N 123-60530S-3825a: T. O. 1 STRESS WAVE PROPAGATION...used to record dynamic photoelastic stress...

38

Transcript of N 123-60530S-3825a: T. O. 1 STRESS WAVE PROPAGATION...used to record dynamic photoelastic stress...

  • N 123-60530S-3825a: T. O. 1 Galcit 90

    SOME EXPLORATORY PHOTOELASTIC STUDIES IN

    STRESS WAVE PROPAGATION

    by

    M. L. Williams M. E. Jessey R. R. Parmerter

    October 1958

    This research was supported by the United States Bureau of Ordnance, through the Naval Ordnance Test Station, China Lake, California, Dr. John Pearson, Project Engineer.

    Guggenheim Aeronautical Laboratory

    California Institute of Technology

    Pasadena, California

  • SOME EXPLORATORY PHOTOELASTIC STUDIES IN

    STRESS WAVE PROPAGATION

    * M. L. Williams M. E. Jessey R. R. Parmerter

    SUMMARY

    During the last three years the Guggenheim Aeronautical Laboratory of the California Institute of Technology (GALCIT) has been conducting a photo-elastic study of stress wave propagation in solids using a high speed framing camera.

    This paper presents a technical description of the camera, now operating at 100, 000 35 mm frames per second at one tenth microsecond exposure time for an elapsed time of approximately two milliseconds. The design capability is expected to approach a half million frames per second. This equipment has been used to record dynamic photoelastic stress fringe patterns in various specimens under impact loadings. Typical experimental records of wave propagation in cracked plates, layered media, compressed bars and beams, and cross sections of rocket heads are included in this report.

    I. GENERAL DESCRIPTION

    In 1955, Sutton ( 1) as part of his doctorate thesis at the

    California Institute of Technology presented a series of dynamic photo-

    elastic fringe patterns in a rectangular plate under impact compression.

    To record the data he made use of a high speed framing camera devel-

    oped at the Institute by Ellis (Z) for cavitation studies.

    The unique feature used in this equipment was a repeatedly pulsed

    Kerr cell which operates as a shutter based upon an electrical rather than

    a mechanical time base. The principle of operation is essentially that if

    two parallel plates immersed in a closed container of nitrobenzene are

    charged, the fluid becomes optically birefringent until the charge is

    removed.

    *M. L. Williams, Associate Professor; M. E. Jessey, Research Engineer: R. R. Parmerter, Graduate Student, California Institute of Technology.

  • 2

    Having a fast shutter thus solves the first problem. Next one

    desires stationary film upon which to record the events, thus obviating

    the necessity for introducing mechanical motion. The Ellis design used

    a circular drum whose longitudinal axis coincided with the optical axis

    and was collinear with a shaft driven at high speed by an air turbine.

    The end of the shaft was tent- beveled with two 45 degree plane cuts, one

    of which was blackened and the other polished to a mirror finish. The

    image coming along the optical axis through the Kerr cell was thus

    turned at right angles by the mirror and flashed to the stationary film

    track. The shuttering of the cell coupled with the rotation of the mirror

    printed successive events on the film strip.

    Whereas some experimenters have used multiple light flashes,

    Ellis achieved satisfactory results using a two millisecond continuous

    flashtube light source which operated from the discharge of a bank·of

    capacitors.

    The last essential ingredient of the first design was a mechanism

    to synchronize the timing in order that the light was on and the camera

    recording while the desired event was occurring. Ellis solved this

    problem by combining a time delay and duration timer.

    Upon observing Sutton's results which were not directed toward

    studies of stress wave propagation per se, it appeared that the experi-

    mental set up could be adapted to investigate stress waves in various

    geometries of engineering interest as a primary objective. Accordingly

    a second camera assembly has been built incorporating several state of

    the art improvements and modifications on the basis of experimental

    convenience and solely dynamic photoelastic objectives.

    The main features were {l) reasonably high framing rates, of

    the order of a half million frames per second, (2) relatively larger

    optical field to study larger models, (3) long enough time history of the

    events to permit studies of wave reflection and refraction phenomena in

    models with low characteristic velocities, (4) a precise start-stop and

    timing control, and (5) a reliable, safe, and simply operated design.

    The preceding requirements necessitated some changes to the

    basic design. For example, the larger field introduced problems of light

  • 3

    intensity, already critical because it is necessary to have a very high

    film speed or emulsion sensitivity if it is to be activated in exposure

    times of 50-100 millimicroseconds. A ten inch diameter field has been

    attained by using larger collector lens, opening the gap on the Kerr

    cell plates at the expense of increasing the operating voltage to 20, 000

    volts, using only one 45 degree planar mirror cut on the turbine shaft -

    thus requiring more careful dynamic balance detail design, and

    increasing the diameter of the film drum. While 35 mm pictures are

    presently being recorded at 100, 000 frames per second, the turbine is

    being run at less than half the rated speed and hence 200, 000 frames

    per second seems assured. At the expense of reducing the image size

    to 16 mm, provisions have been made for printing twice as many

    pictures, at the same exposure time, thus again effectively doubling

    the framing rate. These last two items have not been demonstrated in

    practice however as it has been the experimental philosophy to

    increase the turbine speed slowly - and as required for the specimens

    under consideration - so as not to come upon a critical vibration speed

    unexpectedly.

    A magnetic pickup senses the passage of a 128 toothed gear

    mounted on the turbine shaft. Each passage generates a pulse which is

    amplified and formed into a rectangular shape which activates the Kerr

    cell. Exactly 128 pulses are guaranteed by passing the pulses through

    a counter containing a gate circuit which closes after the 128 pulses

    have passed. Overprinting on the film track is thus prevented.

