Module 3 Investigating Issues in the Caribbean[1]
-
Upload
vandana-ramadhar -
Category
Documents
-
view
51 -
download
4
description
Transcript of Module 3 Investigating Issues in the Caribbean[1]
Ms. F. Hyatali
MODULE 3INVESTIGATION ISSUES
IN THE CARIBBEAN
CARIBBEAN STUDIES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Research is the systematic investigation of a problem. It is the process of forwarding ideas to be tested in a systematic way, collecting raw data, converting this data to be understood and presenting conclusions.
Research is defined as a process of enquiry and investigation.
WHAT IS RESEARCH?
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
NATURE AND PURPOSE OF
RESEARCH
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
TRADITIONAL- Knowledge that would have been passed on from generation to generation. For example: Bush medicine.
EXPERIENCE- Knowledge comes through familiarity and practice.
SCIENTIFIC- Scientific knowledge is knowledge grounded in both reason and experience. It involves rigorous testing and empirical evaluation.
FORMS OF KNOWLEDGE
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
To engage in systematic enquiry.
To generate new knowledge.
To provide solutions to societal problems.
PURPOSE OF RESEARCH
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Reliability can be defined as the ability of another researcher to repeat the study exact and obtain the same results.
Validity is the degree of accuracy that reflects the reality of those being studied.
Objectivity refers to the ability to be open minded and free from personal and political bias.
Representativeness refers to whether the group being studied is typical of the larger group to which the social scientists can generalize their findings to the larger group.
TERMS IN RESEACH
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
THE RESEARCH PROBLEM
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A research problem is an intellectual stimulus (hypotheses) calling for a response in the form of scientific inquiry.
Within every research problem there are variables. A variable is an empirical property that can take on two or more values. For example: Social Class- upper, middle, lower.
Dependent variable(ISSUE) is the variable that the researcher wishes to explain.
Independent variable (CAUSES) is the variable expects to explain change in the dependent variable. It is the presumed cause of changes in the values of dependent variables.
RESEARCH PROBLEM
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
DEPENDENT AND INDEPENDENT VARIABLES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
It must be relevant to the dependent variable identified.
It is directly linked to the research problem
It is informed by existing literature and academic
studies
It provides clarity as to what the study intends to
research and where the study will be conducted.
CHARACTERISTICS OF RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A research question involves the probing of the link of a independent variable with the dependent variable. It is gives the reader a clear idea of what you are attempting to find.
A problem statement is a statement that encapsulates delimitations of the study.
A hypothesis is a tentative answer to a research problem, expressed in the form of a clearly stated relation between the dependent and independent variables.
RESEARCH QUESTION, PROBLEM STATEMENT & HYPOTHESIS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
SOURCES OF INFORMATION
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Existing literature and academic research Internet sources- Website, blogsOral histories- Biography, Auto biographiesNewspaper reportsMinutes of meetingsArchives
SOURCES OF INFORMATION
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Surveys
Focus Group
Indepth InterviewsSecondary Data
Observation METHODS OF ENQUIRY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A survey is a study made up of a large group of
people in order to collect standardized information
from them
The Factual Survey- Government Census. Attitude Survey- To obtain opinions and
preferences. The Explanatory Survey- To gain more in-depth
answers.
Surveys generally use questionnaires (Mail/ Email) and structured interviews. (Face to face /Telephone Interview)
SURVEYS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
The survey is said to very reliable. Use of the survey allows for large
quantities of data to be collected from a large sample but also in a fairly short space of time.
Generalizations can be made from findings of the research.
Data collected can be easily quantified and coded and with the aid of computers data can be analysed quickly and efficiently.
ADVANTAGES OF THE SURVEY METHOD
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Validity of the findings from the survey is questioned. There is a low return rate for mailed questionnaires and many
of the questionnaires when returned are incomplete. There is little scope to give additional information by
respondents. Interviewer bias is another strong criticism against this
method. The presence of the interviewer may influence the respondent answers since they attempt to impress the interviewer and thus bias the data. (Hawthorne Effect)
According to some theorists, the findings from surveys tend to reinforce the existing status quo in society
DISADVANTAGES OF THE SURVEY METHOD
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A focus group is defined as a form of qualitative interviewing that uses a researcher- led group discussion to generate data. (Morgan 2008, 352)
The advantage of using a focus group is that the researcher is able to hear a wide range of participants at the same time.
The focus group provides information and the researcher can determine the sample for in-depth follow up individual interviews.
One disadvantage of focus groups is the possibility of group bias. This is when an individual in group may be influenced by the consensus of the group not to share his or her true opinion. However this can be overcomed the use of individual interview to obtain the person’s feelings about such sensitive issues.
FOCUS GROUP
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
In-depth interviews are interviews in which participants are encouraged and prompted to talk about the topic under investigation without the researcher’s use of predetermined, focused, short answer questions. (Cook 2008).
