Motion for New Trial
-
Upload
nancy-deloach -
Category
Documents
-
view
58 -
download
1
description
Transcript of Motion for New Trial
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 1/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
NANCY DELOACH, IN PRO PER
CRAIG DELOACH, IN PRO PER
1815 VIRGINIATOWN RD.
LINCOLN, CA 95648
TEL: 916-645-2768
FAX: 916-645-2768
!PERIOR CO!RT OF CALIFORNIA, CO!NTY OF PLACER
P"#$"%&' '( C%)*+(#&*% C( (+ C**) P#(/"# 0CCP 657, 658, 659, 6590%, ' $3. %& CRC R")
.16, D+&%&'$, C#%* W%#&# DL(%/ %& N%&/ A&& ' DL(%/ ( ' C("#' '( $' %$*
' "&' &'# (& F;#"%# 4, 215 (& ' /("#'$ /*$*(& (+ D/;# 2, 214, %& '( #%&' %
&< '#*%) *& ' %;(-#+#&/ %/'*(&.
T*$ ('*(& *$ % (& %/ %& %)) (+ ' +())(<*& #("&$, %/ (+ <*/ $=%#%') (# *&
/(;*&%'*(& %$ %'#*%)) %++/' ' $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' +&%&'$ %& =#&' % +%*# '#*%):
1. I##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' /("#' >CCP $/'*(& 65701?@
2. A;"$ (+ *$/#'*(& ; ' /("#' >CCP $/'*(& 65701?@
. I##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' %#$ =%#' >CCP $/'*(& 65701?
- 1 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
C%$ N(. : BCV-59951
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@BEBORAND!B OF POINT ANDA!THORITIE IN !PPORT@DEFENDANT DECLARATION
H%#*& D%':
T*: D=':
C(=)%*&' F*): 1221
T#*%) D%': 82814, 82914 92414
D/*$*(& D%': 12214"&' E&'#: 2415
LINDA EAN TYVE !ION,
P)%*&'*++,$
NANCY ANN TYVE DELOACH %&CRAIG WARNER DELOACH,
D+&%&'$
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 2/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4. A//*&' (# $"#=#*$, <*/ (#*&%# =#"&/ /(") &(' % "%# %%*&$' >CCP $/'*(&
65707?@
5. T *&/ <%$ *&$"++*/*&' '( "$'*+ ' /*$*(& >CCP $/'*(& 65706?@
6. T /*$*(& *$ /(&'#%# '( )%< >CCP $/'*(& 65706?@ %&
7. E##(# *& )%< (//"##*& %' ' '#*%) %& (;/' '( ; ' (*& =%#' >CCP $/'*(& 65707?.
HE MO ION FOR NEW RIAL SHOULD BE GRAN ED BECAUSE HE
DEFENDAN S HAVE BEEN PREVEN ED FROM HAVING A FAIR RIAL
AND HEIR SUBS AN IAL RIGH S HAVE BEEN MA ERIALLY AFFEC ED
BY EACH OF HE FOLLOWING:
THERE WAS AN IRREGULARITY IN THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE COURT
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ I##")%#*' *& C("#' P#(/*&$. O& ' %==)*/%'*(& (+ ' =%#'
%#*, ' #*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ; #%&',
(& %)) (# $( (+ ' *$$"$, (& ' #("& (+ *##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' /("#' ; <*/ *'#
=%#' *$ =#&' +#( %*& % +%*# '#*%) *+ $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%))
%++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/. 65701 >D#*&$?.
B. D=%#'"# ; C("#' F#( D" %& O##) B'(. A& *##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' /("#'
*$ %& =%#'"# ; ' /("#' +#( ' " %& (##) '( (+ *$=($*'*(& (+ %& %/'*(& ; <*/ '
$";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ % =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' 0G% . T(##%&/ 0194 145 C%). 144, 149, 78 P.
54.
C. C("#'$ P#"&' (+ C%$ +(# H%#*&. A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' (& ' #("& (+
*##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' /("#' <& ' '#*%) " %$ =#" % /%$ ;+(# '
*&'#("/'*(& (+ %)) *&/ ; *'# =%#' 0W;;# . W;;# 01948 C%). 2 15, 156-158, 199 P.2
94@ B/V . B/V 01955 12 C%). A==. 2 12, 122-125, 281 P.2 898.
THERE WAS AN ABUSE OF DISCRETION
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ O## (+ C("#' (# A;"$ (+ D*$/#'*(& P#&'*& F%*# T#*%). O& %==)*/%'*(&
- 2 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 3/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(+ ' =%#' %#*, ' #*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) %
; #%&', (& %)) (# $( (+ ' *$$"$, (& ' #("& '%' '# <%$ %& (## (+ ' /("#' (# %;"$ (+
*$/#'*(& ; <*/ *'# =%#' <%$ =#&' +#( %*& % +%*# '#*%), *+ $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ '
%#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0 C( C*. P#(/. 65701>D#*&$? @ H%$ . V*$/(
0195 122 C%). A==. 2 15, 17-14, 264 P.2 17 .