    In over fifty runs on the equipment, there have been two failures

    to operate, one due to a burnt out flash tube and one due to a faulty

    trigger circuit on the load application mechanism for the model.

    II. DETAIL DESCRIPTION

    The camera design was broken down into eight major components

    as indicated on the block diagram (Figure 1) by appropriate dash numbers:

    1 Camera Assembly

    2 Kerr Cell

    3 Photoelastic Bench

    4 Control Chassis

  • 4

    5 Pulse Power Amplifier

    6 Light Source

    7 Initiator Circuit

    8 Input Power Control Unit

    A isometric drawing of the physical layout is shown in Figure 2.

    - 1: Camera Assembly. A schematic drawing of the assembly

    is shown in Figure 3. Its main function is to provide a light tight housing

    for the pulsed images which have passed through the Kerr cell. After

    the images are focused through appropriate lens (Bausch and Lomb,

    Baltar, 100 mm, f/ 2. 3) they are reflected through ninety degrees by the

    rotating mirror and onto the stationary film track. In Figure 3, most

    of the necessary items are shown including the general design of the

    mirror itself. Whereas in the earlier Ellis design V-wedge mirror

    planes were used, one single plane at forty-five degrees to the turbine

    axis was employed. In this manner more light was gathered but the

    turbine shaft was unbalanced. A fish-mouthed sleeve with a circular

    hole for light passage was therefore designed in order to provide the

    necessary dynamic balance. A critical speed calculation, assuming

    clamped bearings, carried out in the Analysis Laboratory using the

    analog computer indicated that the first or lowest critical bending

    frequency would be at approximately 120, 000 rpm.

    Located behind the mirror assembly is the timing wheel. As

    each of its 128 teeth pass the magnetic pickup - the miniature model

    produced by Electro Product Laboratories - a voltage signal is generated.

    A typical signal record is shown on the oscilloscope record (Figure 4a).

    While it may be remarked that the record has marked deviation in peak

    outputs as well as a general overall oscillatory character, the control

    chassis will accept and easily distinguish voltage signals from 10

    millivolts to 10 volts. Such four decade sensitivity has proven more

    than adequate.

    The images reflected from the mirror fall upon the film track,

    wherein the film lies stationary during a run. The Tri-X or Ilford 35

    mm high sensitivity film with a rated speed of 200-400 ASA is stored in

    100 foot rolls in a manually, or optionally a motor driven, operated

  • 5

    Mitchell camera magazine. The sprocket assembly from a Cunningham

    Combat Camera was modified to feed the film into the film track. After

    some experimentation it was found satisfactory to push the film through.

    Considering that there was nearly 10 feet to feed, the success of this

    operation seemed to hinge upon holding the film track dimensions and

    not permitting local buckling of the strip. After the initial 10 feet was

    loaded, the cranks on the Mitchell film holder of course permitted the

    remainder of the roll to be pulled through without difficulty.

    As will be observed on Figure 3, a prism was installed on the

    front plate to permit focusing the image. The dimensions are adjustable

    on the adapter so that the light path to the film track and to the frosted

    glass on the adapter were the same. It was also found convenient to

    design the adapter to accomodate a 35 mm single frame Leica camera

    to record trial runs to check light intensity without exposing, and

    developing, a complete 10 foot film strip.

    As shown in the photograph (Figure 5) the entire camera

    assembly was rigidly constructed of metal, except the front plate which

    was made of plywood to minimize the weight, and was mounted on three

    adjustable legs to provide levelling and height adjustment.

    - 2: Kerr Cell. This component (Figure 6) was fabricated in

    the Chemistry Department and operated as designed. It is not a new

    development( 3 ) and its principle of operation is described in most text-

    books in physics. Certain substances become birefringent when they

    are placed in an electric field. This is the well known "Kerr effect".

    The birefringence is proportional to the strength of the electric field,

    and thus, for a given geometry, to the applied voltage. By appropriate

    choice of voltage, the cell can be made to act as a half-wave plate, and

    will rotate the plane of polarization of the light through 90°, provided

    the plane of polarization of the incident light is 45° to the principle

    optical axis of the cell.

    The light from the photoelastic set up is therefore polarized at

    45° to the principle axis of the Kerr cell. It passes through the cell

    and is blocked by a polaroid which is oriented at 90° to the plane of

    polarization of the light (In Figure 7, the top of this polaroid is just

  • 6

    visible behind the mounting block). However, when the Kerr cell is

    pulsed, the light is rotated 90° in the cell, and is able to pass through

    this polaroid.

    The device thus acts as a shutter, with a speed which is deter-

    mined by the length of the applied pulse and the relaxation time of the

    nitrobenzene. As the relaxation time is many orders of magnitude less

    than the currently used 10-7

    second pulse, it has no effect in our case.

    At the other extreme, if the cell is open too long - many orders more

    than in this design - a lower limit of operation is reached at which the

    nitrobenzene boils due to the applied voltage and causes optical

    distortion of the transmitted image.

    The 128 signals per revolution which are sensed by the magnetic

    pickup from the timing disk, are chopped, formed, amplified, and

    ultimately applied to the Kerr cell. Thus the time between the one tenth

    microsecond pulses is determined by the turbine speed alone, and is

    always in precise syncronization with the rotating image so that

    uniformly spaced frames, without overlap, are obtained.

    Besides polarizing the light when the voltage is imposed, the cell

    has the additional feature of filtering the white light source to the extent

    of giving nearly monochromatic light without the necessity of introducing

    additional filters which would of course reduce the already marginal

    light intensity.

    It might also be mentioned that while the liquid is sealed within

    the cell, nitrobenzene is somewhat toxic and consequently the experiments

    are conducted in a ventilated room.

