N. Makuljevic, From Ideology to Universal Principles. Art History and Visual Culture of the Balkans...

download N. Makuljevic, From Ideology to Universal Principles. Art History and Visual Culture of the Balkans in the Ottoman Empire

of 6

description

paper from CIHA conference in Melbourne

Transcript of N. Makuljevic, From Ideology to Universal Principles. Art History and Visual Culture of the Balkans...

  • 20From Ideology to Universal Pr i. \ t r I I is torv rrncl the VisLral ( ,u l turc of thc lJalkans in thcOttonr l l I -mpirc:, \ . , , , r ,1 . \ l , i i . , ,1, , i r i . l t r t t r t i r r r i l l ! tu, l t

    n c ip les

    The C

    ru . Ih i

    c\ i ia. I rlhc

    ( rr t ,a f l r

    ( ) i f o i th. So. i ls . t . . r rcf ipor! , . r r r h isu,' I

    l . . t' I -

    c l pLr . t l ,or pr* , i l , l1,rn* , r . , r br t r , nr lLrc, lt , t . . , .

    r r r l L isL,r l prrcrnrs i . 1.r , \ r ( l fa l ) \ r l , ( l i l l t . r is i r

    Mapping, Ideology andInterpretation of the VisualCulture of the Balkans

    It . . l

    ' ' , I I \1. .

    1] t ' . rc.rrrN tn ai t tcrrr ' . l i ! ( \Ls. 1{ ,Lr i . r l . ! iJrr l l

    nrs s,LN\ i f r l . r l l l tos ruL inr . r \nr \ isLrxlt , r t r lLr . r i , ! r Lr r l ,c \ csr. rLf l l l . f r \ l ,o iJf lcJ ( ! r r

    I i rpL, l , l i t , ' l \ i r r t r 11,r l , , Is, , inr l ! ( l fJ r l , . \ ' .sr, \ r l r i .u i r rQsr \ iL l i r l r . l tL. f ,Lb i , tn l )L,br\ r i lroJ rhc Vcrt . rLJ, r Lrr .s i f r l , . lJ . t r . f l . .oni f l , r rhr

    t ,l : ' .n, rhr . .N(. \ .s Ll ic Ins! . r , l i r . r r i .

    l l , ( . (Dl , l r \ r .ot ' .LLr j r r l r ( t r j1r , ! . l rhI I, .1, \ t r r i r ! , , t a i r i . r . I r l isn,Ls rorL cLL,rLr gr.L,p,r rhc ct , l |cs i r rhr r t r r .sr , rorr l , . , , r1 rrLr,

    i t .IL

    : l : "1rr)J t , \ l l ic . r rn i r i , . of , l r t ' r r r r l g i . rs .n l cLl ,. i r in 'L i r rLLrnis [ i r l , f i i r ]1, , i . . r isLr l culrur i

    | \ , I r 'I (n\ lhc\r r i .n. l , (u r l ! , . . ( ls of ( ) rn,r . !

    i rst iLLrr i r rs. IsIr , r . ( t rL,rr ] r i \ i f ( l ( . , , f i ro l i i ( l , r sr i . r '. r r I r , rLni t ic , r r l lcr i ,h rr I rnrrcs. , rnL1 rcsponJ(J I iJ rhr 1. ,1,1,o\ . \ ( ) i .1Qri , r { r . , t ,o, , . ,1 r{{rrr i r r ,( f , jJ , .s \ i .s J i l r r ,or r i i [ r tc J, ] vr LrL i , [ r , r i I rs\ r t .

    - , . , ) ,

    co rf iL rrc.uiLu rhNLgh rr , t l r t , rm (r rh.r i r ic, rr(nr i . r l LL, i ( i t ) r . rbc I lcJirc lrr i l r i r r i , l , \ r , , ) , \s i rr

    \ l ,. , I t : , L L l t . .L | , . .

    L

    ' , '11, ,r fc niJ s,r tctr$ ( . . r ! r r lh is iNLkc( l i , r 1)Lj i l , li r ! . r rJ i i .o! i .J rur ! r r . .Lr l l , r i , rL i f r ' , \ lr l r . r in( r n. . d,r I r r i r ( , i \ \ rs r ! ( i r l r , ! In! . . , ,

    l l l lLrr l ,. i . , . . i . \ l , . r' I l ,

    , . :1!! i { rs.nr l ) l r \h.( l i r f l rc Ll . r lk , r i . r i .s . r j1 ' t . i r lhTLInl i fks\ ! .1, i : rh. t r r , I r | / / , r r t r . i r i . r t , t ,crc,1rrr l

    ' l r " l. r | , , \ t .

