MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township,...

29
STATE OF NEW JERSEY CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION Chris Christie Governor Kim Guadagno Lt. Governor Robert M. Czech Chair/Chief Executive Officer New Jersey is an Equal Opportunity Employer www.state.nj.us/csc MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OCTOBER 1, 2014 Robert M. Czech, Chairperson Robert E. Brenner Thomas J. Perna Richard E. Williams

Transcript of MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township,...

Page 1: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION Chris Christie Governor

Kim Guadagno

Lt. Governor

Robert M. Czech Chair/Chief Executive Officer

New J ersey is an Equal Oppor tun ity Employer

w w w . s t a t e . n j . u s / c s c

MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF

THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION

OCTOBER 1, 2014

Robert M. Czech , Ch airperson

Robert E. Bren n er

Th om as J . P ern a

Rich ard E. William s

Page 2: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 2

OCTOBER 1, 2014

*******************************************************************

A regu lar m ee tin g of th e Civil Service Com m iss ion w as h e ld on

Wedn esday, October 1, 2014, in Tren ton , New J ersey .

P RESENT: Robert M. Czech , Ch airperson , Mem bers Robert E.

Bren n er, Th om as J . P ern a an d Rich ard E. William s; P a m e la Ullm an ,

Depu ty Attorn ey Gen eral; Hen ry Mau rer, Director, Div is ion of Appeals an d

Regu latory Affa irs .

In accordance w ith L.1975, c .231, th e Secre tary to th e Civil Service

Com m iss ion open ed th e m ee tin g w ith th e fo llow in g s tatem en t:

Notice of th is m e e tin g w as fi led w ith th e Secre tary of State an d sen t

to th e Tren ton ian , Tren ton Tim es , Cou rier -P ost an d Star Ledger on

Decem ber 2, 2013, an d posted at th e Civil Service Com m iss ion , 3 Station

P laza , Tren ton , New J ersey .

All ac tion s w ere by u n an im ou s vot e un le ss oth erw ise spec ified .

Page 3: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 3

WITHDRAWAL OF AP P EALS

Th e fo llow in g appeals w ere w ith draw n an d rem oved from th e h earin g

calen dar:

Apryl Anis, Behavior Suppor t Technician , Woodbine Developmenta l Center ,

Depar tment of Human Services, release a t the end of the working test per iod.

J ames Bryant , Equipment Opera tor , Ocean County, Depar tment of Roads, remova l.

J ames Bryant , Equipment Opera tor , Ocean County, Depar tment of Roads,

suspension .

Michael Carr , Senior P lanner , City of Per th Amboy, Depar tment of Public Works,

list removal.

Richard Cot to, County Correct ion Officer , Cumber land County, Depar tment of

Correct ions, suspension .

Malikah Ferguson, County Correct ion Officer , Mercer County, Depar tment of Public

Safety, suspension .

Monica Lin to, Senior Medica l Secur ity Officer , Ann Klein Forensic Center ,

Depar tment of Human Services, resigna t ion not in good standing.

Denise Banks, Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

Determina t ion , layoff.

Wilbur Bapt ist , Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Na tea Bomar , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police, layoff.

Pablo Ca jiga , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police, layoff.

J ashan Car ter , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Omar Coulote, Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Todd Dankins, Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Rocco Desant is, Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Page 4: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 4

Isaac Eason, J r ., Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

David Fanfan , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police, layoff.

Moise F lanagan , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

William Gumbars, Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of

Police, layoff.

Shawn Harr is, Sr ., Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of

Police, layoff.

George Holmes, Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Michael J u liano, Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Anderson Mindset , Police Officer , City of Ora nge Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Travara Morton , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Br ian Mooney, Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Aydil Olivera , Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Marc P ier re, Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Michael P iserchio, Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of

Police, layoff.

J udith Rothenberger , Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of

Police, layoff.

Er ic Schneider , Police Lieutenant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Hakim Sims, Police Capta in , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police, layoff.

Page 5: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 5

J ospeh Tor torella , Police Sergeant , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Vincent Vit iello, Police Capta in , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Ar ic Webster , Police Capta in , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Yolanda Williams, Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Rennie Wilson , Police Officer , City of Orange Township, Depar tment of Police,

layoff.

Karl Powell, J r ., Sheriff Officer , At lan t ic County, Sher iff’s Depar tment , remova l.

William Reid, County Correct ion Officer , Middlesex County, Depar tment of Adult

Correct ions, remova l.

Angel Rivera , F irefighter , City of Passaic, F ire Depar tment , remova l.

Cra ig R. St ruble, Line Super in tendent , Borough of But ler , Depar tment of Public

Works, remova l.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission noted the withdrawal of appea ls without

prejudice.

SECTION A – HEARING MATTERS

A-1 SETTLEMENTS

In the Mat ter of J oseph Gar land

Middlesex County

Depar tment of Public Works

Remova l

In the Mat ter of Pa t r icia Greer

Ancora Psychia t r ic Hospita l

Depar tment of Human Services

Remova l

In the Mat ter of Michael Israel

New J ersey Sta te Pr ison

Depar tment of Correct ions

Remova l

Page 6: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 6

In the Mat ter of Annet te J ones

Ancora Psychia t r ic Hospita l

Depar tment of Human Services

Remova l

In the Mat ter of Shavon Loa tman

Ancora Psychia t r ic Hospita l

Depar tment of Human Services

Suspension

In the Mat ter of Toya Marino

Township of Irvington

Depar tment of Police

Suspension

In the Mat ter of Amber Mart inez

Hunterdon Developmenta l Center

Depar tment of Human Services

Indefin ite Suspension

In the Mat ter of J ohn Young (Consolida ted)

Hunterdon Developmenta l Center

Depar tment of Human Services

Remova l

RECOMMENDATION OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW J UDGE IN

THE ABOVE CASES – SETTLEMENTS

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission acknowledged the set t lements.

A-2 KENNETH BYNUM- CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-500

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 12403-13

Kenneth Bynum, County Correct ion Officer , Mercer County, Depar tment of

Public Safety, 10 working day suspension on charges of conduct unbecoming

a public employee, other su fficien t cause, sleeping on duty, viola t ion of a ru le,

regula t ion , policy, procedure, order or administ ra t ive decision , neglect of

duty, loa fing, idleness or willfu l fa ilure to devote a t ten t ion to ta sks which

would resu lt in danger to persons or proper ty, sleeping on duty and conduct

unbecoming a public employee.

Recommenda t ion of t he Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Uphold the 10 working

day suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

Page 7: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 7

A-3 KEVIN ENRIGHT- CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-0508

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 12816-13

Kevin Enr ight , Laborer /CDL, Hazlet Township, Depar tment of Public Works,

remova l effect ive August 7, 2013, on charges of insubordina t ion , inability to

perform dut ies, viola t ion of federa l law/regula t ions concern ing a lcohol use by

employees who opera te commercia l vehicles, other sufficien t cause, viola t ion

of the Township policies on drug, a lcohol and dr ivers licenses and viola t ion of

the a t tendance and sick leave policy.

Recommenda t ion of t he Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Modify the remova l to a

three month suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission rejected the recommenda t ion of t he

Administ ra t ive Law J udge and modified the remova l to a six

month suspension .

A-4 DOMINIC GENOVESE- CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2000

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 02422-14

Dominic Genovese, Truck Driver , Middlesex County, Depar tment of Public

Works, remova l effect ive J anuary 8, 2014 on charges of conduct unbecoming

a public employee, misuse of public proper ty, including motor vehicles and

other sufficien t causes.

Recommenda t ion of t he Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Modify the remova l to a

90 day suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission rejected t he recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge and upheld the remova l.

VOTE: Robert M. Czech (Yes)

Robert E. Bren n er (Yes)

Th om as J . P ern a (Yes)

Rich ard E. William s (No)

Page 8: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 8

A-5 WILBUR GEORGE - CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-253

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 17221-13

Wilbur George, Boiler Opera tor , J ersey City Public School Dist r ict , six

working day suspension on the charge of ch ronic and/or excessive

absenteeism.

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Modify the six working

day suspension to a four working day suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission rejected the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge and upheld the 6 working day

suspension .

A-6 BRADFORD HABERLIN - CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2471

OAL DOCKET NO. CSR: 04603-14

Bradford Haber lin , Senior Correct ion Officer , East J ersey Sta te Pr ison,

Depar tment of Correct ions, remova l effect ive March 29, 2014, on charges of

conduct unbecoming a public employee, other sufficien t cause, improper or

unauthor ized contact with an inmate, undue fa milia r ity with inmates,

pa rolees, their families, or fr iends, viola t ion of a ru le, regula t ion , policy,

procedure, order or administ ra t ive decision .

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge - Uphold the remova l.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

A-7 WILLIAM R. HENDRICKSON AND THOMAS J . VAN GORDER

(CONSOLIDATED) - CSC DOCKET NOS. 2013-2518 & 2013-2517

OAL DOCKET NOS. CSV: 4683-23 & 4684-13

William R. Hendr ickson, J r ., F ire Prevent ion Specia list and Thomas J . Van

Gorder , F ire Officia l, Vernon Township, Depar tment of Public Safety, layoffs

effect ive October 14, 2011.

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Uphold the layoffs

effect ive October 14, 2011.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

Page 9: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 9

A-8 KILE J OHNSON - CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1214

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 16283-13

Kile J ohnson, County Correct ion Officer , Mercer County, Depar tment of

Public Safety, 10 working day suspension on the charge of conduct

unbecoming a public employee, other sufficien t cause and insubordina t ion .

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Uphold the 10 working

day suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

A-9 ANGEL REILLO - CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1477

OAL DOCKET NO. CSR: 17327-13

Angel Reillo, Police Officer , Camden County, Police Depar tment , removal

effect ive November 13, 2013, on charges of viola t ions of depar tmenta l ru les

regarding t ru thfulness, neglect of duty, withholding informat ion , standards

of conduct , performance of duty, obedience to laws and regula t ions, work

expecta t ions, and respect .

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Uphold the remova l.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

A-10 ROBERT SP ARKES - CSC DOCKET NO. 2011-2974

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 01333-11

Rober t Sparkes, Geographic Informat ion Systems Specia list , Mapping,

Township of West Milford, remova l effect ive February 20, 2009, on charges of

incompetency, inefficiency or fa ilure to perform dut ies, conduct unbecoming a

public employee, neglect of duty and other sufficien t cause.

Recommenda t ion of the Administ ra t ive Law J udge – Reverse the remova l.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission rejected the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge and acknowledged the

set t lement .

Page 10: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 10

A-11 BASEM ZAGHLOUL - CSC DOCKET NO. 2012-2210

OAL DOCKET NO. CSV: 01899-12

Basem Zaghloul, Police Officer , City of Newark, Police Depar tment , 10

working day suspension on charges of conduct unbecoming a public employee,

insubordina t ion and viola t ion of the Newark Police Depar tment ru les and

regula t ions.

Recommenda t ion of t he Administ ra t ive Law J udge Uphold the 10 working

day suspension .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission a ffirmed the recommenda t ion of

the Administ ra t ive Law J udge.

Page 11: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 11

SECTION B – MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS

B-1 CHANGE IN CLASSIFICATION P LAN – TITLE INACTIVATION AND

COMMON

The Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management request s the

inact iva t ion of four loca l t it les and tha t two Sta te t it les be made common.

Page 12: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 12

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

Page 13: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 13

B-2 CHANGE IN CLASSIFICATION P LAN – TITLE CREATION

The Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management request s the

crea t ion of four new loca l t ra inee t it les.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

Page 14: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 14

B-3 CHANGE IN CLASSIFICATION P LAN – TITLE INACTIVATION

The Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management request s the

inact iva t ion of the Sta te Monitor Advoca te t it le.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

Page 15: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 15

B-4 C. B . – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1600

C. B., appea ls her r eject ion as a County Correct ion Officer candida te by

Union County Correct ions and it s request to remove her name from the

eligible list for County Correct ion Officer (C9966M) on the basis of

psychologica l unfitness to perform effect ively the dut ies of the posit ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-5 E. B . – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1105

E. B., appea ls h is reject ion as a Correct ion Officer Recru it candida te by the

Depar tment of Cor rect ions and it s request to remove h is name from the

eligible list for Correct ion Officer Recru it (S9988R) on the basis of

psychologica l unfitness to perform effect ively the dut ies of the posit ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-6 J . P . D. – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1569

J . P . D., appea ls his reject ion as a County Correct ion Officer candida te by

Union County Correct ions and it s request to remove h is name from the

eligible list for County Correct ion Officer (C9966M) on the basis of

psychologica l unfitness to perform effect ively the dut ies of the posit ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-7 T. S . P . – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1171

T. S. P ., appea ls h is reject ion as a County Correct ion Officer candida te by the

Depar tment of Cor rect ions and it s request to remove h is name from the

eligible list for Correct ion Officer Recru it (S9988R) on the basis of

psychologica l unfitness to perform effect ively the dut ies of the posit ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 16: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 16

B-8 J AMES FEHRING – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-756

Lit t le Egg Harbor Township, on beha lf of J ames Fehr ing, request s tha t he be

permit ted to pa r t icipa te in the in tergovernmenta l t ransfer program and to

complete h is working test per iod as a Police Officer with Lit t le Egg Harbor .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

B-9 BARBARA BELUSIK – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-463

Barbara Belusik appea ls the decision of the Division of Select ion Services

denying her request for a make-up examina t ion for Taxpayer Service

Representa t ive 3 (PS2142U), Depar tment of the Treasury.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-10 RICHARD A. FAIRLEY, J R. – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-368

Richard A. Fa ir ley, J r ., appea ls the decision of the Division of Select ion

Services denying h is request for a make-up examina t ion for Socia l Service

Technician (C0015S), Passa ic County.

ACTION: The Civil Service Comm ission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-11 EARL CAIN – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-691

Freehold Township request s tha t Ear l Ca in be provided with a ret roact ive

da te of permanent appoin tment as a Police Sergeant .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

B-12 OLUFEMI IJ ANDIP E – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2162

Olufemi Ijandipe, represented by Cra ig S. Gumpel, Esq., appea ls the decision

of the Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management , which upheld

the remova l of h is name from the Fire Fighter (M2554M), City of Newark,

eligible list due to h is fa ilure to meet the residency requirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 17: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 17

B-13 KENNETH IMMERSI – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2292

Kenneth Immersi, represented by Char les M. Grossman, Esq., appea ls the

decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management , which

upheld the remova l of h is name from the F ire F ighter (M2554M), City of

Newark, eligible list due to h is fa ilure to meet the residency requirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-14 MICHAEL J ALLAD – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1781

Michael J a llad, represented by Cra ig S. Gumpel, Esq., appea ls the remova l of

h is name from the F ire F ighter (M2554M), City of Newark, eligible list due to

h is fa ilure to meet the residency requirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-15 CHRISTOP HER MATEIRO – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2130

Christopher Mateiro, repr esented by Cra ig S. Gumpel, Esq., appea ls the

decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management , which

upheld the remova l of h is name from the F ire F ighter (M2554M), City of

Newark, eligible list due to h is fa ilure to meet the residency r equirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-16 RAYVONN E. MERCADO – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2456

Rayvonn E. Mercado, represented by J effrey J . Berezny, Esq., appea ls the

remova l of h is name from the F ire F ighter (M2554M), City of Newark,

eligible list due to h is fa ilure to meet the residency requirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 18: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 18

B-17 SALVATORE MONTANTI – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2351

Salva tore Montant i, represented by William D. Sayers, Esq., appea ls the

decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management , which

found tha t the appoin t ing author ity had presented a sufficien t basis to

remove the appellan t ’s name from the F ire F ighter (M2578M), We st Orange,

eligible list on the basis of fa lsifica t ion of the employment applica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-18 NADEYAH SARMAD – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-0629

Nadeyah Sarmad, a former Family Service Specia list 2 with the Depar tment

of Children and Families, represented by Laur ie Taylor , CWA Loca l 1037,

request s tha t the Civil Service Commission reinsta te her appea l of her

release a t the end of the working test per iod effect ive September 9, 2013,

which was dismissed based on the pet it ioner and her union representa t ive’s

fa ilure to appear a t the scheduled hear ing.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

B-19 MICHAEL D’ERRICO – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1992

Michael D’Err ico a ppea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management tha t h is posit ion with the Depar tment of the

Treasury is proper ly classified as an Invest iga tor 2, Taxa t ion . The appellan t

seeks an Invest iga tor 1, Taxa t ion job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-20 BRETT HAMLIN – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1007

Bret t Hamlin appea ls the decision of t he Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management which found tha t h is posit ion with the Depar tment of

the Treasury is correct ly classified as Technica l Assistan t 2, Treasury. The

appellan t seeks an Invest iga tor 3, Taxa t ion job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 19: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 19

B-21 CAROL HODGE – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-161

Carol Hodge appea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management tha t the proper classifica t ion of her posit ion with the

Civil Service Commission is Customer Service Informat ion Specia list 3. The

appellan t seeks a Pr incipa l Clerk job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

VOTE: Robert M. Czech (Abstain ed)

Robert E. Bren n er (Yes)

Th om as J . P ern a (Yes)

Rich ard E. William s (Yes)

B-22 DONALD HUBER – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1458

Donald Huber appea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management which found tha t h is posit ion with the Depar tment of

the Treasury is proper ly classified as Assistan t Chief of Opera t ions,

Treasury. The appellan t seeks a Chief of Opera t ions, Treasury job

classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-23 GLENN P ULLIAM – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1256

Glenn Pulliam appea ls the decision of t he Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management tha t the proper classifica t ion of h is posit ion with the

Depar tment of Hea lth is Occupa t iona l Hea lth Consultan t 1. The appellan t

seeks a Research Scient ist 2 job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed th a t th is appea l be

denied.

B-24 ANTHONY TARR – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1945

Anthony Tarr appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management tha t his posit ion with the Depar tment of Human

Services is proper ly classified as An a lyst 1, Hea lth Care Facilit ies (Menta l

Hea lth Services). The appellan t seeks a Sect ion Supervisor , F isca l Resources

job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 20: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 20

B-25 VALERIE TUCKER-TROWER – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2712

Valer ie Tucker -Trower appea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion

and Personnel Management which found tha t her posit ion with the

Depar tment of Hea lth is proper ly classified as Public Hea lth Representa t ive

2, Communicable Disease. The appellan t seeks a Public Health

Representa t ive 1, Communicable Disease job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied and the appellan t ’s current classifica t ion undergo a

classifica t ion review.

B-26 G. N. – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2502

G. N., a Senior Examiner , Unemployment Tax with the Depar tment of the

Labor and Workforce Development , appea ls the determina t ion of the Office of

Diversity and Compliance, Depar tment of Labor and Workforce Development ,

which determined tha t D. W. did not fa lsely a llege that the appellan t viola ted

the New J ersey Sta te Policy Prohibit ing Discr imina t ion in the Workplace.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-27 J UVENILE DETENTION OFFICER (C0788P ), CAMDEN COUNTY –

CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-677

Camden County request s tha t the eligible list for J uvenile Detent ion Officer

(C0788P), be extended for one year beyond it s or igina l expira t ion da te.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

B-28 CRISTINA OLIVIERI – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2227

Crist ina Olivier i, a former Family Service Specia list Tra inee with the

Depar tment of Children and Families, pet it ions the Civil Service Commission

for reconsidera t ion of the final administ ra t ive decision , rendered on May 14,

2014, in which the Director of the Division of Appea ls and Regula tory Affa irs

denied her request for a hear ing with respect to her release a t t he end of her

working test per iod.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is pet it ion be

denied.

Page 21: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 21

B-29 ANGELA ANDERSEN – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-255

Angela Andersen appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t she did not meet the exper ience requirements for the

promot iona l examinat ion for Clerk 2 (PM0322S), Long Beach Township.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-30 DAWN BLAKE – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-327

Dawn Blake appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion Services

tha t she did not meet , per the subst itu t ion clause, the exper ience

requirements for t he promot iona l examina t ion for Program Monitor

(PC0413S), Ocean County Prosecutor’s Office.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied and the appellan t ’s provisional posit ion undergo a

classifica t ion review.

B-31 TYRONE BRINKLEY – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2822

Tyrone Br inkley appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services, which found tha t he did not meet the exper ience requirement for

the promot iona l examina t ion for Supervisor , Repa ir and Maintenance

(PM2298R), East Orange Water Depar tment .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-32 EDWARD CONKLIN, ET AL. – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1525

Edward Conklin , Rona ld Fernandez and Mat thew Lopes appea l the

administ ra t ion of the Ent ry Level Law Enforcement Examina t ion (S9999R),

Sta tewide.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t these appeals be

denied.

Page 22: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 22

B-33 LOUIS DELGADILLO – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2682

Louis Delgadillo appea ls the determinat ion of the Division of Select ion

Services, which found tha t he did not meet the exper ience requirement for

the promot iona l examina t ion for Public Health Representa t ive 1

Communicable Disease (PS2925H), Depar tment of Hea lth .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied and the appellan t ’s provisional posit ion undergo a

classifica t ion review.

B-34 YVONNE HERNANDEZ – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-3166

Yvonne Hernandez appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services, which found tha t , per the subst itu t ion clause for educa t ion , she did

not meet the exper ience requirement for the promot iona l examina t ion for

Personnel Assistan t 2 Employee Rela t ions (PS6821G), Depar tment of

Environmenta l Protect ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-35 J EWELL HILL – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2970

J ewell Hill appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion Services

tha t she did not meet the educa t iona l requ irements for the promot iona l

examina t ion for Rehabilita t ion Counselor , Menta l Hea lth (PS6834K),

Depar tment of Human Services.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-36 RONALD J OHNSON – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-349

Ronald J ohnson appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t he was below the minimum requirements in exper ience for the

open compet it ive examina t ion for Assistan t Zoning Officer , M0152S),

P la infield.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

Page 23: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 23

B-37 ROBERT KENDRICK – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1960

Rober t Kendr ick appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t he did not meet the exper ience requirements for the

promot iona l examina t ion for Network Administ ra tor 1 (PS0581K),

Depar tment of Children and Families.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-38 DEAN LAMP E AND WILLIAM SLOAN –

CSC DOCKET NOS. 2015-76 AND 2015-127

Dean Lampe and William Sloan appea l the determina t ion s of the Division of

Select ion Services which found tha t they were below the minimum

requirements in exper ience for the promot iona l examina t ion for Capta in ,

Sta te Boa t (PS6750G), Depar tment of Environmenta l Protect ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t these appea ls be

granted.

B-39 LINDSAY LOWE – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-301

Lindsay Lowe appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion Services

tha t she did not meet the exper ience requirements for the promot iona l

examina t ion for Technica l Assistan t 3, Community Affa irs (PS7192H),

Depar tment of Hea lth.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-40 J ENNIFER ROTHER – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-345

J ennifer Rother appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t she was below the minimum requirements in exper ience for the

promot iona l examinat ion for Secreta ry, Board/Commission (PM0427S), Br ick.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

gran ted.

Page 24: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 24

B-41 GARY SCHADWILL – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-211

Gary Schadwill appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services which found tha t he was below the minimum requirements in

exper ience for the promot iona l examina t ion for Supervising E lect r ician

(PM0474S), Br ick Township School Dist r ict .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-42 P ERRIS STRAUGHTER – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-66

Perr is St raughter appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t he was below the minimum requirements in exper ience for the

promot iona l examinat ion for Supervising P lanner (PM0236S), Newark.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-43 ROSA TOTH – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-184

Rosa Toth appea ls t he determina t ion of the Division of Select ion Services,

which found tha t she was below the minimum requirements in exper ience for

the promot iona l examina t ion for Taxpayer Service Representa t ive 2

(PS7137U), Depar tment of Treasury.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-44 RICHARD WRIGHT – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2922

Richard Wright appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services, which found tha t he did not meet the exper ience req uirement for

the promot iona l examina t ion for Const ruct ion and Maintenance Technician 3

(PS6059T), Depar tment of Transpor ta t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

Page 25: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 25

B-45 DEBORAH ZUCZEK – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2069

Deborah Zuczek appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t she did not meet the exper ience requirements for the

promot iona l examinat ion for Clerk 3 (PM1620R), Elizabeth .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-46 CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MINUTES

Submit ted for adopt ion a re the Civil Service Commission minutes of it s

meet ing of September 17, 2014.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission adopted the minutes of it s

meet ing of September 17, 2014.

B-47 RECENT COURT DECISIONS

Submit ted for the Civil Service Commission’s review are summaries of recent

cour t decisions involving Civil Service Commission determina t ion s.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission noted the decisions.

B-48 J ESSICA FANE – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-761

The City of Marga te, on behalf of J essica Fane, request s tha t she be

permit ted to pa r t icipa te in the in tergovernmenta l t ransfer program and to

complete her working test per iod as a Police Officer with Marga te.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

B-49 J ERRY BURGOS – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-678

The Township of Hazlet request s tha t the eligible list for Police Sergeant

(PM2590J ), be revived in order to appoin t J er ry Burgos effect ive May 1, 2012.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

Page 26: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 26

B-50 LAVIE LINTON – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1964

Lavie Lin ton appea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management , which found tha t the appoin t ing au thor ity had

presented a sufficien t basis to remove her name from the specia l

reemployment list for Police Officer , Newark, on the basis of having an

unsa t isfactory background repor t .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-51 SEAN NALLY – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-3056

Sean Nally, represented by Michael L. Pr igoff, Esq., appea ls the

determina t ion of the Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management

upholding the remova l of h is name from the F ire F ighter (M2542M), J ers ey

City, due to h is fa ilure to meet the residency requirement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-52 MARCUS ROORDA – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-419

Marcus Roorda appea ls the decision of t he Division of Classifica t ion a nd

Personnel Management tha t the proper classifica t ion of h is posit ion with the

Depar tment of Environmenta l Protect ion is Environmenta l Engineer 2. The

appellan t seeks an Environmenta l Engineer 3 job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-53 VICTORIA YIP – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2015

Victor ia Yip appea ls the decision of the Division of Classifica t ion and

Personnel Management which found tha t her posit ion with the Depar tment

of the Treasury is proper ly classified as Accountant 3. The appellan t seeks

an Accountant 2 or Auditor 2 job classifica t ion .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

Page 27: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 27

B-54 GWENDOLEN S. CHEIN – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-276

Gwendolen S. Chein appea ls the decision of the Division of Select ion Services

denying her request for a make-up examina t ion for Socia l Worker (S0039S).

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-55 CHRISTIAN N. STEVENS – CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-1094

Christ ian N. Stevens appea ls the decision of the Division of Select ion

Services denying h is request for a make-up examina t ion for Inspector

Tra inee Mosquito Extermina t ion (C0281R), At lan t ic County.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-56 P ATRICIA CARLSON – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-426

Pat r icia Car lson appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services tha t , per the subst itu t ion clause for educa t ion , she did not meet the

exper ience requirements for the promot iona l examina t ion for Records

Manager (PC0419S), Monmouth County.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

VOTE: Robert M. Czech (Abstain ed)

Robert E. Bren n er (Yes)

Th om as J . P ern a (Yes)

Rich ard E. William s (Yes)

B-57 TODD CATON – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-375

Todd Ca ton appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion Services

tha t , per the subst itut ion clause, he was below the minimum requirements in

exper ience for the promot iona l examina t ion for Tra ffic Signal Supervisor 1

(PC0480S), Ocean County.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

Page 28: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 28

B-58 J OHN DURISH – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-86

J ohn Dur ish appea ls h is score on the examina t ion for Deputy F ire Chief

(PM2160R), Irvington.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-59 ANTONIO GARY – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-81

Antonio Gary appea ls h is score on the examina t ion for Deputy F ire Chief

(PM2160R), Irvington.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-60 J OHN HENSZ – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-74

J ohn Hensz appea ls h is score on the examina t ion for Deputy F ire Chief

(PM2161R), Pa terson .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-61 ANDREW RICCIARDI – CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-50

Andrew Riccia rdi appea ls h is score on the examina t ion for Deputy F ire Chief

(PM2161R), Pa terson .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

denied.

B-62 DONDRIA LEWIS - CSC DOCKET NO. 2015-606

The Division of Classifica t ion and Personnel Management , on beha lf of the

Depar tment of Banking and Insurance, request s tha t Dondr ia Lewis’s out -of-

t it le work exper ience be accepted to a llow her to meet the eligibility

requirements for Technica l Assistan t 1, Insurance.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is request be

granted.

Page 29: MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL … Carter, Police Officer, City of Orange Township, Department of Police, layoff. Omar ... CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING OCTOBER 1, 2014 29

B-63 J USTIN J . COLATARCI - CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2935

J ust in J . Cola ta rci appea ls the determina t ion of the Division of Select ion

Services which found tha t he did not meet the requirements for the

promot iona l examinat ion for Supervising Road Inspector (PC2299R), Passa ic

County.

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission directed tha t th is appea l be

granted.

B-64 MANAGEMENT ASSISTANT (SP ECIAL), CITY OF NEWARK –

CSC DOCKET NO. 2014-2047

The appoin t ing author ity’s fa ilure to dispose of the cer t ifica t ion for

Management Assistan t (Specia l), City of Newark, while a provisiona l is

serving in the t it le, has been refer red to the Civil Service Commission for

enforcement .

ACTION: The Civil Service Commission ordered the appoin t ing author ity

to remove the provisiona l appoin tee, make an appoin tment from

the cer t ifica t ion , and pay compliance cost s.

Th ere be in g n o fu rth er bu s in ess be fore th e Civil Service

Com m iss ion , th e m ee tin g w as adjou rn ed to con ven e on Wedn esday ,

October 22, 2014, at 10:00 a .m ., at 3 Station P laza , Trenton , New J ersey .

_______________________________

Robert M. Czech

Ch airperson

Civ il Service Com m iss io n