B. O## P#&'*& R)*%&/ (& F%(#%;) P#$"='*(&. A& (## (+ ' /("#' '%' =#/)"$ '
%#* =%#' +#( #)*& (& % +%(#%;) =#$"='*(& ;/%"$ (+ %*$$*;) ;"' *=#(=#) /)"
*&/, %& '%' '#; =#&'$ * (# # +#( %*& % +%*# '#*%), % ; #("&$ +(# ' #%&'*&
(+ % &< '#*%) 0H%$ . V*$/( 0195 122 C%). A==. 2 15, 17-14, 264 P.2 17.
THERE WAS AN IRREGULARITY IN THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE
ADVERSE PARTY, CONSISTING OF THAT PARTY'S MISCONDUCT
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ I##")%#*' *& P#(/*&$ (+ A#$ P%#'. O& ' %==)*/%'*(& (+ '
=%#' %#*, ' #*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ;
#%&', (& %)) (# $( (+ ' *$$"$, (& ' #("& (+ *##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' %#$
=%#' ; <*/ *'# =%#' *$ =#&' +#( %*& % +%*# '#*%) *+ $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#*
=%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/. 65701 >D#*&$?.
B. O#' A/'$ (+ A#$ P%#'. A& (#' %/' (+ ' %#$ =%#', *()%'*& ' #*' '( % +%*# %&
*=%#'*%) '#*%) %& %("&'*& '( *$/(&"/', % ; #%# %$ %& *##")%#*' +(# <*/ % &< '#*%)
% ; #%&' 0$ G#% . R(;*&$(& 0199 C%). A==. 2 177, 182, 91 P.2 194 .
C. O& P%#' B*$) ; A/' (+ O'#. W&# (& =%#' *$ *$) '( *$ (# # =#"*/ ; ' %/' (+
' ('#, "$'*/ %&$ '%' % &< '#*%) ; #%&' 0P*&% B/D(&(" . B/F%#)%& E)#(
01855 5 C%). 17.
D. P#&'*(& (+ F")) P#$&'%'*(& (+ E*&/. A& *$/(&"/' (+ % =%#' '( %& %/'*(& '%' =#&'$
+")) =#$&'%'*(& '( ' /("#' (# "# (+ *&/ %'#*%) '( ' ('# =%#'$ /%"$, '"$ =#&'*& % +%*#
'#*%), *$ %& *##")%#*' +(# <*/ % &< '#*%) % ; #%&' 0P*#/ . P*#/ 0196 149 C%). 16, 166, 6
P. 57.
- 3 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 4/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
OPPOSING COUNSEL MADE PERSONAL ATTACKS
ON THE CHARACTER OR MOTIVES OF THE DEFENDANTS
THAT WERE UNSUPPORTED BY THE EVIDENCE
A. P#$(&%) A''%/$ (& C%#%/'# (# B('*$ (+ A#$ P%#', C("&$), (# W*'&$$. P#$(&%) %''%/$(& ' /%#%/'# (# ('*$ (+ ' %#$ =%#', /("&$), (# <*'&$$$, "&$"==(#' ; ' *&/ %&
/%)/")%' '( *&+)% ' "#, <*' '%' #$")' ;*& %/*, %# %& *##")%#*' +(# <*/ % &< '#*%)
% ; #%&' 0$ *(&$ . ("'#& P%/. T#%&$=(#'%'*(& C(. 01976 62 C%). A==. 41, 51-55,
1 C%). R='#. 42@ L( . W()+ 01964 226 C%). A==. 2 78, 91-92, 8 C%). R='#. 18.
OPPOSING PARTY URGED FACTS THAT WERE NOT IN EVIDENCE AND
INSINUATED MATTERS THAT WERE NOT SUPPORTED BY THE EVIDENCE,
THUS PREJUDICING THE COURT
A. C("&$)$ "$'*(& (+ B%''#$ O'# T%& ; L*'*%' I&'#("/'*(& I&'( E*&/. C("&$)$
%''='$ '( $"$' %''#$ (+ %& *&'*%# &%'"# '( % "# ('# '%& ; ' )*'*%' *&'#("/'*(&
*&'( *&/, <'# ; 3"$'*(&$ (& /#($$ %*&%'*(&, %#"&', (# ('# %&$, *$ *$/(&"/' +(#
<*/ % &< '#*%) % ; #%&' 0*' . C()) 0198 1 C%). A==. 947, 96, 161 C%). R='#.
77.