    , t .l ' f r r i l r ! .or f . i . { l i i . l , . . i rcrrr . , r i \ o hoJ.\

    ' '1, . , ' l, . t . : L | . . . . .

    . , , \ , , . . , . . . , t .\ , , . . t 1or. thtLl . r l l .$. L lL,rnutI ispcr i r r l r , { ) r rhoJo.r ,nr : | l I tpr l , l i r r r i . l tJ r , . XI fLf i r r \L l r (N tr lk. ! !

    l l r r ,r r . . Lrr rhc f i i ( r . . , rh . .nIur l { t t ) i r ' r , iLrLn{f \ jnt , l .s . t d, . r , ,nplcr r rL l tLnr l , j r r l ( .1 . l 1 lx

    : l 'r"r" l

    ' ' , r l l

    l . . r . r l ' '

    ' l . r r .! i rL, . r i (nr . r rL r i r l \ is , , r l (L i l1, i r . ,n rh( l l . lk . r . o

    98

  • t t , t ' , lJ , , '1 ,x1 t ' , Lt t lD.r \a l htn. , tL l 99

    d

    build

    al l

    iki.

    . Je. .n. l ,J,"1. ' f r . . l po. i r . , . ' | r ' " ' ,31' , { ' -

    research on thc Balkus in rhc Middle ^ges

    hrs. ' f - rpJ r J,r f- (n r , . . - . l rJrr o . ,1 | p ar' r

    h i . ^r"

    L ' . In !p, ( " 'Fur -L n "b ru rJrr r t

    ,n r l - b, \ r "

    , , | | ,hrr . , , t ' . .${dmooc.n.Lcrorrd.rnonr"rr , , . . t , , ( , t . .b. r . , r , . :Jc. lrorr , l . 'e r :e$. |

    ' r "p. , r . c. . r 1 i r . r

    \ . ' " , r r l - L- q, l l ' - . . l . r lor ' ,d " . r i -srr l

    1J .J I . r . \ l . r .u. - 1, ' l . ' . - . i F

    Orona fr"e|" . r ' r ' r r ' r

    L. n. r : r ' . , r i .cJ

    . . l . . r r i . , , \ ' , 1, i r . r ' ' \ r \d.- l ' , - r .\ ' , l , . o l o. l

    - f r . F. , r ' , ' , r , , , l ,ur , L

    ninctccntb ccntury', the national h istoiograph, cs of.h \"no' , , . nJ.

    " f L- B. \J

    '

    J . , , {J , , . , u -n, .

    . r r r rJ- lc , \ , r .1 l "* ,* .1 q,r l i , \ard lmportance, srb(trJiiarcd it to thc corccprol r r .dn'J rn rnJ r 'eJ 1." i r .Jr . ' l . , 'J i , ,

    , , L J, .' r . - t . r . l 1 ' \ . t r r oI"r Lr , l r r - . , , , rq' r '^rB u ' . rn ' . r . rnJ rerr .J. ' .

    ' r . r ' l -c

    conccpt of llyzancc apris Byzarce'. l

    The Concept of Balkan CultureR,-. , r , . ,n rr .

    " . _, t . r , rn.- t r c of l .

    Brlkars rcquires e conplex mcrhodological rpproach bdscd on rheider.frhe crcssing ofcultLucrand rhe neerl o ncludc all aspccts o1 vrurl

    , l , l ( 'n. " . .1 . , r ' t i^u

    and irleologicrl contcnts, in , unilicd conrcrrualI ror

    "1" ' . . \ r r r - r I I w,. nr I , I ' , ,J . rstanding ol thc r isur l cul turc ol thc Bl lk i .s crnIt iound in rcscarcl thar has been brsel on rriichrsion of all thc particult rspects ol thc cul. r

    .Thr 11r" . n"1 eturr , rn.5. , r

  • 100 / / / . , \1 l l l , , l l , ,

    f ! !n,r ur [nownlt*l .on.nr! s. Mo ine.) ,vrr .cyyr.r . . ig l r ree nh .e^urPl ,croirrph Ne nd Mrk! re! .

