Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

download Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

of 82

Transcript of Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    1/82

    MULTIPLE ACESS TECHNIQUESFOR WIRELESS

    COMMUNICATIONS

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    2/82

    Multiple access schemes are used to allow

    many mobile users to share simultaneously afinite amount of radio spectrum .

    Sharing of spectrum is required to achievehigh capacity by simultaneously allocating the

    available bandwidth to multiple users.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    3/82

    INTRODUCTION:

    In wireless communications systems, it is oftendesirable to allow the subscriber to sendsimultaneously information to the base stationwhile receiving information from base station.

    This effect is called DUPLEXING. Duplexing may be done using frequency or time

    division techniques.

    Frequency division multiplexing provides two

    distinct bands of frequencies.Forward band and reverse band

    Forward band: provides traffic from BSMS

    Reverse band: provides traffic from MSBS

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    4/82

    In FDD,duplex channel consists of two simplex channel(a forward and

    reverse) and a device called duplexer is used inside each subscriber unit

    and base station to allow simultaneous bi directional radio transmission

    and reception.

    Frequency separation between forward and reverse channel is constant.

    TDD uses time instead of frequency to provide both forward andreverse link.

    In TDD, multiple users share a single radio channel by taking turns in the

    time domain.

    Individual users are allowed to access the channel in assigned time slots

    and each duplex channel has both a forward time slot and reverse time

    slot to facilitate bi-directional communications.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    5/82

    Illustration of FDD and TDD techniques:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    6/82

    There are several trade off between FDD and TDD approach.

    FDD is geared towards radio communications that allocateindividual radio frequencies for each user.

    TDD enables each transceiver to operate either as a

    transmitter or a receiver on same frequency and eliminatesthe need for separate forward and reverse frequency bands.

    Because of the rigid timing required for time slotting, TDD is

    generally limited to cordless phone or short range portableaccess.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    7/82

    The three major access techniques:

    Frequency division multiplexing access(FDMA),

    Time division multiplexing access (TDMA) Code division multiple access(CDMA)

    These techniques can be grouped as narrowband

    wideband systems

    depending on available bandwidth.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    8/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    9/82

    Narrowband TDMA allows users to share the same radio

    channel but allocates a unique time slot to each user in a

    cyclical fashion on the channel.

    For narrowband TDMA systems, there generally are large

    number of radio channels allocated using either FDD/TDD.

    Such systems are called TDMA/FDD or TDMA/TDD accesssystems.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    10/82

    Wideband systems: In wideband systems, the

    transmission bandwidth of a single channel is

    much larger than the coherence bandwidth ofthe channel.(B >> Bc)

    Here a large number of transmitters are

    allowed to transmit on the same channel.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    11/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    12/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    13/82

    Frequency division multiple access:

    FDMA assigns individual channels to individual

    users.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    14/82

    These channels are assigned on demand to users

    who request service.

    During the period of the call, no other user can share

    the same channel

    In FDD systems, the users are assigned a channel as

    a pair of frequencies, one for forward channel and

    other for reverse channel.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    15/82

    FEATURES OF FDMA ARE AS FOLLOWS:

    If an FDMA channel is not in use, then it sits

    idle and cannot be used by other users toincrease or share capacity.

    After the assignments of voice channel, thebase station and mobile station transmit

    simultaneously and continuously.

    FDMA is a continuous transmission scheme.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    16/82

    The bandwidthsof FDMA channels are relatively narrow i.e.

    FDMA is implemented in narrowband systems.

    FDMA systems have higher cell site system costs as compared

    to TDMA systems.

    FDMA mobile unit uses duplexers. This result in an increasein the cost of FDMA subscribers units and base stations.

    FDMA requires tight RF filtering to minimize adjacent channel

    interference. Ts>>tau, thus ISI is less and little or no equalization is

    required

    Complexity is less

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    17/82

    Nonlinear effects in FDMA:

    In a FDMA,many channels share the same antenna at the base station.

