Myths and Reality of Doing Business in Mexico
description
Transcript of Myths and Reality of Doing Business in Mexico
Myths and Reality of Doing Business in Mexico
Dante Di Gregorio, Associate Professor
January 2010
Mexico Myths
• ‘Not a significant market, other than basic goods’• ‘Continuous economic crises – no stability’• ‘The peso is worthless, inflation is rampant’• ‘Technological backwardness’• ‘Industry is dominated by US-led maquiladoras’• ‘Mexican culture is not conducive to business’
– Corruption– Land of mañana
• ‘Mexico is a failed narco-state’
Myth: Mexico is too poor to be a significant market for anything but basic goods
• Reality:– Mexico is a middle-income country
• GDP/capita: $14,270 (or $9,980 GNI Atlas method)
• Comparable with Russia, Chile, Turkey, Poland & Malaysia
• Double the GNI/capita of Serbia, South Africa, Colombia
• Triple the GNI/capita of China and 10X that of India
• US GDP/GNI per capita - $47,580 / $46,970
• China GDP/GNI per capita - $2,940 / $6,020
– 2nd most important metropolitan market for high-end luxury goods in the Americas – Mexico City
– 2nd largest market for US exports (Mex > China + Japan)
Myth: Mexico has constant economic crises, the peso is worthless, & inflation is high
• Reality:– Cycle of econ. crises (1976, 1982, 1986-87,
1994) broken in 2000 and 2006– Avoided contagion from emerging market
crises (e.g., Southeast Asia, Argentina)– Peso – stronger & more stable than US$ for
most of the last decade (until recently)– Inflation < 5%; investment grade status
Myth: Mexican industry is technologically backward and dominated by US-led maquilas
• Reality:– Technologically-advanced engineering &
production capabilities– Approximately 50 Mexican companies with
revenues greater than US$1billion/year– An emerging entrepreneurial culture– Dominant role of maquiladoras limited to
border
Myth: Mexican culture is not conducive to business: corruption, land of mañana
• Reality:– Carlos Fuentes:
• “The Mexican mañana does not mean putting things off till the morrow. It means not letting the future intrude on the sacred completeness of today.”
– Comparatively moderate levels of corruption & largely limited to government
– Workforce is young and ambitious, with strong technical skills and work ethic
– Important to recognize the distinction between social culture and business culture
Myth: Mexico is now a failed narco-state
• Reality:– Violence and insecurity in isolated areas of
Mexico are not new– Violence and insecurity are more isolated
than is depicted:• Murder rate of US citizens (50/year) is equivalent
to 1/3 of Albuquerque’s or 1/5 of Houston’s• Violence concentrated along border and among
those involved in drug trade, security, media
– Risk is no higher/lower than US, just different
10-Minute Economic History of Mexico
Pre-Columbian Era to the Revolution
• Mexico City – focal point of civilization– 1500-100K inhabitants, 30M in Mexico– Architecture, irrigation, engineering, writing– Feudal system: caciques and tribute
• 1520-1810 – Spanish imperialist economy– Emergence of ‘la raza’
• 1810-1910 – Incomplete independence– Spanish control displaced, but feudal system
remained (caudillos)
The Revolution and the ‘Institutionalized Revolution’
• 1910-Diaz regime ousted– Zapata, Villa, Carranza, Obregon– The revolution never ended, but was
‘institutionalized’ (PRI)
• Economic system inspired by the revolution, but patterned after colonialism– Unequal development; closed economy– Poor separation of firm & state
The Technocrats and ‘The Crisis’
• Pattern of sexenio crises, 1976-1994– ‘administering the abundance’
• Technocrat Presidents– De la Madrid and the ‘lost decade’ (1980s)– Salinas de Gortari – renewed hope, shattered
dreams, and the ‘errors of December’ (1994)– Zedillo – weak but transformational sexenio
Economic Reforms, 1980-2000
• Monetary & Fiscal Policy– Inflation reached 100+%, now under 5%– Balanced budgets
• Deregulation & Privatization– Privatization of banks, rail, telcom, industry– FDI & franchise laws; increased transparency
• Trade Liberalization – Export Orientation– GATT (max tariffs from 100% to 20%)– NAFTA (most tariffs eliminated by 2003)
The Mexican Business Environment in the new
Millennium
New Millenium: A ‘New’ Mexico?