    Creating thc Visual Culture of theBalkans in Early Modern Times

    Snth ot brorJcr rs l )c.rs ot r l ,c .utu. . . l rL icI t \ . r 1. , , . . r . . , . , r . ,

    r . . t . .1. . r : . r t . ,' r ' ' t l l. t , . , t t , , ,

    \ t r i rL xr i ( l !c . !h lh i . r l . i , ,Lrr j \ r .n,csj . t , . . , .1rh. . r6L i r r | . f f r i r t , f . r .q!aik\ j , r rhc n)nn.r io

    r" ln.rs . [ (L] t i . r l ) i ) i . . . , ! l r i r . t r l r r l rn(1 i r !kr

    r l r r lIh. O( l (nndN ( l ( r r . t fJ r l igFL,s rd. l nx i i l sr , [u\

    l t , " lr t r i rur l . ( \ \ r s,)r lk. , r f l l ! iLrN c. I r ,L i , i r ic i

    ' . . | , , . . . . .

    . t . . 1. . " . ,

    , .

    I I r lcc. t lur ing Ih. s((ni( l l r . l i . t rh. s i \ r . ! .Lr i

    \ . rs i s11.d l lhrrsr i , r i f . \ t r i l . \h i . l , . r ,sel mdr,I

    ' r . r . : r ' , l

    ' . . l . . .1 , , . .

    D.cJt ol ( lhf( t r r r eonD,!r i l i .s '(1c, , ! r i fh ic

    .onJ[ i (nN dc r l ! r ot s] ,c. i . ri , , rpo, t , r rcc a, tbc r isL r l crL1rrrc ot thc l i lkrrs. '( i , l i poirrcr l Lhlr) i . , , r xra r lo r , r ( i r r r .r r r r r i tD.f .s nuc ol l l ,c r rcr .qr is i r .s l i ! r i . t i

    . , , , . t . .1t ) rcstr . r ot | r ! . rs \ | i .1, i . ,ncJ hy e. f r \ i rs|

    ' , ' '

    . { , 1, , , r ' . , , . , . urr . . t t , \ . , t , . .

    ' I t "

    . , ,

    ' , l

    '

    I t i l r i { , r l '

    , r' . . , , . , . t ,

    ' r ' l r ' l r ,

    " r"rr . r l . , . . t, . ,1 ' , . , . " .1. . ' l

    c , r r , t r r is inr I { rasirr c( f r rcs ro rb. Br lkdb ''11 r . ,

    n drc Br lkms lcJ r i ' r fc rJor,rnn ot crmn,or

    t , th i rhr l tcd m11 ,c1r,LrtJ prrrcms oi ,chgirrr :' ' ' ' ' ' l t r '

    r rLI publ ic t lcot i r r \ i rhrr thc ()rr( !nrr l i . t , i rcI1,r . \ . \mI lc\ or v(udl . ! l ru 'c i , i r l ic B, , lk , r . :

    \ l i i l . l r

    llxll.rlbr i lJo

    r rD I

    ( lh, isr i

    Or

    ( .hf isr i rlhr

    lnr i f . .

  • F\ in(r rh( kr l r . I r { , f l c !mnor, \ . : , . . ,1 i l ! .L rnJ{,r ,F,c. I l t r !a t . . \Tcr nl Jrr l h- l \ . r l . lf t is t ic ! !d efx l r ski l ls rcsafdless oi rhc

    ' . l is ious,dl , , , , . , ' , 1, . ' l , , t r '1, , , . ,1 ,d, , , \ , r rh . r . , ^ .'1. , 'n, | . ' r . .1. . ' rs n . . , . .1 J J. r .1r . r i i

    " l \n ' , ' l. | 1.1tr in r lR rr1i , n.

    '

    i I r , , , . ,m,1. , , r , ' r . , , r . , , .1tbc bernt ; lu l rnJ rhe drasni l iccDr 'Nfr p.cs.nrin rh. c.rrr l r r r r r . r rh< rr luc ot sork. . , r . rn.rnJrrchitecurc. Ihc rrsc of sucb crnrrir is contirnerlbl thcwrirings ol rhc frnrous Tork*fi soorrccrrlr. - , .

