N 286 - Rochester Institute of...
20
ISO/TC 130/WG 13 N 286 ISO/TC 130/WG 13 Printing conformity assessment requirements Email of secretary: [email protected] Convenorship: ANSI (United States) WG13 Standards - A New Vision v4 Replaces: N 270 Document type: Other committee document Date of document: 2015-10-29 Expected action: INFO Background: Committee URL: http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/open/tc130wg13
Transcript of N 286 - Rochester Institute of...
ISO/TC 130/WG 13 N 286
ISO/TC 130/WG 13Printing conformity assessment requirements
Email of secretary: [email protected] Convenorship: ANSI (United States)
WG13 Standards - A New Vision v4
Replaces: N 270
Document type: Other committee document
Date of document: 2015-10-29
Expected action: INFO
Background:
Committee URL: http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/open/tc130wg13
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
WG13 Standards, a New Vision
R. Chung, Professor (v3f) ISO/TC130/WG13 10th Meeting, Seoul, Korea, November 4, 2015
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
WG13 Goal and Scope
ISO/TC130/N1744 (2010-11-10)
The goal of WG13 is to harmonize worldwide certification activities within Graphic Technology.
The Working Group is aimed at developing guidelines for printing quality management system that cover – Technical aspects of the certification criteria – Quality system aspects of the certification criteria
2
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
WG13 Goal and Scope
WG13 Bologna meeting (Italy, 2015) – WG13 is aimed at developing conformity assessment guidelines
applicable for the evaluation of quality of production printing and the evaluation of colour quality management system.
3
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO/IEC 17007 (2009)
Conformity assessment — Guidance for drafting normative documents suitable for use for conformity assessment – Overview of conformity assessment activities
4
ISO 16761-1 ISO 16761-2
ISO 19301
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
How Are We Doing, So Far?
2015 WG13 membership survey (WG13 N260) – Most respondents understand the ISO process and the
relationship between technical standards and conformity assessment requirements.
– Majority (56%) agrees that WG13 standards should specify guidelines or requirements for printing conformity assessment activities in order to enable all scheme developers.
There are rooms for better alignment among the WG13 standards.
5
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
How Are We Doing, So Far?
ISO 16761 (part 1 and 2) are developing workflow and product conformity assessment schemes for the commercial printing industry and the packaging printing industry. – These two standards overlap in color printing workflows and tone
and color reproduction conformity assessment requirements. – The packaging printing conformity assessment scheme includes
supply chain responsibilities and printing process specific checklists.
Question: “Should ISO 16761 be developed as a “ready-to-use” scheme to compete with other schemes in the market?”
6
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
How Are We Doing, So Far?
ISO 19301, based on the BPiF scheme, is developing a color quality management certification scheme, including a product conformity scheme and a sector-specific ISO 9001 scheme. – The current product conformity scheme references to ISO 12647
series of standards.
– The colour quality management system certification scheme references to ISO 9001 standard.
– Question: “Should ISO 19301 be developed to have its own product quality requirements? What if it’s in conflict with ISO 16761-1?”
7
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
Conformity Assessment Principles
There should be a separation between technical standards containing product conformity requirements and technical guidelines containing conformity assessment activities requirements. – WG3 should develop technical standards. – WG13 should develop conformity assessment activities requirements.
WG13 documents, per ISO/IEC 17007, should be organized by conformity assessment activities, i.e., certification of printed products, certification of color quality management system, and supplier’s declaration of conformity.
8
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-1 Title
(Current) • Graphic Technology
— Printing workflow definition, requirements and testing conditions — Part 1: Commercial printing
(Proposed) Graphic Technology
— Printing workflow definition, tone and colour reproduction conformity requirements and testing conditions
9
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-1 Scope
(Current) This standard defines CMYK
and CMYK+spot commercial printing workflows, their requirements and testing conditions for the evaluation of their conformance with the appropriate international standards.
(Proposed) This standard specifies
common guidelines for the establishment of schemes to evaluate tone and color reproduction requirements for printing processes which are based on individual International or national standards.
10
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-1 Intro (Proposed)
The aim of this International Standard is to harmonize on a global level the tone and color reproduction conformity assessment requirements of all printed products.
This International Standard, aligned with ISO/IEC 17007 and other WG13 standards, enables certification bodies and scheme owners to develop conformity assessment requirements and certification schemes.
While this International Standard is not a “ready-to-use” scheme, individual organizations are free to choose appropriate methods to fulfill the requirements of this International Standard.
11
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-2 Title
(Current) • Graphic Technology
— Printing workflow definition, requirements and testing conditions — Part 2: Packaging printing
(Proposed) Graphic Technology
— Packaging printing conformity requirements and testing conditions
12
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-2 Scope
(Current) This standard defines CMYK
and CMYK and spot, spot only and multicolor packaging printing workflows, their specific requirements and testing conditions for the evaluation of their conformance with the appropriate international standards.
(Proposed) This standard specifies
requirements applicable to the development of conformity assessment schemes, including supply chain communication requirements, for the evaluation of packaging and label printing quality.
13
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 16761-2 Intro (Proposed)
The aim of this International Standard is to harmonize on a global level the conformity assessment requirements for packaging and label printing product quality.
This International Standard, aligned with ISO/IEC 17007 and other WG13 standards, enables certification bodies and scheme owners to develop conformity assessment requirements and certification schemes.
While this International Standard is not a “ready-to-use” scheme, individual organizations are free to choose appropriate methods to fulfill the requirements of this International Standard.
14
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 19301 Title
(Current) Colour quality
management certification scheme
(Proposed) Graphic Technology
— Guidelines for developing colour quality management system conformity assessment and certification schemes
15
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 19301 Scope
(Current) The scheme aims to ensure that a
Colour Quality and Production Management System functions effectively within any organisation certified under this scheme to an international colour quality standard. Such standards include the ISO 12647 series of standards and other colour quality standards as may be published by ISO from time to time.
(Proposed) This International Standard
specifies conformity assessment requirements for a colour quality management system where an organization needs to demonstrate its ability to ensure sustained production management performance and to seek certification of its colour quality management system by a certification body or make self-declaration of conformity to this International Standard.
16
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
ISO 19301 Intro (Proposed)
The aim of this International Standard is to harmonize on a global level the conformity assessment requirements for colour quality management systems.
This International Standard integrates the principles of SMART...
This International Standard, aligned with ISO/IEC 17007 and other WG13 standards, enables certification bodies and scheme owners to develop conformity assessment requirements and certification schemes.
While this International Standard is not a “ready-to-use” scheme, individual organizations are free to choose appropriate methods to fulfill the requirements of this International Standard.
17
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
Discussions
Can we agree on the following principles? – WG13 is aimed at enabling conformity assessment activities by
developing printing conformity assessment and certification guidelines for the printing industry stakeholders, including certification bodies, scheme developers, and auditors.
– WG13 documents, per ISO/IEC 17007, should be organized by conformity assessment activities, i.e., - ISO 16761-1 specifies tone and color reproduction conformity
requirements - ISO 16761-2 specifies packaging and label printing conformity
requirements, and - ISO 19301 specifies color quality management system conformity
requirements and supplier’s declaration of product quality.
18
Copyright 2015 RIT – May not be reproduced without permission
Discussions
How much efforts are required to make the mid-course correction?
Should WG13 documents be IS, TS or TR?
Others?
19