AdvantagesThe researcher is able to retain some control over the direction
and content while allowing the respondents to be free in expressing his or her opinion.
Interviews are advantageous to researchers because allows the researcher the flexibility to probe the respondent for details.
Within the interview setting the researcher is able to pick up on spontaneous reactions which can be very useful in the data collection stage.
This method is very popular in the qualitative world because it is cost effective and provides rich descriptions necessary for qualitative analysis.
IN-DEPTH INTERVIEW
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
The participant and researcher is limited by the recall of the participant,
The ability of the participant to articulate his or her experiences within the timeframe of the interview and the ability of the researcher to ask the right questions to prompt a more detailed discussion that would aid analysis. The recall of information is a different process from actually observing the phenomena first hand.
Also the issue of interviewer bias comes into play as the interviewer can influence the responses. Despite an interviewer attempts to eliminate the communication of personal views, non verbal communication can override those attempts. Even the interviews gender or ethnicity can lead respondents giving answers they feel the interviewer might want to hear.
DISADVANTAGES OF IN-DEPTH INTERVIEWS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
ADVANTAGE DISADVANTAGE
Collects a large quantities of data from huge sample of people in short period of time
Doesn’t provide indepth data.
There is little personal involvement of the researcher in the data collection thus reducing interviewer bias
Research assumes what is important to test thus resulting invalid results
The data derived can be easily quantified.
Respondents may lie. They may forget events and give inaccurate information. They can leave out question.
The study is reliable as it can be repeated by another researcher to test the findings
One can identify the causal relationship and correlations of variables
QUESTIONNAIRE
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
The researcher joins the group being studied and participates in the activities of the group. This can either be overt or covert observation depending on the researcher.
AdvantagesInteractionists consider this the best means of obtaining
a valid picture of reality. The researcher is better able to understand the group’s
behaviour or the phenomena being studied since they experience many of the experiences, as that of the observed group.
Participant observation provides in-depth information that serves in generating new hypotheses or is useful in falsifying existing theories.
PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Method is very time consuming and demanding on the researcher. Scope for use of this method is seen as limited since many areas cannot be studied using participant observation e.g. criminal activities. Samples are too small for generalizations to be made from findings. Validity may also be questioned since the presence of the researcher would result in the group acting differently from the norm. This method is seen as being too subjective. Going native!Recording of the data is very problematic. This method lacks reliability.
DISADVANTAGES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
The researcher does not participate in activities of the group but merely watches and records the activities of the group without interference.
AdvantagesReduces bias in study as compared to the use of
participant observation. Recording of data would be easier since researcher not
involved in the group’s activities but is at a distance. The researcher is less likely to get emotionally involved
with the group and study is more objective in nature.
NON-PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
The validity of the data is compromised by the fact that the researcher draws conclusions about people’s behaviour with whom he did not interact. Personal bias can infiltrate.
Putting people under laboratory condition creates artificial reactions. (they will put on a show for you, natural reaction will not be seen) Hawthorne Effect
DISADVANTAGES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Secondary sources consist of data that have already been produced often by other persons.
Official Statistics- Census- population statistics that is taken up every 10 years. Advantage- Can assist in developing government policy. Disadvantage- Often distorted by government.
Historical Sources- these are documents that can assist the researcher in recreating the past. For example: Parish records, birth certificates, receipts. The problem is that they open to interpretation.
Internet sources- One must be extremely cautious in using that material. One must verify authorship, the authority of the author, the organization the author represents and objectivity of the research.
SECONDARY SOURCES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
PRIMARY AND SECONDARY SOURCES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Primary Data- This is information that consists of data that are collected by the researchers themselves during the course of their study.
Questionnaires InterviewsObservation Longitudinal StudiesCross- Sectional Studies
PRIMARY SOURCES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Secondary sources of data is information that already exists about the phenomenon being investigated.
Official statistics- Census ReportsDiaries/ Journals/ Auto biographiesBooksOfficial documents/ records
SECONDARY SOURCES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A cross-sectional study is involves observation of a sample or cross section of population or phenomena that are made in one point in time. (Barbie 2009) For example the Census gives a snap shot view of the society at that point in time.
The issue with Cross- sectional studies is that the conclusion can only account for that period in time.
You cannot generalize the findings. However it is useful for understanding causation.
CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
In contrast to Cross sectional studies, Longitudinal studies involves the study of a group over a period of time, where data collection is done in intervals.
A Longitudinal Study is designed to permit observations of the same phenomenon over an extended period.(Babbie 2009)
First used to measure changes in public attitudes- more reliable since same people would be used, the changes would not result from composition of sample. It is a form of research where quantitative data is collected in social surveys.
LONGITUDINAL STUDIES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
LONGITUDINAL STUDIES
Advantages DisadvantagesAttitudinal change can be readily seen
Time consuming
Valid data is obtained Impractical to locate sample over a period due to death, migration, refusal to participate- sample attrition *
Large number of variables can be collected over the time span and pinpointed at a later date
Behaviour will be altered over time
*Sample attrition:- depletion of original sample size, loss of members of the sample. Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
A population is the group from which the researcher will choose the sample.