    ' r .^ . l ld l \1, \ . , \ . l .u i . \ ' r ' ,1. . . - r l \ - . i \

    .1. , \ ,* "

    , t ' - , ' . " I \ ' l r " r l f r r \ ' . l

    -ut toman buik l ing t r rduior respcctcJ thc uuk ol\ |n,rr : i , r r . ,s rh. nr- i f

    '1- , r r . rnr . r r r l r . . r , , t . l ro, ; . i r . . . rn, l hs s ' r [ . rn r l -c t r lkJ . . s(h." rhch,,Jr , no I l , ( Dr, . , . , r \ i . . r lJ . h.r l . i r r^ i r \ rre.eptnrn inur8 trluslin\ as \cll ds (lhristirns.'

    R, l r r"s. t l t r r re. r , r ' J . ' l ' , i | | l ' \ InNr-buil

  • 102 Ih Ll t r r , l \ \ t ' r ! , i l t t t t r t r , , t

    r isur l cul turr r1.pcr s. r lo r ! n i rh , , . l ,Ni , ! , . l sc()' I , 1

    " t l ,

    l " { . , , ,r l l . l l , , lk | , , r l t . ( ) t t rDrn LDt, i ic o l l . rs r . rod. l

    , LL

    l ' | | I ', ,11. . .

    rcccpror rn,1 i r r . rprcrrL!{r ot rsrLr l crLlrrLrr I rI . t

    i t 'c l t rs. , r r r l . ' l lor r r r lJ l t hsLor ' .

    NoTES

    , s di . \ r ,L l r ! i , r l l r r r r i . L j ! " ] . t r f . r l l .LLr.r . l .1r . .2 \ . l , r r L l ] , , r , r i , r , , l , / i , , / r i , i r ! \ I , i , , [ , r ,l . \ ' . l r ( l ( , r nr t r r \ , , 1rr* l , " , l . l l , r \ .L, i i ; . ., ; r . f . l l svr \ 1( l . l i . ] t \ l . t i r t i t : , ' t t ! , .1

    \r , , r i I I i r r , I : r r f r . h\ i iL r ' . l l . r l , . t r r srLtr l i |

    | \ I ) l ,d l r$ l ) , , l ) ,1, i ( r . r i , . r1r ,n/ , !1,i , r t l ; r , l i r ! i , r r ,a, , , l I l t i , t . . ' t , ' , i l ) )1. t , l1. , . r , ; , r , " . I , t . r : . i r . I i , i r I , I r \ f r i : \ , I ' r ml

    ,) l ) I l .1| l f \ I i , 'Lr l i r j r l l l . / i i r r " r , , r : / i r , rq. , I1I I ] i l i . ' . \ . t r .x. ,Lr l , l l r ! , r l r . le is rr . e ' )2 l\ ! r , \ ( r

    .L[ . [ ' . r ' \ ( !1. . /n ] , r ' f i r / 11' / r r r r l r f , i\ l iN,r . r ( r ln,r lL. \ , l .n,k i L l t i\ \ l i r n \ , , : r r , i , l r rJr , . l " i r . , / , . i , r , r , , r . r r r ; l

    , . . t r t , i . , .1 ' ' t , r t r . r ' r , . i ' . , . r ' . . ( \ ) i r i r i .L!r . ( .1sfr . r t r .sfr . r . L l r , f i r i5 2!n l l l . r . l , \ . t r ]r ( r , i ! , i , , r l , i r | , , ' i . , r i , . , i : .L r : , . r ' r r \ \n sr , , .In! . f . l . r iLr : { ) .2r i . ) . L l , \1, ,1. ! . ,7/ i . ' ,1 r .qrrj \ 1:n-:1ir.';r I l:rj;. \r,lri,: \. r*rl,i,Li(1. l )i6()r

    . r r l l . t , i \ r . \ nntL! \ .1 ! .nf l . \ .b i t rLrLtr , i . l Lhr\ t r t r . cL: lLL,rr t r l , r l l .L i . r ' ' .1,"r\ r

    ^1, \ . ' l : \ , 'L \ r , r ! , ' "1: .1, . . , ' ( ,1nrl l . , l .Lr$.La,, f rnn, f . ,Nirr . t .L l r , . ' . r r . lf . r r j l i r , r n l i , r i ! ( n!nrai l i ,L l \ ml rr rnI L