    - 3: Photoelastic Bench. The optical system (Figure 9) is

    standard and self-explanatory except that the lens used are not believed

    optimum for the set up. They are mainly GALCIT equipment from stock

    and it is anticipated that improvements can be made by designing new

    items for this application. The present system has, however, operated

    satisfactorily, and the question is merely one of potential improvement.

    When the light source is fired, it remains lit for approximately

    two milliseconds, the middle portion of which is essentially flat. The

    light is collected by a 10 inch lens and a non-parallel beam passes through

  • 7

    the model area. Quarter plates are used to give circularly polarized

    light. The converging beam is passed through another lens and quarter

    plate and thence into the Kerr cell, through the Kerr cell polarizer, and

    into the camera.

    Through the tests to date there has been no noticeable distortion

    of the image due to using converging light either through the model or

    the Kerr cell.

    In most of the tests conducted so far the drop rig, shown in

    Figure 9, was employed. While other loading devices are deemed more

    appropriate in further experimentation, the drop rig was the simplest

    with which to carry out the initial tests. A steel ball was restrained by

    a magnetically operated plunger at the top of a vertical tube. Upon its

    release downward to impact upon the specimen, it interrupted a photo-

    cell circuit which provided the input to an initiator circuit to be

    described presently. Other loading mechanisms would likewise provide

    an initial signal to trigger subsequent action.

    4: Control Chassis. Returning to the magnetic signal picked

    off the timing disk, it is fed into the control chassis (Figure 1) to be

    amplified and formed into a rectangular pulse on its way toward the Kerr

    cell. From the original signal given in Figure 4a the resultant signal

    shown in Figure 4b is generated. Each pulse rises to an amplitude of

    10 volts and returns to zero in one microsecond. The rise time may be

    observed in the figure. After forming, the pulse, which is monitored by

    a Berkeley Universal Counter (Model 550 I) for the visual information of

    the experimenter, is fed into the gate circuit which, when triggered,

    passes into a seven stage binary strip. The binary count is displayed

    on the control panel (Figure 10) and runs through 128 counts - the number

    of teeth on the timing wheel. When the count is complete, the gate circuit

    closes, the pulses stop and the Kerr cell remains closed thus preventing

    overprinting inasmuch as the camera dimensions are such to provide 128

    * 35 mm pictures around the periphery •

    Actually four or five pictures at an indeterminant point during the run are lost due to the cut out for the film magazine and blanketing by the prism.

  • 8

    - 5: Pulse Power Amplifier. Inasmuch as the 10 volt signal

    from the control chassis is considerably less than that required to open

    the Kerr cell, it is amplified to approximately 20 kilovolts. With the

    exception of the 21 kilovolt, 1. 5 Mfd capacitors and the Solar regulating

    transformer, all components were GALCIT designed and represented a

    significant amount of time devoted to electronics. The amplifier is

    separately controlled as a safety precaution. Its general layout and

    size may be observed in Figure 5 or Figure 10 where it lies to the left

    of the control panel.

    These signals then are those which open and close the Kerr cell

    electrical shutter for the camera.

    - 6: Light Source. The light source is another important

    component inasmuch as a critical problem in high speed photography is

    a proper matching of light intensity and film speed. Following Ellis'

    experience, a xenon-filled General Electric Model FT 524 Flash tube

    rated at 5 kilovolts, 250 Mfd was us ed. The power supply consisted of

    a bank of 10 kilovolt, 25 Mfd capacitors; when the design voltage of

    5000 was reached, the light, coordinated with the drop rig photocell

    signal by appropriate time delay units, was fired.

    A photograph of the unit (Figure 11) shows the coiled nature of

    the flashtube geometry which did not give uniform intensity and led to

    streaks on some of the resulting pictures. At the expense of losing

    light a frosted glass was inserted between the source and the collector

    lens in later tests to provide diffused light.

    The spectral distribution of intensity for the source is given in

    Figure 12 and is seen to be relatively flat over the light sensitivity band

    of the film. The life of the flash tube for this type operation seems to

    be in the vicinity of 100 firings when operated intermittently at voltage

    dis charges of 5000 volts and below. The light will not fire if the voltage

    is lower than 2000 volts.

    - 7: Initiator Circuit. The photocell circuit (Figure 1) is a

    standard GALCIT item and has been used successfully for several years.

    One unusual feature incorporated into the drop rig pick up (Figure 9) is

    the relatively small light source used. Its focal point is interrupted by

    the ball to trigger the circuit. In the first tests two pickups four inches

  • 9

    apart were used and the velocity of the one inch diameter 0. 15 lb. steel

    ball at impact was determined to be 155 inches per second.

    - 8: Input Power Control Unit. The last major component of

    the camera is the power routing control. The entire system operates

    from 120 volt AC, 60 cycle; power is routed to the various individual

    power supplies, Berkeley counter, and auxiliary equipment by

    appropriate cables.

    Generally speaking, with the exception of the separate safety

    control on the pulse power amplifier, all controls are centralized in

    the control panel (Figure 10) which contains the time delay units, light

    source and initiator triggers, the counter, turbine speed control and

    lubrication indicator, and auxiliary power. This arrangement has

    considerably simplified checkout prior to testing as well as permitting

    direct control during experiments.

    III. PRELIMINARY RESULTS

    The camera has been used over the last few months to perform

    a number of exploratory experiments. The specimens tested have been

    made from one of the standard photoelastic plastics, CR- 39(4

    ). When

    this plastic is loaded and ¥iewed in circularly polarized light through a

    quarter-wave plate and polaroid, light and dark lines or fringes appear.