B. A$$"*& F%/'$ N(' *& E*&/ D"#*& A#"&'. A#"&' ; /("&$) '%' %$$"$ +%/'$ '%' %#
&(' *& *&/, (# '%' %# &(<& '( ; "&$"==(#' ; %& +%/'"%) ;%$*$ %& *&*' ' "# '( $=/")%'
(& "&$"==(#' *&+#&/$, *$ %& *##")%#*' *& ' =#(/*&$ (+ ' %#$ =%#' +(# <*/ % &< '#*%)
% ; #%&' 0B%)%$*%& . I#<*& 01964 61 C%). 2 78, 745-748, 4 C%). R='#. 78, 94 P.2 822.
AN ACCIDENT AND/OR SURPRISE OCCURRED AT TRIAL,
AGAINST WHICH ORDINARY PRUDENCE COULD NOT HAVE GUARDED
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ A//*&' (# "#=#*$. O& %==)*/%'*(& (+ ' =%#' %#*, ' #*/' (#
/*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ; #%&', (& %)) (# $( (+ '
*$$"$, (& ' #("& (+ %//*&' (# $"#=#*$, %%*&$' <*/ (#*&%# =#"&/ /(") &(' % "%#, *+
- 4 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 5/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
$";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/. 6570
>D#*&$?.
B. A//*&' %& "#=#*$ D+*&. T '#$, %//*&' %& $"#=#*$, %)'(" &(' $'#*/') $&(&("$,
% $";$'%&'*%)) ' $% %&*&, %$ %/ *$ "$ '( &(' $( /(&*'*(& (# $*'"%'*(& *& <*/ %
=%#' '( % /%"$ *$ "&=/') =)%/, '( *$ (# # *&"#, <*'("' %& +%")' (# &)*&/ (+ *$ (## (<& %& <*/ (#*&%# =#"&/ /(") &(' % "%# %%*&$' 0J%"++%& . D B"'**$ 01948 1
C%). 2 429, 42, 189 P.2 271.
C. D*++#&' R$")' P#(;%;) (& R'#*%). A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' (& ' #("& (+ %//*&' (#
$"#=#*$ *+ ' %#* =%#' $(<$ '%' *& ' &' (+ % &< '#*%), % *++#&' #$")' <(") ; #%/
'%' <*)) ; +%(#%;) '( '%' =%#' 0W*'+*) . D;#*&/%' 0197 18 C%). A==. 2 7, 78, 64 P.2
96.
D. E#/*$ (+ O#*&%# P#"&/ '( G"%# A%*&$' "#=#*$ (# A//*&'. A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' *+
' %#* =%#' %$ #/*$ (#*&%# =#"&/ '( "%# %%*&$' ' $"#=#*$ (# %//*&' 0W*'+*)
. D;#*&/%' 0197 18 C%). A==. 2 7, 79-74, 64 P.2 96.
E. F%*)"# '( C(&'*&"%&/ (# A$ +(# R)*+ %' T* (+ "#=#*$. A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' &
'(" ' %#* =%#' %$ +%*) '( $ % /(&'*&"%&/ (# '( %$ +(# #)*+ %' ' '* (+ ' %//*&'
(# $"#=#*$, *+ &( =#%/'*/%;) $'=$ '%' /("&$) /(") % '%& <(") % ++%/ ' *$%$'#("$ ++/'
(+ ' %//*&' (# $"#=#*$ 0$ W*'+*) . D;#*&/%' 0197 18 C%). A==. 2 7, 77, 64 P.2 96.
F. R%*$*& N< B%'#*%) I$$" ; A#$ P%#'. A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' (& ' #("& (+ %//*&'
(# $"#=#*$ *+, "#*& ' '#*%), ' %#$ =%#' #%*$$ % &< *$$" '%' * &(' %==%# *& ' =)%*&$
%& '%' *$ $"==(#' ; '$'*(& /(&'#%# '( <%' <%$ %&'*/*=%' 0)%&%& . P%#$(&$ 01925 7
C%). A==. 218, 224-225, 28 P. 728.
THE EVIDENCE IS INSUFFICIENT TO JUSTIFY THE DECISION
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ I&$"++*/*&/ (+ E*&/. O& %==)*/%'*(& (+ ' =%#' %#*, '
#*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ; #%&', (& %)) (# $( (+
' *$$"$, (& ' #("& (+ *&$"++*/*&/ (+ ' *&/ '( "$'*+ ' #*/' (# /*$*(& *+ $";$'%&'*%)
#*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/. 65706 >D#*&$?.