    The power amplifiers or the power combiners when operated at or near

    saturation for maximum power efficiency are non linear.

    The non linearity's cause signal spreading in frequency domain and

    generate intermodulations(IM) frequencies.IM is undesired RF radiation

    which can interfere with other channels in FDMA systems.

    Spreading of the spectrum results in adjacentchannel interference.

    Inter modulation is the generation of undesirable harmonics.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    18/82

    The number of channels that can be

    simultaneously supported in FDMA systems is

    given by

    Bt = total spectrum allocation

    Bguard = guard band

    Bc = channel bandwidth

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    19/82

    Time division multiple access:

    TDMA systems divide the radio spectrum into time

    slots, and each slot only one user is allowed to either

    transmit or receive.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    20/82

    Here each user occupies a cyclically repeating

    time slot, so a channel may be thought of as a

    particular time slot that recovers every framewhere N time slots compromise a frame

    TDMA systems transmit data in a buffer andburst method hence transmission is

    noncontious

    Hence digital data and digital modulation

    must be used with TDMA

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    21/82

    TDMA frame structure:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    22/82

    A frame consists of a number of slots.

    Each frame is made up of preamble, information and tail bits.

    In TDMA/TDD ,half of the time slots in the frame informationmessage would be used for the forward link channels and rest halffor reverse link channel.

    In TDMA/FDD an identical/similar frame structure would be usedsolely for either forward or reverse link (fc is different for F link andR Link).

    In TDMA frame, preamble contains the address and synchronizingbits/information.

    Guard times are utilized to allow synchronization of the receiversbetween different slots and frames.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    23/82

    FEATURES OF TDMA ARE AS FOLLOWS: TDMA shares a single carrier frequency with several users, where each

    user makes use of non over lapping time standards.

    Data transmission for users of TDMA system is not continuous but occursin bursts.

    Handoff process is much simpler in TDMA(because of discontinousTransmissions).

    TDMA uses different time slots for transmission and reception, thusduplexers are not required.

    Adaptive equalization is necessary in TDMA systems.

    In TDMA, guard size must be minimized.

    High synchronization is required because of burst transmision.

    It is not possible to allocate different number of time slot per frame todifferent users.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    24/82

    Efficiency of TDMA:

    Efficiency of TDMA is the measure of the percentage of transmitteddata that contains information as opposed to providing overheadfor the access scheme.

    The frame efficiency f, is the percentage of bits per frame which

    contain transmitted data(source and channel coding bits)

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    25/82

    The frame efficiency can be found as follows.

    No. of overhead bits per frame is

    Where

    Nr=no. of reference bits

    Nt=no.of traffic bursts

    br=overhead bits per reference burst

    Bp=over head bits per preamble

    Bg=no. of equivalent bits in each guard interval.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    26/82

    Total bits per frame bTis

    where

    Tf=frame duration

    R=channel bit rate

    The frame efficiency is thus

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    27/82

    No. of channels in TDMA system: Multiplying

    the number of TDMA slots per channel by thenumber of channels available

    where

    m = maximum no of TDMA users on each radio channel.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    28/82

    Spread spectrum multiple Access:

    Spread spectrum multiple access(SSMA) uses signals whichhave transmission bandwidth that is several orders of

    magnitude greater than the minimum required RF bandwidth.

    A pseudonoise(PN) Sequence converts a narrow bandwidthsignal to a wideband noise like signal before transmission.

    Provides immunity to multipath interference and robust

    multiple access capability.

    Not very bandwidth efficient when used by a single user but

    efficient in a multiuser environment

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    29/82

    There are two main types of spread spectrum

    multiple access: Frequency hopped multiple access(FHMA)

    Code division multiple access(CDMA)

    FREQUENCY HOPPED MULTIPLE ACCESS:

    Frequency hopped multiple access is a digitalmultiple access system in which the carrierfrequencies of the individual users are variedin a pseudorandom fashion within a widebandchannel.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    30/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    31/82

    FHMA allows multiple users to simultaneously occupy the

    same spectrum at the same time, where each users dwell at a

    specific narrowband channel at a particular instance of time,

    based on particular PN code of the user.