    For CR- 39 subjected to dynamic loading, a given fringe is a line of

    constant difference in principal strain(Z), which itself is proportional to

    the maximum shearing strain. In order to determine the complete stress

    field as a function of time, further measurements and analysis of the

    data is necessary. Our program however has attempted to obtain

    qualitative data for a number of problems, the most interesting of which

    are to be discussed.

    A drop rig (Figure 9) was chosen as the simplest method of

    applying a dynamic load in these tests. AO. 15 lb. steel ball is held at

    the top of a 41 inch tube by a solenoid. Closing the circuit to the solenoid

    releases the ball, which falls freely down the tube and strikes the speci-

    men at 155 inches per second. The ball trips a photocell, which is

    located just above the specimen, and this signal opens the gate circuit to

    the Kerr cell amplifier after a suitable time delay.

  • 10

    Two fields of view have been used, a 2 1I2 inch diameter field

    and a 10 inch diameter field. The 2 1/ 2 inch field provides higher

    resolution of fringes, while the 10 inch field allows a longer time to

    observe the fringes without interference from the reflection of the stress

    wave by the boundary. All pictures included are 35 mm and have been

    taken at 70, 000 or 100, 000 frames per second.

    Fracture

    Because of the interest at GALCIT in fracture and stress distri-

    butions at the point of a crack, it was of interest to see if the dynamic

    fringe pattern was similar to the static one, predicted by theoretical

    analysis(S)• as well as to compare it with the data obtained by Wells

    and Post(6), using individual spark photographs. For this reason a

    1. 2 x 2. 5 inch rectangular specimen 1I4 inch thick was prepared. A

    small slot 1/ 4 inch deep and ten thousandth of an inch wide was cut in

    the top to accommodate a Shick razor blade, chosen for its low aspect

    ratio and consequent rigidity (Figure 13). The blade protruded

    approximately 1/ 16 inch over the top of the specimen and was contacted

    by the falling steel ball. Figure 13 shows interesting sections of the

    complete record obtained.

    First of all it is observed that as the force introduced by the ball

    is transmitted to the specimen, the stress gradually builds up without

    any immediate fracture. Furthermore the gross appearance of the

    fringe pattern possesses the characteristic "bug-eye" appearance

    predicted for the static case(S) (Figure 14), spoiled somewhat of course

    in sharpness because the width of the crack is actually finite, and hence

    the vertex is rounded. With time the load builds up as indicated by the

    increasing number of fringes until at about the third or fourth picture

    (separated timewise by 14. 5 /.). seconds) the ultimate load is reached

    and the crack appears to accelerate. The time of running is affected by

    many factors of course, not the least of which are the generally compres-

    sive nature of the stress field, the local stress condition after machining,

    and the interference of reflected waves which take approximately 20

    microseconds to cross the specimen.

  • 11

    The first clear indication of the propagation may be noted on

    the ninth frame after contact where the gross "bug-eyes" have given

    way to an elliptic-like shape. This qualitative characteristic pattern

    predicted statically (Figure 14) may be associated with an antisymmetric

    stress field due to the blade not being precisely centered in the slot and

    hence contributing a high localized shear stress. In the eleventh frame

    the "bug-eyes 11 are beautifully reestablished at the crack front and

    carry very plainly through six frames until the crack breaks through

    and the stress field unloads completely in the latter frames of the

    second row.

    Returning to the first frame for a moment it will be noted that

    the ball emerging from the tube is pressing upon the razor blade.

    Beginning in the third row, where several frames are missing as may

    be noted by the coded numbers on the film strip, the ball has now pushed

    the blade into the plastic and has itself contacted the specimen. Due to

    a slight antisymmetry the dynamic Boussinesq fringes are not perfectly

    paired, although the second frame is coincidentally remarkably

    continuous across the crack (as it should be because the fringe value or

    shear is zero at the crack). These latter frames are included to give a

    striking visual illustration of the complex interaction to be expected

    when the waves have time to reflect from free and fixed boundaries.

    Before making any semi-quantitative deductions at all from the

    strips, consider the next specimen, shown in Figure 15. In contrast to

    the previous case where the crack was loaded, an experiment was tried

    wherein a similar specimen was inverted and simply supported with the

    crack on the bottom. It was then impacted on the top as indicated in the

    figure with the resulting 100, 000 frames per second fringe pattern as

    shown. (The striations observed, as mentioned earlier, are due to the

    undiffused helical light source.) Reading from the top left down, the

    characteristic Boussinesq pattern is exhibited. As it progresses to the

    supports and across the bar sensing the presence of the crack, a

    reflected signal observable at strip number 38 and firmly established at

    39 indicates the crack progressing toward the load. While the pattern

    is complex it appears that the crack accelerated too quickly for the

    quasi-static "bug-eyes" to appear before complete fracture.

  • 12

    In order to explore this point a bit further, a crack front

    position vs. time plot was prepared based upon reading the film strip

    in an enlarger and gave the data shown in Figure 16. It is immediately

    noticed that for this geometry, the loaded crack reached a maximum

    speed only half that of the unloaded crack. It is interesting to observe

    the very rapid acceleration in the latter case and the quantitative value

    of the propagation - 17, 700 inches per second. If one uses Clark's

    value(4

    ) of the sound velocity, viz. 60, 000 inches per second, the

    propagation speed can not be less than 30 per cent of the sound velocity,

    or approximately 50 per cent of the shear velocity.

    Considering the qualitative nature of this experiment, the values

    are in reasonably close agreement with Wells and Post's, although the

    records seem to indicate that the acceleration - for the unloaded crack -

    was a bit more rapid than their case which would tend a bit more toward

    their theoretical expectations.

