mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005...

175
RD-R167 273 CONMANDER FLEET ACTIVITIES SRSEDO FLEET MOORINGS 1P2 UNDERUATER INSPECTION REPORT(U) NAVARL FACILITIES ENGINEERING COMKAND MASNINGTON DC CHESAPERCE DIV UNCLASSIFIED SEP 03 CRES/NAVFRC-FPO-1-83(28) F/O 13/10 ML mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME

Transcript of mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005...

Page 1: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

RD-R167 273 CONMANDER FLEET ACTIVITIES SRSEDO FLEET MOORINGS 1P2UNDERUATER INSPECTION REPORT(U) NAVARL FACILITIESENGINEERING COMKAND MASNINGTON DC CHESAPERCE DIV

UNCLASSIFIED SEP 03 CRES/NAVFRC-FPO-1-83(28) F/O 13/10 ML

mhhhhhhhhhhhhu

mhhhhmhhhhME

Page 2: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

iiut 11.02.1122

NhII=IL2 0

1.813

1..25 0'1111 ~*~ -

MICROCOPY~~ RESLUIO TETCHR

NAIN LB R AUO-Y N A D 1 9638 A

'IN'________ ______%

Page 3: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.................... ............................. ..........................

.. ............... .............FPO ............ ............... ............... ............... ............... .......................

ST OF 7:

DTICZLECTEAPR 3 0 W6

DIV N... ... . ... .. ... .. .. .... ... . .. .... .... ...... .. .. .. .. ... ... .. .

(v)....... ....................... .. . ... .. ... .. ...................... ............. COMMANDER FLEETCv.. ... .. .... ... .. ... ..... .. .. ..... ..... ............ ............... ... .. ..... .. .. .. ...... .. .. .. .. ... .. ... .. ... .. ... .... .. ... ...... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .... ... ... ... ... ... .. .......... ................ .. ... .... .. .. .... ..... .. ... .... .. .... ...... ... ... ... ... .. ... .. .... ... .... ... ... .. ...to %'*'1'1'.*%*1 "*'1'1'1*.****.*"1*1*1* A CTIV ITIES SA SEBO.. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .... ... .. .... ... ... .. ........... ................. .. ... .... .. ... .. .......... ................................... ................ .. .. ... .. ... .. .. ... .......... ....................... ............... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. ... ............ ......... FLEET MOORINGS.......... ..................... .............................. ....................... ............... ................ ............... ... .. .. ... ... ... .. .. ... .. .. .. .. .. ... ... .. .. . UNDERWATER... ....... ........................ ................ .. .. ... ... ... ... .. ............. ....................... ........................ ...................... ........................ ....................... ......... * .............. ......... .............. ............................... INSPECTION.. ........................ ................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .............REPORT............. .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... .......................... ................ ... ... .. .. ..... .... .. ............... ............. forigla" 0ausat" solos,... ...................... .......pUtes s All D216 roproduat.......... .. ..................... .......... 1 Mau be As bimt ad............. .......................... ........................... .......................... .......................... ...................................................................................................................................... SEPTEMBER 1983.. ............ ........... ............ ............ ............ ............ ........... ............ ........... ............ ........... ............ ........... ........ OCEAN ENGINEERING

AND CONSTRUCTION PROJECT OFFICECHESAPEAKE DIVISION.... ....... wl........ NAVAL FACILITIES ENGINEERING COMMAND..... ........... .......

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20374

...... ...... FP0 -1 -83(28)K

ot., TtATEmrmr' A...... Approved for public rejewcj

patribuom

....... ....

........ ....

27. 0 ki... . .........

Page 4: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

UnclassifiedSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE

REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGEla. REPORT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION lb. RESTRICTIVE MARKINGSUnclassified

2a. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION AUTHORITY 3. DISTRIBUTION AVAILABILITY OF REP.Approved for public release;distribution is unlimited

2b. DECLASSIFICATION/DOWNGRADING SCHEDULE

4. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER 5. MONITORING ORGANIZATION REPORT #FPO-I-83(28)

6a. NAME OF PERFORM. ORG. 6b. OFFICE SYM 7a. NAME OF MONITORING ORGANIZATIONOcean Engineering& Construction FProject OfficeCHESNAVFACENGCOM

6c. ADDRESS (City. State. and Zip Code) 7b. ADDRESS (City. State. and Zip ) 'BLDG. 212. Washington Navy YardWashington, D.C. 20374-2121Ba. NAME OF FUNDING ORG. 8b. OFFICE SYM 9. PROCUREMENT INSTRUMENT INDENT # --

8c. ADDRESS (City. State & Zip) 10. SOURCE OF FUNDING NUMBERSPROGRAM PROJECT TASK WORK UNIT 'ELEMENT # * * ACCESS #

11. TITLE (Including Security Clas.ification)

Commander Fleet Activities Sasebo Fleet Moorings Underwater Inspection Report

12. PERSONAL AUTHOR(S)

13a. TYPE OF REPORT 13b. TIME COVERED 14. DATE OF REP. (YYMMDD) 15. PAGESFROM TO 83-09 67

16. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTATION/ , / I-""

17. COSATI CODES 1 . SUBJECT TERMS (Continue on reverse if nee.)FIELD GROUP SUB-GROUP )*Mooring inspection. Underwater inspection.

Fleet mooringsK€ommander Fleet ActivitiesSasebo. Sasebo. Japan

19. ABSTRACT (Continue on reverse if necessary & identify by block number)This report contains results of the inspection of 34 fleet moorings operatedand maintained by the Commander Fleet Activities. Sasebo. Japan. A CHESNAV-ENGCOM-assigned Engineer-in-Charge and divers from Underwater ConstructionTeam Two conducted the inspection from 10-20 May 1983. (Con't)20. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY OF ABSTRACT 21. ABSTRACT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION o

SAME AS RPT.22a. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE INDIVIDUAL 22b. TELEPHONE 22c. OFFICE SYMBOLJacqueline B. Riley 202-433-3881DD FORM 1473. 84MAR SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE

. I

Page 5: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

BLOCK 19 (Con't)

Of the 34 moorings inspected. 31 were found to be satisfactory for continueduse at their rated class. One required downgrading to a lower mooring P.classification. and two were found to be in poor condition and recommended for -overhaul at the earliest practical time. Additionally, a thorough designreview to determine the adequacy of these Japanese built moorings to withstandthe forces associated with the mooring classes, as defined in NAVFACENGCOM'sDM-26. is recommended. Specific comments concerning each of these moorings

and recommendations for future actions are included in this report. F

°'.

. 4-'i-

SPI°

Page 6: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

i . .- ,

~ Ths r por co tain re ult of A bstract

hThis report contains results of the inspection of 34 fleet moorings operated and

maintained by the Commander Fleet Activities, Sasebo, Japan. A CHESNAVFACENG-

COM-assigned Engineer-in-Charge and divers from Underwater Construction Team Two

conducted the inspection from 10-20 May 1983.

Of the 34 moorings inspected, 31 were found to be satisfactory for continued use at

their rated class. One required downgrading to a lower mooring classification, and two

were found to be in poor condition and recommended for overhaul at the earliest practical

time. Additionally, a thorough design review to determine the adequacy of these

Japanese built moorings to withstand the forces associated with the mooring classes, as

defined in NAVFACENGCOM's DM-26, is recommended. Specific comments concerning

each of these moorings and recommendations for future actions are included in this- report. L' . I -/. , ... ..

1. W .%

C--- .. , . . . . ., , . . . . . .- - - - -.. . .- - . .- - .. - . -. -. . . , . . .- - - . - ,.*'2'-- C - Cl.. i Ii m~ lCCll...

Page 7: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

V TABLE OF CONTENTS

Paragraph Page

ABSTRACT

1.0 INTRODUCTION I• : I.1I BackgroundI ',

1.2 General Mooring History I

2.0 INSPECTION PROCEDURES I2.1 Inspection Objectives I2.2 Buoy 6

2.3 Riser 72.4 Ground Legs 72.5 Sinkers 72.6 Anchors 7

3.0 INSPECTION SUMMARY 7

4.0 MOORING INSPECTION COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 10

Annex t,,I

A FLEET MOORING INSPECTION RESULTS A-II-N A-2

I -S Accesion For A7

61 A-I10_:2: 61 NTIS CRA&I A

A-I1 DTIC TAB 0 A- 13

" A-12 Unannounced 0 A- 16Justihication........"' A -13 ,, •... ........ ............ ... -1

A- By ........ A-22

A- 15 Dist. ibution I A-25

A- 16 Availability Codes A-28

Avail ardiorDist Special

I "3' - "

Page 8: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

q A- 17 A-31g

A-l18 A-34

A- 19 A-37

I-1 A-40

1-2 A-43

M-10 A-46

M-I I A-49

M- 12 A-52M- 13 A-55

M- 14 A-58SM- 15 A-61

M-20 A- 64

S-2N A-67

S-2S A-70r-io A-73T-1II A-76

T- 14 A-85IsT-15 A8

Y-1 A-98

Y-2 A-101Y-3 A- 104

B BUOY LOCATION SURVEY DATA B- I

CPHOTOGRAPHS C-ID REFERENCES D-1 p;.

Page 9: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

COMFLEACT SASEBO FLEET MOORING INSPECTION REPORT

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Badk iid. Under the COMNAVFACENGCOM Fleet Mooring Maintenance

(FMM) Program, CHESNAVFACENGCOM has been assigned the responsibility to plan and

conduct periodic diver inspections of all fleet moorings worldwide. In carrying out this

responsibility, CHESNAVFACENGCOM designated an Engineer-in-Charge (EIC) to provide

inspection planning and onsite technical direction for the underwater inspection of fleet

" moorings located near Commander Fleet Activities, Sasebo, Japan. The actual under-water portion of the inspection was performed by divers of Underwater Construction

Team Two (UCT TWO). The inspection was conducted 10-20 May 1983.

. 1.2 General Mooring History. COMFLEACT Sasebo currently operates and maintains

34 fleet moorings; one A, seven B, and 26 E class moorings. The A class mooring is a

telephone-type mooring while the remaining moorings are riser type. Figure I shows the

geographic location of Sasebo, figure 2 shows the geographic positions of the mooringslocated in Sasebo Bay, while Figures 3 and 4 show the locations of those moorings

installed in Juliet Basin (south of the Main Base Area) and those located in the NOF

Maebata Area respectively.

COMFLEACT Sasebo's message I50602Z April 83 to CHESNAVFACENGCOM

contained a summation of the Sasebo mooring numbers, class, locations and dates of last

mooring overhaul. A copy of this summation is contained in Table I.

2.0 INSPECTION PROCEDURES

2.1 Inspection Obiectives. The purpose of the mooring inspections was to determine

the general physical condition of the buoys and chain assemblies and, when possible, to

verify or update existing as-built and maintenance records. Divers inspected only a

portion of the submerged buoy hull and chain assemblies in order to compile a general

description of the mooring's condition. The existence of fairly consistent measurementsLduring this inspection provides a good indication of the mooring's overall condition. It

should be kept in mind that periodic underwater inspections are intended as

.. - . . .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... ,-....:'-. .. . . . . . . . .-. ~~ . . . ~ 4 * ' * *

Page 10: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

4C Meane Tesr'jw

nq n EmToetsu~4 ~ Shuln *~nan M g Plastun ,a.,.(Su"nque Groae~po Dasse uAT~.. Na

Kir 'un n C ern, v a Tetyulkhe.Pristan HOr j 1 asCan *Arsenyev Rumo Engar I

angh USUurtysk \OE ACHa4 +AKsh"a

('P ftskU oe 0 K K A I D Taklgawa rV7asmhua IP rsolU SnakotOvo C A12111Ay Z, S.KT tr ili 1A

T en bq lSucnan 2 ,., " o etau ,IOOalt1 ,,yOChl oasI,,.Hij~(ChutZucn,e * ua ana4 a Yia

hoa6 guka SOAt.".\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005Fu,, oran jrc'vmoad~suy sa ll Unggi, Setana NOboribotS

IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ~~~r* M

Ch5ngjIn Esasmn C SI1 .,yea 1 61sdnq as liakodatd

K ggyqe Kaosam, ~ '6ngan 6s'M KO ao %Wtse Ch&.ngj,, "qar KllChU imacetS us

Igsa*Ai Alz, PuIIsual onel-

SaM uKimha GosnogawaUdnjin *Ax! I iI * ~ r Hachohe

Sin- .. ~ n Tn~ -*J4OSU 0sakt g., Iff.-oo NORTH K(OREANoro d:

-ongwan Nssh Hi g~ilI, "Jap -3 iga W

jrn, kOte KamasIhik. 70og +CM,_ AZAHI 6NtnatAI

4<Sdnga*

akt CPOkiye-r. * Kesennuma

Fp]' 0 Shn

Sal- s&0aCSA Yar~gyang rf an) ga Se aibu hunch.,,w Ackawa. .Rstsrif10 Kanqnung CN iEat Y a

s~ae 7 aLL-N IF1 sma

OChng,u aegm

t-na '. u~r .t JShinz T a sin Tairamho n IIM Cia~i AkafaOshT I

a'arg SO THtau tah

Saq4., Maejok A~ Ias Ma laa aTua~ ongU Kana OTt5 644 Tan itr

Kmamo oau~v mTa

hd* cilleg Mw amata KYUSkHOschur* ~ ~~~ SLANDSO~y ti

Klaqohi akonok htay h~h

\A. Ka.m4'"X1 1 Ua

Fgsue 1. Gogahia octono Ssb

c- Gifu20 Mas Ke Iweenw'cr'K

. Ka

Page 11: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

*tj ~ X.'~L ~Th~ l: C 1LITY-

i-- L!............AS"-1-'j>

p

iAVl ORDNANCE FACILITY

-SKSO MAeATA AREA

A 3 T

, . , . SFW

ft A-A.5.'T

* 5A.

"T.I ".*

Page 12: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

01 Lh~0

M I 2"

V -T

.0 ,, oei

.__'____ _ .,,..

R 3 . P ITIN O .

--.. 0 '4

-4 .! "D

Page 13: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

WI 2 " 1r.

., '2

M- 1/2" t

33" 08' 30w 3308'3"

o4..

,. D)ETAI L MAP, PMAEBATA AREA

.=:/6 o0

"- FIGURE 4. POSITIONIS OF MOORINGS INq THE 'IAEBATA AREA

o5

Page 14: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- ." Z. . ., .- 7. F.; w rW._.6r, r -;r.w-.1

A

TABLE 1. COMFLEACT SASEBO FLEET MOORINGS

Mooring Mooring Water Last Last ReportedNumber Class Location1 Depth (Ft) Overhaul Condition

1N AT Sasebo Bay 40 5/79 Poori iS BR Sasebo Bay 43 /82 Poor61 BR Sasebo Bay 58 3/82 Poor

A- 1 E R Hario Shima Area 30 /82 GoodA-12 E R Hario Shima Area 26 /82 GoodA-13 ER Hario Shima Area 25 /82 GoodA- 14 E R Hario Shirna Area 40 9/77 PoorA-15 ER Hario Shima Area 41 9/78 FairA-16 ER Hario Shima Area 41 9/78 FairA-17 ER Hario Shima Area 40 11/80 FairA-18 ER Hario Shima Area 37 /82 GoodA-19 ER Hario Shima Area 30 11/79 PoorI-1 BR Orizaki Area 40 12/79 Fair

- I-2 BR Orizaki Area 60 12/79 FairM-10 ER Maebata Area 40 11/79 PoorM-11 ER Maebata Area 40 12/77 FairM-12 ER Maebata Area 40 11/79 FairM-13 E R Maebata Area 42 12/77 PoorM-14 E R Maebata Area 33 11/79 Poor "M-15 ER Maebata Area 30 12/77 Poor,.-.M-20 ER Yokose Terminal 52 11/79 FairS-2N E R Juliet Basin 14 2/81 Good .