    ' , ' \ r . , ' l j ,1. , . \ .1 l \ ' /1, ! \L:k i l l . ,Lhtr \

    I r i L)r l rJ. \ . i ln/nr r r l . l . \ ,ntr fNJ..\ .L l r .L l . . r , r f : r , I lLr . r , t r . l , , : , . l ) : ! , 1t ! ) r t i,1, , / -1:r , , i l r , , i i , , r r r L. \ , , : ,J- . i ,1, L l r . l l( , t r i ) ! . rL\rnrf r . ! l l rJL. , r \ n Ll .LLlr t r . r . . . '1. ,, , \ , .1. i , .J r l r fL j l r nLtrL!r , j jn i l r . l r i .du. r r .n,rr l , i t r , . . f r l r r , r lLrn\Lt . ,L l r rd iLL,\ S(f ( . r r i ! l , iI l I l t r .L r t r r l r . r r" r f : ! r ! , r r , i i lJ , , i . r l : r i :1 l / r , r i ' .; ' i r r i i j i i . r ' rL J I ' t )n1. , l l t ' l ) i . t ' . .1\", \ t \ t ( ls . I r r$.1,r , [ . i re; .

    2L

    .t;

    l i

    \ ! l

    l t i \ IS \ \L

    I , , , J f tu r r r , .n, l rnr , r . ' r l l LtLL[r f . * .I l , ' . l l . \ , i " , : r ! i r r t , l i

    ' i , r , ' l ) , r . , ! iI I r . r lLr l l r$ I j \ l f r f L i9_.1, , . | j ;1:rLtrr . l , , r , r , . r , l r ,n r f .

    ' r , l , L l r r . f r r i r '

    l j r1. , I ln i nr . \ i , , 1 l r n) rh i r r r . ! r r l r ! . ,LL, \, , lL t l t . \ \ r \ l f .nrn l , i | ' r , , i . ' , r ' r i , , . " r . ' i ' ,

    1a,r ," . : ! l l r , i , , , ; , l : , r " i i : ; ' ln ' t LLL rr n, , :LL nir r"rL l l t l ! , r1. . l ' r \ l l l ( . . \ / ; , . , i ,

    " '

    , r '

    r )1r l ' , ; ,1 i r r : r . r r ' ! , r / r , i l , r i . , i \ ' . i 1,rr lt - . , , .1. , , )q ' , . \ l ( i r ! : . l , \ , t r ' ,

    " r r i ,

    , i , , r , '

    - ' , . i - l i , , , i ' , ' , ' i r ' , r

    r?.r ' r j j r r i : ,' i t l t l r t ) ) ! t , i r t . t , i . t , t , ! \ t , t i /x i , t t ! r. r i , r l i \1, . t r f : . , \L ld$ ! ; r . l ) l ' . r l ) . r1, , r : , \ .l ) . ,1. i i f ' , r , r ,aa) ' l l ,a i i r i l , t t ' . : ' l 4t : r t l

    l . l i , r r . . \ . i rh, r L ' r ' )1rrI l ) , \h i 1, L, , , l r r , r , , , l l l j t l l , ,

    ' i , ,| . j l , . , , " , i . l i t , ,1, , \ ' : r , i , i , , i . i ' r 1 , . ,( , L l l , r L \ . r i , t r r ,1. J. i , \n, Lr , .L l , .L r .L l l j x l\ \1 | , . , i r f \ i r : , , r r

    " r , , , r i '1. , i i , r , i r i i . : i ] . i , , .

    \ rLLLr i r iL i ' , , . \ f l r ) r ; . ! r r r l , , \ i / . l , 1. i ' i r , . , " , I r - i , r i ) i f i f l r r i i l l j i ; l i l r .I1Lrt , . : . .1 i , \ . r , \ t r ! l . l . ) . i I lSLrLL.\ ' / . . r. r / i r r : , r , r : , r , r r r i ' i t . r , , r i r i ) ! j i l r . I , L, / . rIu l L L r .L r t r r . l l r l ! n l . . l ' r r l ; . , r \ I l )1, ,1.1 .l - t t , t " t t , , .1- . i | . r , , i I \ l \ r r i j / . . r r", , " , r ' ,4, , i , i

    ' / r i i ' , , i ' i r r , ' , r i i , i : i , , , , r ' l t r . f, . , L, l t l , . , l , , . \ r r r r , . . ,L i , l r , l j r f t r l , . . lLr l ,