    Layered Media

    Another set of experiments pertained to layered media. Such

    geometries are of fairly wide concern in aeronautics, civil engineering

    and atomic warfare. Generally theoretical treatment is difficult if not

    impractical, but the initial tests indicated that two-dimensional tests at

    least could be conducted simply with quantitative interpretation. In

    Figure 17, the same drop rig has been used to apply a load to a

    rectangular specimen of CR- 39 which was separated into two pieces

    separated by a section of electrical tape having of course a different

    modulus. It was desired to examine the feasibility of recording wave

    transmission phenomenon such as is illustrated in the figure. To add

    a bit of additional practical interest, a circular hole was cut in the

    lower piece of CR- 39 and consequently the results show not only a

    transmission delay but also the pas sage of the transmitted wave

    around the inclusion giving rise to a dynamic stress concentration

    factor. The stress pattern is quite symmetrical with the expected

    clover-leaf pattern very apparent. Inspection of the film strip in an en-

    larger indicates that quantitative analysis is perfectly feasible. Hence

    the effect of parametric changes in materials, relative thicknesses and

    changes in the shape of the inclusion can be evaluated without undue

    difficulty.

  • 13

    Simulated Head Studies

    The third set of tests to be described relates to the impact of

    ogive type specimens with variable head angles. Figure 18 shows a

    set of data using the drop rig and a 70, 000 framing rate which was

    among the earliest records obtained. Here a qualitative idea of the

    cone angle magnitude was desired for which the wave front remained

    essentially planar. In the limit for very small included angles or

    wedges, one would normally treat the problem theoretically as a

    * one-dimensional wave by simply replacing.:_ dC by.:! • From the records it appears the one-dimensional assumption be-

    comes increasingly accurate for included wedge angles less than 60 degrees.

    Following up the wedge tests, another series was run at 70, 000

    frames per second for a 90 degree included angle with a rectangular "after-

    body" (Figure 19) which was used to compare with the same geometry

    except it was notched symmetrically (Figure 20). The constricting effect

    of the notch is quite evident by simply comparing the fringe density in the

    upper and lower sections. While data interpretation in the vicinity of the

    corners would be difficult more generous fillets in this region would

    permit straightforward quantitative analysis inasmuch as the fringe

    patterns are satisfactorily distinct.

    For the final test in this set, the previous specimen was again

    used except the central part was removed to simulate the cross section

    of a rocket head (Figure 21 ), although it hardly need be remarked that

    the wall thickness is relatively oversize. Again the steel ball was

    dropped on the point of the head and the resulting fringe pattern observed.

    The separation and diffusion of the load down the two legs of the "tuning-

    fork" in a most symmetric fashion is easily observed. Moreover the

    skew wave front indicates the bending or flexural character of the wave

    transmission which proceeds through the length of the specimen in very

    close to the 50 microseconds expected. A fracture occurs at about the

    fifth frame and the propagating crack runs into the reflected stress field

    from the maximum stress point at the radius of the inside ogive contour.

    Fracture is complete by the ninth frame and in all the subsequent pictures

    the two legs are behaving as two independent bodies.

    *While ·it is to be emphasized that the fringes are not necessarily dilitational - actually they are maximum shear strain lines, considerations of symmetry and boundary conditions usually permit proper interpretation without additional data such as the dynamic isoclinics . This point deserves careful consideration for quantitative analysis however.

  • 14

    IV. CONCLUSIONS

    In reviewing the program, it is believed that the exploratory

    studies have established that the camera design is satisfactory to

    achieve quantitative dynamic design data for a considerable number

    of engineering problems.

    It is, of course, obvious that there are places where improve-

    ments can be made, most particularly in the optical system where it

    is known that the optimum system has not been used. Furthermore, a

    more appropriate loading mechanism should be designed to simplify

    quantitative analysis; also certain state of the art improvements can

    be introduced in any research tool. In addition, certain advancements

    will be required in the theoretical area as well as in determining and

    interpreting material property data, especially if other than CR-39 is

    contemplated.

    Nevertheless it is the opinion of the authors that an important

    and convenient tool has been dem·onstrated for dynamic analysis. The

    proper quantitative exploitation remains.

    ACKNOWLEDGMENT

    The authors wish to acknowledge the able assistance of other

    present and former members of GALCIT who have contributed to this

    program. In particular the consultations with Prof. E. E. Sechler

    and the mechanical design work of Mr. A. E. Gaede has been

    especially helpful.

  • 15

    V. REFERENCES

    1. Sutton, G. W.: Study of the Application of Photoelasticity to the Investigation of Stress Waves. Thesis in Mechanical Engineering, California Institute of Technology, June 1955. See also an abbreviated version, A Photoelastic Stud of Strain Waves Caused by Cavitation. Journa of App ied Mechanics, ept. 19 no. 3, p 340.

    2. Ellis, A. T.: Observations on Cavitation Bubble Collapse, Thesis in Mechanical Engineering, California Institute of Technology, 1953.

    3. White, H. J.: The Technique of Kerr Cells, Review of Scientific Instruments, v. 6, 1935, pp 22-26. See also: Kingsbury, Rev. Sci. Instr., v. 1, 1930, p 22. Beams, Rev. Sci. Inst., v. 1, 1930, p 780. Dunnington, Phys. Rev., v. 38, 1931, p 1506.

    4. Clark, A. B. J.: Static and Dynamic Calibration of a Photoelastic Material, CR-39, Report 4779, Naval Research Laboratory, June 1956. See also Soc. Exp. Stress Analysis, vol. 14, n. 1, 1957, pp 195-204.

    5. Williams, M. L.: The Stress Distribution at the Base of a Stationary Crack, Journal of Applied Mechanics, March 1957.

    6. Wells, A. A. and Post, D.: The Dynamic Stress Distribution Surrounding a Runnin Crack - A Photoelastic Analysis, Report 4935, Nava R ...::search Laboratory, Apri 19 ee a so Soc. Exp. Stresd Analysis, vol. 12, n. 1, 1954, pp 99-116.