* S-2S ER Juliet Basin 15 2/81 GoodT-10 ER Juliet Basin 35 2/81 FairT-1I E R Juliet Basin 32 12/77 PoorT-12 ER Juliet Basin 32 12/77 PoorT-13 E R Juliet Basin 29 /82 GoodT-14 ER Juliet Basin 33 /82 FairT-15 ER Juliet Basin 20 NR GoodT-16 ER Juliet Basin 30 NR FairT- 17 ER Juliet Basin 30 NR Fair

Y-1 BR Yokose Terminal 112 1/81 FairY-2 BR Yokose Terminal 112 1/81 FairY-3 BR Yokose Terminal 74 1/81 Fair

NOTE. (1) See Figures 1 through 4

• . - i,2 -2 2.ik .2 '

Page 15: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

an expedient and relatively inexpensive supplement to accurate maintenance records. As

such, they cannot fully substitute for a complete inspection involving recovery of the

mooring and the measurement and evaluation of each component.

Chain wire diameter measurements are used to evaluate the condition of a

mooring. After the chain was cleaned to bare metal, a selective sampling of the wire

diameter of chain links and connecting hardware was taken in order to determine the

amount of deterioration due to corrosion and wear. "Single link" measurements were

taken where the chain was slack to detect corrosion loss. "Double link" measurements

were taken where two links connected under tension to detect the combined effects of

corrosion and wear. Chain links and other components which measured 90 percent or"- greater of original wire diameter are considered to be in "good" condition; measurement

between 80 percent and 90 percent of original diameter is considered "fair" condition and

Le is cause for the mooring to be downgraded in classification; any measurement less than 80

percent is considered "poor" and is cause for the mooring to be declared unsatisfactory for

fleet use. When a mooring is constructed from oversized chain, a measurement between

80 and 90 percent of the original wire size results in a mooring being considered in "fair

condition," but no downgrading is required if the worn chain is still larger than required in

the original design.

Standard underwater inspection procedures do not call for the inspection of any

part of the mooring which has been buried. Ground legs and risers were observed only to

the point at which they became buried; no attempt was made to locate and inspect

anchors or other mooring materials which were not readily visible.

:2.2 BO

2.2.1 Buoy Topside. Each buoy was inspected to determine its general condition. The

buoy markings were checked for conformance to those noted in applicable charts.2- Physical damage such as holes, dents, or listing were noted. The fiberglass coatings were

inspected for cracks, wear, peeling, or rust-bleeding.

The buoy fenders and chafing rails were checked for integrity and secure

connection to the buoy. Buoy top jewelry was measured with calipers to find the overall

Coutside dimensions and areas of most severe reduction in wire size.

7

4,.o

Page 16: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.jn.

2.2.2 Buoy Lower Portion. Divers inspected each buoy below the waterline. Thethickness of marine growth was recorded, two I -foot-square areas were selected and

cleared of growth without damaging the fiberglass, and the condition of the fiberglass was

noted.

2.3 Riser. To determine chain wear, each riser chain was inspected by taking three

consecutive double link measurements, using precut gauges and/or calipers, at both ends

and at the center of the riser. To determine original chain size, divers took single linkcaliper measurements of the wire diameter. When visible, divers also documented the *.

type of hardware connecting the riser chain to the sinker. In many cases Japanese chainsizes between standard American sizes were used. When this occured, the next larger

precut gouge was used, and all measurements below 80 percent were. verified with

4 calipers.

2.4 Ground Legs. Except for the telephone type mooring (IN) and Mooring T- 15,where its single ground leg was exposed, all ground legs were buried in the bottom. The

legs that were exposed were visually inspected and single link caliper measurements oftheir wire diameters taken.

2.5 Sinker. When lisible the hairpin of each sinker was inspected for wear and theconcrete around it checked for spoiling. Caliper measurements were made of the hairpin.

2.6 Anchors. No anchors were sighted during the course of the inspection.

2.7 Buoy Survey, With the assistance of the Public Works Office, a rough geographicsurvey was conducted. Preliminary survey markers were created and marked with paintuntil more permanent concrete monuments can be installed. The data contained in AnnexB gives the locations of these benchmarks and the transit angles to the buoys obtained bybacksighting from points ashore. Until these new benchmarks are accurately surveyed and

tied into the local gird, no precise determination of the buoy locations can be made from

this data.

3.0 INSPECTION SUMMARY

An in-depth discussion of the inspection results is contained in Annex A.

Annex B contains buoy location survey data, Annex C contains photographs, and Annex D. contains a copy of the preliminary report of the results of the inspection. A detailed

evaluation of the information gathered during the inspection indicates the following:

8•. ** * . * .... . - .. .. * ... - .-**.* .. *s* .'.*. %- '

Page 17: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

* Of the 34 moorings, 10 were in good condition and satisfactory for continued

use at their rated class; I was in good condition but should be downgraded due

to undersized chain; 21 were in fair condition and satisfactory for continued

use at their rated class due to oversized chain; and 2 are in poor condition

and recommended for overhaul. Table 2 presents a summary of the current

status of the Sasebo fleet moorings.

- None of the COMFLEACT Sasebo fleet moorings have cathodic protection

systems.

* No anchors were observed during the inspection.

* The construction of Mooring I N is unique and does not comply with any of the

standard designs described in DM-26. It consists of oversized chain and more

ground legs than required for a class A mooring.

9 The riser chain of Mooring M-1 I has been worn to less than 80 percent of its

original wire diameter. This mooring is in poor condition and unsafe for

operational use.

* The wire diameter of the single ground leg of Mooring T-I 5 was measured to

be I 1/2 inches. Per DM-26, the ground leg chain of a class E mooring is

required to be 1 3/4 inches as a minimum.

e The riser chain of Mooring Y-I has been worn to less than 80 percent of its '-]

original wire diameter. This mooring is in poor condition and unsafe for

operational use.

e Based upon the as-built documentation; 7 of the moorings have 2 anchor legs;

II have just one leg; and 10 have no legs at all, with the riser connected

'*-. directly to a single anchor. All have sinkers at the base of the riser. If a

mooring is used as a free-swinging mooring, 3 legs are necessary. If these are

.. bow-stern moorings, at least 2 legs per buoy are needed. Sinkers should not

be used as substitutes for anchors.

* The ground legs of all but 2 (IN & T-15) of the 34 moorings inspected were

completely buried in the mud bottom and inaccessible for inspection.

9

Page 18: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

TABLE 2

INSPECTION SUMMARY

MOORING REPORTED CONDITION CURRENTNUMBER CLASS GOOD FAIR POOR REMARKS STATUS

IN A V0 Repair Buoy. Complete design review SATto determine requirement for

seven legs.IS B 10' Riser chain worn SAT61 B 6' Riser chain worn SATA-I I E PRiser chain worn SATA-12 E 1 Riser chain worn SATA-13 E V0 Riser chain worn SAT

A-14 E PO Riser chain worn SAT- A-1I5 E 'SAT - .

A-16 E bo Riser chain worn SATA-17 E P0 SATA-18 E & Riser chain worn SAT

A-19 E 0' SAT

I-I B 9' Riser chain worn SAT1-2 B &' Riser chain worn SATM-I0 E PO SATM-I I E 60' Riser chain badly worn. Remove UNSAT

from service. Replace riserM-12 E PO' Riser chain worn SATM-I3 E a0 Riser chain worn SATM-14 E 00 Riser chain worn SATM-15 E -' Riser chain worn SATM-20 E a" Riser chain worn SAT

S-2N E $00 SAT 7

S-2S E 00" SAT

10 W%°~

Page 19: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

TABLE 2 (CONT')

INSPECTION SUMMARY

MOORING REPORTED CONDITION CURRENT *

"NUMBER CLASS GOOD FAIR POOR REMARKS STATUS

T-1 I E 0SAT

T-12 E 600 SATT-13 E 000 Riser chain worn SATT-14 E a0 Riser chain worn SATT-15 E a0 Ground Leg Undersized for Class E SAT -

Downgrade to class FT-16 E Wo Riser chain worn SAT

T-17 E a0 Riser chain worn SAT

Y-1 B bl Riser chain badly worn. Remove

from service. Replace riser. UNSATY-2 B a0 Riser chain worn SAT

Y-3 B 0" Riser chain worn SAT

m TOTALS II 21 2

7-

II F

. . . - . . . . .

Page 20: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

9 The riser chains of nine of the moorings inspected (IS, 61, A-18, A-19, 1-1, I-2, M-10, YI, and Y2) were measured by the divers to be of different sizes

than shown in the schematic drawings provided to CHESDIV by COMFLEACT

Sasebo personnel.

4.0 COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONSm-

As a result of an analysis of the data collected during the inspection the

following comments/recommendations are pertinent:

- Since the vast majority of these moorings were designed and built by theJapanese many years ago (probably prior to World War II), a review of thedesign of each of these moorings should be conducted in order to determinewhether the current configurations of these moorings are adequate to meet

expected load requirements.

" A review of the unique design of Mooring IN has been completed by

CHESNAVFACENGCOM and the results of this review forwarded to COM-FLEACT Sasebo.

" Moorings M-1 I and Y-1 should be removed from service and scheduled for

complete overhaul at the earliest practical time.

" Mooring T-15 should be downgraded from a class E to a class F mooring.

" Based on the information contained in the diver data reporting sheets, the

schematic drawings of these moorings should be updated.

12* . . .

Page 21: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

V _ I. 1 . -7

ANNEX A

1PMOORING INSPECTION FESI.LTS --

This Annex contains, for each mooring,__

o a summation of the inspection data obtained by the CHESNAVFACENGCOM,EIC, and UCT TWO divers,

o a diver data reporting form, and

o a schematic drawing of the mooring which includes the latest as-builtinformation. These drawings were submitted to CHESNAVFACENGCOM by

K COMFLEACT Sasebo in April 1983.

r A-ICtttS4AVFACLCP4 4LPOHT FPU.j-q3(Z~i1* -C0W!IACT ',AS%'IO 'rIt 411111 1N,,i wArL N "R ra.~

Page 22: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

-~ MOORING I-N

General

The construction of this mooring is unique and does not comply with any of thestandard mooring designs outlined in DM-26. This mooring consists of a telephone-type

I. buoy and a riser chain attached to four ground legs and anchors via a ground ring.*. Moreover, this mooring has three additional ground legs and anchors attached directly to

" padeyes on the bottom of the buoy. A schematic drawing of the design of this mooring is

contained in Figure A-I.

4..Y

This is a I 5-foot-diameter Japanese designed telephone-type buoy with a- hawsepipe. The buoy has three legs attached to its padeyes and a riser chain. A 6-foot

section of the fender has been sheared off, and the chafing rail is bent and broken. The 6-inch shackle atop the buoy was freshly painted.

Riser

The riser is oversized L4-inch chain. Double link measurements taken showed thatthe chain is worn to between 80 and 90 percent of its original wire diameter. The riserdoes not have a marine growth covering and enters the bottom at a water depth of 39

-_ feet. The remainder of the riser, the 25-ton sinker, ground legs, and anchors were notvisible for inspection.

K: Ground Lg%

The three ground legs attached to the buoy padeyes were inspected. Eachconsisted originally of 3-inch chain. Although most double link measurements weregreater than 80 percent, one measurement of leg B, the south-southwest leg, was only 79percent of its original wire diameter. The legs are covered with a medium covering ofmarine growth, and each of the legs has scattered areas of extreme rust.

A-2"'....

- .* -o

Page 23: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

P TELEPHONE BUOY

LEG ORIENTATION

3539'

-91f

£2

35t.5

5- FOUR BURIED LEGSAND RISER ATTACHEDTO A 25T SINKER

FIGURE A-i. SCHEMATIC DRAWING OF MOORING iN

A-3," NAWFAc COE41 ~12 1 LA '~.~ ~!s1rll .'n 4 c'

P7 *'' .* 5 * -* .

Page 24: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.%

Sinkers/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

The design of this mooring is being reviewed to determine whether the mooring'scurrent seven-leg configuration is required to meet the design loads anticipated. In

addition, the buoy should be refurbished.

A measurement of less than 80 percent of any mooring component is normallycause for a mooring to be removed from service until an overhaul can be performed.However, in the case of this mooring, the oversized (4-inch) riser is more than capable of

handling class A design loads. The worn section of the ground leg does not pose a threatto the safety of the mooring.

. .

A-4•...*.*. Q I - 1 ?91 C "-. AC' 'A I t-

Page 25: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

t~~~~- %_ ---

-'44uj 0011.

'44)

~141

?2~~t

wTel

a- c.e

- )

w o ~ A 0 66 0j

OC .. - z -

A-5

Page 26: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MORING BUOY NO: I /BUOYANCY: ~O TONS Y:TEkAJ

DEPTH OF WATER: o VF CONDITION OF BOTTOM: /'7Ut'

LAST OVERHAULED: NEXT OVERHAUL:ANNUAL USAGE: 13 DAYS

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNOWN DATE: d-/-,c,, ,_

__ __ __ __ . .

I ' I .

44 44'44"4

!- ., .,, % .,+ + 19 e

o

.-

4k, 4

!. * ."3 ,' .

'. :: S o ' I" .,-..

4" JA -

A -6

VOW .,,31 *

....................................................

• " ,,, ' A , ,;C) 'o~ ' ' , -'. 3' ' ' "' " '£), t5 ,o ¢ r[T qll/,N .h ( ! ,, ,NoL .!4 . ,2 ,,'%1L-*

Page 27: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Owl

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING I-S

This is a Japanese-designed 11.5-foot-diameter drum-type buoy with a hawse-pipe. It has a freeboard of 38 inches, and its topside jewelry consists of 3 1/4-and 5 1/4-inch schackles. The buoy is in good condition.

Riser

The riser is 3 1/4- and 3 1/2-inch chain vice the 2 1/2-inch wire diameterrequired for a class B mooring. All double and single link measurements taken were larger

than 80 percent of the riser's original wire diameter. The riser enters the bottom at awater depth of 40 feet.

Sinker/Ground Leg/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendations

This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class Bmooring. It is uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-builtdrawing can adequately resist the 125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring.Recommend a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-7

~~.S'AFAC~iCOM Of)? ;.' E:

...........................................................................- b.-....

Page 28: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- . . --...-.-.-...-...--.-.--.-- - . - - -. - - . .--..--

UU -

~2i

C ~~1vJo K- KC

II I-

z

C.,

oQ

k-'~ I - ~'- -

Zr--

I-

N'I) ~

(j-~

0

I-. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

* w ~* C., *.D

* >. C

( ).-------------------------------------------'

-~ ~

~XZ ~.,~ z *~

~---------------------------------

: ~;w

C., _________ --------------------------= z 'ILl

'44 --I

C- - -

w >. - - -

- a - = - - a

C,, ~ v ~ 2 ~ '~ ~

I a - - - - - - a - ~ - ~

- - ~ -

I z - a - - - - - a -

~I1~~ - C = Z ~ z ~. -

- -

~ ~. ~ - - -

z - -~ * = =

- -

* I~ I( -~

- ___I~. - - a-- -- I

F - -ZA-8 5;

I I . . * . . - . . * . * *

Page 29: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

NOR~ul N~ui w ?O: B UOYANCY: 12 TON Trim:

DEPTH OF WATER: .43~ CONDITION OF BOTrOM: Ma

LAST OVERHAULED: ..... sL2LNEXT OVERHAUL: 4/&-ANNUAL 03/86 4

USAGE: 1.3 D~AYS DATE:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNJOWN p

4.- 43

41'

44*

"'Al --

~S,AV" A 6EuCON REPORI FoU- I -Ijr "CJ-F SAC' SASEU IQ LET &~Ai ,~~~1

............................................. ...

