Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education...

54
Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas NTFP, Ratanakiri, Cambodia

Transcript of Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education...

Page 1: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities

in the Cambodian Highlands

Presentation by Anne Thomas

NTFP, Ratanakiri, Cambodia

Page 2: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Outline

Background

Kavet Case Study

• Overview 1996-

to present

Local Language Development Initiatives

Challenges & Opportunities

Progress

Lessons Learned

Page 3: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Background- Ratanakiri Province 1996

Literacy rate : 20% males

2% females

Unwritten languages-

(„backward‟, „primitive‟)

Ethnic Minority NGO staff-

few or none

Linguistic work Krung

language- trial alphabet

No bilingual literacy

materials-

First pilot in country

2 NGOs-

NTFP, ICC (World Concern)

Page 4: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Indigenous Population 85,000

Tampuan 25,000

Brao/Kavet/Krung 30,000

Ratanakiri

Cambodia

Page 5: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Background- Kavet- 1996

Widely scattered hamlets

Swidden groups- 5 families

Walked 4 days- last day found the

commune chief walked 4 days

Virachey National Park

NTFP- „Community Based Natural

Resources Management Project‟- Local

communities know best how to manage

their resources

Still war-torn (re-united 1998)

Page 6: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Background

Approach: Literacy Pilot• 2 NGOs work together

• Coordinate closely with Ministry of Education

all steps of materials development & approval

• Community-based, NFE approach

• Train local villagers to be teachers

• NFE approach- lessons relate to livelihood

• Design & Pilot 2 types of NFE materials-

local languages + Khmer materials

Page 7: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Background: Bilingual

Education Pilot Objectives Develop MT writing systems

& Bilingual NFE Curriculum

which have official government endorsement

Promote use of MT in development initiatives (livelihood, education, conflict resolution for land & natural resources)

Village Elder,

Community Forestry

Committee

Page 8: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet Case Study

Community Survey & Action Research -

1996Literacy = Empowerment

Adults told their elders: „If we had been

literate, this would not have happened to us”

(losing our forest, losing our land, being at

the bottom of the pecking order)

Teacher training approach- every 2 months

for packet of lessons- stay ahead of students

Page 9: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Bilingual Literacy ProjectTeacher:

• Community-based

• Same language

Class:

• Flexible schedule

• Classroom provided

by community

Page 10: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Seasonal

agricultural

calendar

Maternal

nutrition

Evening study

hall

Functional

Page 11: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

…so that EVERYONE can learn to

read and write…

Bilingual approach-

Kavet 2002 trial, re-launched 2007

Mother tongue bridging to national language

Page 12: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas
Page 13: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas
Page 14: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet MLE 2007:

Very strong participation

of girls/women

(Khmer NFE was mostly males)

Page 15: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet girls in advanced NFE literacy class (2005)

The next group of volunteer teachers (2006)

Page 16: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet girl students become bilingual

teachers

Page 17: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Bilingual Classes full of girls, young

women

Page 18: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet Case Study-2010

Six Kavet villages (population approx 2,000)

All leaders involved

Student profile:

• All ages, usually between age 9-30

•Dry season 550,

•Rainy season 450

•30-40% females

Page 19: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Highlights Kavet Bilingual Literacy : 2010

(Team leader Krung woman

Total- 2 Kavet Staff, 2 Krung)

Six Kavet villages:

Average 500 students, 30-40% females,

19 teaching locations, 38 volunteer teachers, 3

community libraries (new-started 2009)

Produced local stories, songs

24 community school board members

2009 and 2010: Survey & trainers for Steung

Treng Kavet bilingual project

Page 20: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet staff

Page 21: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Planning NFEAnnual planning

for classes in

hamlets: com’ty

leaders, NFE

teachers

6 villages-19

hamlets

Page 22: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Annual Planning NFE

Page 23: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Local Monitor

Community meeting

Testing

Kavet Bilingual

Project Highlights

2010

Page 24: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Kavet Writer‟s workshop-

Page 25: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Reading their own stories in print

Results of Writer‟s workshop-

Page 26: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Community-Based Non-formal

Education: Best Practices

Orthography development

based on linguistic

research (5 languages )

Effective, pedagogically

strong model which

bridges to national

language

Literacy, life skills

(numeracy & marketing,

health education,

functional topics)

Kavet bilingual teacher training

Page 27: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Local NGO Creative Initiatives Using

Local languages-Non-timber Forest Products (NTFP)

Community-Based Non-formal Education

Community Health Groups

Community-Based Natural

Resource Management

Indigenous Youth

Development Project (IYDP)

Highlanders’ Association

(NTFP ‘spin-off’)

IDEAS (Indigenous Development Education Accommodation Support)

Kavet bilingual teacher training

Page 28: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

MAP: LOCATION OF ETHNIC MINORITIES IN

CAMBODIA (source: Blench, 2002).