    I l f : l r .L lk,rrnl . . ,ur f f r r ! . r ( r i . r . l \ r , i .Lr t r . ll l i . ( ( { ,ur . r ! l i .LLLr ( tL l , \ , r \ l . , .hrr . i , l' I : r , l r \ i . , . / i . r r , ,

    ' r / r i / r r \ l ' , , r l l i ] i . , r i , rr , i \1 i r r a, ' l l r ' i . ] i L.L : \ l ) ( . r . t r / .* \ . idr i l l \ \ .1 ' ) ' ) .1 f r I - .dr l f l . , , f ! l : r , \ , . r '\ t ,Lr . ! r 'Lr '1. , \ . : . t r r f ,11l \ f r . \ f . r l K. t r l j . , r. !1 . l r , / " , , ; l r ' , , , : . , ,1 I lar" , 1 i 1) , / L \ ( , \ r r

    , ,1 \ \ ' r ! , , | , I r* . I l . t r i \ , , . \ \ l . l , 1r I f i r l l t l . )I ( , \ . r . , ! 1. \ r l f \ i , i , ,1, , I1\ , i l r . , r r r r l , i r .

    l l , i .nr t r , , r f : l \ \ . , r l r ! ( .orn. \Lf l i r t r r r r rLL.t r . . i , r r l ' .LI , .LLktr .L:r ' '1 l l i ; , r i , r , . ' , , i l r , i ..rr.) , . lLr; .r \ ,\,r11 \ir\:a. Iiii .,.r,r r!,r,

    " , " r : r , r ( i \ . t l t | rLL. \ , , r ! )11. , . t r r !L ( )Lr l , f .d,

    1. , , . r , , . Lr \ l l i r l f f . t r r \ l l l l ( ,nr r , l . . i ' ,I i '^ , i " l l ; . r , ' . f i i r t ! ) , l l ' \ t , t ' , i r : , ,1,l i . t r , " , r l r ; ' , , , , r , . l r . "d l lL,L, , , r . | ,1, ,1rLr I f t , i r

    6 \ jNJ. i . , r fL! , , r : l \ t l ' r Lr ( . r n, l t r Lnf .LLf, . r .LL.d!r . f : r I l ] . , i |J5 i L l r r , r r f l l r r l i |, , f f : , , \ ! 'S i . , , r ( . i l i i " i i . l . |

    ' ) t l] i i , r r , " i , r , ] l i , l . , r tdr , i , , i r ! " ' r f r r t / : r , ,1rr i , : , r , r

    ' r ' i . , : , r r ' . P] . t r . . L i ( q, t r ] . .1rLl ' ,

    L j ( fn ] , . t r r I r : . r r \ l f r i . . \nrr , r ' , r i , , r " r , , i '! l rtt. it I r ln r t, l l r ..!,t rt t l \.r !,)1t 1 r t, r':rt.t !:r lt : , ! . ' I t ! : t ' r r t ' | , . . . '1, : ' r ' i t ' : , t , ,1: i , . i r t , ' i " t, l ' .1, ! r" , , , \ f l : r I ( ) or . i i r r i !1. \1, , r1f t . .

    I I / f . t l ' ] ( . r i l . , : t . ] , i i r l l . L)(hin.r . l ( ) r r lnn. 1. |n.nr. , r r r l r r l r ( ( . , r1 ! \ . / .1, , r , , .n, , r , , i . t ( ) i l t t . t ! \ r r . t ; . , r , r .21rr l r f L. l0

    j \ . r \ I l .L[ f l . \L. . J l r r 'Zortr f l r 'Nl . ( l r . { ) fL l r f(1. \ | .LrLr f ! n \ f ( r l . . t r r I L, .1) . \J1) l t r ; l r .l i . , l r '1. , n, i t . )Lr i i i . t f lsr 6

    i6 | fL rh! Lr ntr . +I t r \ .1 Ni lnrrL. t r r r t . : . rl ) l ) . r r l r . ,1 . l f . / l i , r , / r ' . ,1 ' r ! i i , r ' r . , r , .! i \ I : . f l i . ' ' r 'a i i / / la" , , " . ,h i \ r r , . l, , r i r , . r r j ) l . j l ) .11)1r j

    l ; L| , r r . i l ! ) i l i \ / , t . , , t , i \ l l r / . r r ! .m.r ] l 'tL 'n, i r , r r I d. : i , r r N l . r l , ,L. ] l i : , t t