B. " (# "# C)%#) (") H% R%/ D*++#&' D/*$*(& (# V#*/'. A ('*(& +(# &< '#*%)
- 5 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 6/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(& ' #("& (+ *&$"++*/*&/ (+ ' *&/ *$ =#(=#) #%&' *+, %+'# <**& ' *&/ %&
#%$(&%;) /(&+#&/$, ' /("#' *$ /(&*&/ '%' *' (# ' "# /)%#) $(") % #%/ % *++#&'
#*/' (# /*$*(& 0C( C*. P#(/. 657>D#*&$?@ R"$$)) . N)$(& 01969 1 C%). A==. 919, 922,
82 C%). R='#. 221.
C. " R3"*# '( W* E*&/. I& =%$$*& (& % ('*(& +(# &< '#*%) (& ' #("& (+*&$"++*/*&/ (+ ' *&/, ' '#*%) " *$ #3"*# '( <* ' *&/ %& *& $( (*& (# $
% *$;)* <*'&$$$ %& #%< *&+#&/$ /(&'#%# '( '($ $"==(#'*& ' #*/' 0$ B#/# .
P#K 01968 68 C%). 2 14, 112, 46 P.2 15@ D*'#*/ . L*''(& I&"$'#*$, I&/. 0197 12 C%). A==.
74, 77, 717, 9 C%). R='#. 856.
D. D"' '( G#%&' N< T#*%) I+ V#*/' (# D/*$*(& A%*&$' W*' (+ E*&/. O& % ('*(& +(# % &<
'#*%) (& ' #("& (+ *&$"++*/*&/ (+ ' *&/, ' " "$' <* %& /(&$*# ' *&/ (+
;(' =%#'*$@ *+ (# $ *$ /(&*&/ '%' ' #*/' *$ /)%#) %%*&$' ' <*' (+ ' *&/, *' *$' "$ "' '( #%&' % &< '#*%) & '(" '# %# /(&+)*/'$ *& ' *&/ 0L"/%$ . H$=#*%
G()+ C("&'# C)"; 01967 255 C%). A==. 2 241, 25, 6 C%). R='#. 189.
E. C("#' N(' ("& ; P#*(# R")*&$ (& "$'*(&$ (+ L%< (# P#*(# V*< (+ E*&/. I& #%&'*& %
&< '#*%) (& ' #("& (+ *&$"++*/*&/ (+ ' *&/, ' /("#' *$ &(' ;("& ; *'$ =#*(# #")*&$ (&
3"$'*(&$ (+ )%< (# *'$ =#*(# *< (+ ' *&/ 0Y%##(< . '%' (+ C%)*+(#&*% 0196 5 C%). 2 427,
47, 2 C%). R='#. 17, 48 P.2 687.
F. " N(' ("& ; C(&+)*/'$ *& E*&/. A " *$ &(' ;("& ; % /(&+)*/' *& ' *&/ <&
#")*& (& % ('*(& +(# % &< '#*%)@ #%'#, (# $ "$' #<* ' *&/, ' *&+#&/$ '#+#(,
%& ' /#*;*)*' (+ <*'&$$$ *& '#*&*& <'# ' "# /)%#) $(") % #%/ % *++#&'
#*/' 0L*==() . H%#' 01969 274 C%). A==. 2 24, 25, 78 C%). R='#. 8.
G. !&#)*%;) ;"' ";$'%&'*%) E*&/ "==(#'$ V#*/'. I+, *& ' (=*&*(& (+ ' /("#', ' *&/ *$
"&#)*%;), *' *$ ' /("#'$ "' '( #%&' % &< '#*%) %& *' % #%&' % &< '#*%) & <& '# *$
$";$'%&'*%) *&/ '( $"$'%*& ' #*/' *+ *' ;)*$ '%' ' *&/ =#=(&#%'$ %%*&$' '
#*/' 0$ B((# . C*' C("&' (+ %& F#%&/*$/( 0197 5 C%). A==. 728, 78, 85 C%). R='#.
281.
THE DECISION IS AGAINST LAW
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ V#*/' (# O'# D/*$*(& A%*&$' L%<. O& %==)*/%'*(& (+ ' =%#'
- 6 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 7/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
%#*, ' #*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ; #%&',
(& %)) (# $( (+ ' *$$"$, (& ' #("& '%' ' #*/' (# ('# /*$*(& *$ %%*&$' )%<, *+ $";$'%&'*%)
#*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/. 65706 >D#*&$?.
DECISION IS AGAINST LAW IN THAT THE COURT FAILED TO FIND
ON A MATERIAL ISSUE AND/OR THE DECISION IS IRRECONCILABLE
A. D/*$*(& A%*&$' L%<. A /*$*(& *$ %%*&$' )%< (&) 01 <& '# *$ % +%*)"# '( +*& (& % %'#*%)
*$$"@ 02 <& ' +*&*&$ %# *##/(&/*)%;)@ (# 0 <& ' *&/ *$ *&$"++*/*&' *& )%< %&
<*'("' /(&+)*/' (& %& %'#*%) =(*&' 0$ J#%)*/ . B%#*&* 01959 172 C%). A==. 2 784, 789, 42
P.2 9@ $ %)$( R&+# . %$ 0195 96 C%). A==. 2 8, 8, 215 P.2 487.