Page 30: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

4.. .

INSPECTION RESILTS

MOORING 61

$. .1,'This is a 12-foot-diameter Japanese designed drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe.

The buoy has a 38-inch freeboard, and its chafing rail is badly dented. The top jewelry is

heavily rusted, and the botttom of the buoy's hull is covered with about 2 inches of marine

growth.

Riser

The riser is oversized 3 1/2-inch chain. All single and double link measurements

were greater than 80 percent of the original wire diameter. Most of the riser chain is

covered with about 2 inches of marine growth, but the lower 5 feet above the mudline areu clean. The riser enters the bottom at a depth of 62 feet. I".

Sinker/Ground Les/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendations"

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is N*

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.) " However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain ,.

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class B mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

leg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-built drawing can adequately resist the125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the .

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A- 10Ci, 'PiAvF ACE,6COm' I. ,t Fu.!. f3281 ". U"FLEACT SASE!IO FLI T mOU P6 )'01 Q' .A' 'I '." C' '4, -o

.-- -

Page 31: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

rn~~-----L* 00.

Aa 1

U< D

Ir

iii-

to

wz Z< K. UJUA6u LJ 0 UJ LJ L

z Z< >. 6w01

W ~ Z.aC j tZ _z

z 'C

A-1 I

Page 32: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-. - . < .. .,. -L- 4-.- 7s -

.'.

MORING BUOY NO: L BUOYANCY: O2 NS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: ,-' CONDITION OF BOTTOM: 'A,

LAST OVERHAULED: J~Q/ 'NEXr OVERHAUL: 4/ j. p-v'

\NNUAL USAGE: 26 DAYS DATE:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNOWN

21-- % z

A-1

C-E'MiAACEGCO.4 RE004T FP0J-?qg, -C-rIEACT SASECO 9'EE m 0!N 1 E.. N' EPO " E

Page 33: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A-li

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy has a 30-inch freeboard and is fiberglass coated. The fenders are ingood condition but the underwater portion of the buoy's hull is covered with about 3 inches

.. of marine growth.

Riser

The riser consists of 2-inch chain. Although double link measurements of the

-. upper and center sections of the riser were all above 90 percent of its original wirediameter, the lower section measured between 80 and 90 percent. The lower end of theriser is attached to a 2 1/4-inch shackle which is attached to an end link partially buried

*• in the bottom. The majority of the riser is covered with 2-to 3-inches of marine growth

but the lower 5 feet are clean. The depth of the water is 39 feet.

Sinker

Not visible for inspection.

* Recomedation

This mooring is in fair condition.

'S. A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

" - allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequately Vresist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forceson the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A- 13* * - - * S* . S

.• ;S-S.'.2.. S-

Page 34: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

r4~

Ni.

cc j

Id

u u "

In w

Z. 0 J L W 6 I

z z

-Z .jZ(t

A-1

Page 35: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.

MOORING BUOY NO: J*- BUOYANCY: 4 TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: jQ..0 . CONDITION OF BOTTOM: ~a'.

LAST OVERHAULED: .NET OVERHAUL: 4 6* ANNUAL" USAGE: 300 DAYS BATE: a-/- .

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

4.

A-15.

" °a

No.- ..- .P

S%

2j;:;:

°

a,

''a. a

A-I 5.9;

"" ~ ~~~~C! .SIAVIFACE6ttCOI I ill~f *01 !? 1 'C!.''.EACTI SAS([ ).t'l *€, ' !.Nl G IN', ATE4 ! S 'Cfl'4 : , ,..

*.. - ** il I i ** 'a. - -ai m li * .'.-.... | .

Page 36: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

K - 7 . W W 7 - ,--- -

-a.

p INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A-12

Buo

This is a Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe. It has a

32-inch freeboard, and the chafing rail is covered with light rust. The buoy appears to be

in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2-inch chain as compared with the I 3/4-inch size required

for a class E mooring. Double link measurements near the lower end of the riser chain

were between 80 and 90 percent of its original wire size. The riser is covered with marine

growth from the surface to 26 feet. The 4 feet of chain between that point and the

bottom has no marine growth but is rusty. The riser contains a shackle and an end link at

26 feet and a second shackle at the bottom.

Sinker

Not visible for inspection.S.*.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequately

resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E nooring. Recommend a review of the forces

on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A- 16

. . . .C".S.IAA... .. C. .GC .Or.. Q oll-. -43 1 C IMF L CT

.AS.9,1 L I'

1.." 'N.. . I RW..IFI.' . .SO.ECT1...O..PT-

Page 37: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

L C.

CU

UJ- 02A

<~A-

V) cc~% &

7 . N

Ln

0. 4lb

<- -~W<z

00

z z

-A N

Page 38: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MORING BUOY NO: ABUOYRANCY: TOSTYPE: ____

DEPTH OF WATER: 26 FT CONDITION OF BOTTOM: AI Up.

LAST OVERHAULED: 81/82 NElT OVERHAUL: 26'ANNUAL

USAGE: 300 DAYSDA:

-. ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

A-18

i F. 4C..G Ow* 5 ,)rc f 1 0- 'SA G J'fW

......-... '. . .. . . . .

Page 39: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

'.1d~

I ,.,

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A- 13

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy has a 30 to 35-inch freeboard and is fiberglass covered. The buoy

appears to be in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2-inch vice the I 3/4-inch wire diameter required for a class

E mooring. Double link measurements of the upper section of the riser proved that the

. chain in this area is between 80 and 90 percent of its original wire diameter. The riser

contains a shackle and end link at the 22-foot level and vertically enters the bottom at aw water depth of 25 feet.

Sinker

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation ,.

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that the" leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequately

resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces -

on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring. i-9' $

A-19.1_1 %**** . .

Page 40: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- -- . - --- - -

44)S

L -V)

z N d

UU

-j-

0k.4

>. 0

<<

< 2

A02

Page 41: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

a -.- . .

OORING BUOY NO: A-/3 BUOYANCY: 4 TONS TYPE: _

DEPTH OF WATER: 2S ' CONDITION OF BOTTOM: A1L/ -,

LAST OVERHAULED: 9182 NEXT OVERHA.UL: 6 1e6

.NNUAL USAGE: 300 DAYS DATE: i--?ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

A-2a-ACE -" qA

?'r:)r:9)!.f'23 , "OLEC ,.. ,.'I ~ .E N

-° .- :.-va--I L L. ;XK q2

Page 42: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

. * , - .- .-,L - ' , .-

' =. . . . " . . . . . - ' , . , ,' ' . ,. ; t ,: . t

INSPECTIONS RESULTS

MOORING A-14

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a freeboard of about 35 inches. There is

no rust on the top of the buoy, but the bottom is covered with 2-to 3-inches of marine

growth. The buoy is in good condition.

Riser

The riser chain originally had a wire diameter of 2 1/4 inches, one-half-inch

-. larger than required for a class E mooring. Double link measurements of the lower

portion of the chain were between 80 and 90 percent of its initial wire size. The chain iscovered with a moderately heavy marine growth and vertically enters the bottom at a

. water depth of 40 feet.

Sinker/Ground Legs/Anchors

*i Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is* normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

" allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequatelyresist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces

on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-22OAE;n Rronqi' po.!- 3,29. !LA ' A 0 IF 'Ol RP)

*.-L.

Page 43: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-T 77 7.

Ilk

ii u

6W aw 6W 2.

CL

-. c -~ 4 -- - - ~ - -

*:. Z~

Page 44: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: L4BUOYANCY: TOS YP: b___%

DEPTH OF WATER: 40o CONDITION OF BOTTOM: Al: p

LAST OWHAULED:NEXT OVERHAUL: 8L

A !NNUAL USAGE: 300 DAYS ij DATE: d -/J.

AkNTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

4

-'II

A-24

C"SAVACENGCOM4 REP'JlT F0 .- 43(281. "Co-FLEAC1 SASE30 c'-ET !ISET0 R E OV)r.

Page 45: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

NSNINSPECTION RIESLLTS

MOORING A-15 ,5'-'

INJOYThis Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy has a diameter of 7 feet 10

inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 30-inch freeboard. The top of the buoy is

slightly rusted at the base of the chafing rail. Overall, the buoy is in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 I/4-inch chain which is a one-half inch larger than

required for a class E mooring. Double link measurements of the riser chain were all

better than 90 percent of the chain's original wire size. About 4 feet of riser rests on the

bottom before the chain enters the mud.

Sirdcer/Ground L%/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Recom.,Me-ndtion

This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class E

mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-

built drawing can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring.

Recommend a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring. .- -- '

"2. ,.,. ,

o .',. - . % -

A- 25 ?-..d1 ''AVFACE4IGCQ4 REPORT PPO-! 83(281, "COMFLEACT SASEBO ) Fr W04Pd6 J-1'*;Ti.

t2 • -".•

. . . . .. . . .. . . ... s .- *: .*.*.. . .. *..**. .*. *..', .;

Page 46: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- - - . - - - - - - - - -

Ic

V1

r >z

5 --44

.A-26

Page 47: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- , . - - . o*. - . --. - - w- r - * , , I W',-im- IF r r i *.

MOORIN BUOY NO: -A - 16S BUOYA: 4 TONS TYPE: ____

DEPTh OF WATER: 4 CONDITIXN OF BOTTOM: I. /

ANNUAL LAST OVERHAULED: NEXT OVERHAUL:

USAGE: 300 DAYS d/87DATE: d-/-22

ANTICIPATED.USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGEo-."

-, , .

Itt1--o

J4%

A-27

-. CE ll QE ,4 FPJ !.329 ,S SF-_'TO :..-l~jR~tR .

Page 48: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTIONS RESLLTS

MOORING A-16

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese-built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe. Thebuoy is fiberglass coated and has a 31 -inch freeboard. There is some rust on the top deck

padeyes and in the hawsepipe. In addition there is some light rust on the top plate at the

base of the chafing rail.

Riser

This is 2 1/4-inch riser chainone-half-inch larger than required for a class E

mooring. Double link measurements of the upper and center sections of the riser arebetween 80 and 90 percent of the chain's original wire diameter. About six chain links

Mrest on the bottom before the riser enters the mud at a water depth of 35 feet.

*. Sinker/Groand Leqs/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

SRecommendation--

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chainallows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that the.leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequately

resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forceson the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

qEPRr c0-!R~f21. COmFLFACT SASEv!1 Ct'.T

I. .- oo

-, L•.ft .62.|

Page 49: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

7Z~

4'JUA

aezz

6uw

661C',.

v(4

~Z

-4 _r I 1 12

A-2 7j

Page 50: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

P moORniG BiUO m: A -16 ANCf: A4TmI YVE: -

OEM'l 07 WATER: CONDITION OF BfOTG: NWl.

LAST OVERHAULED: SJ ~NEa OVERHuANNUAL 4 8USAGE: 300 DAYS r:

- ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

43,40A9

A-3.

-1114,,FACNICM RE O t ;'n-!113(41,-CU" EACTSASL 9. L.4

Page 51: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

i C...,,%

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A- 17

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 33-inch freeboard. The hawsepipe,

padeyes and base of the chafing rail are covered with light rust. The buoy is in good

S , .c o n d it io n .

Riserr

I-o-.

The riser chain consists of 2-inch chain vice the I 3/4-inch chain required for a

class E mooring. All double link measurements were greater than 90 percent of thechain's initial wire diameter. The riser is covered with moderate growth and vertically

enters the bottom at a water depth of 32 feet.

Sinker/Gr %M d Le s/Anchors Z" .

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendions

This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class E

mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown inthe as-

built drawing can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. ,

Recommend a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

,.,.

..

A-31C 1 S'4Av ACENGC OM REPORT - "C F LEAC' SAS F9O Eu l ' . N 'N I w T !4SPECT!ON PEP !. ,.

]'C.".

Page 52: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

44 . . - - * ~ ~ ) . . ~Pr. F I

4 - -- - - - - - - -

UM

I'jSU

z 4

.j2

2 661

-oA-32

%vK

Page 53: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

p MOORING BUOY NO: .Az.LZ -/7OYANCY: TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: 40. r CONDITION OF BOTTOM: %

SLAST OVERHAULED: 11,Q. NEXT OVERHAUL: ,LLANNUAL

USAGE: 300 DAYS.. DATE: ,

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

.°•.e,0

4

*At

IIt

,-'

xN

,.... *y.

Pi A-33

.. ACE .RE C

Page 54: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

pINSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A- 18

rW.

This Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe has a

diameter of 7 feet I0 inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 33-inch freeboard.There is some light rust in the howsepipe and on the top deck plate at the base of the

chafing rail. The buoy is in good condition. 4P

Riser

The riser consists of 2 1/4-inch chain which is one-half inch larger than required

- for a class E mooring. Double link and single link measurements were all between 80 and'"' 90 percent of the chain's original wire size. At a depth of about 25 feet, the riser

contained two end links connected by a shackle. The lower end link was attached toadditional 2 1/4-inch chain. About 5 to 6 feet of this chain were visible on the bottom - -

before the riser entered the mud. The lower section of the chain is rusty.

Sinker/Ground Leg/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

,. Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

.~.~

- allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawing can adequately

-. resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces

on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-34 "'"'!N T-" .; i C[ U" q[PORTr " ) .13(2t), .CO.',LEACT SASrio 1 .1 P y . :,jSPEC1!0N REPORT.

Page 55: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Il In_ -t

v1°1

IlkN~

,0. ',

• ) I,, o i!

" - - - I I -

- - -1.

• ." - ~ "" :

d44

CO .. 7LA-35*

III

Li Y.zI

* . ___ * ~ a t ~ r ~ . . S S S

- _________- - - - - - *-~~~ --vs

-j - ~- -' Z

_ -A-35

Page 56: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MORING 3UOY NO: .±.L& BUOYANY: TON TOE: -

DEPIh OF WATER: - Zd n CONDITION OF BOTTOM: /11/

LAST OVRHAULED: .. L3NEXT OVERHAUL: 7 -

ANNUAL IUSAGE: 300 DAYS x:-

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

464Z

AA~~P ~ ON v' 2A5 viiW r~'47

2 t

A-36i~r, QFpfVqrFP- I -1-?I ?'29 F ACT SrW) F- I. lul ".' 9 '4S~' ' fi4 QE DO

Page 57: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.. . . . . .J

Iq

lit

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING A-I9 19

This Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe has a

diameter of 7 feet 10 inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 32-inch freeboard. -,-

The buoy is in good condition and looks recently overhauled.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 1/8-inch chain which is larger than required for a class Emooring. All double and single links measurements were greater than 90 percent of theoriginal wire diameter. The riser enters the bottom vertically at 20 feet.

Sinkers/GrounKd Leq/Anchor

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class E

mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown inthe as-, built drawing can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring.

Recommend a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A- 37AA-P-'-S-2

% ..

Page 58: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

F_ r.-- -r.

-IZ

~ ~444C ,1

j Njvii.

Er -

* I-I Z -cc

z z

A-38

Page 59: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

NOOWG BUOY NO: AB-UoYANcr: 4 m TONSTPE

DEPT OF NATER: 30 ,CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

ANULLAST OVERHAULED: -&j~g mmX OVERHAUL: ~I~

USAGE: 300 DAYSDATE:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

2.

. - ,. °- - ..

°.*

'7'

21-

-It

D I -0 Pafo,12r-'D 2.4Vi eff,IAJ ,Ft~ ?3) I

A-39"Op~

4c' %iCI4 QC01 F i ' .Wf Ill "CO LEACT SAS14 rll f )oi I ~ f i^,'t~~'O '

ilk

Page 60: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

p MOORING 1-1

This is an I I-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and a 49-inch freeboard. There is some lightrust in the hawsepipe and 2 inches of marine growth on the bottom.