Non-formal Education (NFE)

• Ratanakiri (1997) ICC, NTFP, POE (2009)

• Steung Treng (2002) YWAM

• Mondulkiri (2001) ICC, POE

• Preah Vihear (2009)

Community Extension & Integrated Development:Ratanakiri, Mondulkiri

Primary Education:

Ratanakiri (2002 CARE)

Mondulkiri, other Provinces (CARE technical support, UNICEF, NGOs)

Nationwide –

Bilingual Initiatives 1997-presentLanguage Research:

Kuy, Cham, Pearic

Languages

5 Scripts Officially

Approved:

(Ratanakiri- 4 languages)

Official Policy: 2011

Page 29: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

NTFP- Kavet Community Health Workers

Page 30: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Cambodian pre-

literate level

(1996):

re-hydration

lesson

Based on Unicef

“Facts for Life”

Page 31: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Re-hydration lesson: Brao language

Page 32: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Natural Resources:

Bilingual Community Forest Regulations

(Kavet + Khmer Languages)

In 1997, the

Kavet language

was unwritten

Among the 6

villages, only a

handful were

semi-literate in

Khmer

Page 33: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Reviewing Community Forest

Regulations: Kavet Language

Natural Resource Committee

members and commune leaders

Checking Kavet language

community forestry

regulations

Page 34: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Community leaders- literate

• Community Leaders

• Educated through NFE project

Page 35: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Expansion site: Steung Treng Province

7 Kavet villages

Our language can be written down!

Page 36: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Climbing tree

for better view of

literacy books and

alphabet chart

Page 37: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

How many want to

learn to read?

(Everyone!!)

about 650 students-

7 villages

Page 38: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Former Khmer Rouge

Child Soldier learning to

be a literacy teacher

Page 39: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Challenges & Opportunities

Page 40: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Ratanakiri Overcoming

challenges…

Page 41: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Unexpected Survey Outcome….

Steung Treng

Page 42: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Opportunities: Indigenous Youth

Development Project assists NFE

Page 43: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

IYDP coaching

bilingual literacy class and teacher

Page 44: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

IYDP consult with village education

board members

Page 45: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

IDEAS

from IYDP

alumni

2008: 30 students, including 10 girls

First girl primary school graduates

start secondary school

Page 46: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

IDEAS 2010:

50 students all language

groups (20 girls)

Cholera outreach training

Nurse in

training:

First girl

graduate!

Page 47: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Cultural and linguistic diversity is important to Cambodia as a nation.

Through affirming and preserving the language, identity, and cultural heritage of the ethnic minority peoples, together with providing access to education and civil processes, they will be engaged and integrated into the Cambodian civil society and building the country.

H E Em Sothy Ministry of Education, Youth, and Sport

Cambodia

Page 48: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Bilingual Literacy-Progress• Strong women‟s participation- 30-40%

students, female teachers

(Much more confident in bilingual approach

than Khmer approach)

• Literacy teacher training main source of

education in Kavet villages-

• All Village and commune leaders involved,

most former NFE volunteer teachers

Page 49: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Progress cont‟d

Literacy a useful skill- basis for all development, accessing government training

Previously -„no literates- no one to send‟- for TBA training, veterinarian, malaria worker….

Now teachers become leaders, students become teachers- pool of literates in Kavet + Khmer

Page 50: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Ongoing Challenges

NFE approach is not yet priority in gov‟t ed.

sector, formal ed gets much more attention

Need to strengthen cooperation between all

partners- from village to local authorities, district,

to provincial level, and IOs, GOs, NGOs

POE Ratanakiri no ethnic minority staff

DOE Ratanakiri has few ethnic staff in

leadership

However neighboring Mondulkiri has many ethnic

staff in leadership in POE, DOE

Page 51: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Lessons Learned(local Senior Advisor)

NFECommunity ownership to Bilingual NFE key

Strong cooperation between all parties (IO, GO, NGO)

NFE teachers (bilingual, Khmer) would benefit by becoming official government staff

Bilingual approach needs to be more widespread , adopted by government education services, many areas are waiting

(Currently NFE in 3 villages supported by Ratanakiri POE)

Attitudes

Bilingual skills have become „useful‟ and valued: NGOs have posts required local language/cultural skills

Page 52: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Lessons Learned-

Factors Contributing to Success (NTFP Staff)

Community ownership and decision making

Community teachers

Importance of Expansion

Consensus within the

Kavet villages in Ratanakiri

Synergy with

Kavet in Steung Treng:

“We can do it, you can do it too!!”

Page 53: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

Empowerment Ratanakiri Highlanders style:

“Keep on teaching, keep on learning, keep on

starting new initiatives as needed….”

Page 54: Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in ...€¦ · Multi-lingual Education Empowers Indigenous Communities in the Cambodian Highlands Presentation by Anne Thomas

References• HE Chey Chap, In The, Anne Thomas (2003). Bilingual Education in

Cambodia (www.sil.org/asia/ldc/parallel_papers/he_chey_chap.pdf )

• Thomas, Anne (2003). Designing and Launching Bilingual Community-based Non-formal Education and Extension Initiatives in the Cambodian Highlands.(www.sil.org/asia/ldc/parallel_presentations.html)

• Thomas, Anne ‘From Bullets to Blackboards’ Chapter on Cambodia Highlands. www.riseinstitute.org

• Thomas, Anne E. Thomas (2002). Bilingual Community-based Education in the Cambodian Highlands: a Successful Approach for Enabling Access to Education by Indigenous Peoples. Journal of Southeast Asian Education. Vol 3, No 1, pp.26-58.

• UNESCO 2004: Manual for Literacy and Adult Education Programmes in Minority Language Communities. UNESCO Bangkok, Dr. Susan Malone