Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

11

Click here to load reader

description

We saved the best for last. In this unique panel, lawyers and e-discovery experts presented with a real-world fact pattern argue for and against cost-shifting before a top Santa Clara Court judge. The session will probe: • Appropriate use of case management strategies, • Proportionality, • The applicability of Daubert to predictive coding, and • Judicial consideration for allocating e-discovery costs. These 60 minutes are worth the price of admission.

Transcript of Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Page 1: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Friday, Oct. 11 | 11 – Noon

Page 2: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Lael Andara

IP Litigation Partner | Ropers Majeski Kohn Bentley

Page 3: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Robert Brownstone

E-Discovery Counsel & Co-Chair, Electronic Information Management

| Fenwick & West

Page 4: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Hon. Socrates Manoukian

Judge | Santa Clara County Superior Court

Page 5: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

J. William Speros

Evidence Consulting Attorney | Speros & Associates

Page 6: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Hypothetical• Defendant BrainBooster Corp. (Robert Brownstone): Sells NZT-13 advertised as containing “natural active ingredients” and to “enable people to learn more quickly and to exhibit better recall”• Class Action Plaintiffs Sean Senseless, et al. (Lael Andara): False advertising, products liability (potentially leading to loss of smell, taste, hearing and sight)

Page 7: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Hypothetical

• Motion for protective order (before Judge Socrates Manoukian) re e-mails:– Costs re restoring back-ups and reviewing e-mails– Whether/ how to employ Technology Assisted Review

• Judge’s neutral expert (Bill Speros)

Page 8: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Caveat

Ideas expressed here are intended to be informative, sometimes using hyperbole.

Consequently, these ideas do not necessarily reflect

our own opinions or experiences or those of our court, employers or clients.

Page 9: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Your Notes

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Page 10: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Your Notes

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Page 11: Mock Hearing: The Great E-Discovery Cost-Shifting Debate

Your Notes

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


Reordering Ranganathan: Shifting Behaviors, Shifting Priorities

Reordering Ranganathan: Shifting Behaviors, Shifting Priorities

Doppler Shifting by AstroCappella Doppler Shifting.

Doppler Shifting by AstroCappella Doppler Shifting.

Moving Services to the Community: Shifting the PMTCT/MCH Integration Debate

Moving Services to the Community: Shifting the PMTCT/MCH Integration Debate

Shifting Shorelines, Shifting Conservation Strategies ......September 2011 Shifting Shorelines, Shifting Conservation Strategies: Assessing Wetland Conservation Priorities in Maryland

Shifting Shorelines, Shifting Conservation Strategies ......September 2011 Shifting Shorelines, Shifting Conservation Strategies: Assessing Wetland Conservation Priorities in Maryland

Inbound Marketing: Shifting Budgets, Shifting Expectations

Inbound Marketing: Shifting Budgets, Shifting Expectations

Shifting from Debate to Dialogue: Let’s Talksrdc.msstate.edu/civildialogue/ShiftingFromDebatetoDialogue-Welbo… · Moving from Debate to Dialogue Conventional Process One right

Shifting from Debate to Dialogue: Let’s Talksrdc.msstate.edu/civildialogue/ShiftingFromDebatetoDialogue-Welbo… · Moving from Debate to Dialogue Conventional Process One right

DEBATE THROUGH DIALOGUE PROJECT International Debate ... · DEBATE THROUGH DIALOGUE PROJECT International Debate Education Association INTRODUCTION TO DEBATE Debate Through Dialogue

DEBATE THROUGH DIALOGUE PROJECT International Debate ... · DEBATE THROUGH DIALOGUE PROJECT International Debate Education Association INTRODUCTION TO DEBATE Debate Through Dialogue

Reordering Ranganathan: Shifting User Behaviors, Shifting ...

Reordering Ranganathan: Shifting User Behaviors, Shifting ...

Shifting the Dialog, Shifting the Culturegupress.gallaudet.edu/excerpts/SDSCintro.pdfindividuals, Shifting the Dialog, Shifting the Culture looks more systemically at the factors associated

Shifting the Dialog, Shifting the Culturegupress.gallaudet.edu/excerpts/SDSCintro.pdfindividuals, Shifting the Dialog, Shifting the Culture looks more systemically at the factors associated

A Middle School Guide to Debate, Mock Trial and Critical ...

A Middle School Guide to Debate, Mock Trial and Critical ...

SAU MOCK - WordPress.comsau mock –s08 . sau mock –s08

SAU MOCK - WordPress.comsau mock –s08 . sau mock –s08

A Middle School Guide to Debate Mock Trial and Critical Thinking

A Middle School Guide to Debate Mock Trial and Critical Thinking

Shifting the Peak Oil “Debate” to Strategic Managementodland/Shifting_the_PO_Debate.pdf · reported reserves, those of the OPEC countries bordering the Arabian Gulf, have been

Shifting the Peak Oil “Debate” to Strategic Managementodland/Shifting_the_PO_Debate.pdf · reported reserves, those of the OPEC countries bordering the Arabian Gulf, have been

Mock-up Test Methods (Laboratory Mock-up or Field Mock-up) · 2014-03-21 · Mock-up Test Methods (Laboratory Mock-up or Field Mock-up): ASTM E 283, Standard Test Method for Determining

Mock-up Test Methods (Laboratory Mock-up or Field Mock-up) · 2014-03-21 · Mock-up Test Methods (Laboratory Mock-up or Field Mock-up): ASTM E 283, Standard Test Method for Determining

~rII r‘scIINIcIA’n - ocr.lib.ncsu.edu · for the first scheduled debate, and no spectators were present. ... This paper mock-uph ... ”res.“for National Advertising by NATIONAL

~rII r‘scIINIcIA’n - ocr.lib.ncsu.edu · for the first scheduled debate, and no spectators were present. ... This paper mock-uph ... ”res.“for National Advertising by NATIONAL

Mock-up examples by RS Lighting Design · Mock-up Photos 6th Avenue Mock-up Garden Mock-up Photos 6th Avenue Mock-up. 12 Mock-up Photos Mock-up Mock-up Photos Mock-up. sting . Title:

Mock-up examples by RS Lighting Design · Mock-up Photos 6th Avenue Mock-up Garden Mock-up Photos 6th Avenue Mock-up. 12 Mock-up Photos Mock-up Mock-up Photos Mock-up. sting . Title:

Take the mock out of mock trials

Take the mock out of mock trials

BY SREEDEEP MOCK, MOCK! WHO’S CALLING?

BY SREEDEEP MOCK, MOCK! WHO’S CALLING?

Student Mock Election Flyer - elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov€¦ · Title: Student Mock Election Flyer Subject: Student Mock Election Flyer Keywords: Student Mock Election Flyer Created

Student Mock Election Flyer - elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov€¦ · Title: Student Mock Election Flyer Subject: Student Mock Election Flyer Keywords: Student Mock Election Flyer Created

Ethical Issues in Forensic Science: A Mock Trial Debate ( Dr. John Wang of Forensic Science Dept. of Criminal Justice California State University-Long.

Ethical Issues in Forensic Science: A Mock Trial Debate ( Dr. John Wang of Forensic Science Dept. of Criminal Justice California State University-Long.