B. F%*)"# '( R$() =/*+* C(&'#(#' I$$". T /("#'$ +%*)"# '( #$() % $=/*+*
/(&'#(#' *$$" *& *'$ $'%'&' (+ /*$*(& % ; % ;%$*$ +(# #%&'*& % &< '#*%) (& ' #("& (+
/*$*(& %%*&$' )%< *+ '%' +%*)"# %'#*%)) %++/'$ ' $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' 0$
C( C*. P#(/. 62>D#*&$?, 64>D#*&$?, 657>D#*&$?@ $ %)$( R&+# . %$ 0195 96
C%). A==. 2 8, 8, 215 P.2 487.
C. I&/(&$*$'&', A;*"("$, %& !&/#'%*& '%'&' (+ D/*$*(&. I+ ' $'%'&' (+ /*$*(& *$ $(
*&/(&$*$'&', %;*"("$, %& "&/#'%*& '%' *' *$ *&/%=%;) (+ ;*& #/(&/*) %& *' *$ *=($$*;) '( '))
(< % $=/*+* /(&'#(#' *$$" *$ '#*&, ' /*$*(& % ; %%*&$' )%< %& % &< '#*%) %
; #%&' *+ ' $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' 0$ C( C*. P#(/.
62>D#*&$?, 64>D#*&$?, 657>D#*&$? @ $ %)$( R&+# . %$ 0195 96 C%). A==. 2 8,
8, 215 P.2 487 .
D. B(*& P%#' B% R%*$ N< L%) T(#. /'*(& 65706>D#*&$? (+ ' C( (+ C**)
P#(/"# =(<#$ % '#*%) /("#' '( /(&$*# &< )%) /%))&$ &(' =#*("$) #%*$ ;+(# '
#*/' (# "&' <& ' /("#' *$ #")*& (& % ('*(& +(# &< '#*%) 0H(++%&-H%% . T#%&$%#*/%
I&$. C(. 01991 1 C%). A==. 4' 1, 15-16, 1 C%). R='#. 2 85.
THERE WAS AN ERROR IN LAW, OCCURRING AT THE TRIAL
AND EXCEPTED TO BY DEFENDANT
- 7 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 8/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
A. N< T#*%) (& G#("& (+ E##(# *& L%< O//"##*& %' T#*%). O& %==)*/%'*(& (+ ' =%#' %#*, '
#*/' (# /*$*(& % ; %/%', *& <() (# *& =%#', %& % &< '#*%) % ; #%&', (& %)) (# $( (+
' *$$"$, (& ' #("& (+ ##(# *& )%< (//"##*& %' ' '#*%) %& /=' '( ; ' =%#' %*& '
%==)*/%'*(&, *+ $";$'%&'*%) #*'$ (+ ' %#* =%#' %# %'#*%)) %++/' '#; 0C( C*. P#(/.
65707 >D#*&$?.
. E##(# B"$' P#"*/*%). A /("#' *$ =#$$) &(*& ; A#'*/) VI, /'*(& 1, (+ ' C%)*+(#&*%
C(&$'*'"'*(& +#( #%&'*& % &< '#*%) +(# %& ##(# *& )%< "&)$$ ' ##(# *$ =#"*/*%)@ (<#, *+ '
##(# /(") =($$*;) % ;& =#"*/*%), ' /("#' "$' /(&$*# *'$ =#(;%;) ++/' %& /* '
('*(& %//(#*&), %& *+ *' /(&/)"$ '%' ' ##(# *$ =#"*/*%), % &< '#*%) *$ =#(=#) #%&'
0#(<& . G(# P==#*& F("&%'*(& 0194 2 C%). 2 256, 262, 14 P.2 929.
THERE WAS AN ERROR IN LAW, OCCURRING AT THE TRIAL
AND EXCEPTED TO BY DEFENDANT IN THAT THE COURT
ERRONEOUSLY ADMITTED AND EXCLUDED EVIDENCE AT TRIAL
A. E##(&("$ A*$$*(& (+ E*&/. T '#*%) /("#'$ ##(&("$ #")*& (& ' %*$$*(& (+ /#'%*&
*&/ *$ %& ##(# *& )%< +(# <*/ % &< '#*%) % ; #%&' *+ ' *&/ %*'' *$ &('
$"++*/*&') =#(;%'* %& #$")'$ *& =#"*/ '( ' %#* =%#' 0$ R*/%# . /('' 01978 79 C%).