    The digital data of each user is broken into uniform sized

    bursts which are transmitted on different channels within the

    allocated spectrum band.

    The instantaneous bandwidth of any one transmission burst is

    much smaller than the total spread bandwidth.

    The difference between FHMA and FDMA is that the

    frequency hopped signal changes channel at rapid intervals.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    32/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    33/82

    Code division multiple access:

    In code division multiple access systems, thenarrowband message signal is multiplied by a very

    large bandwidth signal called the spreading signal.

    The spreading signal is a pseudo noise code sequence

    that has a chip rate which is orders of magnitudes

    greater than the data rate of the message.

    All users in a CDMA system use the same carrier

    frequency and may transmit simultaneously.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    34/82

    Multipath fading may be substantially reduced becausethe signal is spread over a large spectrum

    Channel data rates are very high in CDMA systems.

    Since CDMA uses co-channel cells, it can use

    macroscopic spatial diversity to provide soft handoff. Selfjamming is a problem in CDMA systems.

    THE FEATURES OF CDMA ARE AS FOLLOWS:

    Many users of CDMA system share the same frequency.

    Either TDD/FDD may be used.

    Unlike TDMA or FDMA,CDMA has a soft capacity limit.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    35/82

    Hybrid spread spectrum technologies:

    Hybrid FDMA/CDMA(FCDMA):Thistechniquecan be used as an alternative to the DS-CDMA

    techniques .

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    36/82

    The available wideband spectrum is divided into a

    number of subspectras with smaller bandwidths. Each of these smaller sub channels becomes a

    narrowband CDMA system having processing gainlower than the original CDMA system.

    This hybrid system has an advantage in that therequired BW need not be contiguous anddifferent users can be allotted different subspectrum bandwidths depending on their

    requirements. The capacity of this CDMA /FDMA technique is

    calculated as the sum of capacities of a systemoperating in the sub spectra.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    37/82

    HYBRID DIRECT/FREQUENCY HOPPED

    MULTIPLE ACCESS(DS/FHMA):

    This technique consists of a direct sequencemodulated signal whose center frequency is

    made to hop periodically in a pseudo random

    fashion

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    38/82

    Direct sequence, frequency hopped systems have

    an advantage in that they avoid the near-fareffect.

    TIME DIVISION CDMA(TCDMA):

    Different spreading codes are assigned todifferent cells. Within each cell, only one CDMA

    user is transmitting in each cell.

    When a handoff takes place, the spreading code

    of the user is changed to that of the new cell.

    Using TCDMA has an advantage in that it avoids

    the near-far effect since only one user transmits

    at a time within a cell.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    39/82

    TIME DIVISION FREQUENCY HOPPING(TDFH):

    This technique has an advantage in severe multipathor when severe co-channel interference occurs.

    It has been adopted for the GSM standard.

    Avoids co-channel interference. The use of TDFH can increase the capacity of GSM

    by several fold.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    40/82

    Space division multiple access(SDMA):

    SDMA controls the radiated energy for eachuser in space.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    41/82

    SDMA serves different users by using spot beam antennas.

    These different areas covered by the antenna beam may be served by the

    same frequency or different frequencies.

    Sectorized antennasare primitive applications of SDMA. Later adaptive

    antennasare likely to be used.

    The base stations has complete control over the power of all the transmittedsignals on forward link.

    The reverse link presents the most difficulty in cellular systems for several

    reasons.

    Because of different radio propagation paths between each user and base station,

    transmitted power must be dynamically controlled to any single user from driving up

    interference level for all other users.

    Tx pwr is limited by battery consumption at the SS unit which limits the power control

    on reverse link

    Capacity of cellular systems:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    42/82

    Capacity of cellular systems:

    Channel capacity for a radio system can be defined as the maximum

    number of channels or users that can be provided in a fixed frequencyband.