• Political change– 2000 elections: Vicente Fox (PAN)– Political pluralism = Political Gridlock
• PAN – Presidency• PRI – Senate and Chamber of Deputies• PRD – Governorships, Mayor of Mexico City
– 2006 elections: Felipe Calderon (PAN)• AMLO (Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador) factor
• New Federalism in Estados Unidos Mexicanos– Increasing importance of states & municipios
Recent Economic Performance: Reasons for Renewed Optimism
• Consistent economic growth 1995-2000– Change in GDP under
Zedillo:• 1995: - 6.2%• 1996: +5.1%• 1997: +6.8%• 1998: +4.9%• 1999: +3.9%• 2000: +6.6%
• Stagnation under PAN, 2000-2006– Change in GDP under
Fox/Calderon:• 2001: - 0.2%• 2002: +0.8%• 2003: +1.4%• 2004: +4.2%• 2005: +3.2% • 2006: +5.1%• 2007: +3.3%• 2008: +1.3%• 2009: - 7.2%
Lingering Pessimism:Limits to Development
• Economic, Political & Social Issues:– ‘So far from God, so close to the US…’– Dependence on oil, maquiladoras, exports– Unequal living standards/poverty/stagnant real wages– Drugs & drug-related violence, lawlessness– Immigration & the loss of human capital– The natural environment & water– Indigenous issues & Chiapas– Legal, tax, labor reforms– Deregulation (telecommunications, electricity)
Demographics
• 2010 Population: 110 Million (1950-25M)• 91% literacy
– Education expenditures: 6% of GDP (US-5%)
• Life expectancy: 76 years (US-77 years)• Urbanization: 75% (US-77%)• Access to potable water: 83% (Korea-
83%)• Physicians/100,000 people: 120 (US-280)• GDP/GNI per capita = $9,980/$14,270
The Many Mexicos: Mexico City
• The Capital: 25M inhabitants– Largest city in the world (along with others)– Distrito Federal: Seat of power for
government, financial, & corporate (domestic & MNCs) sectors
• No manufacturing
– Los chilangos:• Fast-paced, chaotic lifestyle• Cosmopolitan, status-conscious culture
The Many Mexicos: Monterrey
• The Sultan of the North• Economic Sectors:
– Traditional strength in heavy industry (steel, autos, other manufacturing)
– Migrating to new economy & higher value-added
– Cemex, Alfa (Alpek, Nemak), Vitro, Femsa
• Los regiomontanos:– The Texans of Mexico
The Many Mexicos: Guadalajara and Jalisco
• The ‘Mexican’ City• Economy oriented toward:
– Traditional sector (textiles, furniture, ceramics, tequila, mariachis)
– High-Tech (IBM, Acer, other telcom/IT equip)
• Los tapatios:– Unique mixture of traditional Mexico with global
orientation
The Many Mexicos: The Border
• 2,000 miles and 10%-25% of Mexico’s pop.
• Historical importance is less than the rest of Mexico– 1940-1970: Border population grew 10 times
• High interdependence with US economy– For better and for worse
• Does NAFTA make the border more relevant, or less relevant?
Economic Sectors
Manufacturing
• Traditional strength: low-tech & heavy mfg.– Steel, auto parts, products for domestic
market– Low-end export items (golf club shafts)
• Transformation of Mexican manufacturing:– Emphasis on ISO 9000– Capital-intensive activities– From wire harnesses to electronics systems
Maquiladoras
• ~$100B/year in exports (half of Mexico’s total)– But only ~1/4 is value added
• Highly cyclical, vulnerable to global econ.– Approx. 300,000 jobs lost in last downturn– Represented ½ of Mexico’s job loss
• Sectors: autos, electronics, apparel • Locations: Cd. Juarez, Tijuana, border,
Yuc.
Non-Maquila Manufacturing
• There’s more to manufacturing in Mexico than the maquiladoras– PITEX: Preferential tariff treatment for
temporary imports.– IMMEX: new umbrella for maquila, Pitex,
other
• The border v. the interior.– Border plants tend to follow ‘twin-plant’ model.– Plants in the interior are more likely to serve
the Mexican market.
Financial Sector
• Tumultuous history of banking sector– Nationalized, then privatized, then bankrupt, then sold
off to foreigners; now stable– Bank loans as % of GDP: 40% in 1994, then down to
10%, now 30% (global average=136%)– Leading players are foreign: Citibank (Banamex),
BBVA (Bancomer), Santander (Serfin)
• (Re-)Emergence of middle class creating opportunity for insurance/other fin. Services– Interest rates have declined, but credit is still scarce
for the private sector
Other Sectors
• Energy: continued state dominance– Pemex (oil), CFE (electricity)
• Tourism– Traditional emphasis on state-led developments– Transition to diffused & sustainable development
• Professional services– Potential competitive advantage for Hispanic-
owned firms
The ‘Grupos’
• Importance of the diversified conglomerate– Relation to other emerging markets
• Grupo Monterrey– Alfa, Vitro, Femsa and many subsidiaries
• Other important grupos:– Grupo Carso (America Movil, Telmex, Telcel,
Prodigy, Sanborns, CompUSA, Xignux, banks)– Grupo Bimbo– Televisa
Entrepreneurship in Mexico
• There’s more to Mexico than maquilas, PEMEX, and the grupos.
• Mexico has one of the highest rates of entrepreneurship in the world.– Entrepreneurial activity is driven both by
necessity and by opportunity.
• Economic activity in Mexico remains regionalized or localized.
• Growth in microfinance & social entrepreneurship
New Mexico and Old Mexico
• Where does NM stand in terms of trade and investment ties with Mexico?– NM exports just about $384M/year to Mexico (of
$2.8B/year to all countries)• Mexico is #1 market for NM in dollar terms (excluding
semiconductors) and in number of products.
– 35th state in exports to Mexico; 44th in exports to world– BUT, we must account for the nature of NM’s
economy.• 43rd state in terms of exports as % of GSP• 20th state in terms of exports to Mexico as % of GSP