A==. 57, 6-64, 144 C%). R='#. 672@ $ %)$( H())*& . C%&)# 01966 241 C%). A==. 2 19, 2, 5
C%). R='#. 219.
B. E##(&("$ E/)"$*(& (+ E*&/. A &< '#*%) % ; #%&' (& ' #("& (+ ##(# *& )%< *+ '
'#*%) /("#' ##(&("$) /)"$ /#'%*& %*$$*;) *&/ %& '%' /)"$*(& #$")'$ *& =#"*/ '( '
(*& =%#' 0$ "##("$ . &$ A"'( P%#, I&/. 01945 27 C%). 2 449, 456, 164 P.2 897 .
C. A#$ R")*& (& E*&/ D E/=' T(. A /("#'$ #")*& $"$'%*&*& (# (##")*& %&
(;/'*(& '( *&/ *$ /=' '( <*'("' +(#%) (;/'*(& 0C( C*. P#(/.
647>D#*&$?.
D. D*$/#'*(& (+ T#*%) ". I+ %& ##(# (+ )%< %$ (//"## *& ' %*$$*(& (# #/'*(& (+ *&/,
' '#*%) " % /(&$*# %)) ' /*#/"$'%&/$ $"##("&*& ' #")*&, *&/)"*& ' <*' '%' %
; %//(# '( ' 3"$'*(& *&/, ' %''*'" (+ ' *&'##(%'(#, %& %& ('# +%/' '&*& '(
$(< ' *=(#'%&/ (+ ' %*$$*(& (# #/'*(& (+ ' *&/ 0D V*/'(#*% . E#*/$(& 01948 8
C%). A==. 2 26, 28-29, 188 P.2 276.
- 8 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 9/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
THERE WAS AN ERROR IN LAW IN THAT THE COURT
ERRONEOUSLY DENIED DEFENDANTS A JURY TRIAL
A. E##(&("$ D&*%) (+ "# T#*%) I$ E##(# *& L%<. T /("#'$ ##(&("$ &*%) (+ % "# '#*%) '( % =%#'
*& %& %/'*(& '#*%;) ; "# *$ %& ##(# *& )%< +(# <*/ % &< '#*%) % ; #%&' 0$ H#&%&K .
W*)$(& 01961 19 C%). A==. 2 615, 619, 14 C%). R='#. 585@ $ %)$( (&$(& . "=#*(# C("#' 0192
121 C%). A==. 288, 292, 8 P.2 147.
B. D&*%) (+ "# T#*%) %$ B*$/%##*% (+ "$'*/. T /("#'$ &*%) (+ ' #*' '( % "# '#*%) *$ %
*$/%##*% (+ "$'*/ <*'*& ' =#(*$*(&$ (+ A#'*/) VI, /'*(& 1, (+ ' C%)*+(#&*% C(&$'*'"'*(&, %&
% &< '#*%) % ; #%&' '#(& 0H#&%&K . W*)$(& 01961 19 C%). A==. 2 615, 619, 14 C%).
R='#. 585.
ARGUMENT AND DECLARATION IN SUPPORT
D+&%&'$ #*+* %&$<# '( ' /(=)%*&' )*$'$ '<&'-+* %++*#%'* +&$$. D"#*& '#*%)
+&%&'$ <# =#&' +#( #/*$*& '*# #*' '( =#$&' (#%) '$'*(& (& '*# (<& ;%)+, /%))
%& %*& %'#*%) <*'&$$$ (# =#$&' *;*'$ *& $"==(#' (+ '$ +&$$ '( ' /("#' %' ' '*
(+ '#*%). P)%*&'*++, (<#, <%$ %))(< '( +")) =#$&' *'$ /%$ <*'("' +%*# %#"&' +#( ' +&$.
T*$ *$ /)%#) (/"&' <*'*& ' /("#'$ '#*%) *&"'$.
O& B% 2, 214, +&%&', N%&/ DL(%/, $# (& ' =)%*&'*++ %& +*) <*' ' /("#' %
%& '( #/*$ # #*' '( % '#*%) ; "#. A + <%*# <%$ %)$( #3"$' %& <%$ %==#( ; '
/("#' <*' ' (## +(# '*$ <%*# ;*& +*) (& B% 2, 214. !=(& +&%&'$ #3"$' +(# ' $'%'"$
(+ '*$ #3"$', +&%&' <%$ '() '( #*< CCP 61. H(<#, CCP 61 0 $'%'$ MT /("#' %, *&
*'$ *$/#'*(& "=(& "$' '#$, %))(< % '#*%) ; "# %)'(" '# % % ;& % <%*# (+ % '#*%) ;
"#.