  • ,----

    ----

    -,

    I A

    MP

    LIF

    IER

    AN

    D

    I I

    30

    0V

    P

    ULS

    E F

    OR

    MIN

    G

    PO

    WE

    R

    I I

    NE

    TWO

    RK

    S

    UP

    PLY

    I

    --·-

    ---

    --I

    I ~~7 S

    TAG

    E

    BIN

    AR

    Y S

    TR

    IP

    I

    I I I I L

    2

    92

    -4

    :CO

    NT

    RO

    L

    CH

    AS

    SIS

    _J

    -----------

    ,---

    ----

    ---,

    I

    TIM

    E

    0-5

    KV

    C

    AP

    AC

    ITO

    R

    I I

    DE

    LAY

    PO

    WER

    B

    AN

    K

    UN

    T

    (IO

    eo. 6

    KV

    I

    I S

    UP

    PLY

    2

    5M

    FD

    ) I

    I p

    Q

    I TR

    IGG

    ER

    '1 L

    I C

    IRC

    UIT

    -

    L 2

    92

    -6:

    LIG

    HT

    SO

    UR

    CE

    _J

    I _

    __

    __

    __

    __

    __

    _J

    ,---

    ---

    1 ---

    q l 121

    CO

    MM

    ER

    CIA

    L IT

    EM

    "Q

    D

    ES

    IGN

    ED

    A

    T G

    ALG

    IT

    TIM

    E

    PH

    OT

    O-

    I D

    ELA

    Y

    GE

    LL

    I

    UN

    IT

    CIR

    CU

    IT

    I ~9

    2-7:

    INIT

    IAT

    OR

    CIR

    CU

    IT I

    __

    __

    __

    _ _

    _J

    BE

    RK

    ELE

    Y

    TIM

    E D

    ELA

    Y

    AU

    XIL

    IAR

    Y

    CO

    NT

    RO

    L L

    IGH

    T

    PU

    LS

    E

    PO

    WE

    R

    CO

    UN

    TER

    U

    NIT

    S

    EQ

    PT

    . C

    HA

    SS

    IS

    SO

    UR

    CE

    A

    MP

    LIF

    IER

    29

    2-8

    : IN

    PU

    T

    PO

    WE

    R

    CO

    NT

    RO

    L

    UN

    IT

    12

    0 V

    (A

    G),

    60

    CY

    CL

    E

    ,---

    ----

    ----

    -,

    I 2

    0K

    V P

    OW

    ER

    I

    I S

    UP

    PLY

    I

    I ~g;E

    vR SU

    P.

    11--

    --1

    I 2

    .5 K

    V,1

    .5 M

    FD

    1 I

    M

    AG

    NE

    TIC

    I

    : C

    AP

    AC

    ITO

    R

    1 I

    PIC

    KU

    P

    I

    I 1 I

    I A

    MP

    LIF

    IER

    CH

    AS

    SIS

    1 I

    I 1

    1

    I ~2

    -52U

    LSE~

    WER~

    MPLI

    F~ _

    _j _

    _J

    I I

    I I

    GU

    GG

    EN

    HE

    IM

    AE

    RO

    NA

    UT

    ICA

    L

    BLO

    CK

    D

    IAG

    RA

    M O

    F

    LA

    BO

    RA

    TO

    RY

    H

    IGH

    S

    PE

    ED

    PH

    OTO

    -

    CA

    LIF

    OR

    NIA

    IN

    ST

    ITU

    TE

    E

    LA

    ST

    IC

    CA

    ME

    RA

    OF

    T

    EC

    HN

    OL

    OG

    Y

    DR

    AW

    ING

    SE

    RIE

    S X

    -29

    2

    I L1

    I I I I I I 35m

    mr-:::

    I

    FIL

    M

    --H

    OU

    SIN

    G

    I D

    RU

    M

    I ~:.=.'._:GAMER~A-=-S~

    U.S

    . NA

    VA

    L O

    RD

    NA

    NC

    E

    TE

    ST

    ST

    AT

    ION

    TA

    SK

    OR

    DE

    R l,

    N 1

    23

    -60

    53

    0S

    ·

    38

    25

    A-

    GA

    LG

    IT 9

    0

    Fig

    ure

    1.

    Blo

    ck

    Dia

    gra

    m o

    f H

    igh

    Sp

    eed

    Ph

    oto

    ela

    stic

    Cam

    era

    Dra

    win

    g

    Seri

    es

    X-2

    92

    .

    ...... "'

  • P

    Po

    lari

    ze

    r

    QP

    Q

    ua

    rte

    r P

    late

    A

    An

    aly

    zer

    s S

    peci

    men

    p f/

    2.3

    A

    l _t1

    21)_*

    0 I/~

    Pu

    lse

    ... ;1

    f /

    1.9

    Gire

    ui t

    p~~

    -/0

    ''~,

    O

    P

    ,%

    Co

    nd

    en

    sin

    Lig

    ht

    Len

    s 9

    So

    urc

    e

    Lo

    ad

    T

    imin

    g C

    ircu

    it

    ::-..:::

    .:: .....

    ...... ...

    ....

    ;...-:;

    ,.-.....

    ..........

    ... '

    / '

    ' /;

    :'-fu

    rbi.n

    e A

    ir

    ',\

    //

    Hou

    sing

    '\Pressur~7'

    ' .

    I I

    , \

    \

    I /-

    -,<

    .:::

    :::

    I I

    / ,,

    c-.'

    '<

    I I

    ,'/M

    agne

    tic"

    ;'.-.