The sampling frame is the list of members of the population that satisfies the requirements of the study.
A sample is a small proportion of an entire population that will be used in the research.
A sampling unit is the member of the population to be studied.
SAMPLING
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
1) It is costly to use an entire population2) It is time consuming on the researcher 3) Impractical to survey the entire population4) Since only a small number within the group is used it is then possible to make generalisations of the population once a representative sample is chosen.
WHY CHOOSE A SAMPLE?
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
1) Random:-this is where each and every member of the population has an equal and fair chance of being selected. E.g Play Whe, Picking from a hat
2) Systematic:- this is where every nth term is used from a list of items from the population. E.g. choosing every 3rd person from the roll to form the sample.
3) Stratified:- this is where the population is divided into different layers(age, sex, religion, race) and then the sample is taken. This would be a more representative sample as the same proportion chosen from the group would be reflected in the sample group.
PROBABILITY SAMPLING
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Quota:- it is considered stratified sampling but the selection within the strata are non random. E.g. a pharmaceutical company conducing research on 50 people who are over the age of 50 and strictly women.
Mud/Snowball sampling:- the sample is formed based on contact to one individual who will in turn direct/ introduce to other members of the sample. Obviously this method will be non- random and hence unrepresentative. E.g. Rapists, burglars, heroin users, collectors of Ancient Greek coins.
NON-PROBABILITY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Convenience/opportunity sampling:-involves the sample being drawn from that part of the population which is close to hand. That is, a sample population selected because it is readily available and convenient.
NON-PROBABILITY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Tabular- TablesGraphic- Bar charts, histograms, line graphs, pictures, mapsText- Thematic and content analysisTrends/ patterns- A trend is the latest development or finding
about a phenomenon. It is the general tendency of the finding. Pattern is an arrangement of repeating theme in your study.
ComparisonsCategorization
PRESENTATION OF DATA
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Main findings of in relation to the research objectives Identify areas of contention in relation to research objectivesHighlight new and interesting findings Identify limitations of the study- MethodologySuggest areas for further research
CONCLUSION/ RECOMMENDATIONS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
American Psychological Association- (APA) Modern Languages Association- (MLA) Chicago Manual of Style- (Chicago)
What is a bibliography?A bibliography is a list of sources used in conducting the
research project. It is arranged using an appropriate referencing style.
What is referencing?Referencing is an appropriate style of academic
acknowledgement of the authorship of pieces of literature used in your study.
REFERENCING STYLES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
You must receive consent of research subjects.Respect for privacy and confidentially Must maintain integrity and transparency of the research
process. Eg. Acknowledge false starts and flaws in methodology
Avoid plagiarism of other researchers intellectual property.
ETHICAL ISSUES
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Theoretical assumptionsPractical restraintsCost TimeEthical issues
WHAT FACTORS INFLUENCE OUR CHOICE OF RESEARCH DESIGN?
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Quantitative
Emphasizes the collection of data and concentrates on measuring phenomenon.
Generates statistical data.
Uses scientific methods: Experiments, Surveys.
Uses the hypothetico- deductive method.
QualitativeIt involves examination of
less tangible aspects- values, ideas. Etc.
Research is conducted in natural settings.
Inductive reasoning is used.
The methods are descriptive and narrative.
The interpretation can be difficult.
QUANTITATIVE VERSUS QUALITATIVE
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Advantages Disadvantages
1) Output of research is close to reality
Subjective and unreliable
2) In-depth feelings and meanings
Not scientific and measurable
3) rich description Cannot generalise and easy to mis-interpret
QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Advantages Disadvantages
1) used to study trends and test hypothesis
Lack depth
2) reliable and representative
Output of research has no meaning
3) easy to analyse and objective
No focus on the individual
QUANTITATIVE DATA ANALYSIS
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Surveys- A survey is a study made up of a large group
of people in order to collect standardized information
from them. The survey usually involves the use of
questionnaires or structured interviews. Questionnaire- These are a series of pre-set questions
that are handed out or mailed to respondents to be completed and returned to researcher.
Structured Interviews- These are questionnaires that are administered orally by an interviewer to respondents.
GLOSSARY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Secondary Data- This is the use of data that already
existed by researchers in the course of their study.
Research Methods- These are the tools or instruments
utilized by sociologists in gathering data.
Triangulation- the use of both quantitative and
qualitative methods.
GLOSSARY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School
Methodology involves the principles of research, how we go about creating knowledge.
Method- Is the research instrument that will be used to collect data.
Data is the raw facts and figures which when analysed is transformed into information (processed data). There are two types of data:- quantitative and qualitative.
GLOSSARY
Ms Fariah Hyatali- Naparima Girls High School