Ministry of Strange Affairs in the 1970sOlga Bertelsen 394
articles
Identity, Contingency, and Interaction: Historical Research and Social Science Analysis of Nation-State ProliferationLynn M. Tesser 412
Trapped in the Past: Memories of Georgian Internally Displaced Persons on the Margins of SocietyMalkhaz Toria, Nino Pirtskhalava, Elene Kekelia, and Konstantine Ladaria 429
State, Nation, and the National Flag in Post-Soviet Lithuania: Legitimating Identities of the State in Institutional and Social DiscoursesEglė Kesylytė-Alliks 445
State Ownership and “State-Sharing”: The Role of Collective Identities and the Sociopolitical Cleavage between Ethnic Macedonians and Ethnic Albanians in the Republic of North MacedoniaArianna Maria Piacentini 461
The Dark Side of the Moon: Nationalism, Human Rights, and the Erased Residents of SloveniaBarbara Gornik 477
NPS_47_3_FM.indd 1 07-06-2019 11:55:56
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 27 Oct 2020 at 18:51:44, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.
The Peculiarities of Traditional Marriage Rituals of the Dungan Diaspora: A Comparative-Historical AnalysisZulfiya Imyarova 492
Book symposium on paul robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the Mountains
The Tensions and Triumphs of the First History of Carpathian Rus’ and the Carpatho-RusynsNicholas K. Kupensky 506
Comments on Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the Mountains: A History of Carpathian Rus’ and Carpatho-RusynsHarvey Goldblatt 512
Orientation within Concentric Circles: Comments on Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the MountainsJohn-Paul Himka 515
An Historic History: Comments Regarding Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the MountainsPeter Galadza 520
The Interwar Years in Paul Robert Magocsi’s With Their Backs to the MountainsValerii Padiak 523
Threats to Regional Identity: From Atheist Communists to the Virgin MaryChris Hann 526
The Author’s ObservationsPaul Robert Magocsi 530
NPS_47_3_FM.indd 2 07-06-2019 11:55:56
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 27 Oct 2020 at 18:51:44, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.