    . X

    }7 1

    1 : :

    I

    "kUp~1

    't ,,

    ,1

    I

    'Pie

    :· ·,

    uy-)

    1 ,_

    ,, 0

    ·11 ' ,

    I

    I ~·

    ,•

    ,.

    /I

    I \

    ' '-

    .>-

    -S

    up

    ply

    ,' ,

    ' \1

    /

    ','

    \ '_

    ...

    I I

    '\

    Film

    /:

    / ',

    ,, T

    racl

    ~:::: ...

    ''

    ,,,,,.,.

    ', .::-

    _, ---

    ___ _

    -...

    . __ -

    Fra

    me

    A

    sse

    mb

    ly

    Fig

    ure

    2.

    Sch

    em

    ati

    c L

    ay

    ou

    t o

    f th

    e C

    am

    era

    Ass

    em

    bly

    .

    ......

    --.I

  • ----Back Plate

    Turbine Assembly

    Magnetic Pickup,

    Ai research Turbine

    18

    Mitchell Camera Model 54 L

    Box With Cunningham Sprocket Assembly

    Prism For Focussing and Single Frame Recording.

    \Adopter For Mounting Leica Single Frame Camera . Frost Gloss and Cover Plate Not Shown .

    Front Plate

    °'"\ Lens Mount Kerr Cel I

    .------./ 1 t

    LL ens Assembly Bausch 8 Lomb Balter IOOmm, f/2 .3

    ..--+--1--- Fi Im Track

    Rubber Tubing Seal

    Typical of 8 Bolts Securing Front Plate. Note Front Plate Is Removable .

    Figure 3. Camera Assembly - Schematic .

  • 19

    Figure 4.

    a. Magnetic Pickup Output. b. Control Chas sis Output.

  • 20

    Figure 5, General View of Pulse Power Amplifier,

    Kerr Cell and Camera.

  • T

    15

    /161

    1 1

    u ..----~1

    I --

    ---

    -· ' -

    ----

    , I

    II

    I I

    .__

    I 1

    /16

    --1

    1

    I ~

    --

    --

    --

    ---i

    :

    I I

    I I

    I 0

    11

    I

    I I

    I

    I ~-

    ----

    ---.

    J:

    I I

    I

    Pyr

    ex

    Sto

    pp

    er

    to

    Se

    al

    Ce

    ll Pyre

    x

    ,...

    11/16~

    Nic

    kel

    Pla

    tes

    N 0

    TE

    : C

    e 11

    Fi 1

    1 e d

    to

    9

    5 °/o

    V

    o I u

    m e

    W

    ith

    N

    itro

    B

    en

    zen

    e

    (Ea

    stm

    an

    K

    od

    ak

    38

    7 )

    Fig

    ure

    6.

    Kerr

    Cell

    .

    Silv

    er

    So

    lde

    r

    N ,_.

  • 22

    Figure 7. Close up of Kerr Cell.

  • Fro

    sted

    G

    loss

    I011

    Dio

    . Pol

    aroi

    d

    22

    11F

    .L. f

    /2.2

    C

    onde

    nser

    Le

    ns' n

    I II

    2 i'2

    D

    ia. P

    ola

    roid

    Axi

    s 4

    5 °

    To K

    err

    Ce

    ll P

    late

    s

    Po

    laro

    id O

    rie

    nte

    d

    90

    ° To

    In

    cid

    en

    t L

    igh

    t

    Film

    T

    rac/ 1

    -ow

    --

    ----

    -:;i

    >=

    ---

    -,..

    . II

    -I

    II

    II I

    J'

    31

    1 f

    L. f /.

    75

    ,

    Con

    dens

    er ~e~

    u 10

    11 D

    ia. Quor~

    Wov

    e P

    late

    Cir

    culo

    rily

    Po

    lari

    zed

    Lig

    ht

    I II

    2 V2

    Dia

    . Qu

    art

    er

    Wov

    e P

    late

    1

    00

    mm

    . F

    L.

    I II

    2

    72 -

    --j

    I'::::

    f/2

    .3 L

    ens

    I ~

    23

    " i-

    -11

    " -~~------

    14

    011

    =

    :l

    Fig

    ure

    8.

    Ph

    oto

    ela

    stic

    Ben

    ch

    , 1

    011

    F

    ield

    .

    N

    VJ

  • 24

    ~ :-1

    :11

    Figure 9. General View at Drop Rig Showing Typical CR-39 Specimen

    in Place.

  • 25

    Figure 10. General View of the Camera, Amplifier and Control Panel.

    From Top to Bottom on the Panel: Two Delay Timers,

    Light Source Capacitor Control, Firing Panel, Counter,

    Turbine Control, Photo-cell Control.

  • 26

    Figure 11. Close up of the Light Source and Collector Lens.

  • 14

    0 --~~~---,,--~~~--.-~~~~~~~~~-.--~~~~-,.--~~~~~

    Xen

    on

    Fla

    shtu

    be

    ~

    0 ...

    10

    0 ~<

    l

    Blo

    ck

    Bod

    y S

    pe

    ctr

    um

    Fo

    r 7

    00

    0 °

    K

    Q) ~

    80

    Q) >

    -6

    0

    0 Q) er

    40

    20

    0 4

    00

    0

    50

    00

    To

    tal

    Lig

    ht

    Ou

    tpu

    t 3

    00

    0 W

    att

    -Se

    c.

    G.E

    . F

    lash

    tub

    e N

    o. F

    T 5

    24

    Re

    f: G

    en

    era

    l E

    lectr

    ic C

    o.

    60

    00

    Wov

    e le

    ng

    th -

    An

    gst

    rom

    s

    Fig

    ure

    12

    . S

    pectr

    al

    Dis

    trib

    uti

    on

    fo

    r th

    e F

    T 5

    24

    Fla

    sh

    Tu

    be.