O& A""$' 2, 214, C#%* %& N%&/ DL(%/ +*) B('*(& *& L**& 1 '( /)" '
*&'#("/'*(& (+ *&/ &(' =#("/ *& *$/(#. T*$ ('*(& %)$( *&/)" % /)%#%'*(& ; '+&%&'$ '%' =)%*&'*++ % #+"$ '( /(=) <*' "*/*%) C("&/*) +(# DIC-15 $# *&
%//(#%&/ <*' CCP $/'*(& 96. T*$ &(&-/(=)*%&/ $(") % ;%## =)%*&'*++ +#( (++#*& %&
<*'&$$$ (# *;*'$ %' '#*%). T +&%&'$ <# =#"*/ %$ ' <# "&%;) '( =#(=#) =#=%#
+(# '#*%). !=(& /(&/&' (+ '#*%) +&%&'$ #;%)) ;#("' '*$ ('*(& '( ' %''&'*(& (+ '
/("#'. T /("#' #$=(& '%' % B('*(& *& L**& <%$ $'#*/') +(# "# '#*%)$. T $";$3"&' %))(<
- 9 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 10/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
*&'#("/'*(& (+ <*))+")) <*') *&/ %& <*'&$$$ /(&$'*'"' $"#=#*$ %& =#"*/ '( '
+&%&'$ <( #*'+")) #)* (& &%/' *$/(# $'%'"'$ '%' %# *&'& '( $%+"%# %%*&$'
$"/ $"#=#*$.
O& A""$' 28, 214 %)) *;*'$ <# %# %& *&'*+* ; ' /)#. A)) ;"' (& (+
P)%*&'*++$ *;*'$ <# %*'' $=*' ' ('*(& '( % %)) ;%##. T /("#' #%'# '%& %#(;/'*(& %+'# (;/'*(& ; ' +&%&'$ '( ' *;*'$ #;%)) $'%' '%' +&%&'$ $(") '#"$' '
/("#'$ M*&/ +*)'#. D"#*& ' (#&*' #/$$, =)%*&'*++ <%$ %))(< '( '% +&%&'$ *;*'$
( +(# +"#'# #*<. O& A""$' 29, 214, %'#*%)) #)%&' +&%&' *;*'$ <# #+"$.
T$ *&/)" %*$$*(&$ %& "*/*%) /("&/*) +(# *&'##(%'(#*$ (;'%*& "#*& ' *$/(#
=#(/$$ *&%*$$*;) %$ ' <# &(' %''(#& #%+'. H(<#, ' /("#' "'*)*K ' &'*#
+&%&' =($*'*(& #/(# %)'(" ' =($*'*(& % &( %''(#& =#$&/ %& <%$ (&) '( ; )(
<*' ' /("#'. P)%*&'*++ * &(' &('*+ +&%&'$ (+ *&+(# ' /("#' (+ <*/ =(#'*(&$ <# '( ; "$
%$ *&/. D+&%&'$ #=%') (;/' '( ' 3"$'*(&*& '#("("' ' =($*'*(& %*&%'*(&
/)%**& ' *&+(#%'*(& $("' <%$ ;(& ' $/(= (+ '*$ %/'*(&.
O& A""$' 2, 214, *& =#=%#%'*(& +(# '#*%), D+&%&'$ +*) % #3"$' '%' ' /("#' '%
"*/*%) &('*/ (+ /)%#%'*(&$ %& %*$$*(&$ % ; =)%*&'*++ "#*& %#*("$ =#*(# /("#' =#(/*&$
'%' %# /(&'#%*/'(# '( ' =)%*&$ (+ ' /"##&' %/'*(&. T$ /)%#%'*(&$ %& %*$$*(&$ *&/)"
/)%#%'*(&$ '%' ' $";/' (+ '*$ /"##&' /%$ *&()$ (&) ' /(&'#%/'"%) *&'&' (+ ' =%#'*$ M)(%&
%#&' %& +"#'# )**'*& ' $/(= (+ '*$ /"##&' %/'*(& '( *&/)" (&) ' (")%# ( <*'
&( *&()&' (+ %& ('# =#(=#', %*$$*(&$ '%' ' (")%# ( *$ +&%&'$ =#(=#' %&
+"#'# %*$$*(&$ '( /(-(<&#$*= (+ ' #%) =#(=#'. !=(& /(&/&' (+ ' '#*%) (& A""$'
28, 214 =)%*&'*++ =#(* +")) '$'*(& (& # (<& ;%)+ %& <%$ %))(< '( =#$&' <*'&$$$,
=)%*& *;*'$ %& %*& ' (==($*& =%#'*$ ;+(# #$'*& # /%$ '%' %+'#&((&. I*%'),
+&%&'$ ('*(& ' /("#' 0#;%)) +(# % '#*&%'*(& (+ &(&-$"*' ;%$ (& ' =#*(# %*$$*(&$
'%' "*/*%) &('*/ % ;& #3"$', ' +%*)"# '( =#(=#) $'%' % %)* /)%* %$ <)) %$ /*&
' $'%'"' (+ )**'%'*(&$ %$ =#*("$) $'%' *& ' +&%&'$ %&$<# '( ' /(=)%*&', %& % +%*)"# '(
' ' *&'*%# ;"#& (+ =#((+. T $";$3"&' /("#'$ #3"$' (& A""$' 29, 214 +(# % %
/(&'*&"%&/ *& (## '( %))(< ' /("#'$ #*< (+ ' +*)$ +(# '*$ %/'*(& %$ <)) %$ ' ('# %#*("$
/%$$ ;'<& ' =%#'*$ <%$ %# '( ; ' +&%&'$ "&# ' =#*$ '%' *' <%$ &/$$%# *&
(## +(# ' /("#' '( % *'$ '#*&%'*(& (& ' ('*(& +(# &(&-$"*'.