    ' t ! ) r l r l ! r l

    l r l r , t r , r i . l i r ! , t . .1. l . t t , i r i . r r r l I f j r f l,L l . r i t r l . " L i \ r f r r , . . . lnrrr . { . ler i_

    s (r r / r . t r , f ! , l r , f ! , \ r n l [ i , ] fu, . r . . .1Lt ,L)r . r l rL . , lLtr i f , r r l r . r i r . r , r f r l r ( . r i f \ S!rl r ( .1 r t r / . \ . , / ' r , r i , , r , , , r1",n. t l ' , l ,a rr l ) r i . i .LrrLlrL u r lo kr :u ic l , lorrr l . l , t r r l , ' r rL lSL N,1. [ . , r . \ i f f l r f ] \ , r r r , , I I i r l i , i i, ,

    " l r r r ' , i i , r i , /n ' r , , i , ' , , " , , . I J, i / , , ' , , ! r , 1! , r_.

    l , , f \ . . r ! . 36r.R, ' i . r r \ , i \ , / i r r , , , l \ , i , it t t ! . t t . t t t ' : . , t t i t t , ' r l r 'n, r \ . r | \ l i K, i , : l l1) ltrrJ srINln,Lt..rL vi.rfrL L3as i)"i.,r iirr!.ir,lr ' , i , r , r l i , r , l? ' i , r , r , . i . , " r '11, ' , " / , , ( ,

    " . r : , . r i l, r i ! ] i , l i t r ; r l ! r i r i ! , / I r . \ . l . f / '1. l t i t r .dr lr ) , , 1" , ; , r , , ; , i \ , i / , r , , ? i , i ,1 i , , \ i r f . / , l i ,

    -

    . i ! lI t " r . , : ,1

    " , : i ' l ; , r ' [ r r l \1. \ r r . l - . r ) / ! . r ' ] l r ' l

  • 20

    2I

    222)

    21

    25

    2i

    l0

    I artjia, A,ttut.taeoEnkki ttubk$i thlkMskort&lotha Srttiil l'nstillb .hr,rl l,/ .r, Srpskakrulielskr rkr.lemii,, BelsBJe, 1902. pp 22 r7Lt Pahi,\,1. Btl.ttht.t,., raortu?l\. h,,tui.t. A ailln,

    ar\iia, Ld Ph"^r l. Bakd".1rt,pp l1r llji alijia.tulkorb p.lhntu, Ztw,l zA uJtbenikr i.?s,vn,icd$v., BrlstuJt, 1991, p 126T St.iano\ i.h, !/1tu, !7,116 thtFtur,JLti!,/,pc, Mt Sh.rpc lrrc,NN York.199,1' lbdofovr,rp. I 20, l6 l 81.Ottomn hvs h,.1 very dednne rules3b.ui cldhins.Nhich enphAird rh. symbolisD .f nnoun ddlisious afliliarion. See D Quarefar. Clorhins l-a\!s,St.re andSocEty in theOi ioman |mp,.e.1720 1829.t,t dlotrt la,u,t .l M1.Ub Lrn tal..s. r. 29,l9r)7.pp .l0l I12r M lid. Dress Co{les in rhe Ottoma. EmFift The C,se ot the lrm.s, i. S l,n)qhi& C( N.uma.. lc.ls), a)rn ,r,, t (ii"n.\ F nnlaxtil. ta ldc,tn\ Et.n,lst^nbtLl, 20!,1, pp l(),]-21.and r\ I.tii. Lmedr!,alona injesole ffmene'. i,lA l.tX \e.l ). Pinrx tnt r ttp\kn, knrd,tr,.\t;l\nol.t,.A d.ba. al1o, tsrlllrdc,200t, pp. a',1 70lor the odhodor Church rcforn, rnd risurl.ulture iDth si xreenth rn d nineten dr .en Mies. see Pctkovia idd Makuljevia. lhe ZoEnph Modelofofrhodox