    70

    00

    N

    ...J

  • SC

    HIC

    K

    RA

    ZO

    R ~----

    i" S

    TE

    EL

    BA

    LL

    B

    LA

    DE

    T

    r===

    =z=,

    0

    .15

    LB

    1.20

    " -l~o.010"

    155

    IN /

    SE

    C.

    _J_

    .__

    __

    _ ~

    MA

    TE

    RIA

    L,C

    R 3

    9

    FR

    AM

    ING

    RA

    TE

    1

    /4"

    TH

    ICK

    7

    0,0

    00

    FR

    AM

    ES

    /SE

    C.

    NO

    TE

    : S

    IX F

    RA

    ME

    S A

    RE

    MIS

    SIN

    G

    BE

    TW

    EE

    N

    24

    A A

    ND

    35

    A

    Fig

    ure

    1

    3.

    Dy

    nam

    ic S

    tress D

    istr

    ibu

    tio

    n f

    or

    a L

    oad

    ed

    Cra

    ck

    .

    Fra

    min

    g R

    ate

    70

    , 0

    00

    Fra

    mes p

    er

    Sec

    on

    d.

    N

    00

  • ~I o Crock 'O c:

    6 8 CD

    IX= Xo I

    2. 9

    y

    r

    x

    14 o - GEOMETRY

    Crock

    14 b- SYMMETRIC FRINGES

    Grae

    n"'r-1/2

    14 c -ANTI - SYMMETRIC FRINGES

    Figure 14. Static Isochromatic Fringe Patterns.

  • n II ,, {' (j {j {J ,, ,, ,~

    30

    {~~~~EL BALL 0 .15LB. 155 IN./SEC. T L2"

    o.010"--n:.10.2s " .l

    MATERIAL, CR 39 1/4" THICK

    FRAMING RATE

    100,000 FRAMES/SEC .

    Figure 15. Dynamic S tr e ss D istribution f or an Unloaded Crack.

    Framing Rat e 100, 000 F r a m e s p er Second

  • 31

    I. 0 (/) Maximum Velocity Q)

    .c 8 600 ln./Sec. (.) 0.8 c

    ..c ..... 0.6 O'l c: Q) _J

    ..x 0.4 (.)

    0 ..... 0

    0.2 Ref. Fig. 13

    0 50 100 150 200

    Time - fl Seconds

    (/) I. 0

    Q)

    ..c (.)

    c 0.8

    ..c ..... 0 .6 OI

    c Q) _J

    ~ /7

    ..x 0.4 (.)

    0 ..... 0

    0.2 I Maximum Velocity 17,700 In. /Sec .

    [7 Ref. Fig. 15 -- -

    0 50 100 150 200

    Time - fl Seconds

    Figure 16. Crack Length vs. Time.

  • ELECTRICAL

    TAPE -

    32

    ~.....:;...._,_r:-112"

    T, .. 0 114

    l/4"DIA. _l 1-1·~

    MATERIAL, CR 39 114" THICK

    FRAMING RATE

    70,000 FRAMES/SEC. LOAD, I" STEEL BALL 0 .15 LB. 155 IN./SEC.

    Figure 17. Dynamic Stress Distribution in a Layered Media Having

    an · rnclusion.

  • 33

    Figure 18. Wedge Angle Effect Under Impact .

  • LO

    AD

    , I

    11 S

    TE

    EL

    B

    AL

    L

    0.1

    5 L

    B.

    15

    5

    IN./

    SE

    C.

    17

    ,, 2.

    0 1~

    _,0

    .94

    7"

    r-

    MA

    TE

    RIA

    L,

    CR

    3

    9

    1/4

    11

    TH

    ICK

    70

    ,00

    0

    FR

    AM

    ES

    I S

    EC

    ON

    D

    Fig

    ure

    19.

    D

    yn

    amic

    Fri

    ng

    e P

    att

    ern

    s fo

    r a

    45

    ° W

    edg

    e-B

    od

    y C

    on

    fig

    ura

    tio

    n.

    VJ

    ~

  • LO

    AD

    I"

    S

    TE

    EL

    B

    AL

    L

    0.1

    5 L

    B

    15

    5

    IN./

    SE

    C.

    L o.~ t

    o.n +

    0.4

    0· t

    o.sr

    · _

    L..

    ..._

    __

    -..J

    0. 2

    .

    --i

    0.9

    47

    r-

    MA

    TE

    RIA

    L,

    CR

    3

    9

    70

    ,00

    0

    FR

    AM

    ES

    /SE

    CO

    ND

    Fig

    ure

    20.

    D

    yn

    amic

    Fri

    ng

    e P

    att

    ern

    s fo

    r a

    45

    ° N

    otc

    hed

    Wed

    ge-

    Bo

    dy

    Co

    nfi

    gu

    rati

    on

    .

    UJ

    U1

  • t

    45° T~

    -

    2.0

    " 0

    .32

    8"

    l ~

    --1

    0.9

    4if

    ---

    MA

    TL

    ., C

    R

    39

    1

    /4"

    TH

    ICK

    FR

    AM

    ING

    RA

    TE

    7

    0,0

    00

    FR

    AM

    ES

    / S

    EC

    LO

    AD

    , 1"

    ST

    EE

    L B

    AL

    L

    0.1

    5 LB

    15

    5 IN

    ./S

    EC

    .

    Fig

    ure

    21

    . D

    yn

    am

    ic F

    rin

    ge P

    att

    ern

    s in

    th

    e C

    ross

    -Secti

    on

    of

    a

    Sim

    ula

    ted

    Ro

    ck

    et

    Head

    .

    w

    O'