O& A""$' 29, 214, %+'# #$'*& *'$ /%$, P)%*&'*++ $";*'' '( ' /("#' % (/"&' &'*')
- 10 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION
7/18/2019 Motion for New Trial
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/motion-for-new-trial-569bc8b8361c7 11/11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
P(*&'$ %& A"'(#*'*$. T*$ (/"&', %$ <%$ =#$&', *&/)" &< /)%*$, '(#*$, %& %#"&'$
&(' =#*("$) ;#("' ;+(# ' /("#', % $=/")%'*(&$ &(' $"==(#' ; *&/ (# '$'*(&, %&
*&/)" *$#=#$&'%'*(&$ %& ('# *&+#&/$ %$ '( +&%&'$ ('*$, =($*'*(&, %& +&$$.
D+&%&'$ #$=(&$ '( '*$ (/"&' %%*& #*'#%' '%' '*$ %/'*(& *()%' ' $'%'"' (+ )**'%'*(&$
%& /(&'%*& %;*"("$ /)%*$. A*'*(&%)), +&%&'$ <# +(#/ '( #$=(& '( ' &< /)%*$
%& '(#*$ =#$&' ; ' =)%*&'*++, #3"$'*& '%' =#*("$) $";*'' %'#*%) *&/ %&
%*'*(&%) *&/ ; %//=' ; ' /("#' *& #-;"''%).
W& ' /("#' #/(&& (& =';# 24, 214, *' $'%' '%' '# <# &( +"#'# 3"$'*(&$
+(# ' =%#'*$. D+&%&'$ **%') =#(+$$ '%' '*# /%$ % &(' ' ;& +")) =#$&' '( '
/("#'. N(&')$$, ' /("#' %++*# '%' *' <(") &(' %# %& +"#'# '$'*(& (# % %& +"#'#
*&/ =#$&' '( *' '#; =#"*/*& ' +&%&'$ %& =#&'*& ' +#( %*& % +%*# '#*%).
A*'*(&%)), %)) *$$"$ #%*$ *& ' =)%*&$ % &(' ;& %#$$ *& ' /*$*(& %& *' *$*=($$*;) '( #/(&/*). F"#'#(#, ' /*$*(& $'%'$ ' +&%&' %$ C#%* W%& DL(%/ #%'#
'%& C#%* W%#&# DL(%/.
I de!"#e $%de# &e%"!'( )* &e#+$#( $%de# ',e !"-. )* ',e S'"'e )*
C"!/*)#%/" ',"' ',e *)#e0)/%0 /. '#$e "%d )##e'1
D%':
N%&/ DL(%/ C#%* DL(%/
P"#$"%&' '( L(/%) R") 2.2., ' /("#' <*)) *$$" % '&'%'* #")*& +(# '*$ %''# (& ' /("#' % ;+(# ' %#*&. T '&'%'* #")*& <*)) ; %%*)%;) %+'# 12: &((& %$ %& %"*( #/(#*&%//$$*;) %' 0916 48-648@ ' '&'%'* #")*& <*)) %)$( ; %%*)%;) %' ' /("#'$ <;$*',
<<<.=)%/#./("#'$./%.(. T '&'%'* #")*& $%)) ;/( ' +*&%) #")*& (& ' %''# %& &(
%#*& <*)) ; ) "&)$$ (#%) %#"&' *$ '*) #3"$' (# ' '&'%'* #")*& *&*/%'$ ('#<*$.R3"$'$ +(# (#%) %#"&' "$' ; % ; /%))*& 0916 48-6481 &( )%'# '%& 4: =.. (& ' /("#'
% =#*(# '( ' %#*&.
- 11 -
DEFENDANT BOTION FOR NEW TRIAL@ BEBORAND!B
OF POINT AND A!THORITIE@ DECLARATION