    Radio capacity is a parameter which measures spectrum efficiency of

    wireless systems.

    This parameter can be determined by C/I and Bc (Channel bandwidth).

    In a cellular systems, the interference is of 2 types

    Reverse channel interference(Interference due to subscriber units in

    the surrounding cells at BS Rx)

    Forward channel interference (Interference due to surrounding co

    channel base stations at subscriber unit)

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    43/82

    Consider Forward channel interference problem:

    The minimum ratio of D/R that is required to providea tolerable level of co-channel interference is the co-

    channel reuse ratio

    The co-channel reuse ratio is given by

    Ddistance between the 2 co-channel cells

    Rcell radius

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    44/82

    The carrier to interference ratio is given by

    Where Mclosest co channel cells

    n0path loss exponent in the desired cell

    D0 distance from the desired base station to the

    mobile

    Dk distance of kth cell from the mobile

    nkpath loss exponent to the kth interfering BS

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    45/82

    Illustration of forward channel interference for

    a cluster size N =4

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    46/82

    C/I i l i b

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    47/82

    C/I is also given by

    Now if we assume D0=R, then

    Therefore

    The radio capacity of a cellular system is definedas

    N is related to Q = 3N

    From the above equations ,we can conclude that

    F th if Bt d k t t t it b

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    48/82

    Further if Bt and m are kept constant ,it can bewritten as

    Further

    (C/I)= EbRb/I = EcRc/I

    From the above equations, it can be written as

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    49/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    50/82

    Capacity of digital cellular TDMA:

    TDMA systems improve capacity by a factor of 3 to 6

    times as compared to analog cellular radio systems.

    Powerful error control and speech coding enable betterlink performance in high interference environment.

    By exploiting speech activity, some TDMA systems areable to utilize each radio channel.

    Mobile assisted handoff(MAHO)allows subscribers tomonitor the neighboring base stations.

    TDMA also makes it possible to introduce adaptivechannel allocation.

    GSM,PDC have adopted digital CDMA for high capacity.

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    51/82

    C it f ll l CDMA

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    52/82

    Capacity of cellular CDMA:

    Capacity of cellular CDMA is interference limited, while it is BWlimited in FDMA and TDMA.

    Therefore any reduction in the interference will cause a linearincrease in the capacity of CDMA.

    Interference can be reduced by the use of multi sectorised

    antennas which results in spatial isolation of users.

    The directional antennas receive signals from only a fraction ofcurrent users, thus leading to the reduction of interference.

    CDMA capacity can be increased by operating in discontinuoustransmission mode(DTX).

    In DTX mode , the Tx is turned off during the periods of silence inspeech

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    53/82

    For evaluating the capacity of a CDMA system ,first consider asingle cell system.

    Let the no. of users be N,

    The SNR at the base station receiver can berepresented in terms of Eb/N0

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    54/82

    Taking noise into considerations,

    The no of users that can access the systems is

    thus given as

    further

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    55/82

    The number of users that can access thesystem is given as

    Interference can be reduced by using antenna

    sectorization.

    Eb/No within a sector is given by

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    56/82

    When the number of users is large and the system is

    interference limited rather than noise limited, thenumber of users is

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    57/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    58/82

    Capacity of CDMA with multiple cells:

    In CDMA cellular systems , neighboring cells share

    the same frequency and each base station controls

    the transmit power of each of its own in-cell users.

    A particular base station is unable to control the

    power of users in neighboring cells and these users

    add to noise floor and decrease capacity on the

    reverse link of the particular cell .

    Ill i f i hi CDMA ll l

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    59/82

    Illustration of users within a CDMA cellular

    radio systems:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    60/82

    Fig shows how the users in adjacent cells may bedistributed over the coverage area

    Transmit powers of each out-of-cell user will add to thein-cell interference (where users are under powercontrol) at the base station receiver

    The amount of out-of-cell interference determines thefrequency reuse factor, f, of a CDMA cellular system

    Each cell shares same frequency and maximum possible

    Value of f = 1 is achieved

    The frequency reuse factor of a CDMA cellular

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    61/82

    The frequency reuse factor of a CDMA cellular

    system on reverse link is.