    Ior ge.sr,th], a.d 3rt, see Th.mA D3C.{a(aulnrn. I,,,rl / c.,.,{'rh ,//r, Univdsnr oiChic.Ao lles, Chicaso, lL. 200.1.N Ntrkuljevii. Vtuelo3 kutuD i pnlatni LlenntetprAosll\nih hiia2nr u 1lr veku

    . in lotia, P,url

    R SmrJtii Bdcd{lc u i,cJiunfoJnoj rs.vnii lvll XVll \eLr', in R SxDarJiia. ItoiTt B.ortrh. $L r,SANU I,rosve(r,Llclrnd.. l.rtr.pp.12t-62.NI Jova.ovia. t?r/., /,r,1. ,,r.r,1i1.( ,(t , XVl l IukL zbunk F;l...fi|or lrInt tu l,rl l. Iil(,zofikif rkul t . ( . tsclr dc, 1961,pp.179- i t r9.R DanLo* & R lhie. /i,14, q'.Lbi n Albni ot,lAlrcot Rqlott (Kotat, mott.".rtu, Qhil). Brll.Leiden. Bo{on a.d C.bg.e, 2000, p 209SrtC (l,ndNin, r{ lt:v,n.y' Otu,mn Afindrt,Thn* & l ]u. ly,n, Lo.don,19i l . pp. l l l 1.1 rnd

    Fnm ltleology to U ,-ct'al Pritdpfu\ 101

    AGiljtetdins,P,kq"tt ra |].ft,t ,ft B.i"r i ttdtui\l'ri. Veselin NIsneir,Srrijev.,1972, tp 10.1 t.

    I I Thr bd t\mpL Gon t|t lvtdJlc As\ ir thc durchofthc ScLbian nr...n.L! ofDei.nid (osoro, buihbi_ the l finc$D triaf Vna in 1rl.l It SeeBftdii&NI aanrk \te.lia. Il,d di D.t,t Muzciu PrinnriNinehosync Mrndin Vnoki Dcimi. BclgfuJc, 200t.

    t2 A AnJrcje)ii, ALltt Dtl,trfu bii, lfftnrt z.isroriju Lnetroni. ldgude. 1972, pp 17 60.

    ll V Sr irrcria, I'rlir:i e ,ir, tiit Etoii."ratud anl"id, P.h,tr' txtxrk".tn*nd a inoriiuunret.oni.Belgf.de, l97r,pp. 162-t.

    l4 See A Sverierd, .:4,/.,r /,uu dolati i ni r.It l..L,r,,In*nut a lolklu MrrkoCepe.k.!',

    r5 Dilkft.t kinds ol mrble. ur .f sold $d silvei,.11r i.h culutu ofie{il.s Jcfincd th.l6ks oId.hitdrrl bril.linss dnd

    'hc clLinots of tlr

    i.reior decoration ofdifferent srte. feliAious mdprira.eobjec* See \ NiakuliAia. Viuuelnrkulturr'.

    t6 \ H^n,],ttt4n tu pa,ltuli, Peak? I'nririik, M^r\.ls$skr, No\ iSrd.1966, pp r l 108.

    19 lorOttoman Raroqle, seeGoodw., pp.:r8l -121r

    md U leker '\reier. Induncer .n the On.manEnpircd.dO.. cotJiin i. drcAr.hncduieoftst^nbol, l ltrhtee" th-C."1,a t ift, !o1. 26, no. :,, 2002.

    t0 For ihe (i,loured iU{xque i. Tct,!o, see I ZJ vkolia.Izb.t zulk zt pto,idrd,r. \ po,t.

    "

    tkta ilab l. ttblr.li,r,.l,!oJr,rt,.luFoslovcnski i.$nut za zritnu

    , spoDcnih kult!r.. tsL:lgodc, l9d. pp.96 r.,41 N Makulicvia. Icon Panrins ofthe Vrinj Epar.hy

    132G1910.in M Timoljerc & N Makulrelt,lp.roN V ,ritu qrrh|, K{eda za isoiju ubdndti.ovoe l(ka !-ilozofsLos tululeta-Epdhijr vnnisLr.lelrrade drd Vfanje.200t, p :r2

    .12 See \XJT Mnche!1, 'Show,ns Seei.g ACftiqueoiVnualCuhure. in M Holly & K Morev (eds),,4rlll1n.a Arihrti\ UnullhtlM, Sterling & Ira.cine(:hrk ,{rt In*nure. \(illian{oun, NI4,2m2,