Riser

The riser consists of 3 1/2-inch chain which is about I inch larger than required

for a class B mooring. The lower portion of the riser was measured to be between 80 and90 percent of its original wire diameter. At a depth of 38 feet, the riser contains ashackle and an end link. About 10 feet of riser chain rests on the bottom before it enters

the mud.

Sinker/Ground Legs/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

" RecorinNEI tion

"~ This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chainallows it to still be capable of withstanding class B mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

*. leg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-built drawing can adequately resist the,- 125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-407"', *,VA , C E' R ORr FD,.. *, '29 , .,tr ¢LEA r S' E90 Fl- _ -01 !-6 .r IWTE 1,PE - 1,1' 1

Page 61: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

IR

U.1~

.. I z

I.-.4 A-41

Page 62: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: -IBUOYANCY: / 2 TONS TYPE:

DEPTH4 OF WATER: Qf0 CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: JZ'NEXT OVERHAUL: 611/4.Pi '0NNUAL USAGE: 30 DAYS

DATE:d- jV' NTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNOWN

it

II

-620'

A-42p~r Q. ~ 3 2tl * " FLEAC! SASFr1 :,,; P' f'' T !04 "'' R qON o,,

Page 63: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

J%%

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING 1-2

This is a 12-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a." hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 49-inch freeboard. Two attaching'L bolts have been pulled out of the fender.

," Riser

The riser is 3 1/2-inch chain vice the 2 I/-inch required for a class B mooring.

Double link measurements taken near the middle and lower portion of the ground ringwere between 80 and 90 percent of the chain's original wire diameter. The riser contains

an end link and a shackle at the 30-foot depth and a second end link and shackle at the 60-* j foot depth. The riser enters the bottom at 63 feet.

ISinker/Ground Legs/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

R 1.In.ion

This mooring is in fair condition.

* ' A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class B mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-built drawing can adequately resist the

" 125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-43pCHSNAVFACENGCOM REPORT ;PO-1-13'?8? . "COMFLEACT SASEBO FL"E' 01 1 G " j ' :")O ,

-= . . . . .. .. , , , . , ,. . : : " - , -, ,

_ _ • ., , . .. , ,. .' ..

Page 64: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

B.

L __- ~,.L 4~ V VXI.- - -

UI.)

V~ \~ "

U ~

~-

I- ~- z -J ..- ~

z w kk

- -.4 N.J~.1~ \i

-\ -z '..'

a-

\.-

- 0-'o

-~ 4z~

~ c.~* ). C

* . ,- ~

* I I -

* oa~* - -~- -- -

* H- -.

- f-I II-. I

o I

- 5* I ~-----.-.-.-

~ ~

- 2I5K,-~ z z-'-~ -~

~ - -I

<II =1

N.- - I Ii 2 Z 2* - z - -- IT

- - I -* . - I I* I I z* 3 ______ __________________________

A -44

*~~*~~45*~* . **,.**.. *. S

Page 65: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: BUOYANCY: 12~. TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: 60 l CONDITION OF BOTTOM: mvLQ.

LAST OVERHAULED: .. ~YNEXT OVERHAUL: 2~

!1!ANNUAL USAGE: 30 DAYS DATE: d-1f

A IIATE USAGE/TYPE: UNIMOWN

ed'q~ (t~ S'

go 6t 85

A-4511SAVACEN mQC O RT 10--q 21 -C()LEACT SASEn Fl'Fl P~ ~. ' 4.SDECT1O04 pr

Page 66: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTIN RESULTS

MOORING M-10

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy has a fiberglass coating and a 24-inch freeboard. The sides of the

, buoy show evidence of rust bleeding. The 3 1/8-inch shackle atop the buoy has beenrecently painted.

Riser

The riser consists of I 7/8-inch chain vice the required I 3/4-inch. Double link ,.

measurements were all greater than 90 percent of the chain's original wire diameter. The

riser contains two end links and two shackles near the bottom and the chain enters the

mud at a depth of 32 feet.

Sinker/Ground Lees/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Reconmendation

* This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class E

mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-

• ,. built drawing can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. '.-

Recommend a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-46CHESNAVFACE'IGCO4 RED)T r)-.93(2q) 'COFLEACT SASE O 'LE90 'fQT , ! , , ,

__ , , *, . ,, -*- . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..- . .-.-...--. ..-.... ..-.-...-.-. -. '.-,.-.,...,-. .-. .......,., . ,' '.., ,,.,

Page 67: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

:-Y-' ~ YY ~ -Y~~ ~T~ U.~ - ~. m- .1 7 jd

Uj

U -Z

6W

z z-

z z

0 -'Z

A-47

Page 68: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

)OORDIG BUOM NO: M BOYACY: mm TM:

NP'n OF NAMn: 40 cuM wO OF BoTrcR: -Mj

LAST OVERHAULED: N14 EW OVERHAUL: ./e4

ANNUAL - -

USAGE: 340 DAYSDA7E:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

2 t

2%

I~. It

S.2"

A-48

.5.1 8 1 9 . "04 'E C A E 0 FE -4 N !E - ER 1 S E T 0 E M

Page 69: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

rr

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M-I I

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 36-inch freeboard. The top deckpadeyes are heavily rusted while the deck plate and chafing rail are moderately rusted.

. Riser

The riser was initially 2-inch chain vice the I 3/4-inch required for a class E

mooring. Although double link measurements taken near the top and middle of the riserwere above 90 percent, the measurements near the mud line were considerably lower,with one measurement less than 80 percent of the original wire diameter. The chain is

covered with moderate marine growth above 30 feet, but there is no growth below this

depth.

Sinker/Ground Leg/Anchor

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

Due to the riser chain being worn to less than 80 percent of its original size, this* "mooring is considered in poor condition and unsafe for operational service. Recommend

that this mooring be overhauled, its riser replaced, and the buoy refurbished. It is

'. uncertain that the leg/sinker/anchor arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built drawingcan adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class Emooring. Recommend a

review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-49S * *4SDE'T O RED.OR-'," - .-- . -,

•~~~~~~ j.2,'.'Z : -:'

Page 70: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

U'44

3k

ww

,jz 4

Z --

-j

0~JA-50

Page 71: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOOIN BUOY(;nt NO: 1/ BUOYANCY: dTONS TYE:t

OMOF WTERl': 40 CM ¢TIGrzN OF, BMrrM: M-u/. -

',':tr OVERHULED: / /7. NI-r OVERHAU: .61.._&.ANNUAL

24 7-

2.t.

USADG: 34O0 DAOS .. /Lao ic: OS T

-. -4-?.

• - LATOEH/-D .. L.Z2r VEHU:*6 ~

..--

ANTICIPATED UPE:'SAG/TP' 20.DYS/ BAR

, .4...

% .

C°.iJ'C.C.d ,'- ' .* 7'AC A.0 J 'w~Q'~ o~,

ft ft ft. U f

Page 72: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.- ~,-~-,-~.-,--'--.-.'- VLNV% VWL--~

%%%'

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M-12

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

* hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 38-inch freeboard. The hawsepipe is

severly rusted, and there is heavy rusting of the chafing rail and heavy rust bleeding ofthe buoy's sides. This buoy is in fair condition.

Riser

The riser was originally 2-inch chain vice the I 3/4-inch required for a class E %

mooring. Double link measurements show that the middle section of the riser is worn tobetween 80 and 90 percent of the chain's initial wire size. The chain is covered with

h moderate marine growth from the bottom of the haswepipe to a depth of about 20 feet. -Between this point and the bottom (38 feet), where the riser enters the mud, the chain is

rusted.

Sinker/Ground LeqlAnchor

Not visible for inspection.

- Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the

50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on themoored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

%-•:

- A-2 ....2I., C dA'J'/ACE'GtCO

' [' UD-!-R]'2UI, "CO LEACT SA$ERO r. . u lG ,lr^ , .. ,=tO urr , .

3 °

Page 73: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

~7W~ :"j V~A.'.' ~J ~C, LW~'~'~TiIW'.~W ~ V -. -,.i c~ . - ~ NI~J~ 'JW~

____ - - -------------------

4'

- z -~ V2

o -'~'~

- -~

~z~JK

14j

-

;: -

I ~ 0 1-

w ~a. ~ 0). 0

Cd,

I NI-~ I=

I IU 1 t in

\'\I~IIiI

*** .- *-* - -. -,yr-i-' z:i~

_______ - -

'4 I-. 4

~, .~Z Z~ ~ZI I-

J - z

z ~

rv~- 2 j 2

A-53

Page 74: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

SOoRD4G BUOY NO: - 1 BUOYANCY: 4 os TYPE: %

EM OF WATER: O CCNDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAUJLED: / 9NWX OVERHAUL: I4ANNUAL

USAGE: 340 DAYS DATE: d-/-& .

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

A-54

.. , -. '.C~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 14 E. S 1AVFACE'•CO f 2Q

,.~~ 6 "o)9

Page 75: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

i.

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M- 13

This Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe has adiameter of 9 feet 2 inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 36-inch freeboard.The top plate is moderately rusted, and the chafing rail is badly dented. There is much

. .-. rust bleeding on the sides of the buoy.

" Riser

The riser originally consisted of 2 3/8-inch chain which is almost 5/8 of an inch

larger than required for an E class mooring. All double link measurements of the riserwere between 80 and 90 percent of the 2 1/2-inch wire size gauge used. Therefore the

chain measured between 84 and 95 percent of its original wire size. The riser vertically

enters the bottom at a water depth of 40 feet.

Sinker/Ground Leq/Anchor

Not visible for inspection.

*. .ReconiNndation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.* However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

' allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A - I P11 - I N * ' L F A CT S A I -' -A t

4 .. ': .' N;I F I T r q ! . . 'r M.L A T S qI u .~ ",!, A 'q !; ,. T * ( It

"* '.*. ,'- * -'" ".i'. " " " ' ".'".. . ... .-.. .-.. . . . .-. "'-.. .".".. . . .- "-.. . . . . -. -. ,. .- . . ..-. . ..""-.....".""-' -" -" ." " -';". " "-°'

. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . * -ii* -* ** .

Page 76: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

. -V -~~.v ~ - -

#1z

CC

- ~ Is

i2 2-I I

~ ~.} -i

A-56

Page 77: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

R 'V

MOORIG BUOY NO: .m.jJ. BOANCl: TYT PE:____

DEPTH OF WATER: 42.X CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: /0._ ,7 NEXT OVERHAUL: .__/...ANNUAL 6/87

USAGE: 340 DAYS DATE: -/-"

* ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

00

M jeV

qO

4t

i i'

A-57P. ,*. N; rr .Q~PQFlOnT FDf.l*.AVq ' "UmLr F ASfin g, FT' mInR!,rF N4orFATEQ INS £ CT!I4 REDOT,"

................................................................................

Page 78: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

'4

pI

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M-14

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 36-inch freeboard. The topsidepadeyes are heavily rusted and the galvanized pipe chafing rail has been scraped to baremetal. The buoy bottom has only a light covering of marine growth.

Riser

The riser originally consisted of 2-inch chain vice the I 3/4-inch required forclass E moorings. Double link measurements of the rise revealed that its lower portion isworn to between 80 and 90 percent of the chain's initial diameter. The riser enters themud at a depth of 30 feet.

Sinker

-Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

7" A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component isnormally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chainallows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the

%,. 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the ."

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

o'.4

A-58 .-"CPFSNAdFACEIGCOM EO0(iT FPO-1-8(,9), "CO'LEACT SASE(j) FLET 4 IF. N, .A Q !. QP'T"

7 .

Page 79: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

V.

11

*~1~

II ,.

z w ~ut~flN~ zz~a.(Z~

N

- .- '..- p -~

N

-

Q

fr~ z~- -

0. ~ I

I I-~ w ~ I I

------------------------------------ ELELLI ~.

L I j -

a r ~ -~ -Ti

- I

.1.1* 1 z ~ In

* -t, (~J7J-I,-

I - - -. ~4~---,-.-.---

- - - - -

- .- 2 =- - - ~ ~

2

-- I ~ 2

I -I2 I I- z

I -

I(

A-59

Page 80: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- www~w~~w..i; w U;..

MORING BUOY NO: - 4 BUOYANCY: TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: d13 CONDITION OF BOTTO:

LAST OVERHAULED: //_12? NEXT OVERHAUL: E. .

.\,NNUAL USAGE: 340 DAYSDATE: -

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

..

.o'.

U%

A-60

C~SEAJFA~t~IGC!y R OT R.~ ~~ ;ATER !4SPSCT!0O4 POT."

C, ,4,%-JFAENGCM RPORTFPO..93291."V-LEAC SAS!(),'.-,"

Page 81: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

t~q I %

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M-I5

This Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe has a

diameter of 9 feet 4 inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 39-inch freeboard.

- The chafing rail is severly dented, and one attaching bolt is missing from the fender. The

"* bottom is covered with a 2-inch marine growth.

Riser

The riser is 2 3/8-inch chain vice the required I 3/4-inches for an E class

mooring. Double link measurements show that the chain is worn to between 80 and 90

g percent of the 2 1/2-inch wire size. Therefore, the chain measured between 84 and 95

percent of its original size. There is moderate growth on the riser down to a depth of 22

feet. Some links are shiny and pitted below this point, and some of the chain link studs

are worn.

Sinker

Not visible for inspection.

- Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring..'

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the

50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on the

- moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

.A-61

rj,*AjFACI1jCOM REPORT FPO-I-d3'2fl, 'eO-FIAAC' SASE11O *.EEI -01 R14G 1,1'tRWATER !NSPECT!O. 4f' A,

Page 82: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

7Z)7 . *

~~~Y srlr w rr n rr C

a i - - - - - -

z

he..

z z

wA-6

Page 83: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

i r

MOORING BUOY NO: M 1 5 BUOYANCY: 6 TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: 30CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: 7-7. NEXT OVERHAUL: .81

uNTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

C"S.lAEG0 E'lf-rMLAT A-63 1

C. SAE9 FL- -0"Q4 M R -E -.... *,..**..C

Page 84: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING M-20

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 26-inch freeboard. The chafing rail isA rusted and dented, and the deck plate at the base of the chafing rail is dented. The

fiberglass coating and fender are in good condition.

Riser

The riser is 2 1/4-inch chain which is one-half inch larger than required for aclass E mooring. With the exception of one caliper measurement which was less than 90percent, all single and double link mfeasurements were larger than 90 percent of thechain's original wire diameter. The bottom is at a depth of 50 feet, and about 20 feet of

* the riser rests on the bottom. The lower end of the riser is attached to a shackle to an

• "end link to the sinker hairpin. There is no growth on the lower 25 feet of chain.

Sinker

" The top of the partially buried sinker was observed. Its hairpin was measuredwith calipers to be 3 1/2 inches.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component isnormally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the

• - 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on themoored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

PIA-64

..- **FAC..GCO.. ...... F..1......f...., CT SA.. .'.. .... J!. N.l...A

..-

.. ..... 4 .P....".

Page 85: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

cj

43 '41'u

vu .i

t48

A-65

Page 86: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BuoY NO: -M.. 20 BUOYANCY: .. TONS TYPE:

%DEPTH OF WATER: FT CONDITION OF BOTTOM4: / S

LAST OVERHAULED: // 29 NEXT OVERHAUL: ._ /LANNUAL

USAGE: 340 DAYS DATE: --

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE

.

" 2A

p A-66 W

........................................

Z- * .Wp .-. -,E~liiFCE4COM EPOT FO-193(21, COW-EAT SAE10Fj~ -0MI.

% -6 ~_

Page 87: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

%

INSPECTION RESLLTS

MOORING S-2N ..

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 36-inch freeboard. The buoy is in goodcondition and has two inches of growth on its bottom.

Riser .

The riser is 2-inch chain which is larger than required for a class E mooring.Single and double link measurements of the chain were all greater than 90 percent of itsinitial wire diameter. About 15 feet of the riser rests on the bottom before entering themud at a water depth of 10 feet. ,

Sinker/Ground Leq/Andor

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and satisfactory for continued use as a class E*- mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-'S. built can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended .

a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of ie mooring. J-

-A-67

-- -

Page 88: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-U-

h~..

"V

~ -~--------------- -

'1

~zzz~

I* -

p-,. ~

wp

0

a -\

13 -~

-'p1 - -.4 '-4!

2 -.

0 tz~ '-2

b

I-------------------------------- IIii SII

w ~)- o I.

_ I -,

* I>. - - - ~ I un

* -I W

U-.-'-. -- T .1.- I

LU I I II II IN I I II I

- - I, Fl IK -

I 2

~ N-j--' I I I 2

* I - I 111.1

I I

- __________ 1........... .... I~ . I

~i-,-i~u~I~~2~I

I. 2 ~ I

- ~Z i~ z'Z 2 2

I - IF I

I___ I _____________________- . . I. 211 2

A-68

- '.-XP- .. AV.tAt-

Page 89: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

3 ORNG BUOY NO: 5 -2,V/ BUOANCY: 2 N TYPE:

mEPm OP WATER: 14 CONDITION OF BOTrOM: NU

ANULLAST OVERHAUJLED: 2ip NECT OVERHAUL: VsIs

USAGE: 3oo DAYS

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 0

2.4'

%4

A--

I.''IAVF A CE~liCOM Q~l'QRt Ft-n. Hd3'2 ?i tl".LE ACT SASEPO F.E~l -0)jj U-C)ER ATR~ -isp~Cv!nlp PQ -

Page 90: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING S-2S

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 36-inch freeboard. Overall, the buoy

is in good condition.

Riser

This is 2-inch chain which is larger than required for an E class mooring. Single

and double link measurements are all greater than 90 percent of the chain's original wire

2" diameter. The riser enters the bottom at a water depth of 10 feet.

Sinker/Ground Leg/Anchor

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and is satisfactory for continued use as a class

E mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-

built can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended

a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring. ..

" ".

A-70K .A O . " n- - t A ' .F.W.FR 'NS0ECT:hN qrOf) f"

- ..o..%

Page 91: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

I~Ilkb

LU

0.0

LU

- 4 .. *7

<IIIf2

LUcn'~

- gg - h - -- 6W

A-71

Page 92: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

)WIORNG BUOY NO: 2 BUOYAN: 4 TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATE: -- IS Lz CMMITION OF BOTTOM: /TuD

ANULLAM OVERHAULD: MT~ NE MOERHAU: 4 /JAS ANNUALUSAGE: 300 DAYS• ' ~DATEI: 4

..

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 0

"4

dt

A-72C, "SP.'NVFACE4GCO'! REPORT FPO-! -9]291, "C)-FIJACT SASEBOf C Er '1 ,)111 4SC ,, ;R JrFOT I ) ,

* - -2-..

Page 93: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

1,

UINSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING T- I10

This is a 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 34-inch freeboard. The topside

jewelry consists of three shackles in good condition. The condition of the fiberglass is

good, but the buoy has a 6 to 10-degree list. The buoy bottom has about 3 inches of

marine growth.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 1/2-inch chain which is a 3/4 of an inch larger than

required for a class E mooring. Double link measurements of the riser were all greater

than 90 percent of the chain's original wire size. The riser has about 3 inches of marine

growth. About 10 feet of riser chain is visible on the bottom before it enters the mud.

Sinker/Ground Legs/Anchors

*Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and is satisfactory for continued use as a class

E mooring.

However, because of its slight list, the water-tight integrity of the buoy should

be checked at the earliest opportunity. It is uncertain that the leg/anchor/sinkerarrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design

load of a class E mooring. Recommended a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s)

and the design of the mooring.

i .

I' ..

A-73

..

Page 94: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

zI.|,

O.

~i

'I)

-- - - -- - - - -- -- - -- - - - --- I- . _-

I I I

SA-74

~ _ _ fi

Page 95: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

frOOKG B oy No: T- 10 Um cY: 6 Taa TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: 35CGIDITION OF BOTTIOM: -

LAST OVERHAULED: 2N=fl OVERHAUL: .ANNUAL

USAGE: 360 DAYS

.:. ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

e-4,

--

i .

2. *. . . --

Page 96: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESLL-TS

MOORING T-I I

I..Y

This is a 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 34-inch freeboard. A large section of

the fiberglass coating has peeled off the side of the buoy, and the buoy's sides are heavily

*. rusted. The chafing rail is dented and the top deck plate is covered with light rust.

* Riser

The riser consists of 2 1/2-inch chain which is three-quarters of an inch largerthan required for a class E mooring. All double link measurements were greater than 90

percent of the chain's initial wire diameter. The riser is covered with heavy marine

growth and vertically enters the bottom at a depth of 30 feet.

- Sinker/Ground Leq/Anchor

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and is satisfactory for continued use as a class

. E mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-

built can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended

a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-76

... . . . . . .. . o

Page 97: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

--- " -- Z 77 P. IZ W

LUae c<~

L*U

K z

A-7

~~jr-

Page 98: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: 7-// BUOYANCY: 6 ToNs TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: ?2 CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: .- L2? NEXT OVERHAUL: . ,ANNUAL 6188

USAGE: 360 DAYS DATE:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

6t

xI

'?

,1"Ar

A-78

.I ' C-,SNAAFACENGCOM QEPORI FP'O--(2 fl. "D.OuLEACT

SASE1O I 'E' Q' PI '1.,0 A' R ' '. 4 WE'O :T ,

. . 'C."

Page 99: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

RO-A167 273 CONMNOER FLEET ACTIVITIES SASEB FLEET MOORINGS 242UNDERWATER INSPECTION REPORT(U) NR FACILITIESENGINEERING COMMAND WASHINOTON DC CHESAPEAKE DIV

UNCLRSSIFIED SEP 83 CHES/NRVFRC-FPO-i-83(2) F/B 13/18

I'mmlmmlmmmllllllllllllll

BI~~MEBIII

Page 100: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

1.0.81.25

11111 1.6

11111 L@UEA O.F TA NAD -9-

6, 4r,

Page 101: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESUJTS

MOORING T-12I

This is a 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahowsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 34-inch freeboard. There is littlegrowth on the bottom of the buoy. The buoy is in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 1/2-inch chain which is three-quarters of an inch larger* than required for a class E mooring. All double link measurements were larger than 90

percent of the chain's original wire diameter. The riser is covered with a heavy marinegrowth and enters the bottom at a depth of 22 feet.

Sinker/Ground Leg/Anchor

L%

Not visible for inspection.

* Recommendation

This mooring is in good condition and is satisfactory for continued use as a classSE mooring.

It is uncertain that the leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the 50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended

" . a review of the forces on the moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

i.

- 1 .

, .A-79* ~ ~1T ~ '3 ~ ) K! '11EE NSPA' ')N

Page 102: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-. = -- . -- & % -........ *- . .~ . . -

___ - ~1~ - - - - - - - - - -:4

aI

IU4'

~44 V. A.I-zw

z~ .%' '1a K

*:~

~kj

p -

LU .~j I I I0 1

I -

- .1I -- -- -- *-

= ±1- LU I I I

= I I -= - ~ - - - - - . - -o ~~ I

-

- -a- - -.

- z

.. O~t~ Si*1.LU: - I

-.-.- ~ - n.e.- -J-a-~p~ \ I -r I I

- :2: I ~ -. -. - I - -

9... *4*~ ~ -

.1~ 'C II~a~Il~ I I 'a...'

I -2 Ii

a -- - , a2 I

a - - - -~-~ I

~I~] I - 'C - -

- - Iix- a' I 2

A -80

*......................................- .

Page 103: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

r ~ ' * 7.*) 7 7b~ '' .~j' 7~7 7' 7 ~ .~r~r:-~, E ~ N' X. -~.~-A -

LI

mwitzNG Buoy No: 7 - 12 BUOYANCY: 6 ON TYPE:____

DhPTH OF WATER: J.s2..Z CONDITION OF BOTOM:..LQ. /IU:D--A

- ANNUAL 7 JUSAGE: -360 DAYS DT: d~

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL -

2i-

424

A-81

Page 104: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

,'%'

0 INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING T- 13).N.

This is an 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 33-inch freeboard. The buoy's '.

identification number is badly worn and needs repainting. The buoy has only a light

coating of marine growth on its bottom but has a 10- to 15-degree list.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 f/2-inch chain which is three quarters of an inch larger

than required for a class E mooring. Some of the double link measurements of the riser

are between 80 and 90 percent of the chain's original wire diameter. About 10 feet of the

riser rests on the bottom before the chain enters the bottom at a depth of 21 feet.

Sinker

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring. -

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the

50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended a review of the forces on themoored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring. In addition, due to its list, the watertight

integrity of the buoy should be checked at the earliest opportunity.

A-82.. .. .. .. . .. .. .. . ............ E.oRr F.0-1-13?V, "LEACT SASE.O , " 'E .7-1

Page 105: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

0-- z -

Kz 0'Ut

~ I

i t_ 45

* - A-83

Page 106: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: 7"- BUOYANCY: E TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: /J_.k- NEXT OVERHAUL: _.A'A.,

V ANNUAL USAGE: 360 DAYS -

"NTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

I,"

6.z-

A-84

.4C-4- COM RLPOR *' **T ~ -Al W

Page 107: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESLTS

MOORING T- 14

N"'

This is an 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 35-inch freeboard. There is some light

rust bleeding of the buoy's sides, otherwise the buoy is in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 I/2-inch chain which is three-quarters of an inch larger

than required for a class E mooring. Double link caliper measurements of the riser were

between 80 and 90 percent of the chain's original wire size. About 10- to 15-feet of the

riser rests on the bottom before being connected to a sinker hairpin by an end link and a

shackle. The bottom is at a depth of 23 feet.

Sinker

The top of a partially submerged sinker was visible. Its hairpin was measured to

be 4 7/8-inches in diameter.

- Recommwndation

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is biL, normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in, this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the50,000 lb. design load of a class E mooring. Recommended a review of the forces on the

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-85

'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. . -,... ."......- -.....-.-................ ..-. '-........--.-..,

Page 108: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Q..

IsIt

~~6iw%KW

-Z

)A-86

Page 109: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORiNG Buoy No: T-1/4 BUOYANCY: 6 ToNs TYPE: ____

DEPTH OF WATER: d..L..z CONDITION OF BOTTM: iD'

LAST OVERHAULED: _.21124..- NEXT OVERHAUL: 4 ~7/87

ANNUJAL USAGE: 360 DAYS DATE:

kNTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMIEL

e0

A -87

C W F A CE GC OM Q f OR 9 n ~' 3 f 9 M; EC '.s~r~-jqpq.

Page 110: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING T- 15

This is a 9-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a"* hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 32- to 36-inch freeboard with a 5- to

10- degree list. The top jewelry consist of three shackles. The buoy is in good conditon.

Riser

This riser consists of 2 1/2-inch chain which is 3/4 of an inch larger than required. for a class E mooring. Double link measurements are all larger than 90 percent of the %

chain's original wire diameter. At a depth of 20 feet, the riser is attached to a sinkerhairpin.

Sinker

The top of a partially buried sinker is visible. The sinker has 4-inch hairpin,which is attached to the lower end of the riser and a single chain leg by the connecting

hardware shown in Figure A-2.

* Ground LeQ

This mooring has a single I I/2-inch diameter ground leg. One end of this leg isattached to a sinker and the other end to a bollard located ashore at the Helipad. DM-26

- requires I 3/4-inch diameter ground legs as a minimum for a class E mooring, and* therefore, this leg is undersized. A schematic drawing of this mooring is shown in Figure

A-2.

Recommwndation

" This mooring is in good condition. Due to its undersized ground leg, this mooringshould be downgraded from a class E to a class F mooring. Due to its list, the water-tight

integrity of the buoy should be checked at the earliest possible time. Additionally, theforces on the moored barge and the design of the mooring should be reviewed

A-88

S-..g "GCO14 ' rW, -A'' SASE E.

Page 111: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

N I

CM z

0 u 2

4 41

C44

.u .U A. ;" z

Page 112: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Al~z~Zt

144

.7'

~ZZ

;:l 0

1 L ~ ~ t- Tf III . h

-ZII I-Z

I\.\I N ~ NA'90

Page 113: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY No: 7- IS BUOYANICY: TONS TYPE:____

DEPTH OF WATER: 2 FTCONDITION OF BOTTOM: ~~

LAST OVERHAULED: I8jNEXT OVERHAUL: _ 8 .V NNUAL USAGE: 360 DAYSDAE

kANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

t~y4

dW*A Amd...w

Page 114: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

5%

~~~MOORING T-16g,..

This is an 8-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

{ hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 30-inch freeboard. The fiberglass is in"

"j ~good condition but the topside chafing rail is severely damaged. l.

.- '. Riser.i.

~~~This riser consists of 2 3/8-inch chain which is 5/8 of an inch larger than required :*;

for a class E mooring. Double link measurements near the middle of the exposed riser ; :

'-i were between 80 and 90 percent of the 2 I/2-inch diameter gouge used. Therefore, the

--:

5" ~chain was between 84 and 95 percent of its original wire diameter. The riser contains an -..

end link and a shackle at a depth of about 18 feet. The riser chain enters the bottom at a -"i depth of 30 feet.

'" ~Sinkcer .'.

N*.5

JJJ ~Not visible for inspection.,.".

_" Recoommndation ..

This mooring is in fair condition. il

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is -..

"'- normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring. "'''

I However, in this case, the larger- than-requi red original wire diameter of the riser chain I

. ~allows it to still be capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. It is uncertain that Ve , .

~leg/anchor/sinker arrangement and sizes shown in the as-built can adequately resist the "'

50,000 lb. design fod of a class E mooring. Recommended a review of the forces on the .

moored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-92

', G RESORT FPOE-]2Rl, " mFL_.CT SASE FIL S ,R

-. . '

MOORING-T,,6o

Page 115: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ab

'44 R,

z1 -

Q1 0

> ~

00

I z

LU -.

-A-9

Page 116: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: 7 /aBUOYANCY: 4 TONS TYPE: ____

DEPTH OF WATER: 30 PT CONDITION OF BOTTOM:

LAST OVERHAULED: t3133 NEXT OVERHAUL: 32ANNUAL

USAGE: - 0 (Installed in FY-83) DATE: j...&2 *

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

24

:,TN

A-4

J*IA--7

Page 117: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

mV 4.

INSPECTION RESLLTS

MOORING T- 17

,.... ,.

This Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a hawsepipe has a !.-6

diameter of 9 feet 4 inches. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 40-inch freeboard.The buoy has a 5- to 10-degree list, and its chafing rail is badly damaged. The fiberglass

coating is in good condition.

Riser

The riser consists of 2 3/8-inch chain which is 5/8 of an inch larger than required

for a class E mooring. Although the middle and upper portions of the riser were found to

be in good condition, the results of double link measurements of the lower portion were

between 80 and 90 percent of the 2 1/2-inch wire diameter gauge used. Therefore the

W chain measured between 84 and 95 percent of its original wire diameter. The riser is

covered with light marine growth and enters the mud at a water depth of 30 feet. -.

Sinker

"Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component isnormally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows this mooring to be still capable of withstanding class E mooring loads. Because ofits list, the water-tight integrity of the buoy should be checked at the earliest

opportunity. Additionally, the forces on the moored barge and the design of the mooring

should be reviewed.

A-9

1qSAFC4C% EOT"OFLATSSB

7' I, qr o r".

Page 118: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

'-.

0'I5

C6 V-N

z44(3X

z z4

- - % -r- 4 4 -- -A,-96

Page 119: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MOORING BUOY NO: -T .zL7. BUOYANCY: 6- Toms TYPE: ___

DEPTH OF WATER: t0 F CONDITION OF BOTTOM: /11

LAST OVERHAULED: NEXT OVERHAUL: 4ANNUAL

USAGE: 0 (Installed in FY-83) DATE:

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: 20 DAYS/BARGE, FLOAT, CAMEL

2Y4

A-97-

~ Qc~ 11r 3U.'~3{Z~,'COMWLEACT SASE90'~ ~ ~ ~ ~ !

Page 120: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.,- - 11, -r - .- -I- -- - -..V -

.°.w,0

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORNG Y-I

This is a 13-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

:. hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 39-inch freeboard. The chafing rail

has been scraped but shows little rust. There are some rust spots where the chafing rail

stanchions are welded to the top deck plating.

Riser

The first 65 feet of riser consists of 3 1/2-inch chain. The lower end of this

* . section of the riser is connected by a 5 5/8-inch shackle to the lower portion of the riser,

which consists of 3-inch chain. Both of these sections of the riser are comprised of chain

considerably larger than the 2 1/2-inch chain required for a class B mooring. However,

double link measurements taken at the 40-foot level and near the mud line were less than

80 percent of the chain's original wire size. The lowest double link measurement recorded

was 4 5/8 inches (77 percent). This measurement was obtained at the bottom. About 20

feet of chain rests on the bottom before the riser enters the sand.

Sinker/Ground Les/Anchors ::

Not visible for inspection.

Recornmmndation

This mooring is in poor condition.

With a portion of the riser chain worn to less than 80 percent of its original wire

-: diameter, recommend that this mooring be removed from service, overhauled, and its

riser chain replaced. ,..

A-98'I C'.4AVo ACENGCOm 3 c DOw I FDO - .-93f28 , "COMFL.ACT SASE(I --

2 " " L J,004!IS V.1'-_ '.w.A'E-4 .,,',c 10 ; o .

-%

Page 121: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Ui -

41147

L.L

0~Z I Ii

A-9

Page 122: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

I - MOORNG BUOY NO: Y - BUOYANCY: /8 TONS TYPE:

DEPTH OF WATER: J12 CONDITION OF BOTTOM: _

LAST OVERAULED: ._...eE -NXT OVERHAUL: _

4- NUAL USAGE: 30 DAYS DATE: 4-/"8.3

ANTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNOWN

-% . .C h L 6 c g d g f•i/

.J

,o-a

/84.

6YAIA 11 -,- r

~A-lO0

• - .t r ,, ' .I,.,L ,.. .'. - ".. - -.-'-:-"--'.--" -' ".-',"."-.-"....'" '-" "."-- .-, - ." . , ..-. -' -' -" -', -

Page 123: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING Y-2

This is an 13-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with ahawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 54-inch freeboard. The chafing rail isdented but has no rust. The fiberglass coating and fenders are in good condition. Thebottom is covered with 3 inches of marine growth.

%l Riser

The first 60 feet of the riser is 3 1/2-inch chain. From the 60-foot level to the* bottom (120 feet), the riser consists of 3-inch chain. All measurements were greater than

90 percent of the chain's original wire diameter except near the bottom where double linkmeasurements taken were between 80 and 90 percent. About 20 feet of the riser rests on

the bottom before the chain enters the mud.

Sinker/Ground Legs/Anchors

Not visible for inspection.

Recommendation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component isnormally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

.. However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

V. allows it to still be capable of withstanding class B mooring loads. It is uncertain that theleg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-built drawing can adequately resist the125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on themoored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-101

# * E , ,, C. * * G C 0. .P *T * *- ' - U 1 2 V * C UW L E A C S A S E R. 0 * '. " t *' *, . - '- X . - . , . .

Page 124: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

4- -J .-

U ('. -4,.-

U ~

3-2

z - -o -.

43

- ~~4>~4 ~

- ~

\~ ~* ~ ~ - - I N

-' Ti I.~ -

~ ~- IiN

).. 0

- - I I -

~ 0 I~\I -

- ~- I-

'U

~BJ~* -. -.--- ~--

- LU

~ ~.- -

IF ~N

- I

LU - -. -- - -. I I - * -

2 ii ______

- I* I iii 'I [ L~1 ~ ~* - I III *

- i 2 i III -I III t ill I~IiI' -

I~

*< ~ -1 2i ~I-

- IK~* - <I~)I -I- . -

- - -- z ~ -. 2,C. i:~ i -. ___ _________

- - - Th~- - I

hI __________________________

V A-102

- * . .

-, k tL tI

Page 125: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

7. 7 77 7 7. 7 - . W. . .

mooRING UOy No: Y-2 DUOANCr: To TYPE: _ _

DEPTH OF WATER: /2 C ONDITION OF BOTTr: AiuD

LAST OVERHAULED: /1/ OVERHAUL: .2/ .

::*..NNUAL USAGE: 30 QAYS DA72: 4/~L

,NTICIPATED USAGE/TYPE: UNIKNOWN

\ --A

," . *- "7 " -

_ i '. 6±._6t

&d

A-103. 7 . . . . . c.D... .

Page 126: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

INSPECTION RESULTS

MOORING Y-3

This is an 13-foot-diameter Japanese designed and built drum-type buoy with a

hawsepipe. The buoy is fiberglass coated and has a 46-inch freeboard. The hawsepipe and

top jewelry have been recently painted. The top fender has several bolts that have pulled

free. The buoy's bottom looks good.

Riser

The riser consists of 3 1/2- and 3 1/4-inch chain vice the 2 1/2-inch required for

a class B mooring. Some of the double link measurements revealed that sections of the

riser are worn to between 80 and 90 percent of the chain's original wire size. There are

12 chain links on the bottom before the riser.enters the bottom. There is no marine

3 igrowth on the riser chain.

Sinker/Groud Legs/Anchors

! Not visible for inspection.

Recomwndation

This mooring is in fair condition.

A measurement between 80 and 90 percent of any mooring component is

normally cause for a mooring to be downgraded to the next lower class of mooring.

However, in this case, the larger-than-required original wire diameter of the riser chain

allows it to still be capable of withstanding class B mooring loads. It is uncertain that the

leg/sinker/anchor arrangement shown in the as-built drawing can adequately resist the

125,000 lb. design load of a class B mooring. Recommend a review of the forces on themoored vessel(s) and the design of the mooring.

A-104i-IREPORT FPO-}-f](21. "-Cn fLE4CT ,AS '1 "~ -0 44, " ' - • '"..r

..... . .. ................ ..* ." . '-" ~ -" - ' S"" *.* - "' % " - " - " '"* ' % "*"% - % % %*°' % "

Page 127: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- -

6AJJ

..

A-0

Page 128: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

MORYNG BUOY NO: YL i BUaNmCY: 8...L. Tom TYPE: -

.. o-

CFTH OF WATER: 7, d CMMITION OF BOTTOM: .

LAST OVERHIAULED: /118/ N=~r OVERHAUL: - /4.

NNUAL USAGE: 30 DAYS DATE: -

.ANTICA-PATED USAGE/TYPE: UNKNOWN

VV

4T... .

3~4*

p-

o ...- o

4664

A-106r;CE A'FACNGCOm QEPORT Po0-.-83 29), "COMFLEACT SASEBO

-LE" -WQ,4 G . iSPEP.121 ,,

. .. . . . ... . . . ', . - . , . ' . ,

Page 129: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ANNEXB

BUOY LOCATION SURVEY DATA

Page 130: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ANNEX B

SASEBO BUOY LOCATION SURVEY DATA. PWC SASEBO provided the inspection teamwith maps of the six areas in Sasebo Bay which contain fleet moorings. These areas are asfol lows:

JULIET BASINMAEBATA AREA

HARIO SHIMA (NORTH END)HARIO SHIMA (SOUTH END)

YOKOSE TERMINAL

IORIZAKI AREA

Applicable sections of these maps which depict the geographic locations of the bench-

marks used to obtain the survey data are contained in this Annex. Descriptions of these

benchmarks, their specific geographic locations, and the buoy angles measured from each , :A

benchmark follow. All photographs referenced in these descriptions are contained inAnnex C.

Juliet Basin

Description of Benchmark J-I - located on the western wall of Juliet Basin on a

concrete jetty supporting a steel crane at the eastern end of building 140. Thebenchmark is a red X with an orange painted circle around it near a yellow bollardhalfway between the end of the concrete and the crane footing. Photographs S-Iand S-2 show details of Benchmark J-1. See Figure B-I for location of this

benchmark on the map.

Description of Benchmark J-2 - located on the helipad at the western side of the

entrance to Juliet Basin. The benchmark is a red plastic marker with an orangepainted circle around it located approximately IS' west and 15' north of the SE inner Icorner of the low walk. See Figure B- I for location on the map. Photographs S-3

and S-4 show Benchmark J-2.

B-2

Page 131: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

I \ NEX SNACK BAR& CMO ANNEX- allSPECIAL SERVICES & NMPX2R

SENAVY EXCHANGFLEET LANDING

-Pl.______POST OFFICE, 8-*x - I- - 350-42- TELEPHONE EXHANGE-

PACKAGI

w 140

362 Benchmark J-17'

~-TATEGAMI PENINSUL

101 3 H-IRASE PENINSULA~

MSDF JULIET BASIN-- -

362~~ HIP REPAIRSM

* ~Z.-- SMALL CRt

S359 3IEM BAR

SECURITY

___ BASE GY y-:-36 :--. EMEW D1

irHOBBY' S-1010 1 E A1379.. -- 7 0 100 200 300 400 500,LGA

-

o l-~ 50, 100 150'

- '%x.. GRAPHIC SCALES C AR

AVOROFAC SA

IL HO/COIMUN ICATIONSLAT. 09629"1

LONG. 120 43' 16"Benchmark J.2

FIGURE B-1. JULIET BASIN (J-i/J-2)_________%

B-3

Page 132: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Description of Benchmark J-3 - located on top of southern most concrete jetty oneast side of the mouth of Juliet Basin. The benchmark is the NE corner of a steel

plate located 2 feet south and 2 feet east of the NW corner of the jetty next to the%

H(O/Crommuanicaionsi building (see Figure B-2). It also is marked by a painted red X

and a circle. Photograph S-5 is a picture of Benchmark J-3.

Ancles Measured at Benchmark J- I Angles Measured at Benchmark J-2

Bu~ Clockwise Angle from "J-3"' Buoy Clockwise Angle from "J-3"T- 12 280 32' 40", I-S 970 59' 0

T- 17 280 36' 00", I -N 970 38' 40"1T-1I3 300 38' 20", T-1I3 -660 29' 20"1

T-16 300 40' 00" T-12 -680 41' 00"1

T-lI 1330 47, 40"1 T-17 -860 14' 20"T-14 350 491 40"1 T-16 -860 18' 00"1

T-10 380 23' 00" T-lI 1 920 25' 40"f

T-15 380 44' 00" T- 14 -1080 31' 00"T-10 -1080 52' 20"1

To 11.-211 330 52' 00"1 T-15

S2S -1500 33' 20", To "OA" -920 32' 00"S2N -1660 34' 00"0

* Angles Measured at Benchmark J-3

Buoy Clockwise Angle from "Ji-I"I

S-2S 50 14' 40"9

S-2N 30 09' 40"1

T- 17 -200 08' 40"1

T-16 -260 46' 40"#

T-I 1 370 21' 20"1

T-12 -370 25' 40"1T-10 -380 07' 40",

T- 13 -440 20' 00"

T-14 -450 05' 20"1

T-1 I-450 44' 20"* P

I N -970 39' 40"1

is -Illo 18' 20",

Approximate Angleto Benchmark J-2 -53o 49 20"1

OPB-

Page 133: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

> Z .'Z zt .- ~ . - .-

* 9D

C?)

K' - LU

w U)

m :

wcix m -E._

40 U.4 0 I-->

Wr wL Wwr U

U) *- D0 ( L_

a. 0

0S

O_ c.)

-Z (2- 4 0

Page 134: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Maebata Area

Description of M-1 - located on the seawall in front of building 728, 69 feet NE of

the corner of the wall shown in Figure B-3. The benchmark is an orange painted

circle with an X in the center on a rack about 2 feet from the edge of the wall. SeePhotograph S-6 for a close up view.

Description of M-2 - located on the same wall as M-1, 114 feet NE of M-1. The

marker is an orange painted circle with an X in the center on concrete. Figure B-3

shows the location and Photograph S-7 is a close up view of the benchmark.

Description of Backsight - From both M-I and M-2, the peaked front center of the

roof of Building 728 shown in Photograph S-8.

Angles Measured at Benchmark M- I Angles Measured at Benchmark M-2

Buoy Clockwise Angle from Bid. 728 Buoy Clockwise Angle from Bid. 728M-12 1890 13' 40" M-13 1190 21' 00"

M- I1 2140 23' 00" M-12 1390 04' 40"

M-10 2300 36' 20" M-l 1 1700 41' 20"

M-15 2500 17' 40" M-10 1910 52' 40"

M-14 2500 17' 40" M-15 2070 6' 00"

M-13* M-14 2110 25' 20"a * Note: M- 13 in process of being overhauled.

YD blocking view of buoy.

Hario Shima - North End

Description of H-I - located 3 feet north and 3 feet east of SW corner of pier with

Building 984 on it. Figure B-4 shows the location. The marker is an orange painted

circle with an X in the center. Photograph S-9 shows the details.

Description of H-2 - located 244' 10" east of H-I on the same pier. See Figure B-4

for location and Photograph S-10 for details.

B-6

............... ........._. ., ........ _,,,. - . .,.,........,.......... --......... ..................... .... ............................ ,...-.-.:.:.:

Page 135: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

00

% ID

q- ii

________

'cc

t-t

z ow~~" A ~ ~

B-7

Page 136: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

V1

40

*8.2

30.2'

- 20 &

- N 300.5- - x ~* W~ j~? V;32.1 ~ <

9b? 3 30'73VI (-3072

-~H-1l H-6A')ST EMR FAC/OPS BLDG 6615' *

'974 H-9 ~ -.3007'34' E 129046 191. - 97 -

ft-9

-ft5

Benchmark H-1 0 3- 7 t

*ft 'At

Benchmark H1-2 i

A--

AA-13

FIGURE B-4. HARIO SHIMA.NORTH END

B-8 P7

Page 137: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

F . - I T'_ _K _,"

7

Angles Measured at Benchmark H- I Angles Measured at Benchmark H-2

Buoy Clockwise Angle from H-I Buoy Clockwise Angle from H-2A 10 0' 40" A13 350 47' 20"

A12 -102° 14' 00" A12 530 49' 20",

A13 -1300 34' 40" A ll 1790 20' 00" "

KL

Hario Shima - South End

Description of H-3 - located at bend in seawall near Buildings 772 and 3052B. The .

benchmark is an orange painted circle with an X in the center on the concrete capof the wall. Figure B-5 shows the location on the base map and Figure B-6 shows

the position of utility pole #16 (see utility pole map) which is near the benchmark.Photograph 5-I I shows Benchmark H-3.

Description of H-4 - located on same wall as H-3, 273 feet north near utility pole

#18 (see utility pole map). The marker is similar to H-3. See Figures B-5 and B-6.

Photograph S-12 shows pole #18 while Photograph S-13 is a closeup of the H-4

marker.

Angles Measured at Benchmark H-3 Angles Measured at Benchmark H-4

-Buoy Clockwise Angle from H-3 Buoy Clockwise Angle from H-4

A14 -3520 28' 00" A14 -1730 48' 40"

A15 -3470 10' 40" A15 -1670 34' 40"

A16 -34 0 15' 40" A16 -1590 06' 40""A17 -3320 06' 00" A17 -1420 45' 20"'A18 -2940 47' 40" A18 -830 15' 20"A 1 -2520 22' 40" A19 -650 22' 00"

Yokose Terminal

Description of Benchmark Y-A - located at corner of wall as shown in Figure B-7.The benchmark is an orange circle with an X in the center painted on the concrete

top of the wall. Photograph S-14 shows the details of Y-A.

," %,

B-9

-:...'.: .... - ."" ." : .' ,',.- ' - .' ..... ,. , . . .*. .. . .. .. . ,..-. . . . .-- . . ... . '. . -. .- .

Page 138: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

30 i63

0:6

P-I'S - ol

lo -3

9eanchw'ark 14

P-1

30 - -30

\

FIGURE B-5. HARIO SHIMA-SOUTH END C'xr

5' B-10

Page 139: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

t'- -777 77.7-777771 -z- T-IT-707 -! M

837

* . 8360

:2 p * ' 976

A . *835

302

p... ~834

j D F '833

vAMrACTEM mf rL 832 * 32

1-1 I3 K VA

UTILITY POLE =1883

*7 71 2 UTILITY POLE =16 8

305298 82

8-1

3052-

BB8.

9-1-2

3052

30054

30 49 3047 3046 S

* 3050*FIGURE B-6. HARIO SHIMA-SOUTH END (UTILITY POLES)

Page 140: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ONN~0

Benchmark VA

Benchmark YB

Backsight ,L

40

-.D

P4""4

0

1IUR B-.YKSETRIA

j-1 <

Page 141: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Description of Benchmark Y-B - located 181' 4", west of Y-A on the some wall and is i.:l-similarly marked. See Figure B-7. Photograph S-15 shows a distant view of Y-B.

Description of Bcksight - The NW corner of Building 803.

i Angles Measured at Benchmark Y-A Angles Measured at Benchmark Y-B j_

. ]Buoy Clockwise Angle from Bid. 803 Buoy Clockwise Angle from Bid. 803 2''

00'1~

Y-1I 200 561 401" Y-1I 240 081 0 '''

""Y-2 1540 24,1 00" Y-2 1590 48' 20" .,5:

-- Y-3 1960 071 40"1 Y-3 1900 06' 4 0" ',

.- M-20 2280 551 00", M-20 2140 051 40" ,

to Y-A 790 02' 0 -''1

Iorizaki Area -

" , ..

Description of Benchmark I-A - located at NE corner of pier on top of a bollard.

Figures B-8 and B-9 show the location of the mark. Photograph S-16 shows theds ti oY

- ~bollard. -'

Description of Benchmark I-B - cated on the same pier at the corner, 2of' Builing803

west of I-A (see Figures B-8 and B-9, and Photograph S- 18). The mark is an orange --

~circle with an X in the center pointed on the concrete.

Description pf Benchmark i-C -located at the concrete entrance to a storage tunnel

Bone lockwuisAng0ade ngtg from Bd 80u e C tckie N lrer fr Bidi80

-21 Phowomaph S- 1nd Photograph S-0 0 5 'h0 view of 0' I ing

to Y-Ackat 790ad02'. 00"]

I.. __-____

Description of Benark-Wesitngfo I-A - oaeatN onr ofB pieo bcsto of ah bollard.

Dcriptir of Bnchm0,ak Iwoado hensgtg saom pIer ate the N corner, 255 6"ldn

S-0. showtmrker-7isBidng60fo I-CAan Photograph S-22 isth view of thBirurm i-C loing "'

600 from I-B.

B--13

* ..... **.."

Page 142: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Benchmark IS

Backsight for I A and IB

0652- 4

Benchmark IA

Backsight for IC

A"~

Or 'a -

* - Benchmark IC

B-1

Page 143: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d .7 17 -.* -*- -* ---.--.-- . ---- - - - - -- -7 - -. -- - .

C,..

MA4

c. ,

UIA

N

UA.

1 10

CC

z a.

B-15

Page 144: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Angles Measured from Benchmark I-A

Clockwise Angle from I-A off NW Comer of T-600

Buoy I-I 540 36' 40"

Buoy 1-2 2420 13' 40"

Site 1-8 580 05' 00" (as a check)

Buoy6 1 2110 44' 40"

Angles Measured from Benchmark I-B

Clockwise Angle from I-B off NW Corner of T-600

Buoy I-I 145 0 44' 41"

Buoy 1-2 3340 22' 40".

Site I-A 3310 47' 00" (as a check)

Buoy 61 3160 01' 20"

Angles Measured from Benchmark I-C

Clockwise Angle from I-C off NE Corner of T-600Site I-A 080 25' 20" (as a check)

Buoy 1-2 400 I19' 00"

Buoy 61 1280 03' 40"

%

. A

B-16

Page 145: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ANNEX C

PHOTOGRAPHS

C-

Page 146: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

A..... ~

.1*

%. %-

S

Ii.. .~~.

~~1~

COMFLEACT SASEBO

SURVEY PHOTOGRAPHS

U.

m

qa.

'1..

C- 2~~~~1

- ... ~........ ..

.* ~

Page 147: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

S-1. Benchmark J-1 at Juliet Basin

S-2. Closeup of Benchmark J-1

C- 3

Page 148: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

p4 5,

p 'p

S-3. Benchmark J-2 on the Helipad at Juliet Basin -.

I4. 4

4 p.4.J.

U

'-4

t S-4. Closeup of Benchmark J-2

VC- 4

Ii~

4- ,.4. . .......

Page 149: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

II

g0

S-6. BcmakM- ncha W-3atl Jintet Basin re

Page 150: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ft ,t

S-7. Benchmark M-2 on a Wall in the Maebata Area -a

S-8.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Buldn 72 atMeaa lsrRo ea sda aki on

Page 151: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

S-9. Benchmark H-1 at Hario Shima Area (North End)

was.*

S-10. Benchmark H-2 at Hario Shima Area (North End)

C-7

Page 152: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-2,,

S-l1. Benchmark H-3 at Hario Shima Area (South End)

L.S-12. Benchmark H4 Behind Utility Pole t0l8

C-9

Page 153: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-. S-13. Closeup of Benchmark HA at Hario Shima (South End)

S-14. Benchmark V-A at the Yokose Terminal

C- 9

Page 154: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

I- Benchmark Y-!3

S -15. Benchmark Y-B at the Vokose TerminalOP

-1

Page 155: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

-v.

- 1pC

IT'L

S-17. View of Building 600 from Benchmark I-A

S-18. Benchmark I-B at the lorizaki Area

C-11

Page 156: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

S-19. View of Building 600 from Benchmark I-B

2C 1

Page 157: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

It

S-21. Closeup of Benchmark I-C

71~

r S-22. View of the lorizaki Pier from Benchmark I-C

C-13

Page 158: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

C-14

Page 159: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- - - W. ~'. *-. .~,.T.f ~ -~ -._ - *.. - .. ' .~ -

.rVN

V

.1.9

V. j-- ft.

S.

*1,r.eSection of Lower Fender Sheared off Buoy I-N

p9~w

'I-,-.

IL

4~%,

Iv,-:4-

I4 Mooring I-N. Clean, Shiny Chain Near Bottom

*1-MI

C-iS ~-:

1<V .... I

............................ - - - ...........- . .

..........................

-r . .r -.................tfla..

42sZ,..\2. tAm - 2% 2....

Page 160: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Damaged Fender of Buoy 1-2

C Buoy A-17. Excellent Topside Condition

Page 161: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

'Ca-

Page 162: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Buoy M-15 with Damaged Chafing Rail

Mooring T- 15. Ground Leg Between Water Surface andthe Bollard on the Helipad

Page 163: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

%VMooring T-15. Closeup of the Ground Leg in the Sea/Air Environment '

tL

C-1

ZIPP

Page 164: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

ANNEX D

REFERENCES

D-

Page 165: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

11, 02 - - ' UUUU _ 17

F-R..OMCHESNAVFACENGCO1 WASHINGTON DC :I. bTO:COMiFLEACT SASEBO JA

INFO COINAVFACENGCOMI ALEXANDRIA VA

PACNAVFACENGCOMI PEARL HARBOR HI

UNCLAS //N11000// " -

ISUBJ: FLEET MlOORING INSPECTION

1. A CHESNAVFACENGCOl/UCT TWO UNDERWATER INSPECTION OF THE 34 FLEET

MOORINGS LOCATED AT SASEBO WAS CONDUCTED DURING THE PERIOD 10-20

MAY 1983. THIS IS A PRELIMINARY REPORT OF THE INSPECTION RESULTS

TO PROVIDE AN ALERT TO SEVERAL SIGNIFICANT FINDINGS;A. MOORINGS A-17, A-19, -i, S-2-N, S-2-S, T-10, T-11, T-12:

i GOOD CONDITION.

B. MOORINGS 1-S, 61, A-11, A-12, A-13, A-14, A-15, A-16, A-18,

-1 - 1, 1-2, M-12, M-13, MI-14, MI-15, M-20, T-13, T-14, T-16, T-17,

Y-2, Y-3: OVERSIZED CHAIN FOUND WORN TO BETWEEN 80 -D 90 PERCENT

OF ITS ORIGINAL SIZE - FAIR CONDITION. NO DOWNGRADING REQUIRED.

A C. MOORING T-15: 1-3/4 INCH CHAIN FOUND WORN TO BETWEEN 80

4 AND 90 PERCENT OF ITS ORIGINAL SIZE - FAIR CONDITION. RECOMMEND3

2 DOWNGRADING FROM CLASS E TO CLASS F.

0DiSTR

Pii l

fl-&Ilfb 1 P % I l&"I T.Lji 0O.ll1 -VVDL 0 Ill sobt Imt 'Ni lllIU lOft

COPY FPO-1C..09..00. DAILY--THEODORE JONES, FPO-1C{(PDC) :

433-3881 29 JUN 1983 (.FPO-IC{PDC FPO-1C7. . FPO-10P2-

" H.S- TEVENSON, CDR, CEC, USN 0161._ ]]

DD , 0 .',, 173/2 (OCRi P*I OSOWl ,I0.,1o,S ,• OLI1

I 9 us Gpe lt, . *,33,0, 1 ,0l U,

*,. .. .. , . . . ' ' ' " ' ' " "* * ". ..S . . t . S. . . * "..

.... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~If 0 102 L lt~iiibi i~lLll'll~ I1 4=rlliJ~t Ii 72bl/ ~i

Page 166: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

____c 01 ft - C..Ass SLA jc

o -. • ° .. . . . .

02 RR I uuuu_ 1791620

D. nOORINnG 1-N: CHESNAVFACENGCOM ALREADY TASKED TO ADVISE

ON DISPOSITrvA OF IOORINGS 1-N AND 1-S. "tIR. BILL SEELIG HAS

RESP014DED SEPARATELY. LARGE SECTION OF BUOY FENDER SHEARED OFF

RECOMMENDED REPAIRING BUOY.

E. MOORING M-11: 2-INCH RISER WORN TO LESS THAN 80 PERCENT OF

ORIGINAL SIZE - POOR CONDITION. RECOMMIEND OVERHAUL.

F. MOORING Y-1: 3-INCH RISER WORN TO LESS THAN 80 PERCENT OF ITS

ORIGINAL SIZE - POOR CONDITION. RECOMIEND OVERHAUL.

2. RECOMMENDATIONS PRESENTED HERE BASED ON DIVER MIEASUREMENTS OF

ACCESSIBLE CHAIN. AS DISCUSSED BETWEEN MR. K MUKAIGAWA {PACNAVFAC-

ENGCOl} AND MR. T. JONES {CHESNAVFACENGCOM} ON 24 JUNE 1983, THERE

ARE ADDITIONAL CONCERNS ABOUT THE MIOORINGS HOLDING CAPAC.ITIES DUE

TO THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JAPANESE AND THE STANDARD DESIGNS

SPECIFIED IN THE FLEET fOORING DESIGN MANUAL {DM-26}. A DETAILED

m DISCUSSION WILL BE PRESENTED IN THE INSPECTION REPORT. ANTICIPATE

DISTRIBUTION IN AUGUST 1983.

" - 3 CHESNAVFACENGCOM POINT OF CONTACT IS MR. TED JONES AT AUTOVON3.".

3 288-3881 OR {202} 433-3881.

2I

CA"1.... ityp T*M( 14I1 O6,,Cl SI~M O. l....f SIL i UC,OlSIOU $'...

1.0P1 D %.me himl OfocI IST0L AND P.001

$.&"Tat CLuArt, , Al.o0 Dal[ 711 GROUP

D0 ,.:r, 173/2 (OCR) 0., -,2 ,,'I o-+oLI, I U I • I-N' - , " , I1

D-3 ft..

Page 167: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

.. L . L L " .' .' A I | t .I i

L Lp

RUUII r4E

R 1sbnflz APR R3

FM CLI:,FLEAC) SAbEbO J&

. .NI

7U ClikLSsgAvFArE.6aCLU U~~,rGOwIC

RTUNCLAS //'411000//

ATTN: mR TED JUtJISSuBJ: FLEET mAORIG I NSPEC TIOiS

A. CHESNAvFACENGCOM AASHINGTON DC Oa2029Z APR R3

1 1. IN REPLY TO kEF At THE FOLLOMING INFORMATION IS FOR.lAx&ED FOR f(jR I- L

.: RLFERENCE:A. MAINTENANCE HISTORY

DATE INSTALLED: UNKNOON, EXCEPT THE FOLLOWING UUOYS

T-16: MAR 1983T-17: MAR 1983

DATE INSPECTED: AbOVE-,EATER INSPECTION: JUN 82

UNDER-WATER INSPECTION: AUG 81

*-. DATE OVERHAULED: REFER TO IHE LIST BELumCONDITION: REFER TO THE LIST BELO"-

8. MOJRIN&U DESIGN CALCULATICoN AND ORAwINGSDESIGN CALCULAIU4S: NOT AVAILABLE

DRAWINGS: MAILLD SLPARATELYC. "AS-dUILTO MATERIAL LIST: MAILED SEPARATELY

D. LOCArIUN MAP OF ALL ,MOURINGS:3AILEo SEPAIRA1ELY

E. ANTICIPATED MOJRING USAGE DURING INSPECTION:REFER TO 1HE LIST SELUA

F. PLANNED REPAIRS AND OVERHAULS: REFER TO THE LIST BELOW

G. TYPES OF CLASSES OF SHIPS: AEr AD, CGv FFe TAEP SUBAND CARGO SrIPS

H, CATHUDIC PROlECTION SYSTEM: NOT APPLIED1. SPECIFIC DATA PER MOORING

LAS1 REPORTED ANTICIPATED PLANNEDt4O. OVERHAULED CONDITION USAGE OVERHAUL

1-N MAY 79 POOR UNKNOAN MAY 8461 DEC 76 POOR UIIKNOAN JUN 83I-i DEC 79 FAIR UNKNOv.N JUN 841-2 DEC 79 FAIR UNKNOnN JUL 84

DLVR:CHESNAVFACENGCOJM WASHINGTON DC(9)...ACT

RTD: 000-000/COPIES: 0009

606456/105 1 OF 2 Mi 0310 105/14:3bZ 150602Z APR "3

C3N:RXOY00316 CUMFLEACT SASES) JA

uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu iiuU U UNC L A SSIF I ED UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

-4 ........................

Page 168: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

SIV

V-I Jn A 4 (AI Fl l JUN 8-S

Y-2 JUN A 1 UU U F AT I JUL 85Y-3 A!AIFArqAG8

1'S Jj 'v 79 PuOkcUK.e~ J~jN 6.5A-l1 JOL 82 GOOD ZU uArS APR 86

. A-12 AUG 82 GCO%) 20 uAyS MAY 86A-13 SEP 82 G3O0 20 DAYS JU IN 8 6A-114 SEP 77 POOk 20 DAYS APR 83

A-I SEP 78 FAIR 20 DAYS MAY a3A-1b SEP 78 FAIR .20 DAYS JUN ASA-17 NOV 80 FAIR 20 DAYS FEB 85A-18 JA4I 83 GUOD 2u JAYS JUL 8bA-19" NOV 79 POOR 20 DAYS FEB 84iM -10 NOV 79 POOR 20 DAYS MAR 8qM-1l DEC 77 FAIk 20 DAYS JUN 83

. M-12 NjV 79 FAIR 20 DAYS APR 84M-13 DEC 77 POOR 20 DAYS JUL 83M-14 NOV 79 POOR 20 DAYS AUG 84

M-15 DEC 77 POOR 20 DAYS AUG 83M-20 NOV 79 FAIR 20 DAYS SEP 84

* T-10 FEB 81 FAIR 20 DAYS MAR 85

T-11 DEC 77 POOR 20 DAYS SEP 83

r+ T-12 DEC 77 POOR 20 DAYS SEP 83

T-13 JAN 83 GOOD 20 DAYS MAY 86

T-14 JA4 75 FAIR 20 DAYS JUN 83

T-15 FE9 83 GOOD 20 DAYS AUG 87

T-16 .%TE GOOD 20 DAYS MAR 88T-17 iEA GOOD 20 DAYS APR 88

S-2S FEB 81 GOOD 0 .APR 85S-2N FEB 81 GOOD 0 MAY 85

2. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PACKAGE MAILED UNDER SEPARATE COVER TO

CHESNAVFACENGCOMST

o

606456/10S 2 OF 2 M1 0310 10s/14:36Z 150602Z APR 83L CSN:RXOYO0316 COMFLEACT SASEBO JA

U U N C L A 3 S I F I E D UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

D- 5

S......,' ' ', , .,'' ''" -.. "' '" ' "" " % """ ' " ' % "" ' '

Page 169: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

* ~~~~~ ~... .....-. . . -. .- . --

CHESNAVFACENGCOfl WASHINGTON DC

COIIFLEACT SASEB3O JA p,

.LNFO COMNAVFACENGCOII ALEXANDRIA VA

PACNAVFACENGCOI PEARL HARBOR HI

UCT TWO

UNCLAS //N11000//

SUBJ: FLEET MOORING INSPECTIONS

r. 1. AS DISCUSSED IN TELEPHONE CONVERSATION BETWEEN MiR. SUGA iSASEBO'r

ANDIR. TED JONES {CHESNAV.FACENGCOI ON 29 MIAR 831 CHESNAVFACENGC(";-

WITH SUPPORT FROMI UCT TWOi PLANS TO CONDUCT AN UNDERWATER INSPECTI'.1

OF THE 34I MOORINGS OPERATED AND MAINTAINED BY COIIFLEACT SASEBO AS

PART OF THE COIINAVFACENGCOI FLEET MOORING MAINTENANCE {CFfMfl PROGRAMI

J DURING THE PERIOD 1-21 MAY 63. AVAILABLE DATA INDICATES 1 CLASS A

* IrELLPHONI TrYPE MOONING IN 30 FEET OF WATER, 7 CLASS B RISER TYPL

flMOORINGS IN 31-125 FEET OF WATER AND 26 CLASS E RISER TYPE MOORINGS

I1N 15-59 FEET OF WATER.

.2. THE FLEET MOORING INSPECTION TEAMI WILL C091IST OF A CHESDIV

ENGINEER-IN-CHARGE (EIC}- AND A PET FROMI UCT TWO- IN ORDER TO PREPARE'

A DETAILED INSPECTION PLAN, THE FOLLOWING INFORMIATION IS REQUIRED

mosAlsI'" #j~bklontI lie@ t441wo bV11141100 rovel.@ t COY'Vi""09. 00. FPO-lC. DAILY.TEDIIIIOAAlE)S FPO-J.C{PDCI4I33 3886. 6 APR 1983 J F PO-lC{PDCI..FPO-10P2..FPO-lC7.. . V

**i*.*mUS -- - 0161. MIINIMIIZED CONSIDEREDHS. ST VENSON, CDR, CEC, USN

*g 15 I..*S

D-6

Page 170: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

o- .

LJ .. U3, tR UUUU~ j ,091,.140n:....

JPEK MOORING;

A. MAINTLNANCE HISTORY - WHEN INSTALLED, WHEN INSPECTED% WHEN

OVEIHAULED, LAST IEPORTED CONDITION, ETC.

U. COPILS OF MOORING DESIGN CALCULATIONS AND DRAWINGS-

C. COPIES OF "AS-BUILT" MATERIALS LIST.

D. FACILITY MAP SHOWING LOCATION OF ALL MOORINGS, WITH SPECIFIC

LOCATIONS FOR THOSE CURRENTLY IN USE.

E. ANTICIPATED MOORING USAGE DURING THE INSPECTION PERIOD -

'TYPES OF SHIPS.

F. PLANNED REPAIRS AND OVERHAULS - PARTICULARLY THOSE BEFORE .*,!'

JTHIS INSPECTION.

SG- TYPES OF CLASSES OF SHIPS USING MOORINGS.

H- WHETHER CATHODIC PROTECTION SYSTEMS ARE INSTALLED AND TYPE

OF MA'K AL UTILIZED--

3. COMFLEACT SASEBO IS REQUESTED TO MAIL THE ABOVE INFORMATION AS

SOON AS POSSIBLE TO CHESNAVFACENGCOM {CODE FPO-lC7}, BLDG. 212,

WASHINGTON NAVY YARD, WASHINGTON , D. C. 20374"

4. ADDITIONALLY, COMFLEACT SASEBO IS REQUESTED TO REPLY BY MESSAGE

WITH THE ABOVE INFORMATION EXCEPT FOR DRAWINGS AND MAPS BY 15 APR A.-

uu~aaevnvtaM~asu,,~g..n --bP~fS .U-...CNb..

ii;, 1760-74" " , Moo..4. . . .

p"y pol'.ow 0".-.,' '"II

0-7b

. * \,

Page 171: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

Ul03 RR uuuu 1 0961400

55- CHESNAVFACEN6COLI POINT OF CONTACT IS MIR. J. fICLAU6HLIN OR

MN T. JONLS AT AUTOVON 2-68-3881 OR -C2023 433-3881.

L. YouItc r SlL UIPPOIT WILL BE IG1UATLY APPRECIATED.

- JI.

pD-3

Page 172: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

VIJU, I .JUULJU I Ij]AUJLILIIILUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUtj N A 5SSI FI ED U

z ?2ri.3z AUG 82

r. Cl CpACFLT PEARL HAR6,ON HI

T C' crofar PEAkt IVMRbr1. M.I

1,,Fu Cm..avlAT N.ASmTN.G~flI, LC COr*JAVSEASYSCOm "ASMINGTON DCr -l-,.-AA1OySCu"- ASHING1O DC COMNAVELEXSYSCOM WASHINGTON DC

aiv~FACL*fJP' ALEXAi~f,TA VA CNR ARLINGTnba VAC-_,'.,AvTELCn.., V.Ab l'ITUtl DC COMNAVLOGPAC PEARL )4ARdOR HI%CUVAdSUJQFPAC SANJ fIE60 CA CoeMSU8PAC PEARL HARBOR NJcgjD-4.,AvaIvPAC 5.:.. DIMGL CA COMTMIRDFL7CG F?A1PAC CO'MARCORBASESPAC CAMP H M SMITH HICL5mUCEAriS.PAC PEARL hAp.RUP NJ COMI'AVFORJAPAN YOKOSUKA JA

Ct.,, '8v "A .4 UA COMUSNAVPMIL SUBIC BAY RPCL-'1*lAC'1SiF3TCE.- FT tl*LLD CA PACNAVFACENGCnm PEARL HARBOR HI,vESII.AVFAcE~vGCnbh. SA;. mHUNu CA CHLSNAVFACENGCOM WASHINGTON DCn1CC :.'TvPAC PE.A'L ml~.'e MI CC SUWESTPAC MANI1LA RP".ICC G"A"* (3CC FAR EAST YOK~OSUKA JA'ICL DI). ibACIA HUSTu&I TA PVAC PEARL mARRUR HI

c,..rGtiampWC SUE'IC BAY RPP.-.C Yuj.,5tJKM; J4 PWC SAN DIEGU CAP..C S44 FNA.41SLri CA C0I' THREL ONE NCR PORT HUENEME CA

S Cil'- 7ieQLr 7EPU liCIk WA' UCT 1Io* .V1 AL LE..TLPVTLLL* tEAC- CAi i4AVQCEANSYSCEN SAN DIEGO CA

-*V STA SVAL. RLALM CA iSU SUBIC BAY RP*~s1~irpcsualc HjAY Rt& KCAS IoAKUNI JA

,..F PiSul7.1 JA NAVUSEAgfARENGISTA KEYPORT WAk':;!JJP'rn P~r-.T SC~ttid.5 "A ivAVMAG LUALLIALEr HI

.Lc sia',. flIEGO CA SUbASE BANGOR wAI. T-I-EIFAC MA46(~11iw 4A. NAVPIIIBASE CORONADO SANd DIEGO CA

~ fuh.NAVSHIPREPFAC GUAMjt.vsopIPI.aL wILC~u 6AliCIA NAYSlA SAN DIEGO CA\i.VSTA VIN FACh CA NAVSMIPYD PEARL HARBOR HI'ibC PLAK.L HARti0K hl SLIBASE PEARL HARBOR HI!:AVSH.1PY,' MiIL ISLAD CA'P!MC?.15RA-jFAC tiA;.AkEA LjANK1'G bAi'.tIS h I

* UNCLAS //ull0Of//

SLij.Jo: UCT 12vU Pyhl3 Fi.PLnYPMEfwl ASK1tNt

* %vtCLiAVAL~C! f .AShi!IGlCVP UC(q) ... INFO

RID: OOO-OOO/COPIES:OOO9

2 11&77b~/235 J UF 3 ml 0348 235/23:21Z 210331Z AUG 82

C k A.~ uQ CINCPACFLT PEARL HARBOR HI

Ut'IULIIU ft ftJ U~il 'IJUIJ UU UU UUUUUUUUUUUUUU

0-9

Page 173: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

UUUUUUt UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU U N CLA 31FIE0

::s UuuUUUu UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUuUUUUUUUuU ,

A, CINCPACFLT PEARL HARBOR HI 260654Z JUN 82

1. REF A REQUESTED NOMINATIONS OF PROJECTS FOR UCT TWO ACCOM-PLISHMENT FY63-85. FROM THE RESPONSES TO REF A THE FOLLOWINGPROJECTS ARE TASKED FOR ACCOMPLISHMENT IN FI63:

A. CENTERVILLE BEACH fCLASSIFIED)B, ARCTIC WEST (CLASSIFIED)C. BARKING SANDS, HI, CABLE LANDING AND REPAIRSDo .WPNSTA SEAL BEACH, DEMOLISH ANAHEIM BAY BRIDGEE. NSD SUBIC, PILE REPAIR POL PIERF. NSD SUBIC. PILE REPAIR MARINE TERMINAL PIER PHASE I

(REPAIR ALL SEVERE AND MAJOR DAMAGE)G. IAVSHIPREPFAC SUBIC, INSPECT ALAVA IHARFH, FLEET MUORING INSPECTION - PACIFIC DATA BASE (PEARL HARBOR

rHi GUAM, YOKOSUKA# IKAKUNI, SASEBO, INDIAN ISLAND WA,BREMERTON WA)

I. NAVMAG LUALUALEI, INSPECT AMMO PIERS Wl-sJ. UNDERnATER INSPECTION PROGRAM (.NSC SAN DIEGO)K, SUBASE, BANGOR wA, UNDERWATER INSPECTIONL. TRIREFFAC BANGOR wA, UNDERWATER MSF RANGE REPAIRM. DEGAUSSING RANGE SURVEYsSAN FRANCISCO CAN. NAVPHIBASE CORONADO SAN DIEGO CA, PIER INSPECTIONS

2. THE FOLLOhING PROJECTS ARE TASKED AS FILL IN wORK FOR FY83:6, UNDERWATER INSPECTION PROGRAM (NAVSTA PEARL HARBOR)0. NAVUSEAssAkENGSTA KEYPORT hAt INDIAN IS PHASE TWO MOORINGC. NSD GUAM, REPAIRS TO SIERRA WHARF GUAM.

REQUIRES COURDINAI1ON WITH ON SITE NMCB FOR ACCOMPLISHMENT,

.THE FOLLOnING PROJECTS ARE TENTATIVELY TASKED FOR ACCOMPLISHMENTAl ZUDKICATED:

p A, FY-84(1) ARCTIC WEST (CLASSIFIED)

-. "-(2) NAVSHIPPEPFAC GUA~o REPAIRS TO LIMA WHARF

(3) FLEET MOORING INSPECTION - PACIFIC DATA BASE 9SUBICBAY, NSF DIEGO GARCIA, POC SAN DIEGO, NAVSTA SANDIEGO, WPNGTA SEAL BEACH, NAVSTA LONG BEACH)

(4) NSD SUBICP WATERFRUNT FACILITIES INSPECTION(S) NSD SUBICP MONOBUOY FUEL LINE REPAIRS

(6) DEGAUSSING RANGE SAN FRANCISCO, RANGE INSTALLATION(7) UNDERWATER INSPECTION PROGRAM CNAVSHIPY PEARL HARBOR,

NSC PEARL HARBORt SUBASE PEARL HARBOR)(B) SCARF REPAIR/INSPECTION(9) BARKING SANDS, UNDEROATER RANGE REPAIRS

(10) NSD SUBICP PILE REPAIR MARINE TERMINAL PIER PHASE 2

red

114776/235 2 OF 3 MI 0308 235/23:21Z 210331Z AUG 82RxooY0030 CINCPACFLT PEARL HARBOR HI :

UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU UUUUUUU UUU UUUUUUUU UNCLASS IF ED U

0-10

........................................... *

*- *9* .... .*.V*.* .** .* .. 4 .% % .- . . % ., .,, ,:.. .< ..; . -< . . ,

Page 174: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

IJt...:".!UUuuUUUUuUUUUUUuut. ,Uj,'uUUS..

(PEPAIPGTo MODFRATE ANiD KIYOR 0AMAD;)

(3) FLEET MOORING INSPECTO9 - PACIt IC AAT-. oIV q'-4au1ARaOR Mir GUAM, JAPANp iPU6ET SOUND &A)

(a) UNDERVIAYEP ls $PECT30k FRCCRAM (RARE ICL&VI'5) SUSASE PERL, F4CON -P-089, REPAIR AND EXTENp SEAINALL

~Tm1s PRojEcr W'lt. 'REGUIRc VEPARA7E T45irin. &,F 4NgWMCS, CdlUOR CMEP_?20R9AAj1VpflON. AS apgxxrzCGAThACTDRO FOR IZLE D)KfV3?o'G A-0 TOPSAMj ZroII W.4THtbtCT RCCOt'gL I 9Hl AK XlC XA9r 9pPPr,

*P A~*

SZ4147 122-1 r4ip ~ t AG 8

:qxc~~~~~~. 110 kr.4A_'ABRH

a..lL;1)1!j.IL.J V UU U II'

V N C L 3 ..1

041

iiO

lb-

*~4i~/2 ~ ~ ~ 1 C'.~p ~ RG 8

Page 175: mhhhhhhhhhhhhu mhhhhmhhhhME - DTIC\N bufnen Fsn ordg Or ahda '80 r-AeksandrSuttsu. HA1nm4 Mi. PO005 Fu,, oran Unggi, jrc'vmoad~suy Setana sa NOboribotSll IJIJ SA 9 Nalon ...

- ~ ~ - - I.

A4

I

W .4.5-

.5

S.

.5

.5

55.*

9.

4..-.9

6-56 5.

/1-'

f

9

'4S.

5