    No is the total interference power receivedfrom N-1 in-cell users

    Naiis the average interference power for a user

    located in the ith adjacent cellUi is the number of users in the ith adjacent

    cell

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    62/82

    and frequency reuse efficiency F

    the average interference power for a user located in

    the ith adjacent cell

    Nijpower received at the BS from the jth userin the ith cell

    A geometric technique called concentric circle cellular

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    63/82

    A geometric technique called concentric circle cellular

    geometric is used to determine how the propagation path loss

    impacts the frequency reuse of a CDMA system considering

    the interference from both in cell and out of cell users

    Thi t h i ifi ll f i t t t b i l ll l t d t th

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    64/82

    This technique specifies cell of interest to be circular cell located at the

    centre and the interfering cells are wedge shaped and arranged in layers

    Let centre cell have Radius = R

    d0be the close in distance such that all users in the cell are >= d0

    All the users in the cell are located at distance d from BS such that d0

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    65/82

    The concentric circle cellular geometry was

    proposed by Rapport.

    The area of the centre cell,(if d0

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    66/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    67/82

    For each first layer to possess U =KA users apply weight factors such

    that

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    68/82

    that

    K

    user density

    W1inweighting factors for the user density within the

    inner

    W1out

    weighting factors for the user density within the

    outer

    If W1in=1 & W1out =1 then 3/8 of users are in inner sector and

    5/8 users in outer sector

    To find the capacity of multicell CDMA systems, the concentric

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    69/82

    p y y ,

    circle geometry can be used in conjunction with a propagation

    path loss model to determine the interference from adjacent

    cell users.

    The in-cell interference power N0 is

    Where P0power received from any one of the U users inthe centre cell

    Assume all adjacent cells contain U users and receiving P0

    power from each user of its cell and id at a distance dfrom BS

    In the forbidden zone it is assumed not to contain users

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    70/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    71/82

    Approximation for d is made while computing the power of

    the adjacent cell user to its BS

    By considering the figure, using the law of cosines,

    The interference power at the centre of the cell from jth user in

    the ith interfering cell is

    where P0=interference power received.

    npath loss exponent ,d is a function of theta

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    72/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    73/82

    f can range from 0.316 to 0.707 depending on

    the path loss exponent and distribution of

    users.

    Single Cell CDMA system offers ideal

    frequency reuse of f=1

    Capacity of space division multiple access:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    74/82

    Capacity of space division multiple access:

    For interference limited CDMA operating in an AWGN

    channel, with perfect power control with no interference from

    adjacent cells and with omnidirectional antennas, the

    average bit error rate, Pb, for a user can be found from the

    Gaussian approximation.

    K-number of users in the cellN - spreading factor

    Q(x)Standard Q-function

    Illustration showing different antenna Patterns:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    75/82

    Illustration showing different antenna Patterns:

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    76/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    77/82

    Directive pattern can be formed at the base station using N

    element adaptive array antenna

    Assuming that a beam pattern, G() is formed such that max.

    gain is in the direction of the desired user

    Beam pattern is as shown in the figure without variation inthe elevation plane

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    78/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    79/82

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    80/82

    An idealized flat topped pattern with 60 deg beam

    width and -6db side lobe level:

    As the antenna beam pattern is made more narrower D and I

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    81/82

    As the antenna beam pattern is made more narrower D and Ireduces proportionally

    The average bit error rate for user 0 is given by

    Thus Pb is dependent on beam pattern of a receiver

    Further using the fact that additional interfernce from adjacent cellssimply adds to the interference level in a multi cell environment

    Where f=frequency re-use factor

    A fi ill t ti th b bilit f f diff t

  • 8/13/2019 Multiple Acess Techniques for Wireless Communications

    82/82

    A figure illustrating the average probability of error for different

    propagation path loss exponents: