Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro...

10
Per. Mineral. (2008), 77, 2, -14 doi:10.2451/2008PM0008 http://go.to/permin PERIODICO di MINERALOGIA established in 1930 An International Journal of MINERALOGY, CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, GEOCHEMISTRY, ORE DEPOSITS, PETROLOGY, VOLCANOLOGY and applied topics on Environment, Archaeometry and Cultural Heritage l ABSTRACT. — Fluoro-edenite crystals from Biancavilla, a mineral characterized by various cations in different crystallographic sites, have been studied with Electron Microprobe Analysis (EMPA) and micro-Raman spectroscopy. The spectroscope used in this study was fitted with an optical microscope equipped with two polarizers and a rotating plate with a vernier, allowing precise orientation of the sample. The Raman spectra were acquired after precisely aligning the crystals with respect to the incident laser beam. The spectra recorded are discussed in relation to the chemical data from EMPA analyses. This investigation suggests that a similar methodological approach can be used to discriminate other fibrous amphiboles which can be difficult to identify by conventional techniques. RIASSUNTO. — Tramite microsonda elettronica EMPA e spettroscopia micro-Raman sono stati studiati cristalli di fluoro-edenite provenienti da Biancavilla, specie minerale caratterizzata da variabilità cationica nei diversi siti cristallografici. Lo spettroscopio utilizzato in questo lavoro è munito di microscopio ottico dotato di due polarizzatori e di un piatto rotante con nonio, accessori che permettono una precisa orientazione del campione in esame. E’ stato così possibile acquisire spettri Raman su cristalli ugualmente orientati rispetto al fascio laser incidente. Gli spettri registrati sui cristalli esaminati sono discussi in relazione alla composizione chimica determinata mediante la microsonda EMPA. Questa metodologia potrebbe essere estesa all’analisi degli anfiboli fibrosi, spesso difficili da identificare con le tecniche convenzionali. K EY WORDS : Fluoro-edenite, micro-Raman spectroscopy, amphiboles, EMPA INTRODUCTION The identification of the Raman spectra of minerals defined as “asbestos” has demonstrated that Raman spectroscopy is a powerful technique to identify the mineral phases even in minerals very close mineralogically and chemically (Blaha and Rosasco, 1978; Wang et al., 1988a; 1988b; Lewis et al., 1996; Bard et al., 1997). Recently, micro-Raman spectroscopy has been applied to mineral associations where different phases are strongly intergrown (micro-crystal associations, mineral fibres, etc.) and to thin sections obtained from rock samples (Rinaudo et al., 2003a; 2003b; Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole ELISA FORNERO 1 , MARIO ALLEGRINA 1 , CATERINA RINAUDO 1, * , SIMONA MAZZIOTTI-TAGLIANI 2 and ANTONIO GIANFAGNA 2 1 Dipartimento di Scienze dell’Ambiente e della Vita, Università degli Studi del Piemonte Orientale “Amedeo Avogadro”- Via Bellini, 25/g - 15100 Alessandria 2 Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, Università degli Studi di Roma “La Sapienza”, P.leA. Moro, 5 - 00185 Roma * Corresponding author, E-mail: [email protected]

Transcript of Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro...

Page 1: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

Per. Mineral. (2008), 77, 2, �-14 doi:10.2451/2008PM0008 http://go.to/permin

PERIODICO di MINERALOGIAestablished in 1930

An International Journal ofMINERALOGY, CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, GEOCHEMISTRY,ORE DEPOSITS, PETROLOGY, VOLCANOLOGYandappliedtopicsonEnvironment,ArchaeometryandCultural Heritage

l

AbstrAct. — Fluoro-edenite crystals fromBiancavilla,amineralcharacterizedbyvariouscationsindifferentcrystallographicsites,havebeenstudiedwith Electron MicroprobeAnalysis (EMPA) andmicro-Ramanspectroscopy.Thespectroscopeusedinthisstudywasfittedwithanopticalmicroscopeequippedwithtwopolarizersandarotatingplatewithavernier,allowingpreciseorientationofthesample.The Raman spectra were acquired after preciselyaligningthecrystalswithrespecttotheincidentlaserbeam.Thespectrarecordedarediscussedinrelationto the chemical data from EMPA analyses. Thisinvestigationsuggeststhatasimilarmethodologicalapproachcanbeusedtodiscriminateotherfibrousamphiboles which can be difficult to identify byconventionaltechniques.

riAssunto. — Tramite microsonda elettronicaEMPA e spettroscopia micro-Raman sono statistudiati cristalli di fluoro-edenite provenienti daBiancavilla, specie minerale caratterizzata davariabilitàcationicaneidiversisiticristallografici.Lospettroscopioutilizzatoinquestolavoroèmunitodimicroscopiootticodotatodiduepolarizzatoriediunpiattorotanteconnonio,accessorichepermettono

una precisa orientazione del campione in esame.E’ stato così possibile acquisire spettriRaman sucristalliugualmenteorientatirispettoalfasciolaserincidente.GlispettriregistratisuicristalliesaminatisonodiscussiinrelazioneallacomposizionechimicadeterminatamediantelamicrosondaEMPA.Questametodologiapotrebbeessereestesaall’analisideglianfibolifibrosi,spessodifficilidaidentificareconletecnicheconvenzionali.

Key words: Fluoro-edenite, micro-Raman spectroscopy, amphiboles, EMPA

introduction

The identification of the Raman spectra ofmineralsdefinedas“asbestos”hasdemonstratedthatRamanspectroscopyisapowerfultechniqueto identify themineralphaseseven inmineralsveryclosemineralogicallyandchemically(BlahaandRosasco,1978;Wanget al.,1988a;1988b;Lewiset al.,1996;Bardet al.,1997).Recently,micro-Ramanspectroscopyhasbeenapplied tomineralassociationswheredifferentphasesarestrongly intergrown(micro-crystalassociations,mineralfibres,etc.)andtothinsectionsobtainedfromrocksamples(Rinaudoet al.,2003a;2003b;

Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole

elisA Fornero 1, MArio AllegrinA 1, cAterinA rinAudo 1, *, siMonA MAzziotti-tAgliAni 2 and Antonio giAnFAgnA 2

1DipartimentodiScienzedell’AmbienteedellaVita,UniversitàdegliStudidelPiemonteOrientale“AmedeoAvogadro”-ViaBellini,25/g-15100Alessandria

2DipartimentodiScienzedellaTerra,UniversitàdegliStudidiRoma“LaSapienza”,P.leA.Moro,5-00185Roma

*Correspondingauthor,E-mail:[email protected]

Page 2: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

6 e. Fornero, M. AllegrinA, c. rinAudo , s. MAzziotti-tAgliAni and A. giAnFAgnA

2004;2005;2006;Groppoet al.,2006;Bellusoet al.,2007).Thetechniqueiscertainlyveryusefulwhenappliedtocrystalsnon-embeddedinresinsorothermaterialsasallobservedbandsmaybeascribedonly to the examinedmineralwithnointerferencefromglue,sampleholdersorsimilar.On the other hand, when analyzing preparedsamples,thinsectionsorcrystalsgluedtoasampleholder,particularcaremustbetakentodistinguishthe spectrum contribution of the mineral fromtheothercomponents.InfactallchemicalbondswhichchangetheirpolarizabilityafterinteractionwiththelaserincidentbeamareRaman-active.

TheintensityoftheRamanbandsdependsontheorientationofthesamplewithrespecttothelaser incident beam. Usually this orientationis uncontrolled, therefore the intensity of theresultant Raman bands is not indicative of theamounts of the different chemical componentsin the studiedmineral.Theamphibole silicatesshow mostly complex chemical formulas anddifferentelectrovalencesubstitutionsinequivalentcrystallographic sites. In particular, a correctassignmentof thebands isverydifficult in thespectralregion<600cm-1,wherethevibrationalmodesof thecationsoccurring inoctahedralorcubic coordination are active, because in thisspectralregionalsoliethebendingmodesoftheSiO4 tetrahedra and the vibrations of the OH–groups.

In our laboratory the Raman spectroscope isequippedwithanopticalmicroscope,twopolarizersandarotatingplatewithavernier,whichallowsustoobtainspectrafromdifferentsamplesplacedinexactlythesameorientationwithrespecttothelaserincidentbeam;thereforetheintensityoftheRamanbandsinspectraobservedfromdifferentcrystalsmaybeconsideredorientationindependent.In order to study the effect of substitutions indifferentcrystallographicsitesontheintensityandwavenumbersoftheRamanbands,weappliedthetechniquetosinglecrystalsoffluoro-edenite,anamphibolefoundintheetneanvolcaniccomplex(Gianfagnaet al.,2003;Burragatoet al.,2005).ThismineralgrowswithbothfibrousorprismatichabitasdescribedbyGianfagnaandOberti(2001).The chemical and structural characteristics ofprismaticsampleshavebeenstudiedbyGianfagna

andOberti(2001),whodeterminedthefollowingchemicalformula:

A(Na 0.56K 0.15) B(Na 0.30Ca 1.62Mg 0.03Mn 0.05)C(Mg 4.68Fe 2+

0.19Fe 3+0.10Ti 4+

0 .03) T(S i 7.42A l 0.58)O 22

O3(F 1.98Cl 0.02) 2showing different cations in theA, B and C

sites. The Raman and IR spectra of the sametypeofcrystalsstudiedbyGianfagnaandOberti(2001)havebeendeterminedanddiscussedbyRinaudoet al. (2006)onnon-preparedsamplesand with random orientations with respect tolaser incidentbeam.Amore thoroughchemicalcharacterizationbyElectronMicroprobeAnalysis(EMPA)ofseveralsamplesofprismaticfluoro-edenitedemonstratedavariabilityinthecontentofthecationsoccupyingtheA,B,CandTsites.WecollectedtheRamanspectrafromthesamesetofsampleswith thehopetocorrelate thebandsobservedintheRamanspectrawiththedifferencesinchemicalcompositionsandsiteoccupancy.Inthisstudywedescribetheresultswhilstremainingconsciousthatatheoreticalapproachtocalculatethe wavenumbers of the different vibrationalmodes would be a more conventional method.Nevertheless, the calculations of the vibrationmodesischallengingandsignificantdifferencesareobservedbetweenthecalculatedandobservedwavenumbers(Pascaleet al.,2004;Prencipeet al.,2006)formineralsinvolvingvariouscations,alsoheterovalent,inacrystallographicsiteandinsitesdifferentfromacrystallographicpointofview.

Inaddition,forenvironmentalandhealthissues,itisextremelyimportanttocorrectlyidentifyandcharacterizetheamphibolesamples(Gianfagnaet al.,2003;Gunteret al.,2003;Meekeret al.,2003;Soffrittiet al.,2004;Bruniet al.,2006;Gianfagna et al., 2007; Gunter et al., 2007). Accuratelyinterpretedmicro-Ramanspectroscopyisprovingto be a useful method to discriminate fibrousmineralswithsimilarstructureand/orchemicalcomposition(i.e.serpentineminerals)noteasilyidentifiable using other techniques such as X-RayPowderDiffractionandAnalyticalScanningElectronMicroscopy.Micro-Ramanspectroscopymightalsoproveausefulmethodwhendealingwithmineralmixturesandhelpingtoverifyresultsfromotheranalyticalmethods.

Page 3: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole 7

Methods and techniques

The prismatic fluoro-edenite crystals studiedinthisworkoriginatefromtheBiancavillaarea(intheregionofMountEtna,Sicily),withtheirfirstreportedoccurrenceassecondarymineralinthe lava fissures. Gianfagna and Oberti (2001)structurally characterized these fluoro-edenitesamplesanddescribedtheirchemicalvariability,provingheterovalentsubstitutionsinthedifferentcrystallographicsites.

In the present work, a suite of prismaticfluoro-edenite crystals are characterized byElectronMicroprobe(EMPA)andmicro-RamanSpectroscopy.54millimetric-sizedsinglecrystalswerepreviouslypreparedinthinsection(enclosedin resindirectlyonslide, thinned,polishedandgraphitized). Selected single crystals, like thatrepresentedinFig.1,wereanalyzedbyEMPAtoassessthedifferencesinthechemicalcomposition.ElementalcompositionofthestudiedcrystalswasobtainedwithaCamecaSX-50electronmicroprobe(IGAG,Rome“LaSapienza”)underthefollowingoperatingconditions:15kVacceleratingvoltage,15nAbeamcurrent,3µmbeamsize,20speakcount-time and 10 s background count-time.Calibrationwasperformedusing the followingstandards:wollastonite(SiKα,CaKα),rutile(TiKα),corundum(AlKα),magnetite(FeKα),metallicMn(MnKα),orthoclase(KKα),jadeite(NaKα),fluorophlogopite(FKα)andsylvite(ClKα).

Somesamples,chemicallyanalysedbyEMPA,were thencharacterizedbymicro-Ramanunder

a Jobin Yvon HR800 LabRam μ-spectrometer, equippedwithanOlympusBX41microscope,arotatingplatewithvernier,aHeNe20mWlaserworkingat632.8nmandaCCDair-cooleddetector.ThecalibrationoftheinstrumentwasobtainedbycheckingnotonlythepositionoftheSibandat±520.6cm-1,butalsoitsintensity,takingparticularcaretoregisterallspectrastartingwiththesameinitialintensity,measuredonaSistandardsample.Inorder tobalance thesignalagainstnoise,10cycles of 200 scans were performed on eachsample.Duringpreparationofthethinsectionsallthefluoro-edenitecrystalswerepositionedwiththehk0faces,whicharealsocleavageplanes,paralleltotheslice,thereforeweanalyzedinEMPAandmicro-Ramancleavagesofthestartingsamples.AfterEMPAanalyses,sixselectedcrystalswereseparatedfromthesectionandtapedontoaslide.InordertoverifythecrystallographicorientationofthecrystalsselectedforRamananalysis,anopticalstudyunderapolarizedmineralogicalmicroscopewasalsoperformed.Bytheobservedinterferencefigures(off-centeredopticalaxes),itwasconfirmedthatallcrystalswere lyingonthecleavagehk0planes.For theRamancharacterization, all thecrystalswereorientedexactlyinthesamepositionwith respect to the elongation axis. RamanspectrawereinitiallyregisteredwiththecrystalspositionedwiththeelongationaxisparalleltotheN-Sdirectionofthecross-hairoftheocularlensofthemicroscope,thenat90°withrespecttothepreviousorientationandfinallyat45°.Inthisfinalposition, the most defined and intense Ramanbandswereobserved,thereforeintheremainderoftheworkthespectraweredescribedoncrystalsplacedwiththeirelongationat45°withrespecttoN-Sdirectionofthecross-hairoftheocularlens.TheRaman region corresponding to the latticemodes,1200–200cm-1,wasanalyzedindetail.Inordertoobtainbettercomparisonsofthecollectedspectra,therawspectraareshown(i.e.,theyhavenotbeenprocessed).

results and discussion

Table1showstheaveragechemicalcompositionofthe54crystalsstudiedherein.DespitesignificantcompositionalvariationsofSiO2,Al2O3,MgOandCaOcontents,all thecrystalsmaybeclassified

Fig.1–Polarizedlightimageofaselectedfluoro-edenitecrystal.

Page 4: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

8 e. Fornero, M. AllegrinA, c. rinAudo , s. MAzziotti-tAgliAni and A. giAnFAgnA

as“edenite”.Forthepresentedstudysixcrystals,consideredrepresentativefortheentiresuite,wereselected.

Thesixcrystals,labeled:3,4,9,10,31and48areshownplottedinFig.2intheLeakediagram(Leakeet al.,1997).

Sample3showsthehighestcontentofAl2O3,primarilylocatedintheTsites.Crystal4representsahalfwaypointbetweensamples9and31.Sample9ischaracterizedbythehighestamountinSiO2,MgO and Na2O, the lowest content in CaO,sodiumcontenthigherintheBsitesthanintheAsitesandpotassiumcontentcomparablewiththosedetectedintheotherstudiedcrystals.Crystal31isveryclosetotheaveragecompositionforthesix samples described in thiswork.Sample48isthecrystalwiththelowestamountofSiO2.Inaddition,samples10and48exhibitahighcontentinNa2O,TiO2andMnO.ThesecrystalshavethehighestoccupancyoftheAsites,asaconsequenceof both high content in calcium and high∆C(Mn,Fe2+,Mg)value,seeTable2.Despitesamples10and48showingasimilaraveragecomposition,we included both samples because sample 10

showsawidecompositional range,while48 ismorechemicallyhomogeneous.

Table2 shows the chemical formulas for thesixcrystalscalculatedonthebasisof24(O+F+Cl)apfuandFe3+/∑FetotdeterminedbyMössbauerSpectroscopy.

Unfortunately, the small dimensions of theindividualfluoro-edenitecrystalsusedforRamananalysispreventeddeterminationoftheFe3+/∑Fetotratioforeachsampleandameanvalue,obtainedbyMössbauerSpectroscopyon~20mgofpowderedcrystals(Gianfagnaet al.,2007),wasnecessarilyconsidered.Howeverinthesixanalyzedsamplesthe total FeO content is very close (Table 1),and the partition between Fe2+ and Fe3+ in therespectivecrystalchemicalformula(Table2)maybeconsideredreliable.

Asdescribedearlier,thespectroscopicdatawerecollectedonhk0cleavages,alwaysorientedwiththeirelongationaxisat45°withrespecttotheN-Sdirectionof theocular lenscross-hair.Three tofourRamanspectrawerecollectedoneachsamplewiththesameorientationbutdirectingthelaserbeamtodifferentareas,howevernodifferences

3 4 9 10 31 48 Average* Average **SiO2 51.58 52.47 53.93 51.91 52.92 51.46 52.38 52.38TiO2 0.61 0.59 0.04 0.73 0.55 0.62 0.52 0.57Al2O3 4.50 4.17 3.04 4.07 3.87 4.41 4.01 4.07FeOtot 2.58 2.32 2.49 2.48 2.34 2.59 2.47 2.39MnO 0.46 0.53 0.47 0.54 0.48 0.57 0.51 0.51MgO 22.45 22.61 23.05 22.63 22.78 22.6 22.69 22.66CaO 11.05 11.07 10.36 10.87 11.03 10.77 10.86 11.01Na2O 3.12 3.07 3.28 3.18 3.03 3.25 3.15 3.10K2O 0.92 0.81 0.84 0.86 0.84 0.83 0.85 0.85F 4.43 4.56 4.63 4.35 4.28 4.55 4.46 4.49Cl 0.07 0.07 0.09 0.08 0.06 0.09 0.08 0.08Total 101.78 102.27 102.24 101.71 102.22 101.75 102.00 102.15-(F+Cl=O) 1.88 1.93 1.97 1.85 1.82 1.93 1.90 1.91Total 99.90 100.33 100.27 99.86 100.41 99.82 100.10 100.23

tAble 1 – Results of quantitative analyses of fluoro-edenite crystals from Biancavilla

*Derivedfrom6analysesofprismaticfluoro-edenite**Drivedfrom54analysesofprismaticfluoro-edenite

Page 5: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole 9

inwavenumbersandintensityofthebandsweredetected; thus,on thesamecrystalandalongasamecrystaldirectiontheresultsarereproducible.In Figs. 3 a-f a Raman spectrum from the sixfluoro-edenitecrystalsisshown.Spectralartifacts,attributable to theadhesive tapeused to fix thethinsectionstothesupportglass,weresometimesdetectedonsample48andalwaysonsample4.Onthesecrystalsbandsat1166,1114,1073,910,878,847,653,516cm-1,neverobservedonnon-preparedsamples(Rinaudoet al.,2006),appearonthespectra,Fig.3b.Moreover,thebandnear1040cm-1showsananomalousintensity.Ramanspectra,fromtheglassandfromtheglassonwhichthe adhesive tape was added, were collected.

Theresult fromthe last test isshowninFig.4,provingthatwhentheamphibolecrystalismoretransparent,asonsamples4or48,thecontributionoftheforeignmaterialsisdetectableontheRamanspectrum.Itshouldbenotedthatthespectrumforsample48,reportedinFig.3f,waschosenwherethe scattering from thematerialused to fix thecrystalwaslessstrong.

BaseduponthespectrashowninFigs.3a-fandthechemicaldatainTable1,wecandeterminethefollowing relationshipsbetweenRamanspectraandchemicalcomposition:

•inrespectoftheamountofSiandAl,cationsintetrahedralsites,sample9representsthecrystalwith the highest content of SiO2 – almost 1%

Fig.2 – Classification graph plotting the composition of the six crystals analyzed in this work. The average chemical2– Classification graph plotting the composition of the six crystals analyzed in this work. The average chemicalClassificationgraphplottingthecompositionofthesixcrystalsanalyzedinthiswork.Theaveragechemicalcompositionsforthese6samplesandforall54crystalsarealsoreported;modifiedbyLeakeetal.(1997).

Page 6: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

10 e. Fornero, M. AllegrinA, c. rinAudo , s. MAzziotti-tAgliAni and A. giAnFAgnA

higher than in theother samples.Therefore theAl-Si substitutions in the tetrahedral sites arelowestinthissample.IntheRamanspectra(Fig.3c),themostintenseband,assignedtosymmetricstretching modes (νs)A1goftheSi-Ob-Silinkages,liesat679cm-1andthebandsat1061and1042cm-1,ascribed to antisymmetric stretching vibrations (νas)of the Si-Ob-Si linkages appear as two distinctbands.Finallythebandat929cm-1, νsmodesof

theO-Si-Obonds, isbetterdefined than in thespectrafromalltheothersamples.Inconsideringthespectrafromsamples48and3,Figs.3fand3arespectively,correspondingtosampleswiththelowestamountofSiO2 (see Tables 1 and 2) the (νs)A1gmodes lieat678cm-1andthebandat1061cm-1disappears.Moreoverthebandnear925cm-1,produced by the νsmodesof theO-Si-Obonds,appearslargeandconvoluted;

3 4 9 10 31 48 Average * Average **

Si 7.216 7.287 7.469 7.262 7.348 7.203 7.298 7.289IVAl 0.742 0.681 0.496 0.672 0.619 0.728 0.659 0.667

∑T 7.958 7.970 7.965 7.933 7.982 7.931 7.956 7.957

VIAl 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000†Fe3+ 0.277 0.246 0.264 0.265 0.249 0.278 0.263 0.255†Fe2+ 0.025 0.023 0.024 0.024 0.023 0.025 0.024 0.023

Mg 4.682 4.682 4.759 4.720 4.716 4.715 4.712 4.701

Ti 0.064 0.062 0.004 0.077 0.058 0.065 0.055 0.060

Mn 0.055 0.062 0.055 0.064 0.056 0.067 0.060 0.060

∑C 5.104 5.077 5.107 5.151 5.115 5.150 5.117 5.099

ΔC(Mn. Fe2+. Mg) 0.104 0.077 0.107 0.151 0.115 0.151 0.117 0.105

Ca 1.657 1.648 1.537 1.630 1.641 1.615 1.621 1.642

Na 0.240 0.275 0.356 0.220 0.244 0.234 0.261 0.253

∑B 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 2.000

Na 0.607 0.551 0.523 0.642 0.573 0.649 0.591 0.584

K 0.164 0.144 0.149 0.154 0.149 0.149 0.151 0.151

∑A 0.770 0.695 0.672 0.796 0.722 0.797 0.742 0.736

tAble 2 – Crystal-chemical formulae of the six prismatic crystals analyzed by micro-Raman spectroscopy, calculated on the basis of 24 apfu (O + F + Cl)

*Derivedfrom6analysesofprismaticfluoro-edenite**Derivedfrom54analysesofprismaticfluoro-edenite†Fe3+/FetotwasevaluatedbyMössbauerSpectroscopy

Page 7: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole 11

Fig.3a-f–Ramanspectraoffluoro-edenitesamplesintheregion1200-200cm-1.Fromatof:sample3,4,9,10,31and48respectively.

Page 8: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

12 e. Fornero, M. AllegrinA, c. rinAudo , s. MAzziotti-tAgliAni and A. giAnFAgnA

•inthespectraofsamples10and48(Figs.3dand3f)alargefluorescencehumpoccursunderlyingtheRamanbands.Itcanalsobenotedthatthesesamples correspond to fluoro-edenite with anhigheramountofFeO+MnO+TiO2(3.75and3.78,respectively)substitutingMgOintheCsites;

•consideringnowthebandnear380cm-1,wherenointerferenceofadhesivetapeisseen,weobservethatinthesample9(Fig.3c),correspondingtothelowestamountofCaOandthehighestcontentofNa2O,aconvolutedbandat381cm-1wasdetected.InsampleswithincreasingCaOconcentrations,abandnear365cm-1appearsmoreandmoredistinctuntil sample 4 (Fig. 3b), where two separatedbandsat382and366cm-1werevisible.

Forallcrystals,theRamanspectrumintheregioncorresponding toOH–vibrationswasregisteredalthoughnobandswereobserved,confirmingthechemicaldataofTable1concerningthepresenceofF–andCl–substitutingtheOH–.

The present work would be a contributionto the understanding of the effects of cationsubstitutions in thewavenumbersof theRaman

bandsinamphiboleminerals.ChemicalanalysesandRamanspectroscopyhavebeencarriedoutonthesamesamplesoffluoro-edenite.Thecouplingof the optical microscope with a rotating plateallowedconsistentorientationsforeachsamplewithrespecttotheincidentlaserbeam.Althoughatthemomentthetechniqueseemsmoresensitivetotetrahedralsubstitutions,manyotherspectroscopicstudiesmustbeperformedoncrystalsonwhichquantitativechemicalanalyseshavebeencarriedout.Useofaspindle-stageequippedmicroscopecould allowcollectionofRaman spectra alongthe principal vibration directions of opticallyanisotropiccrystalsasdiscussedinGunteret al.(2005)andGunterandTwamley(2001)oralongtheircrystallographicdirectionsasdiscussed inGunterandTwamley(2001).

Nevertheless,animportantobservationcanbedrawnfromthisstudywhenRamanspectroscopyisappliedonsamplesthatusesometypeofmountingmedia:everyforeignmaterialmaybeRamanactiveandthereforeitscontributiontotheobservedbandsmustbeconsidered.NewRamanbandsorthoseof

Fig.4–Ramanspectrumregisteredontheglassonwhichadhesivetapewasadded.

Page 9: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro-edenite amphibole 13

anomalousintensitymustbecarefullystudiedinordertobesurethattheyarenotproducedbythemountingmedia,bythematerialsusedtopreparethesample,orbytheuseofaparticularexcitationsource.From theseconsiderations it isobviousthat Raman spectrum must be collected fromsampleswhichhaveundergonenopriorsamplepreparation,thuseliminatingtheextraneousbandsinthespectra.

Finally,thisstudyontheprismaticfluoro-edeniterepresentsafirststeptostudytheamphibolefibresfrom Biancavilla which exhibit compositionalvariation.Specific investigationson thefibrousphasescoulddemonstratethepresenceofdifferentcompositions in the fibres in the geologicalsetting.

AcKnowledgeMents

TheauthorswishtothankProf.G.DellaVenturaandProfM.E.Gunter for thehelpfulsuggestionsandthe“Ministerodell’UniversitàedellaRicerca”of Italy for financial support (PRIN2004project:“Spectroscopicandcomputationalcharacterizationoffibrousmineralsnotclassifiedasbestos”).

REFERENCES

bArd t., yArwood J. and tylee b.(1997)-Asbestos fiber identification by Raman microspectroscopy.J.RamanSpectrosc., 28,803-809.

belluso e., Fornero e., AlbertAzzi g., cAiro s. and rinAudo c. (2007) - Use of micro-Raman spectroscopy to distinguish carlosturanite from the serpentine minerals.Can.Mineral.,4�,1495-1500.

blAhA J.J. and rosAsco g.J. (1978) - Raman microprobe spectra of individual microcrystals and fibres of talc, tremolite, and related silicate minerals.Anal.Chem.,�0,892-896.

bruni b.M., PAcellA A., MAzziotti-tAgliAni s., giAnFAgnA A. andPAoletti l. (2006) -Nature and extent of exposure to fibrous amphiboles in Biancavilla.Sci.TotalEnviron.,370,9-16.

burrAgAto F., coMbA P., bAiocchi V., PAllAdino d.M., siMei s., giAnFAgnA A., PAoletti l. and PAsetto r.(2005)-Geo-volcanological, mineralogical and environmental aspects of quarry materials related to pleural neoplasm in the area of Biancavilla, Mount Etna (Eastern Sicily, Italy).Environ.Geol.,47,855-868.

giAnFAgnA A., Andreozzi g., bAllirAno P., MAzziotti-tAgliAni s. and bruni b.M.(2007)-Structural and chemical contrasts between prismatic and fibrous fluoro-edenite from Biancavilla Sicily, Italy.Can.Mineral.,4�,249-262.

giAnFAgnA A., bAllirAno P., bellAtrecciA F., bruni b.M., PAoletti l. and oberti r. (2003)-Characterisation of amphibole fibres linked to mesothelioma in the area of Biancavilla, Eastern Sicily, Italy.Mineral.Mag.,67(6),1221-1229.

giAnFAgnA A. and oberti r.(2001)-Fluoro-edenite from Biancavilla (Catania, Sicily, Italy): Crystal chemistry of a new amphibole end-member.Am.Mineral.,86 (11-12),1489-1493.

groPPo c., rinAudo c., gAstAldi d., cAiro s. and coMPAgnoni r. (2006) - Micro-Raman spectroscopy for a quick and reliable identification of serpentine minerals from ultramafics.Eur.J.Mineral.,18,319-329.

gunter M.e.,belluso e.andMottAnA A.(2007)-Amphiboles: Environmental and health concerns.HawthorneF.C.,ObertiR.,DellaVenturaG.andMottanaA.Eds.TheMineralogicalSocietyofAmerica-Chantilly(USA),545pp.

gunter M.e., downs r.t., bArtelMehs K.l., eVAns s.h., PoMMier c.J.s., grow J.s., sAnchez M.s., and bloss F.d. (2005)-Optic properties of centimeter-sized crystals determined in air with the spindle stage using EXCALIBRW.Am.Mineral.,90,1648-1654.

gunter M.e., dyAr M.d., twAMley b., Foit F.F. and cornelius s. (2003) - Composition Fe3+/∑ Fe, and crystal structure of non-asbestiform and asbestiform amphiboles from Libby, Montana, U.S.A.Am.Mineral.,88(12),1970-1978.

gunter M.e. and twAMley b. (2001) - A new method to determine the optical orientation of biaxial minerals: A mathematical approach.Can.Mineral.,39,1701-1711.

leAKe b.e., woolley A.r., ArPs c.e.s., birch w.d., gilbert M.c., grice J.d., hAwthorne F.c., KAto A., Kisch h.J., KriVoVicheV V.g., linthout K., lAird J.o, MAndArino J.A., MAresh V.w., nicKel e.h., rocK n.M.s., schuMAcher J.c., sMith d.c., stePhenson n.n., ungAretti l., whittAKer e.J.w. and youzhi g. (1997) - Nomenclature of amphiboles: report of the subcommittee on amphiboles of the International Mineralogical Association, Commission on New Minerals and Mineral Names.Am.Mineral., 82,1019–1037.

lewis i.r., chAFFin n.c., gunter M.e. and griFFiths P.r.(1996)–Vibrational spectroscopic studies of asbestos and comparison of suitability for remote

Page 10: Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied on oriented crystals of fluoro …tetide.geo.uniroma1.it/riviste/permin/testi/V77.2/2008PM... · 2008. 9. 16. · Micro-Raman spectroscopy applied

14 e. Fornero, M. AllegrinA, c. rinAudo , s. MAzziotti-tAgliAni and A. giAnFAgnA

analysis.Spectrochim.ActaA,�2,315-328.MeeKer g.P., bern A.M., brownField i.K., lowers

h.A., sutley s.J., hoeFen t.M. and VAnce J.s. (2003) - The Composition and Morphology of Amphiboles from the Rainy Creek Complex, Near Libby, Montana. Am. Mineral., 88(12), 1955-1969.

PAscAle F., tosconi s., zicoVich-wilson c., ugliengo P., orlAndo r. and doVesi r. (2004)–Vibrational spectrum of brucite, Mg(OH)2: a periodic ab initio quantum mechanical calculation including OH anharmonicity.Chem.Phys.Lett.,396,308-315.

PrenciPe M., noel y., ciVAlleri b., roetti c. and doVesi r. (2006) - Quantum-mechanical calculation of the vibrational spectrum of beryl (Al4Be6Si12O36) at the Γ point.Phys.Chem.Miner.,33,519-532.

rinAudo c., belluso e. and gAstAldi d. (2004)-Assessment of the use of Raman spectroscopy for the determination of amphibole asbestos.Mineral.Mag.,68(3),455-465.

rinAudo c., gAstAldi d., belluso e. and cAPellA s.(2005)-Application of Raman Spectroscopy on asbestos fibre identification.N.Jb.Miner.Abh.,182/1,31-36.

rinAudo c., gAstAldi d. and belluso e. (2003a)

- Characterization of chrysotile, antigorite and lizardite by FT-Raman Spectroscopy.Can.Mineral.,41,883-890.

rinAudo c., gAstAldi d. and belluso e. (2003b)-La spettroscopia Raman: tecnica di identificazione rapida di fibre di asbesto.Siticontaminati,2,116-120.

rinAudo c., gAstAldi d., cAiro s., giAnFAgnA A., MAzziotti-tAgliAni s., tosi g. and conti c. (2006)-Characterization of fluoro-edenite by μ-Raman and μ-FTIR spectroscopy.Mineral.Mag.,70(3),291-298.

soFFritti M., MinArdi F., buA l., degli esPosti d. and belPoggi F. (2004)-First experimental evidence of peritoneal and pleural mesotheliomas induced by fluoro-edenite fibres present in Etnean volcanic material from Biancavilla (Sicily, Italy).Eur.J.Oncol.,9,169-75.

wAng A., dhAMelincourt P. and turrell g. (1988a)-Raman Microspectroscopic Study of the Cation Distribution in Amphibole.Appl.Spectrosc.,42,1441-1450.

wAng A., dhAMelincourt P. and turrell g. (1988b)- Infrared and Low-Temperature Micro-Raman Spectra of the OH Stretching Vibrations in Cummingtonite.Appl.Spectrosc.,42,1451-1457.